r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 19 '25

Discussion Why Molly Wasn’t the Mother Harry Needed

0 Upvotes

Molly Weasley’s care for Harry is often seen as warm, generous, and healing. She gives him Christmas sweaters. She fusses over his meals. She screams at him like a concerned mum. But there’s a deeper, less comfortable truth behind this relationship: Molly doesn’t just support Harry — she claims him.

From early on, Molly treats Harry as one of her own. She writes to him. Sends him gifts. Speaks to him with a tone of authority. By Order of the Phoenix, she’s openly referring to him as “like a son.” But Harry never asked for this. And emotionally, he never fully accepts it either.

Because for Harry, love is sacred — and specific. His parents died for him. He grew up yearning not for any mother, but for his mother. And though Molly provides kindness, her version of motherhood is based on insertion, not invitation.

⸻

What Harry needed was connection to his origins — not substitution.

That’s why Sirius mattered. Sirius knew James. He was a living, breathing bridge to Harry’s real family — not a replacement, but a continuation. Sirius didn’t try to be Harry’s father; he simply was someone from the past who belonged in Harry’s life.

Molly, by contrast, came from a different emotional logic. She stepped into a vacant role and filled it with what she thought a mother should offer — but without asking what Harry himself needed. There’s love in that, yes. But there’s also a quiet kind of emotional pressure.

⸻

Molly’s mistake wasn’t love — it was assumption.

She saw a lost boy and tried to heal him in her image. But what Harry really needed wasn’t a surrogate family — it was the freedom to explore who he is, and the right to choose his emotional anchors.

By wrapping him in a family he didn’t ask for, Molly blurred the line between support and expectation. She meant well. But good intentions don’t cancel out the emotional mismatch.

⸻

And the tension becomes obvious when Sirius enters the picture.

In Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 5 (“The Order of the Phoenix”), Molly and Sirius clash over how much information to share with Harry. Molly argues he’s “just a boy,” while Sirius says he has a right to know. But this isn’t just a debate about age — it’s about who has the right to guide Harry emotionally.

Molly calls Sirius reckless. But beneath the surface, there’s fear. Sirius represents real family. He holds Harry’s loyalty, his grief, and his identity. And Molly sees that as a threat — not just to Harry’s safety, but to her place in his life.

That’s not maternal. That’s territorial.

⸻

And in the end, Harry didn’t run to Molly in grief. He didn’t share his secrets with her. He thanked her, respected her — but kept her at a distance.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 06 '25

Order of the Phoenix Hermione’s jinx on the DA contract is so nasty it makes me uncomfortable every time

0 Upvotes

I get that Marietta betrayed the DA, but I think Hermione went too far. The jinx wasn’t just a temporary consequence—it left permanent scars on Marietta’s face. In Half-Blood Prince, Harry sees her on the Hogwarts Express wearing heavy makeup to try and cover them, meaning they never fully faded. That’s a lifelong punishment for a mistake made under immense pressure. More than just a disfigurement, it’s also a public humiliation because it spells the word SNEAK. It’s literally a medieval punishment.

Marietta wasn’t a Death Eater, she was a scared teenager whose mother worked for the Ministry, just like Ron’s dad. Not everyone had the freedom to rebel like Hermione or Harry, who don’t endure any family pressure. The DA was important, but ruining a girl’s face forever for being afraid? That feels cruel rather than justified. The natural consequences of the treason, which would be losing her friends’ trust and respect, would have been punishment enough.

I also feel that Cho would normally have broken her friendship with her over this but she didn’t out of compassion because of how outraged she was at the spell (that’s what she expresses to Harry the last time they speak at the end of year).

On top of that, Hermione never even warned the DA members that she had jinxed their signatures. That’s a serious breach of trust. If she had told them upfront, maybe Marietta would have thought twice before betraying them, or simply wouldn’t have signed at all in the first place. Instead, she tricked them into signing a magically binding contract without their informed consent. For someone who values fairness and justice, that’s a major ethical lapse.

For comparison when Ron recalls when he was a toddler and Fred and George tried to trick him into making an Unbreakable Vow, so also entering a magical contract without realizing it, he says that his Dad was mad with fury and that seems justified.

It makes me think of Pettigrew’s magical hand gifted by Voldemort : unbeknownst to him it was cursed to punish him if he were to fail his master by showing pity. And his own hand ended up strangling him.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 11 '26

Controversial opinion maybe, but Marietta's punishment in OOTP was way too harsh

1 Upvotes

(Inspired by another post made a few days ago on this sub about Harry's lack of remorse for what happened to Marietta)

Obvious disclaimer that I'm not trying to justify Marietta's betrayal of the DA: she was a coward and untrustworthy friend, Harry and the others could have faced expulsion and even torture because of her, and she did deserve some sort of punishment for what she did.

But one truth doesn't necessarily cancel another, and in my opinion having her face permanently scarred was too disproportional of a punishment. I had no problems with it initially, thinking that it might be a temporary jinx: if it was something that lasted a month or two, and then would disappear completely, I would have considered it a just and even funny punishment.

But knowing that she still has scars months later in HPB, and JKR apparently confirming in an interview that Marietta would have some permanent scarring on her face for the rest of her life, I think it was unfair and it doesn't sit right with me anymore.

I don't even care if Harry doesn't feel remorse over it, he has other priorities going on obviously and it's not what I want to discuss in this post, but the fact that so many readers and the author herself seem to be ok with what happened to Marietta is what I find more concerning (I wouldn't be surprised if Marietta was inspired by some girl Rowling hated when she was in school or something, and this was a way to "get revenge" on her).

The face is such an essential part of a person's identity and self image, both in relation to self and other people, now imagine having it permanently disfigured over a (admittedly very bad) choice you made when you were a teenager.

Maybe I'm reading too much into it and making a fuss over a stupid fictional plot point, but given how irl scarring and disfigurment are methods that are commonly used to threaten, humiliate and punish women in particular (especially in heavily patriarchal cultures), to have a female author who always claims to "care about women" use exactly this specific form of punishment for a young female character (and perpetrated by the female main character at that!) is extremely icky imo.

Also, trust goes both ways, and Hermione not disclosing to anyone that she jinxed the parchment was in itself dishonest and a breach of trust toward the students who signed it. Let alone it being a stupid choice not to tell them, as it didn't help preventing someone to betray the DA, given they didn't know they would be jinxed for it.

Marietta was 16, 17 at most when she did what she did, and the scars she got as punishment for it will remain with her even in adulthood and in old age. Now, the comparison I'm going to make might anger some fans, but Sirius was also 16 when he used Remus' condition to almost kill Snape: an action that would have had far worse consequences for those involved had James not intervened; an action that showed Sirius' lack of concern for the wellbeing not only of someone he hated, but also of someone who was supposed to be his friend; finally, an action consisting of a huge betrayal of Remus' trust. And if the handsome 16 years old Sirius didn't deserve to have his pretty face permanently disfigured over something that could result in the death of at least one person, so Marietta didn't deserve that very punishment for shitting her pants about her mom's job and betraying what for her was not much more than a school club.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Mar 16 '26

James Potter didn’t save Snape to be "heroic". He was doing damage control for his friends and saving his own ass. Spoiler

3 Upvotes

New fan here (listening to the full-cast audiobook) This could be a popular, unpopular opinion....i don't know..

I’m currently diving into the series for the first time via the full-cast audiobooks and I just reached the part about the "prank" at the Shrieking Shack.

​Maybe it’s because I’m coming at this with fresh ears, but I feel like the "official" Hogwarts version of this story is total PR.

Dumbledore keeps framing it as James being this noble hero who saved his rival’s life, but looking at the stakes... James wasn't saving Snape. He was saving Remus Lupin.

​Like.... ​Lupin would have been sent to Azkaban. If Remus kills a student while transformed, the Ministry wouldn't care that it was a prank gone wrong. They already hate werewolves. Remus would have been executed or thrown in a cage for life.

​The Marauders would be finished. If Snape dies, the investigation reveals the tunnel, the Whomping Willow and the fact that three students are unregistered Animagi. Sirius goes to jail as an accessory and James’s reputation is ruined.

​Snape’s bitterness is actually... logical? I totally get Snape’s POV. Imagine being lured to your death by one bully, "rescued" by the lead bully so his friend doesn't get arrested, and then being told by the Headmaster to shut up and be grateful because you now owe your bully a "Life Debt."

​James did the right thing by stopping it, but it feels like he was protecting his pack, not showing mercy to an enemy. It turns a "heroic rescue" into a desperate attempt to keep his friend from becoming a murderer.

​Am I missing something, or is James Potter way more complicated than the "Gryffindor Golden Boy" image suggests?

Also, I'm not even a Snape fan, but Sirius calling it a 'schoolboy grudge' is insane. You tried to kill the guy (or at least let him get mauled). That’s not a grudge Sirius, that’s a crime scene. Gaslighting much..


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Sep 29 '24

Discussion Does anybody else really dislike the worldbuilding around Patroni and love?

2 Upvotes

Rereading the book and I came across the bit about Snape's Patronus being a doe because Lily's was, and it makes me really uncomfortable for two reasons. One is the whole thing where her Patronus is a reflection of her husband's, and second because sure, the woman who stood up to Voldemort three times and called the most popular boy in school a bullying toerag to his face is really going to be something as gentle and docile as a doe. I also hate that Tonks' patronus changed to a wolf when Remus hated that part of himself. (Mind, I never shipped Remus/Tonks, but that's a different story.)

Harry's Patronus being a stag makes a lot of sense, but I really don't like the idea that romantic couples must have the same Patronus, especially since in the two examples we see in canon, it's the woman's matching the man's. I'd have much rather Lily's been a tigress (for how fierce she was) or something that represented her own nature rather than Mrs James Potter. Thoughts?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Sep 29 '24

Deathly Hallows Regarding the kiss between Harry and Ginny on Harry's 17th birthday in chapter 7 of Deathly Hallows, I have to say that Ron was very immature to get upset with Harry

0 Upvotes

Ron even went so far as to accuse Harry of giving Ginny false hope, of simply having fun with her, of toying with her feelings. Given the circumstances, he should have shown Harry understanding. It's true that Ginny was devastated when Harry broke up with her, but she knew very well the reasons for it, she knew that Harry never really wanted to break up with her, she also knew that they could never know the happiness they desired as long as Voldemort lived. After all, the Dark Lord had constantly tried to kill Harry by any means necessary on countless occasions because he considered him the only one capable of defeating him. If Voldemort had discovered Harry and Ginny's relationship, he would have gone after Ginny and used her to get to Harry.

Hermione understood all this and tried to explain it to Ron, but he wouldn't listen. If one of his brothers (Bill, Fred or George) had caught Harry and Ginny kissing, he would certainly have shown Harry understanding. Ron didn't want to understand that Harry broke up with Ginny for the sole purpose of protecting her from Voldemort.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Oct 15 '26

Could adult Hermione become as powerful as Dumbledore?

0 Upvotes

Characters in the books say that Dumbledore and Tom Riddle were the best students at Hogwarts at the time. The same is often said about Hermione. She's done insane feats of magic for such a young witch. Do you think that, eventually, she could become as powerful as Dumbledore himself?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Mar 01 '24

Hagrid deserved to be expelled, just not for the killing of another student.

7 Upvotes

He deserved to be expelled for bringing a giant man-eating spider into the school. And the fact that over half a century later, at the battle of Hogwarts, he’s still more worried about that vile acromantula’s descendants (it’s his fault they exist in the first place, for finding Aragog a mate) shows he doesn’t truly care about his own students, bearing in mind this wouldn’t be the first time they’d endangered them (think about what had almost happened to Harry and Ron five years prior). He truly deserves to be called a barbaric savage. If he cared about his students, he’d use the Death Eaters’ temporary distraction to start punching them (one punch from him was enough to put any normal human out of action), but instead he stops both the Hogwartians and Death Eaters from attacking those vile spiders.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 25 '25

Deathly Hallows Harry never stupidly speaks Voldemort's name. How else would you have gotten the Trio to Malfoy Manor under duress?

1 Upvotes

Not only dod Harry speaking Voldy's name seem stupid but it felt lazy from a reader's perspective, respectfully. Clearly, the author needed to ramp things up and needed to get the Trio to Malfoy Manor to progress the story. But it feels so sudden and rushed. Not to mention stupid.

How would you have gotten the Trio to Malfoy Manor if you could rewrite that bit?

I'm no author but I think I wouldve had the Trio remember the Malfoy's were already in possesion of one Horcrux so why not another? Harry also overheard Lucius talk about a secret compartment in the Manor. Maybe they polyjuice potion themselves into Diagon Alley and imperius a death eater into divulging the Malfoys address.

Before you come after me, Harry's already used an unforgiveable curse **twice** by then in anger AND they'll use imperio on a goblin just trying to do its job later in the book.

Idk, I havent thought it out but how would you get the Trio to Malfoy Manor?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 15 '25

Deathly Hallows Did JK Rowling ever confirm the 3 brothers theory with Voldemort, Snape, and Harry?

4 Upvotes

paltry squeeze correct snatch amusing grey governor cautious cause provide

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 12 '24

I’m listening to GoF and Hermione triggers me.

9 Upvotes

Any insight would be helpful because I don’t want to be pissed at her but she’s pissing me off.

The Durmstrang and Beauxbatons students just showed up and Hermionie is so mad that Ron and everyone wants Krum’s autograph. Then she says “no one is making you stay!” when the beauxbatons show any sign other than happiness. Is she just fiercely protective of Hogwarts? Or is she just not very understanding of others?

Edit: why is this getting downvoted? I’m looking for other perspectives and it’s as if because I don’t already think the way you all do, I get downvoted. This sub is just as bad as r/harrypotter.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Dec 01 '24

Prisoner of Azkaban Hermione was such a jerk in the prisoner of Azkaban

0 Upvotes

like seriously, she was so annoying. She didn’t care about Ron’s pet rat at all, because despite Ron asking Hermione many times to not let her cat come near, she didn’t bother to take his advices at all. As a result blood stains were found and Ron’s rat was missing. Yet Hermione blamed Ron for not being responsible for his pets. and also she reported Harry’s firebolt to McGonnogal without telling Harry why. That is why, not surprisingly Ron and harry didn’t speak to her for a while.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 17 '25

Discussion What would Ginny name her kids?

5 Upvotes

We all know Harry's and Ginny's three kids are named James, Albus and Lily. And we can safely assume Harry was the one who had the final say in these names. But lets, say Ginny was the one who got to pick the names. what would she name them?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 21 '24

One minor change would have given so much depth to Harry's understanding of his parent's love for him.

0 Upvotes

TW for James Potter haters.

If I could add/adapt one passage from the series it would be the note Harry finds at #12 in DH. Instead of some toss aside details of a Christmas gift, imagine if Lily wrote to Sirius (the only person who could appreciate this) about how much James had grown. How much he adores Harry and how great a dad and husband he is and that she finally feels like one of the Maruaders.

Everything else can stay the same including the picture that came with the letter.Just change the contents of the letter to that and think about what kind of metaphor that would be for the entire Snape/Lily/James relationship and also Harry's understanding of his parents love for him.

Snape finds the letter, probably reads it. Tears off the 'Love, Lily' portion and the Lily portion of the picture leaving just James and Harry.

If that one detail had been added with nothing else in the books changing whatsoever, I'd be satisfied with Harry's relationship with his parents memories.

Wdyt?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jun 10 '25

Discussion Why did Harry name his son Albus Severus – and was it the right choice?

0 Upvotes

I shared a post about this elsewhere, and it sparked some discussion. Here is the link

But I wanted to hear what this community thinks: Do you believe Harry made the right call naming his son after Dumbledore and Snape?

Personally, I think it's more complex than people give it credit for, and says a lot about Harry's character, but it’s definitely not a popular choice for many fans.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 07 '26

Character analysis Controversial Opinion: I hate the Weasley twins

3 Upvotes

“You can’t prank someone you don’t like. That’s just assault” ~ Mitchel Pritchett

Modern Fam said it right. And it’s why I can’t stand the twins. Thoughts?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Aug 25 '26

Chamber of Secrets A very common question.

0 Upvotes

I noticed a running joke with this question being asked all the time and Harry Potter fans keep giving answers to it over and over again.

"If basilisk venom destroys horcruxes, why didn't Harry die when he was bitten in 2nd year?"

All the answers seemed to be convincing and JK Rowling herself gave the answer that since he didn't die and was healed by that phoenix, that means he didn't get destroyed by the venom.

I personally think the answer is much, much simpler than everything I've read on Reddit, including what JK herself said. The answer is that she never planned that far ahead. She didn't plan for Harry to become a horcrux. The idea of horcruxes was developed much later, and all the explanations for why Harry wasn't destroyed by the fang that day are all after the fact explanations


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 28 '24

Like siblings?

3 Upvotes

She picked up the book and then walked back past him into the tent, but as she did so, she brushed the top of his head lightly with her hand. He closed his eyes at her touch, and hated himself for wishing that what she said was true: That Dumbledore had really cared.

Yes, they weren't the canon couple, that was always Romione. But I never felt they were like siblings. Put the names of two siblings in their scenes and it's not gonna feel entirely right. Also, they shared too many emotionally close moments in the books to even count.

This is what JKR had said about Harry & Hermione:

"When I wrote Hallows, I felt this quite strongly when I had Hermione and Harry together in the tent! I hadn't told [Steve] Kloves that and when he wrote the script he felt exactly the same thing at exactly the same point.”


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Mar 10 '24

how many years after reading Philosopher's stone did you realize the Dursleys live on "Privet Drive" and not "Private Drive"?

6 Upvotes

I never realized I was reading it wrong until some post on here explicitly mentioned that common misreading. Think it was like at least 10 years after I started reading the books.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Dec 05 '25

He ran a fascist regime but hid horcruxes like a clueless teen: why?

0 Upvotes

Why didn't Voldemort hide his Horcruxes in the magical equivalent of a NATO base? After all, he had political and military control over the wizarding world.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 11 '26

Discussion Snape is a weirdo

35 Upvotes

I dont like snape at all, everyone just seems to baby him because he was bullied by james, and some people dislike lily for refusing his apology. What’s your opinion on snape


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Sep 16 '22

Prisoner of Azkaban Snape's grudges are pathetic

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one who thinks Snape's grudges are unbelievably selfish, petty, immature and childish? I mean he still has grudges after 20 years, pretty pathetic don't you think? Snape was the type of person who never forgives or forgets if you ever do anything to annoy him. He can never let go of even the most smallest of things. He held grudges and was extremely spiteful toward those whom he disliked.

"I've told the headmaster again and again that you're helping your old friend Black into the castle, Lupin, and here's the proof. Not even I dreamed you would have the nerve to use this old place as your hideout —" "Severus, you're making a mistake," said Lupin urgently. "You haven't heard everything — I can explain — Sirius is not here to kill Harry —" "Two more for Azkaban tonight," said Snape, his eyes now gleaming fanatically. "I shall be interested to see how Dumbledore takes this… He was quite convinced you were harmless, you know, Lupin… a tame werewolf —" "You fool," said Lupin softly. "Is a schoolboy grudge worth putting an innocent man back inside Azkaban?" BANG! Thin, snakelike cords burst from the end of Snape's wand and twisted themselves around Lupin's mouth, wrists, and ankles; he overbalanced and fell to the floor, unable to move.

"Listen to me, Harry. It is too late, you understand me? You must see that Professor Snape's version of events is far more convincing than yours." "He hates Sirius," Hermione said desperately. "All because of some stupid trick Sirius played on him —"

"Blimey, haven' yeh heard?" said Hagrid, his smile fading a little. He lowered his voice, even though there was nobody in sight. "Er — Snape told all the Slytherins this mornin'… Thought everyone'd know by now… Professor Lupin's a werewolf, see. An' he was loose on the grounds las' night… He's packin' now, o' course."

"No. Professor Dumbledore managed to convince Fudge that I was trying to save your lives." He sighed. "That was the final straw for Severus. I think the loss of the Order of Merlin hit him hard. So he — er — accidentally let slip that I am a werewolf this morning at breakfast."


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Aug 08 '25

Discussion How would Harry and Ginny react if people called them out for naming their children like the way they did?

0 Upvotes

...


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jul 08 '24

Prisoner of Azkaban Lupin deserved to lose his job Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Lupin is a selfish coward who endangered students lives more than once. And in fact because of his cowardly and selfish actions, a student was killed by Voldemort the following year.

He knew about Sirus Black being a black dog animagus and knowing about the secret passageways. And Lupin like everyone else all 100% believed Sirius had betrayed the Potters to Voldemort, believed he was a mass murderer, and had broken out of Azkaban to try and kill Harry, and despite this knowledge, Sirius keeps quiet and doesn't tell his employer what he knows which would have protected the school better and the students would have been kept safe. But because Lupin didn't speak out, Sirius broke into the school three times.

Second time he had a knife and got into Gryffindor tower slashed Ron's bed curtains. Had the Sirius really been a mass murderer he would have managed to kill Harry that night. Third time Sirius broke Ron's leg, Lupin transformed into an uncontrollable werewolf and tried to attack Harry and Hermione, and dementors attacked Harry and Hermione. Pettigrew got away and found his way back to Voldemort helped him return and killed Cedric.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jul 30 '25

Discussion Which light side character is the most condescending to Muggles?

0 Upvotes

Arthur Weasley.