r/IndustrialAutomation • • 3h ago

Open-source control plane for industrial assets with command approval and audit. I want OT engineers to critique the safety model

0 Upvotes
I'm building Waylorn, an open-source (AGPL-3.0) control plane for industrial infrastructure. Today it provides an authenticated asset inventory, asset relationships, command approval records and an audit trail.

What it does NOT do: it does not talk to controllers. The Rust OT gate is fail-closed and has no device I/O, and approvals are never dispatched to equipment. It is not safe to deploy beside production equipment and the README says so.

The design principle is that approval is not execution. A command request goes through a risk class, a ticket and window, and a separate human approver before anything could ever be dispatched.

What I'd like from people who work in OT:
1. Is this approval model realistic next to how change management actually works on your sites?
2. What is missing from the threat model (docs/threat-model.md) and the IEC 62443 mapping?
3. Where would a control plane like this get rejected by your security or operations team?

Disclosure: I use AI coding tools in development and I review and design the architecture myself. The docs include 14 ADRs if you want to see the reasoning.

Repo: https://github.com/AbdulNafaySarmad1/Waylorn

r/IndustrialAutomation • • 8h ago

Containers on Windows / WSL with Docker, Podman, and Kubernetes — how are we approaching local workflows vs. production?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about how container workflows have evolved on Windows—especially with WSL 2 / newer WSL container (now WSL 3 and WSLC) capabilities alongside Docker Engine updates, alternatives like Podman, and local-to-cluster paths involving Docker Desktop and Kubernetes.

On paper, containers solve a very familiar headache: packaging an application and its runtime dependencies so behavior stays consistent across environments instead of depending on whatever is installed on a single machine. At the same time, moving from a local Windows/WSL development setup to real workloads brings practical questions around licensing (Docker Desktop vs. open-source Docker Engine or alternatives like Podman), daemon/runtime overhead, networking, and when a simple multi-container setup is enough versus when orchestration like Kubernetes actually makes sense.

For those working on Windows/WSL or industrial/edge/backend environments:

  1. Are you running Docker Engine/Desktop, Podman, or another runtime in your day-to-day workflow, and what made you pick it?

  2. Where do you draw the line between simple single-host container setups and orchestration tools?

  3. Have you run into any friction points with WSL container integration, networking, or licensing policies?

Curious to hear what’s working well and what trips people up in practice.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 8h ago

Overload opens on the first seconds of a pump start

1 Upvotes

Transfer pump panel, contactor and thermal overload, across the line. Nameplate current sits inside the overload range and the dial is on that current. Cold start, discharge valve still partly closed, and the overload opens in the first few seconds. Reset it, and once the pump is at speed it holds.

All three legs come up. It only does this on that loaded start.

What are you checking on the starter before you touch the valve?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 14h ago

I am looking for testers for a closed test of ServMod, a free Android service tool for maintenance engineers and electricians

0 Upvotes

I am looking for testers for a closed test of ServMod, a free Android service tool for maintenance engineers and electricians (back up, edit and compare parameters of industrial drives; plus phone tools such as a leak finder, motion measurement and nameplate reading).

You do not need any drive or hardware. Just install the app, open it and use the tools that work on a phone (Tools, Sensors, Nameplate, demo modes). Please keep it installed for 14 days and open it now and then.

How to join (3 steps):

Join the Google Group: https://groups.google.com/g/servmod-testers (the request is approved by me)

Opt in to the test: https://play.google.com/apps/testing/com.servmod.app

Install from Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.servmod.app

Feedback (anything that crashes or confuses you): [email protected]. Happy to test your app in return - just reply with your link.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 1d ago

iFix 2023 help

1 Upvotes

Some time ago, i don't even know what i did, my iFix stopped working. When i try to open an existing dynamo, or try to set a foreground, position or any animation i get thrown to VBA with a Compile error: Variable not defined for FixTimeDefControl1, or when trying to make a new picture, same error for CommonDialog1. I tried uninstalling and reinstalling, uninstalling and deleting all GE/Proficy/iFix files before reinstalling, but nothing helps. Any solutions?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 2d ago

Curious about your horror stories

5 Upvotes

We are a small integrator, most projects are under 250k. We've bid a couple 1M+ projects lately and I'm very nervous if we actually win them. What if something goes wrong? I know there are ways to mitigate risk but I've been in this game long enough to know you can never predict everything.

Those of you who have had a project go sideways, what happened? What did the customer do? Has anyone been sued? I'm just trying to figure out how much risk we should realistically take or if we should just stay in our comfort zone.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 2d ago

Wanted to share a recent reality capture project I worked on.

36 Upvotes

We used LiDAR scanning to create a detailed 3D digital twin of the production floor, capturing equipment, machinery, and the surrounding environment.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 2d ago

how are you utilizing AI in your day to day work?

2 Upvotes

how are you utilizing ai in your day-to-day work? did it actually improve your productivity or did you find any cool hacks in which it provided you or the customer great value?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 3d ago

Where to start with PLC systems for a visual learner?

3 Upvotes

I'm a second-year digital security and forensics student fascinated by PLCs, wiring, and power grids, and I want to become a professional. As a visual learner who loves seeing the hardware, where should I start with books, YouTube channels, and free software/simulation tools to learn from scratch?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 3d ago

Best Industrial Automation Internship Opportunities in Sri Lanka

3 Upvotes

I'm an undergraduate student from the Department of Manufacturing and Industrial Engineering, University of Peradeniya.

Which industries and companies in Sri Lanka have the most advanced industrial automation systems?

Where would you recommend doing an internship to gain hands-on experience with PLCs, SCADA, robotics, and industrial automation?

I'd appreciate suggestions from industry professionals and experienced engineers. Thanks!


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 5d ago

Can a CSE student build a career in Industrial Automation and Robotics

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm currently a third-year Computer Science Engineering (CSE) student, and I'm considering exploring a career in Industrial Automation and Robotics rather than following the conventional software development path.

I'm particularly curious about technologies such as:

  • PLC Programming (Siemens, Allen-Bradley, etc.)

  • SCADA and HMI

  • Industrial Robotics (KUKA, FANUC, ABB)

  • Industry 4.0 and Smart Manufacturing

However, my academic background is primarily in computer science, so I don't have much knowledge of electrical engineering, electronics, mechanical systems, or industrial automation.

I have a few questions for people working in this industry or those who have experience with these technologies:

  1. Can a CSE student realistically enter the industrial automation and robotics field?

  2. Do companies hire CSE graduates for PLC programming, SCADA development, and industrial robotics roles?

  3. How much electrical and mechanical engineering knowledge is required to work in this field?

  4. What are the career opportunities and long-term growth prospects for someone with a CSE background in this industry?

  5. If you were starting from scratch as a CSE student, what learning path would you follow?

I'm genuinely interested in understanding how this industry works and whether it's a realistic career direction for someone from a CSE background.

I'd especially appreciate advice from CSE/IT graduates who have transitioned into industrial automation or robotics, as well as professionals already working in this field.

Any suggestions regarding learning resources, courses, certifications, projects, or internship opportunities would be really helpful.

Thanks.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 5d ago

Upcoming Co-Op

1 Upvotes

Hello all,

I’m a Junior electrical engineering major who’s worked at a paper mill during the summer since I’ve graduated high school. The last two summers, I’ve interned in electrical project engineering starting with documentation work, heavy on audits and moving into some small project management last year.

I’m asking you guys what kind of work would be good to try to get into. Like equipment types, techniques, etc. So far I’ve had some project experience making prints for simple installs like E-stops, some DCS additions for level sensing, and a lot of documentation / verification work with MCCs, MVS, and some Allen Bradley control logix wiring. I’m looking to build some valuable skills over the next 8 months and need some help where to start.

Thank you in advance for any input. I’ve lived lurking here so far.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 6d ago

Control Panel Shop?

6 Upvotes

I love electrical work, and Im an engineer by background.

Something ive always been fascinated in is the idea of building a UL508a Panel Shop. Ive got access to a 4000sqft light industrial space with 480v wired in.

I am in the very early stages of this process and ive got another successful business running already but I'm seriously considering getting into this.

Most of my professional experience is knowledge work on a computer. But I have some family members with electrical and machine shop acumen.

Ive got a business connection and friend who used to be the sales director at a bigger panel shop in NY, and he told me he would hook me up with those guys to potentially start building their one offs and overflow.

My wife is an ME and could quite potentially be the UL508a MTR for the shop.

Here is really my question: Where the hell do I start? So many YouTube videos, so many training courses, but I dont know what to trust, where to go to get the deeper education, and how to take this pile of mess and ideas and turn it into a business. It feels like the glue to push it all together is missing.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 8d ago

I spent 5 hours diagnosing a fault and couldn't find anything. Then the senior technician came over and just pressed a button.

11 Upvotes

r/IndustrialAutomation • • 8d ago

Beckhoff vs Elmo

6 Upvotes

My company develops machinery which uses articulated multi axis systems to control the position of an end effector. We have some more compact machines we currently use an older centralized setup that we want to modernize without blowing up our cabinet space. We will be adding some automated features, and there is somewhere in the region of 40 - 50 IO points plus the servo axes in the system.The key considerations for getting the most from the control system are that we need a cycle time in the ballpark of 1ms (or sub-ms) with minimal jitter and IO/axis reads and writes synchronised to the program cycle.

Given this, Beckhoff and Elmo seem like the natural choices, with Ethercat designed to meet these requirements out of the box easily. I could probably do something with Siemens, but when you spec everything up with Profinet IRT and safety drives, the panel footprint and cost get out of hand. I have some experience with Beckhoff and I really like the platform from a software point of view. However, in this application the drives will be subjected to very harsh environments - particularly with regard to vibration and tight mounting space - and to me an Elmo setup (paired with a compact EtherCAT master) seemss to be much more compact and rugged for machine mounting than standard Beckhoff cabinet drives.

I don't have much hands on experience with Elmo's newer hardware, so I would appreciate it if anyone who has could share any insights.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 8d ago

Where do I go from the regular controls, automation and process engineering?

6 Upvotes

Context: I am a manufacturing engineer that has been working on design, automation, control systems, commissioning, SCADA work and OT/IT infrastructure for about 2.5 years.

I finished my masters last year from UofM in Manufacturing, during that I learned a lot while working as a Co-Op, basically taught myself control systems, robotics and automation design in a year while solving a broad range of problems for the battery manufacturing line.

I am an electronics undergrad so control logic, automation logic, electrical and electronics diagrams are like back of the palm, intuitive for me. Problems that senior engineers find complex are pretty easy for me to digest because I think in code and electronic logic.

In the last year and a half I worked for THK as an automation engineer, where I did everything that was thrown at me from setting up OT infrastructure for data logging, jigs and fixture design, firefighting controls issues, safety changes for preventing mishaps, planning and designing an AMR fleet operation, rigging, welding carts, programming robots, the whole 4 corners of the field. Then I moved to JnJ as a manufacturing engineer to work on their SCADA systems to configure, data logging, monitoring, alarming, BI capabilities, networking old hardware, designing databases, doing process characterization for new manufacturing processes, electrical changes, controls design for new processes, learned a lot of Injection Molding nuances, worked on a new line commissioning for cells, a lot of compliance learning (OSHA, NFPA/NEC standards, IEC), spares strategy, managing budget, coordinating vendors, creating BOMs, spare parts strategy, work instructions.

After doing all this, and doing it pretty well I feel like I am stuck in an industry where unless you have 5-8 years of experience, or are a people leader, you don't really get to drive larger manufacturing changes or initiatives.
Most of the time that I spend working, it's mostly basic knowledge coordination, my brain is only working at like a 10-15% of the capacity that it could otherwise. I have had more complex engineering challenges trying to figure out air intake issues on my car than a million-dollar manufacturing line. I've solved better manufacturing problems for my friend's job shop in a 3rd world country.

The question is, is a jack of all trades, 26 year old, feels like he could solve a lot more complex problems is just overthinking or are there actual manufacturing positions that exist, that require broad cascading problem solving skill sets, for if not complex at least financially significant projects?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 7d ago

Looking to Get Into IA

0 Upvotes

I'm an electrician and don't enjoy pulling cables ect.

Plan is to get into PLC programming, do an EET cert (design), then pivot into robotics or manufacturing. Location: Alberta, no problem relocating

Good plan? Bad plan? Suggestions?

Edit: math and econ degrees, data dev experience, and SCADA experience


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 9d ago

Do we still need low-code/no-code tools if we can just vibe code our own production dashboards?

0 Upvotes

I attended a talk at FABTECH in Las Vegas a few weeks ago about vibe coding, and I've been thinking about it ever since.

We have several Siemens machines in our production and run 3 shifts. I'd like to build a dashboard that shows machine status, production numbers, downtime, and maybe some OEE metrics.

With all the AI coding tools available today, I'm wondering why I would still need a low-code or no-code platform for that?

Building the dashboard itself seems pretty easy. But what about connecting it to our Siemens PLCs? Can AI actually handle the connectivity, data collection, and everything behind it?

We also run production 24/7, so the dashboard would need to work reliably across all three shifts, track historical data, and handle connection issues.

Has anyone here actually vibe coded a production dashboard and connected it to Siemens machines?

Is this realistic without much programming experience, or would you still go with an established low-code/no-code solution?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 11d ago

Self-taught 18 y/o building a CLICK PLC conveyor trainer is this enough for an entry-level job?

6 Upvotes

Hello. I'm 18, living in Texas, and learning industrial controls on my own. English is not my first language, so I'm using a translator.

I'm putting together a small trainer to practice on. Parts list:

* CLICK PLC with an 8-input module and an 8-output module

* Real 24V belt conveyor, two photoelectric sensors, one inductive prox sensor on the roller

* E-stop button and pull-cord switch wired to a safety relay that cuts motor power (not through the PLC)

* Forward/reverse using two relays with interlock

* Start, stop, fault reset, jog, Auto/Manual selector, 3-color tower light, horn

* Mounted on a backboard with DIN rail, wire duct and terminal blocks, like a mini control panel

Things I want to learn on it: LOTO, testing before power-up, seal-in start/stop, pre-start warning horn, part counting, jam detection, zero-speed (belt stopped) detection, E-stop and pull-cord fault handling, safe restart after a power loss, and troubleshooting with a meter.

Questions for people working in the field:

  1. Would knowing all of this be enough to get hired as an entry level tech?

  2. What tasks do new techs usually get in their first months that I'm not practicing here?

  3. What do interviews usually test questions or hands-on?

  4. Is CLICK fine for learning, or is Allen-Bradley worth starting with?

  5. If you could add one item to this trainer, what would it be?

Any feedback is appreciated, even if it's harsh.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 10d ago

In industrial automation, how do you verify that an AI-supported decision actually produced the intended result?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about the difference between issuing a command and confirming what happened afterward.

For example, an industrial system may identify a condition, recommend a response and initiate an authorized action. But how does the system establish that the equipment or process responded as expected?

That seems to be an important part of the feedback loop.

A few questions for people working in manufacturing, industrial engineering and automation:

  • What signals or observations do you use to confirm that an action was completed?

  • How do you handle situations where the command is sent but the expected result is not observed?

  • How do you distinguish a genuine process change from incomplete or delayed data?

  • At what point should the system request human review?

I'd be interested to hear how different teams approach verification after an automated or AI-supported decision.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 11d ago

What happens when you want to scale from a few AMRs to a larger fleet?

5 Upvotes

I've been wondering how things change once you start adding more robots. Starting with two or three seems manageable, but does fleet management get significantly more complicated as you scale? I'd like to understand what people struggled with most when moving from a small pilot to regular operations. Would be great if you all could share your experiences here.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 14d ago

Projects and hobbies to sharpen my skills

9 Upvotes

I am a recent automation technician graduate and finding a job has been hard. My teacher said companies are always looking for people who have side projects. I looked into buying used PLCs to practice on but they are expensive. I have tried other hobbies like working with my dad fixing air conditioners, programing Raspberry pis, and arduinos. I am curious of what kind of projects or side hustle you have done and how to get started.


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 14d ago

Trying to learn

2 Upvotes

I'm a non EE, non-ME (just an all-around non-E) minded guy who's learning about SMT. For those who are familiar with the company and machine, what type of companies would use a GPD Global Max series solder-paster?


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 15d ago

Starting as a Lead Maintenance Engineer at a greenfield AS/RS & AMR warehouse (175 robots + vertical lifts). What should I watch out for?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I just accepted an offer as a Service Engineer at a new automated distribution center (heavy loads - mostly pallets of ceramic tiles) and could really use some wisdom from folks experienced in intralogistics.

The setup at the new site:

It is a Goods-to-Person system currently in the installation phase. We will have around 175 low-profile pallet/tote robots (AMR/shuttles), vertical pallet lifts (about to be installed), high-bay and low-bay racking, and goods-to-person picking stations. The server room and picking stations aren't built yet.

Management is super supportive and told me it takes up to 2 years to master the whole complex, with a potential path to Project Chief Engineer down the line.

Since I have two weeks at the mature site and then return to watch the installation/ commissioning at my home site, what should I focus on?

What are the most common mechanical/ electrical failure points on vertical lifts and low-profile warehouse robots handling heavy/dusty loads like tiles?

What commissioning mistakes by contractors should I look out for while the lifts and racking are being installed?

What specific questions or logs should I grab from the guys at the 5-year-old site during my 2-week training?

Thanks in advance for tips!


r/IndustrialAutomation • • 16d ago

Industrial AI: How Much Context Does a Model Need Before Its Output Becomes Useful?

3 Upvotes

I've been thinking about a challenge in industrial AI that goes beyond model accuracy.

Imagine an AI system identifying an unusual equipment reading. The reading may be correct, but does the system know which asset produced it, what the equipment was doing at the time, its operating limits or its maintenance history?

Without that context, interpreting the result can be difficult.

Industrial information often comes from different sources, including sensors, work orders, production schedules and inspection records. Connecting those sources is not always straightforward.

For those working in industrial engineering and manufacturing:

What information do you consider essential before trusting an AI-generated recommendation in an industrial environment?

Is it asset identification, operating history, production context, data quality, or something else?