r/HCTriage • • Sep 30 '15

I made this for you! (a HCT subreddit alien if you'd like to use it)

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jan 11 '17

Sassy Aaron Carroll

40 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jun 10 '15

Aaron's scientific opinion on going out in the cold. (For everyone who enjoys HCTriage Live)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
22 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jul 07 '15

New Coffee Mug Proposal (Inspired By Coffee Episode)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
16 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Nov 01 '15

Health Care Triage Episode Idea

15 Upvotes

As a nutrition/ dietetics student I get a lot of questions regarding "how much protein (usually protein powder) should I have before I go to the gym?" My opinion is usually ignored when I say that the current recommended intake of protein before/during/after exercise is not anywhere near as high as is recommended on the back of the protein packets/ bodybuilding forums.

Many of my superiors have communicated their fear that this protein supplementation craze is not only resulting in expensive urine, but also possibly poor health outcomes. Would the HCT team pleeeeaaaseee consider doing an episode on excess protein consumption/ supplementation? :D :D :D


r/HCTriage • • Jul 15 '15

How much do antibiotic ointments (like neosporin) contribute to antibiotic resistant bacteria?

14 Upvotes

Follow up to your answer about wound cleaning.


r/HCTriage • • Jul 03 '15

Dysmenorrhea: why is medicine failing women?

14 Upvotes

TL;DR: Debilitating periods suck and birth control & pain killers aren't always the answer. Where is the science and where are our better options?

Dysmenorrhea is the medical term for painful periods, and it definitely goes beyond abdominal twinged & dull cramps. For many women, myself included, dysmenorrhea is a debilitating condition with severe abdominal cramps, back pain, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea and the really unlucky ladies also get an extra dollop of headaches and leg pain, cause why not. And all that's for primary dysmenorrhea (i.e.: no known cause), with secondary dysmenorrhea, you could even get some monthly fever thrown in the mix! (Yep, that was teenage me with ovarian cystitis, but not PCOS.)

Dysmenorrhea affects at least 1 in 2 women of reproductive age to some degree, and for roughly 1 in 10 women, it is so severe that they're unable to maintain their normal schedules during their period. Going to school, going to work, is just not achievable.

 

Unfortunately, the condition still gets minimised a lot, and treatment options aren't stellar. If I can take 600 mg of ibuprofen + 20 mg of Buscopan (butylhyoscine bromide) before the cramping starts, I can keep pain levels to about a 3-4 (with 0 being no pain and 10 being the worst pain imaginable) and then just have to deal with nausea, heartburn and occasional vomiting (yep, I've tried medication for that too - didn't help!).

When I'm unfortunate enough to have my period start at night and be woken up from the severity of my menstrual cramps, I would definitely rate the pain as a 9 (and it's possibly a 10, but I have a strong imagination) and at that point, painkillers can hardly achieve anything. This happened last month, and it took 2,5 hours to get the pain down to a 6, and for the entire first day, I didn't get it below a 5 at all. Of course, the strong uterine contractions take the bowels along, and this also spells diarrhea.

 

So how does dysmenorrhea get treated in most cases? Hormonal birth control. The pill, the patch, the ring, the implant, the hormonal IUD (Mirena), ... And, you know, it's pretty effective at preventing painful periods, because you don't get any actual periods any more (in some cases you do get withdrawal bleeds). All fine and dandy, right? Well, no, sadly, it's not. It really feels like the medical field is saying: "Well, there is a fix for dysmenorrhoea: just cut your reproductive ability, kill your libido and pump up your risk for a venous thrombo-embolism, that'll do nicely."

It's all about weighing risks and benefits of course. The increased risk for VTE is still pretty minor, unless you have had a previous deep vein thrombosis (like me) or pulmonary embolism and you can forget all about it. If you shop around, you'll like find some form of hormonal birth control that doesn't affect your libido very much. The worst part about it though, is the fact that this "fix" prevents conception, because you know what? Lots and lots of women want to become a mother, and contrary to popular belief, that doesn't generally happen the first time you have unprotected sex, so there are still many excruciating periods to be had before motherhood is achieved.

 

It's just really frustrating that there's so little even a gynaecologist can do for or explain about primary dysmenorrhea, as well as the fact that society as a whole doesn't seem to take it seriously and seems to think women are moany creatures who exaggerate about periods. With these epidemiological stats (1 in 2 affected, 1 in 10 debilitated), you'd think there's a large enough population for some good scientific research (even the holy grail: double-blind randomised control trials!) and to try to find some preventative measure or effective symptomatic treatment that at the very least doesn't impact a woman's fertility. The current approach of birth control, pain killers and heat packs just doesn't cut it.

There's got to be an economic incentive too, right? How much productivity gets lost because of dysmenorrhea? How willing do you think women are to shell out money to get some relief?

Does anybody have an explanation? Any quality research that's been lurking around but not picked up by the general community? Any tips on making shark week less terrible?


r/HCTriage • • May 05 '16

Healthcare Triage has a catchy theme, so I thought I'd try and create an extended version.

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
12 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Oct 21 '15

Why do recommendations for vaccinations for kids vary from country to country?

12 Upvotes

I am German and here the recommendation from the "Ständige Impfkommission" (vaccination commition) says that kids should be vaccinated to get a basic immunization (Tetanus, Diphtherie, Pertussis, Poliomyelitis, Haemophilus influenzae b and Hapatitis B) four times till they are two years old, starting at 6 weeks. In Austria they start later and vaccinate only three times. Don't they have the same research?


r/HCTriage • • Sep 09 '15

Dr. Carroll, why do you hit the desk with your fist so much? Also why were you asked to stop?

12 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jun 25 '15

Topic Idea

12 Upvotes

I am not sure if this would get off the ground or if there are enough people staffed at Healthcare Triage to do so, but it would be an interesting idea if someone could explain what different medical staff do, like a summary, for people to have a better idea of what people do in the medical field.

I think most people think about just doctors and nurses, but there are so many others in a hospital beyond just administration staff and custodians that it would be interesting if we had a reference for what those people do.

For example, I don't think many people know what an occupational therapist, phebotomist, or radiologist's jobs entail.


r/HCTriage • • Nov 18 '15

Does HCT have a page where they post all the questions they've received on live HCT, linked to their corresponding video?

11 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Aug 25 '15

Sources for "Sitting vs. Standing. Is Your Sedentary Life Killing You?"

11 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jun 17 '15

Healthcare Triage is Live Now!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Sep 22 '15

US pharmaceutical company defends 5,000% price increase

10 Upvotes

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-34320413?ocid=global_bbccom_email_22092015_top+news+stories

" CEO Martin Shkreli has said that the company will use the money it makes from sales to research new treatments. After Turing's acquisition, a dose of Daraprim in the US increased from $13.50 (£8.70) to $750. "

Oh my god. Please for the love of god cover this in the next HCT news? This is the most depressing thing I read today. Please reassure me there will be a backlash/intervention somehow to override this decision? Or am I over concerned? What is the real impact?

While I agree that development and distribution costs should be shared among consumers (patients), I have a feeling this increase is undue and excessive. Hopefully someone can do the math to judge whether it is justified.

In more detail: The Guardian - http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/sep/21/entrepreneur-defends-raise-price-daraprim-drug

New York Times - http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/21/business/a-huge-overnight-increase-in-a-drugs-price-raises-protests.html?_r=0


r/HCTriage • • Oct 24 '17

Specialist just charged us $800 for 5minutes and "I don't know". How do I shop that around?

9 Upvotes

Unconscionable prices are hidden through the insurance system thus ignored. Also there's a guilt riddled coercion component that amounts to extortion. No one would tolerate a mechanic charging $800 to glance at your car then say "meh, come back next year and I'll sell you some snake-oil". Different story when that snake-oil might save a family member's life. So, show topic idea, how do I shop around for extortion?


r/HCTriage • • Jun 26 '17

Vaccines: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Aug 17 '16

What evidence is there for blue light, specifically from LEDs, being bad for you?

9 Upvotes

Saw a sign at the eye doctor advertising special lenses to protect you from "eye strain, retinal damage, sleep problems and ADHD" caused by the blue light from LEDs. As a physicist, I am deeply skeptical that the narrowband blue light from LEDs are any worse than broader band blue light from supposedly safe sources. What does the research say?


r/HCTriage • • May 11 '16

Folate during Pregnancies causes autism? Are we being trolled?

Thumbnail
researchgate.net
9 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • May 02 '16

Aaron must be very happy with Vox right now

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Feb 12 '16

Ask HCT: My parents are terrified of electromagnetic "radiation" or "electrical pollution" but I'm not. What studies are actually out there?

9 Upvotes

So, I've asked on two different HCTLive episodes about my mother's fears about different mobile devices and some "panic of the week" stories that have come about because of them.

It started when I was in high-school and my school gave me a laptop, and she heard that putting a laptop on your lap can lower sperm count. (Yeah, that question was me.) She claimed it was everything from the heat of the computer (which is silly) to "radioactivity" coming from my computer.

More recently, she has become worried about mobile devices like phones and tablets charging while near me. For example, if I'm on the couch and my phone is charging but also close to my leg so I can find and use it easily. After hearing of a few stories of kids getting "burned" by charging phones, she will squawk at me if I have my phone or tablet charging and also touching my body.

Out of sheer curiosity, besides these news stories which tend to have misleading headlines, have there been any serious studies conducted about electromagnetic radiation? Anything about people living under power lines having higher cancer rates?

P.S. I'm sure no amount of evidence will convince them. My sister has everyone convinced that microwaving food causes food to lose some nutrients. I fear I'm the only one in my family who knows how electricity and microwaves work.


r/HCTriage • • Jan 27 '16

Risks or benefits to cleaning my ears with Q-tips? I like clean earbuds & end up removing orange wax from my ears about once a week. Is this safe as long as I don’t go too deep?

9 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jan 06 '16

Ask HT: Diet is the key to weight loss, what food have low calories and will keep me full and functional the longest? Basically, how do I reduce calories without feeling hungry?

9 Upvotes

I've seen conflicting studies online. That's why I'm asking you


r/HCTriage • • Oct 11 '15

I would like to suggest Vasalgel be covered on HCT Triage or at least considered.

9 Upvotes

Vasagel is a male contraceptive that works for many years with one cheap shot. It is gel that is injected into the sperm tubes which disables all sperm going past it or blocks them then then they dissolve. It is supposed to be easily reversible and benign.

I believe I heard bill gates didn't want to fund them because he was concentrating on female contraceptive but maybe because he didn't believe it would work but didn't want to say.

This dnews clip (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69fBYvwKNLk) is overly optimistic as they seem to have funding issues and have hit some hurdles. I read on their email the reversal wasn't working well enough on the dog and baboon trials but they don't have any info on what they mean by that.

Their website http://www.parsemusfoundation.org/projects/vasalgel/


r/HCTriage • • Sep 30 '15

HCTriage Reddit book club/research club?

9 Upvotes

Would anyone be interested in a HCTriage Book Club or some medical research version?