r/Forex_Reddit • • 18h ago

How prop firms make money

2 Upvotes

In this post I will explain how prop firms make money, mathematically speaking.
We will get all the figures, profit targets & rules of the challenge, get their hypothetical odds, and turn them into RTP (Return to player). If the RTP is over 100% it means that the house is Losing money (mathematically), while if it’s under 97% it means that you’re better off gambling that money on roulette.

We will be using a one step challenge by aifo (not affiliated) as reference.
Using 2 step challenges, and trailing down downs complicates things a bit, and I can’t get into that in this post.

So they have this one step challenge that costs 99usd, with a max loss(static) of 600$ (which is the actual balance of the account, the account size does not matter), and a profit target of 1k$ . If you pass that challenge, the balance resets to the initial 600$.

We will assume that every trade, with a 1:1RR has a 50% chance of succeeding.

So once you have passed the account, you can bet all of that on one trade, and have a 50% chance to cash out 600$ (or blow the account up).

You are essentially paying the house 99$ to get a chance to win 600$.

Now let’s calculate the odds of you actually being able to pull that off.

Step 1: calculate the odds of passing the challenge

6/(10 +6) =0.375 so 37.5% (max drawdown /(target + max drawdown), gamblers ruin model look it up).

Step 2 : calculate the odds of us winning the 600$ when. The challenge is passed (it’s 50%, assuming that nothing is rigged against us)

Step 3: calculate the actual odds of us winning the 600$

37.75% x 50% =18.75%

We have an 18.75% chance of winning it all.

Let’s calculate the RTP now.

RTP = (reward x odds of reward)/ cost to participate

So (18.75 x 600)/99

Which comes at 113.64% RTP, that is IF we were to get the full 600$, but we actually don’t. We get to keep 80% of it (reward share). So we’re actually getting ti keep 480$.

The new RTP is 90.91% (way worse than roulette and regulated slot games).

And it doesn’t stop there.

I did not factor in the following rules that completely breach the contract

- odds of you losing more than 3% in a day
- odds of you using a vpn while placing a trade
- all the swap fees & spread that they charge you on the demo account.

And many, many other factors, that if combined will reduce your RTP by at least 10% more.


r/Forex_Reddit • • 1d ago

Bitcoin Could Still Drop to $50K Before a Major Reversal

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 1d ago

AUDUSD today: bounce into resistance while the bigger trend stays heavy

Post image
2 Upvotes

AUDUSD still looks pressured overall.

News flow leans against the Aussie, with weak labor conditions, cut speculation, and commodity softness weighing on sentiment. On the other side, the dollar stays supported by hawkish policy expectations, firm real yields, and some safe-haven demand.

Positioning is heavily long, which can add contrarian downside risk. On the chart, the short-term move up looks more like a corrective bounce inside a broader downtrend, with resistance overhead and support being tested.

Do you see this bounce fading, or can AUDUSD hold up a bit longer?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 1d ago

Be honest: What breaks your trading discipline most? 👇 #TradingPsychology #ForexTrading

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 1d ago

Introducing r/Brokshield! Here's what we're all about 👉

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 2d ago

your position size formula has two inputs you almost certainly assumed, and both of them change per instrument

3 Upvotes

Nearly got myself badly oversized on gold and only caught it because the margin number looked wrong.

Position size is risk amount divided by stop distance times pip value. Everyone knows that part.

Pip value depends on contract size, and contract size is not a constant. For FX a standard lot is 100,000 units of the base currency, and that’s stable enough that you stop thinking about it. Then you move to something else and the assumption silently fails.

Gold is the classic one. One lot is 100 ounces at most brokers and 10 at some. Same symbol, same price, one order of magnitude difference in what 0.1 lots means. If you carry over your FX habit of “0.1 lots feels about right” you can be ten times the position you intended and nothing on the screen looks unusual.

Indices are worse, because the contract is a multiplier per point rather than a quantity, and it varies by instrument and by broker.

And for crosses where neither currency is your account currency, pip value involves a conversion, so it drifts as that rate moves.

The second input: leverage is per instrument, not per account

This is the one I’d never understood. The retail cap isn’t a single number for your account. Under the ASIC and FCA regimes it’s tiered by instrument class, roughly 30:1 on major pairs, 20:1 on minors and gold, 10:1 on other commodities and non major indices, 5:1 on individual shares.

So margin consumed per unit of notional varies by something like a factor of six across instruments you can trade from the same account. “My leverage is 30:1” is true for majors and wrong for most other things.

Which means a strategy ported from EUR/USD to another instrument needs both inputs re-derived, not one. I’ve seen people conclude a broker had changed something when they’d simply moved to a 10:1 instrument.

The two minute habit

Before the first trade on any instrument I haven’t traded before: open the symbol specification and read contract size and the margin requirement. Every platform has those fields, so this is a look rather than a support ticket.

What varies is what’s in them. Gold at 100 ounces is the usual convention and mine follows it, which is the only reason my FX sized assumptions didn’t blow up when I moved across. That’s Axi, If yours runs 10 ounce gold contracts it isn’t wrong, but every mental shortcut you’ve built on standard sizing is out by a factor of ten and nothing will warn you.

Then compute pip value from the contract size rather than reusing the number in your head.

Has anyone been caught out by contract size, and on what? Gold is my guess for the most common one.

And did you know leverage was tiered by instrument, or did you also think it was an account setting?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 2d ago

USDJPY update: short-term bullish inside a bigger range

Post image
1 Upvotes

USDJPY still looks like a short-term bullish move inside a wider sideways market.

News flow leans in the dollar’s favor, with USD sentiment strong over the last 24 hours, while JPY sentiment stays clearly negative. That keeps the pair supported for now.

Positioning is still net short, which can help squeeze price higher. On the chart, price pushed above the recent 158-160 congestion and keeps printing higher lows. Main support is around 156-157, while resistance sits near 160.8-161.5.

Do you think it breaks higher from here, or stalls again near resistance?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 3d ago

💎 DIAMOND GEEZER — PREMARKET PULSE

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 3d ago

Where would you draw resistance on this EUR/USD chart?

Post image
2 Upvotes

In August 2025, EUR/USD daily reference rates reached 1.1715, 1.1708, and 1.1713 on three separate dates. That gives us three observations clustered within seven pips. The chart uses daily reference rates, so intraday highs can differ.

Would you mark a single level around 1.1710, draw a narrow zone, or wait for more evidence? What rule would you use consistently when reviewing similar setups?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 3d ago

Fx Jordan (Fx Alexg friend) Remember him??RIP

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Anyone following his supply and demand strategy???


r/Forex_Reddit • • 3d ago

Should I stop using Oanda for forex? If so, what should I use instead?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

No oanda manipulation chart is really bad ... Is impossible to make money on oanda platform... The spread only goes against you if you look alive chart it will sure NOT match after the trade is open ... They are pretty much a scam...

One of the biggest scammers I ever seen


r/Forex_Reddit • • 4d ago

Lot sizing between accounts of different sizes: a worked example

1 Upvotes

Running the same idea on more than one account catches people out, so here's the arithmetic I use.

Say your setup is 1.00 lot on a 50k account. Put that same 1.00 lot on a 10k account and you're risking five times as much of it. Same trade, completely different exposure.

The simple fix is a ratio. 10,000 / 50,000 = 0.2, so 1.00 lot becomes 0.20 lot and both accounts risk the same percentage.

Two things that quietly break that:

Rounding. A 0.07 source lot at 0.2x is 0.014. With a 0.01 step it rounds to 0.01, which is about 29% less than you meant. Worse, a 0.03 lot at 0.2x is 0.006, under the 0.01 minimum, so the order can just get refused and you end up with the trade on one account only.

Balance or equity. If you size off balance, an account that's in drawdown keeps carrying its original share, which is more than it should. Equity tracks what the account actually has right now. I use equity for this, but I know people who deliberately don't.

Also worth checking the smaller account can carry the size at its leverage and margin. A rejected order is worse than a smaller one, because you don't find out until the trade you wanted is already gone.

Honestly though, the ratio is the second step, not the first. Pick a risk percentage per trade, work the size back from your stop distance on each account, and then compare that with what the ratio gave you. If they disagree badly, the ratio is usually the one that's wrong.

How do you handle it across accounts, and do you size off balance or equity?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 4d ago

Where can you see the orderbook for Forex trading? I don't see how anyone can successfully time their entries consistently, without it.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 4d ago

EURUSD Analysis for 18 Nov 2026

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 4d ago

Hey traders! 👋I'm building "Piply – An Automated Forex Trading Journal"

2 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 4d ago

Hey traders! 👋I'm building "Piply – An Automated Forex Trading Journal"

1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 5d ago

โบรกเกอร์ฟอเร็กซ์รายใดอนุญาตให้เทรด NFP CPI ตามข่าวด้วยเลเวอเรจ 1000 เท่า?

1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 5d ago

ironfx fraud reviews

2 Upvotes

i wanna sign up, but still a bit hesitant. there are both good and bad reviews. generally, what is giving me hope is their whole history, 15 years is no joke. any users here?


r/Forex_Reddit • • 6d ago

🌍 Q1: What Is Forex Trading and How Does It Work?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Forex_Reddit • • 6d ago

Help!!!!!

1 Upvotes

I live in canada and looking for good and reliable forex brokers. I have been scammed too many times.
So if anyone has suggestions, please share.


r/Forex_Reddit • • 7d ago

Need Advice on Growing a Small Trading Account – Exness

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I started trading on Exness with a $100 deposit. Initially, I managed to grow my account to $225, but unfortunately, I lost almost everything and now have only $2 left.
I can deposit another $13, which would bring my total balance to $15.
I mainly trade XAUUSD (Gold).
I’d genuinely appreciate advice from experienced traders:
Is it realistic to make profits with a $2 or $15 account?
What lot size would be appropriate for such a small balance?
Is gold trading even suitable for a $15 account? Or ethereum ?
Or if anyone here can help me and guide me in turning this into profit ?
I want to understand how to trade without repeatedly blowing my account.
Thank you!


r/Forex_Reddit • • 9d ago

SPX500 85+ points before and after trade

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

before and after buys/longs trade on spx

  1. ⁠bullish/new highs for retest for bias planned yesterday to look for buys

  2. ⁠wait for price to retrace

  3. ⁠waited for liquidity confirmation for entry


r/Forex_Reddit • • 9d ago

Looking for a Reliable Broker – No Withdrawal Issues or Scams

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m looking for recommendations for reliable, well-regulated brokers available to European traders.
Which broker do you personally use for trading, and have you ever experienced any issues withdrawing your profits? I’m particularly interested in brokers that process withdrawals smoothly, pay out your full profits without unnecessary delays or complications, and have a trustworthy reputation.
I’ve heard mixed reviews about IC Markets and RoboForex, with some traders reporting difficulties withdrawing their money.
I’d really appreciate hearing about your personal experiences and recommendations. Thanks!


r/Forex_Reddit • • 10d ago

How legit Trading Sphere broker is?

3 Upvotes

Was surprised that not many of reviews are online, and then I found out that this is a relatively new platform. Being new is not bad, but I don't want to end up in a trap. Can anyone share his opinion on how legit the broker is?