r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 13 '22

Me every time Josh comes on talking about his vendetta against Murphy

Post image
380 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 13 '25

Discussion This Show Is Criminally Underrated

Thumbnail
gallery
293 Upvotes

In the Dark is honestly one of the most underrated shows out there. On the surface it’s about a blind woman who stumbles into solving a murder, but it’s so much more than that. Murphy is one of the most flawed, messy, and brutally real protagonists I’ve ever seen on TV. She's a fully human character who’s sarcastic, selfish at times, but also deeply loyal.

The show juggles crime drama, dark comedy, and raw emotional moments really well, and the twists are genuinely unpredictable (which is rare). It doesn't matter which direction the show goes, there are always twists and turns that are completely 100% unexpected.

It also tackles things like disability, friendship, addiction, and morality without sugarcoating. I honestly don't know why it didn't blow up more. It is a hidden gem more people should check out.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 13 '22

The biggest incel in all of fiction:

Post image
278 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 20 '21

Josh sucks eggs

247 Upvotes

He is so obsessed with her!! Like please I’ve had milk in my fridge longer than Murphy used him!! He never has anything fun or lighthearted to say. He is always on 10. He is making the case so personal and he is such an intense and uncomfortable character. Nobody seems to enjoy his company

Edit- I’m not saying Murphy didn’t do anything wrong. I just think Josh’s character has 0 dimension outside of his hatred for Murphy and it makes him unenjoyable and impossible to feel sympathetic towards.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 20 '21

Discussion Josh Is THE WORST

209 Upvotes

Dude isn’t even a real cop & he’s over here acting like he needs to put Murphy away for life … basically because he’s a man scorned? Right? Like, c’mon man. Go to therapy or read a self help book but get over it. Gah, I can’t even handle it anytime he comes on screen anymore.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 18 '22

Discussion Who is your favorite character in the show and why is it Pretzel the Dog ?

193 Upvotes

I mean cmon… what an adorable dog.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 06 '22

In The Dark a series f’n finale

185 Upvotes

The end did not make me feel better. No spoilers for those of you who say you aren’t watching it tonight. I paid for the last season on Prime so at midnight I got to watch the last episode and i can say with all honesty that this final episode truly sucked ass. If you watch it tell me I’m wrong. The only way this could’ve ended well was if this had all been just been a bad dream and Max and Murphy rode off into the sunset. To all the writers of ITD, quit your day job and get another profession. Peace out MF’s!!


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 25 '21

I know Murphy has her problems, but…

163 Upvotes

Can we talk about the fact that everyone around her blatantly refuses to take accountability for their actions?

“You ruined our lives, although we are the ones who stole Nia’s money and caused the snowball effect that actually ruined our lives and we’ll never acknowledge it.”

At least Felix came around to seeing it.

And the police department? The same police department that saw one of its own kill a teenager, covered it up, and then had the audacity to say, “Why didn’t you just come to us and claim self-defense?”

Insanity. A clear display of zero accountability.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 27 '21

Josh’s whole vendetta against Murphy was just deeply rooted in his fragile masculinity 😭

160 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 16 '21

Max is the worst and I said what I said

154 Upvotes

ALL he does in S3 is be useless and act like Leslie is the love of his life. Bruh you’ve known her for like 3 days. Seriously, I’m annoyed at every scene he is in!!!


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 19 '22

Discussion Justice for Pretzel🥨

147 Upvotes

For the entire show I was like Pretzel has seen more crimes and murders than any other service dog in the entire world probably 😭 He’s just trying to do this job, what a good boy


r/InTheDarkCW • • Nov 06 '21

What Scene Actually Infuriated Me

146 Upvotes

When Trey tells the police he'll only give him $100k or whatever amount and then proceeds to hand him the entire bag. The most stupid move ever, NO one would do that.

I thought Trey was going to dump all money in the car and then fill the bag with the 100k, but nope.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Aug 17 '22

Discussion Which character do you hate the most and why is it Josh?

140 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 06 '21

Episode Discussion In The Dark - 3x13 - "Expectation is the Root of All Heartache" Episode Discussion

139 Upvotes

SEASON FINALE

Murphy finally learns the truth about what happened to Jess and it forces her to take a closer look at who she herself has become.

 

In The Dark has already been renewed and season 4 is expected to be sometime in 2022.

 

These past few months were my first time moderating a subreddit and I hope I did a good job. If you have any suggestions or comments let me know. See you all next year!


r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 22 '22

Spoilers When the ghost in my apartment keeps testing me 🤣👻

131 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 17 '22

Discussion Anyone else just really hate Josh? (Not sure if it counts as a spoiler or not, but just going to mark it as one just in case) Spoiler

131 Upvotes

I just started watching season 4, and Josh is already getting on my nerves again, so much like dude, stop being overly obsessive, and what do you even gain from trying to put Murphy in prison? Thats all he's been trying to do since she wronged him. Josh literally has no strong motivation or purpose besides trying to put Murphy away, like where's the character development?? So useless to the plot and just annoying to see on screen.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Nov 01 '21

Discussion JESS SUCKS… Spoiler

121 Upvotes

I ended up loving her character to hating her…But how is she gonna let Murphy take the fall for a murder she didn’t commit? AND RUN AWAY AND FAKE YOUR DEATH??? Talking about “you have no idea what I’ve been through”, when Murphy literally went through most of the same things…I’m not the biggest Murphy fan, but Jess is a BITCH.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 04 '22

Discussion Josh is trash

112 Upvotes

I literately cannot stand him. He’s so obsessed with Murphy and the only reason why he hates her so much is bc she doesn’t want to be with him, so he’s out to ruin her life. He is crazy obsessive and annoying lmfao. He’s so bad that I had to come to this group just to complain about him


r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 25 '22

Pretzel is the star of the show.

108 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Sep 06 '22

Episode Discussion In The Dark - 4x13 - "Please Shine Down On Me" Episode Discussion (SERIES FINALE)

104 Upvotes

This was my first time being a moderator of a sub and I've enjoyed discussing and eventually making fun of each episode with y'all for the past two years. The show might not be perfect and it definitely started going off the rails in Season 3 but it has been a fun ride. Alright, let's do this one last time.

In the series finale, Murphy copes by distracting herself with a new motivation: getting even. Felix attempts to help her find other ways to deal with her emotions, but like anything with Murphy, it's an uphill battle. Josh is smug as he slowly puts together how the night unfolded, until he realized that it's not over yet.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 22 '21

jess is a bitch

104 Upvotes

That last episode in season 3 actually made me so fucking angry and i need to rant. the whole season was basically murphy trying to find jess and doing anything to find her including putting herself in danger MULTIPLE times only to find out that JESS JUST FAKED HER DEATH LIKE WHAT THE FUCK. and then has the audacity to blame everything on murphy and tell her how bad of a friend she is???? yes murphy sucks sometimes and can be terrible, but for jess to put all the blame on murphy rly made me mad. i just hate how jess didn’t even seem apologetic about the fact that she faked her own death and was going to let murphy believe she was dead???? that’s not what a best friend does sorry yeah goodbye fuck you jess


r/InTheDarkCW • • Nov 19 '21

Question I'm having a hard time with this show because of this guy... why in the heck does hate Murphy so much???????????????????????

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 22 '21

Discussion I'm so sick of the Murphy hate.

100 Upvotes

I tagged this "discussion" because it's the closest option. But this is just me ranting to the ether.

Man I'm sick of the Murphy hate. The writers try SO hard to make us hate Murphy. Making every single character blame their woes on Murphy when in reality all her woes are their fault.

Max was in bed with Mia way before he met her.

Jess and Felix are the ones that stole Mia's money bringing her into their lives. Had they not done that everything would have been fine.

While they bitched and moaned about it, Murphy is the one that tried to get them out of it. All while Felix is busy getting blackmailed and Jess is busy boning the enemy.

Jess is the one that killed Mia. Yeah it was to protect Murphy but ultimately it was still Jess's choice to pull that trigger. We can all agree she did the right thing by protecting her best friend from a crazed drug dealer but Jess has no right to place that blame on Murphy.

Murphy is crass, blunt, and a straight asshole at times. But actions speak louder than words. Her actions have proven time and time again that she is the most loyal and loving of all of them. All the shit she did to get justice for Tyson, the deals with killers to protect her friends, spending this entire season searching for Jess. The multiple times she's offered/turned herself in to the cops and take full blame to get her friends immunity. The fact that she could have at any time said "I'm not the one that killed Mia Jess did.

In-universe I can see why certain characters dislike her and would want to break contact. Max has had his heart played with, the shit she said to Felix was so fucked up considering his feelings, but the way he has just used her blindness against her was also fucked up. She was a straight bitch to Felix's sister so it's no surprise there's no love there. But none of them can legitimately say that Murphy ruined their lives. They did that shit themselves. They need to stop blaming the mean blind woman and start taking responsibility for their own actions.

And Jess can get all the way fucked. She should choke on her toast and die alone. It takes a giant giant GIANT piece of shit to do what she did. That kind of cold-heartedness is not learned. That's innate. It's her true colors shining through.


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 27 '21

Omg Josh is so annoying

96 Upvotes

Anybody else wanna beat the shit outta Josh? How did this dude go from a desk job at the IRS to senior detective calling the shot as a "consultant" for the police department?!

And everyone at Chicago PD just let's him do whatever?! Omg


r/InTheDarkCW • • Oct 03 '22

Spoilers Things Murphy is blamed for (that can't possibly be her fault)

92 Upvotes

I know I'm going to forget a bunch, but I wanted to make a list of things that people are blaming Murphy for, even though they're literally not her fault. Help me remember more!

Nia's Murder Jess did it, it was self defense, and Nia was a murderous drug dealer anyway. I can't imagine any jury on the planet convicting a blind woman of shooting her from several yards away in an actual murder, let alone the first degree type of murder it would take to "rot in prison for the rest of her life" (thanks Josh). And how the hell is even Sam blaming Murphy for it? Literally only because Josh told her "Murphy did it" and for some reason she believed him without question.

Ben's Death Chelsea blames Murphy... but that little jerk stole the heroin and ODed on it just fine on his own. How clueless is his sister? Josh even claims that the fact he ODed was proof Murphy was involved. Like, what?!

Jule's Becker's Murder I can't remember who said this, it was one of the cops though. They said Murphy killed Jules. I mean WHAT. How can you even draw that line?

Being Forced to Launder Money for Nia Jess tells Murphy that it's her fault they ever got involved with Nia at all, except NO, she's the one who stole a bunch of money from Nia. When Murphy tried to fix it, Nia said nah, y'all can launder for me now.

"Seducing" Felix Felix's sister and a couple other people say that Murphy was manipulating Felix by using sex. Except Murphy super did not want to have sex with Felix, they were just forced into it to maintain a cover story to keep from being discovered by the police.

Jess is Nearly Killed by Nia There was this whole big thing when Nia finds out Jess doesn't know specifics about the heroin at Guiding Hope, she's like "gosh if they don't trust you, neither should we", and this flimsy-ass excuse is used to justify murdering her. Somehow this is Murphy's fault. Even though clearly that's ridiculous, they decided not to tell Jess for her own safety, and the contrived plotline here can't possibly be Murphy's fault anyway.

Corrupting Chloe Dean just sort of randomly declares that Murphy is "corrupting Chloe" a few times. I guess because she wants to go out with friends and not be monitored at all times by her overbearing father? And because she contacted Murphy to get her out of bad situations rather than her dad? Murphy literally never does anything to hurt Chloe. If anything, their relationship was really sweet until Dean went and screwed everything up.

Getting Josh Fired at the IRS He lied for months (or longer) about losing his eyesight, knowing that he was making huge mistakes and that he'd be fired if they found out, yet he still blames Murphy for the inevitable job loss.

Nia's Body Being Discovered by Gene and Josh Felix and Jess tried to blame Murphy for the body being found because they didn't want to come back for the button (which DID turn out to be the only evidence they had against her), and then they follow Murphy and Max, using their own car, without bothering to cover their tracks, leading the detectives right to the spot. Then they had the gall to blame her for some reason.