r/Koans • u/NeoPlatonist • Jul 21 '13
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • Jun 11 '15
I respectfully resign from /r/koans
Good morning!
As many of you already know, I have spent several years transcribing koans here in this little subreddit. I've always been happy to do it, and I've always considered it my own little way of "giving back" to the Reddit community at large.
This may seem hard to believe, but when I first discovered reddit (back in 2006 or so) it propagated the classic "hacker culture" What do I mean by this? It encouraged creativity, intelligence, community participation- and above all else- discouraged censorship in any form.
I realize that sounds absolutely insane in the context of the Reddit of 2015, but its true. There was a time (albeit a long time ago) when Reddit understood that the freedom of speech was more important than the feelings of SJW's.
I do not care for the leadership of Ellen Pao. And I don't intend to rant and rave my own personal politics at you; you are all free to agree or disagree with me however you wish. But as for me- I simply refuse to spend any more time building content and traffic for an organization that simply does not share my core values anymore.
Reddit is filled- FILLED- with ridiculous, offense subreddits. This has been true since the moment I first arrived. I could link to the most vile, gross, racist, sexist, violent, mentally unhinged subreddits that exist, but rather than illustrate my point, that would only drive traffic to them, so I won't.
My biggest problem with the new pro-censorship policies of Ellen Pao is that they are inconsistent. I myself am extremely offended both by many of these remaining subreddits, and by the behavior of reddit admins. However, for reasons known only to reddit administration, some offensive subreddits will be banned, and other allowed to thrive.
I know for a fact that some people are offended by /r/koans here. They are offended by my habit, and they are convinced I "don't get it". Others are offended by non-Christian religions altogether. Yet others aren't offended by the koans themselves, but of the general "cultural conquest" as our primarily-white audience assimilates eastern culture. Point being: there is no shortage of potential reasons to be offended.
I believe that when offense occurs, the correct course of action is to either (a) engage in thoughtful debate to establish a better understanding and/or (b) ignore the bullies who are simply trying to get a rise out of you.
Ellen Pao and her staff elect instead for a policy of selective censorship- where some offensive things are removed, and other offensive things (things that personally offend the hell out of me myself) are allowed to fester. I am simply not ok with this. Who has the authority to decide what content has merit and which content does not? And just because I personally dislike or am offended by a subreddit, should I have the right to butt-in and shut it down?
This entire "victim culture" is absolutely poisonous and it does nothing but further victimize those it intends to help.
I am ashamed and embarrassed to have wasted so much of my time on this service. Rather than "offend" anyone further, I will self-censor, and this will be the last you hear from me.
If anyone wishes to take over this subreddit, send me a PM and I will happily hand over the keys.
Good luck to all of you with your additional study.
EDIT: I feel the need to clarify the concept of "freedom of speech".
Legally, as an American, this usually refers to the First Amendment, a specific law that prevents Congress from establishing any laws that limit freedom of religion or the press, usually referred to collectively as "freedom of speech". It has been interpreted to apply to all sorts of mediums beyond the written word, including but not limited to, music, film, Internet memes, and all sorts of other media that simply did not exist yet when this law was written. Furthermore, the "freedom" of speech is absolutely limited, and for a variety of different reasons. Yelling "fire!" in a crowded theatre is a crime, as is producing a t-shirt with Mickey Mouse on it (without the permission of Disney)- just to name two quick examples.
The legalities of the "freedom of speech" is a fascinating topic, and my personal opinions were strongly influenced by my (now dead) personal heroes such as Frank Zappa and George Carlin and Bill Hicks and Aaron Swartz.
But- Reddit is not Congress, nor is it passing any laws in violation of any constitutional rights. And I wasn't trying to claim otherwise. As a private company, Reddit is free to set (and change) their Terms of Service at any time. By using this service, I am agreeing to said terms. They can make whichever policies they wish, and censor whatever they like. But do not conflate a legal technicality with a philosophical value.
Anyone can "censor". For example, private network television stations often edit R-rated films to remove thing considered profane for broadcast. Photographs may be blurred or cropped. Parents might disallow specific content. A school might remove certain materials. Calling these acts of censorship is meant to be descriptive, not alarmist. There are perfectly reasonable reasons we censor things, and most acts of censorship are not part of a vast conspiracy to deprive us of liberty but rather, an attempt to make things more pleasant.
I totally get that. Not everyone wants to listen to Frank Zappa. I totally get that too.
But for me, the entire issue boils down to a simple (if not pretentious) quote:
I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it.
This is often credited to Voltaire, but regardless of who said it, the truth is contained herein.
Now- can I address the elephant in the room? The banning of "Fat People Hate"?
If you wish to waste hours of your life looking through my comment history, you will see that a year ago I had lamented the fact I was nearly 240lbs, and still smoking a pack of cigarettes per day- two extremely unhealthy habits. My career was doing gangbusters, but my personal health had gone into the crapper. Simply stated, achieving work-life balance has been the major challenge of my 30's.
I am proud to tell you that as of this morning I am over a month nicotine-free, and I am still hovering around 190lbs (I was down to about 175lb before I quit the cigs). My BMI is at the edge of "overweight"- and I'll tell you something- its totally correct. To have a BF of 15% or so, I'd expect I need to weigh around 160lbs, which means I still have 30 to go.
Now- I'm not here to defend Fat People Hate. First of all, the word "hate" is right there, so I'm pretty sure if Reddit were hosted in the EU that name would be prevented by law (again-different places have different laws- don't confuse the legalities of freedom of speech with the philosophical questions behind those laws). I think it was pretty obviously a mean-spirited sub, and I'm not proud to tell you that I poked around in there on a few occasions on my recent weight loss journey. And if you check my history, you will see I was a "lurker". I never posted anything, I never commented. I was very much "on the fence" about it.
My goal is to be a better Josh, a better me. Not a bully, not better than you- a better me. And to be honest, "Fat People Hate" just never really sat right with me, and so, I never joined or participated- although I was well aware of it.
I want to share some facts, because I like facts, and I believe the truth will set you free. Besides, I've already completely screwed my schedule for the morning, so I may as well keep ranting into the Internet, just in case someone is listening.
FPH did not allow its users to link to other parts of reddit- nearly everything I ever saw submitted was a screenshot. They did not encourage "brigading" or interfering with other subreddits. I never intended to get involved in this debate; I'm not a member of FPH, but as an occasional lurker, I know this to be factually untrue. I don't like being lied to.
FPH posted a public picture of the people being IMGUR in their sidebar. The image was public. No personal details were included in that picture. No "doxxing" took place as far as I can tell. Again, I never intended to get involved in this debate; I'm not a member of FPH, but as an occasional lurker, I know this to be factually untrue. And I really don't like being lied to.
FPH was mean spirited, full of bullies and self-loathing fat people. I know this because I was one of them. I'm still very torn here. I feel guilty for having been motivated by it. Furthermore, it made me aware of things like "HAES" which I simply would never have been exposed to otherwise.
So now that "I'm out" as a self-loathing fatty, let me share some more facts:
Quitting smoking, and quitting ice cream, are both extremely hard to do
BOTH involve chemical addiction. Sugar is a serious drug; just because they push it on kids doesn't mean its safe.
As a society we have agreed that the health consequences of smoking outweigh the issue of "smoker freedom". If I argue I have a "right to smoke" in your favorite restaurant, you would find that laughable. If I was to exhale a single puff, I'd be tossed out on my ear (rightfully so). No one is arguing for "smoker acceptance". I'm not claiming that "real men have tar filled lungs". Anyone who did would be labeled insane.
We are quickly approaching the point of no return- the point where more of us are obese than not obese. The point at which the dystopian vision of WALL-E becomes a reality.
People smoke for all sorts of reasons; stress, to cope with pain, to fill time, due to tradition, and ritual, and routine, and temptation, and the power of marketing, and whim.
People eat for all sorts of reasons; stress, to cope with pain, to fill time, due to tradition, and ritual, and routine, and temptation, and the power of marketing, and whim.
WE ARE THE AUTHORS OF OUR STORY
WE WILL DECIDE HOW THAT STORY WILL END
We can choose to be victims in our story, but I choose to be the hero instead. All of my power in this life is contained within that simple choice.
It is quite possible to lose 50 pounds, and quite possible to quit smoking. Its not easy, but it's quite possible. And let's cut the bullshit here- this is simply science. Track what you eat, track your exercise- be honest with yourself and let the data guide you, and you WILL LOSE WEIGHT. I promise you that- I'm walking evidence of that.
Holy shit- what a rant. Ok, I'll shut up now.
tl;dr- Freedom of speech rules; addiction to cigarettes or food can be overcome via willpower. Don't be a victim; be a hero. Be a better you.
EDIT 2 - June 12 @ 7:42 am - Is there anything worse than a guy who quits but then won't leave? Probably not. Needless to say, I am completely blown away by the response to this post.
Many of you have expressed interest in these koans, and so, I am trying to setup a new home for us here:
However, due to the latest "mass exodus" the voat servers are still completely overwhelmed, so it may require some patience before it loads for you. Please note: moving forward, this is a small community focused on koan study; I normally try to keep my personal politics and opinions out of it.
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • Jun 04 '15
The Dialogue of Manjusri and Wu Cho - (BCR - 35 of 100)
Pointer
Determining dragons and snakes, distinguishing jewels and stones, separating the profound and the naive, to settle all uncertainty: if you haven't an eye on your forehead and a talisman under your elbow, time and again you will miss the point immediately. Right at this very moment seeing and hearing are not obscured; sound and form are purely real. Tell me, is it black? Is it white? Is it crooked? Is it straight? At this point, how will you discriminate?
Case
Manjusri asked Wu Cho, "Where have you just come from?"1
Wu Cho said, "The South."2
Manjusri said, "How is the Buddhist Teaching being carried on in the South?"3
Wu Cho said, "Monks of the Last Age have little regard for the rules of discipline."4
Manjusri said, "How numerous are the congregations?"5
Wu Cho said, "Some three hundred, some five hundred."6
Wu Cho asked Manjusri, "How is it being carried on hereabouts?"7
Manjusri said, "Ordinary people and sages dwell together; dragons and snakes intermingle."8
Wu Cho said, "How numerous are the congregations?"9
Manjusri said, "In front, three by three; in back, three by three."10
Notes
It is necessary to pose the question. There is still this news.
He sticks his head up from his nest in the weeds. Why should he hoist it on to his eyebrows? There is nothing outside the great vastness; why is there nevertheless a South?
If he asked someone else, a disaster would happen. It still lingers on his teeth and lips.
A truthful man is hard to find.
At that moment I would immediately give him a shout. With one nudge he pushes him over.
They are all wild fox spirits. After all he's let slip.
He's pushed! Immediately he turns the spear around and comes back with it.
He's suffered quite a loss. In fact his feet are frantic, his hands in confusion.
Give me back the words. Still he can't be let go.
Crazy words, insane talk. But tell me, how many are they? Even the Great Compassionate One with a thousand hands could not count them all.
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • May 09 '15
Kuei Shan and Iron Grindstone Liu - (BCR - 24 of 100)
Pointer
Stand on the summit of the highest peak, and demons and outsiders cannot know you; walk on the bottom of the deepest sea, and even the Buddha's eye cannot catch sight of you. Even if your eyes are like shooting stars and your intellect is like flashing lightning, still you won't avoid (being like) the spirit tortoise dragging his tail (leaving traces.) At this point, what is proper? To test, I'm citing this: Look!
Case
Iron Grindstone Liu arrived at Kuei Shan.1 Kuei Shan said, "Old cow, so you've come!"2
The Grindstone said, "Tomorrow there's a great communal feast on T'ai Shan; are you going to go, Teacher?"3
Kuei Shan relaxed his body and lay down;4 the Grindstone immediately left.5
Notes
Unavoidably it'll be hard to stay there. This old lady is out of her depth.
Check! A probing pole, a reed shade. Where should you look to see the obscurity?
The arrow is not shot to no purpose. In China they beat the drum, in Korea they dance. The letting go was too fast, the gathering in is too slow.
The arrow got him. Where will you see Kuei Shan? Who realizes that in the far-off misty waves there is another more excellent realm of thought?
She's gone. She saw the opportunity and acted.
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • May 30 '15
Ministry President Ch'en Sees Tzu Fu - (BCR - 33 of 100)
Pointer
He does not discriminate east from west, nor distinguish south from north, from morning till evening, evening till morningi but can you say he is fast asleep? Sometimes his eyes are like comets, but can you say he is wide awake? Sometimes he calls south northi but tell me, is he mindful or mindless? Is he a man of the Way or an ordinary man? If you can pass through here, for the first time you will know the ultimate, and then you will know how the ancients were so or not so. But tell me, what time is this? To test, I cite this. Look!
Case
Ch'en Ts'ao, ministry president, went to see Tzu Fu. When Fu saw him coming, he immediately drew a circle.1 Ts'ao said, "My coming here like this has already missed the pointi how much more so, to go on and draw a circle!"2 Fu thereupon closed the door of his room.3
Hsueh Tau said, "Ch'en Ts'ao has just one eye."4
Notes
This is a spirit recognizing a spirit, a thief recognizing a thief. If he were not relaxed and at ease, how could he discern this fellow? But do you see the adamantine cage?"
Today he has encountered a man who's fast asleep. This old thief!
A thief does not break into a poor man's house. He has already entered the other's cage.
Hsueh Tou has an eye on his forehead. But tell me, where does his meaning lie? He should give him another circle. Clearly. Ch'en Ts'ao has a dragon's head, but a snake's tail; at that time he should have given Tzu Fu such a thrust that he would have had no gate to advance through, and no road to retreat upon. But tell me, what further pressure could he bring to bear on him?
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!
r/Koans • u/[deleted] • Sep 19 '21
R/Koans Suggestions Thread
This is a post for everyone currently active in r/Koans to discuss what they want to see, what types of discussions they envision for the community, and any other meta ideas they would like to bring to the table.
Got ideas for the sub?
Leave a comment below.
r/Koans • u/HerbAsher1618 • Mar 23 '15
A modern koan for the modern man's mind.
How much wood would a woodchuck chop if a woodchuck could chop wood?
r/Koans • u/demmian • Oct 02 '12
Hekiganroku, case 5: Seppô's Grain of Rice
Instruction:
Whosoever may sustain the principle of our school must be a person of noble and excellent spirit. Only those who are able to kill someone without blinking their eyes can become buddhas right where they stand. Hence you illuminate and act simultaneously, you hold fast and let go at the same time. Essence and phenomena are not two, expedients and reality are equally employed.
[Yet] you descend one grade and adopt a secondary method. If you cut off all complications on the spot, late-comers and beginners can hardly abide in the port. Yesterday was this way, it could not be avoided; today was also this way, the transgressions fill up the heaven.
If it is a clear-eyed person, however, he or she cannot be fooled even a bit. Otherwise, you are sure to put yourself in the tiger's mouth and lose your life. I will cite an example, look!
Case:
Seppô said to the assembly, "When you pick up the whole great earth, it is as small as a grain of rice. You throw it down before you. Like a black lacquer bucket, you don't recognize anything. Beat the drums, summon all the people, and search for it!"
Verse:
A cow head sinks, a horse head turns up.
In Sôkei's mirror no dust is found.
I beat the drums for you to look – but you don't see.
For whom do the blossoms bloom in the spring?
Links:
Introductory post to Hekiganroku
List of posted koans.
Extended commentary on verse, case and introduction
r/Koans • u/demmian • Oct 12 '12
Hekiganroku, case 14: Unmon's "A Preaching in Accordance
Case:
A monk asked Unmon, "What are the 'periods and teachings' of the whole lifetime of Shakyamuni?" Unmon said, "A preaching in accordance."
Notes:
Alternative translation of the answer:
"Preaching one thing." [In Japanese: Tai-issetsu.]
Verse:
"A preaching in accordance"!
How lofty and unique!
A wedge is struck into an iron hammer with no hole.
Under the tree in Embu there is loud laughing:
The black dragon had his horn broken last night.
Remarkable, remarkable!
Old Shôyô [still] has one horn.
Links:
Introductory post to Hekiganroku
List of posted koans.
Extended commentary on verse, case and introduction.
r/Koans • u/[deleted] • Jun 18 '12
/r/ awakened is a new sub reddit. It is a gathering palace for those seeking self knowledge and truth in life.
r/Koans • u/imkharn • May 14 '15
All is lost [OC]
Teacher, I worry my husband may die soon. What can I do to ease my worry?
Teacher: You knew you he would die when you met him. Shouldn't you have started worrying earlier?
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • Jun 06 '15
Ch'ang Sha Wandering in the Mountains - (BCR - 36 of 100)
Pointer
None.
Case
One day Ch'ang Sha went wandering in the mountains. Upon returning, when he got to the gate,1 the head monk asked, "Where are you coming from, Master?"2
Sha said, "From wandering in the mountains."3
The head monk asked, "Where did you go? "4
Sha said, "First I went pursuing the fragrant grasses; then I returned following the falling flowers."5
The head monk said, "How very much like the sense of springtime."6
Sha said, "It even surpasses the autumn dew" dripping on the lotuses."7 Hsueh Tou added the remark, "Thanks for your reply."8
Notes
Today, one day. He has only fallen into the weeds; at first he was falling into the weeds; later he was still falling in the weeds.
He still wants to try this old fellow. The arrow has flown past Korea.
Don't fall in the weeds. He's suffered quite a loss. A man in the weeds.
A thrust. If he had gone anywhere, he couldn't avoid falling into the weeds. They drag each other into a pit of fire.
He's let slip quite a bit. From the beginning he's just been sitting in a forest of thorns.
He comes following along, adding error to error; one hand uplifts, one hand presses down.
He adds mud to dirt. The first arrow was light; the second arrow was deep. What end will there ever be?
A group of fellows playing with a mud ball. The three have their crimes listed on the same indictment.
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!
r/Koans • u/FluffyAmethyst • Feb 02 '17
Osho - Talks on Zen: The Buddha: The Emptiness of the Heart, Chapter 6: To take up a koan
r/Koans • u/NeoPlatonist • Sep 12 '14
To thicken a sauce
To thicken a sauce, one adds a small amount of the liquid to the thickening agent, then adds the resulting slurry to the remainder of the liquid.
Stir vigorously, then throw away.
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • May 19 '15
Nan Ch'uan's Truth That's Never Been Spoken - (BCR - 28 of 100)
Pointer
None.
Case
Nan Ch'uan went to see Master Nirvana of Pai Chang (Mountain.)
Chang asked, "Have all the sages since antiquity had a truth that they haven't spoken for people?"1
Ch'uan said, "They have."2
Chang said, "What is the truth that hasn't been spoken for people?"3
Ch'uan said, "It's not mind, it's not buddha, it's not any thing."4
Chang said, "You said it."5
Ch'uan said, "I am just thus. What about you, Teacher?"6
Chang said, "I am not a great man of knowledge either: how would I know whether it has been spoken or not?"7
Ch'uan said, "I don't understand."8
Chang said, "I've already spoken too much for you."9
Notes
A master should know. It stands like a wall ten thousand fathoms high. Does Chang feel his teeth falling out?
He's fallen into the weeds. Why so brash? Then there is such a thing!
Look how his hands are flustered, his feet frantic. He adds error to error. Just try and ask!
As it turns out he suffers defeat. After all he indulges quite a bit.
Don't explain it all for him: Let him go wrong his whole life. Chang shouldn't speak this way to him.
Fortunately he has a place to turn around. With the long, he's long; with the short, he's short. When the reasoning is superior, he goes to it
Look how his hands are flustered, his feet frantic. He hides his body but reveals his shadow. He acts totally dead. There are thorns in the soft mud. Though he acts like this, how could he swindle me?
He can only act this way. Luckily he doesn't understand. If you understand I'll immediately break your head open! Fortunately this fellow is just this way.
Adding frost on top of snow. Why the dragon's head and snake's tail?
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!
r/Koans • u/[deleted] • May 04 '12
My first Koan.. maybe? I'm not sure you tell me..
People give perfect advice.. only when they think it's too late.. do they take it.. but in fact it was the perfect advice they needed at the time..
r/Koans • u/demmian • Sep 30 '12
Hekiganroku, case 3: Master Ba Is Unwell
Instruction:
One movement of the mind, one movement of the body, every word and every phrase: each is a means to lead students to enlightenment. Yet this is nothing but gouging a wound into a healthy body; it simply creates pitfalls and ditches. When the great activity manifests itself, there are no fixed rules. You endeavor to have your students realize that there is yet a higher truth. It covers up the heaven and earth. If you search for it, you will never attain it. "Yes, yes" is right, "no, no" is right too. It is so minute and delicate! "Yes, yes" is not right, "no, no" is not right either. It is so steep and inaccessible! Without treading these two paths, what could be right? I will show you an example, look!
Case:
Great Master Ba was unwell. The chief monk of the temple came to ask him, "Master, how do you feel these days?" The Great Master said, "Sun-face Buddha, moon-face Buddha."
Notes:
The "Sun-face Buddha" is a buddha, who is said to have a life of 1800 years, while the "Moon-face Buddha" lives only 24 hours.
Verse:
Sun-face Buddha, moon-face Buddha!
The Five Emperors and the Three Sovereigns! – what are these?
I have suffered for twenty bitter years,
Descending countless times into the pale dragon's cave for your sake.
What distress! Now I can relate it for others.
You clear-eyed monks, do not take it lightly.
Links:
Introductory post to Hekiganroku
List of posted koans.
Extended commentary on verse, case and introduction
r/Koans • u/originalforeignmind • Jan 27 '15
Upvoting Decisions on these Koans
How do you all decide to upvote a post in this subreddit?
Been here for two months now and I see some koans are upvoted to reach a dozen, while some are not and stay very low. I personally love the recent golden carp story and I'm a bit shocked to see it gained only 2+. (So most likely myself and the poster alone?!)
I'm sure upvoting does not matter much here and many readers here just appreciate what is posted, yet I'm very interested in how the subscribers here decide on what to upvote and what not to, seeing more than a few being constantly online in here.
Does it depend on your taste/liking of the content? your understanding? translation? how it helps your practice? or any other particular reasons that I cannot think of?
This is just out of my pure curiosity! (I hope none of you misunderstand that.)
r/Koans • u/demmian • Oct 08 '12
Hekiganroku, case 10: Bokushû's "Fake Monk"
Instruction:
Yes, yes; no, no. Seen in terms of combat, each stands unconquered on his or her own pivotal point. Therefore it is said: if you turn upward, even Shakyamuni, Maitreya, Manjusri, Samantabhadra, the thousand and ten thousand holy ones, and all Zen masters under heaven will immediately choke back their breath and swallow their voices. If you turn downward, even maggots, gnats, and all creeping creatures emit a great light, each one towering like a cliff of ten thousand fathoms. But when you turn neither upward nor downward, then how would you deal with it? If there is a rule, follow it; if there is no rule, follow an example. I will try to present one, look!
Case:
Bokushû asked a monk, "Where did you come from?" At once the monk shouted, "Kaatz!" Bokushû said, "This old monk has been scolded by you with a 'Kaatz'!" The monk shouted again, "Kaatz!" Bokushû said, "After three or four shouts of 'Kaatz,' then what?" The monk was silent. Then Bokushû hit him saying, "You fake monk!"
Verse:
Two "Kaatz," three "Kaatz":
The great ones know how to act freely.
If you say they ride on a tiger's head,
They both must be blind.
Who is blind at all?
I will bring forth a case for everyone under heaven to see.
Links:
Introductory post to Hekiganroku
List of posted koans.
Extended commentary on verse, case and introduction.
r/Koans • u/bunker_man • May 27 '15
New subreddit for helping clear up misconceptions about, and bad interpretations about eastern philosophy.
r/Koans • u/BetterJosh • May 14 '15
Pai Chang's Sitting Alone on Ta Hsiung Mountain - (BCR - 26 of 100)
Pointer
None.
Case
A monk asked Pai Chang, "What's the extraordinary affair?"1 Chang said, "Sitting alone on Ta Hsiung Mountain."2 The monk bowed;3 Chang thereupon hit him.4
Notes
There's an echo in the words. He demonstrates his ability in a phrase. He flabbergasts people. Though this monk has eyes, he's never seen.
His awesome majestic air extends over the whole country. The one standing and the one sitting both are defeated.
A clever patchrobed monk! There still is such a man who wants to see such things.
Chang is a competent teacher of our school: why does he not speak much? The imperative is not carried out vainly.
We are currently studying the Blue Cliff Record- and you can help!