r/InsuranceAgent • u/FirearmConcierge • Aug 16 '25
Leads (Marketing) I sue insurance brokers and insurance companies over illegal marketing practices. Ask me anything!
So, my good old buddy u/vedgehammer who's spent decades in the insurance industry told me HEY MAN YOU SHOULD GO ON REDDIT INSURANCE AGENTS AND TALK ABOUT WHATS UP so here I am
About me: 5'10", tall dark and handsome I enjoy long walks on the beach and writing the great american novel whoops sorry wrong intro. I'm FC. I'm an old stock market jockey that's traded more equity and derivatives than any man should responsibly admit to. I opened a firearm business years ago and in an effort to fight back against the scourge of illegal telemarketing I started suing telemarketers a few years ago.
BUT WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH INSURANCE?
I'm getting there you dingus.
I get 100+ calls a day on my registered on the DNC for 21+ years telephone that are illegal telemarketing calls. Obamacare/ACA coverage, medicare advantage, car insurance, home insurance, extended warranty on car, roofing, doors, windows, flip my house, refinance my house, etc etc etc. They call me for student loan forgiveness and I have no student loans. They call me for debt consolidation and I have no debt.
IT DOES NOT FUCKING STOP.
A few years ago I got fed up and sick and tired of being sick an tired. 100+ calls or texts to my DNC cell plus 100+ to my landline got to be infuriating.
The next time I got a call pitching insurance, I played dumb, I played along and I followed the money.
DO YOU BUY LEADS? DO YOU HAVE A RELATIONSHIP WITH SOME ARKETING COMPANY? YOU SHOULD READ THIS PART.
Here's something to think about. Anyone ever go to leadscon, or an insurance brokerage conference/expo and you find yourself face to face with a sales weasel from a marketing company that's promising you some leads on the cheap so he can get your business for the long run? These are the best leads. Nobody's got leads like this. Not China. Not Crooked Hillary. Not sleepy Joe. These leads are the best leads. Nobody's got these leads. Incredible leads. Virile leads. These leads are so potent that they require a warning - do not operate heavy machinery or drive after using these leads. If your erection does not subside after 3 hours, consult your physician leads. Yeah those kinds of leads. Spread your legs because you're about to get the money shot of leads. Yeah, those guys.
Believe it or not, people fall for it. And they say things like "we use AI enabled lead capture technology" or "our leads are clean" and "everything is triple vetted" all that jazz just to get you to sign on the line that is dotted.
Not that long ago Amazon pioneered CASHIERLESS TECH! Walk into the store, walk out, AI has done all the work!
The AI was actually 1000 people watching live video feed in india calculating what you purchased. Don't believe me? https://www.businessinsider.com/amazons-just-walk-out-actually-1-000-people-in-india-2024-4
Said differently, marketing people doing marketing people things and lying their asses off.
Anyways, the message and wisdom I want to impart to you is that every single one of these motherfuckers are dirty. Not some, not most. EVERY. SINGLE. ONE.
Storytime!
I got a call on my DNC cell. It was a pakistani call center with the same script. It goes something like this. BTW they can't pronounce a hard R so it goes "Hello Wichawd this is Steve O'Bwien from USA AUto Care How you doing today doing good? We are not making a sales call we are just here to infowm you about the new auto insuwance pwogwam that is dwopping down the wates of auto insuwance up to 45 pewcent" and I played along and the guy hung up on me after 10 min.
Why? The call centers are using litigator scrubs/dnc databases and disconnecting calls once they realize they might have trouble. They call from a spoofed number and are usually in India/Bangladesh/Pakistan and are not traceable.
New strategy. I set up a vonage line at my house for $15 a month. The next time I got one of those calls, I played along and told them that I was at work and to call my office line so I could tell the boss I was on the phone with a customer. I get the whole thing on gopro. The pakistani calls back and my vonage caller ID displays a spoofed local number, a fake name, and sure enough connects me to a lead broker, who then connects to me to a VERY large US based auto insurance company that has super bowl ads that everyone is familar with. I buy the policy.
After coverage is bound, I make copies of the dec sheet, payment history, email from the agent thanking me for my business, etc etc and I send it to the broker and the insurance company corporate office.
I tell them they're doing illegal telemarketing. Not surprisingly here's the response back.
Corporate: We do NO telemarketing and we have no liability. We have investigated ourselves and we've done nothing wrong.
Broker: We do no telemarketing. In fact, you called US asking for insurance and your claims are groundless. If you sue us we will countersue you for fraud, abuse of process, and vexatious litigation.
I'm the child of immigrants. I barely graduated high school. I am a college dropout. And I CONSISTENTLY go to federal and state courts by myself and fight these idiots. I have hired attorneys to make some claims and we've managed to win more than we lose on asserting consumer protection claims.
What I learned is that a gopro at costco is about $350 - add in some extra SD cards, a few batteries and the charger and you're at about oh $500.
Having a video recording of the inbound call, the callback on the vonage line and the connection to the agent - AFTER they have said in writing WE DO NOT DO ANY OF THE THINGS THAT YOUR LETTER SAYS WE DO GO THE FUCK AWAY - that I upload to dropbox and tell counsel to review the video with their client..........that's fucking priceless.
I've settled with one MAJOR insurance company twice in 12 months over this well into the 5 figures based on telemarketing liability. And yet I got two more calls this month that we're gonna settle again. The brokers/their marketing company are eating this one and passing it on to their lead brokers/publishers/etc because they know damn well that they do not want to get corporate involved with litigation.
In fact with one recent call, the lead gen working for insurance company number 1 that I bought a policy from - double dipped, sold the same lead to the competitor to insurance company 1 and I bought that policy as well. I got called at 3PM from insurance company 1's lead gen and then called again on the same line from insurance company 2 not 2 hours later? That is not a coincidence. Insurance company 2 gave up their lead gen in their denial and I am betting that insurance company 1 bought from the same well.
Here's the lesson to be learned for anyone who's doing insurance, as an agent or a brokerage - captive or otherwise.
DO NOT FUCKING TRUST LEAD PROVIDERS. NONE of them are worth a damn. Every single one of them do shady shit to fill the pipeline and it only takes one motherfucker with a gopro to video the overseas inbound call and the warm transfer to your brokerage to create a six figure problem.
But don't take my word for it.
Allstate said WE DID NOT MAKE THE CALLS WE HAVE NO LIABILITY and a federal judge said BULLSHIT. Your agent, your product, your liability. This was a recent decision.
Do you really want your upline being hauled into federal court because you thought the sales weasel was telling you the truth? Don't do it. It's a trap.
Enough about me - feel free to ask me anything about the dirty business of insurance lead gens. Or I can tell you more war stories but you get the idea.