r/FoodNYC • • Mar 23 '24

Burger Review Series: Unveiling the Culinary Gem: 4 Charles Prime

0 Upvotes

In the bustling heart of New York City, where culinary delights are as abundant as the city lights, lies a hidden gem that only a fortunate few have had the pleasure to experience. Tucked away on Charles street in the West Village, is 4 Charles Prime, a haven for burger enthusiasts and connoisseurs of fine dining alike. In a city where exclusivity is the norm, securing a reservation at this establishment is akin to tickets the Eras Tour.

Stepping into 4 Charles Prime is like entering a culinary sanctuary. With only a handful of tables and its plush leather booths, the ambiance gives an air of sophistication and exclusivity. The attentive staff, head to toe in crisp attire, elevate the dining experience with their impeccable service, complete with literal white-glove treatment—a rarity in today's restaurant scene.

But it's not just the ambiance and service that sets 4 Charles Prime apart; it's the star of the show—the burger—that truly steals the spotlight. Renowned as one of the top burgers in the city, this masterpiece is a testament to the artistry and skill of the chefs behind it.

Meticulously crafted, each component of the burger contributes to its unparalleled flavor and texture. From the perfectly airy bun to the indulgent thick steakhouse-style bacon to its layer of American cheese, every bite is a symphony of flavors that activate the taste buds.

However, it's the centerpiece of the burger—the incredibly rich wagyu beef patty—that truly sets it apart from the others throughout the city. Made from the finest cuts of beef, expertly seasoned and griddled to perfection, this burger is a carnivore's dream come true.

Elevating the experience, the burger is presented and cut fresh at the table, revealing its juicy layers and inviting aroma—a showstopping moment that sets the stage for the culinary journey ahead.

Having had the privilege of indulging in this delight, I can fully attest to its claim as the best burger in town. Each bite is a revelation, a testament to the dedication and passion that goes into every aspect of the dining experience at 4 Charles Prime, oh and lets not forget the pickles on top.

So, if you find yourself craving a burger experience like no other, I implore you to seek out this gem and discover the culinary magic that awaits. 4 Charles Prime, where the burger isn't just a meal—it's an unforgettable experience that will leave you craving more.

PS: The Prime Rib French Dip is also worth a flyer.

NEXT STOP: Nowon for it’s Korean-themed smash burger! Let me know other spots that I should add to the list! Looking forward to you following along.


r/FoodNYC • • Dec 01 '24

AIO: Got this pizza at Rubirosa and sent it back because the cheese was overcooked

Post image
16 Upvotes

They claimed it was standard but I’ve been around the block enough to know the cheese on a classic NY pie isn’t supposed to look like that. It tastes worse when burned like that.


r/FoodNYC • • Sep 02 '24

Finally tried a Smash Burger

3 Upvotes

I’ve always wanted to try a smash burger; just never got around to it.

A few weeks ago, 7th street burger opened in my neighborhood. We went last night and ordered two double cheeseburgers and fries.

I wasn’t impressed at all and don’t understand the hype. The burger was extremely greasy & didn’t have a lot of flavor. I was wondering why it was relatively cheap and the size explains it.

Is 7th street the typical smash burger or is it one of the lower tier smash burgers?


r/FoodNYC • • Sep 15 '25

Review Lindustrie is flavorful but overhyped

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

https://www.lindustriebk.com/

Tried lindustrie yesterday for the first time And I have mixed opinions. Had the New Yorker, the reg pepperoni, and two white slices.

The tastes is def solid. The New Yorker and pepperoni slices were def flavorful. The New Yorker I liked the most. You can taste the tomato paste, and it def tasted fresh. Tomatoes had a very rich taste. The white slices were ok. I’ve had better white slices where the ricotta tasted rich. The white slices were prob the weakest slices. Seems like they were rationalizing dough to save on costs lol. Literally like cardboard.

Overall, this place is overrated. The crust is too too too thin. It was like eating cardboard. I understand crusty, thin slices (I love crusty slices) but this was like they were trying to skim on dough or something. Good dough makes up a good pizza and this just tasted too gimmicky to be considered as one of New Yorks best. Two slices prob equate to one solid nyc slice.

There was a line outside, and this was on a Sunday, which is fine. But this wasn’t worth the wait. I put this up there with Joes as overrated tourist trap pizzas. Give it a 6 out of 10.


r/FoodNYC • • May 27 '25

Balthazar is garbage.

71 Upvotes

Food was mid. Service and management was even worse. Don’t support this place.


r/FoodNYC • • Jul 27 '26

Question Anyone know where I could find Schnitzel Middle East style?

0 Upvotes

When I visited Israel and the West Bank, just about the most popular street food/shop dish, after falafel, was chicken schnitzel inside a pita. Usually with hummus, tahini, some kind of tomato salad, often with French fries inside.

I know plenty of places to get an excellent German schnitzel, but I’ve not found one prepared like that. Anyone have suggestions? Brooklyn is ideal, but tbh, I’d travel for one.

Thanks!


r/FoodNYC • • Nov 30 '25

Question Asian folx: are you dining at Cesar?

0 Upvotes

Hey hivemind, I've been looking for a nice holiday/celebration dinner for next Saturday, and I made a reservation (with non-refundable deposit) at Cesar.

Then I found out there has been mega drama with the chef, including lawsuits against him for serving the worst scraps of meat/fish to us Asians, and calling us "shit people?" I had no idea and now I feel like an idiot for chasing Michelin stars.

I am torn. I've lost interest in going, but I don't want to lose my deposit. I've been searching up and down and everything's booked. The lawsuit is from 2014 and I believe that people can change, although considering there was another lawsuit two years ago with Brooklyn Fare, seems like there hasn't been much improvement in character. Chef seems to be drama city.

Wondering if anyone can offer reassurance as a BIPOC that me and my guest (who is Black) won't be treated like trash. Hoping that Cesar has changed his ways.

Thanks,


r/FoodNYC • • Jun 05 '26

Discussion 👏🏽 Thank goodness for Plantega! Cheap, easily accessible veg* foods in bodgeas throughout NYC

Post image
0 Upvotes

As a lazy vegetarian trying to transition to plant based, Plantega is a life-saver. I never visited deli's until it. Now I go to my local deli more than most fast food spots.

For $10-$13, I can get a nice vegan friendly sandwich in a variety of versions. That was unthinkable a few years back.

(Note, the OP menu is outdated. Or maybe it differs from spot to spot. I've never seen the cream cheese bagel at the Plantega spots I visit. And they recently added a Po'Boy that I haven't tried yet)


r/FoodNYC • • Feb 19 '25

Review I ate at Katz’s

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Forewarning: I am going to trash Katz’s.

I ordered the pastrami reuben after much deliberation and reading threads on Reddit. All the videos of people trying the sample the cutter gives while he works show them going wide-eyed and happy. The only emotion I felt while trying was a preemptive sense of loss for wasting my $33 on poorly cooked meat. I don’t know if it’s because I’m from texas, but the pastrami at Katz’s felt like an utter waste of brisket.

I don’t think melt-in-your-mouth tender should include audible crunches of gristle when you chew the meat, nor the pieces pulling out with your teeth when you try to pull your bite from the sandwich. I’m glad I didn’t just order the pastrami on rye, because without anything else on the sandwich I’d just be chewing on a mountain of meat that needed more hours in the smoker and slobbered-on bread that dissolved before it even left the cutter’s hands, Slicing the pieces thin certainly didn’t hide the fact that the brisket was poorly cooked.

Not only was the cook of the meat not up to par, the pepper crust provided nothing and offered little advantage over the corned beef. Not only do they cut most of it off on the slicing board, but it’s steamed so there’s no crunch and the pepper isn’t coarse enough to do anything for you anyways. The sauerkraut wasn’t sour at all, and the best thing in the sandwich is a toss-up between the grocery store Swiss cheese or the Russian dressing. At least the pickles were good.

I’m just saddened because Katz’s was also one of the things I looked forward to most on my trip. Previously in New York I’d tried Pastrami Queen, and after being similarly disappointed I set my sights on Katz’s which was spoken of as the far-and-away champion of pastrami only to be punched again in the gut by disappointment.

I truly feel sorry for all of the cattle that died for their brisket to turn into Katz’s pastrami instead of something worthwhile. I mean look at that sandwich! The meat isn’t even piled high like everyone praises Katz’s for.

I guess stuff like this still being hyped up makes me remember that I’m lucky to live in my home city that still has great food.


r/FoodNYC • • Aug 11 '25

Question Iced Tea

2 Upvotes

I recently moved from Texas and out of ALL the changes: price, people, humidity, job hunt... out of ALL the things... the one I am most struggling with is the seeming LACK of iced tea at most of the restaurants I go to.

Am I going to the wrong restaurants?
Should I adjust my expectations?

Is iced tea NOT A THING up here?

*pearls fully grasped*


r/FoodNYC • • Nov 28 '24

Tipping culture in NYC?

0 Upvotes

Hey all!! I’m from Toronto visiting for the first time. What’s the tipping culture there? Is 15% the standard or is it more? 😅


r/FoodNYC • • Aug 16 '25

NYT Cooking | Salt Hank Rules the Sandwich World

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/FoodNYC • • Aug 09 '26

Review Unpopular opinion: Mountain House was bad and not worth the wait

0 Upvotes

Went to Mountain House in East Village based on some of the posts here (plus I think it was ranked in the top 9 restaurants in the NYT at some point). Combined together and the fact that NY is usually really good for Chinese food, we waited about 1.5 hours to get into the restaurant and was wondering what happened.

The menu was a disappointment - how do they not even have cold noodles on a menu and the restaurant doesn't even have AC in the height of NY summer? With all the steam going, they only had fans mostly which didn't do much to dissipate the poor circulation inside.

We got:

  • Pickled Pepper fish (super salty, they didn't use the right greens, ie., didn't wash them. There was 0 peppercorn in there, 3 small red peppers and a green shishito pepper??)

  • Shredded Potato (Strips were uneven and thick. This was some intern level knife work, at least use a mandolin. Had only an oil flavor and was undercooked. It had celery in it??? )

  • Green pepper Eel dish ( didn't have a basis of comparison for this so I guess this one is fine)

  • Mung Bean Jelly -Liangfen (closest we got to cold noodle. It was in 1 strip when you picked it up, it wasn't even cut all the way. How do you not cut the noodles? We had to try to cut it with our chopsticks and they didn't knead it enough for the texture. It also was bland in flavor compared to the times I've had this dish).

My friend was really disappointed because Chicago shouldn't have better Sichuan food but at least the food was spicy and not just greasy and sour (and not in the right pickle sourness). We then looked up a few places and maybe New York is good for like Cantonese food and not actually other regions like Sichuan?

My friend would rank this similar to Lao Peng You in Chicago, while reddit raves about it and in actuality it is questionable to an Asian palate seeking more familiar flavors on how they would be cooked in China. There is some flavor adjustment to the palate of westerners and that makes the food too salty or too changed in flavor profile to be considered delicious to eat.

I think Che Li was owned by the same people and while on the slightly sweet side, we still enjoyed our meal. She thought we wasted our calories on the Mountain View meal. I didn't think it was that bad but it was definitely not worth the wait.

-


r/FoodNYC • • Feb 19 '24

*NEW SUPPER CLUB ALERT IN NYC*

0 Upvotes

BAZAAR_NYC (a monthly supper club in NYC)

Hi, I'm Nirupa, an Indian immigrant navigating the tech world with a side of culinary flair. By day, I’m diving into the tech scene, contributing my two cents to innovation. But when the workday winds down, I’m in my kitchen, infusing my childhood dishes with a dash of creativity. My favourite asmr is the slow dance of spices in a pot of hot ghee. 🌶️

Bazaar was created with an intention of bringing strangers under one roof with incredible food and genuine connections. At Bazaar, you'll be breaking bread with strangers, turning a simple meal into a shared experience that transcends cultural boundaries.

To me, every stranger is a potential friend, and every meal shared is a chance to build connections. I’m not just embracing diversity; I’m throwing my arms wide open to it. Through the flavors of Indian cuisine, I’m inviting souls to savor, connect, and appreciate the cultural tapestry I bring to the table.

Join the mailing list: https://stan.store/Bazaar_nyc

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bazaar_nyc/


r/FoodNYC • • Dec 12 '25

Review You can get their pasta & pizzas for around $18 - $25 only (Rubirosa)

Post image
3 Upvotes

one of the Budget Friendly Restaurant in NYC


r/FoodNYC • • Sep 02 '25

Question We’re the team from Atto Sushi (Midtown East) — Ask us about NYC sushi culture, dry-aged fish & omakase

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone—we’re the team from Atto Sushi in Midtown East. We’re here for an AMA focused on:

  • NYC sushi culture: sushi trends, etiquette, and sourcing realities

  • Dry-aged fish: why we age, timelines, texture/flavor results, and how it differs from fresh

  • Omakase in NYC: seasonality, pacing, pairings, and what to expect at different price points

We’re also here to listen to your suggestions for improvement—from lunch specials and delivery/packaging to menu clarity, vegetarian options, or sake ideas.

We’ll be active in the comments and share notes on our process where helpful. We look forward to your questions and a great conversation


r/FoodNYC • • Oct 25 '23

Yelp is trash

0 Upvotes

I know it's a given, but Yelp is trash. I posted a FTR for a new business, but because I didn't have a 'photo', some elite stole this 'honor'. I know there's no point to grieve this. But just venting, that's all. I really just rely on this review site for new businesses and photos. Never the wannabe critics.


r/FoodNYC • • Jul 24 '24

What do you Recommend? My 10 year old wants to try the best pizza in NYC when we visit. Extra points if its a halal spot

1 Upvotes

r/FoodNYC • • Jul 22 '24

18 essential Israeli restaurants in New York City - Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Thumbnail
jta.org
12 Upvotes

r/FoodNYC • • Dec 29 '23

Mediterranean / Israeli Recs

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

My wife and I are catching a show on Broadway near Times Square tomorrow. Lately, we've been into Mediterranean and Israeli food and would love to grab dinner somewhere in the area. We're open to places in Tribeca or the West Village too, or anywhere that's a quick hop on the PATH.

Thanks for any tips you can share!


r/FoodNYC • • Oct 10 '23

Worst bagel spot in New York?

0 Upvotes

I think people make too much of bagels. They're such a simple thing that I don't know that there can really be a place that makes bagels which are just heads and shoulders above the rest. With that said, I've recently found that while there probably aren't many amazing bagel spots, if we're being honest, there certainly can be bad bagel spots.

My vote is for bagels on the square. It's just bread. Not even slightly chewy and lacks that unique aftertaste bagels have. The salmon is also not fresh and a little crusty. Just really bad overall.

I guess as a follow up, what do you think the best bagel is in the west village? it doesn't seem like there are many good bagel spots here.


r/FoodNYC • • Feb 17 '25

7 bucks for bodega eggs on a roll…

25 Upvotes

Ordered two eggs and ham on a roll from my local bodega. Came to 7 dollars. Not two eggs and ham on a nice bagel, two eggs, two slices of ham, no cheese on a toasted roll. About $1.50 more than a month ago.

It’s becoming a “treat” to get breakfast like this on the go. Definitely going to make more breakfasts for on the go.


r/FoodNYC • • Feb 27 '25

Question The thought of Katz’s gives me anxiety…

0 Upvotes

Taking my fam to NY at the end of May. I want to take them to some iconic food spots. I want to take them to Katz but the ordering process and chaos kind of gives me anxiety. I went there once with a former coworker many years ago when we flew up for a day trip and I sort of remember it being chaotic then. But my memory is a little fuzzy. I do see that you can get waiter service there? Is that true? Do you miss out on anything by opting for this or is it best to just suck it up and deal with the chaos of the line ordering? My wife and I would be getting pastrami or a pastrami Reuben but my son would most likely get a hot dog and it seems like you have to go to a separate line for that. So the whole process seems weird and unnecessarily hectic to me. Thanks.


r/FoodNYC • • Aug 23 '25

Review Cathédrale Restaurant @ The Moxy by Tao Group in East Village: Best Deal in the City?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Now I know what the $28 vodka sodas at the Venetian's Tao in Las Vegas are paying for — Cathédrale's six-day SUNDAY thru FRIDAY happy hour at Moxy in East Village: NYC's best kept secret? Pictured: $2 East Coast Oysters; $5 dollar mini lobster rolls; $5 horseradish & olive tapenade steak tartar; $5 Parmesan wild mushroom truffle toast; $5 young pecorino fonduta w/ Acacia honey & toasted hazelnuts.. $14 classic martinis.. Shout out to bartender "Barry like Barry White..." Top notch food and service ("especially for the price").