I discovered the original Final Fantasy VII the year it came out, 1997, as a little kid, and it quickly became my favourite game of all times. I replayed it enough times to stop counting (I certainly went beyond 50 playthroughts) and it became an important work of art for me, a huge creative, philosophical and political aspiration.
I was never this interested in the extended universe, though, the Compilation of Final Fantasy VII. Advent Children disappointed me to no end: it is the textbook example of a terrible sequel, that brings about nothing new to the table except the bright technical demonstration it started as. Last Order was quite mediocre, Dirge of Cerberus looked like a joke, etc etc. Only Crisis Core I was pleasantly surprised by, and that was despite its flaws (which were mostly, again, flaws of repetition).
So when Final Fantasy VII Remake started approaching, I didn't have high hopes. The hopes fell down a few more stories when I saw all of the characters and places maintained their 1997 designs with just a few tweaks (I'm not a fan of 1:1 remakes and consider a lot of stuff should have been revised in these characters designs, starting with Avalanche working "undercover" with big Anime Protagonist looks). My hopes plummeted when I learned that it would shoehorn significant elements of the Compilation. By the point I saw Cloud still wore his sword without a sheath in the subway and every secondary element of the 1997 work had been inflated and bloated into a gigantic event (hello Demon House), I was running as far away from the remake trilogy as possible.
But some friends talked to me about the game, told me it was worth playing.
I was never this glad of being this wrong.
It's true the remake trilogy is a work without subtlety. Of course. It's the blockbuster to end all blockbusters, it's shamelessly maximalist, colorful, explosive, it sticks Sephiroth everywhere, turns every fight into a half-divine battle, it unfolds every gigantic landscape and architecture possible and cranks everything up to eleven overnine thousand. It would be hard to find a heavier game in existence.
It's true some new elements tend to pollute the rest. I was most disappointed by the Whispers, that offer nothing of value and make a few scenes confusing. I'm also not a big fan of both Remake and Rebirth ending with a gigantic, hours-long, multi-stages Sephiroth fight. And the second sewer visit and Drum subquests are asinine, they assassinate the pacing.
HOWEVER.
Beyond all of these flaws, Final Fantasy VII Remake + INTERmission + Rebirth is a fantastic work. A beautiful, stunning, powerful story. Using a very provocative mix of tones, never hesitating to become completely ridiculous and campy as fuck in some parts, and then to dive into deep depression, mental torture, brainwashing, body horror and themes of extraordinary violence and gen0cide in the next scene. A passionate human work, that breathes new life into old characters.
Conceived by the creators of the original game, the story of the remake trilogy does NOT make the mistake of faithfulness to an ultimately rough and sometimes childish mid-90s plot, and instead takes into account the way the medium matured, and the myriad of new tools to tell stories in the 2020s. It enriches and strengthens its world, themes, characters and then spreads all of it in a way unique to video games.
Regarding the revision of the previous structure, many choices are fantastic it could take entire books to list them all, I'll just mention that the way Dyne's death and Cloud beating up Aerith are reworked gives two examples of extreme attention given to the tone and the new impact some scenes could have in way more detailed and realistic visuals than the old polygons; in the case of the second sequence, it's actually split into two new scenes, Cloud trying to kill Tifa and Cloud running after Aerith on the Whisper roots, which both successfully get rid of the worrying undertones of domestic violence (do we really want a male protagonist who beats up his female friend/love interest in full frontal?) while amplifying the theme of Cloud's collapsing mental health (and manipulation by the antagonist) and providing powerfully horrific moments. The new progress of the journey also makes a lot of sense, with the new quest to follow the Black Capes for their own good, and let's observe how the Black Capes are humanized through the characters of Roche and Broden.
Remake, INTERmission and Rebirth are FULL of smart tweaks like that, that solve many ethical, political, geographical, consistency-related and philosophical issues were the 1997 scenes to simply be translated as they are.
Beyond this impeccable reinterpretation of the original, the remake trilogy goes further. It is never afraid of doubling down on its ecological themes (more important than ever in the 2020s, where fighting for our own survival and the survival of ecosystems becomes a matter of... well, survival) and its social criticism, of sculpting new character psychologies and of carving all new scenes and locations everywhere in its sumptuous environment. More than often, you'll start a simple, apparently autonomous and light-hearted subquest only to find it tying into the main plot in the most stunning, heart-shattering way (the Cosmo Canyon and Nibelheim Protorelic quests being particularly fucked-up example). The Final Fantasy VII remake trilogy is relentless in its desire to always offer the most high quality, detailed and deep experience possible.
A thousand scenes could be talked about, but Aerith's monologue near the end of the Temple illustrates the general mastery of the storytelling. She starts a powerful speech about life, about death, about grief, about the inevitability of mortality, the kind of speech that can change lives, the kind of speech that can give everyone the courage to fight. And Cloud, under Sephiroth's influence, just... breaks it. Quick close shot on his mouth, he cuts "Are you finished?". A simple, sober line. But the buildup to it in the speech, in Cloud's behaviour, in the themes of the game makes it brutal. In this moment, we understand this is not Cloud, or we don't know Cloud (or both). And that we are following the path of a ravaged puppet of a man. This scene demonstrates how much the creators understand the strength of modern video game writing mise-en-scène.
It all converges with the end of Rebirth. The entirety of Remake was built towards the promise that we could change destiny, and the underlying possibility that one of the most known events of video game history, Aerith's death, might be averted. But Rebirth reveals that isn't true. Aerith is still planned to die, will die, and partially expected to die. (This prophecy of death was in fact an obscure lore point of the original game: you can read in the 25 January 1997 Official Establishment File, page 22. The remake trilogy develops directly from the original work.) Finally, Aerith dies, under Cloud's eyes, and Cloud... cannot accept it. His mind already ravaged by previous and repeated losses of everyone dear to him, wrapped in denial and the fantasy of his Soldier persona, he rewrites reality, his inner reality, and finds himself in a mental world where "Aerith is alive". While his companions were grieving, Cloud stood up, and started walking further and further in his delusion. That is the ultimate tragedy of Rebirth, a game whose very title sounds like a horrible lie, a story that plays with your expectation and ultimately revises its most famous moment to better break your heart.
I cried more before this game than before any work of art (and FUCK, that includes Pan's Labyrinth or Grave of the Fireflies). What an incredible story. What masterful writing.