r/FoodNYC
•
u/KindOfSleepyBadger
•
6h ago
Discussion At the risk of blowing up some favorites, here are my most underrated spots in the city.
*Disclaimers
1. "Underrated" is not the same as "totally unknown." These are places that seem to me to be under-patronized and under-hyped relative to how good they are. That said...
2. It's hard to know with full certainty how 'popular' a spot is, so I'm basing this off of how busy they were when I've gone, review counts on Google/Yelp/Beli, follower counts on Instagram, and how much I've seen them talked about here, then comparing that to how popular I personally think they deserve to be.
Lillo Cucina Italiano
The inspiration for this post. Husband and wife shop, maybe 6 tables, cash only. I've walked in at 630p on a Saturday when the weather was perfect. Pastas are insanely good; Veal tortellini is white wine sauce and lobster ravioli made me stop and say "wow," literally every time I took a bite. Prices are substantially better than other places with similar quality. Hours are somewhat limited.
Taqueria El Gallo Azteca
Probably overlooked because it's on Staten Island, but I think maybe the best tacos in the city and my wife (from Houston) agreed. Really cannot go wrong - every meat was excellent.
Lamoone Bakery
Recently getting a little more attention, but still underrated. The basque cheesecakes here are out of this world good, particularly the black sesame, though I would not sleep on the pandan which is also excellent. Lots of seasonal/rotating flavors. The lady who runs this place is amazing, and for whatever it's worth, the shop is very charming.
Slicehaus
L'Industrie alum pumping out some of the most balanced slices with light, crisp but chewy crust. I go probably once a month and have still never had to wait in line here.
Hay Hay Roasted
I prefer it over Wah Fung for roast duck and roast pork and it is a similar value (higher price but for larger portion) with no line whatsoever when I've gone.
B'Artusi
L'Artusi sister restaurant, so somewhat popular, but I've been able to get a same-day Saturday table for 4. Seems that people mostly come for drinks, but they actually have probably the best lasagna in the entire city (Yes, that includes Don Angie).
Virginia's
I can't think of another place selling a burger this good that you can just walk into or get a last minute table most days. Tied for my favorite in the city (with 4 Charles), if you are someone who is an absolute glutton for the rich and savory - one who dreams of bathing in bone marrow and caramelized onions - then you will love it.
Pop's Pizza of East Village
Old school, simple, and delicious. Basically empty every time I've gone, though has lots of Google reviews, so maybe more popular than I realize? Either way, this is what Joe's wishes it could be and yet it gets a fraction of the recognition.
Dolly's Coffee Shop
The honey bun is a maximalist experiment in just how pillow-y and gooey you can make something, and possibly the best sweet baked good in the city. Focaccias are superb and their breakfast sandwiches rule. Maybe somewhat popular based on Instagram follower count, but the only time I've seen a line there is right at opening, which is crazy for what is IMO a top 5 bakery in the city.
Philomena's Pizza
Probably a victim of location, but the plain and pepperoni slices are as good as anywhere, and I'm not sure how more people aren't dropping in as an easy stop off the 7 train.
Beijing Dumpling House
A good amount of online reviews, but basically empty when I went, and I feel it really doesn't get the attention it deserves. Duck sesame pancake is insanely good. Noodles and dumplings are very solid. Such an easy stop off if you are on your way to/from JFK, and recommend spending your money here if you have the time vs blowing it on overpriced airport food.
Joe's Italian Deli
Not sure how Casa Della gets all the attention in the Bronx when Joe's is as good as it is. To me, this place is second only to Defonte's (which is untouchable perfection) for the best Italian deli in the city. Get any sandwich with cutlets and it will be a winner.
Smashed
Probably controversial because it's a chain, and somewhat talked about, but for me this is probably the best smash burger in the city, and (at least the West Village location) is always a ghost town for some reason.
Liu Liu Sheng Jian (formerly PanBao 66)
This is a fairly popular spot in the New World Mall food court, but it is still not nearly popular enough. After just spending a week in Shanghai eating every last pan fried pork bun I could, my wife and I agreed that we didn't have a single one we liked as much as these. Value is off the charts, and despite a line typically, wait times are short. Again, it is popular, but really should be getting the level of attention that somewhere like Mei Lai Wah does.
Food Lovers Halal
In Jersey City, and slightly more expensive than some trucks, but the lamb over rice is the best in the city for my money. They sometimes skimp on white sauce a little, but that's easily fixed by asking for more, which they will happily give you.