r/gallifrey • u/EthanWritesStuff • Sep 24 '21
r/gallifrey • u/[deleted] • Jan 28 '17
CONFIRMED John Hurt has died aged 77
r/gallifrey • u/pcjonathan • Mar 31 '25
ANNOUNCEMENT /u/Dr_Vesuvius, moderator of 8 years, has passed away
I was emailed yesterday, by his father, that /u/Dr_Vesuvius that he passed away Thursday evening.
/u/Dr_Vesuvius has had an instrumental role in the community for several years, contributing as a moderator for here since 2016, as well as on r/DoctorWho and the Discord server for several years, and has been a huge contributor to the community as a normal member (contributing over 1.6 million words over his time!).
He liked to keep his lives separate so I'll respect that and not provide any more information, however if you wish to say a few words on the positive impact he has had, I'll be happy to collate them and pass it on to his family.
Rest in peace.
r/gallifrey • u/[deleted] • Jul 28 '22
NEWS Bernard Cribbins has died aged 93
r/gallifrey • u/ECR115 • Aug 09 '20
AUDIO NEWS Big Finish - Christopher Eccelston returns as the Ninth Doctor
r/gallifrey • u/DrummingUpInterest2 • Jun 01 '25
SPOILER The longer I think about the Poppy stuff the more it makes me deeply uncomfortable about where RTD's politics have gone Spoiler
So let's talk about that finale shall we.
Poppy is the result of Conrad's fake reality, the one that specifically erases LGBT+ people/identities from existence and also views women as belonging at home with children. Now it could be argued this is the result of Conrad's lack of a two-parent household (which is a whole discussion unto itself) but at the end of the day, her "creation" is still born from a world where Fifteen has their sexuality erased and Belinda loses her independence.
So when both The Doctor and Belinda regain their memories of what is reality they aren't horrified, outraged, or in any way upset at being forced into 50s-style heteronormative gender roles but instead want to do everything they can to "protect" this fictional baby they insist is theirs is bad enough. The fact this then goes on to see Belinda spending most of the "battle" sat in a box taking care of the child is worse.
But then we get to the entire final act where reality corrects itself and Poppy disappears as both The Doctor and Belinda are removed of the lingering influence of Conrad's politics. Only no, wait a minute, we get a big speech from Ruby about how The Doctor would always try and save a child (ignoring for some reason that she's imaginary and the result of bigotry at that) which prompts this Doctor to decide to change the fabric of reality itself so that Belinda always had his child, even if it costs him his own life.
And Belinda is okay with this. The same Belinda who brings up her lack of consent about getting a DNA scan is okay with her own history being changed into forced motherhood. Seriously?!
For all the talk of this era being "woke" this finale is one of the more bizarrely Tory "family values" style plot you could write. Conrad becomes a good person because he has a father in the picture. The same-sex attracted Doctor is shown to prefer his "wish" of a child with Belinda so abandons his male love in what appears to be hell, to the point of killing himself to make it so and is clearly disappointed Poppy isn't biologically his. Belinda is shown to be in a more stable and happy situation as a co-parenting mother (with the father still in the picture) living at home with mum and dad compared to the grotty flatshare as the childless independent woman she was before.
r/gallifrey • u/biblicalbullworm • Jun 02 '25
SPOILER (Character)’s inclusion in the finale was genuinely harmful Spoiler
Rose (Donna’s daughter) was only in the finale for them to make a comment about her gender. Awful.
She’s not even a character at this point, she’s a political point whose only trait is being trans. They give her nothing else.
I hated how she was only in this episode for the doctor to say “conservatives hate trans ppl” and then she disappeared into the background.
Trans rights are extremely important, but making her nothing but a message rather than a regular character is actively harmful rather than progressive.
Same thing goes for shirley, most of the time her inclusion comes down to her disability.
r/gallifrey • u/BeanoTown-23 • Dec 24 '23
DISCUSSION What do you think of Idris Elba saying he doesn't want Ncuti Gatwa's Fifteenth Doctor to be defined as "the black Doctor"?
"Earlier this month Ncuti, 31, claimed he would be bringing his “beautiful blackness” to the role."
"Idris said: “I don’t think the fact he is black makes any difference at all. It doesn’t even need to be mentioned."
“It’s like when I was being linked with the Bond role. I was getting called the ‘first black Bond’ when in truth my colour had nothing to do with if I was suitable for the role or not."
"Don’t call Ncuti ‘the black Doctor’ as it insinuates that it had anything to do with him getting the job. He got the job because he was the best qualified to play The Doctor – and that['s] it what we need to be talking about."
"It’s great for Ncuti that he has got one of the most iconic roles on British TV and I am sure he is going to smash it.”
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/entertainment/celebrity/idris-elba-doesnt-want-ncuti-31735179
r/gallifrey • u/mc564 • May 08 '22
SPOILER Major casting announcement from the BBC Spoiler
r/gallifrey • u/TimesandSundayTimes • Feb 24 '25
NEWS Jodie Whittaker: ‘I didn’t fit the mould for Doctor Who’
r/gallifrey • u/InitialApricot6824 • Oct 23 '21
DISCUSSION The thing that bothers me most about Chibnall Who, way more than the Timeless Child or the shallow characterization, is the removal of the Doctor's agency. Which *especially* rankles me as it's the first woman Doctor. I think Chibnall's characterization of 13 is straight up sexist.
I'm gonna be honest- I don't particularly care about the Timeless Child- honestly I'm not a big enough nerd to get bothered about it. And I am merely disappointed, and not angry, about the lackluster dialogue, characterization.
What does make me actually angry and resentful is the awful r/menwritingwomen type stuff. For what it's worth I don't think it stems from any malice and I don't think it's intentional sexism at all- I do think it's subconscious and just incompetence, or perhaps just a fundamentally different vision of who the Doctor is. But that doesn't change the fact that the first woman Doctor has been written to be far more passive, far less competent and with far less agency than all of her predecessors, especially in NewWho.
The 13th Doctor isn't treated the same way as her predecessors. The previous Doctors were allowed to be demigods hulking over the plot- they had boatloads of agency, they were allowed to have the spotlight, they were allowed to actually be competent.
13 on the other hand is far too passive. Her agency is often removed. Side characters are allowed to usurp her spotlight (usually men). Some examples:
Revolution of the Daleks: The Doctor is imprisoned by Judoon. How does she escape? Well, she doesn't. She sits around apparently doing nothing for (going by the markings on the wall) decades until she's rescued by a man. There is no indication that she even tried anything. No, The Doctor was reduced to a damsel in distress waiting to be saved by a man (Jack Harkness). Hell, even during the rescue she entirely follows his lead, and they even have Jack do the 'hand grab + run' thing- that's the Doctor's thing! This whole sequence robs the Doctor of any agency or competency. Compare this to 12's imprisonment in Heaven Sent.
(Not)Trump's lack of punishment by the Doctor- To keep this post brief I will link Giga Who's quick rant about this. A snippet: " Why tease us with the Doctor’s anger, the suggestion that she wants to actually do something about Robertson this time, only to instantly drop it all in a manner that accentuates her inaction?" TL;DR: She utterly fails to take Robertson to task for his shittiness with the Daleks or the spiders. Compare that to 10 destroying Harriet Jones' government- was that a good thing to do? Maybe not, but it showed agency on 10's part, compared to 13's usual impotent inaction.
One of the reasons people like Ruth is that she actually does have agency: I don't think Ruth's actor bested Whittaker (well, maybe she did but that's not the whole picture)- Ruth actually had agency- regardless of how good or bad her ultimate plan was, she actually had a plan, she actually affected the plot in a meaningful way when she squared up against the Judoon and Gat. What did 13 do in the midst of all this? Well, as usual she stood there passively taking it all in with a horrified expression.
Pretty much all of Timeless Children: She does essentially nothing this entire episode. She literally sits paralysed while other actors (the Master, the Cyberzealot, hell even the companions) actually do stuff. She instead just receives a lore dump. And even worse is standing aside while Ko Sharmus sacrificed himself. Characters sacrifice themselves for the Doctor all the time, but it's always involuntary and for good reason- the Doctor (well, except 13 apparently) would never let a good person sacrifice themselves while they could do it instead. To have her voluntarily stand aside and back away from the challenge while Ko Sharmus takes lead is just completely insulting. There really is no reasoning for what she did other than "I don't want to sacrifice my life so I will let you, a good person, do it instead" which imo runs completely counter to everything about the Doctor.
There are more examples but you get the gist.
Honestly I think it crosses the line into sexism, intentional or not. I don't think Chibnall is a sexist person- in fact I think he's a very well intentioned & good person at heart. But whatever the reason, the end result is very bad, especially for the first woman Doctor.
I was deeply excited about the first woman Doctor- I've been watching since 4's era and I've always believed that the Doctor could be a woman as well. It is thus genuinely depressing to me, more than any Timeless Child nonsense, that the first woman Doctor has been written in such an insulting manner. And I also think it's important to be clear that 13 sucks not because of "SJW-nonsense" or whatever, but rather old fashioned sexist portrayals of woman characters. This whole fiasco to me proves why there needs to be more strong woman characters in media.
r/gallifrey • u/Stonkmarketcommie420 • Jan 03 '24
DISCUSSION Wow series one is very “woke”
Been rewatching series one recently and realised that if it was released today the usual suspects would lose their minds. Jack is unapologetically bisexual and not subtle about it (they even have a joke of him having a laser up his arse). The doctor is drops a line about how stealing from the rich families is “Marxism in action”. Henry van Statten is literally Elon musk. So when everyone’s complaining about how woke doctor who is now remember that is what brought the show back in 2005.
r/gallifrey • u/JamesBrennecke • Feb 27 '25
NEWS Disney calls Dr Who "a top 5 series on Disney+ globally every week it aired" & a "one of the biggest programmes for the [under 35's] demographic across all streamers and broadcasters"
r/gallifrey • u/Disorder79 • May 16 '25
RUMOUR NEWS: DOCTOR WHO WILL CONTINUE WITH FURTHER SERIES ON BBC ONE, IRRESPECTIVE OF DISNEY DECISION
r/gallifrey • u/Magister_Xehanort • 13d ago
MISC Doctor Who star Peter Capaldi says the BBC "doesn't really understand" the show: "It needs love" - The Twelfth Doctor favourite also reveals that he was approached about joining tenders.
r/gallifrey • u/amplified_cactus • Jun 04 '24
NEWS William Russell has died
r/gallifrey • u/BearEatingToast • Sep 20 '24
NEWS Original Dalek voice actor, David Graham, has passed away at 99
r/gallifrey • u/Electronic_Total_922 • Jun 01 '25
SPOILER Disney leaving is deserved. Spoiler
If I were promised a fresh jumping on point for new viewers, only for the first three episodes to be desperate fan service featuring two returning actors in an attempt to appeal to tapped out fans, followed by SPACE BABIES and the return of CGI villains only die-hards will recognize, completely sabotaging any chance of successfully marketing the show, I’d be pissed too.
If RTD2 is anything, it’s a bunch of well written STUPID deas. The definitive article of being creatively bankrupt along with pathetic desperation. I can’t believe they brought Billie back to spite Ncuti like that. RTD is doing the exact thing he did with the 60th. Bring back a fan favorite to convince people to tune it. And it will work! Because you’ll believe the desperate PR campaign that Ncuti was always going to do 2 seasons as if D+ didn’t leak an image from the original ending of this season…
For the best. Ncuti’s talent is deserved elsewhere. In more competent projects.
r/gallifrey • u/[deleted] • Jan 22 '16
NEWS Steven Moffat quits Doctor Who - To be replaced by Chris Chibnall.
r/gallifrey • u/prisongovernor • Apr 01 '25
SPOILER ‘Woke’ criticism of Doctor Who proves show on right track, says its newest star
r/gallifrey • u/ConstructionPutrid34 • Jan 26 '25
META Proposal to ban Social Media site X
Twitter has in the past been an incredibly active and useful part of the overall Doctor Who fanbase. Yes, as discourse shifted in the 2010s, it became a less pleasant space to spend time on, but that is nothing compared to what happened when it was bought out in 2022 by Musk.
Aside from the rename to the far more generic X, the website formerly known as Twitter became progressively less and less moderated when it came to far right discussions, while at the same time a lot more rife with misinformation as Musk devalued the Blue Check Marks.
Given everything Musk has done over the past year and indeed, just recently when he gave two Nazi Salutes in a row, it has become increasingly difficult to separate Xitter from the far right allignment of its new owner. As such there is a growing movement on various Subreddits to ban links to Xitter overall, whether they be sports, anime or comic books. Subreddits such as r/Bleach, r/One Piece, r/DCcomics, r/Marvel and r/comicbooks have all taken the plunge while further subreddits have their mod teams actively discussing it.
I feel that a fandom like Doctor Who is fundamentally incompatible with what Xitter has become just like these other subreddits to the point that I would like open up this discussion. Can we ban X as well?
If people do want to post tweets from X, there have been discussions on these other subreddits to instead use Screenshots over links to discourage traffic. Or encourage the use of Social Media like Bluesky which many former Twitter users are moving over to. These options aren't perfect, but this is a bad situation overall.
Just keep in mind though that if you feel that someone is arguing in bad faith, whether they are agreeing with you or not, try not to engage with them. As people used to say "Don't feed the trolls."
r/gallifrey • u/macshordo • Nov 14 '13
50th ANNIVERSARY The Night Of The Doctor: A Mini Episode - Doctor Who: The Day of the Doctor Prequel - BBC
r/gallifrey • u/FinnsChips • Sep 15 '19
NEWS Christopher Eccleston comes out about anorexia struggles almost driving him to suicide while filming Doctor Who
r/gallifrey • u/ComprehensiveHyena10 • Jan 18 '24
DISCUSSION Why won't people leave Peter Capaldi alone?
Once again he's out promoting a new show and once again people won't stop asking him about Doctor Who.
He's been clear time and time again that he's never coming back. He's also been clear that while he enjoyed playing the role he was not happy with all of the extra responsibilities that come with it.
So why does it seem to be impossible for (some) people to accept his word and just let him get on with his life?
r/gallifrey • u/TemporalSpleen • Feb 05 '24