r/Forex_Reddit • u/New_Leg3640 • 18h ago
How prop firms make money
In this post I will explain how prop firms make money, mathematically speaking.
We will get all the figures, profit targets & rules of the challenge, get their hypothetical odds, and turn them into RTP (Return to player). If the RTP is over 100% it means that the house is Losing money (mathematically), while if it’s under 97% it means that you’re better off gambling that money on roulette.
We will be using a one step challenge by aifo (not affiliated) as reference.
Using 2 step challenges, and trailing down downs complicates things a bit, and I can’t get into that in this post.
So they have this one step challenge that costs 99usd, with a max loss(static) of 600$ (which is the actual balance of the account, the account size does not matter), and a profit target of 1k$ . If you pass that challenge, the balance resets to the initial 600$.
We will assume that every trade, with a 1:1RR has a 50% chance of succeeding.
So once you have passed the account, you can bet all of that on one trade, and have a 50% chance to cash out 600$ (or blow the account up).
You are essentially paying the house 99$ to get a chance to win 600$.
Now let’s calculate the odds of you actually being able to pull that off.
Step 1: calculate the odds of passing the challenge
6/(10 +6) =0.375 so 37.5% (max drawdown /(target + max drawdown), gamblers ruin model look it up).
Step 2 : calculate the odds of us winning the 600$ when. The challenge is passed (it’s 50%, assuming that nothing is rigged against us)
Step 3: calculate the actual odds of us winning the 600$
37.75% x 50% =18.75%
We have an 18.75% chance of winning it all.
Let’s calculate the RTP now.
RTP = (reward x odds of reward)/ cost to participate
So (18.75 x 600)/99
Which comes at 113.64% RTP, that is IF we were to get the full 600$, but we actually don’t. We get to keep 80% of it (reward share). So we’re actually getting ti keep 480$.
The new RTP is 90.91% (way worse than roulette and regulated slot games).
And it doesn’t stop there.
I did not factor in the following rules that completely breach the contract
- odds of you losing more than 3% in a day
- odds of you using a vpn while placing a trade
- all the swap fees & spread that they charge you on the demo account.
And many, many other factors, that if combined will reduce your RTP by at least 10% more.