We are told, at some point in our childhoods, or at least I was, that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting the same results. That's of course not true, various psychological metrics can better describe fitness. It's a homely phrase, nothing more.
Until I read this Liberal Democrat proposal to invade Afghanistan.
Have we not learned as a nation? An errant Britain unilaterally intervening in a Muslim majority country against the US’s wishes? It’s not like this is a new concept, it's just a throwback to a bygone era. Ironically, the OG botch job’s successor, Harold MacMillan, told Alec Doulgas Home “my dear boy, as long as you do not invade Afghanistan you will be absolutely fine.”
This was supposed to be a warning, the Lib Dems interpreted it as a “hold my beer” cue.
Their proposal is here in full.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/p1adii/afghanistan_the_unfolding_disaster_for_british/
Let’s set a few clarifications first.
Advisors are troops. They are indistinguishable. At every single point in history, these so-called advisors end up doing more shooting than advising, and oftentimes will eventually make up a majority of the committed forces. If that point doesn’t get across, I would be happy to repeat it in Vietnamese.
Next, these advisors will be in a ground war. The Liberal Democrat op-ed says it is on the table, but the table is made exclusively of one material. The entire premise of the op-ed is we should replace the United States in this endeavor, and their strategy has relied on control of land via ground forces. This will not be a byproduct of the Liberal Democrat proposal, should it happen, it will be a feature.
Now, let’s establish some basic facts about the astronomical commitment the Liberal Democrats want to sign Britain onto.
There are several likely scenarios for what this invasion would entail, and I’ll offer some differing examples based on different numbers. The first basic assumption I am going to make is that the current residual levels of troops in Afghanistan by America would not be enough for the Liberal Democrats. After all, if their entire claim is that Britain can win the war against the Taliban, surely that would require more resources then the current American troop deployment that until the pullout was very much in a statement.
The most radical scenario. The Liberal Democrats want to wipe out the Taliban completely and entirely. While the numbers I present here may sound insane, I think there is a case that this scenario is the natural conclusion to the Liberal Democrats policy. They don’t want to tell the public they will be in a war forever, so they will commit overwhelming force in a bid to end the war quickly.
The height of American presence in Afghanistan was 100k troops. Again, I must emphasize these numbers were not enough to defeat the Taliban. Assuming they were, this would amount to 2/3rds of the British military sent to just one country. This would represent a 950%, yes, that's a serious number, increase in active deployment, which currently sits at around 11k.
Maybe somehow this magical boost in power you get when you fight in a Liberal Democrat war versus an American one means we need less troops. Ok. Lets cut that number down to 60k, numbers before and after the announcement of the Obama era “surge” policy. That is a 550% or so increase in active deployment, and a commitment of over half of the entirety of the British Military.
Even in the most generous possible scenario, where we simply replicate the residual troop levels America had before the pullout, that 14k number represents a doubling of our deployment. I gotta repeat this to make my point crystal clear. In the best case scenario, the Liberal Democrats will commit more British troops to Afghanistan then literally every other place on planet Earth.
These scenarios of course assume large amounts of things go right which almost certainly won’t, as I shall now lay out.
First, intelligence. The benefits of coalition intelligence gathering and sharing networks are not to be understated. The NATO coalition has a pool of resources bigger than the sum of its parts. Without NATO’s help, and in fact, having alienated and angered the largest NATO power by far, Britain would be flying blind. No doubt our military would try to compensate, but there is just physically no way to make up for the infrastructure laid by the Americans.
Next, troop levels. All the Liberal Democrat assumptions on this war are based on the confusing and unfounded assertion that British troops are somehow a magical panacea to a long ailing problem. How is this the case? We have an incredibly deep bilateral military relationship with the United States, if their troops were unable at 100k to eradicate the Taliban, what reason is there that ours would? Additionally, this take forgets the fact that Britain was already part of the stalled NATO coalition in the first place. We already took part in this failed project, yet somehow, by doing more of it, with more of our involvement, the problems that arose in the project we participated in go away? Inconceivable.
All of this sits on top of the fact that, while we are prosecuting the war over there, we will be facing our own diplomatic onslaught over here. Shunning the US and the rest of NATO, we would send ourselves spiralling into international pariahdom. America will be furious, as it seems to them a major source of condescension that a nominal ally somehow thinks it can take over an entire war on its own under the notion that the United States just wasn’t cutting it. One can only guess what secondary ramifications this severe diplomatic crisis would cause in other areas of our foreign policy.
And for what outcome? I only see two.
One, we stay there forever. At this point, the only thing extra the Liberal Democrat op-ed needed was the announcement of Shadow Viceroy for Afghanistan, because their proposal amounts for a permanent occupation with no end in sight, and just to confirm this notion, one of their other members said the goal was a vague “when the job is done”, which, to anyone with casual knowledge of this war, means never.
Or two, they eventually see the light and leave, putting us back at square one, with the only difference being countless British troops dead, avoidably, for no tangible achieved goal.
The failure of the west to protect Afghanistan is not based on the need for more Victorian Era cosplay around the strength of the British Empire. It is a failure of the institutions we built up, the aide we provide, and the political system we encouraged. If we want to help Afghanistan fix that, we need to accept that a large part of this mess was on our end, and that to truly solve this war, everything can’t look like a nail.