I'm a medical professional spending my personal time researching how best to help people lose weight and keep it off. I'm not interested in finding that one diet that somehow works for everyone. Instead I think some diets, or dietary approaches, work better for some people than others. I'm much more interested in understanding how sustainable/maintainable the various approaches are.
Ultimately, I'd like to be able to say to people such and such approach is sustainable by a reasonably large number of people, and it's worth your time to try it. Meanwhile, there are very few success stories with these other approaches - try them as last resort.
There's no question the Keto approach is effective for weight loss. But I've come across arguments on other subs about how sustainable Keto really is - people cite some research that's often hard to generalize. So there's a real question about whether Keo is sustainable in my mind.
Which is why I'm so excited to find this group! The name of the group says it all. Could this really be a large group of people who qualify technically as weight loss sustainers?
I've skimmed through a bunch of posts on r/Keto_Maintenance, and searched for terms like "weight cycling", "regain", and "yo-yo", and to my amazement, there are NO post results for any of these terms. Of course this sub is a self-selecting group of "maintainers", but you'll find posts returned with those search terms on other similar subs.
Can you help me with a couple of question:
Are you a weight loss sustainer on Keto? (lost at least 10% of your weight, and kept it off for at least a year) If so, what percent weight loss, and for how long?
How difficult is it to keep that weight off with Keto?
(1-very easy, 2-easy, 3-moderate, 4-difficult, 5-very difficult).
I'm just trying to get a sense of how realistic it is. Feel free to answer open-ended. This isn't really scientific.
Thanks for your help in sorting this out!
Update 12/18: Thanks to all the commenters! I've tried to create some takeaways from what you've said in a follow-up post.