r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/_tripetta_ • Jul 13 '15
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/irontide • May 05 '16
"Dark Buddhism is an integration of Zen Buddhism and Ayn Rand's Objectivism..."
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/bunker_man • Jan 18 '17
Steve jobs is the foremost scholar in historical Buddhism, and you're a racist asshole if you imply that asians in 500 bc were ever "stupid" enough to be theist, since all intellectuals in all time periods were equally capable of knowing the same truths (atheism).
np.reddit.comr/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jul 25 '15
Some deep career counseling from Confucius
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/KaliYugaz • Apr 19 '16
Renounce this Defiled World, and Become the Pure Weeb!
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jan 28 '17
Blaze on, lads. Once again, r/Buddhism shows it's obsession with balancing drugs and enlightenment.
np.reddit.comr/badEasternPhilosophy • u/shannondoah • Jul 14 '15
Navy Seal Copypasta:A Hindu Dvaitin to a Hindu Advaitin
What the fuck did you fucking say about me,you crypto-Buddhist maya-vadin?I'll have you know that I am the best disciple of the abbots of the Eight Monasteries of Madhva,and I've been involved in numerous debates with Sankara's followers,and have 1008 confirmed victories.I'm trained in fruitful debate(samvada) and I'm the most senior swami of all the monasteries of Udipi. You are nothing but another follower of the doctrine of illusion to me.I will expose your false pretenses with an exactitude that has never been seen herewith,mark my words.Do you think you can still hold these views and still not incur Sri Vayu's wrath?That same Vayu,who in his second incarnation destroyed Lanka and in his third incarnation,destroyed Sankara?Think again,deluded fool.As we are discussing,I am talking with my disciples so you'd better be prepared for a sound bashing,you prachhanna-Bauddha.That storm that wipes out your pretensions to follow the Vedas,you tamo-yogin.Not only am I extensively trained in all the Vedangas and the proper understanding of the Prasthana-trayi,but I have full access to all the Mahayana Buddhist texts as well,and I can use them to expose your fakery.You could have been at least a mukti-yogya,any time,in over 108 ways,and that is just with the study of the Vishnu-tattva-nirnaya.If only you could understand what horrible karma these words of yours would sow, perhaps you would have had the wisdom to keep silent.But you couldn’t, you didn’t, and now you’re paying the price.I'll vanquish you in debate and you'll drown in Buddhism.You're eternally damned,son.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/NoonsbotLove • Jul 05 '20
This goddamned price gouging for Eastern phil translations is why no one cares about Eastern philosophy. Its holding back our fields across the board.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/bunker_man • Apr 22 '16
[Satire] Christianity is such an exotic and mysterious Western religion
np.reddit.comr/badEasternPhilosophy • u/like4ril • Jan 08 '16
[dank maymays] When eastern philosophy has too many spooks
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/LE_WHATS_A_SOUL_XD • May 28 '15
[Satire] If Gandhi Took a Yoga Class (2:49)
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/kusimanse • Jul 11 '15
"Daoism isn't serious, best read it on acid", with a bonus "don't take Eastern philosophy seriously"
I've lurked for a while here, but this is my first post, hopefully everything goes well...
Here. There was a thread earlier on one of the subthreads, but I feel this is worth highlighting.
Lao Tzu is a must I would say, especially Timothy Leary's translation (on some acid is best).
No, not if you want to understand what it is talking about, rather than some vague duuuude, far ooout bullshit.
I'm not. I think it's great to study, but not seriously. If you get too serious in your interpretations you will not be able to appreciate the paradoxical nature of the philosophy.
and
Try the first line, "The Tao that can be said is not the true Tao." This is the first line of the stanzas and it clearly announces that the doctrine is paradoxical and hard to understand.
Not really... "~" is impossible to truly understand/convey/whatever seems to be common in religions, and I feel this is fairly similar. It is saying is the Dao that you can describe is not the true Dao. It is not saying, "Daoism is paradoxical and hard to understand".
Look, I get that Daoism can be hard to understand, at least beyond the bullshit spiritual Tao of Pooh level garbage, for a westerner. In my bit of time trying to study it, I've found I'm missing too much of the historical, cultural, and religious background to really understand a lot of what something like the Daodejing is saying. There are occasionally jumps in thought that I can't follow. But there are millions of people who do at some level understand it, and follow it. The solution isn't to dismiss it as "not serious" out of hand. It is to learn more.
Also, while the Daodejing is critically important in Daoism, it isn't an all authoritative bible equivalent for Daoism, dismissing the whole religion off of the a few lines you can't grasp is stupid.
Now for the worst bit:
Eastern philosophy is not Western philosophy and I wouldn't recommend taking it seriously in the same sense as we might take Western philosophy seriously.
Wonderful. Why take eastern thought seriously, when we westerners are just the best? I guess I should stop learning classical chinese and go read Plato or whatever... Then I could learn about Serious Philosophy.
Sorry for writing so much, it's just seeing this kind of westerner arrogance has gotten kinda obnoxious..... And like I said, I still don't know all that much, hopefully I didn't mess anything up ><
Oh, and props to /u/LaoTzusGymShoes for fighting the good fight over there.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/like4ril • Oct 20 '16
[dank] What the fuck did you just fucking say about me?!?!?!?!!!!!!111
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/durpyDash • May 29 '16
So if /r/Buddhism is full of misrepresentations of the religion...
Before I start, if this topic isn't appropriate for this sub, I'm sorry and will remove the post.
From what I gather from here, /r/buddhism frequently misrepresents the "true" nature of Buddhism and is full of people who only solo study and/or are very new to the RELIGION (caps for differentiating it from just a philosophy.)
I cite recent relevant sources:
So as a someone who is interested in learning about the religion for what it is, how do I not fall into the pitfalls that this sub seems to think /r/buddhism frequently falls into?
Relevant info: I live in the states so I'm a little worried about zen centers that only teach the "Westernized" version of Buddhism. Problem is, I don't know what I don't know, so it's hard to discern what is misrepresenting the religion.
EDIT: Wow. I've gotta say, this one thread has been more informative than the sum of the posts I've read elsewhere. You guys are awesome.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jan 06 '20
Basically New Confucianism in a nutshell outside of the narrow confines of Asian Philosophy departments.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/Karl__Mark • Jun 30 '17
Got told off at by a chick in a Harry Potter shirt at a Buddhist Temple that "My desires matter!"
Kinda hard to explain this one, I forget the play by play. We were going over the week's Lojong and she says "I think it was about being middle of the road: don't desire too much, don't desire too little, it's about not feeling entitled to things." And I say "Well the funny thing is that all suffering comes from desire." and she says "Are you saying that my desires are entitlement?!" and I say "Yes, but without the negative connotations of entitlement, because it's very natural to want things." and she says "My. Desires. Matter!"
I didn't have the heart to tell that her desires create the illusion of independence and are the source of her misery, and that this hip new mindfulness thing she's so excited about was created to help people realize that they do not exist separately from the universe. So I let her shout at me about acceptance and letting things slide, which I did. Thanks, lady in a Harry Potter t-shirt cheerfully proclaiming she's a "such a nerd!".
It's only the four noble truths, I'm sure it's okay to let this slide. Buddhism's about peace and happiness. Who the hell let this debbie downer tell people what Buddhism is?
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Apr 19 '17
The Onion really went and did it.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jun 05 '16
Will somebody please explain to me what fucking corporate Buddhism is supposed to be.
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/shannondoah • Dec 28 '15
[Good] [Existential Comics] Featuring Mahavira: Snakes and Ladders
r/badEasternPhilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jan 13 '18
Some asshole writes about Chinese philosophy, /u/qinhuangdi decides that that maybe a burning of the western books may not be such a bad idea.
I considered a list of 50 to see if some Chinese and Islamic philosophers would make it, but then I realized that if non-European names were added I needed to add many other Europeans who were (at least) just as great. This is why I opted for a list of 75. I wanted a list with a bit of competition, rather than a list with a silencing score of 25 to 0.
What's that one team four star quote by Popo? "You, the dirt, the worms inside of the dirt, Popo's stool, Kami, Mr. Popo." Except this time, it's "Chinese, Islam, the worms inside of the dirt, european stool, some europeans, white people." I don't really think this is philosophical, I just wanted to quote team four star.
Okay, let's go on.
one could seriously argue that China did not produce one single great philosopher. It produced individuals better described as writers of guidelines on how best to rule, how best to meditate, contemplate nature, combined with some allusions and illustrations about the "boundless" and about the ways of nature, without "elaborate reasoning and detailed argument."
Unless you include the Daoists, Legalists, Confucians, Buddhists, and Mohists. Three of these schools, Legalists, Confucians, and especially the Mohists, were especially concerned with logical reasoning including inductive reasoning. Mohists have a canon specifically for elaborate reasoning and detailed argument, Xunzi followed the Mohists in his logical reasoning (as noted by Ivanhoe), and while the legalists were more of a loose kite group who only came into being after the fact, Hanfeizi was very much like Xunzi in his writing and logic (although this is more of a personal opinion).
Feng Youlan
Was trying to distinguish what made Chinese philosophy great in comparison to western philosophical movements. Indeed, even if we deny that, he still made comparisons between philosophical movements in the west with philosophical movements in the East. This only makes them not great if you are thinking in very specific terms of what makes something great -- the european and only the european sense. If you want to do that, make a list of great european philosophers, don't shit on other philosophers because they weren't using the western methods of philosophy.
Below I will go further saying that Chinese philosophy never rose beyond the pre-rational, mystical, poetical, bureaucratic, style of writing that prevailed in all cultures up until the ancient Greeks singularly discovered the faculty of reasoning and came to realize that there is a mind that reasons, and that this mind can generate its own rules of reasoning in conscious distinction to presuppositions from extra-philosophical beliefs.
He hasn't read the mohists. That much is clear.
Below I will go further saying that Chinese philosophy never rose beyond the pre-rational, mystical, poetical, bureaucratic, style of writing that prevailed in all cultures up until the ancient Greeks singularly discovered the faculty of reasoning and came to realize that there is a mind that reasons, and that this mind can generate its own rules of reasoning in conscious distinction to presuppositions from extra-philosophical beliefs.
He hasn't read any philosophers. Not every philosopher has to think in terms of metaphysics and epistemology. Even then "a mind that reasons" is specifically what the operation of "xin" is in terms of Confucian philosophy. The xin is called the heart-mind for that reason, it included emotions and reasoning, in fact Xunzi develops a theory of empiricism based on this, and includes reasoning about metaethics similar to Aristotle's. Mengzi believes in a kind of natural law theory, a argues for a metaphysical view of human nature that includes stuff like Aquinas.
But even though they are not Aristotle's and Aquinas' theories, they can stand up on their own. For one thing, the analogical reasoning used by a lot of ancient Chinese philosophers is very well developed, again by the Mohists. Besides Western standards, the Chinese philosophers have inspired the largest portion of civilization in the modern world and their society continues to thrive.
He showed that true philosophical statements are composed of basic categories — substance, quantity, quality, relationship, place, time — which express the various ways in which being is, and that these statements can be formulated to be subject-predicate statements. This is just a little particle of what this incredible philosopher did.
And Xunzi developed a theory of Heaven/Earth/Man and what makes them seperate, a developed theory of religion, some deep philosophy of language, including categories for naming. Again, Xunzi is a kind of empiricist, and he makes that very clear through his arguments about the xin.
In some ways Chinese philosophers resemble pre-Socratic philosophers. Aristotle criticized the pre-Socratic for failing to articulate fully criteria for differentiating faulty arguments from good arguments.
Xunzi did this too... Refer to his zhengming chapter.
Chinese philosophical statements are devoid of demonstrative reasoning.
"The heart has the power to judge its awareness. If it judges its awareness, then by following along with the ears it is possible to know a sound, and by following along with the eyes one can know a form. However, judging awareness must await the Heaven-given faculties to appropriately encounter their respective kinds and only then can it work."
Xunzi: The Complete Text (p. 238) Hutton translation. So here we have an argument of how reasoning occurs. You have the xin, and then the object, and the xin follows along a faculty of experience one comes to know its object. He gives two examples: hearing and seeing.
Chinese arguments lack clearly stated primary premises, with precisely defined categories.
This is precisely why all chinese literature isn't written in chapters, or books, and differentiated by subject. Oh wait, I just quoted a Chinese philosopher who does that.
Joseph Needham
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/chinese-phil-science/#ChiSciDao
Note the Mohists. Again.
But these statements are not at all "mechanistic" in outlook. They are not even at the level of the pre-Socratic search for ultimate causes.
Dao caused Heaven, Heaven caused Earth, Earth caused life. It's not that hard to distinguish the mechanism from which Laozi thought the ways of man occured. The Dao is not unlike the first cause of Aristotle. Even with the water, the Daoists are arguing that the water has no will of it's own, but that height causes something to fall. They are establishing a cause and effect.
Mohist Hui Shih
Not a mohist.
The difference is that Kant's discussion is framed within a very complicated discussion about the limits of traditional metaphysics when it comes to answering the fundamental questions about the ultimate nature of being. Pure reason, independently of any observable phenomena as its object of cognition, cannot answer the fundamental questions about the ultimate or the first beginnings. In the second antinomy he shows that making the claim that the world consists ultimately of simple substances is not more intelligible than saying the opposite, namely, that there are no simple substances since all substances are infinitely divisible. Kant's discussion of the second antinomy is far more complicated than this; suffice it to say that his antinomies, which include more than two, are aimed at showing the limits of traditional metaphysics, or the limits of pure reason beyond objects of possible experience. Reason cannot know things in themselves but only things that arise out of experience and which can be structured as objects of knowledge by the apriori categories inherent to the human mind.
I just want to note that he spends more time discussing the historical contexts of Kant than he does discussing chinese philosophical statements in total.
Legalism is not a movement in philosophy. It is not concerned with truth. It is not reflective thinking on the great individual and social problems of life. It does not seek the general principles under which all facts can be explained. It is a system of methods and principles for the operation of the state, and even the state is given only the barest of ideological foundations. Legalists were content to justify their system by the single comment: "It works"
A poor conception of legalism.
So it looks like Hsun Tzu (298-238 BC), the founder of legalism
...
...
...
...
...
...
Xunzi is the founder of legalism like Kant is the founder of postmodernism.
Students across the West are being taught that non-Europeans are just as prominent in their philosophical contributions and that non-Europeans should be equally represented in short lists of the 10 greatest. Multiculturalism is inherently an ideology that suppresses the highest achievements in the planet, levels down Western culture in the name of equality.
If I can use my chinese exceptionalism in full force, I have to say I agree with this statement. Western culture shouldn't be leveled down in the name of equality, it should be trampled underfoot in the name of Chinese superiority.