r/InsuranceAgent • u/Wise-Astronomer-2923 • 9h ago
P&C Insurance New insurance producer here. Does the emotional roller coaster ever get easier?
I’m about two months into my first insurance sales job, working primarily with P&C. I’m completely new to the industry, having recently gotten licensed.
So far, it’s been an emotional roller coaster. Some days I make a few sales and feel accomplished, like I’m finally getting the hang of things. Other days, I’ll make 50–80 calls, generate a couple of quotes, and barely get anything out of it.
For example, today I reached out to around 50 people, generated two quotes, and got one sale that was practically handed to me. It was a slow day, and I couldn’t help feeling frustrated.
I think my biggest struggle isn’t necessarily rejection, but the pressure of meeting expectations. We have weekly Monday meetings where we review everyone’s production. Our office works collectively, and my agent hasn’t really criticized me for my numbers. Everyone has been pretty supportive and understands that I’m new.
Still, I constantly worry about whether I’m producing enough or pulling my weight. Even a lighthearted joke from my agent about needing to sell more life policies got under my skin today.
I came into this industry because I saw an opportunity for financial growth and career advancement. I’m currently making a base salary of around $50k annually, and I haven’t really seen the financial upside yet.
I’m planning on giving myself at least 6–12 months to learn the business, improve my sales skills, and see where things go. I genuinely want to succeed, but I’m realizing how mentally exhausting sales can be when you’re constantly measuring yourself by your production.
For those of you who’ve been doing this for a while:
What did your first 3–6 months look like in terms of production?
How many calls, quotes, and policies were you averaging when you first started?
How long did it take before you felt comfortable and consistently productive?
Does the pressure ever get easier, or do you just learn to manage it?
I’d appreciate hearing from other producers, especially those who started with little to no insurance experience.