r/HarryPotterBooks • • May 07 '25 Take My Energy

Can't believe I was that thick.

6.6k Upvotes

Book 1, Harry gets his wand and Olivander tells him the core is a phoenix feather. In fact, that very phoenix gave only one other feather, and who got that? None other than totally-dead, definitely-carked-it, pushing-up-the-daisies Voldemort. Later that book, Harry finds out that "dead" isn't necessarily that correct - Voldy's still kinda hanging on there. Good thing he definitely dies at the end of the first book. For good. Book 2, Harry sees Dumbledore's pet bird die, and he gets told "Yeah, they do that - but they get better. Sort of." And lo and behold, Fawkes is alive again. Book 4 - guess who's back? Back again? Book 7 - Harry dies. But he comes back. So - 2 characters with a PHOENIX feather in their wand die. And come alive again. Like a PHOENIX. And one stays dead after he gives up his phoenix wand...

How did it take me that long to make that connection?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 12 '24 Sipping Tea Bless Up Take My Silver

Half-Blood Prince AITA?? My nephew is ruining our lives

3.6k Upvotes

When he was 11, his school rep came to our homestay while we were on holiday - and severely harmed my son. Physically and emotionally. It took thousands of pounds worth of surgery and therapy. He never apologised.

When he was 12, he made me miss out on a million pound deal. And then demolished my home. Thousands of pounds. Again.

When he was 13, he physically harmed my sister and traumatised her forever.

When he was 14, his friends demolished our home. Again.

I hate him. He is moody and sullen and doesn’t get along with our son. He has criminal friends and is costing me literally thousands of pounds every year. Can I report him to any authority??

Edit - pounds, not dollars. Please focus on the issue, we’re really struggling


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Sep 04 '25

Character analysis Reading the books it is so painfully obvious why Hermione is in love with Ron

2.4k Upvotes

Ron is extremely Brave, witty, courageous, argumentative who challenges Hermione and goes toe to toe with her. She likes being challenged and protected. She does not want a 'yes dear, no dear' relationship. She wants someone who instead of blindly following her can tell her on her face that 'I dont think you are right'. Ron does that all the time.

He is also over 6ft tall, blue eyed and lean. Any Hermione type girl would go head over heels for him. He also lets her take front stage without outshining her. He makes her feel like she is smartest person on earth. She also became the minister of magic while being married to him. And there was zero jealousy on his part about her having the most prestigious position in the wizarding world.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Dec 16 '24 Heart of Silver

Lupin must have been absolutely tripping when he taught at Hogwarts.

2.4k Upvotes

We see it all from Harry’s perspective so it’s easy to just see Lupin as a calm and collected teacher.

However in reality he was a fairly young man (34?) who had basically been pretty traumatised and spent half of his life struggling.

Then he gets this lifeline job back at Hogwarts. The one place he was happy but also where so many ghosts of his past are.

He turns up and suddenly all his trauma is back. Sirius (the traitor and ex best friend) is back and trying to kill James son. He meets Harry who is the spitting image of James, even plays quidditch and has Lily’s eyes. He old nemesis Snape is there too and is making him the potion he needs for his transformation.

Dumbledore, is the one person who Lupin idolises and feels he owes everything, is trying to keep Harry safe from Sirius Black. Lupin is totally torn over whether to come clean on the animagus stuff and the tunnels in and out of the castle. Speaking of which Snape is trying to get Lupin fired and already seems to know about the map.

There’s also the dementors, bringing up Lupin’s worst fear and also providing this odd opportunity to spend time with Harry. Harry who recalls the details of his parents deaths, Lupin’s friends deaths. On the one hand he wants to help Harry but on the other feels irresponsible by making Harry relive that awful night.

It’s a wild ride for Lupin man…


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 15 '21

Theory Hermione and the Locket

2.2k Upvotes

I'm really curious about how the Locket affected Hermione. We know it made both Harry and Ron extremely short-tempered and angry. Harry's doubts about his friends' loyalty and his own capabilities magnified exponentially while Ron's jealousy just about exploded out of him.

So what did it do to Hermione?

I think the Horcrux played with her fear of failure and got her to work harder.

And it seems counter-intuitive at first, but think about it. How much harder can Hermione work before she crashes and burns? She's the main strategist for their team. It's her magic that means they have food to eat most days. She's the one doing the protection charms. She has been the designated peace-keeper of the group. That's a lot of responsibility and stress for a teenage girl.

Now imagine that the Horcrux is whispering to her that she's not doing enough. Ron almost died in her arms because she splinched him. He is still in a sling because she didn't learn healing spells when she really should have. They don't have any food because she was stupid and she should have prepared for this as well. Her mind plays all the ways her protective enchantments fail and they die because she was negligent of her duties. Let it play the names of all the people who died because she's not producing the answers they need fast enough.

She's supposed to be better than this.

And so Hermione reads her books over and over. She obsesses over the littlest details in their plans. She checks her wards once, twice, thrice even when she's meant to be sleeping. She inventories what they need to get and panics when they run out of supplies. She practices the magic until she loses all feeling in her arm. She makes plans, contingency plans, and contingency plans for her contingency plans. She is the first one up and the last one to bed, and even then, it takes hours to fall asleep because her mind is still whirling about everything they still have to do and everything she doesn't know.

And still, the Horcrux croons to her all the ways she's failing and failing and failing. How can she just lie there and do nothing as others are out there and dying?! Forget that she can't remember the last time she's slept. Ignore the fact that she can barely see straight from the exhaustion, that her hands shake as she weaves the wards. She's so tired she's about to puke, but she can't stop yet. She hasn't earned her rest yet.

The Horcrux can't make her leave, but it can work her to the ground until she has nothing more to give. This would be how the Horcrux beats Hermione Granger.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 12 '25

Half-Blood Prince Severus roasting Bellatrix in HBP is something I live for.

2.1k Upvotes

“He’d have me!” said Bellatrix passionately. “I, who spent many years in Azkaban for him!”

“Yes, indeed, most admirable,” said Snape in a bored voice. “Of course, you weren’t a lot of use to him in prison, but the gesture was undoubtedly fine —”

Next one hits harder.

“Hardly,” said Snape, “although the Dark Lord is pleased that I never deserted my post: I had sixteen years of information on Dumbledore to give him when he returned, a rather more useful welcome-back present than endless reminiscences of how unpleasant Azkaban is “

LMAO! How I wish Bellatrix got killed after Harry revealed Snape’s true loyalties. Her maniacal reaction would've been an entertaining read.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 15 '21

Prisoner of Azkaban Unpopular opinion: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is the best book in the series.

1.8k Upvotes

Prisoner of Azkaban is my favorite book in the series. The absence of Voldemort, alongside Sirius Black escaping from Azkaban after nearly 12 years and the wizarding world hearing about it made for what I consider to be an adventurous story. Additionally, Harry encountering dementors and fearing them challenged his character. I also like how Remus Lupin was different in teaching Defense Against the Dark Arts in conjunction with his kindness and sympathy. Harry, Ron, and Hermione learning the truth about Sirius Black and Peter Pettigrew was a defining moment. Update: Apparently this is actually a popular opinion.

Second update: I've acknowledged this is a popular opinion.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • May 18 '25

Discussion It is absolutely insane how little we know about Hermione's personal life.

1.7k Upvotes

She is one of the main characters. But what do we know about her personal life? We don't even get her parents' names. Nothing about her childhood. Her liking, disliking, Hobby, goals, dreams. Literally NOTHING. I wonder why didn't jk flesh out her character more.

Harry is so disinterested even in his best friends' personal lives that it's borderline annoying. He does not care about anything that doesn't concern him and the books being his pov we get very little insight into Hermione's character.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jun 29 '26 LOL Popcorn Bravo

Deathly Hallows Imagine being Bill Weasley during and after Harry's stay

1.6k Upvotes

"Hmm, Harry is spending a lot of time with Griphook, what are they scheming?"

"I think I should warn him about the dangers of dealing with goblins"

"Well, off they go"

(read the newspapers later that day)

(spit out butterbeer)

"HE FUCKING WHAT"


r/HarryPotterBooks • • May 27 '25

A line in Half Blood Prince I just recently understood

1.4k Upvotes

HBP probably has the best Dumbledore moments in the whole series. One highlight is the exchange between him and Draco on top of the astronomy tower. Dumbledore has set all his plans in motion, including his own death; all he has left to fight for now is Draco’s soul.

“You have no wand”, Draco says. “You are at my mercy!” “No Draco,” Dumbledore says quietly. “It is my mercy, not yours, that matters now.”

At first read, it seems like an expression of self-confidence. As if Dumbledore is somehow still sure he could defeat Draco even without his wand. And who knows, maybe he could have. But that’s not the mercy he means. His entire plan to have Snape kill him is to protect Draco’s innocence. The boy that he still is, even after all the harm he’s done. That is the mercy he extends to Draco; mercy to his soul.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Dec 04 '24

Just made a realisation about who destroyed the horcruxes that I've never noticed before.

1.4k Upvotes

So im on another re-read, almost finished deathly hallows, and I realised that while it feels like harry destroys most of the horcruxes in actual fact each horcrux is destroyed by a different person.

Diary - Harry

Ring - Dumbledore

Locket - Ron

Cup - Hermione

Diadem - Crabbe

Harry - Voldemort

Nagini - Neville

This is probably really obvious and somehow just always eluded me but I thought it was interesting that nobody destroyed two.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Oct 03 '24

Discussion I feel bad for Hermione’s parents

1.4k Upvotes

On rereads, I always feel a twinge of sadness when it comes to Hermione and her parents. They are of course muggles but are supportive of Hermione’s magical gifts. However, I feel like they were both probably quite sad at how cut off they felt from Hermione as the years went on. This entire world in which they were not a part of, nor could they relate to her about it either. They couldn’t even discuss Hermione’s real life with relatives cos it was a secret. As the years go on, we see that Hermione sees less and less of her parents. In the second year, she stays at hogwarts for Christmas, and the image of her parents sitting at the table on Christmas Day thinking of Hermione always makes me sad. Wanting to watch Christmas movies with her, and spend as much time as possible with her but they can’t

There’s a few other instances where she had chose not to go on holiday with them, or she went to the burrow during the holidays before school term started. I’m sure it was clear to all of them that their relationship dynamic had changed, and whilst I’m sure her parents were always proud of Hermione, they probably did feel a bit left out from it all. Does anyone else have these thoughts?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Sep 17 '21

Theory Do you ever think about the patch of corridor swamp Flitwick left 'as a tribute to Fred and George'?

1.3k Upvotes

Flitwick left a small corner of the swamp Fred and George set off in the corridor in OotP and roped it off, because he just thought it was a really good bit of magic. Well, we never hear if he ever removed it..

Imagine how poignant it would be if it was still there after the battle of Hogwarts! I like to think they put up a little plaque, 'In memory of Fred Weasley, 1978-1998', and that it just becomes part of Hogwarts. Just a part of the furniture like the trick step; 'the corridor with the swamp'.

First years would sometimes inevitably push each other into it and have to go to class covered in swamp. The Trevors of the future would escape to it. Text books would be thrown in it. Peeves would chuck handfuls of mud and pondweed at unwary pupils. Superstitious 5th and 7th years drop a galleon in for good luck before their exams. And - best of all - it Filch and all subsequent caretakers would HATE it.

I just think it's the absolute perfect tribute to Fred! I think he'd be really proud if that was his permanent mark on Hogwarts.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 08 '21

Do you ever think about the fact Voldermort always called Peter Wormtail to remind him of the people he had betrayed? He never let him forget his betrayal so he never had the mental strength to fight against him.

1.3k Upvotes

r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 10 '25

Chamber of Secrets Mrs. Weasley’s telling Harry to eat is so beautiful

1.3k Upvotes

You know, just after the twins and Ron rescued him from the Dursleys in the flying Ford Anglia.

Originally, I saw it as just another example of her motherly nature, like a grandmother insisting you’re too skinny after serving you three huge portions. But on reread, I realized it’s so much more than that.

Harry wasn’t just underfed, he was starved for weeks. The Dursleys gave him cold canned soup that he had to share with Hedwig, meaning he wasn’t just hungry, but also severely malnourished. He spent most of his time in his room, sleeping.

Mrs. Weasley is furious when the twins show up with Harry, but the moment she registers what kind of shape he’s in, her anger shifts. She’s still firm with her boys, but she’s no longer raging. Given her skill in healing magic and cooking, she almost certainly recognized the signs of malnutrition in Harry. That’s why she keeps piling food onto his plate and watching him eat, not as a funny “mom thing,” but because it’s probably the first proper meal he’s had since he left Hogwarts.

Even more than that, she makes sure Harry knows she’s not mad at him when she starts screaming at the twins and Ron. She constantly gives him praise and reassurance throughout the meal, following the textbook approach for helping someone who’s been through abuse, providing stability, care, and safety.

It’s such a small moment, but it really stands out as one of the rare times an adult truly looks after Harry’s emotional and physical well-being. And it makes me appreciate Mrs. Weasley even more.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 28 '26

The Weasley family isn’t actually poor, they are middle class.

1.2k Upvotes

I’ve been listening to the Jim Dale versions again and I keep getting stuck by the fact that the Weasley family, for as often as they are called poor, aren’t actually poor. They seem very middle class.

Are things tight when they have 5 children in a private school? Absolutely. They have to use some hand me downs, and buy a few things second hand. Again, they are buying books and school supplies for 5 kids at one point.

When they win the prize money from the Daily Prophet drawing, they spend it on a family trip. If they were as poor as they’re made out to be, that’s highly reckless (though I know that low income families aren’t always known for making the best financial choices).

Ron is able to buy his friends Christmas gifts. His parents can send Christmas and Easter gifts to Ron’s friends (Hermione gets chocolate eggs at least twice on Easter). Harry routinely gets gifts from Hagrid, the Dursleys (always a terrible gift), Hermione, Ron and Mr. & Mrs. Weasley. Ron’s pile of gifts is still bigger every year.

Arthur has enough discretionary money that he can buy a Ford Anglia and acquire a collection of muggle artifacts in his shed. Arthur doesn’t come across as the type would steal from muggle (by using magic to trick them) and he doesn’t see like the type who would buy stuff for himself at the expense of his children’s needs.

I’m not trying to argue that the Weasley family is rich, they are not. But they own a home (when other wizards have been known to live in flats), they always have enough food, and they can be their children’s friends gifts. They seem very middle class, though they are on a budget.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Aug 14 '26

Deathly Hallows Rereading Harry Potter as an adult changed how I see Ron

1.2k Upvotes

Just reread the HP books as an adult and I have so much more empathy for Ron now. As a kid, I was always annoyed by his jealousy and especially him leaving in DH, but now I understand it much more. Harry never asked to be special, but Ron was constantly living in his shadow; fame, money, praise, incredible gifts, and even Dumbledore’s personal attention. Meanwhile, Ron rarely got the same recognition despite being there for Harry and Hermione constantly.

What really struck me is that, despite all those insecurities, Ron actually regulated himself pretty well most of the time. His jealousy doesn’t make him a bad friend; honestly, the fact that he repeatedly chooses his friends despite those feelings makes his loyalty even more meaningful.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 09 '25

Currently Reading A moment of foreshadowing I recently noticed for the first time

1.1k Upvotes

In the first book, when Harry comes across Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest, he is saved by a centaur named Firenze.

After Firenze saves Harry, the other centaurs get mad at Firenze. They claim that the had saw in the stars that Harry was supposed to be killed by Voldemort in this very forest.

Obviously Harry survived that night, but the centaurs were right, Harry was killed by Voldemort in the Forbidden Forrest, it just happened six years later.

This is my eighth time reading the Philosopher Stone, yet I just caught this one. It’s crazy how much new details you discover in this series each time you read it.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 16 '21

Oh.. what I wouldn’t give to wipe all memory of Harry Potter and read the books all over again

1.1k Upvotes

Currently re reading PoA and I just realised that it has a lot of suspense for a first time reader


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Jan 25 '22

Theory What is Draco Malfoy's Boggart?

1.1k Upvotes

Ok, so I have a theory that Draco Malfoys boggart would be a werewolf, here is my evidence.

  1. In PS/SS he gets afraid after getting detention with Harry, Hermione and Neville and says "the Forbidden Forest?! I thought that was a joke. We can't go in there, there's werewolves.."

  2. In HBP when Dumbledore and Draco are on the Astronomy Tower and the other Death Eaters show up with Fenrir Greyback. Dumbledore questions why Malfoy would bring him, Malfoy's response was “I didn’t,” breathed Malfoy. He was not looking at Fenrir; he did not seem to want to even glance at him. “I didn’t know he was going to come —” This tells me he was afraid of Greyback.

  3. In DH while the Death Eaters are having their meeting, Voldemort reveals that Narcissa and Bellatrix's neice just married the werewolf Remus Lupin and this is what he says to Draco, “What say you, Draco?” asked Voldemort, and though his voice was quiet, it carried clearly through the catcalls and jeers. “Will you babysit the cubs?” The hilarity mounted; Draco Malfoy looked in terror at his father, who was staring down into his own lap, then caught his mother’s eye. She shook her head almost imperceptibly, then resumed her own deadpan stare at the opposite wall. it could be argued that he was afraid of Voldemort but why did Voldemort single out Draco with this question? My thought is that Voldemort knew Draco's deepest fear and was using it against him.

Do you think this is plausible? Please let me know and feel free to share.

Edit: I think it's not just any werewolf, I think it's actually Greyback himself that he is afraid of. I left a lengthy comment that actually explains it all.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Nov 02 '22

Half-Blood Prince Snape's Avada Kedavra does not kill Dumbledore

1.1k Upvotes

The fall kills Dumbledore.

For an Unforgivable Curse to succeed, the caster has to really mean the spell. In ‘Half-Blood Prince’, Severus Snape has no desire to kill Professor Dumbledore. His heart is not in this “murder”.

Dumbledore is already dying from the curse on the Gaunt ring. His system has been terribly damaged by the poisonous potion consumed in Voldemort’s cave. He has decided to die. He helpfully positions himself inches from a perilous precipice when Snape points his wand and says the words.

The killing curse takes deep psychological commitment. FakeMoody explains in ‘Goblet of Fire’ that the whole DADA class could aim their wands at him and say Avada Kedavra and “I doubt I would get so much as a nosebleed.” Bellatrix Lestrange is categorical in 'Order of the Phoenix': "Never used an Unforgivable Curse before, have you boy? You need to mean them Potter! You need to really want to cause pain – to enjoy it." Harry's meaningless Cruciatus Curse does not cause Bellatrix to writhe and shriek in agony. But it knocks her off her feet. Likewise, Snape's empty Avada Kedavra simply shoves the elderly headmaster off the ledge.

Snape blasts Dumbledore with a bolt of green light. Harry screams, but the scream is silent. Before he was disarmed, Dumbledore immobilized Harry: this final spell continues to work, rendering Harry unable to move and unable to speak. Out of sight Dumbledore hits the ground and dies. Only then is Harry liberated. Dumbledore’s restraining spell breaks when the headmaster’s life ends — at the bottom of the Astronomy Tower, not the top.

In ‘Deathly Hallows’, Harry considers his own death and reflects on Dumbledore’s. His thoughts are not of Avada Kedavra, but of the broken body at the foot of the Tower. Professor McGonagall also attributes Dumbledore’s death to a long drop and a sudden stop. After the duel with the teachers Snape jumps out of a window. Snape is dead? asks Harry. No, replies McGonagall: “Unlike Dumbledore, he was still carrying a wand.”


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Apr 21 '25

Mr. Weasley is the MVP for the first 10 chapters of Goblet of Fire

1.1k Upvotes

-Is going to show up at Dursley's to get Harry whether the Dursleys give permission or not

-Destroys the Dursleys living room, which was well deserved

-Forces Vernon to say goodbye to Harry even after hearing Harry doesn't care, seeing how awful it is that they'd let Harry leave for 9 months without a word

-Answers all of Harry's probably tedious questions about splinching and setting up the world cup

-Has the time of his life using a mallet and failing to light matches, which is just amazing

-Angrily defends Harry when Cedric's dad says he cast the dark mark

-Is the only damn person in the ministry group to talk to Winky kindly and gave a rational explanation for why she had a wand

Mr. Weasley owns the first 100 pages of the book, what a legend


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Aug 28 '26

Theory Gilderoy Lockhart was part Veela based on the effects he had on Witches

1.0k Upvotes

All the Witches in the books seem to have a similar reaction to Lockhart than the Wizards do to Fleur.

Hermione who is usually so level headed completely loses it around him.

Even after he has lost his mind and ends up in St Mungos the healer seems a bit infatuated by him.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Feb 11 '25

Goblet of Fire Can we all acknowledge how smooth Fred actually is

1.0k Upvotes

"Who're you going with, then?" said Ron.

"Angelina," said Fred promptly, without a trace of embarrassment.

"What?" said Ron, taken aback. "You've already asked her?"

"Good point," said Fred. He turned his head and called across the common room, "Oi! Angelina!"

Angelina, who had been chatting with Alicia Spinnet near the fire, looked over at him.

"What?" She called back.

"Want to come to the ball with me?"

Angelina gave Fred a sort of appraising look.

"All right, then," she said, and she turned back to Alicia and carried on chatting with a bit of a grin on her face.

"There you go," said Fred to Harry and Ron, "piece of cake.

I mean… damn !!! Smoother than a Firebolt hairpin turn.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • Aug 31 '26

Deathly Hallows Now I get the meaning of Dobbys Death

1.0k Upvotes

I’ve never been a particular fan of Dobby but I’ve always been particularly aggrieved by his death. It’s just always pissed me off on a deeply personal level. Like, hasn’t this poor creature’s life been rough enough? Even his “liberation” has been rough and ostracized him from his elf peers. It just seemed a pathetic existence and ending- still serving the needs of “superior”humans. And may that is still largely true. But. But. I’ve just listened to HBP and Hallows back to back and I am floored by a revelation. First the tight construction of key ideas of the series. Rowling has said the series is about death. I’ve always thought of it as about grief. Versions of the same thing.

In HBP chapter — Dumbledore gives Harry his last lesson as they don’t know how imminent his death is. He gets so worked up that it’s “essential” that Harry understand and take seriously that his ability to love is his ultimate advantage and magical power over Voldemort.

At the time, Harry doesn’t understand. Rowling literally pays this out with Dobby’s death. Harry doesn’t respond with vengeance or by grasping for more power. He responds with grief. He digs Dobby’s grave by hand. He honors him. And in doing so, he finally begins to learn what Dumbledore had been trying to teach him.

Moreover, Harry achieves what Snape never managed to teach him. He closes his mind to Voldemort not the way Snape (poorly) taught him - through discipline, emotional suppression, or technical Occlumency, but through grief, which is itself an expression of love. And finally he could block Voldemort out of his mind.

Rowling writes:

“Grief… drove Voldemort out… though Dumbledore, of course, would have said that it was love.”

That line unlocked the entire endgame for me in a way I’d never understood.

Dobby’s death isn’t simply a tragic loss. It’s the psychological turning point of the series. It breaks Harry’s growing obsession with the Hallows and power, returns him to love, sacrifice, and reverence for life, and prepares him for the final choice Dumbledore knew he would one day have to make.

It still breaks my heart every time I read it. But the purpose and storytelling is beautifully done.

RIP Dobby.