r/GermanCitizenship • • 42m ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 What if I made a Sachstansanfrage and/or an Untätigkeitslageandrohung for my §5 StAG case?

1 Upvotes

I'm not interested in an actual Untätigkeitslage due to the legal fees, but I thought a Sachstansanfrage or Untätigkeitslageandrohung would be successful at getting the BVA to speed up my declaration so that they wouldn't have to deal with a lawsuit. If I were to use these abilities, I wouldn't do it until 12-18 months after my submission date because I know the BVA would just get an extension if I took action too early. My case is simple, and I submitted all the appropriate documents. I haven't seen any talk about UKs being used for §5 StAG applicants in this subreddit, only ones under §10. My question is the difference between the two and if they would actually work.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 7h ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 Questions Regarding Name Changes, Possible Adoption, and Naturalization Paperwork!

5 Upvotes

Hi all! In the last week I've found out I'm (probably) eligible via StAG 5 ruling and its been a whirlwind of finding paperwork.

I have some questions regarding primarily my grandmother, who appears to have gained citizenship at birth. Her father was born in Germany, and moved to the US as a child with his family. None of them naturalized until the mid-late 1930's, and my great grandfather didn't naturalize until almost 2 years after my grandma was born.

My questions are:

  1. Listed on his naturalization petition paperwork is my grandma as his child. As far as I've gathered, this doesn't strip her of her citizenship, as she was already a US citizen by birth and therefor couldn't "naturalize." Is this correct, or does this break the chain?

  2. Her father died VERY young, and her mother remarried. As far as I can tell, she was not adopted. She did change her last name to be hyphenated with her birth fathers name, and step fathers name. As long as I can prove the name change, I'm assuming this is okay? Furthermore, if she was adopted, from what I see this didn't strip her of her German citizenship?

  3. Unrelated to above and the title (sorry!) since my great grandfather was only about 7 when they left Germany, should I try to hunt down his parents info (marriage cert, birth certs) or do they consider him German because he was born there (1905 was his birth year.) I have so many random documents because my dad is a genealogy buff, so I also have things like his dads insurance stamp card (with the last stamp dated right before they left) and enemy alien card. I'm assuming even certified copies are unhelpful?

Thank you!!


r/GermanCitizenship • • 8h ago

Something Interesting I Found German ancestry from Galicia (Dornfeld)

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’ve recently started researching my family history. My ancestors lived for several generations in Dornfeld (Galicia, now Ukraine), a German settlement founded in the 18th century.
Our family surname seems to be of German origin. However, I haven’t found any documents confirming my ancestors’ ethnicity yet.
Has anyone researched German ancestors from Galicia, especially Dornfeld? How realistic is it to find records proving German ancestry?
Also, has anyone successfully obtained German citizenship through the Spätaussiedler process based on Galician German ancestry? I’m particularly interested in whether this could be possible for my father.
I’d really appreciate any experiences or advice!


r/GermanCitizenship • • 8h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany 🇩🇪 Finally got my Einbürgerungsurkunde! My full timeline (14.5 months in Karlsruhe, Baden-Württemberg)

Post image
50 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

After 14 months and 19 days, I can finally say that I'm officially a German citizen! 🇩🇪🙂

I've been following this subreddit for quite some time, reading other people's experiences and timelines, so I thought I'd share mine as well. Hopefully, it will be useful to those who are still waiting, especially anyone who applied in Karlsruhe.

Here's how everything went:

📅 01.09.2025 | Application submitted

I submitted my Einbürgerung application by dropping all the required documents directly into the Einbürgerungsbehörde's mailbox (Briefkasten).

No appointment, just the complete application with all the necessary paperwork.

📅 02.09.2025 | Application acknowledged

Surprisingly, the acknowledgement letter was already dated 02.09.2025, just one day after I submitted my application.

I received it in the mail about a week later, together with my Aktenzeichen.

The letter also mentioned that the expected processing time was more than 20 months.

So, naturally, I prepared myself for a pretty long wait.

📅 20.09.2026 | First status inquiry (Sachstandsanfrage)

A little over 12 months had passed without any further communication or updates.

I decided to send a polite email asking about the current status of my application. I also asked whether all my documents were complete and offered to provide anything else they might need.

I wasn't expecting much, considering the originally stated waiting time of over 20 months.

📅 21.09.2026 | Request for additional documents

To my surprise, the authority actually reacted very quickly!

A letter requesting two additional documents was already dated 21.09.2026, literally the day after my email.

I received that letter about a week later.

Since I was on vacation at the time, I couldn't provide the requested documents immediately, but I managed to submit both around 08.10.2026.

📅 October 2026 | Invitation to an appointment

Just a few days after submitting the missing documents, I received another letter inviting me to an in-person appointment.

I was asked to:

  1. Bring all my original documents for verification.

  2. Read through and familiarize myself with the information in the Merkblatt zur Verfassungstreue and the relevant declarations, as I would be questioned about their contents during the appointment.

  3. Pay the naturalization fee of €255.

At this point, I finally had the feeling that things were moving towards the finish line.

📅 06.11.2026 | In-person appointment

I attended the appointment, brought all the requested original documents and paid the €255 fee.

The interview itself was actually a very pleasant experience. The person handling my application was friendly, polite and professional, which made the whole appointment quite relaxed.

However, I should mention that I really did have to prepare for the questions about the Merkblatt. It wasn't just a matter of signing a document or confirming that I had read it. I was actually asked questions to check whether I understood its contents.

So, for anyone who receives the same invitation, my advice would be to take the preparation seriously and make sure you understand what you've been asked to read. At least in my case, it wasn't just a formality.

Everything went smoothly, and afterwards I received another appointment, this time to collect my Einbürgerungsurkunde!

📅 20.11.2026 | Einbürgerungsurkunde received! 🇩🇪🎉

And that was it!

On November 20th, 2026, I officially became a German citizen.

From dropping my application into the mailbox to holding the certificate in my hands, the entire process took exactly 14 months and 19 days.

Final thoughts

Looking back, it was definitely a long process, especially with more than a year of basically no communication. But considering that the original estimate was over 20 months, I'm actually quite happy with how things turned out.

What surprised me the most was how quickly everything progressed after my Sachstandsanfrage in September. Within roughly two months of sending that email, the missing documents were requested, the appointments were arranged, and I had my certificate.

Of course, I can't say whether my email actually helped move things forward or whether my application was already about to be processed anyway. But I'm certainly glad I sent it.

I also have to give credit to the Einbürgerungsbehörde for responding so quickly once things started moving and for making the in-person appointment a genuinely pleasant experience.

After all the waiting, paperwork and uncertainty, it really is a great feeling to finally have the Urkunde in my hands. 🙂

For everyone still waiting, I wish you patience and hopefully some good news soon!

And if anyone has questions about my timeline or the process in Karlsruhe, feel free to ask. I'll gladly share what I can from my experience.

🇩🇪🍀


r/GermanCitizenship • • 10h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany German bureaucracy at its finest: One department makes me wait, another wants to reject my citizenship application because I'm waiting.

40 Upvotes

I applied for German citizenship in January 2026.

I previously held a residence permit under § 18b AufenthG and still work for the same employer with a permanent employment contract.

For the past 7–8 months, I have been trying to renew my residence permit. I currently hold a Fiktionsbescheinigung under § 81 Abs. 4. I have emails documenting my repeated attempts to get an appointment.

Now, the citizenship office has sent me an official letter (Anhörung under § 28 VwVfG), stating that they intend to reject my application because a Fiktionsbescheinigung is not sufficient for naturalization.

I have until December 18, 2026, to respond. No other reason for rejection was mentioned.

So, basically, one government department makes me wait, while another wants to reject my citizenship application because of that very delay.

Apparently, the solution to bureaucratic delays in Germany is to punish the person waiting. Brilliant system.

I'm planning to hire a lawyer and request that my citizenship application remain open until my residence permit is renewed.

Has anyone experienced something similar?

Did your citizenship office agree to wait? Did a lawyer help? Or were you forced to start the entire citizenship process again?

Any personal experiences or advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 10h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany §15 StAG – Jewish family in Berlin since 1919; father & son left 1931, mother likely stayed until 1936. Eligible?

0 Upvotes
Hi! I'm from Argentina and I'd like to know if §15 StAG could apply to us.

- Great-grandparents: a Romanian Jewish man born in Bukovina and a Jewish woman born in Upper Silesia. Married in Berlin in 1919 and lived there.
- Two children born in Berlin in the 1920s (one of them is my grandfather).
- In 1931 the father and my grandfather got a one-way German exit visa and a South American visa.
- The mother and daughter are NOT on that exit visa, and in 1936 the marriage certificate was legalized in Berlin for emigration. So we think the mother stayed in Berlin until about 1936.

Questions:
1. If my great-grandmother left Berlin after 30.01.1933, can descendants claim §15 through her even though her son (my grandfather) left in 1931 as a child?
2. Does it matter that she was probably a Romanian citizen by marriage, not German?
3. Best way to prove her residence after 1933? I've already asked the Landesarchiv and the Bundesarchiv. Anything else that worked for you (address books, compensation files, etc.)?

Thanks!

r/GermanCitizenship • • 14h ago

Other Unsolicited call from PassExperten / rightmart about my citizenship application. Anyone else?

7 Upvotes

I applied for German citizenship through my city about half a year ago. I never signed up for any service or gave out my phone number, but I got a 30-minute call from a Bremen number and then an email from PassExperten (rightmart Rechtsanwalts GmbH) offering their service for €2,000.

Has anyone had the same experience? From what I understood from our conversation, their main selling point was that they could get me the citizenship within 3-6 months. Did some Googling, and the whole thing seems like a huge scam.

I still don't understand where they got my phone number from, and I asked; no one replied.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 18h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Applying while doing a berufsbegleitende Ausbildung

1 Upvotes

Hi dear all,

By the time I'm fully illegible as applicant for the naturalization I will be in the last semester of the ausbildung.

Given the political situation in the country, I'd like to start it ASAP before right wing politics start with their policies...

I'm married to a German citizen and my original visa was a family reunification one, but unfortunately I read that a student status is an obstacle in the process. Is that really so? Do I have to wait until I am finished?

Thanks for your replies.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 20h ago

FAQ: Do I need a Lawyer? Einbürgerung-München-Anwalt

4 Upvotes

Hallo, liebe Community,

ich bin momentan sehr verunsichert und vielleicht könnt ihr mir aufgrund eurer Erfahrungen einen Rat geben.

Ich habe vor 1,5 Jahren meinen Einbürgerungsantrag in München gestellt und seitdem leider nichts mehr gehört. Ich habe nicht einmal ein Loyalitätsschreiben zum Unterschreiben bekommen.

Ich möchte irgendwann auch gerne meinen Job wechseln. Allerdings kann und möchte ich nicht noch weitere 2–3 Jahre bei meinem jetzigen Arbeitgeber bleiben. Deshalb überlege ich, einen Anwalt einzuschalten. Vielleicht kann ich dadurch überhaupt erst erreichen, dass meine Akte geöffnet und bearbeitet wird. Denn mittlerweile habe ich das Gefühl, dass mein Antrag bisher noch gar nicht richtig angefasst bzw. bearbeitet wurde.

Wie sind eure Erfahrungen? Bringt es etwas, einen Anwalt zu beauftragen? Hat es euch persönlich geholfen und konnte dadurch der Einbürgerungsprozess beschleunigt werden?

Die Anwaltskosten sind schließlich auch nicht ohne, und ich weiß momentan wirklich nicht, was ich noch tun kann.

Könntet ihr bitte eure Erfahrungen mit mir teilen? Ich wäre euch sehr dankbar! 🙏


r/GermanCitizenship • • 20h ago

Other What to expect after signing Bekenntnis zur FDGO + Loyalitätserklärung?

2 Upvotes

Dear community,

I applied for german citizenship on 6.10.2026, through department S3 in Berlin.

On side, I had a PR application ongoing since April 2026, M4 paused it saying citizenship has priority over PR and they will await the decision there before deciding upon PR, as it won´t be needed if citizenship is accepted.

I pushed back asking to continue PR application as citizen can take years to come, and I wanted to secure myself legally - they said that such cases as mine are given priority and that S3 will reach out.

Also, as I was changing my appartment starting November, I sent S3 my new appartment docs

  • Updated residence permit

  • New Anmeldung

  • Health Insurance card as I forgot in my initial application

  • DRV Versicherungsverlauf showing continuous contributions since September 2018

S3 got back yesterday on 20.11.2026, asking for my October payslip and signed "Bekenntnis FDGO + Loyalitätserklärung".

I sent the documents yesterday itself. Is it reasonable to expect an "Urkunde Termin" soon?

Moreover, reading on Reddit and overall, some questions arised:

  1. For "Urkunde Termin", Do I need to remember whats written in Loyalitätserklärung?

  2. Is there going to be some sort of an interview?

  3. Is it easy to apply for fast-track passport after Urkunde? - I have to travel to my home country for my sister´s wedding mid-Jan. And my home country doesn´t allow dual citizenship.

Would be very thankful for your answers! <3


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Passport Anyone here applied for German nationality in Landkreis Göttingen ?

1 Upvotes

r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Other Turned 16 during a linked citizenship application — how much longer will it take?

3 Upvotes

One of parents and I applied for German citizenship together 2 years ago. Now that I've turned 16, they asked me to sign and submit a new application for myself.

Does anyone know if this delays things, or what my chances are of getting approved within the next year? I already got the school certificate for language proof and everything. Applied in Darmstadt/ Hessen.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Passport Am I a German Citizen?

6 Upvotes

Hi all, I was born in the United States in 2001. My dad is originally from Germany and remained a German citizen until he became a US citizen in 2004. Am I eligible to claim German citizenship/apply for a passport? Is there any difference between the two?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Obtaining Documents Where do you search to see if an ancestor registered at the German Consulate?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§14 StAG Discretionary naturalization from abroad Update regarding pre-1949 cases and StAG 5 (Houston Consulate)

11 Upvotes

Dear German citizenship subreddit,

Someone reached out to us stating that the Houston consulate approved them to submit their German citizenship through StAG 5.

Their case: Their German grandmother lost her German citizenship due to marrying a foreigner before May 23, 1949.

Her son was born before May 23, 1949, but this person was born after said date.

Apparently, the Houston consulate stated that under new guidance from the BMI applicants can apply as long as they themselves were born after May 23, 1949.

I believe this to be wrong information but wanted to know if anyone heard anything similar.

If it is wrong (which I believe), then the Houston consulate should seriously stop spreading misinformation. They also told another one of our clients that she lost her German citizenship when she automatically acquired US citizenship as a minor throughout her parent’s application, which is bogus.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization Bochum Citizenship Applications: Waiting Times & Experiences (2026)

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm getting ready to apply for German citizenship here in Bochum and would love to hear about the experiences of the fellow Bochumers (can you even say that?) with the citizenship process so far.

How long did you have to wait? How was your overall experience with the Ausländerbehörde? Any surprises, delays, or tips worth knowing?

I tried finding something online but there isn't much especially about Bochum so I thought it would be great if we could use this thread to share our timelines and experiences. Even a small update could be really helpful for someone who's just starting the process or waiting for an answer. Appreciate the help!


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§30 StAG Feststellung (Determination of German Citizenship) Number change

3 Upvotes

Should I inform BVA that I changed my phond number?
My mail is correct and also I added my brothers phone number too.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization EU Applications

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I’m applying for citizenship from an EU country, and I was surprised to see that EU applications seem to move much slower than others. https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/immigration-office/wait-times

Is there any form of de-prioritization for EU citizens? Is there anything that can be done about it (lawyer, etc.)?

I'm a bit worries that the processing time might not be completed before the government potentially changes the immigration law


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Obtaining Documents Obtaining Erweiterte Melderegisterauskunft from former German area of Poland?

2 Upvotes

My father was born in Stettin, Pomerania in 1927, and moved to the US in 1952. When I was born in 1972, he was still a German citizen and didn't become a naturalized US citizen until 1982.

I am interested in obtaining my German passport, and I am trying to gather the correct documents to take to the local embassy here in California.

I currently have:

  • his marriage certificate

  • my birth certificate

  • his certificate of naturalization

...but we could not locate his old German passport.

From what I've read here in this sub, I should be able to request an Erweiterte Melderegisterauskunft that would show he was a German national. But since he was born in what is now Poland, should I be requesting that documentation from the Polish Archive in Szcezcin? If they do have records on him, should that be sufficient documentation to bring to the embassy?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 Endlich bin ich Deutscher.

23 Upvotes

Ich bin in Rio de Janeiro und habe gerade eine Nachricht vom Konsulat erhalten, dass mein Staatsangehörigkeitsnachweis fertig ist.

Mein Aktenzeichen stammt vom Mai 2023.

Beide meine brasilianischen Eltern haben deutsche Vorfahren. Der Nachweis der Staatsangehörigkeit wird jedoch ausschließlich über die mütterliche Abstammungslinie belegt.

Obwohl es väterlicherseits eine ununterbrochene männliche Abstammungslinie gibt, die bis zu meinem deutschen Ururgroßvater zurückreicht, fehlen uns leider Dokumente, die belegen, dass die Staatsangehörigkeit über die Generationen hinweg bewahrt wurde.

Zudem fand väterlicherseits keine Vermittlung der deutschen Kultur an die nachfolgenden Generationen statt – ganz im Gegensatz zur mütterlichen Seite, wo die deutsche Sprache über verschiedene Generationen hinweg bewahrt wurde.

Die Gesetzesänderung hat nun endlich diese historische Korrektur ermöglicht; denn oft sind es gerade die Mütter, die das deutsche Kulturerbe an die nächsten Generationen weitergeben – genau jene Mütter also, denen es zuvor verwehrt war, ihre Staatsangehörigkeit zu vererben.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Naturalization (Einbürgerung) processing time in Landkreis Starnberg?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Has anyone recently applied for or received German citizenship in Landkreis Starnberg?

I'm trying to get an idea of the current processing times. How long did it take from submitting your application to receiving your citizenship certificate?

I'd also be interested in hearing from anyone who is still waiting and when they applied.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization Aachen

1 Upvotes

Has anyone in Aachen applied in November 2025 and got the mail for salary slips or urkunde?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Picked up the Einbürgerungsurkunde

28 Upvotes

berlin, S5, ukrainian

timeline: applied end of june, first contact in mid october (asked for salary statements), decision in mid november


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 Title: Need help finding a 1944 marriage record in Berlin – German citizenship case (§5 StAG)

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m hoping someone here has experience researching historical marriage records in Berlin.
I’m currently helping my mother with her German citizenship application under §5 StAG. The Bundesverwaltungsamt (BVA) is actively processing her case and has requested additional documents concerning my German grandmother.
I’m trying to locate the marriage record of my grandparents:

● Grandmother: Lore Schmitz, born 3 May 1920 in Solingen, Germany

● Grandfather: Fethi Yunis Matloub (also spelled Fathi Younis Matloub)

● Marriage date: 4 November 1944

● Marriage location: Berlin, Germany

The problem is that I don’t know which Berlin Standesamt registered their marriage or the marriage register number.
I’ve already contacted Standesamt I Berlin and the Landesarchiv Berlin. Standesamt I referred me to the Landesarchiv because the 1944 records are now archival material.
However, the Landesarchiv’s online application requires both the register number and the responsible Standesamt. I also called the archive, but they couldn’t help without this information.
I’ve searched the digitized marriage indexes, but many of the available records only go up to 1938.
I’ve also contacted Standesamt Solingen to request my grandmother’s complete birth-register extract, hoping it might contain a marginal note identifying her marriage registration. I’m currently waiting for their response.
Has anyone experienced a similar situation?
Is there another way to identify the correct Berlin Standesamt and marriage register number for a marriage in 1944? Are there any other archives, indexes or services that could help?
Any advice would be greatly appreciated. This is one of the key missing documents in my mother’s ongoing citizenship case.
Thank you so much!