So I finally finished Memories of ice and as I did for DG and GOTM (link here and here) I wanted to give my thoughts on it.
First thing I wanted to say is this is a big book and it's dense so I will probably forget something, like the moment I post this I'll remember something I wanted to talk about. The second thing I just wanted to say is this might thing I've ever read. I am depressed again but also my god this is amazing. So there's the TLDR for this one. Third I am dyslexic so will be some spelling mistakes with names and such.
So first I want to say it was nice to see a lot of these characters again, I didn't realise how much I missed them but I did I really did. I'll get to specifics don't worry.
Next I want to say this is the book that made me realise how good of a writer Erikson is, even from book one his prose was strong, but here's where I realised that man wastes nothing. Not a scene or even a word, there is no filler at all here. And my god does this man weave themes into his plot and characters like no one else. In fact before I get to the story and characters I want to discuss the themes of this piece as I feel in many ways they are the star of the show, Erikson puts so much love into them and getting them across to the reader. Personally I identified four major themes of this work. Of course people may disagree with me here, and there are of course some minor ones as well but these were the ones I found most important to myself.
First there is the Motherhood. To me this is the most obvious theme portrayed in the piece as it proliferates throughout the entire narrative. In the prologue we follow follow a Jaghut mother as she protects her children. It's highly suggested at least to me that the reason that Kilava helps the Jaghut is because she had just lost her own child. But of course we have The Mhybe who herself is a representation of the sacrifice of motherhood. She gives basically everything for Silverfox and it's honestly really sad to see her as she starts to fee abanonded by her daughter. And of course the k'chain matron also falls into this, in fact arguably the entire the story of the K'chain play into this theme of motherhood. And there is also the women of the dead seed. This corruption of what motherhood is, a good showing of how the Pannon domain twists the perverts the world for their dark needs. Oh and who can forget Spindle and his mother's.
Second there is Despair. Through the novel we see a many different ways that despair can present itself, from the hateful despair of the Mhybe (when I say hateful I mean towards herself and everything.). To what I read as a more nihilistic despair of the T'lan Imass, Buke's suicidal despair, to the more fatalistic despair of the bridge burners. There is so much despair here. In fact I would say the fatalistic despair goes beyond the bridge burners. Itkovian was quite fatalistic during the siege of Capustan, and both Whiskey Jack, Brood and Dujek also have this sense of despair with them. And then the Pannon domain, their entire mission is to spread despair. Anaster the first child of the dead seed basically a messiah figure for them was literally nothing but despair.
Third there is Compassion. While not as theme constantly shown as despair. Some of the most notable acts in the story are those of compassion but I think interestingly they aren't succesful. Again Kilava taking the Jaghut children that itself was an act of compassion, but it also caused pretty big issues down the line. Silverfox herself has this goal that on paper is quite compassionate. But in order to achieve it she actually fails to be well compassionate to those around her. In fact failed compassion is something that happens quite a bit in the novel. Korlat telling the Mhybe about the T'lan Ay as another example or even Itkovian telling Bauchelain about Emancipor's broken tooth. However we do get real moments of true compassion, Itkovian of course taking the pain away from the Capustan and the T'lan Imass of course, but I would also point out K'rul turning Buke into a soultaken. In fact I think it's very notable that for the first half of the book the very act of using healing magic hurts the healer. A good showing of the sacrifice that being compassionate can have. But never once is showing this sacrifice is treated as not worth it. One could argue this is the difference between the failed compassion of Kilava and the true compassion of Itkovian. Kilava could have sacrificed herself to save the children, but she didn't. While Itkovian, well we will get to him.
And finally there's what I call Joy but it can also be considered well Sex. There is a lot of sex in this book. In fact I think it's one of the ways that the novel contrasts the Pannon against well everyone else. The Pannon perverse the act of sex so much that even the dead aren't safe (Though to expand they perverse all aspects of well living). And it's all rape as well. While almost all their enemies have like a lot of consensual sex. I honestly thought it was a bit gratuitous for a while. But I came to realise that no it is important. The reason I also call it joy is because it's the counter balance to well the despair. The T'lan Imass are in a way despair incarnate, and also can not have sex. However at the end when Tool becomes mortal again one of the first things that happens is well someone offers him sex. I think it's kind of notable that arguably the two most depressed characters of the book, the Mhybe and Itkovian are the two who don't have sex for different reason but they are presented as unable to. The sex talk isn't just here to be like naughty or funny (to be clear it was both) it's to prove these people are alive. They have a fire within them.
So beyond the themes I want to get to the actual bones of the well novel itself. First thing I really noticed is how well in introspective this book is. There is a lot of internal dialogue here. Which does make sense, there are entire characters who are nothing but internal dialogue to be fair. But honestly I feel like this had more thoughts and internal monologues then the previous two books put together. This is not a complaint to be clear. I actually really like this.
As for the world building in comparison to DG this felt more like it was expanding on elements we already had instead of introducing new ones. And this again I like, not to say there were no new elements of course there were. Just that I felt that here Erikson was more interested in taking what he had already set up. I did love learning more about the Barghast, their relationship with the Moranth and Imass. I actually liked learning more and the Moranth in general. Also how the gods worked in the setting and the deck of dragons. Along with the Warrens of course, Shadowthrone just being the gate keeper to the true warren of shadow was quite funny to me.
Oh also about the prologue, I really want more stone age fantasy now, I didn't know I wanted it but I do.
Also I'll say this was the first novel of the series where I now feel I have an idea of what the overall story is going to go. The title of the next book (which I've already ordered) is the first one where I can look at it and think "Ah I know what that means".
Now onto where I think Erikson shines, his characters.
So might as well start with who chapter one starts with Gruntle, Stonny and Harllo. Well to begin with them as a crew I really like the 3 of them and was actually quite sad when Harllo bit the bullet. I sort of knew it was going to happen, I am using a reading guide along while I'm reading (Just so I don't miss anything which I do sometimes do). And the one I was used images to represent characters and Gruntle and Stonny got them but not Harllo so well I could make a guess. But still sad by his death and he didn't feel like he was the one who was going to die if you get me.
Gruntle as the mortal sword of Trench was quite fun actually, as was his out right not wanting to be it. I honestly like the aspect of him as some who actually doesn't like violence I feel like it's a character trait you don't really see with characters like Gruntle but you know suits him. He's good at it, but he doesn't like doing it. He only did so in Capustan because of Stonny. Onto Stonny herself again I really liked her. Though will be honest didn't feel like she did much after Capustan but I was still happy she was around. I think her and Gruntle still had some great interactions between themselves and Itkovian. In fact I really like it that Stonny was the only one of the three of them actually interested what was going on in the wider war if you will. I felt that was quite fitting. Helps that unlike Itkovian who had lost his god and Gruntle who despite being a Mortal Sword was basically an atheist. She did hold at least some faith with K'rul. Honestly this faith really did help her because despite having horrible shit happen to her during Capustan she bounced back better then Gruntle and Itkovian. And that I think is important. She's good at dealing with these things even though they still do affect her. She was clearly more grief stricken about Harllo then Gruntle but she did stuff about it.
I feel like I should also talk about Buke here. A character who again I did like. He also plays into the theme of despair however he is able to overcome it. Even though I am sad he leaves the story quite soon all things considered I do think he got over his grief and he's now free from it. Though I will be honest I did partially expect the epilogue to be from his point of few. Idk maybe Buke will come back.
Should probably talk about Bauchelain, Korbal Broach and Emancipor Reese. First I loved Emancipor and did feel awfully sorry for him. Second wow Bauchelain and Broach was some of the most intriguing characters introduced in this novel. There is a certain air around them, a feeling of macabre if you will. I honestly find it funny how half way though the novel they sort of becoming punching bags a bit, and they don't seem to realise why people don't like them. I can't wait to see more of them, though I can't shake this feeling that if I do it would be in the non-Book of the fallen Malazan books. Can't say that for sure though. I will say in general this felt like the novel that so far feels it's setting up for I suppose more spin off titles if you will. But yeah I did really like them.
Should probably talk about the Barghast siblings. Hetan and Cafal. Hetan was one of the most entertaining characters in the novel to be honest. Her just wanting to bone any man with a pulse was really funny. But she did have some depth to her as well. Through her I feel I understood the Barghast better, not just their lore and culture but more their view on things, their perspectives. However it's through Cafal that I do feel I learn about the Barghast and their lore. His conversations around the canoes gave the Barghast quite a depth to them. You can definitely tell that their father has been grooming him to take over the clan, and if not that then to act as a wise man from a young age.
Alright next might as well talk about the Grey Swords (Honestly a bit upset I called Geslar, Stormy and Truth the Boar Boys last time around it suits these guys way better.). I liked Brukhalian and Karnadas. Though honestly I was surprised they died so soon. To be honest I first thought that Capustan would last much longer. I kind of expected it to be like this books version of the chain of dogs (and it kind of is in a way). With Brukhalian being the Coltaine. But honestly I think that's what Erikson wanted me to think. It's a very good play on expectations. Showing us that no Erikson will not just write the same plot again. So while we didn't get much of them I did like what we did get, in fact Karnadas's death like legit first shocking death of the book. Next I want to talk about Velbara and Norul. Honestly Velbara's arc of going from scarred Capan recruit to one of the leaders of the Grey swords was one of my favourite more subtle arcs in this book. I did really like her. Norul relationship with Itkovian thought mostly silent was quite tragic in a way. There is this sense through her of how important Itkovian was to the Grey Swords and how decided to give that up. All great stuff.
And speaking of Itkovian. Well god damn man. I would argue he's the strongest written character in the book possible the entire series so far. Personally if this book had a protag it would be Itkovian he represents most of the themes brilliantly. This man for portions of this of this book is in states of despair about his place within the world, he feels almost suicidal at times. With the death of Fener and well most of the original Grey Swords Itkovian just felt he had no place in the world and that hit hard. Especially as it became clear everyone around respected the hell out of him. But he just couldn't believe it. But despite all of that he was probably the most selfless man alive. He did everything for others, including taking their pain. Him taking Capustan's suffering so it could rebuild was one of the most stand out moments for me, and then Itkovian topped it with the T'lan Imass. I honestly think that is the most part of the novel, maybe not the narrative but it's the section where the themes of the story all come together. And his death, I almost cried. In a novel of tragic scenes this one hit especially hard. And then there was his funeral, I did cry. A man who in his life had issues seeing his own worth, believed himself to be basically nothing because of failure, in death his is celebrated by all that knew him. Given the highest honours by people so ancient, so cold, but through Itkovian became living again. God damn Itkovian god damn.
Alright, onto the BridgeBurners, I'll speed run some quickly. I really liked Hedge, I said in my DG review that him and Fiddler kind of blended together. Here I do see a lot more difference though. Hedge to me seems a lot less well depressed. He really likes making things go boom, and he is good at it. Antsy, honestly the change of nervous wreck to actually quite excited when they got to Capustan. Says a lot about him. Detoran, probably the one we got the least of in my opinion but I liked what we did get. Trotts, god damn I thought he really shined actually. Him becoming war chief of the Bridge Burners was quite nice, as was his fight against the other Barghast. Spindle, Spindle was weird and I liked that. I like unnerving Erikson made him, I like weirdo's and Spindle fit to a T. Mallet, I thought Mallet was also great. I honestly felt quite bad for him all things considered, he deserves better. And yes the deaths of the bridge burners did make me sad. Trotts and Hedge probably the most surprising. There were some other Bridgeburners but these felt like the most notable.
Of course I do have to talk about Picker and Blend felt they should go together. Probably some of my favourite characters in the novel to be honest, maybe it's because I like beautiful women. Picker had this gruffness to her that mixed with a snarkyness with a dash of fatalism that honestly made a really enjoyable combo. I did really love a lot of her convos with other characters felt like someone I could have a drink with. And Blend well she was just great. She was also quite snarky but there was less gruffness to her imo. She was more idk what's the word playful I guess, I can't say if this is actually correct but she felt like the youngest of the Bridge Burners here. But her offering Quick Ben her neckless honestly kind of got to me, and Quick Ben rejecting it say she wouldn't be Blend without it ah god my heart. Also Blend has some magic it seems, fun. But I did really like both Picker and Blend, their dynamic was great. I get the sense people would ship them, that or it's a sisterly thing.
Actually the convo in chapter 11 about how the 7th squad is a worse version of the 9th really stuck with me. Antsy the worse Whiskey Jack, Spindle and Quick Ben, Picker and Kalem, in that vain I think Blend is their Sorry. Less skilful (probably) but also less psychotic I suppose. Fits even better if Blend is actually tapping into Meanes without knowing.
Paran (Can't be bothered to spell his first name). To be honest he wasn't my favourite from GOTM and that didn't really change when MOI began however the more important and powerful he became the more I came to care for him. Paran is someone who really does not want to be important. That man seriously just wants to blend in and do good by those close to him, but well now he has the fate of reality resting on his shoulders. And well his girlfriend is back but she's a child and then she's kind of cold for a bit and really has to admit to himself that him and Tattersail weren't that much in love and Paran was just young. I honestly really liked that. In the same way DG was partially about Crokus and Felesin growing up I felt the same for Paran here. It's him realising that yeah he has to take reasonability. Honestly really good arc for him. Also while I'm here him and Raest great duo. Happy they are room mates now (do people ship that?).
Quick Ben. In a novel full of people doubting themselves Quick Ben knows he's hot shit and it's great. Like my god that man does a lot of sick as magic. And he's so entertaining doing it as well. I just love the way he played with Talamandas just trying to figure out the limits of his power. Like every time Quick Ben does magic it feels he's doing something that shouldn't be possible. He's probably one of the most mysterious PoV characters, I'm still not sure how he knows and does some of the things he does. But he's great.
Whiskey Jack and Korlat. Ah Whiskey Jack, most shocking death of the book to me. Like I am still shocked by it. Erikson's portrayal of a man tired from war was just excellent, and honestly I really hoped him a Korlat would get that happy ending. Also speaking of which his relationship with Korlat was seriously so strong. It gave a much needed humanity for the Tiste Andii, through their interactions we really got to understand what makes the Tiste Andii tick. I actually really enjoyed Korlat on her own as well, her relationship with the Mhybe and Silverfox goes between quite sweet to deeply tragic. Korlat's mourning of Whiskey Jack really hit me hard. I did really like the two of them, to be honest separately I felt Korlat was stronger, but Whiskey still had his moments to shine, his sacrifice against Kallor tells you a lot about him, him acting as a mentor to Paran was nice, I really liked the scenes with him and Dujek as well honestly, but I will get to that later. And I did really enjoy his scenes with Anomander Rake, Rake calling Whiskey Jack friend really got to me in a similar way Itkovian's burial did. And I should say I also really enjoyed Rake and Korlat as well. Rake I will get to a bit later but Korlat shows that even to his mythical Tiste Andii Rake stands apart. They almost worship him. But yeah Jack and Korlat, still hurts.
So Dujek. I honestly don't have much to say about his character but I do want to talk about his relationship with Whiskey Jack. One of Erikson's strengths is his ability to present the decades of history that characters share in only a few pages, and yeah he did that well between these two. Through them you still feel the suffocating power of the Malazan empire and Laseen. It made me question Dujek a lot more honestly, a lot of people spoke about him as like one of the last good ones in the empire and I do wonder if that is actually true. Of course we find out last book that them being outlawed was a trick, but I must wonder beyond that. The fear that the Malazans were only doing this to increase the size of their empire yeah did seem to be true if I read it correct. And this lead to a lot of secrecy between the allies, and a lot of actions that imo kind of came across as incompetent to me. But like purposely so. Erikson has created a very Grey world and this adds to that.
Brood and Kallor. I actually really liked Brood. In GOTM I got this image of this big kind of dumb but powerful guy, but no I honestly really liked how level headed he was. The man has the power to destroy the world and yeah he arguably should be the one to have it. He's someone who despite his age feels honestly very human. Now Kallor, well first fuck Kallor for killing Whiskey Jack and the two marines. But also I do find it interesting how in ways he was kind of right. Like the Malazans were planning to conquer Coral, and well Silverfox did kind of do some questionable stuff. Doesn't justify him, in fact I get the sense this will be the most unpopular thing I say here.
The Mott Irregulars. I'm just putting this here to say I hope we see more of them. They are so funny and it's clear they are the best fighting force on Genabackis. No legit I do think that might be the case. These odd swamp folk, you don't fuck with them.
Anomander Rake. It's kind of hard to talk about Rake honestly. I mean he's a great character, his presence is always felt even when's not around. He feels inhumanly strong and compassionate as well. It's clear he loves the Tiste Andii, but that his love isn't only for them as well. He's hard to talk about because every time we get to know him it feels we know him even less. Like so distant and it's clear it's a distance he puts up but like not out of hate, at least that's how I see it now. I of course know this is far from the last time I will see him.
The Mhybe. The Mhybe might be the most well written character in this novel, just behind Itkovian. I said above this book felt quite internal when compared to the previous two and yeah she's a big reason why. It was sad to see her become so despair filled, but at the same time I do deeply understand it. A woman who basically was forced to give up her life so another could live. She is the theme of what a mother sacrifices most taken literal but it works all the same in effeteness. I will be honest while I was reading I actually expected the first book of MOI to end on her death but I'm glad it didn't. As the book went on I grew to sympathise with the Mhybe greater and greater. There was a sense of complete tragedy to her. As she became more and more isolated by those around her, only finding escape in her dreams. But even there she was hunted. It's only the group from Darujhistan who felt like they really stuck by her. And even then there were moments I questioned if they truely had her best interests. The Mhybe was a hard character to read but one I commend Erikson on.
Kruppe. Kruppe was probably my favourite character in GOTM and he doesn't disappoint here. God I love him. Erikson gives Kruppe so much character, like I get the sense he's a character who just fun to write. But also he's a character just fun to read. And along with Quick Ben he's a great character to think about as well because there is so much going on with him that like I'm so interested in knowing more about. I have some theories myself. But yeah Kruppe is great and I love how annoyed characters get with him, but how knows how much he annoys them. If I had to describe him I see Kruppe as someone who presents himself as smart but not as smart as he thinks he is, except Kruppe expects you to think that and he actually yes is that smart. Funny I think the sex adventure he had with Hetan shows this off really well.
Coll and Murillio. I was also happy to see them here as well if only Crokus and Rallick Nom could join them. Ah I digress. It was actually really nice to Coll recovering from his issues. It's clear that his demons still haunt him and because of that he really wants to right by the Mhybe. Also the revelation he might have a child was shocking but got me interested. Murillio mostly felt he was here to give Coll someone to talk to but I didn't mind to be clear. And I do like how he's clearly trying to keep his friend on the straight and narrow.
The Knight of Death. Yeah there is not much to say about him but I do want to say what my reaction to him was. Basically I was like "Oh shit is this Brukhalian? Makes sense Hood came for him personally." And then the story continued and I realised "Wait no this is Baudin. Fucking Baudin's back?" I was not expecting that honestly. Baudin felt like a real one and done. Now of course might be misdirect.
Silverfox. I don't actually have much to say about Silverfox funny enough. I found a lot of the stuff happening around her interesting and I did find her interesting as well to be clear. I do like the subtle battle of control that was going on within her, assuming it even was a battle. Honestly not sure I expected Nightchill to be important, didn't expect her to be an elder god especially. I will say the moment she refused to release the T'lan Imass did send a shiver down my spine. Like her mother there is a tragedy to Silverfox and like a lot of the great tragedies one must question how much of it is self inflicted. She is a really good character just don't have much more to say about it.
Pran Chole. Well and to be honest all the T'lan Imass as well but I did actually really like Pran. Through his interactions with Silverfox and Itkovian there was a real sense of that humanity buried deep beneath the T'lan Imass. He's a big part of the reason Itkovian's death worked so well for me honestly. Their interaction ah still makes me tear up. The T'lan Imass might have been my favourite part of the first two books so I do love how much focus they got here. We see how much their eternal war has cost them. How much they gave up. And to see them regain much of what they lost but keep their undead forms meant quite a bit to me. It showed at least imo that it wasn't the ritual itself that caused them to forget all this, it was there willingness to do it. To put there mortality aside for an endless quest of vengeance. I honestly do like to think that if the the T'lan Imass came across another Jaghut they would just leave them be, because the Imass have already won their war. They arguably won it before the ritual even happened.
Toc the Younger. Ah poor Toc. I do kind of feel bad for him. This basically guy who true little fault of his own just gets swept up in these major events. The man accidently becomes super important. Of course I would argue that him trying to join back up with the Malazans was a bad idea one that cost him a lot. I will be honest it was hard for me to read him go through a lot of that. Like jesus christ poor guy. Though him taking Anaster's body at the end was kind of funny actually. He's still missing the eye. Oh also how horny he is love it.
Tool. So I already gave my thoughts on the T'lan Imass above and a lot of that also fits Tool. But Tool has a lot of other stuff going for him. For one he's actually quite chill all things considered. There was a humanity to Tool that the other T'lan imass didn't really have and a part of me thinks that's because he didn't want to do the ritual. This is quite short but I loved Tool his crusade to rescue Toc damn brought a tear to my eye. Also his fighting with the Seguleh, was epic, tense and also bit funny. Him and Mok dropping everything to duke it out in a torture chamber. I will say the book ending with Tool mortal again did put a smile on my face.
Kilava. I don't have much to say on her as she wasn't in the book much. But I still greatly enjoyed her. I do find it interesting how at times she felt even more vengeful then the T'lan Imass. It's hard to describe but despite being a Imass of flesh and Bone she was the one who felt most stuck in the past. I hope we see more of her, but if her ending is living with the Barghast with Tool that's good too.
Lady Envy and her Seguleh. Ah Lady Envy. She's in that Rake, Brood category for me. You know someone so clearly more powerful then everyone else around them. Except in an odd twist of faith despite being the most human looking she felt the least human at times. I do get the sense that she doesn't spend much time around people. Her manners and attitude felt deeply exaggerated if you get me. Like someone trying to put on what being human is. It made for a deeply entertaining character. As for her Seguleh, I don't have much to say on them. They were cool. That's really it. I do get the sense they will be important later though.
The Pannon Seer. Great villain. One I both hated but also could not help but also pity. He's still clearly some sort of child. One that hates the world for honestly not awful reasons. Mix that with the corruption of the Changed One. I really hope he does get to heal and I hope his sister is safe.
Duiker. What the fuck Duiker is alive? What the fuck? What the Fuck? I'm not upset but like just surprised like Oh my god he's still alive. I remember thinking to myself when reading DG that Coltaine will probably come back but Duiker is probably a one off, but nope guess not. I mean I am happy I think Duiker is great. And also the book ending with him telling the Bridge Burners and the Daru about the chain of dogs. Fucking peak. A part of me hopes the next book opens with him finishing the story and they're all just shocked. Or better yet he tells them basically the entirety of DG including the stuff he would have no idea about. I mean I know that won't happen but the picture is funny in my head. But seriously Duiker is alive. Erikson you can be kind.
Alright so I'm pretty sure that's most of the really important characters, probably missing a few. Didn't give the Two unnamed Marines a section or K'rul, just don't have much to say. But I'm not done yet, I want to try something new where I give some theories I have after reading the books. I have two theories one is more of a meta theory though not actually about the story. Note please do not confirm or de-confirm the theories (well the more meta one is ok I suppose)
Theory 1. Kruppe is the former king of the High House of Shadow
So there is something going on with Kruppe, he clearly knows more then he is letting on and he is a sneaky guy and seems to be the friends of Elder Gods. Along with that we know that the high house of shadow was kingless until ShadowThrone. So my thought is that it was Kruppe and something happened and he lost his throne and became Mortalish.
Theory 2 (Meta Theory). The chaining was the original Campaign ran in the Malazan world.
So I assume most people here know Malazan was originally based on a ttrpg. Gurps mostly but originally it was AD&D I'm pretty sure. This theory goes that the original campaign in the setting was actually the original chaining of the Chained One. At least that's when it ended. In this theory the PC's were Rake, Brood, Envy and maybe Kallor (not so sure on that one).
Even if this is wrong I at least do think Rake, Brood and Envy started as player characters. (In fact in general I felt the ttrpg influence heavy this time around. Which I love I am big ttrpg guy)
Now onto top 5 characters from Memories of Ice.
Itkovian
Kruppe
The Mhybe
Toc and Tool (Hard to Pick)
Picker and Blend (again hard to pick).
I will say this is the hardest 5 to pick yet. The only one I am sure about is Itkovian.