You can find me on Substack
——
In May of 2021 I joined an online membership promising me a safe place within a circle of authentic sisterhood. There was a deal swirling around which allowed me to secure the discounted price of $299 per year which felt like a steal compared to the usual annual price of $499. After all, can you really put a price tag on connection and sisterhood?
Once I passed the gatekeepers with a one on one Zoom interview, I was let into the membership, encouraged to introduce myself, free to explore the past threads and invited to join the live calls. Immediately I sensed a sort of cliquish energy, noticing that some women within the membership had more of a say than others. Their posts seemed of more value. Their opinions held in higher regard. I quickly realized that these women were part of Emilee’s inner circle and that translated into this virtual space.
I joined the first community call with Emilee as host and was immediately put off by her energy. There was a lack of warmth to her, an uninviting presence. Almost like she didn’t want to be there, but she had to be. I ignored those feelings because I had been finding such value in the past threads of mothers sharing their experiences on everything from fevers, food, conception and all other topics I currently was interested in learning about.
That winter I reached out to one of the women I had connected with through the membership stating I was about to join the Radical Birthkeeper School. Having just completed the program herself she insisted she speak with me on the phone before I make that choice. She shared how she does not advise I waste my money as the school is not what it claims to be, how she wishes she could get her $6,000 back, how it was a mistake. I trusted this woman so I decided against taking the course.
In February, after a wild pregnancy, I freebirthed a beautiful baby boy with Down syndrome. I was given a lot of support from the women in the membership as I navigated that realization, but not from Emilee. The following month, after I completed my first 40 days, we closed on a home a few towns over from Emilee. We moved from Black Mountain out to Murphy, NC where I continued my healing and processing. At 5 months old I took my son to get an echocardiogram after noticing some concerning signs. I am so thankful I did as he had a large hole in his heart that would require surgical repair, which he received a month after that echo.
We arrived home from Charleston in October. The colors were warm and the air was crisp since we were last here, nature ready for the season of release. So much had changed, outwardly but also inwardly. Watching your baby be ushered into the operating room will do that to a mother. There is no way I was going to remain the same. Upon arriving home there was a tenderness of my soul unlike I’ve ever known. The past 17 months had been spent holding so much throughout my pregnancy, birth, postpartum and my baby’s open heart surgery. I was ready to be held. I continued showing up within the community, despite feelings of exhaustion from the bi-weekly trips back to Asheville for post-op appointments and the long list of daily medication distribution which disrupted our much needed sleep. During this time I still hadn’t crossed paths with Emilee as she was newly postpartum. We were constantly circling around one another. I had been sharing my journey within the membership, intimate details of my precious son’s surgery and recovery. There were moments when I wondered why she’d never reached out to offer her support, let alone acknowledge my posts within the group. I accredited my feelings to being overly sensitive and instead of taking offense, I sent her messages of postpartum support. She sent a reply inviting me to a women’s circle on her land in a few weeks which I happily accepted.
November was coming to an end. I met one of the women in a local coffee shop to connect over chai lattes. I brought her a gift of chocolate covered almonds from my home and we shared stories of our past and how we came to live in North Carolina. I asked her about the plans she had for Thanksgiving to which she briefly mentioned going to Emilee’s house. Days later I reached out to one of the other women I had grown a friendship with, inviting her family to my house for the holiday, excitedly sharing my plans to make a cheesecake from scratch for the first time. She told me to let her know how it turns out, but didn’t acknowledge my invite. I began to wonder if everyone was going to Emilee’s. I spent the next week waiting for an invitation that never came.
I woke on Thanksgiving morning with a stiff neck. We had no plans that day, we were unable to travel to be with family due to my son’s recovery and I felt the crushing weight of feeling excluded. Nothing prepared me for the visual of seeing the Instagram posts of that day as an outsider. Happening a short 40 minutes from our home, the children’s table full of the kids my son had played with at a birthday party a few days prior. The women I had grown friendships with all circling the table, smiles on their faces, home-cooked food filling their plates. 9 families. My family, the only one not invited.
I wish I could say I put on a happy face and made my baby’s first Thanksgiving a memorable one, but that’s not what happened. It was a somber day with physical pain and even greater emotional pain. I didn’t understand why we’d been excluded when I had been showing up within her membership for 2 years and within the local community for the past 6 months. I’d had some of those women to my home, they walked my land and ate my food. My toddler had played with their children. I imagined if the roles were reversed, of course I would’ve extended an invite. Welcomed them in with an open heart. Fed them, gave them a warm hug with words of encouragement and acknowledgment of all they’d recently been through. Why wasn’t I receiving this authentic sisterhood I’d been sold on?
Thanksgiving was the first time I realized we were on the outside of all of it. Being the only family excluded from that dinner was painful and brought up so many feelings in regards to belonging and worthiness. I questioned why. I wondered what more I could have done to be included. Sharing my heart and my story on the FBS Membership for two years, showing up to multiple women’s circles and gatherings, being a friend… none of that was enough. How could these women exclude me after knowing what I had just endured in the past year? It had only been two months since my freebirthed son had his chest sliced open during open-heart surgery. What I needed more than ever was loving women to hold me. Surely there was enough compassion to be invited in!
I pushed it all down and committed to showing up to the women’s circle Emilee had invited me to a few weeks before Thanksgiving, even though it took a lot of courage to attend that day. During the circle I quickly realized it was unlike any I had ever experienced. Most circles I had attended up until that point allowed the women to share without crosstalk or interjection. This circle felt like an interrogation. Who am I? Where did I come from? Did my baby “really need” open-heart surgery? I shared my story, feeling uncomfortable while doing so, knowing Emilee wasn’t asking from a place of love. The circle continued on, everyone talking in their own conversations. That’s when I heard it. Emilee sharing a story about Johnny, following it with a big smile and the words, “He’s just RETARDED like that.”
I stopped breathing in that moment. I glanced around at some of the other women, hoping someone would speak the words that I couldn’t seem to find in that moment. Emilee cast down her eyes and looked to the side. I wondered if she recognized what she’d said, but instead, she lifted her head and began telling a different story. My heart was shattered. I always imagined the first time I would hear the word used after birthing a baby with Down syndrome would be by a punk teenager on the street. To hear it used by the “leader” of a community, to hear it used in what is meant to be a safe space such as a women’s circle, to be seated in a circle with 10+ other women who didn’t hear/care/speak up… I was heartbroken. What does this mean for my son and his future here? Was the reason Emilee never showed support for me and my baby because he has Down syndrome? How could she so freely use the word “retarded” in a women’s circle after I had just finished sharing the story of birthing a baby with Down syndrome?
I pondered these questions for days, then called one of the women present that night. I asked her opinion on how she thinks I should move forward regarding this. Her response to me was, “You can’t police other people’s choice of words.” It was disappointing to hear, but in my desperation to be accepted, I decided to let it go. Surely she didn’t even notice what she’d said. Forgive. If it is used again, address it lovingly. Forgive. Forgive. Forgive. But it continued to eat away at me as I felt a fierce protectiveness over my son. If this word is being used so casually, and possibly around the children within the community, it is only a matter of time before they begin to use the word themselves. What are we teaching them?
It was a few days after this circle that I got a voice note from Emilee. When I saw her name pop up on my phone, for a second, I believed it was to apologize for being careless with her words, for her lack of sensitivity to me and my situation. That is not what it was about. She, in a phony-sounding voice, asked me if I’d be interested in financially contributing to the new school property with her and Arielle. A few weeks ago I was too much of a stranger to be invited to Thanksgiving. Now, after a single two-hour circle, I was close enough to be a partner in a $400k purchase? I declined. I felt sick to my stomach. All along the way my body kept giving me signs that this group of women wasn’t aligning with my values, my heart. Why was I pushing so hard to be accepted in?
I would continuously be left out in the following weeks. The group chat, dinners that I’d see happening on Instagram, a Christmas parade where, once again, we were the only family not invited. My sons missing out again. Many times I had decided it was time to let it all go. But something kept me coming back… my children. I could endure so much pain and so much rejection for the sake of my children. I wanted them to have meaningful connections with children from like-minded families. I wanted a community for them. I was slowly building friendships with some of the women, so there were moments of hope. Or so I told myself. Having my toddler attend school with the other children was what got me through during the month of December. The night of the women’s circle, Emilee had invited my 3 year old son to join the Yurt School in the new year. It was my light at the end of what seemed to be never-ending darkness. He would benefit so greatly from it. But as it turned out, our experience at Yurt School would cause emotional damage that would take years to heal.
“Hey, I don’t think we’ve ever talked about you coming on the podcast! Let’s do it!” I receive this text from Emilee, and without hesitation, I respond, “Oh, I’ll have to think about that one! I’m a bit camera-shy!” No response. Minutes later, an email lands in my inbox, requesting to schedule a day to record an episode of the Freebirth Society Podcast. So much for honoring my need to think about it. I choose January 20th and try to convince myself that a month will be enough time to work up the nerve, not to be on camera, but to sit one-on-one with Emilee and share the most intimate story I have.
Orientation day for YurtSchool was concerning. There were only two children there. Right away, I could tell the teacher was not a real teacher, at least not in the sense I had imagined. She mentioned that when one of the children was choking on a beef stick, she stuck her finger down his throat to fish it out. I didn’t say anything then but later sent her a message, telling her that is not what you do if a child is choking. I asked if she knew the Heimlich maneuver or CPR. She responded that she was certified, but it had been a long time and that she would sign up for a child-specific certification that night.
I wasn’t entirely comfortable sending my newly three year old son alone the next day, so I texted Emilee, asking if I could shadow him one more day. I shared that I wanted to see how the teacher handled the full roster of children. I expressed my concern about the safety of the large pond that sits just below the yurt. Emilee seemed defensive and told me, “That’s not really how we do things.” So I compromised, I decided to send him for only two hours and visit with one of the women in a nearby yurt. Halfway through, I texted to check in and was told he was doing well, observing and smiling. When I picked him up, I asked the teacher if she thought he’d do better with a longer stretch of time at the next school day. She assured me, confidently, that he would do great.
That Thursday, I left him for a total of three hours. During his time at school, I received an Instagram message from one of the dads. He had dropped his son off a bit late that morning and saw my son in the little red car at the playground, smiling and having so much fun. That gave me peace of mind. When I arrived to pick him up, he was playing with one of the girls. I told him it was time to go, so they began singing the Clean Up song while putting away their toys. The other children walked us to the door, giving him high-fives and fist bumps as we left.
The next school day was going to be a rainy day, which meant the children would likely be inside all day. I had heard the boys were more physically aggressive on days like that. When we arrived, one of the women came too close with her puppy and it jumped on him, which scared him. That made him clingy when I tried to leave, but eventually, he sat down to play, and all was well. The YurtSchool group chat conversation throughout the day about the boys' physicality made me nervous. When my son came home, I asked about his day. He began talking about “hitting.” I wasn’t sure if he was saying he had been hit or if he had witnessed someone else being hit. So I asked in the chat for clarification and was told by the other women that my son hadn’t been involved in any of the incidents that day.
When Emilee called that night, I assumed it was to clarify what had happened with the hitting at school earlier. I imagined she would share her plan to make the pond safer. I hoped she would explain how the teacher actually is qualified and capable.
Instead, she told me that because my son is “nonverbal in school” and “doesn’t play with the other children,” autism was suspected. I couldn’t breathe. Of all things, I was not expecting this. Was this really happening? She said there was suspicion that my child is “on the spectrum” and because of that he is “not a good fit” for the school she was creating. My heart pounded. I felt like I was going to throw up. I tried explaining that he is very verbal at home and that perhaps he wasn’t playing with the others because he has never been in a social environment like this before. It might take time and some patience from the teacher! She then proceeded to read me a list of autism signs from the internet. I was shaking. I told her his behaviors stem from what our family has endured over the past few years—a possible insecure attachment. She dismissed it outright. “That wouldn’t be the reason,” she said. “All the kids are ‘Covid kids,’ and they aren’t showcasing these behaviors.” She ignored everything I said about my son. About my family. About our life. Emilee knew, without ever meeting my son, mind you, that it was most likely autism. Knowing my son, I knew intuitively this was an incorrect assumption. It felt like I was speaking to a pediatrician who was trying to tell me something about my own child, as if they knew him better than I did. Why was this woman doing the exact thing she warns mothers about when dealing with the medical establishment? In that phone call, she tried to convince me my child was autistic. She gaslit me repeatedly. She was matter-of-fact. She sounded, almost, happy? This was how she would get rid of me, of my family, for good. Exclude us from the school was to exclude us fully. I hung up that call feeling confused and angry. This was the final sign I needed to walk away from it all.
That night, I couldn’t sleep. I cried so deeply that my ancestors couldn’t bear the sound of my sadness. They joined me in the quiet dark and wept with me. I grabbed my stomach. It felt like I was trying to grasp my womb, my pain. I dug my hands into the place that hurt the most. Pain caused by other women is felt right there. As my sons slept soundly, I came undone.
The next morning I logged onto the membership and deleted every post I had made, which was many as I’d been very active over the two years since I joined. I left the one where I shared about the birth of my son. I wanted women who gave birth to a baby with Down syndrome to be able to find me. I then sent an email to cancel my membership.
After that, I sent a long, detailed message to the group chat. The ending read: “I was supposed to share my story on the FBS Podcast next week. I’ve decided not to. It doesn’t feel aligned to get on a webcam and share my story when, all along the way, I was shown no true compassion in real life. What I realize is that my time and experience with the Hayesville community is part of my story, it is still unfolding. All of the children are beautiful, perfect, and worthy. Even the ones who show aggression and hit. Even the ones you suspect have special needs. Especially those children. May the babies growing in the wombs of the women within this community be accepted and supported, no matter their abilities. That is my prayer. The YurtSchool email ended by saying, ‘The school is at the center of this village we are creating.’ But we are no longer part of the school. And we were never truly welcomed into this village.”
———
March, 2025
My eyes watch his little body move across the grass of his play school, his mouth wide in a fit of laughter. The warm South Florida sun causes sweat to drip down his skin. He runs alongside his friends, hopping onto a tricycle. One sweet child sits in the front, while he and another take the back. They zoom around the walkway until they are done with the trike. Now they grab paintbrushes, painting pictures of swimming pools and giraffes. Next, they greet a centipede. Someone picks it up and sticks it toward one of the girls, who screeches in both fright and delight. They all run inside. Music is playing. I watch his little body dance. They all dance until they declare themselves tired. And now, they are ready for a snack. He chooses carrots and a rice cake with sunflower butter, then sits between his two best friends. They’ve hardly stopped laughing this whole time. I watch his eyes light up. I watch him simply be five.
———-
You can find me here
https://substack.com/elleburdi