r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Dec 17 '25

Start Here: A compilation of posts and articles

Post image
83 Upvotes

If you are new here, or just wanting to see the “best of” to help you understand what’s really going on with Free Birth Society, here is a list of user-recommend posts to check out. We will be adding to this list periodically.

If you see posts or other resources you think should be here, please alert them to us via the mod mail.

Results of a year long investigation by The Guardian

The 6 part Podcast series The Birth Keepers
Apple podcast link
Spotify link
(Excellently done, with a lot of sensitivity and care)

Main longford investigative journalism Guardian article

Additional Guardian articles

Additional articles

 I brainwashed myself with the Internet (from 2020, still relevant)

Unpacking Emilee and Yolande

Birth Stories

Personal Stories from people who were up close

Culty red flags


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Dec 17 '25

The Guardian articles and podcast

Post image
76 Upvotes

Here are all the articles and podcasts from a year-long investigation by Guardian Journalists Sirin Kale and Lucy Osborne

(posting this to be able to pin it to the top)


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 4d ago

Loss Twins' death after freebirth could have been avoided, inquest hears.

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
48 Upvotes

The mother states she wouldn’t change her decisions despite the outcome of both babies dying.

RIP to those precious baby boys 💖💖


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 5d ago

Birth of Neon George

27 Upvotes

Yolande sent out a Substack, about Neon's birth. As had been suspected, it was not complication or pain-free - that's what she states in the few opening sentences. I don't have access to read the full story. Does anyone? Can somebody share more of what went down?


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 6d ago

Emilee trying SO HARD to put a villain in this story.

Post image
18 Upvotes

Emilee’s rhetoric is actually quite strong on this one. She’s trying so hard to make midwifery care evil when the guest just isn’t meeting her there and seeing things from a much more realistic perspective. It’s actually quite awkward to listen to Emilee here. I ALMOST feel bad for how unhinged she’s being.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 9d ago

Dragging the religious sexual purity shame and fear BS into the birth space 🤮

Post image
56 Upvotes

Another unhinged rant revealing her hatred for literally every woman who engages with her! I hate the eternal insistence from Emilee and Yolande that everything is rape, all of your providers are perverts, etc. This rhetoric scares women out of getting necessary care when things go wrong. Everybody who isn’t brainwashed understands that it’s appropriate for “strangers” to touch your “private parts” to ensure the safety and survival of you and your baby. Yolande’s using the Christian sexual purity conditioning that our culture has imposed on us and conditioning women to be traumatized by every little thing. The complete opposite of empowering. And of course they’re there with a debrief to make sure the trauma really sticks. Yeah, unnecessary touching = bad. Agreed. This is so stupid though. Also stupid, a birth educator saying “private parts” to adult women 🥴


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 10d ago

Action Guardian Journalist Request.

56 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

Sirin Kale, half duo of the fantastic journalists that covered the investigation on FBS last year, and handled the interviews with great sensitivity - is asking pls for any Australian freebirth women who knew Stacey Warnecke - to pls get in touch with her. Thank you.

[email protected]

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/jun/15/stacey-warnecke-melbourne-wellness-influencer-home-birth-hours-before-death-triple-zero-call-ntwnfb


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 14d ago

Feeling angry that “mama sita” has the gall to beg for money and play victim when she has contributed to newborn deaths and caused birth trauma in vulnerable women.

Post image
39 Upvotes

Just needed to vent here. I’m so sick of these self-righteous frauds! Here is the ABC article where she was named

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-11-21/sovereign-birthkeepers-in-freebirthing-putting-lives-at-risk/104528640?utm_source=abc_news_app&utm_medium=content_shared&utm_campaign=abc_news_app&utm_content=safari

What happens to their “ sovereign, your body will provide, the system can’t control me” attitude when the law comes knocking. They love playing playing faux shaman,
but you playing make belief is costing real lives so now you can pay the price. You left women and babies on their own to suffer - now you can suffer on the stand alone.

Rant over.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 15d ago

Births Gone Wrong A 180 on their view of the system.

Post image
33 Upvotes

Today’s email


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 17d ago

Scam Programs Cost of new program "Lemonade"

21 Upvotes

Y'all...it's 3k. I got the email and scrolled through all the fluff just to see the outrageous cost. Bonus though you get a free year in the lighthouse, a $500 value. Just, wow.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 17d ago

Journalist request

21 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am a reporter with The Sun in the UK. I am working on a story examining the online freebirth movement - specifically focusing on the dangerous advice and cult-like tactics within the Free Birth Society and its network of unregulated "birth keepers."

A core part of this piece is highlighting the real human cost and holding the leadership accountable. I am hoping to connect with mothers or families who suffered a loss, a life-threatening near-miss, or trauma after following advice from FBS or an associated birth keeper.

I understand how sensitive and complex these experiences are and therefore we can offer anonymity as well as any other concessions to ensure participants are comfortable sharing their story.   

If you feel you are able to to share, please feel free to send me a direct message or reach out via [email protected] 

Thank you for your time.

Anna


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 18d ago

So many e mails lately!!

11 Upvotes

Omg anyone notice emilee sending out so many e mails lately its driving me nuts I finally.had to un subscribe!


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 19d ago

Done with many influencers

49 Upvotes

I feel like after seeing how FBS is a scam I am kinda bothered by so many holistic and natural living influencers. I feel like during 2020 I felt isolated and wanted to find like minded people so I started following all these accounts but now I find many annoying, pompous and egocentric- can anyone relate? Especially the ones selling courses which they have no expertise and just repeat material from other people. Like no- I am not interested in your woman’s retreat in Colombia which you aren’t even from to learn all about your golden superior perspective on life.

For example At first I thought GMN was interesting but then it got culty. Like the internet is such a breeding ground for these extreme thought groups.

Like I said at first I gravitated towards these groups because I felt so rejected by society and wanted to belong. I guess that how cults get ya. But now I really do feel like I learned. I would rather have my algorithm be recipes and dogs and leave my learning to my books and perhaps some podcasts which I guess you also have to be careful with too.

Also- I wanted to add that I am not on Instagram all the time lol


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 23d ago

Parable of the downing man

20 Upvotes

the latest podcast episode has me thinking about this parable:

A storm descends on a small town, and the downpour soon turns into a flood. As the waters rise, the local preacher kneels in prayer on the church porch, surrounded by water. By and by, one of the townsfolk comes up the street in a canoe.

"Better get in, Preacher. The waters are rising fast."

"No," says the preacher. "I have faith in the Lord. He will save me."

Still the waters rise. Now the preacher is up on the balcony, wringing his hands in supplication, when another guy zips up in a motorboat.

"Come on, Preacher. We need to get you out of here. The levee's gonna break any minute."

Once again, the preacher is unmoved. "I shall remain. The Lord will see me through."

After a while the levee breaks, and the flood rushes over the church until only the steeple remains above water. The preacher is up there, clinging to the cross, when a helicopter descends out of the clouds, and a state trooper calls down to him through a megaphone.

"Grab the ladder, Preacher. This is your last chance."

Once again, the preacher insists the Lord will deliver him.

And, predictably, he drowns.

A pious man, the preacher goes to heaven. After a while he gets an interview with God, and he asks the Almighty, "Lord, I had unwavering faith in you. Why didn't you deliver me from that flood?"

God shakes his head. "What did you want from me? I sent you two boats and a helicopter."


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 24d ago

Do you feel guilty yet?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

The Orthodox/Christian grift is reaching a fever pitch. From the comments, it seems like grieving Orthodox moms are their only remaining audience. I wonder how many of them have experienced stillbirth as a result of following FBS, I’m sure many of them we don’t even know about. It’s so heartbreaking to see these women pour their grief out to such uncaring and money hungry people as Yolande and Emilee.

According to this latest podcast from FBS, it’s obsessive and controlling to want information. Strangers will “speak” death and illness over your baby if you get an ultrasound. You won’t get “miracles” if you obsess like this. It’s not Christian to be obsessed with control.

I wish I could wave a wand to break the spell.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 26d ago

Podcast series discussing FBS, Freebirth, and The Guardian series

15 Upvotes

I came across a series of podcast episodes on the Return to Wisdom podcast by Keshia Tognazzini, discussing FBS, freebirth in general, the media attention they’ve gotten, etc. She interviews some big names like Dr. Stu, Dr. Melanie Jackson, and others, and I’ve really enjoyed the generally very balanced and thought-provoking discussions. There are a number of episodes but here’s the link to one of them. https://open.spotify.com/episode/4wrHLG9w1Pk6ATHlM35uLM?si=YyPprCLRSDeUy3_XBH8qNQ&utm_source=copy-link


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 26d ago

Copyright warning

36 Upvotes

A screenshot I had posted of something Yo shared on her public instagram story a couple weeks ago was taken down by Reddit due to, well,
“A third party submitted a copyright takedown notice” was the exact sentence.

So much for them claiming they never come here?

I can post the screenshots of what Reddit sent me if anyone wants but that’s the gist od it.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 26d ago

Doula in Australia was influenced by FBS

31 Upvotes

"A Victorian inquest has heard a disturbing recording of wellness influencer Stacey Warnecke asking birth keeper Emily Lal whether she was “dying or” simply having a difficult time during childbirth.

Warnecke died on September 29, 2025, after suffering a fatal postpartum hemorrhage following a home birth without medical assistance. Her baby son, Axel, survived.

During a phone conversation played to the Coroners Court of Victoria, Warnecke asked for reassurance, saying: “Am I okay?” and “Am I dying or am I right?”

The inquest heard Warnecke had paid Lal $6,000 for antenatal sessions, birth support and six weeks of postpartum care.

Counsel assisting the coroner alleged the recording contradicted evidence Lal had previously given about her role in supporting Warnecke.

The court also heard allegations that Lal encouraged women to remain committed to home births, even when labor became difficult, and discouraged seeking hospital care.

Counsel assisting the coroner has recommended that Lal be referred to the Director of Public Prosecutions over possible perjury and other offenses. The recommendation does not mean charges have been laid, and the coroner has yet to deliver findings.

The inquest heard that Warnecke died from postpartum hemorrhage, a complication that counsel assisting argued could have been treated had medical assistance been available."

This particular doula was heavily influenced by The Freebirth Society which is essentially a cult. A very different species to homebirths overseen by professional midwives, or down-to-earth freebirthers who are experienced, well-prepared and have all contingencies in place.

Also this doula blew off cautions from other doulas who tried to warn her about extremism in The Freebirth Society and conspiracy theories during Covid. Sadly, those warnings were not heeded.

This recording shows that Lal was not entirely honest and this could have repercussions for her.

Stacey died a month before my own daughter had a 2L haemorrhage with her first baby. She very nearly lost her uterus & her life. I'm supportive of women's decisions to FB, but in this case I paid for my daughter to have professional homebirth midwives. They literally saved her life. And the hospital was 5 minutes away. When I think of what happened with my daughter, how I grieve for beautiful Stacey.

Lal might have become an extremist even without the influence of FBS - who knows - but it sure didn't help.

So here's an example of FBS causing harm even as far away as Australia.

Reminds me of the Born in Zion cult with Carol Balizet. A mother & baby died in Perth because of Balizet's extremist teachings. That was back in the 1990s.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 27d ago

Joys and Celebrations Thread

43 Upvotes

In honor of getting this subreddit back, I thought it might be fun for us to share some good things that have happened in our lives since leaving FBS.

Maybe you were able to birth on your terms (whatever your terms may be) or maybe you found a supportive group of women (who don't just want your money) or found a midwifery or a doula program that aligns with your values?

I'll start...

After previously only taking online herbalism classes, I just graduated this summer from a local herbalism apprenticeship along with a dozen amazing other women from all walks of life. Our main teacher has a successful clinical practice and herbal business without being overly online and that has been such a breath of fresh air for me after spending too much time in the Instagram herbal world. It was a good reminder that there are a lot of amazing women out there doing great things but often they aren't using social media much (if at all).


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • 29d ago

We have our sub back!

136 Upvotes

Hey everyone🥰welcome back!!

This is such fantastic news having our original sub returned into safe hands!

Here are the new mods:

u/Lavendar_Sapphire
u/Electrical_Iron_7619
u/AntDecent1229
u/beautifulrabbithole
u/corpsesdecompose
..and me :)

Please feel free to ask us anything!

We’ll keep the rules the same as the original mod.

There are many of us here and our political and social demographics and opinions may vary, but we’re united by one common purpose.

Let’s stay focused on the topic at hand - Freebirth Society’s $cammy ways - so that the general public wanting to learn more about FBS can easily access.

Let’s also remember that this is a Freebirth friendly sub!

Hope everyone has a wonderful weekend 😎❤️


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 29 '26

Is anyone listening to her new episodes? I’m annoyed.

67 Upvotes

I was listening to the Abbey episode today and when she’s talking about how she was thankful her mom was there to help her with the breast pump after birth, Emily acted like such a jerk and was like, “Why do you need a pump I’m not following?” And the guest was like “she (the newborn) was not getting milk out, does that make sense?” and Emily kept digging in and was like “but what does the pump have to do with it?” And the guest seemed a bit irritated and was like “I pumped milk into a bottle, and she took a bottle because she needs to eat something” and Emily dismissively says “gotcha.”

It just felt like Emily was throwing shade at her using a breast pump to help her baby feed, like a breast pump is a product of The System™️ and shouldn’t be used.

This is the most minor of all of the problems I have with this podcast/episode in general but it was such a weird interaction and I needed to vent about it somewhere


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 24 '26

New sub

39 Upvotes

alright everyone, I went ahead and created

https://www.reddit.com/r/Freebirthsocietytruth/

lets make this a cooperative community and continue the original vision created here. I'm happy to add the suggested community members as mods if they agree to it. please, let's all be civil and transparent and agree to redirect people here, to make this a thriving community. I'm open to receiving any feedback or thoughts.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 24 '26

New moderator nominations

34 Upvotes

As requested on a comment from my last post, I'm willing to go ahead and make this post - let's talk about who is a trusted member who we may nominate as a mod. Thoughts, everyone? I'm thinking initially of therealdirtystyle, I really appreciate the ways she has contributed to this community and I trust her integrity and association with this mission.

(Since I have a new username (different email) than I have used originally, I understand why I may not be a nomination. However, I am happy to share my identity if chosen- I have been in the original facebook group since the beginning, then "the membership" and left in 2020 before it became "the lighthouse" and the giant price increase. I am a freebirthing mother of 2 (emilee did not influence my decision, my first birth was in 2020, but I did find community through it), author, and am on a journey of unpacking all the ways I've been influenced by fbs dogma. I was active on insta and some of you may know who I am, but have since deactivated it all after my 2nd birth and am done trying to be an online influencer person).

Let's continue to keep reporting what's been going on. I don't know if we have any influence over a new mod nomination but we need to try.

If this post gets deleted, we know we have a big issue of censorship on our hands. Any mod should care that the community DOES NOT want them and step down with integrity, especially in a community like this.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 24 '26

Anyway….

12 Upvotes

Biggest news in Free Birth Society history is supposed to come out today according to ES.
What do we think it is.?


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 24 '26

Free birth “study”

2 Upvotes

Do you think her own loss and the losses of the women she is personally responsible for be included? Isn’t a big tenant of free birth to be free of data and trust your intuition. What will the data say and will they even trust it?