r/Malazan • • Sep 03 '24

NO SPOILERS Am I the only one who rolls his eyes at all the "Malazan is so difficult" conversations?

47 Upvotes

Granted, it is more complicated than your average fantasy novel. There's a higher level of vocabulary, grammar, and prose than your average YA novel. There's tons of symbolism and thematic explorations that most fantasy doesn't even bother to attempt. It withholds lots of information and remains vague about many things, lots of them crucial.

But come one.

It's still a fantasy novel, not James Joyce. The writing isn't actually difficult. You never understand fully what's going on, but never so much that it prevents you from reading on, or enjoying the story. Some of the workings of the world, notably magic, are arcane, and only get revealed slowly. But it's not like warrens and aspected magic are a totally novel concept, and I remember a couple of exposition scenes about them in Gardens.

Yes, I'll never totally understand the books and what they offer, from themes to the actual goings on. But that's also true of any lit novel I've ever read. These books are not harder to read or understand than Moby Dick or Paradise Lost, and English is not even my first language.

Anytime people complain about struggling to read Malazan I get the impression they never did their required reading in high school.


r/Malazan • • Jul 23 '23

NO SPOILERS Anomander Rake

Post image
10 Upvotes

I used AI Bing, but I am not disappointed.


r/Malazan • • Mar 07 '24

SPOILERS MBotF Sexual Trauma in the Main 10 Was an Issue Before DOD Spoiler

3 Upvotes

When it comes to discussions of sexual assault in the BOTF, people tend to focus on the hobbling as the single most brutal and horrifying instance of it. I don't have a problem with how people argue about the hobbling as separate from the rest of the Book, but in more general discussions I feel like its unique character tends to deviate the conversation from how sexual assault is more generally treated in the series. This matters to me because there are a few points that I feel don't get raised, or not often enough, when the focus of debate becomes "Should Erickson have written the hobbling at all?" or "What was the point of making it so brutal?", etc.

This is not therefore a post about the hobbling. While I have my own issues with it, I think there's been enough talk about that subject, and there are questions I want to address that I believe are more important to the series as a whole than this one, although egregious, circumstance.


The two best examples of what I want to talk about are the rapes of Seren Pedac and Janath Anar. Seren gets raped in a drunken stupor off-screen, possibly a self-inflicted unconscious punishment; and Janath gets tortured and raped over the course of multiple days, some of it on screen. Both get over their trauma with the help of magic: Corlo uses Mockra to paper over Seren's pain, while Bugg erases Janath's memories. Later Janath gets captured and assaulted again before being eventually rescued.

There's a lot of sexual assault in the series, but most of it happens off screen to redshirts, or is alluded to generally. We know atrocities happen in Pale. We know what the Tenescowri do to their victims. But few are the POV characters who get assaulted. As such, I think using magic to essentially "get over" Seren's and Janath's trauma is a problem. They are two of the most prominent (perhaps the most?) victims of rape in the series, and instead of dealing with their pain and recovery the books brush it off with magic. When Janath gets retaken, her ensuing recovery happens in the timeframe of later books when she ceases being a POV character.

I understand why Erickson chooses to portray sexual assault and its consequences in his books. He doesn't want a sanitised and cool version of war. He doesn't want to steer clear from the most unpleasant aspects of his world out of comfort. A series about compassion is not complete if it doesn't look at the most horrific of experiences in the face. Etc.

But an assault can be a matter of moments; recovery (or the lack thereof) takes a lifetime. If you're going to depict sexual assault, then you have to go through with it and deal with its consequences, which are sometimes more painful and destructive than the act itself, because that is when the violence of the act affects the rest of not just the victim's life, but everyone else around them. Reading the series, I felt that it was convenience that drove the story this way. Seren gets to move on, get to Lether, and meet Trull unencumbered. Janath gets to banter and fall in love with Tehol. Those would have been much harder arcs to write if they'd had to deal with their assault naturally.

But real life isn't convenient, and in a way, that's what Malazan is supposed to be about. Malazan doesn't tie up plotlines neatly, its characters don't get to enjoy the fates they'd be "supposed to" in other series. Things get messy, real life gets in the way, expected meetings don't happen, heroes don't get happy endings.

Which is why I think the treatment of Seren and Janath is a betrayal of the promise of the books, and a bit of a hypocritical one. I suppose you can point to Felisin, who is basically broken the second she gets on the ship, and maybe others, to show that the BOTF does show what sexual assault does to a person. Felisin never recovers though, her arc is one of self destruction, while Seren and Janath learn to move on and rebuild their lives. It was important that they deal with their experience in a real way for the books to fulfil their promise.

Maybe there's a similar character who had that arc earlier in the series that I'm forgetting, but even so, this would still have been important. Some problems you shouldn't just deal away with magic.

To circle back, the hobbling compounds this tendency. After her ghastly ordeal, Hetan gets resurrected, her memories gone, and reunites with her family; essentially a "happy ending". Again Erickson gets his cake and eats it too: he demonstrates the monstrosity inherent to the human experience, but ultimately its aftereffects can be ignored, and his characters can resume their proper existence. This seems to be something that is particular to sexual violence in the BOTF.


r/Malazan • • Jul 18 '26

NO SPOILERS Malazan vibes from “The Odyssey”

5 Upvotes

Just saw the new movie “The Odyssey”. I was watching it and I had just got some major Malazan vibes from it. The design of the movie and the look and themes just felt a lot like Malazan. What about you? For those that have seen the movie, has anyone else feel this way?


r/Malazan • • Mar 01 '26

NO SPOILERS The "RAFO" comments are getting out hand

0 Upvotes

I understand that the best way to experience these books is just by diving in letting the mysteries be mysteries until they're explained. I read books 1-5 before I even knew this sub or the wiki existed and the rollercoaster of puzzlement to comprehension and back again was incredibly exhilarating. There is no doubt that the answer to a lot of questions in Malazan is "keep reading."

But lately I'm noticing a rather tedious trend of people in this community responding "RAFO" to every question under the sun regardless of whether the question being asked is actually addressed in the text. For every mystery that has a definitive answer in Malazan there are four more that are either implicit or open-ended. There are also verifiable internal inconsistencies (eg Crimson Guard timeline, Trull's Shorning, etc) that many people seem uncomfortable with acknowledging, as though an inconsistency would somehow demean our beloved progenitors of Wu.

If I may be so bold I would ask my fellow Malafans to ask themselves: "is this actually addressed explicitly in the text, and if asked could I provide a reference?" If the answer is no then responding with "RAFO" is inaccurate, unhelpful, and merely adds noise to the otherwise thoughtful discussions being held here.

(dismounts soapbox)


r/Malazan • • Sep 27 '23

NO SPOILERS Considering reading Malazan, but wondering about queer characters?

0 Upvotes

I’m a big fantasy fan and have been eyeing off Malazan for a while as my next big undertaking. But I was just wondering about the reputation of queer characters. I’d really appreciate it if someone could give me an overview without any spoilers?

I’m 10 books deep into the Wheel of Time and there is not an explicitly queer character to be seen. So hoping that Malazan might be a bit better in this regard.


r/Malazan • • Jan 16 '25

SPOILERS MoI Don’t get the hype with memories of ice Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I finally got my way through finishing memories of ice about 2 months ago and do not get the praise. Idk if it it because I too such a long time to read it or what but it didn’t click for me. I liked gardens of the moon and loved dead house gates so going in I was super excited. The book just felt like a slog to me which was not what I was expecting at all.

I even read the dragon bone chair right after which is known to be slow and that felt like it had a faster pace. I thought maybe the series just isn’t for me but I’m on house of chains right and am loving it. I finished book one of hoc and loved it like most of you do and am about 100 pages into book 2 and still loving it. Will me not liking moi impact the rest of the series or is it just a bump in the road?


r/Malazan • • Aug 14 '24

SPOILERS MBotF Trigger warnings in each Malazan book NSFW Spoiler

19 Upvotes

Hey you guys! I hope this message won’t catch any hate by way of asking -

I’m currently on chapter 5 of re-reading Deadhouse Gates and am very much enjoying myself but feel the books getting darker and darker. I want to re-explore these themes, however, for my own mental health purposes, I wanted to reach out and kindly ask if anyone created a guide with regards to SA trigger warnings as one journeys across the series. I’m particularly sensitive to violence against children on page.

If anybody can can help a girl out and forewarn which chapters have what, I’ll feel better equipped when diving into it.

Thanks and I appreciate the help in advance 😇🙏🫂

edit: grammar


r/Malazan • • Dec 17 '24

SPOILERS ALL Tayschrenn on the spectrum? Spoiler

11 Upvotes

My son has autism and my wife has a masters degree in special education. We both agree Tayschrenn may very well have autism. Blunt, very literal, everything is black or white, trouble with social skills, hard relating to others, avoids people. Just missing sensory issues and stims lol. I’m not sure if SE or ICE intended this for the character but it would be awesome if they did (for inclusion)! Does anyone know if they’ve discussed this in interviews?


r/Malazan • • Oct 03 '24

SPOILERS DoD His return was so unneeded Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Fuck it man. Tool’s story was as complete as it gets after MOI’s ending. The scene in the end where he meets Toc and tells him “I’ll never forget you brother” was both beautiful and heartbreaking as this duo you’ve loved across the entirety of MOI and GOTM end on this bittersweet note.

Then in RG it’s revealed that oh actually tool became the Barghast leader and met Toc numerous times but “never told him it’s him for the shits and giggles”. Now don’t get me wrong, the moment with Tool holding Toc’s dead body was very emotional. No denying that.

And now we get a whole pov of him in DoD where he focuses on being the war leader now and dies. I feel nothing for the death of a character who was one of my top favorites after MOI. And that’s so annoying. This isn’t the Tool I loved… Just feel like his character arc was perfect up until MOI’s ending point and shouldn’t have been brought back just for it to get so much worse man. Does anyone agree with me or is Tool post MOI still a fan favorite?

No spoilers for past this please


r/Malazan • • Nov 21 '24

NO SPOILERS Is dual wielding even a thing?

6 Upvotes

There are quite a few dual wielding swordsmen in the series, and I honestly don't know if that's even possible. I don't know of any historical IRL examples of warriors fighting with two swords, and I really feel I should have come across some at this point if this was a thing that happened. It seems to me that it would be extremely hard to apply strength or leverage on the individual swords.

Please do note I am specifically talking about swords. Claws fighting with two knives is fine.


r/Malazan • • Jun 18 '25

NO SPOILERS Ganoes Paran, circa the Pannion War

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/Malazan • • 27d ago

NEW READER ADVICE It took 3 years and 4 tries, but I finally finished GotM - Consider Using Slides Instead of Notes

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I am exhausted, but I finally did it. 3 years ago, in September 2023, I purchased Gardens of the Moon. I'm a huge fantasy fan, taken on a lot of books before, but from everything I was hearing, I was mega-intimidated. I thus chose to do a ton of outlining and take a bazillion notes when I tried reading the first time. I also used the Reread of the Fallen guide on reactormag as well. It turned it into a total slog. I got to Darujhistan, saw a whole new set of characters, and gave up.

Same thing in 2025. Same thing earlier this year, though I got quite a bit further along, but still stopped just before halfway through.

Then it turned out a friend of mine had gotten through the first two books and was on the third. He asked me if I'd ever heard of malazan and I immediately raged about my struggles with the series.

He explained he never took notes, just got used to being confused, and let things click together.

I said I'd try again, but really couldn't be screwed to read the first third again. Then, someone else I knew turned out to also be reading GotM, but recommended u/sleepinxonxbed's slides as a helper. This was a game changer. It let me catch up on the first third, helped piece together some things I'd been missing, and honestly after about halfway through I realized I didn't really need it as much as I thought as I felt like things got much clearer in the second half, but it was mega helpful to recap and get everything clear in my head.

Obviously it will depend on person to person, but my tip for new readers is to use these slides if you feel notes/other companion pieces are turning it into homework.

Huge shoutout to u/sleepinxonxbed for their amazing work, you can donate to them here: https://ko-fi.com/sonanomander

The second half blew my mind, and I'm still processing everything, but can say this was finally, definitely worth it. But I'll be damned if that wasn't the roughest start to a book I've ever had to go through...

Can't wait to start from near scratch in Deadhouse Gates!

Edit: For those confused why I was putting so much unnecessary pressure on understanding everything/criticizing that approach; that's exactly my point. I was turning it into a slog/homework for no good reason. Took this long because each time I attempted with the intensive method, I hated the experience haha. I learned to be more comfortable with just reading and being confused.

The slides don't explain much more than what's already been read, all I'll say is it does help organizing thoughts/recapping :)


r/Malazan • • Apr 27 '22

NO SPOILERS “Hard” Magic systems are just magic for dummies!

1 Upvotes

I finally figured it out!

I’m involved in the reread going on - third read through the big 10, while I’m also doing my second read of the other published works.

People always talk about how some authors have a “Hard” magic system, versus a “soft” magic system. I’ve always been annoyed by this interpretation, and feel it does not capture some of the very hard science that is subtly within much of the Malazan world!

I believe we should stop using these words!

I suggest we call one of them the – “Harry Potter” system of Magic, versus

—- “MAGIC?”

As far as I can tell, all of the books that have a “hard“ magic system really are just stories that use up hundreds of pages by explaining to the reader intricacies of some made up nonsense!

That is right! You hear me! I believe that “hard“ magic systems are just a way of drawing an average human into your storytelling.

Quick Ben could actually spend 100,000 hours explaining to you rules and science behind magic.

But, that’s not the story! (and none of us deserve a moment of his time!)

A bunch of scientists could figure out all of the magic in the Malazan world with as much hard language as anything other writers contribute, but that is not the story!

Ultimately – I feel like the authors (SE and ICE) have created a world where magic, and technology, can be explained and dissected for thousands of years, just like reality.

But, unfortunately I now believe that “Hard“ magic systems are really just a way to dumb it down for a basic reader!

Fight me to the death!

EDIT - maybe not the death, as I’m going to bed in a couple hours.

EDIT 2 - when I wake up, I hope there are things to respond to as I love this weird, esoteric, nonsense discussion!

But, as promised, I is now going to bed!


r/Malazan • • Feb 07 '23

NO SPOILERS I find it weird that...

1 Upvotes

...half the Malazan army is made up of women and yet nobody ever gets their period. Menstrual cycles are rarely brought up, or the challenges of having your period in the hygienic conditions of a medieval army camp or on the march.

I'm a huge fan of Erikson's realism, but the logistics of menstruating soldiers is never shown to pose a challenge.


r/Malazan • • Jan 15 '26

NO SPOILERS W’sup Widdit Big Dawgs? I’m one chapter into GOTM. Should I be more confused?

0 Upvotes

I realize it’s 50 pages in, but are people confused just because the story jumps around from situation to situation? Orrr? Cause if that’s all, I find it extremely engaging. Yes I don’t know what’s going on or why certain events happened the way they did yet, but uhh, it’s like a 13 book series or something. I just go in assuming I’ll get loads of context later.


r/Malazan • • Aug 31 '25

SPOILERS TtH Toll the Hounds is all over the place Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Dang does every book have to start off confusing? I’m 14% in and it feels even more all over the place than past books. Things about the Malazan ex-soldiers, the Redeemer, Torvald Nom, Eldest Silann, Kallor, Clip and Nimander, Spinnock, Seerdomin, and countless other plot lines? Come on Erikson, cut me some slack!


r/Malazan • • Oct 04 '26

SPOILERS HoC Why is Karsa Oorlong complex or interesting? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I finished reading House of Chains, and although I liked the book overall, it was the weakest out the first four for me. But I want to focus on Karsa Oorlong.

I don't understand the idea that Karsa is such an interesting or complex character, and I am dissappointed that Erikson chose him as the main PoV (maybe this will change in the later books?). There are so many other characters that I felt were far more compelling. Let me explain.

Karsa Oorlong is basically the Conan the Barbarian trope, which is well known. He's an overpowered fighter. He's a murderer and rapist. Throughout the book he just kills and kills over and over again. And by the end he gained some empathy, so he continues killing (the evil characters this time, like Bidithal etc.).

He is very narrow minded in my opinion, I don't find him interesting nor smart, nor anything really. He's incredibly overpowered with heavy handed plot armor (Easily kills the two Deragoth even though they were made out to be insane beasts). Other than being a killing machine who gets marginally more empathetic, I don't see what makes him complex. I am a big Malazan fan but his character felt borderline like it was written by a teenager with a power fantasy. Am I supposed to be impressed by his humanity after he brutally slaughters people over and over with the stoicism of a gorilla? Feels like he was written with a sledge hammer in comparison to characters like Icarium and Mappo.

Is he entertaining? Sure!

I can see why and how he fits in the story, but dedicating so much of the book to him felt like a missed opportunity to develop deeper and more human characters.

Sorry about the rant, this is coming from someone who otherwise really enjoys the series.

Please explain to me why you think he is an interesting character?


r/Malazan • • Oct 23 '24

SPOILERS MT are the tiste andii circumcised? NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m going to draw the sequence at the end of midnight tides in which silchas is killing the toblakai gods and i know in this scene he is supposed to be naked. is it ever talked about whether the tiste andii practice circumcision or not? if it is and it’s just in a book i haven’t read yet than i’d rather not be spoiled but i’ve read through toll the hounds so if i missed that detail please fill me in! or if erikson ever confirmed their circ status in an interview i could read or listen to that would be great to know!

edit: love you guys thanks for the insightful comments


r/Malazan • • Dec 30 '24

SPOILERS MT How relevant is Midnight Tides? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Just finished midnight tides. Cant figure out how it ties in to the series as a whole. Only connections I realised:

  1. Trull Senegar's back story

  2. all the scenes involving chained god ( left me confused)

  3. Rhulad making that xomment about flooding a world

  4. Errant is maybe an aspect of Oppon like champion or something?

Please let me know If I have missed anything. If I will find out after reading the next book then never mind


r/Malazan • • Sep 30 '24

NO SPOILERS Just finished GotM. Didn't really love it or hate it, is it worth carrying on?

1 Upvotes

Hello,

I have just finished Gardens of the Moon. I don't know how I feel about it, I didn't find it epic or exciting but I didn't hate it, I am just very indifferent to it and I don't know specifically what I didn't like about it, I don't know how to describe what I mean. It didn't 'click' with me like it did with others I have read about on r/Fantasy.

What I did like though were the characters: Tattersail, Sorry, Paran, and Anomander Rake. Is it worth reading on for these characters? And I didn't hate the lack of 'holding your hand', it wasn't as hard as reading Vivia by Tanith Lee if your familiar with that, though I think I would prefer the worldbuilding, lore etc being explained like it is traditionally in fantasy books.

I did enjoy the Second Apocalypse series and I do enjoy dark themes, though I know Malazan isn't as dark as Bakker.

Is it worth it, do you think, for me to read on?

Thanks in advance.


r/Malazan • • Jun 03 '25

NON-MALAZAN Can somebody tell me, really tell me, why I need to read the Book of the fallen first? And not go straight to the easier ones? Like path to ascendancy?

3 Upvotes

Also sorry if this was asked before.

I really want to read one of the prequel series. And I heard that there are not that many spoilers in the path to ascendancy series that spoil the main one. So reading that one should not spoil the main series, right?

Anyway, I just wanted to read the path to ascendancy in order to get my feet wet in this world. To see if I like it or not, and to see if I want to try the main big series eventually.

Thoughts? Please be kind.

Edit: I guess another question is this: Will I spoil anything really important in the main series if I read the prequels first? I think already asked that actually...


r/Malazan • • Dec 31 '23

SPOILERS DG Just finished Deadhouse Gates and Highly Disappointed Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I am a first time reader and I throughly enjoyed GOTM. I have very mixed feelings about this book.

The Good: I enjoyed the chain of dogs plot especially in the beginning though it meandered towards the end.

Mappo and Icarium friendship was cool and Pust was excellent comic relief.

The exposition overall was very interesting and I enjoyed learning about the world and seeing the characters progress, especially Felisin and Apsalar.

The Bad: The first 2/3 or so of the book was an absolute drag with only Duiker and Fiddler story being interesting, everything else seemed like filler.

Mappo and Icarium’s story was too vague to be compelling at first and I only began to appreciate them when they met with Fiddler and the gang.

Maybe just my version, but book was plagued with typos and grammar issues and I didn’t pick up how Heboric was blinded.

Ugly: The ending fell extremely flat for me. The chain of dogs started well, but eventually it just became ridiculous in how implausible it was. I had had enough when there was a delivery of food from two continents away, I couldn’t take the circus seriously anymore. I heard many good things about Coltaine, but he is just a distant, stoic leader who we know little about so I had no reason to care for him one way or the other. Sure his story is tragic, but I felt no connection to him. If anything I almost laughed at how comically stupid Pormqual and the nobles are. I might come off as facetious here but these things really took me out of the story. It also didn’t help that Coltaine will return anyway, so his big sacrifice means nothing because I’ll probably see him in the next book or 2. I am pleased that Duiker will be back though because if Duiker died that would mean that Coltaine’s whole fixation on remembrance would be all for nothing as well. I like Duiker overall but I hate his philosophical tirades. Honestly this goes for every character, it’s all very nihilistic and seems like Erickson thinks he’s imparting wisdom on the reader or something. I just felt like this plot line didn’t have the “huge payoff” I heard it would have.

Mappo and Icarium plot line seems pointless. Sure they helped out and there was a lot of exposition, but they should’ve either killed off Icarium or let him be taken. Instead the status quo is upheld and he is an amnesiac wandering the wastes just like at the beginning.

Kalam being able to kill dozens of Claws while being on his last leg began to break my suspension of disbelief, and I also do not understand why he no longer wants to kill Laseen. Imo he should’ve died.

Shadowthrone and Cotillion bid to kill Laseen through Fiddler and Kalem fails yet reward them with whatever they want??? I also was bewildered at this end to the plot line. It felt very comical.

Enjoyed Felisins arc, but her rise to Sha’ik, while satisfying, is nonsensical. She doesn’t even open the book yet suddenly has power?

Overall I am disappointed with this book after GOTM. People say this is amount the best books so I am wary of continuing. The book started very interesting, dragged for about 600 pages, and picked up at the end but gave me little reason to care about the “payoff”. I was left feeling amused at the ending, and imo the only emotional moment that landed was Kulp and Baudin’s death, which I don’t think the writer intended. The series so far also seems to be hesitant to permanently kill characters so should i expect important named characters to often cheat death? I think this book has a tonal imbalance in that it takes itself too seriously which leaves less room for benefit of the doubt and suspension of disbelief.


r/Malazan • • Sep 22 '24

SPOILERS ALL Question: Does the violence towards women ever lessen? NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I’m currently on Reapers Gale. I like the books, I absolutely loved fiddler and the lads, and the world building is really good. I’ve come to enjoy how he writes the books with little pieces of lore being explained as you go instead of exposition dumps. But with all of that said, the Sexual assault in the series just, throws me out of it a lot. Especially since it happens, or something like it happens to A LOT of the POV women characters. Such as Felisin (both of them), Seren Pedac, and I think a few others that I cannot remember right now. Like i get that it is a more gritty fantasy than Tolkien or the Cosmere, but it still leaves me feeling gross? I’m also not trying to discount the Sexual violence/assault against men either (one example would be Udinaas, and I’m sure there’s more) but it seems like specifically Erikson uses rape a bit as character building trauma on their main pov women characters. Further more there’s the whole Karsa Orlong situation where he goes to rape a whole village, and the ONLY reason it’s not rape is that all of the village women apparently wanted it, or something?

Sorry if this seems a bit offensive. I’m not trying to shame anyone for enjoying the series whatsoever. I’m just wondering if anyone else feels a little uncomfortable with some of the choices in the stories.

Edit: forgot to ask, please just general vibes if you can, I don’t want any hard spoilers for future books after Reapers Gale.

Edit 2: well damn, looks like my read of the Karsa Scene was very much wrong, and that it was in fact rape.