r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jun 13 '19

Reflections after 3 years of low carb/keto

29 Upvotes

I started low carb (not really keto, that came a bit later) on June 16, 2016 on my son's birthday. I decided, mid mouthful of cake, that enough was enough and committed to a new me. I started at 198 (5'11" male) and dropped 50 pounds by October. Around the same time, I took up road cycling. I've maintained both keto and cycling for three years now and have found them to be complimentary - in fact, I just did my third annual century ride (100 miles, 10k feet of climbing) since starting down this path.

Overall, the changes have been profound not just with me, but, as a single dad with full custody during the school year, also with how my young sons (ages 7 and 10) view food and nutrition. They are neither keto nor low carb, but have followed my lead in being much more aware of what they are eating now that they help me prepare our meals together. As I developed an interest in cooking, so have they. Also, like father, like son, they both love cycling with me and we routinely ride 15 mile routes together (mostly flat ground).

Looking back on three years, I look younger now than I did then, feel younger, and have an overall much more positive outlook on life. I still stay strict keto (20g or less) with a heavy emphasis on whole foods (no judgment, that's just how I do it), and while I track carbs, I don't really track the other macros and vary my calories a lot from day to day. I also do a fair bit of intermittent fasting, generally doing OMAD 3-5 times per week and rarely ever more than two meals per day.

I have had fluctuations along the way - a much as 15 pounds during times of heavy travel - but by and large my weight rarely varies by +/- 5 pounds.

I'm happy to have discovered this sub (thanks for Angelica2121 for the tip) as I was getting a little burnt out on reading/responding to noobie posts. So that's me, and looking forward to years more of keto maintenance to follow.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 18 '18

Yes, I’d recommend Keto as a sustainable weight loss approach to patients. But I’m still figuring out to which ones.

26 Upvotes

In a previous post on r/Keto_Maintenance, I asked how sustainable Keto really is. (Thanks to all who commented!) It’s clear Keto is effective for weight loss – the post had nothing to do with the nitty gritty of the approach. The question here is if it’s sustainable. More specifically, I wanted to see if Keto would be something I could recommend as a medical professional. The bar I initially set was if a reasonably large number of people are able to sustain it over a long period of time. Because after all, if it’s usually just a temporary intervention, then I would just be setting people up for weight cycling.

Also, I wanted to fill in a gap in the research. I recall reading a publication from the National Weight Control Registry that noted an increase in the proportion of sustainers on lower carb diets in recent years. But I don’t think they break out Keto.

I just asked a couple of questions in the original post:

  • Are you a weight loss sustainer on Keto? (lost at least 10% of your weight, and kept it off for at least a year) If so, what percent weight loss, and for how long?

  • How difficult is it to keep that weight off with Keto?

TL;DR

Yes, as you all already know as subscribers of this sub, Keto can be sustainable. Of course, another major clue is that r/Keto_maintenance is one of only two active weight loss sustainer subs I could find on reddit. (r/ownit is the other. Do any of you know of others?) At any rate, most responders lost a lot of weight and kept it off for years. And most found it pretty easy to do, at least over time. Of course, these results weren’t universal. But I think it’s enough for me to be comfortable recommending Keto for the right people.

If you’re interested in a little more detail:

Here’s a closer look at the answers to the questions I asked. As suggested above for the first question, research convention defines sustainers as those who have lost at least 10% of their weight and kept it off for at least a year. As you’d expect from a maintenance sub, nearly everyone that replied is a sustainer. But what was interesting was the duration and amount some achieved. Most responders have sustained for at least 2 years (so far), but some have achieved extraordinary numbers – 6, 9, even 15 years. Likewise, several responders lost in the range of 10% and 30lbs, however they decided to list their weight loss. But some lost as much as 27%, 30%, 120 lbs. Clearly, Keto can lead to great outcomes for some.

So extraordinary results can be achieved – I’m convinced of that. Having dispensed with that, three big questions pop in my mind:

  1. How common is it become a Keto sustainer?

  2. Are there certain reasons why some people are successful with Keto?

  3. Can these factors be developed?

Onto the second question about how difficult it is to maintain. I got the entire spectrum of responses, from being unsustainable for some, to being very easy for others. Again, I was surprised by a couple of things. First, the two longest sustainers said that it was easy (9yrs) and very easy (15yrs). I don’t know how much weight these two individuals lost, but as responders, I’m assuming it’s at least 10%. Second, the people who lost the most weight said that it was easy (27%, 30%), and “loving eating this way” (120lbs). The last comment kind of broke the scale. It's also clear that sustaining significant weight loss for a long time is not only possible on Keto, but can be easy for some people.

This is incredibly intriguing. Duration and Amount can coexist with Easy. The huge question here is: is there a relationship between ease of sustaining and duration and amount?

  1. Is there a causal relationship, and if so, which way?

    1. Do those who find/make Keto lifestyle easy more likely become sustainers?

    2. Do sustainers make Keto easy over time?

    3. Do ease and sustainability co-develop?

  2. On the other hand, perhaps no relationship exists?

All of these questions that have emerged have huge implications for sustainability. But as a major disclaimer, this is not definitive proof considering the sample size and the informal questions.

But that’s not the whole story. As it turns out, many people left comments that went above and beyond. They shared many dimensions of what sustaining Keto really entails, and comments were universally thoughtful and helpful. I appreciate them all. They were so good, I’ll try to organize and share some highlights that I hope might be useful to others. I’ll try to get at what might be sustainability factors in future posts. Since it’s clear that Keto is sustainable for some, I’m figuring out if I can tell people “Keto might be sustainable for someone like you”, and/or “To make Keto sustainable, do the following…”

Of course, if you have any thoughts along those lines, I’d love to hear.

BTW, would it be useful to crosspost this on r/keto? I’m not clear on etiquette.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Oct 26 '19

A real milestone

23 Upvotes

I’ve been maintaining for a few months now at around 125 lbs - I’m 5’1. I may decide to lose a little more at some point but at 50 I think a little padding is not such a bad thing. I recently bought my first dressed up outfits since hitting my goal weight. I’d purchased new suits for work but nothing for a special night out. I bought the same dress in 2 different colours - cheap and cheerful really but stylish. And I wore one out last night. And I felt, for the first time in maybe 15 years, like a million bucks. And more importantly, I felt like me. I realize that I have been wearing clothes that flatter my figure but bear no relationship to how I see myself for almost 2 decades. Fat lady clothes. Last night I dressed like me and felt pretty and comfortable and easy in my skin. It’s seems trivial but it was profound. I feel like I’ve been wearing a middle aged fat lady costume forever and I’ve finally been able to take it off.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jun 27 '19

Yesterday's "My 600-lb Life: Where Are They Now" was uplifting

23 Upvotes

If you watch the show, you know that it can be infuriating or inspirational.

However, the show often focuses on "you must change your eating habits" rather than "surgery is an easy fix". I like the message that there are several tools for weight loss, and for the record I do support bariatric surgery when appropriate.

Dr. Now assigns his patients a keto diet, even though they don't say "keto" on the show.

Milla Clark was featured yesterday, started with Dr. Now three (3) years ago.

She was 800 lbs. Now she is 150 lbs.

She worked SO DAMN HARD for three solid years.

She is one of those lovely people beautiful inside and out.

This episode is worth watching, very heartwarming.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jan 08 '20

It’s official: I’ve gained weight doing maintenance

19 Upvotes

I was very fearful about the maintenance phase however I decided to trust my body and listen to my appetite while remaining keto. It didn’t work. At my lowest I was a little below 125. Now I’m hovering somewhere between 128 and 130. I’ve decided I have to rein it in. I’m tracking again. I’m trying to keep my calories low. And I’m trying to accept that I will likely have to track for the rest of my life. Why can’t I trust my appetite? Why am I gaining weight even though I don’t feel I’m overeating? Why do I have to be hungry. Ugh.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 16 '19

Just Got Down to My Goal Weight this Weekend. Want to hear what successful people on maintanance do.

18 Upvotes

I started my weight loss journey 6 months ago when I decided to try keto. I fell in love and then st as red studying it like crazy and started implementing fasting into my weight loss plan. 6 months later I went from 290 to 200.

My goal now is to maintain while doing some body recomposition through lifting. I just want to hear peoples strategies for maintanance from those who have been successful. I am in uncharted territory and would like to get as much wisdom from people who have been there as possible.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jul 16 '19

Maintenance away from home, Day 2.

18 Upvotes

So those of you that are familiar with my keto exploits and shenanigans know the following things about me:

  1. I have been in maintenance mode since reaching my goal of losing 80lbs in October 2018.

  2. I eat OMAD.

  3. I eat the same damn thing every single day. Every day. Always, for all time. Forever. Up to 50g net carbs, because maintenance.

  4. I'm a high school history teacher that NEVER travels (you might actually not know that).

Well, in my school's infinite wisdom, they've decided that I will be teaching a new advanced online course for my students next year through the University of Texas in Austin, which requires a TWO WEEK TRAINING...that started yesterday.

I can't eat my same foods every single day and I'm in shock over it, but I'm managing quite well. Today I learned that I can't even just do OMAD either because the UT campus spans miles, and it's 95 degrees outside. They are shuffling us from building to building every hour, it's just after noon and I've walked 5 miles and I'm dying. I'm exhausted, ketoade isn't cutting it, and I had to actually break down and eat...lunch. 😮

So here's my lunch: a 12-piece Chick-fil-A nugget (~13g or so net carbs) and a Coke Zero (CAFFEINE YES). And a side of ranch that I seriously only use like half a tablespoon of. It was delicious.

http://imgur.com/a/FRmIFUC

Side note: I've never been away from my daughter for more than a few days in her 9 years of life, so I promised her I'd send her pictures with my Bulbasaur (her favorite Pokemon) Funko Pop photobombing it up. I repeat, I did not eat Bulbasaur. Too many carbs.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 06 '16

Go Maintenance

17 Upvotes

This is a nice idea for a new sub, well done to the mod/s.

I am based in the Uk, and have been Keto since Jan'16.

I am using Keto to train for marathon next year with a 5 year goal of doing ultra's. You can catch my ramblings on /r/ketogenicendurance

I don't count calories, just go off feel. I also don't mean to be on IF, but I find I just naturally fast.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Sep 28 '19

Zeroodles have changed my life

16 Upvotes

I’ve been doing keto for over 2 years and have lost 80 lbs. I’m in maintenance now. I tried shiritaki noodles once and have not had the courage to try them again. I more or less resigned myself to a future without pasta. And then I tried Zeroodles soybean fettuccine last night and my mind is blown. They had been in my cupboard for months because I thought a 1/4 package at 5 net carbs would be hardly worth it in terms of portion size. As it turns out, 1/4 package is a very generous serving and the noodles themselves are amazing. They really are. My daughter says they remind her most of fresh/homemade pasta. Pasta is back. Tonight-carbonara!


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jun 09 '19

FYI this subreddit is one of two keto weight maintenance subreddits.

16 Upvotes

EDIT AND UPDATE

I later concluded that the other subreddit r/KetoMaintenance (no underscore character) is basically a "dead" sub with less than 300 members, no active moderators, and almost zero participation.

I abandoned my participation on that dead sub, and now I participate as a member on this r/Keto_Maintenance (with the underscore character) keto weight maintenance sub only.

I hope if you're reading this post that you'll become a lurker, reader and active poster on this sub !!

ORIGINAL

I went searching for a subreddit about keto weight maintenance, and I found two.

I would enjoy seeing both subreddits become more active.

If it turns out that one of them is stale and / or no longer has an active moderator, maybe they would ultimately combined.

This subreddit is, of course, r/Keto_Maintenance with the underscore character.

The other subreddit is r/KetoMaintenance with no underscore character.

I believe more and more people will be succeeding to reach their goal weight on keto, but may especially have questions when starting weight maintenance.

Help for people who are struggling with their initial weight maintenance would be awesome.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jan 28 '19

Self introduction

16 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a “new” keto maintainer, late 30s female.

Starting a decade ago, I ate paleo for a few years, found out my myriad troubles were partly due to multiple sclerosis, and then switched to paleo autoimmune protocol for another year until I was well enough to eat some gourmet grilled cheese now and then.

Then I moved to a city famous for carbs and ate plenty of them. I rarely had health issues, but when I did I would eat keto for about three months at a time to help clear them up.

So I’ve done this a few times before, but not for long. I’ve been low carb-ish for a couple of years, so the transition has been eerily smooth this time, maybe partly because I was on my way to (or maybe already at) diabetic, and so already in a bad place which keto helped me out of in just a handful of days. (What I mean is: maybe the bar was set so low that keto is a breeze. I’m not sure if science would support or contradict this theory.)

Anyhow, I came here because (due to my two low carb years) I am a healthy-weight person who wants to maintain weight while improving overall health. I would love to have discussions with others in the same headspace. R/keto is great but the onslaught of scale victories isn’t for me. Keen to hear more from mid to late-game ketoers, read about science, health effects etc.

Pleased to make your acquaintance.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 13 '18

Can you help me figure out how sustainable Keto really is?

16 Upvotes

I'm a medical professional spending my personal time researching how best to help people lose weight and keep it off. I'm not interested in finding that one diet that somehow works for everyone. Instead I think some diets, or dietary approaches, work better for some people than others. I'm much more interested in understanding how sustainable/maintainable the various approaches are.

Ultimately, I'd like to be able to say to people such and such approach is sustainable by a reasonably large number of people, and it's worth your time to try it. Meanwhile, there are very few success stories with these other approaches - try them as last resort.

There's no question the Keto approach is effective for weight loss. But I've come across arguments on other subs about how sustainable Keto really is - people cite some research that's often hard to generalize. So there's a real question about whether Keo is sustainable in my mind.

Which is why I'm so excited to find this group! The name of the group says it all. Could this really be a large group of people who qualify technically as weight loss sustainers?

I've skimmed through a bunch of posts on r/Keto_Maintenance, and searched for terms like "weight cycling", "regain", and "yo-yo", and to my amazement, there are NO post results for any of these terms. Of course this sub is a self-selecting group of "maintainers", but you'll find posts returned with those search terms on other similar subs.

Can you help me with a couple of question:

Are you a weight loss sustainer on Keto? (lost at least 10% of your weight, and kept it off for at least a year) If so, what percent weight loss, and for how long?

How difficult is it to keep that weight off with Keto?

(1-very easy, 2-easy, 3-moderate, 4-difficult, 5-very difficult).

I'm just trying to get a sense of how realistic it is. Feel free to answer open-ended. This isn't really scientific.

Thanks for your help in sorting this out!

Update 12/18: Thanks to all the commenters! I've tried to create some takeaways from what you've said in a follow-up post.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Oct 05 '17

I am starting the KetoDiet today and looking forward to seeing great results like others are posting about.

16 Upvotes

r/Keto_Maintenance • • Mar 29 '20

Maintainenance during self isolation

15 Upvotes

I’m on self isolation and working at home right now. My loving partner has been doing the shopping with me in my mind. Boy, trying to maintain my weight when I’m working 12 feet from my refrigerator is a challenge. And for some reason, I’m starving ALL the time. I never ate breakfast when I left the house at 8 am but now I can’t make it past 10 am without breakfast. Snacks, within reach, mean eating constantly. I’m staying keto but I’m going to balloon if I don’t get this calorie thing under control. Any tips for resisting? Why am I so darn hungry?


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jun 18 '19

Pro Tips?

15 Upvotes

I finally made it! I’m in maintenance now. For all keto folks, do you have any special tips for me? Also, how often do you weigh yourself to make sure you’re maintaining? Did any of you experience accidental weight gain, despite calculating maintenance calories? Any of your tips would be great!


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Apr 24 '17

Sugary Drinks Tied to Accelerated Brain Aging

Thumbnail
mobile.nytimes.com
15 Upvotes

r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 31 '19

Gaining. Help

14 Upvotes

I’ve been in maintenance for a few months and sadly I’m gaining, slowly but surely. This was my fear. I stopped trying to lose because I was hungry all of the time and so now I’m eating to satiety. Apparently, I’m not supposed to feel full.

I guess I’m going to start tracking again and try to stay low on my calories. I’ve also decided to fully resist any snacking as I thinking having treats after dinner may be responsible.

I’m feeling discouraged right now as I’m starting to thinking tracking and dieting will be something I have to do for the rest of my life. I had hoped that keto would “fix” my crazy metabolism to a degree.

Anybody have any suggestions or shared experiences?


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 05 '19

Finding maintenance so terrifying

14 Upvotes

I’ve been maintaining or trying to for perhaps 4 months now. Maintenance now consists of not tracking/lazy keto and essentially eating to satiation. I gained a little off the hop. I’m perhaps a pound and a half over what I was at my very lowest. But my weight fluctuates a lot more because of water weight if I eat a few more carbs. Sometimes it’s up 5 pounds. But I’m scared and paranoid all the time. I can’t tell if I’m slowly gaining or staying relatively steady. I can’t tell how much I need to eat to maintain. I can’t tell if the few extra carbs are knocking me out of ketosis. The weight loss was the easy part. Now I’m so at sea. Does anyone have any suggestions? I’m a woman so I have a low weight day or two a month so only weighing once a week could have me weighing at my heaviest and in a tailspin.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Sep 18 '19

Weight Maintenance is hard

14 Upvotes

To expand on the info in my Flair: my highest weight ever was 204, and my lowest weight recently was 124. So, lost 80 pounds "lifetime", lost 33 pounds via keto in the past year and a half.

Although I understand that I must maintain new eating habits that I learned while losing weight on keto, I want to allow myself to eat too many carbs and eat too many calories, and I have been though I know I shouldn't.

Since starting maintenance I've been up and down, and as high as 130. Those higher pounds feel so uncomfortable !!

I'm believing that I won't be one of the people who "gains it all back", but I'm struggling to keep a strong mental attitude and strong habits to stop myself from returning to old ways of over-eating foods that will cause weight gain.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jan 25 '20

Maintenance led to weight gain. Back on track.

13 Upvotes

I lost 80 lbs in 2 years, slow but steady. But I never was able to establish a goal weight.

At @125 (I’m 5’1” and 50 y.o), I started getting very hungry all the time and it was suggested I maintain for a while and not try to eat at a deficit. I stopped tracking (although after 2 years I was comfortable that my macros were pretty good although I was going up to about 30 NC).

However I was very hungry all the time and I ate a lot. Although my weight naturally fluctuates a lot, it became clear that I was actually gaining. My lowest was just under 124 and I was hovering around 128-130 about a month ago. And I was unhappy. It scared me.

I started tracking again and eating at a slight deficit. And guess what! I’m at 124.4lbs today. And I haven’t been starving myself. I’m sure some of it was water weight from going up a bit in carbs but I think I’ve lost the real weight I gained. What’s more I think I may have fixed my metabolism to a degree. I’m no longer starving all the time and I may lose another couple of pounds to give me some wriggle room.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jan 27 '18

The Startling Link Between Sugar and Alzheimer's

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
13 Upvotes

r/Keto_Maintenance • • Apr 26 '17

paper says saturated fat won't clog arteries.

Thumbnail
cnn.com
13 Upvotes

r/Keto_Maintenance • • Feb 01 '17

Hey everyone, so what medication do you no longer take due to keto?

13 Upvotes

I stopped taking daily Motrin like candy just to function and stopped taking my prescribed medication for my migraines (3x a month)!

What meds did you stop taking due to keto ?

Edit: also add what medical conditions the meds were used for.


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Dec 10 '16

Any long term ketoers here?

13 Upvotes

How long have you all been maintaining keto for? I'm only my 5th week in. Interested to hear from long term keto adherents!


r/Keto_Maintenance • • Jan 25 '18

Keto Kabinet That one still in your kitchen but you're not too sure why. Usually in a hard to reach area, rarely ventured to, over the stove. But when you do there's a moment of awe and wonder. Why is this still here...

Post image
12 Upvotes