r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Nov 22 '25

The Guardian Article is Officially Here

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
664 Upvotes

And I think they did a very good job overall covering the entirety the situation. The fact that they’ve been able to audit their earnings really demonstrates to me the depth of their money making machine. They didn’t care about anyone at all. They didn’t care about you or your babies, but they loved your money.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 28 '25

Financial Exploitation I was the first woman Emilee Saldaya lured out to her land - this is what really happened

421 Upvotes

My name is Paula Williams and I was the first woman to live on Emilee Saldaya's land in Hayesville, North Carolina in 2021.

This started at her house a year prior at a sleepover gathering of women from the Free Birth Society membership that she invited me to, where she proposed the idea to me:

"You could totally put a yurt on my land."

We discussed it further and she shared how.

"I want yurts on my land as rental properties, I just don't have the capital to build them all at once."

(She also made this same pitch to another woman in the Free Birth Society membership and Radical Birth Keeper school)

We agreed that I would be financially responsible for all expenses and that should I choose to leave, she'd buy me out because she wanted yurt rental properties on her land. Other women at her house overheard our conversations.

When I moved out to North Carolina in early 2021, Emilee had cleared 2 spots in the woods behind her main house for my yurt and hers.

Early that summer I offered to help Emilee buy the acreage next door so she could realize her dream of having a festival and a place for retreats, and lent her $50,000, with interest, which she did pay me back that July.

In the fall I realized living with Emilee was not healthy. She does not live in peace. She is vindictive. Emilee loves to talk shit about everyone, her friends, supposed best friends, Free Birth society members, mothers, Radical Birth Keeper students, coaching clients, business partner, hired singer, sister, brother, dad, EVERYONE. She does not work through relationship challenges with integrity. She does not take accountability. Emilee loves being in the comments on Instagram. Emilee loves gossip and lives for drama. She is not easy nor enjoyable to be around, there was no joy. Emilee has no hobbies, no love of life. She has no vibrancy, no vitality. It's very heavy to be around her.

Since August Emilee knew that I had been supporting a woman 2 hours away in Chattanooga during her pregnancy and this was to be my first birth as newly minted radical birth keeper (I was in her 2020 class). She was due sometime in December or January so I'd planned to take a small vacation from October 27 - November 14.

On October 22nd I requested a meeting with her and Jonny to discuss my desire to leave Hayesville. To which she said:

"Of course we'll buy you out. I don't have that much cash to pay you so we'll have to figure some sort of payment plan or something. Maybe a balloon payment?"

I let her know that I was on call for my first birth through January and was in no rush. I wanted to bring up this discussion now so we had ample time to come to an agreement. I told them that in my mind, I'd wrap up my first birth in December or January and then move out in March.

A few days later on the 24th, Jonny texted me to meet with them again. And he also said to:

"Please come with a number that you think is a far payout price"

On Tuesday the 26th we met on her porch and Emilee asked how much I'd like for the yurt. I said $95,000 (cost was $100,000). She then invented a story that I was the most self absorbed person she's ever met and listed off reasons to convince me she was right. We ended the meeting with them agreeing to discuss a counter offer so we could negotiate and come to an agreement.

I left for vacation the next day and the following night, Thursday the 28th, Emilee texted me to call her. When she started talking she expressed that she felt bad about the way things had ended in our last meeting and wanted to assure me that she was committed to working this out. She asked if I'd be interested in renting out the yurt and taking part of the rental income as payment. I said no, I didn't want to structure repayment based off rental income. She said ok, that her and Jonny were going to come back to the table with an offer.

Two days later, on October 30, 2021, I received an email from Jonny and Emilee with this bullet point:

-You referenced a conversation, or perhaps it was a marco [polo], with Emilee prior to moving here, where she may have said something along the lines of, “If it doesn’t work out, I’ll buy your yurt”. While Emilee has no distinct memory of saying that, of course it’s possible that she did say such a thing. However, casually throwing out an idea in one phone conversation, in no way makes it a formal agreement. If us buying your yurt was critical to your decision to move here, it would have been your responsibility to make this a clear agreement, in writing. Because for us, it certainly wasn’t critical, and still isn’t."

Jonny & Emilee ended the email with:

"We don’t want your physical property. That was never our offer nor our expectation. You chose to invest in these things and they remain yours to deal with.

Because your yurt and its accoutrements are yours, you are welcome to sell all of it. We don’t want any of it. You are also welcome to leave what you wish, and we will deal with it after your departure.

Please keep us up to date on your plans and ensure that whatever you’re taking with you is off the property by November 30th, 2021, which is effectively the expiration date of our offer to share land with you."

I requested a meeting in person upon my return because they somehow believed agreeing to buying me out, asking me what my starting price was, agreeing to come back to negotiate and then saying, oops, it ain't in writing so it don't count was something a person of sound mind - or radical responsibility - would do. So I held a tiny amount of hope that they were responsible enough to take accountability for their mistake and come to the table with an actual offer.

At the meeting she told me she had never made that agreement and I was making it up in my head.

On Thanksgiving weekend Emilee sent me the following email:

"We wanted to give you a heads up that per our previous email sent October 30th, giving you until Nov 30th to remove yourself and your property, we will be filing an eviction on December 1st, 2021 with the local courthouse. As of Dec 1st, should you still be here, you’ll be criminally trespassing, and a sheriff will come here to serve you. On Tuesday, your invitation to stay on our land has expired as has your period to vacate."

Emilee had me served with an eviction on December 2, 2021.

And now I'm on call for my first birth, and Emilee knew that.

I found a local attorney and he advised me to file a lawsuit to stay the eviction.

Shortly after filing Emilee cut off the internet to my yurt. This was the only phone and internet access I had, so I had no way to be reached for the first birth I was to attend as one of her radical birth keepers 2 hours away. What a mentor. What a sister. This is what matriarchy looks like. This is how you walk with integrity. This is definitely above the line. This is how one moves through the world as a sovereign being. What an example!

She then lied to women in the Free Birth Society membership about me all the while she began construction on her yurt rental property that would be rented to another woman in the the Free Birth Society membership, and who ended up leaving with her and her family under duress not too long after she moved in.

My attorney strongly advised me to not move out of the yurt or it could be construed as abandonment. I had to stay.

I lived through a nightmare every fucking day.

She lied to my face about buying my yurt, makes up stories in her head and spreads them around and gaslights me - what the fuck else is she capable of?

I'm on call for my first birth, she's trying to sabotage it, what else could she do because I'm supporting her?

Women in her inner circle stopped communicating with me, are they in on it?

I have to drive by her house everyday, is she going to attack me? Try to destroy my home?

Will she try to ruin my car so I can't get to Chattanooga? Will she poison my dog?

Is she going to use her clout to destroy friends I have in Asheville?

Will she cut off my electricity? My water?

Will she hire someone to hurt me? Will she have Jonny do it?

If I see her on the road, will she try to run me over?

Will she make up a story and tell the cops so they come arrest me?

... keep going

and going,

and you might,

maybe,

get an idea of what I felt

for a moment.

It lasted for 5 months....

If I would've pushed for a trial it would've taken at least another year on top, so in March when we reached a settlement agreement, I was out.

Emilee claims on her website to:

"unleash the power of women through freebirth, sovereign midwifery, and woman-to-woman wisdom"

She does not and cannot because she does not live it, she does not carry it. Emilee uses words but they are empty because she is not a person of integrity.

She has since constructed another yurt. I have heard that all the women who've moved there have ended up leaving because of who Emilee is.

You can fine my lawsuit in Clay County, court file 21 CVS 224.

** To the women who stood by me during this time - a million thank you's for a million years. You held me so I could catch a breath.

** To the land I fell madly in love with, thank you for holding me.

** To Rico Suave, my guy, we were destined to be together in this lifetime, has to be...

** To myself. I did it. I came out the other side, integral. Intact. Whole.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 30 '25

My Personal Experience with Freebirth Society

314 Upvotes

You can find me on Substack
——

In May of 2021 I joined an online membership promising me a safe place within a circle of authentic sisterhood. There was a deal swirling around which allowed me to secure the discounted price of $299 per year which felt like a steal compared to the usual annual price of $499. After all, can you really put a price tag on connection and sisterhood?

Once I passed the gatekeepers with a one on one Zoom interview, I was let into the membership, encouraged to introduce myself, free to explore the past threads and invited to join the live calls. Immediately I sensed a sort of cliquish energy, noticing that some women within the membership had more of a say than others. Their posts seemed of more value. Their opinions held in higher regard. I quickly realized that these women were part of Emilee’s inner circle and that translated into this virtual space.

I joined the first community call with Emilee as host and was immediately put off by her energy. There was a lack of warmth to her, an uninviting presence. Almost like she didn’t want to be there, but she had to be. I ignored those feelings because I had been finding such value in the past threads of mothers sharing their experiences on everything from fevers, food, conception and all other topics I currently was interested in learning about.

That winter I reached out to one of the women I had connected with through the membership stating I was about to join the Radical Birthkeeper School. Having just completed the program herself she insisted she speak with me on the phone before I make that choice. She shared how she does not advise I waste my money as the school is not what it claims to be, how she wishes she could get her $6,000 back, how it was a mistake. I trusted this woman so I decided against taking the course.

In February, after a wild pregnancy, I freebirthed a beautiful baby boy with Down syndrome. I was given a lot of support from the women in the membership as I navigated that realization, but not from Emilee. The following month, after I completed my first 40 days, we closed on a home a few towns over from Emilee. We moved from Black Mountain out to Murphy, NC where I continued my healing and processing. At 5 months old I took my son to get an echocardiogram after noticing some concerning signs. I am so thankful I did as he had a large hole in his heart that would require surgical repair, which he received a month after that echo.

We arrived home from Charleston in October. The colors were warm and the air was crisp since we were last here, nature ready for the season of release. So much had changed, outwardly but also inwardly. Watching your baby be ushered into the operating room will do that to a mother. There is no way I was going to remain the same. Upon arriving home there was a tenderness of my soul unlike I’ve ever known. The past 17 months had been spent holding so much throughout my pregnancy, birth, postpartum and my baby’s open heart surgery. I was ready to be held. I continued showing up within the community, despite feelings of exhaustion from the bi-weekly trips back to Asheville for post-op appointments and the long list of daily medication distribution which disrupted our much needed sleep. During this time I still hadn’t crossed paths with Emilee as she was newly postpartum. We were constantly circling around one another. I had been sharing my journey within the membership, intimate details of my precious son’s surgery and recovery. There were moments when I wondered why she’d never reached out to offer her support, let alone acknowledge my posts within the group. I accredited my feelings to being overly sensitive and instead of taking offense, I sent her messages of postpartum support. She sent a reply inviting me to a women’s circle on her land in a few weeks which I happily accepted.

November was coming to an end. I met one of the women in a local coffee shop to connect over chai lattes. I brought her a gift of chocolate covered almonds from my home and we shared stories of our past and how we came to live in North Carolina. I asked her about the plans she had for Thanksgiving to which she briefly mentioned going to Emilee’s house. Days later I reached out to one of the other women I had grown a friendship with, inviting her family to my house for the holiday, excitedly sharing my plans to make a cheesecake from scratch for the first time. She told me to let her know how it turns out, but didn’t acknowledge my invite. I began to wonder if everyone was going to Emilee’s. I spent the next week waiting for an invitation that never came.

I woke on Thanksgiving morning with a stiff neck. We had no plans that day, we were unable to travel to be with family due to my son’s recovery and I felt the crushing weight of feeling excluded. Nothing prepared me for the visual of seeing the Instagram posts of that day as an outsider. Happening a short 40 minutes from our home, the children’s table full of the kids my son had played with at a birthday party a few days prior. The women I had grown friendships with all circling the table, smiles on their faces, home-cooked food filling their plates. 9 families. My family, the only one not invited.

I wish I could say I put on a happy face and made my baby’s first Thanksgiving a memorable one, but that’s not what happened. It was a somber day with physical pain and even greater emotional pain. I didn’t understand why we’d been excluded when I had been showing up within her membership for 2 years and within the local community for the past 6 months. I’d had some of those women to my home, they walked my land and ate my food. My toddler had played with their children. I imagined if the roles were reversed, of course I would’ve extended an invite. Welcomed them in with an open heart. Fed them, gave them a warm hug with words of encouragement and acknowledgment of all they’d recently been through. Why wasn’t I receiving this authentic sisterhood I’d been sold on?

Thanksgiving was the first time I realized we were on the outside of all of it. Being the only family excluded from that dinner was painful and brought up so many feelings in regards to belonging and worthiness. I questioned why. I wondered what more I could have done to be included. Sharing my heart and my story on the FBS Membership for two years, showing up to multiple women’s circles and gatherings, being a friend… none of that was enough. How could these women exclude me after knowing what I had just endured in the past year? It had only been two months since my freebirthed son had his chest sliced open during open-heart surgery. What I needed more than ever was loving women to hold me. Surely there was enough compassion to be invited in!

I pushed it all down and committed to showing up to the women’s circle Emilee had invited me to a few weeks before Thanksgiving, even though it took a lot of courage to attend that day. During the circle I quickly realized it was unlike any I had ever experienced. Most circles I had attended up until that point allowed the women to share without crosstalk or interjection. This circle felt like an interrogation. Who am I? Where did I come from? Did my baby “really need” open-heart surgery? I shared my story, feeling uncomfortable while doing so, knowing Emilee wasn’t asking from a place of love. The circle continued on, everyone talking in their own conversations. That’s when I heard it. Emilee sharing a story about Johnny, following it with a big smile and the words, “He’s just RETARDED like that.”

I stopped breathing in that moment. I glanced around at some of the other women, hoping someone would speak the words that I couldn’t seem to find in that moment. Emilee cast down her eyes and looked to the side. I wondered if she recognized what she’d said, but instead, she lifted her head and began telling a different story. My heart was shattered. I always imagined the first time I would hear the word used after birthing a baby with Down syndrome would be by a punk teenager on the street. To hear it used by the “leader” of a community, to hear it used in what is meant to be a safe space such as a women’s circle, to be seated in a circle with 10+ other women who didn’t hear/care/speak up… I was heartbroken. What does this mean for my son and his future here? Was the reason Emilee never showed support for me and my baby because he has Down syndrome? How could she so freely use the word “retarded” in a women’s circle after I had just finished sharing the story of birthing a baby with Down syndrome?

I pondered these questions for days, then called one of the women present that night. I asked her opinion on how she thinks I should move forward regarding this. Her response to me was, “You can’t police other people’s choice of words.” It was disappointing to hear, but in my desperation to be accepted, I decided to let it go. Surely she didn’t even notice what she’d said. Forgive. If it is used again, address it lovingly. Forgive. Forgive. Forgive. But it continued to eat away at me as I felt a fierce protectiveness over my son. If this word is being used so casually, and possibly around the children within the community, it is only a matter of time before they begin to use the word themselves. What are we teaching them?

It was a few days after this circle that I got a voice note from Emilee. When I saw her name pop up on my phone, for a second, I believed it was to apologize for being careless with her words, for her lack of sensitivity to me and my situation. That is not what it was about. She, in a phony-sounding voice, asked me if I’d be interested in financially contributing to the new school property with her and Arielle. A few weeks ago I was too much of a stranger to be invited to Thanksgiving. Now, after a single two-hour circle, I was close enough to be a partner in a $400k purchase? I declined. I felt sick to my stomach. All along the way my body kept giving me signs that this group of women wasn’t aligning with my values, my heart. Why was I pushing so hard to be accepted in?

I would continuously be left out in the following weeks. The group chat, dinners that I’d see happening on Instagram, a Christmas parade where, once again, we were the only family not invited. My sons missing out again. Many times I had decided it was time to let it all go. But something kept me coming back… my children. I could endure so much pain and so much rejection for the sake of my children. I wanted them to have meaningful connections with children from like-minded families. I wanted a community for them. I was slowly building friendships with some of the women, so there were moments of hope. Or so I told myself. Having my toddler attend school with the other children was what got me through during the month of December. The night of the women’s circle, Emilee had invited my 3 year old son to join the Yurt School in the new year. It was my light at the end of what seemed to be never-ending darkness. He would benefit so greatly from it. But as it turned out, our experience at Yurt School would cause emotional damage that would take years to heal.

“Hey, I don’t think we’ve ever talked about you coming on the podcast! Let’s do it!” I receive this text from Emilee, and without hesitation, I respond, “Oh, I’ll have to think about that one! I’m a bit camera-shy!” No response. Minutes later, an email lands in my inbox, requesting to schedule a day to record an episode of the Freebirth Society Podcast. So much for honoring my need to think about it. I choose January 20th and try to convince myself that a month will be enough time to work up the nerve, not to be on camera, but to sit one-on-one with Emilee and share the most intimate story I have.

Orientation day for YurtSchool was concerning. There were only two children there. Right away, I could tell the teacher was not a real teacher, at least not in the sense I had imagined. She mentioned that when one of the children was choking on a beef stick, she stuck her finger down his throat to fish it out. I didn’t say anything then but later sent her a message, telling her that is not what you do if a child is choking. I asked if she knew the Heimlich maneuver or CPR. She responded that she was certified, but it had been a long time and that she would sign up for a child-specific certification that night.

I wasn’t entirely comfortable sending my newly three year old son alone the next day, so I texted Emilee, asking if I could shadow him one more day. I shared that I wanted to see how the teacher handled the full roster of children. I expressed my concern about the safety of the large pond that sits just below the yurt. Emilee seemed defensive and told me, “That’s not really how we do things.” So I compromised, I decided to send him for only two hours and visit with one of the women in a nearby yurt. Halfway through, I texted to check in and was told he was doing well, observing and smiling. When I picked him up, I asked the teacher if she thought he’d do better with a longer stretch of time at the next school day. She assured me, confidently, that he would do great.

That Thursday, I left him for a total of three hours. During his time at school, I received an Instagram message from one of the dads. He had dropped his son off a bit late that morning and saw my son in the little red car at the playground, smiling and having so much fun. That gave me peace of mind. When I arrived to pick him up, he was playing with one of the girls. I told him it was time to go, so they began singing the Clean Up song while putting away their toys. The other children walked us to the door, giving him high-fives and fist bumps as we left.

The next school day was going to be a rainy day, which meant the children would likely be inside all day. I had heard the boys were more physically aggressive on days like that. When we arrived, one of the women came too close with her puppy and it jumped on him, which scared him. That made him clingy when I tried to leave, but eventually, he sat down to play, and all was well. The YurtSchool group chat conversation throughout the day about the boys' physicality made me nervous. When my son came home, I asked about his day. He began talking about “hitting.” I wasn’t sure if he was saying he had been hit or if he had witnessed someone else being hit. So I asked in the chat for clarification and was told by the other women that my son hadn’t been involved in any of the incidents that day.

When Emilee called that night, I assumed it was to clarify what had happened with the hitting at school earlier. I imagined she would share her plan to make the pond safer. I hoped she would explain how the teacher actually is qualified and capable.

Instead, she told me that because my son is “nonverbal in school” and “doesn’t play with the other children,” autism was suspected. I couldn’t breathe. Of all things, I was not expecting this. Was this really happening? She said there was suspicion that my child is “on the spectrum” and because of that he is “not a good fit” for the school she was creating. My heart pounded. I felt like I was going to throw up. I tried explaining that he is very verbal at home and that perhaps he wasn’t playing with the others because he has never been in a social environment like this before. It might take time and some patience from the teacher! She then proceeded to read me a list of autism signs from the internet. I was shaking. I told her his behaviors stem from what our family has endured over the past few years—a possible insecure attachment. She dismissed it outright. “That wouldn’t be the reason,” she said. “All the kids are ‘Covid kids,’ and they aren’t showcasing these behaviors.” She ignored everything I said about my son. About my family. About our life. Emilee knew, without ever meeting my son, mind you, that it was most likely autism. Knowing my son, I knew intuitively this was an incorrect assumption. It felt like I was speaking to a pediatrician who was trying to tell me something about my own child, as if they knew him better than I did. Why was this woman doing the exact thing she warns mothers about when dealing with the medical establishment? In that phone call, she tried to convince me my child was autistic. She gaslit me repeatedly. She was matter-of-fact. She sounded, almost, happy? This was how she would get rid of me, of my family, for good. Exclude us from the school was to exclude us fully. I hung up that call feeling confused and angry. This was the final sign I needed to walk away from it all.

That night, I couldn’t sleep. I cried so deeply that my ancestors couldn’t bear the sound of my sadness. They joined me in the quiet dark and wept with me. I grabbed my stomach. It felt like I was trying to grasp my womb, my pain. I dug my hands into the place that hurt the most. Pain caused by other women is felt right there. As my sons slept soundly, I came undone.

The next morning I logged onto the membership and deleted every post I had made, which was many as I’d been very active over the two years since I joined. I left the one where I shared about the birth of my son. I wanted women who gave birth to a baby with Down syndrome to be able to find me. I then sent an email to cancel my membership.

After that, I sent a long, detailed message to the group chat. The ending read: “I was supposed to share my story on the FBS Podcast next week. I’ve decided not to. It doesn’t feel aligned to get on a webcam and share my story when, all along the way, I was shown no true compassion in real life. What I realize is that my time and experience with the Hayesville community is part of my story, it is still unfolding. All of the children are beautiful, perfect, and worthy. Even the ones who show aggression and hit. Even the ones you suspect have special needs. Especially those children. May the babies growing in the wombs of the women within this community be accepted and supported, no matter their abilities. That is my prayer. The YurtSchool email ended by saying, ‘The school is at the center of this village we are creating.’ But we are no longer part of the school. And we were never truly welcomed into this village.”

———

March, 2025

My eyes watch his little body move across the grass of his play school, his mouth wide in a fit of laughter. The warm South Florida sun causes sweat to drip down his skin. He runs alongside his friends, hopping onto a tricycle. One sweet child sits in the front, while he and another take the back. They zoom around the walkway until they are done with the trike. Now they grab paintbrushes, painting pictures of swimming pools and giraffes. Next, they greet a centipede. Someone picks it up and sticks it toward one of the girls, who screeches in both fright and delight. They all run inside. Music is playing. I watch his little body dance. They all dance until they declare themselves tired. And now, they are ready for a snack. He chooses carrots and a rice cake with sunflower butter, then sits between his two best friends. They’ve hardly stopped laughing this whole time. I watch his eyes light up. I watch him simply be five.
———-

You can find me here

https://substack.com/elleburdi


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Aug 30 '25

Births Gone Wrong I’m going to say it, and you can hate me for that.

280 Upvotes

Turns out, there is a reason for observation using various medical instruments, whether a Doppler or stethoscope. There is a reason ultra sound is used to check on babies. There is a reason blood is checked, urine is checked, blood pressure is checked, and so on.

I’m not saying there isn’t good reason to feel concerned about going into any doctor’s office or hospital. It’s hard to not have complete and total say over your body and situation, and there are plenty of instances that they abuse that power.

But maternal and fetal death was high before medicine got involved — high for today’s standards. We are seeing that comparison play out real time in the FBS group. The choice to completely turn away from medicine IS increasing women and infant mortality risk.

I hate to say it, because I fully believed in the freebirth society movement. But I can’t pretend or deny this anymore.

I see that there is death in modern medicine — I’m not saying there isn’t. I’m saying it is much less. Freebirth isn’t as inherently safe as it’s painted by Emilee and Yolanda to be.

The women who have the middle ground approach between medical and freebirth, are turning out to be the most grounded of all us. And interventions don’t seem to be the enemy of pregnancy, birth, and postpartum after-all.

Once again, freebirth isn’t the problem. Freebirth at all costs and to the intensity E & Y teach is.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Oct 22 '25

My traumatic home birth with a “freebirth supportive midwife”

255 Upvotes

This story is still very fresh, but it felt appropriate to post here given how much FBS had an effect on my choices.

I used to think women who freebirthed were out of their minds. Then I started listening to stories about midwives who pressured women into hospital transfers that weren’t necessary, and it planted a seed. I’d been terrified of hospitals since childhood after years of being sick and doctors being unable to help me. I knew when I had a baby someday, I wanted to do it at home. I wanted a birth that was peaceful, powerful, and that centered my desires.

After 18 months of trying to conceive and two miscarriages, I finally got pregnant in December 2024. My husband and I were over the moon. I found a “radical” licensed midwife who seemed perfect. She was an herbalist, had freebirthed her own kids, and I knew people who had used her services. My husband was uneasy. He didn’t like how her website sounded more spiritual than medical, but I brushed it off. We hired her and never discussed his misgivings again.

My pregnancy was easy. My only hiccup was a little extra fluid at 20 weeks, which my midwife carefully monitored by palpating my belly and ordering extra lab tests. I was satisfied that she was covering all the bases when it came to safety and I could simply relax and enjoy being pregnant.

Then my labor started, and everything unraveled.

My water broke and contractions began, but they never formed a clear pattern. I labored at home for 58 hours with open waters while my midwife stayed away. Even though my husband, doula, and I were consistently updating her, she only came once for about half an hour on day two to check my cervix (I was 3 cm) and listen to the baby. Her “support” consisted of: take this herb to slow labor down, take this one to speed things up, call me when you’re pushing.

By the third night, my contractions picked up and I thought this was finally it. I screamed through them, shaking and saying yes to every wave, eager to meet my baby and in total ecstasy despite the pain. My doula was helping me through them with position changes and I was in the zone. Despite not being present, my midwife was unimpressed with my progress and instructed my doula to give me more herbs to slow down labor and put me to bed. Something in me broke. My baby wasn’t coming tonight, after three nights of laboring. My midwife wasn’t coming, either. I took the herbs and my contractions spaced out to 15 minutes.

The next morning, I told my husband I wanted to go to the hospital. I wanted an epidural, pitocin, and continuous monitoring. I was desperate to make sure my baby was okay. When I called my midwife to tell her, she turned on me. Despite not having monitored me or my baby’s vital signs in over 16 hours, she discouraged me from going to the hospital. She blamed me for not following her instructions perfectly. She said pitocin was no different from castor oil. She said the epidural wouldn’t really help me rest. She blamed me for not sleeping enough, and not communicating enough. She said I would likely end up having a surgical birth and it would negatively affect my baby. She finally said she could come over to listen to heart tones, but it was too late. My trust was broken.

I told her my decision was final and she called ahead to let the hospital know I was coming. They had a room ready when I arrived and the anesthesiologist had been paged. They started prepping me for the epidural right away. They gave me options, respected my choices, and treated me with compassion. I got the epidural and pitocin, and my nurse whispered that she’d do everything she could to protect me and my baby. For the first time in days, I felt safe. Finally a provider who cared if I lived or died. I was 4 cm dilated when I arrived at the hospital and within three hours of being on pitocin, I was complete. I pushed five times, and my son was born and they placed him on my chest. It was everything I’d hoped birth could be; ecstatic, peaceful, powerful and raw. My doula made sure the cord stopped pulsing before they cut it, they asked for consent before giving me stitches, and when I barked at the OB to stop pushing on my uterus, he did. Having a fully managed placental delivery after 69 total hours of labor was a relief.

I know I was lucky. I lived near a great hospital. I had an experienced doula and hospital staff who respected my choices. My story doesn’t erase the trauma some women experience in hospitals, but it showed me how good hospital birth can be when the right people are on your side.

These so-called “renegade” or “hands-off” midwives can be dangerous. Anyone who’s tied to freebirth culture is a red flag to me now. It’s code for “you’re mostly on your own, sweetie.” My midwife never once checked my vitals, and only checked my baby’s during that single visit. She never warned me that open waters for many days can lead to sepsis, fetal distress, and death. I only learned the risks after the fact. And even now, she refuses to take accountability and continues to blame me for her lack of support during my home birth.

Some of you may critique me, or downplay my experience by saying I simply didn’t understand what to expect with an authentic midwife. However, the package she sold me was specifically for first time parents who want “additonal, hands-on support” during early and active labor as well as “clinical care”. You’d be appalled to know how much we paid her.

I won’t attempt a home birth again, even though I know second births are typically more easeful and straightforward. I like knowing my hospital midwife is in the building but leaving me alone while I labor. I hate having to text anyone while working through contractions. I like that my postpartum nurses will come by to check my bleeding and hand me ibuprofen twice a day. Some of those nurses helped me fix my son’s latch and get us comfortable breastfeeding. If I was crying, they’d bring me whatever I needed. I saw a lactation consultant who recommended a great naturopath. The only shit I got from staff was when the pediatrician came by and scolded us for declining the vitamin k shot, but we enthusiastically accepted her handout on the benefits of the shot and she was satisfied and left us alone.

If you love home birth or freebirth, more power to you. But please, if you haven’t given birth yet, explore ALL your options. Don’t mistake neglect for empowerment. “Hands-off” can mean no hands when you’re desperate for help. Research your nearby hospitals, they may actually be well rated and have policies that align with your desires. Learn about midwifery licensure in your state and what they are required to provide and any warning signs of medical neglect. Birth isn’t a medical event by nature, but holy shit can it become one so fast.

I went into labor believing I was safest at home. I left the hospital alive, holding my son, knowing this truth:

Abandonment can happen with a “medwife” or a “renegade” “hands-off” midwife. A provider that believes birth is not a medical event does not take responsibility for the gravity of their role. A midwife with many years of experience can still make mistakes, especially if she has a big ego. Having a midwife who won’t alert you to issues and transfer your care if things become risky is not a good midwife. She is simply prioritizing your desires and her own opinions about hospital care over you and your baby’s safety.

I’m done with all of this “variation of normal” nonsense. I would rather be transferred to the hospital too quickly than too late. Home birth CAN be traumatizing. Medical sabotage is not nearly as black and white as it seems. Just because you birth at home in a pool surrounded by fairy lights with no one checking your cervix doesn’t mean your birth is more “pure” or has a higher likelihood of being positive for you and your baby. It might be the right choice for you, but it also might not be. You can have an ecstatic, beautiful birth with interventions and surrounded by strangers.

Maybe everything would have gone differently in my labor if I had a more supportive midwife who actually showed up. Perhaps all the herbs she gave me sabotaged my labor progress. I’ll never know why my cervix wouldn’t open at home. What I do know is that safety isn’t herbs or affirmations or a provider who will encourage you to stay home no matter what. Safety is someone with real qualifications walking through the door when you need them most, looking you in the eyes, and doing everything they can to keep you and your baby alive.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Nov 22 '25

Guardian Article

229 Upvotes

r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Jan 18 '26

Yolande’s hypocrisy on breastfeeding

212 Upvotes

Yolanda is such a hypocrite. She’s obsessed with the idea of uninterrupted natural birth, to the point where even having a midwife present apparently ruins the purity of the experience. And then she pushes this fantasy that you always get the birth you want, that women are fully in control, and that if you don’t, it’s because you chose wtong.

However, she doesn’t apply this logic consistently. If birth is sacred and must be completely untouched, then why doesn’t she extend that same rigidity to breastfeeding? She’s openly talked about struggling to breastfeed and using bottles and formula. Breastfeeding is the most natural thing a mother can do. It’s literally how you sustain your baby’s life after birth. If intervention during birth is a failure, then why isn’t formula considered one too? By her own logic, she didn’t “struggle” with breastfeeding, she chose to have problems with it. If you’re not resuscitating a newborn with rescue breaths because that would be “interfering,” then why would you use formula when your body doesn’t produce milk or breastfeeding doesn’t work?

Such a hypocrite.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 30 '25

About us: The women behind this page

208 Upvotes

We are a group of women directly impacted by Emilee Saldaya and Yolande Norris Clark’s negligence, abuse and manipulation. 

Our group includes women who have been in the inner circles, former and current students, Lighthouse members, coaching clients and free birthing women. 

This is an unpaid endeavor. We have families. We have jobs. And yet, we are working tirelessly out of our love for women and children with the intention of:

  • Warning those currently involved with Free Birth Society LLC, Emilee & Yolande

  • Helping women make sense of what has happened to them, to know they are not alone

  • Consumer Advocacy: Knowing what you’re buying before you buy it

We are pro unassisted birth/freebirth/home birth and want to end the harm that Emilee Saldaya, Yolande Norris Clark, and Free Birth Society are doing to the freebirth and home birth movements.

A note on Reddit:

This is Reddit, not the classiest corner of the internet. We’re going to let it be Reddit. We are making a conscious choice to not heavily control or moderate user contributions. 

Women have been abused. 

Women have been betrayed. 

We will not spiritually bypass or talk them out of their healthy anger and grief. 

With that said, we will do what we can to make sure the conversation stays both civil and focused on the issues at hand.

In addition, Free Birth Society is a high control group. Women arriving to this space are at various stages of coming to terms with what they experienced and/or participated in and may still:

  • Dismiss this space as being on the Drama Triangle or gossip 

  • Cast suspicion on the motivations of this space

  • See Emilee’s abuse and manipulation clearly while excusing Yolande’s role (good cop/bad cop)

  • See themselves as solely benefiting from Free Birth Society membership and programs i.e. “took the good and left the rest behind”

  • Express superiority i.e. see this Reddit as low frequency / not enough women willing to take radical responsibility

This Reddit page is not intended to be the best or only way of coming out of the spell of Free Birth Society and rigid birth dogma.

Please know that this reddit page is one part of a multi front effort. We support and encourage additional spaces, public and private to discuss and process the aftermath of Free Birth Society. 

If you want to message us you can do so via reddit using the link in the sidebar, or by emailing [email protected]


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Nov 23 '25

FRAUD is the root cause

184 Upvotes

As a woman who fell for their fraud, I was fleeced of nearly $100,000 (USD) by Emilee. I am aware it could have been MUCH worse.

I would like to focus on the root cause: their fraud.

They have no midwifery training or experience; they have not attended thousands of births in the capacity of a midwife; they do not have longstanding, reputable mentors; they do not have real, in-person community supporting them; they have not lived as a student of in-person birth as a midwife for decades; they have not studied birth in it's totality.

I lived alongside Emilee and everything she proclaims online is inverted. I know people want details, but that's the simple true. Whatever marketing material she wrote about herself and her work, it's actually the opposite. That's how truth gets perverted and darkness tricks you into thinking it's light.

My wish is that women become aware and move away from Emilee, Yolande and Free Birth Society to reputable women.

Many of these women are in your community, go find them.

Some are online, please list them.

If you wish to see a better world, build it.

Go forward to true wisdom and may God bless you.

-Paula


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 30 '25

Abusive Behavior Sharing my story, despite the many bullying threats to censor us!

184 Upvotes

Prior to signing up to RBK school, I searched online for all the info i could get on this group and i found next to nothing negative about it, so i fell for their false advertising and signed up. I was fascinated, listened to every single F.S. podcast episode and took the bait, hook, line and sinker. "Be the authentic midwife your truly meant to be" Emilee saldaya said. They really know a lot about psychology and mind games and how to use word play and all the tactics to get what they want; your MONEY honey. I took out a loan to pay the $6,000.00 to attend the school. Thinking "ok, well, im gonna make my back with my first few births so great!".

This radical birth keeper school promises a birthworker education, but did not deliver that at all, whatsoever. After i graduated, I was still under the spell (they REALLY hype you up!) that i was prepared and educated to attend births, but it turns out, i was so not. There were sooo many things i had questions about; especially breech birth. In a Q & A Zoom call, i asked about breech and they once again said "oooh you'll never see breech its so rare!" They avoided the question, i never got an answer (anyone in the 2023 cohort can review the video to verify!) and that was all i could do about it other than ask again.

After graduation, they created this 'professional network' on the Mighty Network platform for the recent graduates, which initially i felt great about, but soon realized that they had JUST created this to throw us a crumb, not to actually provide any support. Very few women were even active on there. It was a weird vibe. Anywho, I made 1 post asking for support basically, after the first birth i attended went unexpectedly (luckily noone died). It was a 3 day labor then baby went transverse. I made a post, but got very few responses other than "thats not true transverse", which emilee replied "thats what i was gonna say", she had said nothing prior to that. I was shocked. For i thought this was a loving sisterhood community! I felt no support, just severe judgment and ridicule to my dismay.

I was bullied, gaslit, and 'made an example out of' because of that post. In the replies of that post, i brought up the fact that Yolande had blocked me on IG prior to this and made a comment pointing this out, as I wanted the truth to be known. At that point, i felt my experience needed to be heard, regardless if they didnt like it or not. Prior to all of this I had politely commented on Yolande's IG post promoting her new course HYGEA, where she called her "old self" "sad and pathetic" because she used crystals and such.

Also, within my replies i intensely questioned their statement of how "rare" certain emergencies really are, being that I got a true transverse on my first birth i ever attended! Their response is that its "my fault it went wrong". I "sabotaged" the birth and thats how it ended up transverse. They claim that only real, truly well supported births practically always go right, so when they go wrong, it must be our fault! These people will villainize you, gaslight & blame you until the cows come home. All to make their money. In my experience and so many others.

On the RBK "professional network" Yolande responded with a novel of a reply (to the point where you question her mental stability), villainized me, ridiculed me and removed me from the RBK directory, membership and the network. She stated that they are making an example out of me, that this is what will happen to anyone who has anything negative or intense questioning to say within this space.

There was then a few replies from the women in support of this abuse, one from a Page Lapin, responding "EPIC" to what Yolande 'told me'. They not only bullied me but then were cheered on from their sad little soldiers. It was grade school in the worst way all over again.

So, after a lot of money and even more energy, i was ostracized from the whole cult. Please look up the definition of the word cult. This is exactly what Freebirth society is. For if anyone speaks out or questions them, it will probably be their last time being able to do so. It was mine. It also was for MANY others. Even after everything i experienced, I'm still so shocked as to how many women are NOW finally coming forward to share their story experiencing their deception, lies, & abusive ways. But, now that I have a true experience of this society, i'm not surprised of their bullying threats, even to women STILL in the membership!

This was actually a blessing in disguise, for I had to get really real with myself as far as attending births. In my state it is crazy illegal for any RBK to attend births. And im actually NOT up for going to jail. Or not getting paid (because were not supposed to charge money until after the birth for legal reasons) or any of the countless misalignments with that ideology.

It is completely delusional to think one can obtain a proper midwife education through a 12 week, online course. You cannot learn midwifery in this way. That is delusional thinking. I was weak and desperate for a proper income as a single mom and they effing got me. They played the crap out of me. I was so duped. Unbelievably so.

I also need to mention that I personally know women who are currently in their MMI school and they are reporting back that it is just a glorified RBK school, that they STILL aren't teaching real midwifery (as if that can be learned online). So, I would NEVER fall for that scam either. The 'Matriarch rising festival' is also a complete clown world. They lock women inside the property. Pregnant women were jumping the gates to get to their cars for food. They only serve breakfst and dinner, so women had to fend for themselves at other times. They ran out of ice on the second day! I'm not making this up. So women were eating unrefrigerated things from their car they had to jump a fence to get to. Meanwhile Yolande was allowed to drive in and out to her air b & b. The cops were called on a grandmother. Emilee was incredibly mean and yelled at an eldery women for walking through the poison oak by mistake. Emilees husband is there the whole time, so its not a true womens gathering lol. Ladies....DO NOT say we didn't warn you if you take a chance on these completely insane people.

Theres so many other facts about Emilee Saldaya and Yolande Norris clark that people should know like the fact that Yolande fled Nicaragua to escape legal persecution after a bad birth. Emilees husband is an ex heroine addict who literally thinks emilee is god and sets an alarm on his phone to make her meals as her man servant. Emilee once told us in a Zoom call that the only reason she married her husband was so that she wouldn't lose everything if she got sued. These women are so far from what they claim to be online.

The main point i want to make here is that the Freebirth society sells us a whole boat load of crap that just isnt true and is very dangerous for some. They promise that we will get a comprehensive birthworker education, that we will be set up to attend births after graduation. This is simply a lie. I dont know of one woman who went to Radical Birth Keeper school (and has no other birth education) and is now actively attending births. Not one. And if you somehow manage to attract and obtain clients, it is only a matter of time before you run into trouble of one kind or another. I personally know of more ex rbkers who are now being sought after for legal persecution. They dont tell you that in the school though!

They state over and over in the school that its not illegal what an RBK does and "we dont do anything wrong". Sure. We are indeed taught to just sit there. Dont ever touch a woman, "even hip compressions" are what they call "heroing" and we should always "stick to our own business". We are taught NOT one hands on maneuver (other than Yolandes s.d. shoulder rocking thing, which I am positive has hurt women &/or babies) because its NOT MIDWIFERY that they teach!! Biggest scam of my whole life. Buyer be VERY aware. Better yet, report them and use your money, wisely! One would think (from their super attractive marketing schemes) that, at the very least, this is a kind, loving sisterhood that supports women. But in reality, these women are the most stuck up, angrier as HELL, holier than though, culty women i have EVER experienced. STAY AWAY is my advice.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 31 '25

My freebirth hospital transfer story.

181 Upvotes

Please be sensitive. This is so vulnerable for me to share, but I think it’s important my story is out there.

I found FBS in 2021, in the height of COVID. I really believe it is why I was so easily brainwashed. I work in the medical system and actually have a doctorate degree, but I didn’t believe a lot of what the medical system and big pharma were pushing at the time, and here was a birth movement against it, so I instantly felt aligned with it. I was completely obsessed with the podcast and would speak about the birth stories to my family, and they all told me it was a cult. I rolled my eyes and became even more obsessed. I started feeling distanced from my friends who “just didn’t get it”. I was all in. I had always wanted a homebirth with a midwife, but decided when I tried to get pregnant in 2022 that I would have a wild pregnancy and freebirth. I became pregnant and joined the lighthouse.

While in the lighthouse, I witnessed the gaslighting and red flags during labors that sometimes ended in poor outcomes. It scared me, but I kept reassuring myself with Emilee’s words that “true emergencies are so rare!” Those things won’t happen to me, I thought. Birth is natural, and since I live my life “natural minded” everything should work out! I took the complete guide to freebirth. I devoured it. My husband was on board, although he didn’t do much to prepare. He trusted me, and supported me with whatever decision I wanted to make for my birth and our baby. My mom was the biggest source of conflict through my pregnancy; she wanted me to hire a midwife. I was awful to her, and told her she was trying to sabotage my birth and threatened her that if she can’t be on the same page as me, she won’t be invited to my birth. I feel awful about how I treated her. But all I heard was Emilee’s voice in my head, and that if I hired a “MedWife” I would end up with a hospital transfer and surgery. I was terrified of going to the hospital, I literally thought they may kill my baby. Even though I worked with good nurses and doctors every day! So brainwashed.

I hired an RBK. there was nothing inherently wrong with her and she was supportive throughout my pregnancy, but I think I wanted/ needed more from her. I wasn’t being honest with myself and thought I needed to “do the work” so that I wouldn’t need more support from her. I know now that I should have just honored my feelings. I was a first time mom for gods sake. I had never done this before! Because I was freebirthing, I felt so isolated from my other friends who were pregnant and utilizing midwives and Obgyn practices. I had no one, besides my RBK, and husband, but what I really craved was womanly support. I wished so badly my mom understood me. I tried to get that support from the lighthouse, but some of the extreme views I found in there didn’t resonate with me either, so it was a very confusing time for me. I couldn’t find where I fit in.

Fast forward to 40 weeks and I was very prepared to go overdue. I wasn’t worried yet. I still felt good, although uncomfortable. 41 weeks came, my mother started to get very worried and I had some tearful, angry conversations with her telling her she needed to stop putting out bad energy. At 42 weeks, I finally stopped working. I was convinced baby would be here within a few days. I may have posted in the lighthouse at this point looking for encouragement and started searching the membership for stories of 42+ weeks. All I read was “this is normal” and “you’re doing it mama. your baby knows when to come”. My RBK was checking in with me, and I kept telling her that yes, I was uncomfortable, but that I was trying to trust the birthing process, as I’ve heard so many times. At 43 weeks, I started to freak out. I think I posted again in the lighthouse. I may have gotten some replies along the lines of needing to release any fears that may be preventing me from going into labor. I was starting to get annoyed, like is there anything I should be doing to get this baby to come? I was trying to stay rested and relaxed, but I half heartedly started doing curb walking, the miles circuit. But Emilee said none of these things work, so why should I be wasting energy? I was so exhausted. I cried every day. Finally at 43 weeks and 5 days, my labor started. Hard and fast. Relentless. 0 to 100. I had no time to get used to sensations, there was no ramping up. My RBK and mom arrived at some point. I stayed in the birth pool as much as I could. My contractions were 1-2 minutes apart the entire labor, no rest times. I had “double peaking” contractions for most of the labor as well. At some point I asked my RBK if this was “normal” and that the contractions seem to never fully end. I never got a break, one started before the other ended. She said she has never seen/heard this labor pattern last for as long as mine had. (Almost 12 hours of this at that point) But offered no other words of advice or encouragement. She just asked me to connect with my baby. After 14 hours of labor, I had pea soup looking meconium staining my chux pads and I told my husband I think I need to go to the hospital. I also said “I don’t think I’ve felt the baby move for a while. I just don’t remember”.

What ensued next was my worst nightmare. 4 men came into my living room, hauled me out on a stretcher and I endured a horrible ambulance ride to the hospital 10 minutes away. I arrived to the hospital and was terrified of every person coming into the room to check me, start my IV, etc. I was in complete panic. We had no plan for what to do in the event of a transfer. We hadn’t discussed this at all. I didn’t pack a hospital bag just in case because FBS told me it may make a transfer more likely?…I don’t know what I was thinking. I remember my contractions started to space out a bit. I was complete at 10cm when I arrived but they started pit. They told me I had a fever. I had a full bladder I couldn’t release. After 4 hours of pushing, I birthed my baby. He was put on my chest for maybe 10 seconds, and then whisked away. They told me he was not ok. They started resuscitation. He was intubated and taken to the NICU.

I was in shock. Everything I had actively worked to prevent in my pregnancy had happened. My baby was separated from me. He was ill. I did not know how to make sense of what happened. It felt like someone was playing a joke on me. This was not supposed to happen.

The nightmare lasted 10 more days. My son eventually improved and we were able to go home. Before we left the hospital, he had an MRI and they told us he experienced an hypoxic event at some point (they couldn’t tell me when it happened since I wasn’t being monitored during my pregnancy and most of my labor). They told me he may have mobility issues and delayed milestones. I was devastated but in some ways, I didn’t believe what they were telling me. I was so sure my son would be fine.

Post partum was hell. I was depressed and so traumatized. I was confused. I blamed myself for transferring, and was still brainwashed. I told people that the hospital caused my babies issues. I thought, well if I had my baby at home, maybe this wouldn’t have happened. But I also couldn’t relate to the freebirth stories any more. I didn’t feel welcome in that space because I failed. I didn’t have an amazing freebirth story. I had a horrible, traumatizing hospital birth story. I left the lighthouse.

I’m now 19 months PP. My son does have mobility issues, although not severe. He attends therapy for it. I am slowly starting to wake up to the freebirth society cult. I looked for this Reddit thread after my birth because I had a feeling I wasn’t alone. I didn’t find much. I felt very alone then. Since I had my son, I’ve felt very resentful toward FBS. It’s true that not everything unfolds in birth like they say. It’s not black and white like they make you believe. I had multiple complications that made my birth harder than necessary. If it’s so rare, why and how did it happen to me? Who is normally so healthy? Thoughts haunt me like: If I had a midwife, I may have been able to prevent my son’s poor health at birth. It is so difficult to feel responsible for your baby’s challenges. I really thought I was protecting him. They made me believe that. I just wish someone could have gotten through to me. My mom tried but it didn’t work. I thought I was open minded, but I truly was so close minded while consuming their content. I hope my story can prevent someone else falling into the same trap.

Thanks for reading my story.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Dec 10 '25

Podcast is out

Post image
175 Upvotes

6 episodes in total


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Apr 01 '25

The "birth is always straight forward- look at mammals!" Folly

169 Upvotes

Long time listener and consumer of Yolande Norris Clark's work, and later FBS podcasts. Thankfully, I have never given them any money, but was considering joining as I hope to have a fourth child.

I first became pregnant in 2024 2015 and watched the "Business of Being Born" and hoped for a low intervention home birth thereafter. I was living in Kentucky and at that time, CNM's and LPNM's could not be licensed to attend home births, so I settled on a birth centre. I had an extremely long, excruciating birthing experience. I was shell shocked, disassociated and terrified of becoming pregnant again. I did end up having another baby, and opted for a planned epidural. It was a straight forward, fine experience. I felt guilty sharing my birth story because I felt like I must care more about my comfort than about my baby being "drugged" at birth. Maybe I just don't have the grit, and can't hack it the way other women could. in attempt to redeem myself, I planned a home birth for my third baby, but at a few days shy of 43 weeks they threatened to drop me from their care. I was induced, had an epidural, needed vacuum assistance to get him out. Failed again.

I thought the common denominator here was medical intervention. "If I hadn't been in that unfamiliar birth centre under lights.." "If I had just said no to the induction and stayed home.." and started to really consider freebirth with the fourth baby I plan to have. My husband is entirely supportive of my choices, and stands by me no matter what.With that being said, he is a third generation farmer and has extensive experience with mammalian birth. He started to push back a little when I would repeat things I heard on the podcast, like "there is no such thing as malposition" "hemorrhage is rare in undisturbed birth" "stitches for even third degree tears aren't warranted" "prolapse heal themselves" "Pitocin is never indicated" etc.

Most farmers will tell you mammalian birth works unless it doesn't. Birth tends to work better when the animal is not under artificial lights, you're not constantly putting your hand up their vagina, or otherwise causing undue stress. With that being said, there is a non-trivial amount of ewe and lamb deaths that happen with an entirely hands-off approach. There are malpresentation lambs requiring manual repositioning. There is infection from prolonged rupture of membranes. There is hemorrhage. There is cord prolapse and snapped cords. We've seen perfectly robust, well mineralized and well bred animals abort pregnancies or otherwise die during their birthing process. This is just the truth.

My husband told me he would support me 100% in whatever I decided was best. But talking with him about this did make me examine my "why". Whatever these kooks say, death absolutely is a worst case scenario, how could it not be? Of course there is no risk free option, but there may be a circumstance wherein you might be grateful to have a skilled attendant present. Maybe not all hospital birth is a traumatic satanic rape experience. Maybe you didn't fail if you opted for pain control.

This was my first year helping with lambing from beginning to end, (despite being married to a farmer for 11 years lmao) We lambed out 280 ewes. Boots on the ground, first hand experience in the trenches of it forced me to confront the reality that birth is unpredictable and humility is always in order.

Thanks for reading.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Oct 27 '25

Yolande Norris Clark Yolande Norris Clark is a rage bait bottom feeder on Instagram at the ripe ol age of 44.

165 Upvotes

That’s it. Not a wise woman. Not a truth teller. Just your average slave to the Instagram algorithm metrics looking to piss people off to gain engagement. This is what her life's work is amounting to. She’s squeezing every last drop out of her drying up influencer well while she can. I'm not mad about it. Just don't be fooled. She is indeed performing and her content has now become rage reactions to comments. Sell out. Boring. Embarrassing.

Lets just name what’s going on here with this “public spiral” she’s been performing. Please know, it really is not real, she’s literally doing this to get reactions. Don’t fall for it. She is a reality show. She’s a “real housewife of somewhere in Central America”. She is a bottom feeder scrounging for crumbs to stay relevant and sadly this is her best work.

Best of luck to you, Yolande. It’s time to go to bed.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Nov 06 '25

Bring this sub back to life

160 Upvotes

It was a mistake to move observations on Yolande to a different page.

I understand that some people don't want to see frequent posts about her, but here's the thing you may not grasp. Yolande was the talent - the face, mind, and voice - that drew so many women to FBS. Though Emilee was the founder and CEO, Yolande was a huge personality of the brand and an inspiration to many of us for 5+ years. We thought she was beautiful, fascinating, intelligent, unique, compelling - someone to respect and even emulate.

She had us believing many things that greatly impacted our lives. Through her example, we could have more children than the societal norm. We could thoroughly enjoy motherhood and never feel stressed or burdened by it. We could have a pain free blissful ecstatic freebirth without anyone present. We could avoid the medical system entirely to achieve perfect health. We could easily mother our young kids and make ample money from home without any financial support from the father.

At this point, most of us are blocked and can no longer witness her instagram, substack, and private membership group. She is free to continue curating her image and predating on new audience members and potential customers.

This sub has been a place for me (to a small extent, since I can't observe her through these channels) be able to continue witnessing her and coming to grips with who she really is and how she had me fooled about her character for over five years. It has helped me to realize that this woman who I thought was authentic and respectable - is a cruel, neglectful, narcissistic, fame-and-money obsessed, spiritually bereft, potentially sociopathic, pathological liar and very good con artist. For me personally, this has been the most impactful aspect of the whole project, and it's now been cut off at the root.

The Guardian coverage is still to be released. I would like to make an appeal that this sub remain a place where we can track the responses to it that Emilee and Yolande provide. In part because I don't have a way to see them myself - and in part because the community commentary here is immensely supportive in making sense of it all.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Jan 22 '26

Manipulation We became captured somehow.

159 Upvotes

Hi all. I need to tell you all that I used to be very against the idea of home birth in general. I didn’t know much about pregnancy or birth as we had been trying to conceive for 7 years by the time we got pregnant with our daughter last year. My best friend was a huge fan of all the home birth podcasts and the whole culture around it. We got in lots of arguments over it while I was struggling with infertility because I couldn’t understand how anyone would take “risks” with the thing we had so desperately tried to attain. Anyway, when I became pregnant, I agreed to watch The Business of being Born. Well that was the beginning of my indoctrination. The same best friend has a sister in law who is a doula. With some time and specific information, I was on board with having my besties SIL as my doula and signing up with a local midwifery for a home birth. At this point I had already been to a traditional OB and had NIPT testing done and was classified as low risk. As time went by, each time my midwives asked me to do any routine medical thing, my doula would scoff and roll her eyes and tell me how it was all bs and they were too medical and they were constantly gaslighting me. My doula has a pretty significant presence in the radical birthing world…she’s written a book and has a podcast. Shes pretty influential. She’s also a close friend of the family, being married to my best friends brother. Things got really tense with my midwives over time. I was convinced they had something against me personally for working with my doula who in hindsight was interfering with medical side of things. I wasn’t prepared to come here and tell my story today so I apologize if this is difficult to follow. Long story but my point is that at 41&3 I had high bp and protein in my urine. I also had a BPP the day before that I got an 8/8 on. My midwives wanted to transfer my care to the hospital based on that. My doula promised me I did not have preeclampsia because if I did, I would have a number of symptoms that I was not having. She swore up and down I was fine since I felt fine and that we didn’t need them anyway and she could just deliver my baby. Yes. I trusted this person. So did my husband. We are not ignorant or uneducated people. And looking back, we are so ashamed and confused how this all happened. So my midwives dropped me from care because I refused to go to the hospital. A week later I went into labor at home, felt decreased movement, and called my doula. She showed up to my house and couldn’t find a heartbeat with Doppler so we went to the hospital. When we were driving to the hospital, she was in the vehicle in front of us at a light and she turned left and went home and we turned right to go to the hospital. We never saw her again. Our daughter died because we chose to listen to the advice of someone who is aligned with the beliefs of free birth society. We take responsibility for the decisions we made. We just wanted to keep our baby safe and we fell for the fear mongering that the free birthing world puts in our heads about anything to do with the medical world. This person seems completely unaffected, they took 3 month break from posting anything on social media but are right back in the swing of things already while I am suffering the greatest loss imaginable. Feel free to ask questions, I’m sure this is spotty. I just needed to put this out there. I tried to freebirth and my baby died. Don’t lose sight of what’s really important. I’ve heard a lot of birth trauma stories but I promise you, there’s no greater trauma than this.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Apr 14 '25

Addressing the objectification of loss moms & lost babies in this thread

158 Upvotes

I’m losing sleep over not saying anything about this. I’ve been a fly on the wall through all that’s unfolded in the last couple of weeks, taking it all in from as many sides as possible and just ruminating. But I keep coming back to the thing that brought me to the free birth community in the first place: death. Specifically, the stillbirth of my second son within the medical system. I just saw a post about VAERS stats post-Covid on here. I wrote out a very lengthy reply… aaaand it won’t let me post a reply for some reason. Maybe it’s too long. But I’m taking this as a sign to finally “break my silence”. And it’s not in defense of anyone or anything- it’s to speak up for the mothers of lost babies. I don’t speak as a representative for us, but I will speak FOR us because I know intimately that many of us are hurting through this whole unfolding.

My name is Savannah. If you know me from the FBS community, the RBK school, or the podcast, you know me. I’m breaking anonymity because I’m a real person. So is my baby who died, and my babies who lived. And so are all the mothers and babies who have been rather callously glazed over and boiled down to victims of a death cult, whose unique stories are being blended up into indistinguishable yet “positively telling” goop to bolster paths towards justice by those who have been wronged by FBS leadership. Think that’s harsh? Well, have you lost a child and then had his memory and your faith hijacked to prove a point?

My second child Ambroise died in my womb on my due date. I had been working with a CPM in the state of Texas. I decided to be induced and give birth in the hospital, knowing my baby had passed. I did all the tests and scans my relatively holistic and hands-off midwife recommended throughout my pregnancy (more even, because I felt something was off the whole time). I was constantly told everything was fine, I was healthy, baby was healthy. After Ambroise was born, I was told the same thing. By both my midwife and the attending OB at my birth. No one could tell me why my baby had died. My midwife was told by several OBs & CNMs before, during, and in the months after my birth, that 1) stillbirths have been sharply on the rise since Covid, in women who contracted it during pregnancy and in women who received the vax, 2) less than half of stillbirths even have a discoverable or known cause, and 3) most causes given are the ME’s or attending OB’s best guess given to families for the sake of letting them have something to hold onto and some semblance of closure or understanding in an unfathomably painful situation.

I share all this because for one, we need to get clear that stillbirth occurs and is rising both in AND out of the system, and two, that I started to unpack what it means when a baby (MY baby) dies before I found FBS. I was told I was high risk simply because my son died- even though they couldn’t tell me why. That didn’t make sense to me. I was eviscerated on loss forums on Reddit for considering a home birth again. The deeply beautiful, psychedelic and transformative experience I had through Ambroise’s death and birth, that quite literally saved me through the darkness and grief of it all, was completely dismissed in the name of “statistics”, “safety” and “preparedness”; in other words, the sacredness and importance of my story, my experience, the meaning of my son’s life, was brushed aside as less important than “getting a live baby by any means necessary”.

My first venture into FBS was the podcasts about loss I found: loss that was expected, loss that was unexpected, loss in the system, loss outside the system- and I was deeply moved by the common theme of REVERENCE for death that I heard and felt. Gratitude for the things you learn, the things you let go of, the meaning and transformation and love that can still be found through the darkest fucking most empty, soul-shredding, body-quaking hell that is losing your baby. Finally, here were mothers who got what I was feeling. Here were women who didn’t accept that we should only wallow and disappear within guilt, brokenness, shame, anger and despair (though you WILL go through all of that no matter where or how you birth if your baby dies, don’t get me wrong). I knew my life wasn’t over, my baby still mattered, my birth still mattered, my baby was STILL, born. Neither he nor I were a failure. And within the free birth community, I found women who felt the same. I wasn’t alone.

I do not speak for all loss moms within the realm of freebirth. But I KNOW I am not alone in feeling deeply disturbed by the callous rhetoric and speculation being turned around on those of us who have walked through the portal of death and developed beliefs that you don’t understand around risk, loss, spirituality, babies, and birth. To boil us down to moms who were lured into a death cult where death is favored or idealized (by the leader and/or by women in the space) as long as we “got our free birth” is beyond infantalizing and completely ignorant. To dismiss the very REAL and unique stories and situations of mothers and babies from this community, to say their interpretations of what happened are clouded by the external influence of ES or YNC, that they probably missed something… It reads like you’re co-opting the experiences of real women, re-writing their perspectives and stories, and using them to further your own agenda (that perhaps, at its core, is rooted in something very just and valid and real).

I want to be VERY clear: I am NOT speaking for the women who lost their babies due to what THEY feel was negligence in the face of injury or emergency. Those few stories are devastating and horrifying and should be taken very seriously. As seriously as women who have lost children at the hands of medical negligence. So that we can stop that from happening again and spread awareness. A mother knows when something went very wrong. If there are women who feel unjust leadership and negligence directly lead to the death of their children, let us hear them with love and gentleness. If or when they feel ready. If there are women who are unsure if they could have done something differently and prevented the loss of her child, my God, let us HOLD her with so much love in her sorrow and let her lead the conversation. Let us have compassion for her and support her in what she does to heal and make sense of her loss. This should never happen. In any setting.

However.

Loss will occur everywhere and it is not always identifiable or preventable. I have seen it, heard it, supported it, and lived it. It is, unfortunately, an ugly and devastating truth to being a mortal, biological being. It is as foolhardy to claim that a loss inside the system is somehow the mother’s fault as it is to claim a loss outside the system is somehow the mother’s fault. It is as foolhardy to claim every/most losses inside the system are the OB’s/midwife’s fault as it is to claim that every/most losses outside the system are the unlicensed midwife’s/RBK’s/mother’s/sister’s/mentor’s leader’s fault. There is too much nuance. There is SO much gray area. There is too much pain. There is too much beauty. There is too much darkness. There is too much light. So many of the people in this reddit talking about “loss in the community” just do not have a clue what they’re talking about. And thank God you don’t. None of us want you to know what it’s like. We have been treading these deep, sacred, gray waters since the moment we never heard them cry. We are here to share what wisdom we have discovered to help facilitate empathy and sisterhood and healing and survival. And many of us, like Nancy and Leticia and Skye and Amana to name only a few, have put ourselves and our extremely vulnerable stories out there for this purpose. Not to push freebirth at all costs, not to bolster a dogma, not to glorify a death cult and ignorance over our babies and over life. No. We spoke out because someday, God forbid, it could be you, your sister, your daughter, your neighbor, standing in a silent room. Catatonic. With empty arms. In silence. Feeling the whiplash that is being filled with life in one moment, and in the next suddenly completely void of it. Wondering what the fuck just happened? Did that just happen? Is this real? What do I do? Is this my fault? How did it transpire this way? Whose fault is it? Can I live? Can I live? Can. I. Live???

And we hope that somehow one of our stories makes it to you. And that no matter what happened, you can feel hope. You can take a breath. You can cry. You can know that you are not alone. You can know that your baby still matters. You still matter. Your birth, even though it ended in death, was still beautiful. That healing, joy, purpose and love can still be found intertwined with the dark roots of despair, shock, devastation and pain.

You don’t know how much hurt you are causing by crusading into our bubbles of healing we have shed literal buckets of blood, sweat and tears to create. Speculate on everything else, it is warranted, we get it, and a lot of us are right there with you. But to turn back and cast judgments and assumptions over the only piece of our babies we will ever have- their birth, their purpose, their story- it is sickening. To say that we were brainwashed when what we have found in each other has been utterly life saving and so, so real… it’s sick. It’s sicker than most of the things FBS leadership has been accused of.

We are real women with real lives and real holes in our hearts that will never close or get smaller. We are not objects to be warped to serve a purpose. And neither are the memories of our children. Neither are the gifts of story we have birthed from our losses. Our perceptions of death and loss are things we pray you will never have to understand. But we do hope you will hold us as we navigate this never-ending journey, join us in letting there be beauty where we can find it, and empathize with the simultaneously inspiring and devastating complexity of mystery we face head-on every day. I hope you can ask yourself: can I seek justice and healing through what I know is real, or do I need to speculate and destroy all of THIS^ to feel validated enough? Is it worth it?

With love,

Ambroise’s mama.

EDIT: I wanted to add that if there are any loss mamas on here that are feeling alone or vulnerable and want to connect, I am available for that. No matter what your story is, how you are processing things, what you believe happened, I am here to hold space for everything you are experiencing. I will not share your information or your story with a single soul, you don’t even have to tell me your name. (Though I may ask for your baby’s name to honor him or her, but you do not have to share that either if it feels too precious). I will not project onto your experience or co-opt it for anything. I will do my best to be as honest, frank, compassionate and understanding as I can to support you. I’ve had some women start reaching out already and if this is a need, I want to meet it. With so much love. You can direct message me on Reddit or on Instagram at @savandytx 💛


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Apr 07 '25

My story with Free Birth Society

Post image
157 Upvotes

There is more to my story Im leaving out because it’s just so much. I was involved with FBS from fall 2019 until last week.

I found FBS through the podcast. I had just met my husband, realized we would one day have children and I knew nothing about pregnancy and birth. I enjoy doing my own research. One of the first things I saw was the documentary, The Business of Being Born. That led me to searching for natural minded podcasts on pregnancy and birth on the Apple app. The algorithm landed me with the Free Birth Society podcast in early 2019. My first reaction to the first episode or two I listened to, was that it was a little too extreme for me. Though I continued listening to episode after episode. I was in awe of the women's bravery and redemptive stories, and found Emilee's interjections intriguing. Emilee's horror stories and negative reflections on the medical system, coupled with the positive reinforcement of redemptive free birth stories are the perfect recipe for someone like me, open minded, trying to figure out what I should do, to see 'wild pregnancy' & free birth as the ideal way to go about any future experience I would have. I tend towards black and white thinking, and the ideology was very clearly laid out in episode after episode.

Hospitals = poison, exposure, coercion, abuse, disempowering

Free birth = autonomous, natural, private, safe, transformative, EMPOWERING (intentionally using this because Emilee hates this word)

I binge listened to every episode until I was up to date. I heard about the mighty networks private membership group via the podcast. I joined in fall 2019 excited to interact with like minded women.

It's worth noting that in 2018 I had come out of a seriously emotionally and verbally abusive seven year relationship with a male career mentor. I was looking for a new direction and I found FBS just after I had learned harms of hormonal birth control and was trying to live as naturally as possible. Free birth society being a community of women who were into natural health, aware of abusive dynamics, and many of who had walked the path of pregnancy and motherhood before me- it was too irresistible not to join. I had been socially isolated by my abuser for many years and this was the perfect place to make new connections.

I bought the Complete Guide to Freebirth to educate myself more. I remember being disappointed it didn’t have any details of birth physiology but if they said it was complete enough, I guess that’s all I needed to know.

Spring 2020 rolled around and it felt good to be connected to people who thought the same things about the pandemic and masking etc as me. This is when the price of membership increased from $100 annually to $500 annually. But you could be "grandmothered" in for $299... I remember feeling unhappy about this but didn't want to lose connection so stayed in.

At some point in 2020 I had my first interaction with Emilee. I signed up for a coaching call with her, interested in finding out details on how to run a women's circle. I remember feeling like she was annoyed by me, and my questions about women's circles. Which was confusing because, she talked about them on the podcast so much. She reluctantly answered my questions about how I would go about starting my own circle and seemed relieved when the time was up.

Later in the year I went to a sleepover at Emilee's house. She mentioned to me and my husband she was interested in getting people together to go in on the land purchase next to her house property (eventually became festival grounds). I'm glad we never got involved that deeply, though I thoroughly entertained the idea. In the middle of the Covid era it seemed brilliant to live communally with like minded people... My husband has always been wary of Emilee and Yolande and was the main reason my idealistic thinking never got that far. He understandably was turned off by their money grabbing and man/father hate.

At the 'sleepover' at Emilee's I loved being in person with so many kind hearted women. Emilee has an intense personality. One on one in person she reminded me of my male abuser. Someone who looks through you, and you can tell they are judging you. She asked about my interest in moving to the area, and I told her it was something I needed to talk with my husband about before committing to anything but that I was interested. She looked at me strangely. No comment. (In future I would hear because of this, she told someone my husband was abusive)

I convinced my husband that I needed to invest $6,000 in the RBK school, because I felt ‘called’. Now in hindsight, I think I just felt like I was missing out if I didn’t do it. I asked all the women at the sleepover who did it, if they liked it and thought it was worth it etc and they all gave great reviews. I was having a bit of a career crisis at the time too, so it was a perfect storm. There was zero information on the physiological birth process, once again in RBK. I was disappointed but at this point I was drinking the kool aid and believed it was unimportant. Just get out of the way and let birth happen. Right?

I attended a few more gatherings with FBS women. A gathering in Texas and the women’s rights protest in DC. I met Paula at the Texas gathering, and we became friends there. My husband and I moved to South Carolina that summer 2021 about 3 hours away from ES land where Paula built her yurt.

I helped care for Paula’s dog while she was away and she occasionally came to visit us. I remember her telling me how ES was a toxic person to be around. I believe/d her. From my experience with abusers, I knew charismatic leader coupled with revolving door of “besties” was a red flag. I remember Paula telling me she didn’t intend to stay there and how ES flipped on her verbal agreement to pay her back. That’s certainly out of integrity on ES part. She PREACHES living in integrity in her work. Very hypocritical and “low vibe!” Paula kept me filled in on the situation and she was staying at my house, along with another FBS member friend, when I received the email in this post, kicking me out of the membership without warning. I was not trying to hide my friendship with Paula, and she must have seen an Instagram photo or something that alerted her to our association together. Emilee also kicked out the other woman who was with us. In hindsight I didn’t realize how serious the lawsuit was for either of them and thought it was reckless that they had no written agreement.

Up to this point I had been supporting Paula in her understandable distress. Now that it became clear the leader of the group I had become so grateful for, deemed it impossible for me to remain uninvolved, I was forced to choose.

Do I cut ties with Paula, someone who has been a good friend, to benefit from continued access to the FBS network while I’m beginning my first journey of pregnancy and birth? I had spent almost $1,000 on tickets to MRF for that upcoming summer, and another close friend had bought tickets and plane tickets to fly to my house to go with me. I was also newly pregnant and nervous.

I decided to call ES to ask to hear her side of the story. In our phone call, she said things about Paula and the lawsuit that made me question my friend. I remember part of me was hearing ES manipulation of me and heard a few red flags, but I didn’t want to leave the network. And I wasn’t sure how to approach Paula about the things ES said about her and admit that I considered they could be true. It was easier for me to act out of fear. To double down on FBS and prove my loyalty🤮 to ES by renouncing Paula.

Without any more discussion with Paula, I sent her a mean message saying she wasn’t who I thought she was and more, and I blocked her. For that, I am ashamed. I was reinstated back into the membership. I conceived my first during all of this and so it was not hard to put it behind me and look forward. The next FBS gathering I attended was MRF 22 just several months later. I had a relatively peaceful/blissful pregnancy. I struggled with pelvic pain but I wasn’t aware that it was an issue.

Fast forward to my labor at 41 weeks. I was in labor for 5 days and nights before I decided to transfer. My intuition told me I needed help. I’m glad I went and got their help because by the time my baby was born the doctor told me there was an infection developing in my uterus. I will never know what would have happened had I not transferred, but I felt I did the best I could.

Until I had time for the free birth dogma to eat away at me. Did I really need to transfer? What would have happened had I not done so? I scheduled a coaching call with ES, desperate to “turn my trauma into power.” She told me she believed my baby would have been born just fine had I stayed home longer. I felt worse after the call.

Women were sympathetic to my story in the membership and I did not feel shamed by them. But over the next months I became very angry every time I saw a post of a birth that wasn’t a week long ordeal like mine and so decided I needed to take a break. I was inactive for about 2 years, until shortly before I was sent the Reddit.

I didn’t realize in that time I was gone, nearly all women I had met over the years had been excommunicated. It also seemed like I was hearing and seeing more birth injuries with long term consequences and mortalities amongst the group. The membership was also less interesting in general because there was no difference of opinion anymore. Like all the color was gone. I didn’t realize how harsh the censorship had gotten.

I felt misaligned and decided to make a goodbye post in the hopes of waking up more women to the bullshit. My post was deleted after a few hours and my access revoked, even though I had just paid my annual subscription 6 weeks ago. I asked for a refund and they said no refund, but we will give you access for the remainder of the year if you want.

Hell no! So long FBS

I’m keeping my name out of this because I have somewhat of a high profile job in my local community and want to remain anonymous.

*PS I heard the MMI $12,000 program also has no coverage of the physiological birth process. Doesn’t even contain any documents! It’s just them blabbing about birth theory and birth attendant theory. I can see it for what it really is, now that I’m out. Thank you to the brave women who started speaking out and started the Reddit.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Nov 26 '25

A reminder to be respectful in this space.

155 Upvotes

Hi. Mods here. With the Guardian articles out, we’re getting a lot of new users. Welcome.

Consider this a friendly reminder to new and old users alike to adhere to rule number 1: Be respectful, empathetic and curious.

If you see people calling other women idiots, or blaming women for having trusted the wrong people and gotten hoodwinked or just being unnecessarily judgmental or disrespectful, or any equivilant of “well why didn’t you just leave?” report it so we can review it more easily. Do that by clicking the 3 dots (…)

We are here to share, grow and learn. NOT to tear each other down, point fingers or blame one another. Blame the fraudsters for their fraud all you want, however.

We don’t all have to agree. We don’t have to want to birth the same way. We don’t have to have the same opinions. But we can disagree with decency, even here on Reddit.

Thank you.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Oct 04 '25

Births Gone Wrong I wish I never found FBS

154 Upvotes

I grew up knowing I would birth at home, just like my mom did. She had a midwife before they became regulated here in Canada, and advocated for them to become a regulated profession and to increase women’s access to midwives.

FBS came into my Instagram algorithm about a year before I conceived. I started consuming the videos and the messaging, started listening to the podcast every time I drove. Emilee is so passionate and I enjoyed listening to it, learning about med-wives and how natural birth is. I regurgitated “if you can get pregnant, you can birth your baby. It’s the same physiological process as taking a poop”.

I attended MRF. I joined the lighthouse and got pregnant, then met some great women in my area. Once pregnant, I was a bit confused because everybody I knew would go to the doctor once they’re pregnant, but I decided not to after learning about these cool women and wild pregnancies. Why would I sabotage my pregnancy and birth by “entering the medical system”?

I had a pretty nice pregnancy, and did feel isolated from loved ones because I felt like I had to hide my lack or prenatal care and birth plans, and “protect myself”. I took on the responsibility of managing my own prenatal care. I wanted a “wise woman” at my birth. I found traditional birth companions and interviewed 2. The first listed that she had neonatal resuscitation training and I brought that up in the lighthouse. Emilee said that she would run the opposite way. I didn’t want that “fear” brought into my labour and birth (what?!). I met another TBC once who had freebirthed herself and planned to call her if I needed her. My partner and was agreeable in being my birth support. I did the Complete Guide to Freebirth. I went into labour at 41w1d as I was going to bed. Once my waters broke, there was meconium in the bath water and I could feel bum. I wasn’t worried because “breech is a variation of normal”. I had thought baby may have been breech, and thought about spinning babies or breech without borders, but the lighthouse’s messaging was that it was all unnecessary. I laboured for 23 hours, in all of the positions. My partner called the TBC who we had met once, but I wasn’t comfortable inviting her and we all thought the birth was imminent. I didn’t want to let anyone into my space. My partner supported me as best he could, but he too was exhausted. He tried playing midwife/ doula, but albeit, he is not. No sleep, constant puking, trying to ride the contraction waves that were rocking me, trying so damn hard to “meet my baby”, trying to rest and “transmute the pain”.

My intuition was that I needed help, so we drove 30 minutes away to the hospital. No prenatal care, fully dilated, 10pm, the OB told me that I could try to birth vaginally but if the baby gets stuck there’s nothing she can do, and it could suffocate and she’s seen it happen. I had already admitted defeat and accepted that this would end in a csection if I went to the hospital. “If you don’t want surgery, don’t go to where they preform surgeries”. But I needed help and was concerned about my baby at that point.

A few months later, a woman “in the system” just birthed her breech baby vaginally at that same hospital, because that was the plan and she was prepared and supported.

I was in the lighthouse during the stories of loss. This Reddit thread started in my 3rd trimester but I stayed away. Obviously I’m grateful I have a healthy alive baby, and, what about me? I hate that my body was cut open and I didn’t get to experience vaginal birth. I didn’t get that “initiation” into motherhood.

My biggest lesson has been to let people in. Get support. I didn’t have to do this alone. I’m exhausted and burnt out and untangling myself from the FBS influence while learning to mother. I’d like to call my doctor, tell her that I have a 5 month old daughter, that my mental health is brutal, maybe get some labs done and engage with the big bad medical system.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Apr 24 '26

This Sub Succeeded

152 Upvotes

I got an email from FBS this morning about a nonsense ✨container✨ at the low ‘founder’ price of 5k. It has nothing to do with birth. It’s in line with the grifter gals who life coach and get you to your Highest Self™️ with vibes based credentials.

That prompted me to check on Yo. Who has really moved on from discussing birth or selling birth related products. She’s going all in on orthodoxy and being a ripped woman in middle age.

All the birth related stuff on FBS is replay. And while I don’t think it’s not harmful that they are still selling the complete guide, I think the fever dream is over and way fewer women are buying what they’re selling. Especially for the steep ass prices.

Both Em and Yo appear to agree that continuing to sell freebirth is too risky.

That wouldn’t be true without the stories this sub brought forth.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Dec 12 '25

Emilee’s First Birth

150 Upvotes

The podcast reminded me of what an insane spin she put on this story. I think Emilee ( and Yolande) have a great need to be in opposition to things, it soothes something in them, some feeling of specialness. I find that the hospital story a huge insight into what the fuck is wrong with her and it was the first crack for me in her persona.

Like, you went to the hospital seeking help and they helped you, as you asked for and as they were equipped to do (and as you were not equipped to do). Then you took the feeling of reassurance that THEY gave you, reframed it as self-empowerment (??), reframed their help as unwanted, and framed your own presence there as somehow forced, and your own decision to leave, which was unchallenged in every way, as heroic.

Girl, what’s wrong with you? Say thank you. Have some gratitude, have some humility, learn some nuance and wisdom from experience. Birth is a wild safari, it is not a PR experience for your brand.

You asked for help and it was mercifully given, a privilege not all woman have been given. Many of our grandmothers before us and their babies have died wishing for help. If you received assistance from a medical provider, that is not a freebirth, so maybe consider that there is a vast spectrum of what constitutes a good birth, an empowered and positive birth.

But instead she doubled down, became more dogmatic, and fostered (and charged money for) an environment where women hesitated to seek the same medical help she herself sought, and many lost their babies. Emilee did not deserve to lose her baby because no one deserves that, but i truly wish for her an absolutely searing realization of what she has done. I hope it brings her to her knees, and i hope she goes forward trying to right everything that she has wrought.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Mar 26 '25

The Myth of No Good Midwives

148 Upvotes

If you're someone who would love to have a homebirth, but came away from the podcast thinking all midwives are coercive, overly medicalized, or not truly “sovereign,” I want you to know: good midwives still exist. Even if you don’t plan to hire one for your birth, having a connection with someone you trust, someone you can call during pregnancy or labor if you need support, can make all the difference. You deserve that kind of backup. I’ve seen too many women go into birth under-resourced, and I’ve seen too many preventable tragedies result from an extreme interpretation of wild pregnancy and freebirth.

One of the most damaging messages FBS has spread, in my opinion, is the myth that trustworthy midwives no longer exist—such that the only safe path to avoid medical sabotage and a c-section is 100% wild pregnancy and freebirth. While it’s true that in some countries midwifery is so heavily regulated that homebirth midwives are hard to find, in many places, including the U.S., professional homebirth midwives still practice with real autonomy. Yes, they can be hard to find, and yes, we wish there were more. But they do exist. With a little effort and discernment, you can find someone whose values align with yours and who has the experience to recognize when a pregnancy or birth is veering into tricky territory.

I was lucky to find an amazing independent Certified Professional Midwife (CPM)—someone I’d absolutely consider sovereign. I connected with her through a freebirthing friend who used her for occasional prenatal care. She never pressured me into ultrasounds or any particular kind of care. She respected my choices and never implied that I needed to meet certain requirements for her to attend my birth. She brought deep experience and deep respect for my autonomy.

Even if you don’t plan to hire a midwife for your birth, it’s invaluable to have even just a casual connection with someone who has practical midwifery skills (unlike the graduates of FBS programs) — someone you can call during pregnancy or labor if you feel the need for guidance or support. That kind of relationship can help keep you out of the hospital and out of danger. Since joining the FBS group in 2021, I’ve seen countless stories of women who planned freebirths after entirely wild pregnancies, only to end up in the ER when something came up during their (often long, exhausting) labors. And in many of those cases, I couldn’t help but think, “A skilled midwife could’ve handled that at home.”

Over the past few years in the FBS group, I’ve also read far too many heartbreaking stories of babies lost near the end of pregnancy or during birth—often following truly extreme circumstances that were brushed off as “normal” or “just a variation of normal.” Members, often echoing Emilee’s rhetoric, dismissed serious warning signs as fear, conditioning, or unnecessary concern. While not all outcomes are preventable, even in hospitals, it’s clear that this kind of dogma is having tragic consequences. To me, it’s also telling that when the FBS community first began, licensed midwives participated in the group. Now, they’re almost entirely gone.

Women deserve real support, informed care, and the freedom to make autonomous choices, without being swayed to reject every form of skilled midwifery help in the process. So if you’re considering freebirth, take the time to interview all the homebirth midwives within a few hours of you. Have direct, candid conversations. The FBS podcast actually provides some great case studies that can help you think through what to ask when speaking with midwives. Even if you ultimately choose to birth unassisted, you’ll have a sense of who you can turn to if things shift. Because when that moment comes, you want grounded, experienced, practical support—not just someone to “hold space.”

Unassisted birth isn’t inherently unsafe. I always knew I’d birth at home, and I did, with a phenomenal midwife. I also saw unassisted birth as a valid option if I couldn’t find someone I trusted. But the idea—repeated so often in FBS—that any midwife with medical training is compromised, and that everything that happens in pregnancy and birth is always normal/optimal, has left too many women alone in moments when they needed real care.

Good old-fashioned homebirth with a skilled, respectful midwife is still alive and well, and midwifery is an essential practice that should be protected and uplifted.


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Sep 15 '26

Free Birth Society The downward spiral of FBS

146 Upvotes

Just had a peek at FBS website.
The coaches are gone (as nobody booked) and ES’s private sessions have dropped from $500 an hour to $350.

MMI is done..even though ES was so elated about how “successful” it was.

YNC completely silent.

Emilee Saldaya can try convince her followers that her business is “bulletproof,” that she survived last year’s brutal onslaught ..rising like a phoenix, stronger than ever, ready to share the wisdom she gained from her loss, as she tries to grift another shameless, useless course…

But guys… I think we have officially done what we set out to do over a year ago!

I’m so proud of us!

As this space gets quieter, and many of the original members have moved on..let us never forget all the heavy lifting we did together, from across the world.

Thank you to everyone who shared and kept the momentum going. We stayed laser focused on our purpose.

It has been a privilege to be a part of this sub..not to mention the solace it has given me. Thank you!

We are true birth activists ❤️


r/FreeBirthSocietyScam • • Dec 13 '25

Episode 6 leaves it all on the field

143 Upvotes

Ilex's Mom if you're here - every word you said is a searing truth that cannot be denied. Thank you for cutting through with such clarity...

“Where does their personal radical responsibility come in and recognize the impact of their work and that women are not making their choices in a vacuum."

“And I feel pretty angry hearing them say they don’t hold any responsibility…what was the point of the work you were doing if not to influence people?”

And kudos to the podcast creators for all of this. This is important journalism.