r/Fencesitter • • 15h ago

Questions Reaching a juncture

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, grateful for thoughts and advice. My (32M) girlfriend (35F) of two years are regularly talking about having kids.

She's sure she wants 'one-and-done' with the right person within a couple of years. I've never been drawn to the idea - partly age and financial position (which I assume will change over time), partly being content with just living a happy life with my partner. I know I could be happy without kids. It's not an absolute no, but given our ages (although eggs are frozen), I think its only fair I start making a decision, so she can restart with someone new who definitely knows.

I'm just finding it difficult to imagine wanting something in two years time, when I'm struggling to genuinely want it now. But it would be heartbreaking to end the relationship over this (to me) unknown. I've read the Baby Decision, but it didn't help me loads.

Any advice?


r/Fencesitter • • 18h ago

Pregnancy Tokophobia as a reason to stay on the fence

4 Upvotes

Long time fencesitter here! I have been feeling anxious abt this decision for a while. I always thought I wouldn’t have children. Then I started to question why. And a whole can of worms came out. I have always been fearing pregnancy & childbirth. I wouldn’t mind if a baby would be delivered to my door. I was also considering fostering and adoption. Then I realized I might be experiencing tokophobia. Is anyone else experiencing this as a reason to being on the fence? I have been educating myself on the subject and don’t experience as much anxiety. I don’t have much time to get over this but I’m beginning to see pregnancy as a natural thing that shouldn’t be controlled.


r/Fencesitter • • 19h ago

Questions Just found out I'm pregnant. Are my thoughts normal?

30 Upvotes

Sooo we had a positive pregnancy test earlier this week after ~13 months actively ttc. I have been pretty adamantly no kids until about 2 years ago when my age must have started to kick off something in my biological clock.

When I saw the positive test, I was mostly just relieved that I could cancel my fertility appointment we had scheduled in a few months and save that money. Since then I have caught my mind wandering...thinking about plans that already need to be cancelled around the due date, all the ways this will impact our life negatively, the chance this child is disabled since I had the flu and a very high fever a week ago. The worst part, my husband is traveling for work this week and I caught myself thinking about scheduling an appointment with PP and terminating and just telling him it was an early miscarriage despite this being our potentially only chance since we're in our mid-30s.

Let me preface that my husband is the most loving, supportive partner and would be a great dad, so I feel horrible thinking all this and am a bit freaked out.

Are these thoughts normal (some weird manifestation of anxiety?) or have I made a mistake?


r/Fencesitter • • 20h ago

Positive stories of pregnancy and birth

21 Upvotes

I've noticed a lot of women here suffer from anxiety about having kids. And rightfully so. Pregnancy, birth and motherhood are no joke, and every body carries this differently. BUT I feel like the "horror" stories get so much attention! It's okay to prep and know the possibilities, but don't embrace all the negative stories as certainties for your body. If you have positive experiences to share, maybe this would help other women here see the other side too ❤️


r/Fencesitter • • 23h ago

Anxiety How do I figure out whether I genuinely want children or have romanticised fatherhood?

4 Upvotes

I'm 23M, and I'm on the fence about having kids, leaning towards yes.

I recently broke up with my partner because we were fence-sitting in opposite directions. She was leaning no for multiple reasons (though she wouldn't rule it out), and I was leaning yes. Once we realised we were leaning in different directions, we ended things.

Now I'm realising I'm probably more on the fence than I initially thought. I want a career in tech, which I've just started, and ideally a partner who has her own career, hobbies and interests, and with whom I can travel and enjoy life before settling down. I think I assumed I could have all of that and still have a child. Now I'm wondering whether that was naive, especially in this day and age.

I also think I had a fairly romantic picture of parenthood. I've always been drawn to the idea of being able to give a child unconditional love. I've thought about the emotional work involved in parenting, emotionally regulating yourself, teaching emotional skills, helping them understand the world, etc. I've even thought about being an adoptive single parent, taking up a remote job (I work as a software engineer) to be a parent, and sometimes even being a stay-at-home dad.

Looking back, I also wonder whether I might have come across as too certain or even creeped my partner out with how enthusiastically I talked about wanting kids. Maybe I was approaching it in the way people sometimes joke about men wanting kids like puppies, without fully appreciating the reality of raising a child. I don't know if that's how she actually saw it, but it's something I've started questioning about myself.

But watching older coworkers navigate daycare, doctor visits, school schedules and planning vacations around children has made me realise how much of a commitment it actually is.

The difficult part is that I can't tell whether my doubts are genuine or whether the breakup is pushing me towards the other side. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, and I could have pictured one with my ex-partner. But I'm also afraid of committing to that life and regretting not having children later. Part of me wonders whether I should have stayed in the present and valued the relationship in front of me rather than letting a faraway hypothetical determine its future.

I should clarify that we didn't spend enough time discussing children to really examine my position. I had asked for time to think through this desire. Perhaps she wanted someone who was independently and confidently childfree rather than someone who was still figuring out what they wanted. I can understand that too.

I'm also questioning whether my desire for children is partly shaped by how I grew up thinking about parenthood, and whether I've actually considered the day-to-day realities enough.

For context, I do like children, and I think I have a nurturing and caring disposition. That's what initially drew me towards the idea of fatherhood. But I'm increasingly questioning whether that's enough to justify wanting a child.

This is taking over my days. I keep spiralling about it during work breaks, all while trying to process the breakup itself.

I'm genuinely trying to understand what I want rather than defend a position I've already made up my mind about.

I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people who've been in a similar position. How did you distinguish between genuinely wanting to raise a child and being attached to the idea of parenthood? How did you weigh the lifestyle changes and sacrifices against what you might gain? Did you ever become more certain with time, or did you learn to accept the uncertainty?

Any advice or perspectives would be appreciated.

TL;DR: 23M, recently broke up with my partner because we were leaning in opposite directions on having kids. I'm now questioning whether I genuinely want children or have romanticised fatherhood. I'm only 23 and have only recently started seriously questioning these things, so I'm still figuring out where I stand. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, but I'm also afraid of regretting not having children. Looking for perspectives from people who've been through something similar.


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Anxiety Anyone feel like they don’t deserve to decide to have a kid now because they had an abortion that they aren’t sure they regret?

3 Upvotes

Had 1 abortion a few years ago. Def wasn’t ready. I feel comfortable with this decision.

Had another about 9 months ago. Could have been ready, made a somewhat panic decision and did a home medication abortion. My rationale was I have mental health issues, I still wasn’t 100% (but who is right?), and me and husband still have a lot of conflict and working through past traumas.

Now I am 38, feeling my clock majorly ticking, coming around to idea of maybe having one. But feeling like I should have just kept the one earlier this year if I had just gotten my head right in time.


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Anxiety Anxiety is stopping me from having kids

3 Upvotes

Hi ladies, is your main reason for sitting on the fence due to fears of pregnancy, childbirth and the aftermath of having a baby?? becuase these are all the reasons why I keep procrastinating . I am 35 now, so beginning to panic


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Anxiety Realizing I don’t have unlimited time to decide

21 Upvotes

This feels quite silly, but I kind of forgot the biological clock is a thing.
I’m in healthcare, I know the statistics about fertility after the mid 30s, but somehow I never applied that to myself. I’ve been content to sit on the fence and imagined I would decide someday in the future when my life was in a position I would like to raise children in.

But I am nearly 35. And I have started to experience what might be hot flashes. I thought I was too young, but then last week, my mom shared with me that she was having hot flashes in her 30s and fully menopausal by 40, and my grandmother and aunt also finished menopause by their early 40s. So I might be running out of time sooner than I expected.

A big part of me has always really wanted the experience of pregnancy and childbirth and raising kids through all of the life stages. But the other part of me is anxious about the future (climate, politics) and what it means to bring a new life into this world. And my mental health is good now but has historically not been great, what if I have a major depressive episode when a kid depends on me? And I enjoy travel and independence and I know that having children would mean sacrificing that for quite some time. I imagined I would make a decision after I have traveled more and once I am stable in a career and built a community around me.

I changed careers, went back to school, and I hope to travel across the country for a specific residency after I finish. If I stay on this trajectory, by the time I am stable in my new career, I will be almost 39. And living in a city far from any family or support. I feel like I haven’t prioritized building or maintaining the community or relationships I would want around me if I had a kid and now it feels there may not be enough time. My partner is ambivalent about kids, also on the fence. I feel like if I wanted to raise a family I should have been dating with that lens, but I wasn’t.

But now that I am realizing the door might be closing, the idea of never meeting the kids I had hoped for just because time ran out and not because I made a conscious decision makes me incredibly sad. I feel so silly for not realizing that if I didn’t want that door to just close, I would need to start planning for it before my mid 30s.


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Why is this decision so fucking difficult?

7 Upvotes

I woke up today to hear my husband discussing that his old friend, who’s wedding we are attending later today, chose not to have kids because they would like more free time. And I felt jealous.

We currently have one child, who just turned 4, and I was by and large one and done until maybe 6 months ago when I began considering a second. We were just married this August.

My husband would love a second, third, I am sure fourth child. However, after my extremely isolating and difficult postpartum experience with PPD, birth trauma, ongoing depressive episodes and just general struggles, I am not sure I even want a second.

We’ve been discussing starting to try in a few months, and some days I find myself wanting to buy baby items in Walmart. Then the next day, the idea of having more kids seems like the worst thing I could do, and fills me with dread. Actual dread. I want to travel, write novels, experience more of the world, while my husband would be happy to stay home (we live rurally on a farm) a lot of the time. I love where we live, but I also love travelling.

We have no village except daycare and relatives that live two hours away that we can rely on if planned weeks ahead. Our one daughter is lovely and was an easy baby (except sleep.) But everything is so much more expensive now, and I feel like I am just getting back to becoming myself. I still get the sundown scaries a lot, I struggle with travelling because I feel like I don’t want to go back to my life after I’ve had a chance to be independent and free.

And most of all, I think I would be unhappy if I had a second child because I did what someone else wanted; but I would be unhappy if I didn’t because I would feel I would be letting down my husband and not providing my daughter with a sibling (which I know isn’t a requirement and doesn’t necessitate a “best friend for life.”)

I’m just so, so, SO weary of ruminating over this decision. I have discussed it at length with my therapist and have yet to come to a conclusion of any sort. It takes up so much of my mental capacity some days that I just want to cry. And I am 32 and my husband is 38, so while we aren’t very old, I don’t want to be having a child after 35.

Anyways. Just throwing this out there out of frustration because I know now I am going to be ruminating on this all day, again.


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Anxiety Forced to make a decision sooner than expected

2 Upvotes

Amazing how Reddit algorithm finds the right subreddit to suggest…

I was recently diagnosed with endometriosis, it is not severe but has already affected my fertility at 33.

I just married my husband in September after 4 years together. I never wanted kids before meeting him, but that started to change as our relationship developed. I never felt like I wanted kids or to be a mother as an absolute, but I can imagine doing that with him and I find myself fantasising about it. I still feel like I could go either way though, and that my life would feel complete and full of love with or without children. I was OK with both options I guess. Luckily, he feels a very similar way.

When thinking of a timeframe, I guess we thought that we would arrive at the moment of a decision eventually, maybe never, as our relationship evolves. But this diagnosis changes everything, as every doctor recommends not to waste any time and that if we want to have children, this should happen more or less right NOW. Or I should freeze my eggs, which I guess would be fine, but also requires a level of decision I’m not sure we have yet.

Ultimately, this is just a rant on how weird it is when you’re on the fence but life is forcing you to pick a side sooner than expected!


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Questions Is it fair to view having kids as an "either or" decision when it comes to music/hobbies?

17 Upvotes

I am a musician who already struggles between having a 9-5 and enough time for gigs, practicing, etc. Is it a good mindset to see having kids as greatly cutting into the time for music/hobbies, almost to the point where it's like choosing one or the other? Probably a dumb question, but thanks lol


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Partner’s depression changed his opinion on having kids

5 Upvotes

My (27F) boyfriend (25M) had always been a maybe prior to meeting me. (Before I continue explaining, I want to say that I know we are young, but for certain health reasons, I have always felt strapped for time and want to make sure I have as much time with my (possible) kids as possible and I may want to do IVF, so I’m trying to think ahead). When we met, we dated very intentionally so I brought up these conversations really early, and I told him having kids was possibly very important to me and that I had always wanted to be a mother. I made it clear that being open to children was essential to me wanting to be in a relationship at all. Originally, he said that being with me opened his eyes to having a child and he felt very positive about it. He’d share positive thoughts and ideal number of children, and talk about our future kids and how we’d be emotionally intelligent parents who didn’t make our kids feel how our parents made us feel. He talked about parenting, being confident in our abilities, confident that we would raise our kids well and even with my doubts of having a child in today’s world, assured me it would all be okay.

I have always dreamed of being a mother since I was maybe 5 years old; pregnancy and babies/children have sort of been a special interest for me even, I find pregnancy beautiful and fascinating. The thought of being pregnant excites me and makes me feel like I’d feel the most connected to my body I ever could and the bond I imagine having with a child is something I feel like I could never replace. I grew up in a family with emotional abuse and always felt alone, so it has always been a dream for me to have my own family. I’m confident I would be a good mother, I want to be an amazing one but I’m confident I will be at least a good one.

Although I was very passionate about this, some events in my life led me to really question my wants and I felt I was a maybe. I feel now I’m a maybe leaning yes, but the cons of not having a child far outweigh the cons of having one for me. I worry I’ll deeply regret and grieve never having a child if I don’t. My current philosophy on having one is that I’ll never regret having one and I know I would make it work and feel good about having one; there are pros and cons to both sides and I think I’d be deeply fulfilled by it even if it was extremely hard.

When everything changed:

A big issue with his family occurred where he was insulted, unfairly judged, and criticized and this had a huge effect on his self esteem and triggered his depression which he’s struggled with his whole life, on and off. He expressed thinking about the future is hard or even impossible in times like this. It’s been many months now, more than half of our relationship. He started to feel more negative about kids and expressed he thinks he wouldn’t do a good job, or be able to manage, and sounded very negative. He has said he feels extremely worried he’ll become a terrible person like his divorced parents did and ruin our relationship, and says he’s insecure he won’t be a good father. He insists he’s 50/50 on the issue and that he’s more positive than he’s communicated and admits he’s communicated poorly about his actual feelings and thoughts. Overall, his opinions don’t seem to have changed, it’s more the self confidence or the worry about his mental health if he were to be a parent. I’ve tried to reassure him that the insecurities about himself are far from who he is. He is incredibly caring, kind, fair, patient, supportive, accepting, gentle, smart, and fun. I’ve seen him interact with kids and animals, other people, and with me, and he treats everyone with care and empathy. I know he would be an amazing parent and father. I love him and I truly thought I had found the person I wanted to be with forever and have a family with.

For the first few months, I stayed away from the conversation for his mental health, but since then, I’ve urged for better communication around this topic since then and he has said more positive things that he used to say. I’ve supported him to get therapy and make lifestyle changes, and although things have improved a bit, he still is in a place to not progress how he feels about kids. He said it very much relies on his mental health and improving his executive dysfunction. He is working on getting therapy now but I know it’ll be some time before it gets better. I feel a lot of stress and pressure to figure this out as I feel I’m on a much tighter timeline than him. There’s a lot of communication issues, insecurity issues, and issues that stem from his depression affecting our relationship currently so working through those are hard when this issue about kids is looming over my head. I worry that working through all of our issues won’t matter if he’s not open to kids and it’s a dealbreaker to me if he’s a hard no.

I’m not sure how to go about this or how to handle anything. Has anyone had similar issues or have any insight to how they would handle this?

TLDR; My boyfriend originally was positive maybe leaning yes about kids, became depressed due to family issues and has always struggled with depression, now is unsure about kids but I’m a maybe leaning very positive yes. The stress weighs on me and our relationship, need advice on how to go about this or similar situations.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Parenting Being a good parent

6 Upvotes

I’m 28, turning 29 on Saturday. I’ve been married to my husband (32 M) for four years, we’ve been together for six. Within the past six months, we’ve started seriously considering having a child—just one. I come from a very long line of women who did not want to be mothers OR shouldn’t have been given then circumstances. My 3x great grandmother was pretty much always pregnant from the time she was 11 till she was 49, and had 16 children with a man that beat her. My 1x great grandma had my grandma at 12, as a product of SA and abandoned her on her own mother’s doorstep. My grandma had my mom when she was 11, as a product of SA. And my mom had me at 19, as a product of SA.

As you can imagine, my mother and grandmother were horrifically abusive parents/guardians to me. I’ve been in therapy since I was 13, and am working through the mess they made.

So, there’s a lot of hurt and pain through my maternal line, and I want to end it. I actually WANT to be a mother so bad, I’m married to a man I love who’d be the father, and I already love my future baby so much. I love them with everything I have and am already.

But today I saw a post on TikTok that kind of cut deep and has honestly made me second guess. It was saying that you can say that you will love your child unconditionally, you can say that you will be the best parent, that you won’t traumatize them…and that child can still tell you that you did not love them, that you were a horrible parent, and caused them trauma. Even if you feel in your heart that you did nothing of the sort.

I just want my child to be happy. But then, they said even wanting your child to be happy is “bad” because if they end up having depression, you’ll take it out on them.

And it’s like…I hope I will be a Better mother than my own or my grandmother. I don’t think they, as little girls, said “I’m going to be an extremely abusive mother if i become one.” I have not forgiven them for what they’ve done to me, but I understand WHY the circumstances led to their behavior and poor parenting.

But apparently…I still might be abusive like them? So then it’s like…should I even have a baby if I’m gonna abuse them the way I was abused? Even if I consciously don’t want to and the thought of doing so enrages me, to hurt an Innocent child. Especially one I made from my own body.

Idk. TIA.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Mothers who were fencesitters, did you manage to keep your sense of self and your career?

19 Upvotes

And if so, how?

I don’t see myself in the mothers around me. I see women who either went into motherhood with the intent of being a SAHM or who planned to stay employed but eventually gave up and became one anyway.

I work a job that requires unconventional hours (essentially on-call), travel, and a sense of urgency when addressing stuff that does not go away after 5pm. I’m fine with the idea of that toning down but I would not want to work a job that abandons all of that completely. I like my field of work and worked very hard, against many odds, to get to where I am.

My partner’s job is the same - different industry - and he earns significantly more than I do. It’s his pay that would allow us to give a child the life we would want to give them.

Short of getting a live-in nanny, what do people do? And how do women avoid the trap of becoming the default parent when they make less so “it just makes sense” for their career to take a hit?

This is my number one reason for being a fence sitter. Hoping for some advice as my partner and I debate the path forward.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Reflections 23F, I love babies but I don't want to deal with a teenager

16 Upvotes

I'm okay with the idea of pregnancy, even curious about it. I'd be happy to hold my baby, to comfort them when they're crying, to change diapers even. But they'd soon grow into toddlers, whom I tend to dislike, and then teenagers, who are absolutely insufferable. I don't want to talk to them about body hair, menstruation, etc, I probably won't find the necessary words. I don't know what I'll do if I find out my teen smokes. And I really don't want to deal with everything that comes with a baby growing up. Though I love the idea of my partner and I telling our child(ren) how we met if they asked. But I only like babies? Does anyone else feel the same way? Wanting a baby but not wanting a toddler?


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Questions Considering a 3rd child at 36. How did you decide?

0 Upvotes

Considering a 3rd child at 36. How did you decide?

I'm 36F. Husband is 40M. Daughter is 5.5yo. Son is 2yo.

I thought we'd be done at 2, but lately both my husband and I have been feeling that maybe we'd like to try for a 3rd...

A part of me wants to, and a part of me is hesitant.

  1. I'm just getting back into my career and finally feel like I'm finding my footing. I'm enjoying my role and am potentially up for a promotion. Having another baby would likely mean putting my career on hold just as things are starting to come together.

  2. we have international travel plans that we'd been looking forward to that likely have to cancel or postpone. We're also finally getting to a stage where life feels a little easier.. and I'm not sure I'm ready to go through the newborn phase, sleepless nights etc all over again.

  3. i also feel like everything is designed for a family of four. Cars, hotel rooms, vacation packages, etc. Being a family of five seems like it would make everyday life and travelling more complicated and expensive.

  4. At 36, I worry about age-related pregnancy risks and the possibility of long-term health issues for the baby. I also feel the pressure of having to make a decision sooner rather than later.

  5. I'm scared I won't have enough time and energy for my two kids, or that another child would affect my marriage and the time we have for each other.

...but despite all these concerns, I have this nagging feeling that I might regret not trying for a third. Almost like I'd be making a mistake by stopping at two, even though I can't fully explain why I feel this way.

For those who considered having a third child, what helped you make your decision?

If you stopped at 2, did you struggle with the possibility of regretting not having another?

If you had a 3rd, was it harder than you anticipated? What sacrifices did you have to make? Are you happy with your decision?

I'd specially love to hear from women who had their third in their late 30s.

I know there's no perfect time or perfect answer, but I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences. I'm feeling very torn...

Thanks in advance!


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

The way I talk about my experience getting off the fence changes depending on who I am talking to

2 Upvotes

TLDR; I got off the fence and had kids before my fencesitting friends. They ask for my experience but I noted I am more positive about it when I think they would be good parents and like being parents and more negative when I think they wouldn’t be. Doing this subconsciously but don’t want to do that anymore. Would love some feedback on how to help my friends in a less judgmental way.

I was on the fence for all of my 20s. For me, the decision point was going to be the partner I ended up with as I could see myself being happy either way depending on the circumstances. My boyfriend throughout most of my 20s was most certainly not “fatherly” (and I very well couldn’t see myself as “motherly” as a 50% party girl and 50% boss bitch) so at the time I was leaning towards no kids but unfortunately, he wasn’t providing the carefree DINK life I was looking for. My brother and his partner are child free in their 40s, both have their own businesses and travel luxuriously (when their businesses permit). To me, their life was ✨GOALS✨. My other brother who got married and had a kid, his life by comparison looked awful (more on this later) so I was pretty certain I wanted the DINK life but my ex didn’t have the ambition, financial intelligence, or interest to travel to make that dream a reality so we broke up when I was 28 after 7 years together.

I met my husband in my early 30s and was already convinced I would end up childfree. I had thrown myself into my career and my hobbies. However, my husband, who started out as a fling, was certain he wanted children and as we fell in love it became important for me to decide or end the relationship.

Fortunately, he really could provide the necessary lifestyle for a good family life and I knew he would be an excellent father. He has a large and wonderfully supportive family (something I lack). He has a community of close friends who all have children themselves or were going to have children (also something I lacked). He has a good and reliable job with good benefits (as a public school teacher and football coach) that would be flexible to parenthood (also something I lacked as a corporate slave). He was mentally and emotionally stable and a functioning adult (also something I lacked given severe ADD and a history of depression and anxiety). He is responsible but still fun (when my son was born and I was bemoaning my loss of freedom and that I’d never travel how I wanted, we decided to take some time off using some savings and travel all around Europe with our 6 month old. It was actually amazing! Not the kind of travel I had expected and definitely less nightlife than what I had wanted in my 20s but nonetheless an incredible experience and we had so much fun).

Shortly after I got married, I stopped birth control and became pregnant much quicker than I thought and boy was I freaking out! He was so happy and I was so scared. Both cried but for totally different reasons. Fortunately, he was right and I was wrong and our son is the best thing ever and we are so happy in our family life and I am now enthusiastically trying for more.

As such, and being the first of my friends (all similar to me fencesitting), many have come to me to ask my experience and I’ve observed that how I present parenthood to them changes based on my judgment of their life (I know that sounds terrible. I’m not doing it on purpose but that’s why I wanted to share with this group to be aware maybe I’m not the only one who does this). If I think they have what it takes (supportive partner and community, financial security, mental fortitude, etc), I speak very highly of my experience. If they don’t, I tend to highlight the negative aspects of parenting. My observation of why my brothers life (the one with a kid) seemed so unappealing was because they lacked certain aspects that I think make a family life worthwhile.

Now that I’m aware of what I am subconsciously doing, I’m trying not to do this but would love some advice from this group how to be more honest and less judgmental of my friends.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Approaching the fence for someone I love

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m new to the fencesitter community. I have been firm in my stance that I want to be a Mom someday, ever since I was a little girl. I have a strong nurturing instinct and honestly just want to experience that kind of unconditional love for a child, in the way I know my own mother fiercely loves me. She was a fencesitter herself and decided to let fate take the wheel at 42. I’ve always said I’d do it alone if I didn’t find a suitable partner.

I’m a few years out from being ready to make the baby decision but have recently been starting to think I should approach the fence. Namely, I want to be with someone who told me on the first date that he doesn’t want kids. We’ve been dating ~casually~ for 10 months. I’ve tried to go on dates with other people but I haven’t met anyone who compares to him and my feelings have grown despite my efforts to detach. If he was open to kids, I’d want to give commitment a shot. I’m not certain how hard of a line it is for him, he’s been quiet every time I bring it up, and the future of our relationship is currently in limbo due to some of these commitment issues (EDIT: to be clear, I have been the one avoiding commitment because he had told me he didn’t want kids, and I also didn’t know until recently that he wanted a committed relationship with me).

l have other reasons to approach the fence, too, and I’ve never really given myself the time and space to consider what a fulfilling life might look like for me without being a mother. I just started an audiobook of “The Baby Decision” to prompt more reflection.

One of my questions for the fence sitter community is how to approach this issue in dating? I’ve always operated under the assumption that I shouldn’t bother committing to someone who is on the other side of the fence - that’s the one big compatibility piece that’s not worth questioning or challenging someone on. I know minds can change, clearly, but I keep thinking it would be heartbreaking to get into a long-term relationship only to stay on opposite sides of the fence and have to start over OR risk sacrificing something I’ve wanted for so long to maintain my relationship.

Is it worth asking the person I love if he’s willing to approach the fence, if I’m willing to try and meet him there?


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Questions Looking to hear experiences from other couples where one person is one-and-done and the other is completely against that

1 Upvotes

Hello! Really struggling in the situation I find myself in, and would like to hear from other couples that have experienced a similar conundrum.

I (35F) and my partner (31M) have now been together a few years, and are talking marriage very soon. We were looking at rings, but I've stopped mentioning it at all because of the kids talk. A little background: I've pretty much always thought I was going to be mom. It's not that I'm overly motherly, it just always felt being childfree wasn't really an option? My parent's haven't pressured me, so I guess it was a self-imposed, societal expectation. And since high school, I've always been one-and-done-minded. I have a younger sister (4 years apart) who just had her first baby. We weren't particularly close growing up, but have gotten closer since she became pregnant. I love her very much, but I've never felt that close sibling bond with her, perhaps because we are very different people. I try to picture my life without a sibling, and honestly, I feel having her around growing up was more helpful because of having to deal with my somewhat narcissistic father, who she is much closer with, which takes the pressure off of me.

Now back to my conundrum: it only really hit me this past year that I don't have to have kids if I don't want to. And that I could possibly live a very happy (maybe even happier) life childfree. At the beginning of our relationship, my partner was a 0 or 2 guy, leaning slightly more towards 0 it seemed. He's been very adamant since day one that one child is not an option. He's so against it it feels he thinks it's a form of child abuse to have one child and not give them a sibling. He has an older sister that he's close-ish with, and much of his reasoning stems from that fact that his parents had a pretty bad divorce and continued to be toxic post-divorce, and he shudders at the thought of having to have dealt with that without a sibling. I empathize, and I know everyone says this, but I know I would NEVER act that way and put my child through that if him and I were to separate. My parents divorced when I was in college and have an amazing relationship, they are best friends now. They handled their divorce so maturely and never once said a bad thing about the other to us kids. I respect them so much for that, that I would strive for that should I find myself in that situation. This is not the only reason for him, but much of his reasoning seems to stem from the fact that having a sibling helps you go through and deal with difficult situations (divorce, parent death, etc).

Now that both my sister and his sister had their first kids within months of each other, he's hopped off the fence and very much wants kids. But again, stopping at one is still not an option for him. I know people say "just wait, you'll probably change your mind after your first and want another", but I know myself, and I think there's a 1% chance of that happening. I have always just wanted one if I were to have kids. I imagine our little 3-person family unit, and I imagine a life where I can be a present mother but still live my life and run my business. A life where we have just a little more time to ourselves since we'd be focusing on just one. I am also absolutely DREADING pregnancy and the postpartum phase. And I simply don't want to put my body through that twice. I'd also be late 30's come time for a second kid, and I know more and more women are having children then and even into their early 40s, but I just don't want to do that.

Has anyone else found themselves in a similar situation? I'm especially looking for others where the woman is the one who only wanted one. I feel this is a relationship ending situation for me. I know the logical next step is counseling, but he has been so anti-one child since day one that I feel even if therapy was able to convince him to move forward with just one, he'd end up resenting me down the line. On the other hand, I'm already building up some resentment. I know having children is a two-person situation, but I'd be shouldering the burden of pregnancy, the postpartum phase, and the likely permanent body changes that come with that. Perhaps I'm wrong in feeling this way, but I'd expect a male partner to be a little more willing to compromise with his female partner on this matter.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Reflections Former fencesitters who now have children - does anyone regret it?

150 Upvotes

I recognize that this post may sound controversial, but that is not my intention. I'm a 31 year old fencesitter just wondering... did anyone eventually decide to have children and then regret it later on, even though you likely love your children very much? If so, why?

I feel like this is not talked about enough and think it may be helpful for me.

Thank you in advance for your openness and honesty.

ETA: I am so grateful for your responses. Thank you. This post has gotten a lot more attention than anticipated. I will try to respond to everyone but sorry if I miss you!!!


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

2 years, 2 kids in... and still I wonder if I made the right call !

70 Upvotes

I was reasonably adamant my hub and I would be childfree in my 20s. Probably started to question around 29/30 then really fencesit for 2 years from 31-33. #1 had a late 33 and #2 at 35.5

The love thing is true, no denying that aspect. Loved my daughter overwhelmingly from the minute she was on my chest. Loved my son from the minute two lines appeared on the test.

I think being a fencesitter and someone often in my own head, I do think about motherhood quite often. I'm glad i got to choose for me.  I do think my life would have been much easier and better if I knew kids were always coming as I really would have preferred to have them a much closer to 28-30 and to plan for that. I often stress if my children choose to have children if I'll be around to help them, i worry how long my kids grandparents will be around.I also know i want my daughter to know herself in and out before she makes motherhood part of her identity. It's hard and you can't undo it.

I still feel on the fence sometimes pondering if it was the right call. It's definitely hard. I developed some unpleasant and unfortunate mental health side effects which I'll probably have forever now. I'm also so envious of my friends who knew motherhood was for them and thus had their kids earlier and won't be parenting into their 50s. I absolutely love the kids, i love the hallmark moments but I do wonder what my childfree self might be doing sometimes. I mostly wish I'd had that desperation to be a mom. That secure knowledge to 100% know in yourself it'd be worth it regardless. I find myself in many what-ifs alot.

I thought we'd be oad and that changed very fast. If we'd started 5 years earlier we might have  had 3. But also one would have been great too!

I am happy I got to experience parenthood as I do think the what if would have haunted me. There's also a reason we were having babies in our 20s it is exhausting and I'd consider myself pretty active and healthy.

You can't really explain the love thing of parenthood, and that's the hardest part. It's wonderful and beautiful. It's also insanely anxiety inducing, my head worries like it's never worried before about all manner of things.

I don't think I expected to still wonder about it so much. I'll probably still be here in 20 years wondering with grown up kids.

I wish everyone peace on their choices!


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

Questions Changed my mind after starting birth control?

3 Upvotes

I (27F) have been with my boyfriend (29M) for 1.5 years. When we first met we both were pretty sure about having kids, possibly 2. But over the past year, I was diagnosed with endometriosis and had to start taking birth control. At first I was devastated that I might have trouble with conceiving or carrying the pregnancy.

But overtime, this made me rethink the topic of children.

I think maybe just because I got tired about having to think about my reproductive system, the pain and the anxiety that comes with it, the doctors visits etc. Or could it be because of hormonal changes from birth control?

There are also other factors I have considered over time (my anxious personality, my boyfriend working long hours, impact of pregnancy on my body) that don't make having kids appealing.

Fortunately my boyfriend seems to be ok with not having children. When I brought up the possibility of not wanting or being able to have children (due to endometriosis) he was understanding and reassuring. We both agreed to wait and see.

So to those of you who are/were on birth control, did it change anything for you in terms of wanting to have kids? How did your partner react?


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

My partner (42M) hasn't ever wanted children, but when he expresses doubt I (32F) find myself shutting down the conversation even though I deeply want them.

1 Upvotes

My partner and I love each other, but we're struggling with whether to have children.

I didn't always want kids. My feelings changed after experiencing multiple miscarriages in my previous marriage and one together. I started to feel like I had a deep ache and a yearning for motherhood. I accepted it won't happen in my situation and I get hit with waves of grief over never experiencing it.

My partner has bipolar disorder and has gone back and forth about children multiple times. He's expressed wanting them, particularly when manic or drinking, but when stable and sober, he generally says he doesn't want them and didn't want them whatsoever before we met. He's now scheduled a vasectomy.

When the topic comes up and he can tell I'm grieving, he starts reconsidering. He's explicitly said my sadness makes him want to have children and that he likes imagining the future of a family in with me. I think this is a rubbish reason and I feel like he's only considering it to make me happy or prevent me from leaving, something he's repeatedly expressed fear about.

I also have concerns about his ability to manage the responsibilities of parenting based on the aforementioned bipolar disorder.

When he brings up reconsidering, I tend to remind him of the realities of parenting and our fertility struggles. He feels I'm shutting down the conversation, and that's sort of fair. He says I won't let him explore it, but I argue he has said many definitive times he doesn't want kids and even went so far as to book a vasectomy. I just think he would be miserable as a parent and regret it deeply. He says it makes no sense that I do want children but I always seem to be arguing against having one when he considers it.

I love him, and I know I want to share my life with him. Even if I did want to leave there's a good chance I wouldn't have children anyways. Having a baby would be a long, uphill battle. Despite this I have days where I grieve heavily and it feels like a mountain is on my chest.

I don't know what to do. I don't know how to move forward with the grief. Am I being discouraging? Am I being reasonable? Where do we go from here?


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

The Decision of whether or not I want to have kids has taken over my life

33 Upvotes

Hey guys,

Just discovered this forum and thought I'd share what I've been going through.

I'm 33F, happily married for a year now, and have been with the same partner for a little over 7 years. I've never really had a strong desire to have kids. In fact, I never gave it much thought.

I always assumed that after a certain age, after spending enough years with the "right" person, and after achieving some of the goals you've set for yourself, the desire to become a parent would just... appear?

I always thought some biological clock would eventually go off inside me, sounding the alarm that I was finally ready to take that step.

But here I am, and that desire is nowhere to be found.

I don't think it's fear as much as it is an extreme awareness of the responsibility, sacrifice, and seriousness that come with bringing a child into this world.

Growing up lower-middle-class, my parents worked all the time, and I had to put on my adult pants pretty early on to take care of my sister and myself while they were away.

For most of my childhood, I was praised for being more mature than my age, for making adult decisions, and for being hyper-independent. What people didn't realize was that what they were praising was actually the death of the child within me.

The child who never had enough time to play, be creative, have fun, or discover who she was and what she liked. The child who had no real guidance on how to make the right decisions, how to develop healthy coping mechanisms, or how to communicate properly.

Yet somehow, I had to be all of those things and more for my younger sister.

I love my sister just as much as I imagine any mother loves her child. I helped raise her, guided her, protected her, and carried responsibilities that I wasn't nearly old enough to carry. And the thought of having to go through raising someone all over again weighs so heavily on me.

I've worked really, really hard to become the person I am today. Personally, physically, financially, emotionally.

Countless hours of therapy, self-reflection, making some very bad decisions and some very good ones. Extreme highs and bottom-of-the-pit lows. Unlearning things, relearning others, and slowly figuring out who I am outside of the responsibilities I grew up carrying.

And now that I've finally reached a point in my life where I feel like I can just be, where I can enjoy the life I've worked so hard to build, the thought of giving so much of myself away again feels overwhelming.

I don't know how I could do all of that again. I don't even know if I can.

There's one thing that keeps resonating with me throughout this entire internal conversation about whether or not I want to become a mother:

I know I would love and protect my child with every ounce of my being. But I also know, deep down, that I wouldn't enjoy motherhood.

And I think that's the hardest part to come to terms with. Knowing that you could be a good mother doesn't necessarily mean you want to be one.

But then come the questions.

Will I look back at this post a few years from now and regret not having children? Will I look back and think how stupid I was to let fear, or my need for control, dictate such a big decision in my life? Or will I look back and feel at peace with whatever decision I make?

And then there's the realization that, as I sit here writing this, having children is still a choice I can make.

But for how long?

At what point will that choice no longer be mine to make? When will biology make that decision for me? And more importantly, when that day comes, will I be okay with the outcome?

I guess only time will tell.


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

Anxiety Anyone who was constantly tired before kids, does it end up okay?

24 Upvotes

One of my big concerns is how parents say you don’t know what tired is until you have a child because for me, without a child now I feel kinda exhausted all the time.
My boyfriend really wants children in the future, I’m not so sure. I never really feel well rested, but I can’t recall a time I have because I felt this way even when I was in high school. I work shifts now and if I don’t have anything urgent to do on my off days I can easily sleep 12 or more hours. Even when I sleep that much sometimes I still feel I could to right back to bed.
I’m really worried that if I had a baby I’d be so tired that I’d like crash my car or something like that. Granted it would be in the future so maybe my tiredness would level out idk.
If you were always pretty tired before having a baby did it work out okay?