I have nothing but respect for the mods and the women who’ve shared their experiences here, so if this is out of line or not relevant, please remove.
I do believe there’s a very real possibility that Emilee, Yolande, and FBS were unwittingly used - monitored, amplified, covertly supported, and possibly funded - as naive assets in a strategic PsyOp to sow dissidence throughout, and ultimately derail, a growing birth autonomy and medical freedom movement in a post-covid world.
Most successful influence operations don’t start with an intelligence agency planting someone. They work by identifying an existing extreme figure or group and allowing them to gain visibility through subtly amplifying their most polarizing messages. The final stage is a very public scandal and self-destruction that generates public support for increased government regulation. They are essentially set up to run themselves off a cliff. Again, the group doesn’t have to know they’re being used. If anything, the best “assets” are the ones who believe fully in what they’re doing.
FBs exploded in visibility in a way that naturally drew attention. It positioned itself at the extreme end of the birth-autonomy spectrum: no prenatal care, anti-midwife rhetoric, spiritual-will-over material-circumstances-dogma, framing all medical systems as predatory, etc. Their content made them clickable, controversial, algorithm-friendly, and easy to amplify. Even without intentional interference, groups like this get pushed by platforms because conflict equals engagement. But that also makes them perfect targets for narrative steering, and in the age of social media and technical surveillance, this is easier to do than ever before.
The business model itself strikes me as unusually profitable. Over $13 million since 2018 does not seem normal for a grassroots birth movement. It’s entirely natural to wonder, who is really funding this? Who is benefiting? Why this level of scale? I have zero qualms with entrepreneurship, but a hyper-commercial wing of a supposedly anti-institution movement, growing at a rapid-fire pace, raises my suspicion - especially considering the products that were for sale. An online “midwifery” school that cost more than double what many other programs were charging and taught zero practical or lifesaving skills? All while they were making fraudulent claims about their experience without offering any kind of evidence to corroborate? No photos of them at births? No reviews or accounts from women whose births they attended? All while any criticisms of the programs offered or the dogma behind them failed to gain any real traction until very recently? All while babies were dying?
Intelligence agencies operate in the trillions with virtually no oversight. Is it really out-of-pocket to wonder if perhaps not every account that purchased an FBS course was a traumatized victim of the medical industrial complex or a woman seeking to change the birth landscape and who fell for the slick messaging? It would be very easy to do. It would be very hard to prove. It would be the most convenient way to fund the movement while emboldening its leaders to create even more polarizing messaging and take more risks because they’d believe it’s actually gaining popular traction. Inflating their hubris and setting them up for the downfall.
That downfall, although entirely justified, is suspiciously useful. Medical freedom conversations were growing. Women were questioning institutional birth, and home birth interest has been exploding. From my perspective, it has felt like we’ve been right on the precipice of genuine nuance in these topics to enter the public consciousness in a way we haven’t seen before. And it just so happens that now FBS has imploded in a dramatic, reputation-destroying scandal through a legacy media outlet, and the social media stronghold that seemed to have kept them buoyed for so long is evaporating.
What is the outcome? The entire freebirth movement has been tarnished, and home birth on the whole will probably be the next target for public outrage. The discourse on all sides is rife with emotion, making the landscape very fertile for introducing more regulation and oversight. The broader birth-autonomy movement loses credibility in the public eye because the loudest, most extreme faction somehow wound up with the biggest megaphone. This is a classic pattern in influence ops: amplify an extreme subgroup, let them crash, use the crash to discredit the entire movement. And that’s exactly what happened.
TL;DR
I believe it's very possible that Emilee and Yolande ended up functioning as stooges for the very institutions they claim to oppose, not because they were intentionally collaborating, but because their personalities, messaging style, and escalating extremism made them extremely easy to use.