Hi All, I'm looking for some advice on dealing with requests for unnecessary paperwork from my caseworker. This will be a long post, but is truly a difficult situation and I really hope some of you will stick with me here and hopefully provide some insight/advice.
Background: I live in Munich and have a StAG 5 case pending with the local KVR.
Basis of the case:
Great-grandfather: Born in Berlin 1903 (I have a certified copy of his German birth certificate, and his parent's marriage license); immigrated to USA in 1930. Naturalized as a US citizen in 1946.
Grandmother: Born in USA in 1938 (her mother was also a German citizen and naturalized in 1950); married a US citizen in 1962.
Father: Born (in-wedlock) in USA in 1964; married in 1990.
Me: Born (in-wedlock) in USA in 1994.
So, I submitted my declaration to the Munich KVR in April 2025. I provided certified copies of all relevant birth, marriage, and naturalization certificates. My grandmother never knew until recently that she inherited German citizenship from her father, so she has never had any documentation of her German citizenship...as such, the case rests on her father's pre-1914 German birth certificate.
My caseworker has been impossible to deal with (no surprise), and has only recently started working on my case after I have threatened to file an Untätigkeitsklage (since we have passed 18 months). First, he emailed me and said that he would only work on my case after I send him the Aktenzeichen from my family's case (they are applying via StAG5, Feststellung for my grandmother from the USA, straight to the BVA). I responded that they have not submitted their case yet, but that it is irrelevant because my case should be processed independently, and cannot be put on-hold indefinitely and made dependent on whether my family members abroad may or may not also submit a case. I didn't hear back after that and eventually followed up again saying that I will proceed with filing the Untätigkeitsklage.
That brings us to this week. A few days ago, my caseworker emailed me and said that I need to provide proof that my grandmother did not lose her German citizenship upon marrying a foreigner in 1962. (A few moments to let that sink in...iykyk)... I responded to him citing the German constitution, that this has been illegal according to German law since April 1, 1953, and that 1962 came after 1953, as such, she could not have lost her German citizenship upon marriage.
I mean, this person clearly doesn't understand the laws relevant to StAG 5 in any way...I'm still just speechless that I had to explain this to him (nevermind the fact that on the Munich KVR's own website, it states that StAG 5 also applies to anyone whose ancestors did lose citizenship upon marrying a foreigner before 1953... so even if that did apply to her, StAG 5 would still apply here).
Anyway, now he has emailed me saying that of course he agrees with me that she would not have lost her German citizenship upon marriage, but I still need to provide proof that she held German citizenship at the time of my father's birth in 1964. He lists acceptable proof as: "residence permits for the USA at that time, German identification documents (including your father's), certificates/confirmations from US authorities regarding his residency status in the USA at that time, etc."
My grandmother is a born US citizen and therefore has never in her life needed any kind of residence permits, and since she never knew she was a German citizen until recently, she doesn't have any German documents either. My impression is that this person is just screwing with me because I have annoyed him by threatening a lawsuit, but also that he doesn't know the relevant laws here. Honestly, I do not know how to deal with him going forward and I do not see a way to get my case actually processed. I will tell him that she was born a dual US/German citizen and therefore doesn't have any residence permit or the like, and then he will just say that he cannot process my case then.
Does anyone here have any advice of what I should do here? Is it time to hire a lawyer? I mean, if the caseworker acknowledges that my grandmother inherited German citizenship from her father and didn't lose it upon marriage, then his demands make no sense...where does it end? Even if I were to prove that she held German citizenship in 1963 after her marriage, then he can come back and say that I need to prove that she held it on the day of my father's birth in 1964, and then what is my father lost it at any time during the 30 years of his life before I was born?? We are in a real Teufelskreis here. Please help me.