r/HCTriage • • Feb 23 '16

ASK HCT: Does Circumcision have significant health benefits if so, does the EU experience worth health outcomes because of lower rates of circumcision.

0 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Jun 05 '16

Drawing/comic inspired by Healthcare Triage

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Feb 19 '16

Ask HCT: Could you do a video on cold (weather)? (not the cold myth)

2 Upvotes

Apart from the ever-recurring cold myth I'd love to see an HCT episode on many things regarding coldness, e.g.:

  • What can actually happen if you stay in cold weather for an extened period of time, meaning: feeling cold (without appropriate protection)?

  • Why do people experience coldness so differently (same bodyfat, lived in the same place for years)?

  • Can jogging in cold weather be harmful (if you're mostly breathing through your mouth)?

  • How is the immune system reacting to coldness if it's weak/strong? Or is it only reacting to bacterial/viral infections? That would actually lead to more questions about the immune system, which would probably deserve its own episode.

  • What is happening when I'm feeling cold? Am I using more energy? If so, why not enough to keep me warm? What are the limits of the body's heating capabilities?

I'm sure there are more questions related to this topic that maybe people would like to ask here in the hopes that HCT pick it up.


r/HCTriage • • Feb 18 '16

Ask HCT: In the spirit of Lent, German Monks' would give up food and go on a beer fast

0 Upvotes

Here was someone who recently completed this fast:

https://diaryofaparttimemonk.wordpress.com/

During the fast, strong beer (Doppelbock) is the main source of sustenance.

Obviously, this diet is not healthy/ideal. However, I am curious what the actual consequences of this diet, and particularly, this type of alcohol use are.

What is the damage when beer, as a meal replacement, is consumed in 3+ hour intervals, several times a day?


r/HCTriage • • Feb 18 '16

I make handmade soap as a hobby. (No, I'm not Tyler Durden.) Let's talk about skin care!

0 Upvotes

First off, huge disclaimer: I'm not an expert. In anything. I make hand-made cold-process soaps for fun, sell a few bars here and there, and find the whole process enjoyable.

I'm asking the great minds here at /r/HCTriage; What are some additives you would be interested in seeing added to soap that has an actual effect on the human body?

I make my soaps using a combination of vegetable oils for the base and essential oils for scents. I'm not really someone who thinks essential oils have mystical properties to them or anything, I think they smell good, and soap should smell pleasant.

Here's some stuff I've added to soap with some positive effects on the user experience:

Cayenne pepper: I made a few bars of soap with cayenne pepper in it, because I've heard that capsaicin from peppers is used topically (or sometimes even injected) to treat muscular pain. The bar does create a mild burning sensation where used, but I've used it after pulling a muscle and it works...a bit.

Caffeine: I haven't gone as far as adding caffeine in powder form, but I have replaced the water in a soap recipe with super-dooper strong green tea, mostly for fragrance. The tanins in the tea turn it a brown color, but it smells all right and there is some caffeine in the soap now. No noticeable effect from my own testing, though.

Essential Oils - So, while I'm not going to claim any miracle effects from the essential oils in the soap, as I've said before, they smell good, and the soap leaves the user smelling good too. That's an effect, I guess.

That's about it.


r/HCTriage • • Feb 18 '16

Ask HTC: What do you think of people touting marijuana as some sort of "miracle drug"?

2 Upvotes

You see all these posts on facebook about marijuana curing cancer or depression and how it's all "proven" but "they" don't want you to know. Is it all bunk? It feels like bunk.


r/HCTriage • • Nov 07 '17

What about diet soda?

2 Upvotes

I couldn't find any direct treatment of this in the post history, and I don't think this was directly covered in any episodes, so I guess I'll just ask this here:

Is diet soda bad for you?

I've seen an episode on artificial sweeteners. I've seen an episode on big soda and sugar. I've seen plenty of talk about coffee. All of these are of course have elements that go into diet soda, but they also have elements that do not.


r/HCTriage • • Jul 03 '15

This super nerdy photo of Dr.Aaron Corral should be discussed. LOL

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Aug 20 '15

Where does Dr. Carroll get the questions for HCT Live?

3 Upvotes

Twitter? Live Chat? Comments on his videos?


r/HCTriage • • Jul 30 '15

Is there a genetic component to Lactose Intolerance?

3 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Apr 04 '16

1qt of V8 Fusion a day, every day?

0 Upvotes

Hello, In order to get some vegetables in my diet, I drink a quart of V8 Fusion (or drinks like it, vegetable/fruit juice mixes) every day, without fail. On rare occasion, I may drink a second. Without it, I tend to get very, very few vegetables in my diet. Is there any way this is actually bad for me? Thanks! 25-male


r/HCTriage • • Apr 03 '16

Are there any studies on the effect of latitude on the effects of vitamin supplementation (especially in winter months)?

0 Upvotes

Regarding the recent health care triage episode on vitamin D supplements and their likely ineffectiveness as treatment, I couldn't help but note that nothing was mentioned about winter or studies in northern countries. I live in Finland and a common lay wisdom says that eating vitamin D during winter months is good (the effect is never specified) and I was wondering whether there is any research on this, especially with regard to nordic countries/ Canada/ northern Russia.

The episode did mention a Danish study, but I don't know if it's results are applicable for how much further North from there?

episode link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OISl9NvrSuo


r/HCTriage • • Apr 03 '16

Opinion on Neuroprostheses?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I'll keep it short. Ignoring TDCS quackery like foc.us and thync, Are you familiar with some of neuroengineering's recent advances? Any chance you would be interested in signal-boosting some of these results?

For example, there now exist decent EEG-based Brain-computer Interfaces that function as keyboards (SSVEPSpeller/P300Speller), joysticks for limb control (Motor Imagery type stuff). The spellers are most commonly used to allow fully-locked-in ALS patients to communicate again. There's also restorative neural prostheses, like the always-improving, old-news cochlear implants(everywhere), but more stunningly tactile prostheses, either in the somatosensory cortex (DARPA) or (more reasonably) in the forearm (Univ Utah). The speaker I attended at SFN2015 demoed using a forearm-implanted Utah array to restore the sense of touch to an amputee feeling the wood grain of a VR door with his missing hand, truly incredible stuff. There's also pretty early-phase retinal prostheses as well.

As for an actual question, here: There's an absurd amount of misinformation floating around about the brain, what's healthy for it, or even what it's doing. Companies then grab ahold of some popular (but false) idea of brain function, and then monopolize on it by selling sham products (see here foc.us, thync, "mind machines", even neuro water). They then claim that their effect sizes are "too small to merit regulation by the FDA". Considering I'm too early-career to be affiliated with the FDA, what can we do as scientists working in these fields to push back against this deliberate misinformation?


r/HCTriage • • Jul 15 '16

Newly found nervous system pathway?

0 Upvotes

This paper is getting lots of headlines about how the immune system is directly affecting behavior. What can we really conclude, and what further study is warranted?


r/HCTriage • • Nov 20 '16

Grain Brain Whole Life Plan

0 Upvotes

Recently just got the audiobook for Grain Brain WLP. Starting the diet tomorrow. I'm not interested in weight loss only health. Some have claimed Dr. Perlmutter is a shyster, although most if not all the things he writes about have studies he cites or are falsifiable (these levels in the blood should be here). Was wondering reddit's thoughts on his books (Grain Brain, Brain Maker, Grain Brain Whole Life Plan)


r/HCTriage • • Aug 19 '17

Patients Don't Shop Around, because They Can't

5 Upvotes

I'm confused about patients shopping around.
Most insurance companies in my part of the world (SE PA) don't give us options. In my area, Wellspan bought up all the competition. Now I have two (three) options, pay the $3k for a spinal tap by a doctor thats done it a hundred times or $2.5k for a new kid (or suck a bullet). That's a hell of a choice.
Extortion either way.
Capitalistic principals don't apply to things like this.


r/HCTriage • • Feb 26 '16

ASK HTC: What are hospital reimbursement rates and how do they contribute to the cost of health care?

1 Upvotes

I'm learning about health care and systems in the states. I know that the creation of Medicare and Medicaid had an enormous impact on hospitalization rates in the U.S. (more old people/those in need acquired paid access), which also set the basis for reimbursement rates. These high reimbursement rates fueled the rising cost of health care in the US. Could you help me understand reimbursement rates and it's connection to health care / cost of care for hospitals? Thank you!


r/HCTriage • • Feb 15 '17

Health Benefits of Sulforaphane

1 Upvotes

Hey guys,

Do you know if Aaron has ever done a video about the health benefits of sulforaphane?? I've heard it's supposed to be one if the strongest antioxidants known, and brokkoli sprouts are said to be an amazing source for it. :)


r/HCTriage • • Feb 22 '16

The milk myth.

1 Upvotes

My family believes in the milk myth, and are EXTREMELY pro milk. How do I change their view on it, (they won't listen to the research) without coming off as rude/condescending?


r/HCTriage • • Nov 19 '15

Essential oils cure cancer?

Thumbnail
cancercompass.com
0 Upvotes

r/HCTriage • • Nov 19 '17

Can intermittent fasting help obese individuals who are insulin resistant lose weight without regain?

1 Upvotes

I read the book The Obesity Code: Unlocking the Secrets of Weight Loss, Jason Fung, Timothy Noakes and it promotes intermittent fasting and a low carbohydrate diet for losing weight. The cite several studies to back their claims. However, there don't seem to be that many long-term studies showing the absence of the typical regain after losing weight. Would it be possible to do an episode on this question?


r/HCTriage • • Jul 25 '16

Vaccine advocacy using relative risk

1 Upvotes

Are there any meta-analyses of childhood vaccine risks vs childhood-without-vaccines risks? I feel like there are tons of studies good enough convince people that vaccination is a good decision, but those studies and results are usually too complicated for snappy headlines. Absolute risks can seem negligibly small, but relative risk might tell a clearer story. Something like: "in America, your child is 8 times more likely to die before age 10 if you don't vaccinate." Do those analyses exist? What's the relative risk?


r/HCTriage • • Apr 28 '17

Underdiagnosed of depression in men

1 Upvotes

Women have higher rates of depression than men. However, a 2016 Cracked article made the argument that the difference between depression rates in men and women may be much smaller than what is reported on account of under-diagnosing men’s depressing. The core arguments are that there is a strong social pressure for men not to admit things resembling weakness even to their doctor and the symptoms of depression resemble traditional masculine virtues such as working long hours or reckless behavior. “We don't regard those things as symptoms of a mental health issue; those are symptoms of being Batman.” In addition to suicide rates being much higher for men than women. What are your thoughts on underdiagnosed of depression in men and how well has it been controlled for in the research? http://www.cracked.com/article_23304_6-weird-ways-sexism-screwing-up-healthcare.html


r/HCTriage • • Mar 09 '16

A miscommunication on health?

1 Upvotes

I see quite a few questions on HTC Live starting with some sort of diet, drink, supplement, or activity, and ending with the question: is this thing better for me? AC seems to unerringly answer these questions with no, because there are no studies linking these things to positive differences in health outcomes. My problem is that I think these people don't really want to know how these things affect disease and death which are measurable health outcomes, but more difficult metrics like mood, comfort, and energy. These things are a big part of how we actually feel on a daily basis, but is there any way to actually study these things and what decisions have an impact on them? If there was, would we be less susceptible to all the products that claim to make us "feel better"? I would love to see this addressed on an HTC Live.


r/HCTriage • • Sep 20 '16

Global digital medical record? How long?

1 Upvotes

I would like my wearables to auto share my data to my health record. Also to be able to travel with my health record... Me and some of my friends had a "beer conversation" about what would be an optimal way to make global digital health record a reality and we came up with fairly simple blockchain implementation. Secure, distributed, simple to implement, always online. Is there any movement in medical software market to utilize block chain? Or some at least some NGO pushing a global health record standard or always on person flashdrive?

I have a... My medical history is a read... I am also in a medical trial so is there like a thing that most hospitals recognize that I could show up with it and would not have to tell my entire life story... literally...