My introduction to FF7 was in 2004, watching a neighbor fight the Red Dragon in the temple and it hooked me right then. It was the first game to make a big impact on me and few things have rivaled that feeling since. When I heard they were remaking/reimagining it, I was excited but also worried. Remakes are hard. Nostalgia is really difficult to play on well. How are they going to make a whole game out of the first chapter of the original?
Early in game, my worries felt very justified. I think I was slow on the draw on the combat system and it took a while for things to flow. I had mixed feelings about the voice acting. The out-of-combat movement was sometimes unbearably slow. Really, really did not like the introduction of the "whispers". Tifa felt really lacking in personality.
But man, what a gorgeous game. As it went along and I got better at the combat, I really enjoyed the weapon-centered progression. Loved Aerith's characterization, especially during the first day with Cloud. Barret looked, sounded, and acted exactly as I pictured him back way back when. Aerith's scene with Marlene was wonderful. The music was terrific; in particular the music when you're moving towards Sector 5 with Aerith was a great rendition of one of my favorite tracks. And Cloud's progression throughout felt natural and well-handled.
As the game was nearing the end, I thoroughly enjoyed it rehashing some beats from the original (fight with Rufus, elevator gun mech, car chase, big mech fight) and the ultimate finale was new and surprising and cinematic and 10/10 tremendous.
Some things fell flat for me but it more than made up for it. Very fun and incredibly well animated combat, exciting boss fights, a unique progression system, Hojo's spot-on rendition, and terrific music throughout. Very excited to play the next one.