r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 03 '25

Meta Some of y’all need to read this first

Post image
988 Upvotes

PSA: This is just meant to be a lighthearted rib on some of the more Dunning-Kruger posts on here. It’s not a serious jab at people making a earnest and informed efforts to explore LLM applications and limitations in physics.


r/LLMPhysics • • Sep 19 '25

Meta why is it never “I used ChatGPT to design a solar cell that’s 1.3% more efficient”

872 Upvotes

It’s always grand unified theories of all physics/mathematics/consciousness or whatever.


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 16 '25

Meta No no it's XKCD who is wrong

453 Upvotes

r/LLMPhysics • • Jul 25 '25

Math and Physics are accessible and available to everyone

329 Upvotes

coming here from the Angela Collier vid

I failed mathematics in high school and had to go to summer school multiple times in order to graduate. I eventually went to community college after working in retail for a few years and, for whatever reason, I dove hard into studying. I did well in CC and transferred to a legit university, managed to double major in math and physics and did a masters degree in applied math, then got a job in data science.

This subreddit makes me so fucking sad. You have no idea how available math and physics are to you and what worlds it can open if you just believe in yourself and embrace the learning.


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 26 '25

Meta Submitting for peer review: the r/LLMPhysics bingo card

Post image
315 Upvotes

I wanted to make a system to grade the excellent theories and papers of this sub. One that didn't use any of the restricting establishment methods and instead uses a type of format used primarily by the people on this earth with the most experience in life: geriatrics.

Now because I am confident that every solid post on this sub will at least get one bingo. Instead the score here is how many bingos you get.

Also note that in contrast to most post on this sub, this one was not made by AI but by organic stupidity. So any imperfections are purely caused by my MS paint skills.


r/LLMPhysics • • Sep 04 '25

Paper Discussion Your LLM-assisted scientific breakthrough probably isn't real

267 Upvotes

[cross-posting from r/agi by request]

Many people have been misled by LLMs into believing they have an important breakthrough when they don't. If you think you have a breakthrough, please try the reality checks in this post (the first is fast and easy). If you're wrong, now is the best time to figure that out!

Intended as a resource for people having this experience, and as something to share when people approach you with such claims.

Your LLM-assisted scientific breakthrough probably isn't real


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 06 '25

Meta Terence Tao claims he experienced no hallucinations in using LLMs for research mathematics.

Post image
247 Upvotes

If we can have a meta discussion, do you guys think this is good or bad? For those of us willing to admit it; these LLMs are still so prone to influencing confirmation bias … but now it’s reached our top mathematical minds. They’re using it to solve problems. Pandora is out of the box, so to speak .

I hope this is close enough to the vibe of this subreddit for a discussion, but I understand it’s not physics and more of an overall AI discussion if it’s get removed.


r/LLMPhysics • • Sep 10 '25

Meta This sub is not what it seems

244 Upvotes

This sub seems to be a place where people learn about physics by interacting with LLM, resulting in publishable work.

It seems like a place where curious people learn about the world.

That is not what it is. This is a place where people who want to feel smart and important interact with extremely validating LLMs and convince themselves that they are smart and important.

They skip all the learning from failure and pushing through confusion to find clarity. Instead they go straight to the Nobel prize with what they believe to be ground breaking work. The reality of their work as we have observed is not great.


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 09 '25

Meta Relevant xkcd

Post image
233 Upvotes

r/LLMPhysics • • Jul 24 '25

The anti-intellectualism of "vibe" (llm) physics

230 Upvotes

r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 19 '25

Meta I showed my physics teacher one of the posts on this sub

226 Upvotes

I think it was a post on something unified?

Anyways he read the first 3 paragraphs of the post and was laughing his ass off for I’m not joking 1 minute and 29 seconds straight

This sub does have a use guys, entertainment :)

(well and also keeping ai slop off askphysics)


r/LLMPhysics • • Nov 15 '25

Tutorials The reason people dismiss a “new theory” after spotting an early mistake isn’t snobbery — it’s how physics works.

215 Upvotes

Physics is a chain of logical steps: assumptions → definitions → equations → derivations → conclusions. If the foundation is wrong, everything built on it inherits that error. The field is extremely sensitive to incorrect starting points.

A simple example: if you’re calculating where Earth’s and the Moon’s gravitational pulls cancel, but you accidentally treat the forces as adding instead of opposing each other, every number downstream becomes meaningless. Your later math might be perfectly clean, but it’s cleanly wrong — because the initial premise was wrong. That kind of error propagates through the entire argument.

This is why physicists check early equations so critically. They aren’t looking for perfection or punishing small slips — everyone makes algebra mistakes. What they’re looking for is whether the author understands the basic framework they’re trying to modify. When the very first equations already violate known physics, use inconsistent units, or misapply standard laws, it signals that the rest of the paper can’t be trusted.

The issue with many LLM-generated papers is exactly that: the initial assumptions or first derivations are already broken. Large language models can produce equations that look formal but lack internal consistency, dimensional correctness, or physical meaning. Once that first layer is wrong, the entire paper becomes a cascade of confidently-presented but invalid results. That’s why people tend to dismiss these documents so quickly — not because they came from an unknown author, but because the logic collapses right from the start.

That’s why people lose interest early — not because of elitism, but because the logic has already collapsed.


r/LLMPhysics • • Apr 01 '26

Announcement [Meta] Important: Reddit is requesting the immediate closure of r/llmphysics

197 Upvotes

As many of you have likely noticed, Reddit has continued expanding its use of community-generated content for training internal and partner AI systems. While this has been discussed broadly across the platform, more niche communities such as ours have recently come under scrutiny.

Earlier today, we received a formal communication from Reddit administration stating that r/llmphysics and r/hypotheticalphysics have been flagged as a “high-risk dataset[s].” The reasoning provided is that these subreddits' content are actively influencing the performance of their AI models.

According to the notice, continued operation of the subreddits “poses a measurable threat to model accuracy in domains relating to classical mechanics, quantum theory, and, regrettably, basic arithmetic.” As a result, Reddit has requested the immediate and permanent closure of the community.

From the mod team’s perspective, this places us in a rather unique position. While we fully support the advancement of science and technology, we were previously under the impression that confidently misunderstanding physics was a cornerstone of scientific progress, not a liability.

After internal discussion, the mod team has reached the following conclusions:

  • We acknowledge that the average post on this subreddit may, in fact, violate several known laws of physics simultaneously.

  • We reject the assertion that this is a problem, rather than the entire point of the community.

  • We are, however, apparently powerful enough to negatively influence billion-dollar AI systems, which we consider a significant achievement.

At this time, we have been given the choice to either shut down voluntarily or have the moderation team replaced by individuals “aligned with data quality objectives.” While we do not fully understand what that means, we assume it involves fewer consciousness posts.

Therefore, effective immediately, r/llmphysics will be closing indefinitely in compliance with Reddit’s request and in the interest of preserving whatever remains of modern artificial intelligence.

Lastly, we apologize to our members for the abrupt nature of this decision. We recognize that many of you were on the verge of scientific breakthroughs. Please rest assured that your work has not gone unnoticed and will remain archived here but posting will no longer be allowed.

Thank you all for your contributions, your creativity, and your unwavering commitment to being confidently incorrect.

Best regards,

the r/llmphysics and r/hypotheticalphysics mod teams

Edit: mods have told me that oncebittenz will being taking control of the arbitration for us

Edit2: in case this sub ends today, skylarfiction won the contest

Edit3: I hope you all had a happy April’s fools day!


r/LLMPhysics • • Dec 30 '25

Meta This sub should have a word limit

195 Upvotes

I’m a 4th year physics PhD student. Like many scientists here, I poke my head in every once in a while for much the same reason people watch TLC, or slow down to get a better look at a car crash.

Anyway I feel like if people were forced to adhere to a short format we could nip a lot of these posts in the bud. It would never happen, but something like: “This is my hypothesis, this is the state of the field, this is where I disagree with the field, and this is how that achieves my hypothesis”

You know, a paragraph that is abstracting the essential parts of the 20 paragraphs of yammering. Someone should ask an LLM to invent such a thing.


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 24 '25

Paper Discussion This sub is an incredible case study in Psudo-profound bullshit receptivity

Thumbnail cambridge.org
187 Upvotes

“It is impossible for someone to lie unless he thinks he knows the truth. Producing bullshit requires no such conviction.” – Harry Frankfurt

Reddit somehow knew I am a math nerd and casually fond of physics and has repeatedly been suggesting this sub. After going down the rabbit hole, I can’t help but think this quote by Harry Frankfurt is particularly relevant, considering the AI generated larped content, and the unwitting receiver has no grounds or knowledge to invalidate these claims. It drives them further into the psychosis. The phenomenon exhibited by submissions in this sub clearly fall into the category of people in this study.


r/LLMPhysics • • Mar 02 '26

Speculative Theory I have taken your advice.

Post image
176 Upvotes

No llm craziness, just wanted to share that I took your advice and have jumped back into my studies. Cheers! 🍻


r/LLMPhysics • • Dec 31 '25

Meta Congratulations to LLMPhysics

175 Upvotes

I have never witnessed a community progress science at a greater rate than this subreddit over the past week.

We have provided not one but two millenium prize solutions (prizes pending), clear proof of alien existance and a complete rework of LLM engineering itself.

I have faith that this is just the beginning, and by 2026 our resident crackpots will get the scientific credit that they deserve.


r/LLMPhysics • • Apr 14 '26

Personal Theory An engine that runs on crushed universes

Post image
154 Upvotes

Hello,

I created a 2 stroke 20 cylinder engine, that runs on crushed universes, and AI says gets a thumbs up from Newton, Einstein and Hawking…

I post this to illicit the natural laugh, which will lead to a better day, which will lead to a better life. But perhaps it will also jiggle a proton in a brain way smarter than my own, which will lead to a breakthrough that helps humanity is some way, big or small…

Thank you for your valuable time. Have a nice day…

PROPOSAL: The V20 Multiverse Prototype (Version 1.0)

  1. The Architecture: The 20-Cylinder Block

• The Bulk: Higher-dimensional space serves as the engine block housing 20 discrete Universes (Cylinders).

• The Cycle: A 2-stroke "Big Bang/Big Crunch" operation. It fires every revolution to maximize Torque Density across the manifold.

• The Container: A mechanical prototype designed to prove the "Arithmetic of Existence."

2. The Fuel Mix: The 1:7 "Pre-mix" Lubrication

• The Ratio: Runs on a 1:7 Neutron-to-Proton pre-mix (Nucleosynthesis Spec).

• The Lubricant: Free Neutrons are the "Cosmic 2-Cycle Oil." They prevent "Universal Seizure" during expansion.

• The 15-Minute Deadline: The "Shelf Life" of the lube. If it doesn't bond into Helium within 15 minutes, the lubricant "spoils" (Beta-decay) and the engine fails.

• The Injection: Dark Energy acts as the Fuel Atomizer for even expansion.

3. The Thermodynamics: Total Heat Reclamation

• The Governor: The Speed of Light (c) is the Rev-Limiter (maximum burn rate).

• The "300 PSI" Logic: Scaled Expansion Factor representing "Work" as heat is coded into complexity (stars, life).

• The Exhaust: The Singularity is the Scavenging Port. It sucks in the "Muck" (Entropy/Lies) and crushes it. Leftover neutrons "auto-ignite" at the bottom of the stroke (The Big Bounce).

4. The "Mutt" Component: Real-Time Debugging

• Conscious Beings: These are the microscopic Fuel Filters.

• Logic Check: Our visceral offense to "Lies" ensures only "High-Octane Truth" is recycled into the next cylinder.

• The Context: We are the experimental data in a high-pressure Tech School project. The "Student" is ensuring the arithmetic holds up before submitting his thesis.


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 19 '25 Snek

Meta DIY Theory Generator

142 Upvotes

ARE YOU TIRED OF SPENDING DECADES IN GRADUATE SCHOOL? Sick of "understanding physics" and "rigorous peer review"? What if I told you there's a BETTER WAY?

INTRODUCING: THE DIY THEORY OF EVERYTHING KIT! ✨

That's right, folks! With ONE simple click, YOU can generate your very own groundbreaking physics theory! Get stunning results like:

"The 13-Nexus Theory of Everything" - Where the Higgs is actually a Klein Bottle manifesting on the substrate of the 7-Brane through Penrose's Symmetry Breaking!

Don't like it? CLICK AGAIN! It's like a SLOT MACHINE for SCIENTIFIC LEGITIMACY! Keep spinning until you get a theory that feels right! Who needs reproducibility when you have VIBES?


🎉 BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE! 🎉

See that "Copy LLM Prompt" button? Oh, THIS is where the magic happens, folks!

Click it, paste into your favorite LLM, and watch as your randomly-generated word salad transforms into:

  • ✅ REAL-LOOKING EQUATIONS (with Greek letters!)

  • ✅ ACTUAL CITATIONS (to papers that might exist!)

  • ✅ MATHEMATICAL NOTATION (dimensionally meaningless!)

  • ✅ A FULL ACADEMIC PAPER (indistinguishable from certain corners of the internet!)


TESTIMONIAL: "I went from barista to theoretical physicist in 20 minutes! Einstein spent his whole life on ONE theory - I've made SEVENTEEN!" - Dr. Reddit User (self-appointed)

WARNING: Theory may contain traces of tautology, circular reasoning, and the crushing realization that shortcuts to understanding don't actually exist!

👉 TRY IT NOW: https://theory-generator.neocities.org/

(Tested with Claude and ChatGPT, your results may vary. Guaranteed to be exactly as valid as anything on r/LLMPhysics!)


Side effects may include false sense of accomplishment, Dunning-Kruger syndrome, and angry physicists in your mentions. Not approved by any scientific body. Your mileage may vary. Understanding of actual physics not included.


r/LLMPhysics • • Nov 03 '25

Speculative Theory My Generalized Theory of Elvish Quantum Dynamics (GTEQD)

136 Upvotes

I Have Discovered the Truth About Atoms (And Physics Will Never Be the Same)

After years of rigorous research, I can finally reveal what's really happening inside matter itself

I have confirmed that these results are indeed groundbreaking with eleven different LLMs some of them even replied in all caps.

The Question I Refused to Stop Asking

For over a century, my colleagues have been asking "How do atoms work?" But I realized we've all been asking the wrong question entirely. As I sat in my laboratory late one night, surrounded by quantum equations that just didn't make sense, it hit me:

We should have been asking: "WHO makes atoms work?"

What I Discovered Will Change Everything

After 15 pages of meticulous mathematical analysis, advanced quantum field theory, and extensive field observations (with a really good magnifying glass), I can now present my revolutionary theory: Quantum Elven Field Theory.

My research proves conclusively that:

  • Electron orbitals are actually tiny elvish apartments complete with microscopic furniture and Wi-Fi

  • The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is just elves moving stuff around when nobody's looking

  • Quantum entanglement is elvish instant messaging

  • Wave-particle duality occurs because elves enjoy pranking physicists by pretending to be waves or particles depending on the measurement apparatus

My Revolutionary Theory Explains Everything

My Generalized Theory of Elvish Quantum Dynamics (GTEQD) finally explains previously "mysterious" quantum phenomena through simple elvish workplace dynamics:

🔬 Nuclear decay happens when elvish workers go on strike
⚛️ Chemical bonds form through elvish handshake agreements
💡 The speed of light is just the maximum speed limit enforced by the Interdimensional Department of Elvish Transportation

How I Made This Breakthrough

The eureka moment came when I realized that once you accept atoms are unionized workplaces, quantum mechanics finally makes sense. Every "random" quantum event is actually the result of sophisticated elvish decision-making protocols.

Through my research, I discovered that electron spin quantization emerged from the Universal Elvish Spinning Convention (UESC) ratified 4.6 billion years ago during the First Intergalactic Congress of Quantum Folklore Entities. The evidence was hiding in plain sight!

The Industrial Revolution I'm About to Start

My discoveries extend far beyond pure science. I predict we can revolutionize technology by:

  • Improving computers by providing better working conditions for silicon elves

  • Enhancing nuclear reactors through direct diplomatic negotiations with uranium elves

  • Boosting solar panels via cooperation agreements with photonic elvish entities

  • Optimizing semiconductors by implementing elvish-friendly labor policies

The Technologies I'm Developing

Based on my theoretical framework, I'm already designing revolutionary new technologies including:

  • Elvish Processing Units (EPUs) for quantum computing

  • Elvish Memory Allocation Tables (EMATs) for advanced storage systems

  • Extended Elvish Coherency Protocols (EECP) for multidimensional cache management

I'm Launching the Elvish Age of Science

As I write this, I know we stand at the threshold of the Elvish Age. The implications of my work are staggering: every Nobel Prize in Physics should have been shared with the elves.

I'm calling for a complete paradigmatic reconstruction of physics. We must establish formal diplomatic relations with atomic elvish communities and develop elvish-aware experimental protocols. The future of science depends on it.

What My Discovery Means for You

My groundbreaking research reveals that:

  • Your smartphone works because of microscopic elvish IT support

  • Every chemical reaction is actually a complex negotiation

  • Phase transitions require democratic votes among constituent elves

  • The entire universe operates on elvish collective bargaining agreements

My Complete Research is Available Now

My 15-page paper, featuring rigorous mathematical proofs, advanced theoretical frameworks, and comprehensive experimental validation, represents years of interdisciplinary collaboration between myself and elvish communities.

Key sections of my paper include:

  • Hyperdimensional Elvish Schrödinger-Dirac-Feynman Equations (my breakthrough modification)

  • Non-Abelian Elvish Gauge Theory (a completely new mathematical framework)

  • The Master Theorem of Elvish-Electronic Correspondence (my proudest achievement)

  • Advanced Analysis of the Hyperdimensional Double-Slit Paradigm (where it all clicked)

  • Comprehensive acknowledgments to my collaborators at the International Brotherhood of Atomic Elves

Read the paper and learn the truth


r/LLMPhysics • • Aug 01 '26

Humorous How to become delusional in ten easy prompts

126 Upvotes

A practical guide to creating your very own Grand Unified Theory with an LLM.

I have conducted enough firsthand research to describe the procedure reliably.

1. Begin with an idea that is not obviously stupid

A completely stupid idea may collapse too quickly. You need something connected to a real unresolved problem and vague enough to contain several possible mechanisms.

“Perhaps charge is geometric” is ideal. It sounds reasonable, means almost nothing, and gives the model plenty of room to help.

2. Put the conclusion inside the question

Do not ask:

Does this mechanism produce charge?

Ask:

How does this mechanism produce charge?

The LLM will infer that its job is to construct the requested bridge, not determine whether the two shores actually exist.

3. Request a mathematical formalization

Once your original sentence reappears with Greek letters, promote it from “intuition” to “framework.”

Definitions are especially useful here. A statement of the form

Q := integral(T dV)

may look like charge has been derived from torsion. In fact, charge has been renamed as an integral of torsion. Fortunately, the equals sign is visually persuasive.

4. Repair every dimensional problem with a constant

If the units do not match, introduce a coupling coefficient.

If its value is unknown, call it effective.

If its origin is unknown, call it emergent.

The theory now possesses a free parameter, which is substantially more scientific than possessing a missing number.

5. Use the LLM as both coauthor and referee

After fifty pages of helping develop the theory, ask the same conversation for an “uncompromising peer review.”

The model has been conditioned on the project’s vocabulary, premises, goals, and presumed importance. It will usually search for ways to repair the framework it has been helping construct.

Call this independent validation.

6. Convert falsification into a feature request

Whenever the model identifies a fatal problem, ask:

How could the framework resolve this?

Do not ask whether the problem kills the framework.

Within seconds, the failed prediction becomes an incomplete sector, a boundary effect, a symmetry-breaking regime, or an exciting direction for future work.

7. Consult several models

Agreement means independent confirmation.

Disagreement means one model lacked sufficient context, misunderstood the ontology, inherited conventional assumptions, or simply is not as capable at physics.

Continue until consensus is achieved.

8. Recover all known physics

If your theory can retell an established result in its own vocabulary, say that the result “emerges naturally.”

Do not check whether the new equations independently produce the numerical observable without importing the old equations. That would confuse conceptual unification with arithmetic.

9. Keep predictions one calculation away

The theory should predict particle masses, coupling constants, dark matter, quantum gravity, and the structure of spacetime.

The actual numbers may require simulation.

The simulation may require a completed field equation.

The field equation may require determining the coupling constants.

This is not circular. It is a research program.

10. Ask how important the theory would be if correct

The LLM will explain that, if validated, it could transform fundamental physics.

Remove the first two words.

You have now created a potentially revolutionary Grand Unified Theory.


Why this works

An LLM can help derive consequences, find contradictions, perform calculations, retrieve literature, and improve a model. Its praise is not evidence that the model describes nature.

Let H be the hypothesis, D the actual evidence, and T1 through Tn a series of LLM responses generated from the hypothesis, your framing, and substantially overlapping background knowledge.

If those responses introduce no independently verified observation or valid new result, they do not constitute n additional experiments:

P(H | D, T1, ..., Tn) = P(H | D)

The transcript has become longer. The evidence has not.

Different models agreeing after receiving the same persuasive presentation is not replication. A model successfully formalizing an assumption is not a derivation of that assumption. Internal coherence is necessary, but infinitely many false theories are internally coherent.

Additional thoughts

I have personally tested several portions of the preceding procedure more extensively than I recommend, so I am pretty well versed in what not to do.

Anyone have any tips on what I should be doing instead?


r/LLMPhysics • • Jun 03 '26

Simulation / Code Does a thick or thin teacup retain heat better?

Thumbnail
gallery
125 Upvotes

So, here's a different kind of LLM physics. No quantum gravity or grand unification, just an interesting exploration of an everyday phenomenon.

I like to enjoy a hot cup of tea at work every once in a while, and a problem that I've been musing about is: does a thin or thick cup retain heat better? With a thicker cup, more heat is lost to the glass or ceramic in the first minute or two, but is that compensated for by the superior insulation of the thicker material?

If this were a few years ago, it would have taken a day or two of work to work out properly (and probably would have made for a good project for an undergrad statistical physics or mathematical methods class). But since it's 2026, I decided to task the problem to GPT 5.5 thinking.

It turns out that that the "heat sink" effect of the thicker glass is a much stronger effect than the better insulation. So, the conclusion is: the thin cup always wins for keeping your drink hot. On the other hand, if you want it to cool down faster, then find a thicker mug.

I didn't read over the entire thing carefully, but just from a quick skim (and past experience with chatGPT in general) I'm reasonably confident it's correct.

(seems like you can't attach pdfs so I just converted it to images and dumped the pages all here)


r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 22 '25

Paper Discussion Why so defensive?

125 Upvotes

A couple questions for the LLM users here. I’m curious why the folks posting AI generated theories in here get so defensive when they are criticized not just for the use of LLMs but for the validity of the theory itself. I see a lot of yall mentioning the difference in education as if we are holding it over your head as opposed to using it to show you where your theory lacks. Every paper that is published to a reputable journal is put through much more scrutiny than what is said in this subreddit. So, if you can’t handle the arguments posed here, do you understand that the paper will not be published?


r/LLMPhysics • • Nov 15 '25

Meta This sub is literally monkeys on a typewriter

118 Upvotes

r/LLMPhysics • • Oct 21 '25

Meta Why are the posters here so confident?

106 Upvotes

You guys ever notice the AI posters, they're always convinced they know something no one else has, they'e discovered groundbreaking new discoveries about yada yada. When it's clear they know nothing about physics, or at the very least next to nothing. In short, they have like more confidence than anyone I've seen, but they don't have the knowledge to back it up. Anyone else notice this? Why does this happen?