r/Fencesitter • • Jul 03 '26 Diamonds are Forever Wholesome Seal Hooray Heartwarming Bravo

Childfree Four years later: an update

3.7k Upvotes

Hi all

About four years ago I (37F) wrote a post after my husband (39M) and I decided to be childfree. This community was incredibly helpful while we were making that decision.

When we were deciding, I remember desperately searching for updates from people who were a few years ahead of us. They were surprisingly hard to find. Over the years I’ve gotten quite a few messages asking about more ordinary, everyday things, so I figured maybe this could be that post for someone else.

For anyone wondering what ultimately made the decision for us: it wasn’t one dramatic moment. It was realizing there was a difference between wanting to have children and wanting to be parents. Once we separated those two questions, our answer became much clearer.

I go into more detail about our journey in my original post, I would link it here but my technological capabilities peaked in ‘07. I apologize.

Day-to-day stuff

I’m 37 now. Most mornings I get up around 6, journal, make coffee, and sit on the porch before work. If I have time I’ll take the dog for a walk or squeeze in a little creative work.

I work remotely for a nonprofit, so I get to sneak outside into the garden during the day, which is one of my favorite parts of working from home. After work I’ll eat something while doing whatever I feel like. If I don’t have plans, I’m usually in my craft room, reading in the sunroom, or back out on the porch. We live in a vacation town and love walking the boardwalk just to people-watch.

My husband works part-time at our local library. He can walk to work (but usually he doesn’t lol). We have one car, one tiny dog, and a huge flower garden.

This weekend my husband is across the country promoting a film he wrote and produced with his best friend. It won an award at a film festival in LA, which still feels completely surreal to type. I teach a few college courses every year, and the extra income is nice.

Yesterday I accidentally fell down a rabbit hole researching local honey and somehow spent an amount of money on honey that I refuse to discuss.

We’re slowly fixing up our old, crusty house from the late 1800s. One unexpected perk of knowing we won’t have children is that we’ve designed the house around the people who actually live here.

One bedroom became my craft room, office, and reading room, and my husband has his own creative space. Every room feels like it has a purpose.

We still love to travel and love learning new things. Some weekends we’re exploring somewhere new. Other weekends we barely leave the house.

I cannot believe I’m admitting this on the internet, but every once in a while we’ll decide to sleep in the living room for two or three nights because we’ve built ourselves a blanket fort like we’re seven.

When Artemis launched, we rearranged the furniture, threw pizza rolls in the air fryer, built a fort, stayed up watching the launch, and halfway through looked at each other and silently communicated that this was actually f**king awesome.

We have a perfectly good bedroom.

Sometimes we intentionally choose chaos because it’s just the two of us.

We’re not as spontaneous as we used to be, but if we decide on Friday afternoon that we want to spend the weekend somewhere else, we usually can.

Not all childfree couples are gallivanting around on yachts DINK-ing to their hearts’ content. Some are.
Most aren’t.

That said, we do have financial flexibility. We’re able to save, live below our means and still do what we want to do individually and as a family (yes, I say family even though it’s just us two. People have told me this sounds misleading. But I don’t think you need human children to be considered a family).

Our life isn’t glamorous, it’s actually very ordinary. And I genuinely love it.

There are hard parts

Choosing to be childfree wasn’t easy.

There was grief. There still is sometimes.

Not because I think we made the wrong decision, but because every meaningful decision asks you to let go of another possible version of your life.

I grieve the version of me who would’ve become someone’s mom. Someone’s grandmother. I loved her too, and sometimes I wonder what she would’ve been like. Sometimes I feel an unreasonable urge to apologize to my ancestors in the family tree.

I don’t push those thoughts away, but I also don’t mistake them for regret.

I think you can mourn a life you didn’t choose while still being deeply grateful for the one you did.

One thing nobody really talks about is how quietly the world moves toward families with children.

Your friends’ schedules change. Weekend plans change. Nobody is doing anything wrong, you’ve just stopped moving in the same direction.

Sometimes it feels like everyone got on a train and you’re standing on the platform waving as it pulls away.

I also think society quietly assumes adulthood ends with children.

“So… do you have kids?”
“No.”

There’s often this tiny pause.

“Not yet?”
“You can’t?”
“You don’t want to?”

Not always. But often enough that you notice.

One thing that always makes me laugh is when I’m talking with a parent who’s venting about a rough week.

I’ll say something like, “Wow… that sounds like a lot. They’ll laugh and agree.

Then they’ll remember I don’t have kids. Suddenly it’s, “Oh, but don’t get me wrong… it’s the BEST thing I’ve ever done.”

I always find that funny. You don’t have to reassure me. I can see that parenting is incredibly hard, and I can also see how much you love your child. Those things don’t cancel each other out.

I’m sure I say things as a childfree woman that make parents scratch their heads, too.

Something else surprised me. I genuinely believe there is nothing like having a child. I’ve only ever observed that love, but even watching it has brought me to tears.

I still remember the look on my brother’s face when he held his son for the first time.

No one needs to convince me parenting is beautiful.
It absolutely is. It’s just not the only beautiful life available.

Feeling outside the default doesn’t mean you’re outside of a meaningful life.

It just means you have to build more of it yourself.
One thing I’ve learned is that being childfree isn’t simply the absence of children. It’s the presence of a life you’ve built intentionally.

For me that ended up looking like writing, gardening, volunteering, teaching, traveling, creative projects, a marriage that has had room to deepen, and a house we’ve slowly made our own.

The freedom to become deeply interested in wonderfully weird things…Like honey.

Do I ever wonder “what if?”

Sure. I also wonder what would’ve happened if I’d moved across the country. Or bought a farmhouse.
Or changed careers.

Every meaningful decision closes a door.

I don’t really see that as regret. I think that’s just the cost of choosing.

Somewhere along the way, the question stopped being, “Do I want kids?” and became, “What kind of life do I actually want?”

Those turned out to be two very different questions.

The thing that surprised me most wasn’t that I stopped wondering if we’d made the right decision. It was that our life slowly became so full that the question just got quieter.

Questions I’ve Apparently Agreed to Answer for the Rest of My Life

“Who’s going to take care of you when you’re old?”

Honestly? No idea. But I also don’t think children are a retirement plan.

They’re people.

They grow up and build lives of their own. Some stay close to their parents. Some move across the world. Some become estranged. Some die before their parents do.

Having children has never guaranteed anyone care in old age.

“What if your partner dies?”

Then I’ll grieve. Just like millions of parents would if their spouse died.

Children don’t prevent loss. Death is a human problem, not a childfree one.

I think the saddest part of questions like these is that they mistake having children for having certainty. Life has never made that promise to anyone.

If you’re still deciding…

Know that you have a choice.

You don’t have to choose the childfree life.

And you don’t have to choose parenthood.

But don’t make either decision out of fear.

Don’t have children because you’re afraid of being lonely someday. Don’t stay childfree because you’re afraid of change.

Choose the life that feels most like yours.

Four years later, I can honestly say this one still feels like mine.

Sometimes I look out at the garden and think about how many people have said “you’ll change your mind” Mannnn that used to bother me.

And maybe they were right, maybe I did change my mind.

I just didn’t change my mind about having children. I changed my mind about what I thought a full life had to look like.

I hope this helped someone :)


r/Fencesitter • • Feb 21 '21

Answers to questions you're probably wondering about parenthood from the mom of an almost 3 year old

2.7k Upvotes

Q: Will it make me fulfilled?

A: Ummm sometimes? Honestly, the first year of her life, I felt less fulfilled than I ever have because I was spending most of my time taking care of a tiny baby that couldn't talk or interact in a way that was interesting to me, and it meant that I couldn't do things that really DO make me fulfilled, like writing and creating. Now that she's almost 3, I have a lot more moments where I feel proud or amused or loving toward her, but to be honest, I don't feel fulfilled by our relationship. It's something different.

Q: Will I have to give up my entire life?

A: For me, it took about 1-1.5 years to get my life back. I breastfed my daughter and she wouldn't drink from a bottle for the first 6 months so I could not get away from her for that entire time. And believe me, I wanted to. We also moved across the country and I am self-employed so I didn't have a job to go to. It was REALLY HARD.

But then, she became more independent and we started sending her to daycare. We moved closer to my parents and they watched her sometimes before COVID. Now I get time to be creative on a regular basis, I meet friends for coffee every once in awhile, and I even went on a 5 day retreat with some friends back in 2019.

I can't just do what I want. I have to arrange it or pay for it. But I can do things outside of motherhood. Lots of things.

Also, I saw a post in here where someone wrote that you can't take a step back for self care when you are a parent. And in my experience that is absolutely NOT TRUE. I take better care of myself than I ever have, at least emotionally. And I think that being a mom has helped me do that, because to step up for my daughter and be a happy, whole human, I need to prioritize taking care of myself. It's better for both of us. Because I'm always trying to be aware of her needs, I have learned how to pay attention to myself and my own needs and to mother myself.

Q: Will I be a good parent?

A: Sometimes. Sometimes I don't get frustrated when my daughter screams at me for not reading a book 5 million times. Sometimes I do fun things like making Valentine's Day cookies with her. Sometimes I give her kisses in her palms for her dreams and I feel like she really knows I love her.

And sometimes I get so frustrated I have to leave the room. Sometimes I realize I've been looking at my phone the entire time I've been eating lunch with her. Sometimes I cave into her demands more than I know I should and I worry that I'm not setting boundaries and I'm turning her into a spoiled, entitled brat.

You will likely be a good parent sometimes, too. And sometimes, not so much.

Q: Will I regret it?

A: Sometimes. Sometimes I wish I didn't have to start every day getting my daughter out of bed, and convincing her to pee in the toilet, and then convincing her to let me brush her teeth. Sometimes I wish I could just be free to hang out with a friend without arranging someone to watch her first.

But a lot of the time, I just really love hanging out with my daughter. She is smart and fun and positive. She's not afraid to take risks. She has a good sense of humor. I see a lot of qualities in her that I wish I had as a kid, and that makes me happy.

Then again, that's this month. Ask me again later. My answer will likely change.

Q: Will I enjoy it?

A: I enjoy some aspects of it. Like teaching her new things and going to the zoo with her and watching how excited she gets over little things.

But other aspects of it, like getting her to do stuff and trying to find food she'll eat and reading the same book 5 million times and dealing with her when she's tired just wear me down.

Q: Will I miss out if I don't have a kid?

A: Yeah. You'll miss out on diaper blow-outs and tantrums and the mindless boredom of the day to day care of another human. And you'll miss out on cuddles and watching them walk for the first time and someone who thinks you are the best human in the world.

But you'll also miss out if you do have a kid. You will miss out on lazy mornings and spontaneous trips and adult conversations and devoting your energy to whatever you want. You will miss out on the loneliness and boredom of NOT having a human to take care of.

You will miss out either way.

Q: Will it make me happy?

A: Based on my own experience, and what I've seen from other parents, parenthood does not make you happy. You make you happy. The people I know who were unhappy before they became parents are still unhappy. The people I know who were happy beforehand are still happy. Your set of emotional tools, your level of resilience, your commitment to taking care of yourself, are what will make you happy. Period. Not a kid. Not being child free.

You can make yourself happy regardless.

Q: Why can't I just make up my mind one way or the other?

A: You can't make up your mind because you want to know what it's going to be like, and you just CAN'T. All of the stories you tell yourself, the watercolor images of lovingly holding a newborn (that is keeping you up all night) or dealing with a screaming toddler (who delighted you 5 minutes ago by saying something really hilarious) are just made up.

How YOU will be as a parent, and how your kid will be, is completely different from anything you can imagine. To become a parent, you have to take a leap into the unknown. And once you've leapt, you can't go back. It's really scary. So maybe you're supposed to be uncertain.

So...I don't know why I felt inspired to write this very long, rambling essay about parenthood. I guess I see a lot of people in here trapped in uncertainty based on some idea of what parenting will be. And I want you to know - it's probably not what you think it will be. It won't be as bad. It won't be as good. It will likely be very mixed and change from one moment to another. Just like most things in life.


r/Fencesitter • • Feb 16 '21

Whatever choice you make, you will be whole.

1.6k Upvotes

Before I gave birth to my now almost 3 y/o daughter, I lived in the hospital for a month. My water broke at 30 weeks and they wanted to monitor me until she was born.

I was living in Miami at the time, and one day, a nurse casually mentioned that she was going to the beach over the weekend. The whole day, I couldn't stop thinking about the fact that I would NEVER go to the beach by myself again, stretch out and read a book without worrying about taking care of another human being. I felt shattered by it.

Before I got pregnant, I was pretty sure I wanted kids, but my husband and I kept pushing it off. I loved my freedom, my independence. I loved drinking coffee in the morning with my fluffy dog Kaia as my only company, walking her on the beach and laughing as she tumbled through the waves.

It took me a year to get pregnant, and I was relieved to have that extra time. At 35, I didn't feel ready, but I felt like it was now or never. When I found out I was pregnant, I was happy. But also sad. I grieved my free life.

The whole time I was pregnant, I imagined what it would be like having a baby. All of my guesses were hazy.

I imagined not getting enough sleep. But I couldn't know the feeling of being woken up YET AGAIN at 3 in the morning by a screaming baby, and being so tired I thought I would literally die.

I imagined my little baby wearing the cute clothing a cousin gave us. But I couldn't see her tiny body against mine in the NICU as I stared down with a mixture of wonder and detachment. (Is this really mine?)

I imagined no more going to coffee shops by myself, or the beach, or out to dinner, or traveling. But I couldn't conjure up the time when we flew from Denver to Miami and got stuck on the ground for over an hour, during which she screamed for THE ENTIRE TIME.

I also didn't know that, within a year, I would be able to go to coffee shops and out to dinner by myself again. Hello, grandparents and daycare!

All of the toddler years I imagined as a blur - the tantrums, the messy faces, and that was about it. But I couldn't even fathom the utter joy a tiny brown haired girl would feel when my husband gave her a shiny silver balloon, how she would run around screaming, "Yay, it's a balloon!!!!", her happiness pervading the entire room.

Sometimes I look on Instagram at my friends who don't have kids, at their trips to the Bahamas and Cuba, at their gleeful faces while they hang out on the beach together. I enviously imagine that life. What would it feel like to be that free again?

One time a child free friend told me she had someone over and they drank homemade margaritas and just hung out. I felt such deep jealousy it was absurd. And then she complained that her weekend consisted of sleeping in, watching TV, and taking a bath. That sounded like an utter dream.

But then my daughter came up to me and said, "Mama, will you read me a book?" She climbed onto my lap, and I felt her warm body against mine, and she pointed to all of the characters and we made up what they were saying. And I felt this immense love for her.

I don't think there's a right answer about whether I should have had a kid or not. She's here and I love her, in her words, REALLY, REALLY BIG!!!!

And in a different version of my life, (and in a world without COVID), I am sitting on the beach somewhere, my bare feet in the warm sand, drinking a beer, looking out at the waves and reading a book. Without another human to worry about.

I truly believe that both versions of this life are whole and beautiful and hard and shattering and expansive and heartbreaking.

Whatever choice you make, you will experience sacrifice and loss, gifts and priceless moments. Whatever choice you make, you will be whole. You really will.


r/Fencesitter • • Oct 01 '20

Pregnancy Perspective of a fencesitter who is 9 months pregnant

1.4k Upvotes

I wish I’d seen this community months ago. I’ve always felt deeply uncomfortable with how others seemed to strongly lean one way or the other - aggressively child free or firmly pro children. I felt alone in my early pregnancy as people threw either congratulations or condolences at me.

My SO and I have been together for 9 years, just married last September. I adore him with all of my heart. He’s not a fanatic but it was always in his life plan to have kids. He is AMAZING with kids. I never felt strongly either way, but I’ve never really felt comfortable around babies or kids.

I made that very clear and he never, ever rushed me, insisting that it was my body and we could figure it out as we go. He said if it didn’t happen, it was okay.

So, just a few months after getting married I take a test on a whim and realize I’m pregnant. Based on my last period, I was only 3 weeks along. Husband and I were more shell shocked than celebratory. When I asked if we were ready his response was, “will we ever be?”

I felt numb for a week or two. I felt terrified of losing myself. I couldn’t listen to music, couldn’t watch tv or movies. I barely responded to the enthusiastic congratulations of family and friends. I cried a lot in private.

I called my brother. He and his wife had a baby one year before via IVF after years of trying. He’d always loved children and wanted desperately to be a dad. His first response was “you’ll be a young mom” (I’m 28, he’s 35)

That’s young now?!? That call made me even more nervous.

I set up an appointment for both an abortion and an ultrasound. I still had time to decide.

Because I couldn’t bring myself to discuss abortion with my husband, I no showed the abortion and went to the 8 week ultrasound.

My husband and my mother both cried when they saw the tiny bean shape in my uterus. I couldn’t cry, but I started to feel a little more okay. It was like I was being carried along by a wave.

Quarantine happened and I was forced to stay home. It made me realize how much I adore my husband, how much I love just being with him. I felt more okay about the possibility of slipping away from my friends who are far from having kids, but also more afraid of not being alone with him anymore.

I broke down and told him about the abortion appointment, he cried and held me and told me all of his own fears about becoming a parent. We made rules and plans to make sure we were always there for eachother. This would be hard but we would never let eachother carry the burden alone again.

My body started changing, but I didn’t really care. I’ve always had a little tummy I couldn’t get to go away, so being pregnant almost made me more comfortable. I’m already 9 months in and lucky enough to have zero stretch marks (I aggressively slather coconut oil on everything) I still exercise as much as I can.

Being pregnant made me more conscious of my diet. I’ve actually lost a bit of my own weight and hope these habits will stick.

I saw my baby’s face in an ultrasound and for a moment I felt the kindof heart swelling love for her that I’ve felt for my husband - and that gave me a lot of strength because it doesn’t always just happen.

Sex hasn’t stopped but I’m scared of the unknown that comes after giving birth. I’m TERRIFIED of actual birth but choosing to have an epidural and any meds they’ll throw at me with no guilt.

My husband keeps seeing me doing things, like nesting, reading about baby care or making protective decisions, and remarks that I’m going to be a good mom. At first that made me feel weird and matronly- until I realized he said it with a kind of reverence, and it seemed to boost his libido. It still feels weird but I don’t vehemently hate it.

I have a week to go and it feels suffocating because it could still happen any time. I’m excited and terrified. I’ll never really feel ready.

My life is going to change so much, forever. I have almost as many regrets as hopes. I refuse to lose myself. I refuse to give up art or making music. I refuse to be ONLY a mom, though I accept that this will be a huge part of who I am going forward.

She’s only going to become more and more complex. She’s going to be a whole PERSON with thoughts, feelings, goals... I have no idea who she’s going to be. I could really fuck this up.

I hope I’ll be okay at this.

I don’t know why I felt so compelled to write this but I was just so glad to find this community and see so many likeminded people. I respect people who are child free just as much as I respect those who aren’t.


r/Fencesitter • • Oct 29 '20

Love my kid indescribably but I can't recommend it.

1.3k Upvotes

I was a fencesitter. My wife wanted kids. We have one now. I love my daughter more than anything but I honestly wouldn't recommend it.

  1. There's a lot of drudgery. It's boring, repetitive and tiresome more often than you'd think.

  2. You make yourself more emotionally vulnerable than you can ever imagine. You put your heart into this little person and send it out into the world with no way of protecting it from life's curveballs. Worse, you have the illusion that you can protect it and them, and so you kill yourself trying to do so. And each time you fail, man it hurts bad. It only becomes worse as they get older and start making independent decisions.

  3. You lose a lot of control over your life in every way.

  4. You sign up to this decades long contract to live with this roommate that you didn't choose. Turns out they are CRAZY (obligatory: this is tongue in cheek. But it is one perspective worth considering)

And that's before you navigate the relationships you have with your partner, family, colleagues and society and how they are affected by having a kid.

It's a much easier, simpler, and happier life without one. If you want something to love get a pet, seriously.


r/Fencesitter • • Nov 01 '20

Any other women feel like they WOULD want kids if they were a guy?

1.3k Upvotes

I think its hard for me to deny that a HUGE factor in my fence sitting is my being biologically female, and therefore the one to physically carry and birth a kid, and socially, the one most responsible.

When I picture getting pregnant and being a mom and I just feel sad, dissatisfied...
But if I was the guy, and had that social role, where my partner wanted a kid, and they got pregnant, they birthed it, they took maternity leave and stayed home while I worked, and I got to hang out on weekends. I think I would like that eventually.
I like hanging out with kids, talking to them and playing,
But to be a mom, I feel like all the data is so well established, even couples that intent to split everything, women still end up doing it all. I hate the idea of seeing my partner go off to work while I sit home with a newborn.

I know people say we could have different gender roles, but right now I'm unemployed after being laid off and my partner always earned over double what I do.
I know people say adoption is an option (but very very expensive and years long waiting lists)

I think I do feel some FOMO (fear of missing out) at the idea of never having kids in my life, but I imagine doing it, and I just don't feel anything positive. Just, sad, frustrated, almost angry at how unfair it is.
My partner is the sort of person who sort of says he doesn't want kids, but isn't very form on it, he just doesn't like making any bog life decisions at all. He's indicated if I suddenly really wanted a kid he's just go along with it. But I know that's because of the division of roles, its just not going to be a big deal to him like it is to me.

Anyone else feel like a similar situation?


r/Fencesitter • • Oct 15 '24

Off the fence. Goodbye to this sub

1.2k Upvotes

This sub has been extremely helpful but it is time for me to say goodbye. My husband and I confirmed what we have thought all along, that we want to live the childfree lifestyle. He’s going to be getting a vasectomy this year. Good luck to everyone in making their decision. Goodbye!


r/Fencesitter • • Nov 21 '21

The "just adopt" response

1.1k Upvotes

Hello folks,

We've gotten some complaints about the frequent "just adopt" response. We understand that 99% of the time it's said in good faith and with no intention to hurt but we wanted folks to know that it sometimes falls very flat. It can be downright offensive in many cases when it's tossed about with no understanding of how adoption works or doesn't work.

  • Oh, you're not too old, just adopt: Actually, many agencies will have age limits on adoption.

  • Oh, if you're worried about your mental health, just adopt: No, people with serious mental health issues will be denied adoption in many jurisdictions.

  • Oh, you're LGBTQ and cannot have kids normally? Just adopt: No, in many places non hetero couples are still denied adoption rights.

  • Oh, you're worried about pregnancy? Just adopt: No, adoption of infants is extremely expensive and takes years.

  • Oh, you're worried about autism? Just adopt: No, in many cases neuro diversity issues are not known prior to adoption.

  • Oh, you're concerned about bio kids? Just adopt: Yah, maybe, except that might not be what they're looking for and we ask people to respect that.

  • Oh, afraid of climate change? Just adopt or foster, those kids are waiting for a savior: That's not the way the foster system works and going into it with some savior complex is a horrible idea.

Does any of this mean that adoption or fostering isn't a wonderful option? No. Adoption and fostering through a reputable agency is wonderful. It is not however some perfect option to allow people to choose their designer baby. Head on over to r/Adoption if you want a bit of reality.

So please, it's a wonderful option and it can and should be considered more than it is. It's also not something to be lightly tossed into a conversation as a cure all for any fencesitter question. As always, consider the impact of your words.


r/Fencesitter • • Jan 25 '25

Reflections The one insight about parenthood that got me firmly off the fence

1.0k Upvotes

I spent a lot of time researching parenthood from age 18 or so onward. I felt like I wasn’t getting an accurate portrayal of it anywhere. I sought out stories from regretful parents (especially mothers). I’m a researcher by trade who is also neurodivergent so I have very powerful pattern recognition and mental qualitative data synthesis skills, which over time, after years of collecting story after story, sentiment after sentiment, many seemingly contradicting each other (I.e. many with regrets, many overjoyed), I finally distilled the fact about parenthood that explained EVERYONE’S widely variant experiences with it and allowed me to make the right decision for myself.

It makes the highs higher and the lows lower

That’s it. People who already struggle with emotional lows, or who have unbalanced or antagonistic relationships with their partners, or any other number of negative things which are relatively mild pre-children: they typically have a BAD time becoming parents.

Meanwhile, I reflected on this and found I really didn’t have any real lows in my life, and my husband and I enjoyed a lot of highs. We’d been together 7 years, and experienced plenty of challenges, but we always tackled them effectively as partners. I figured, we could stand to be pushed a lot lower than we have been thus far. And, I would love to experience what these highs would be like if they were even higher, which seemed unimaginable.

Well, 8 months into parenthood, and it’s truly played out exactly as predicted based on this idea. The lows are lower, and we’re taking them all in stride with room to spare. The highs are EUPHORIC. The level of love I get to experience is like nothing I ever could have even begin to comprehend before I first heard my newborn’s cry.

I see so many people in this sub struggling the same way I did with all the seemingly contradictory stories out there. The reality is: parenthood is GREAT for some people and couples. It’s TERRIBLE for others. I firmly believe the way to determine what’s right for you is to ask yourself this question: can I handle lower lows? You have to be very honest with yourself about what your lows have been. Can you handle 50% lower than that? 100% lower? If so, the indescribable payoff that comes with the higher highs is probably worth it. I’m sure there are some exceptions. But this analysis led me, personally, down the right path, and I’m sure it’s relevant to a lot of people here.


r/Fencesitter • • Apr 27 '21

Childfree This is the feeling

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/Fencesitter • • Apr 03 '25

Parenting 'If it's not a hell yes, it's a hell no' - Wrong (my experience)

1.0k Upvotes

After having my baby almost one year ago, after being a fencesitter for pretty much my entire adult life, I thought I'd share my experience.

Before I had my kid, I always heard: If it's not a hell yes, then it's a hell no (to kids). This made me feel so insecure and even more confused about my decision of whether to have kids or not. Because for me, it was never a hell yes. It wasn't even a yes. It was a 'hmm, it sounds nice to have a kid, but it also sounds absolutely terrifying, exhausting, and I don't want to lose myself and the life I have'. What I did in the end - I listened to my heart, AND I made a list of rational reasons for and against a child (e.g. pros: We're financially stable, we have a stable relationship etc., cons: I work full time and I don't want to give up my career for a baby etc). So, I had the baby almost a year ago. And while it has definitely been challenging at times, I can also say it has been the most wonderful thing I've ever done in my life. Zero regrets, so much love, so much FUN (minus the first couple of weeks haha).

So while I'm off the fence (and will probably even have a 2nd child) I just want to say: Please don't listen to people that make everything a black and white decision. I actually think it can be a GOOD thing if you're not a 'hell yes' person to the decision of having kids or not, because it actually shows you take your time to make such an important decision, and don't just decide it lightly. It's very normal to have doubts, before you have a child, and even during pregnancy (and sometimes even after the child is born). Nobody can make this decision for you, but just know that not being sure about having kids does absolutely not mean you're going to regret having a child. My two cents.


r/Fencesitter • • May 09 '21

I think I'm off the fence... for the strangest reason....

1.0k Upvotes

So it's been occupying my mind for the last 2 years, during which I've had 2 miscarriages, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't sometimes think that was for the best.

Anyway... recent GP visit she said... Maybe I should refer you to [local IVF clinic] and I said let me talk to my partner about this.... So I went home and talked and he just said basically no, babe, if we can't do it naturally, if our bodies don't make babies together then that's that and we should accept it and move on. Some people weren't meant to breed, we'll live just as fulfilling a life in a different way.

That was very freeing for me, like there's been a line drawn in the sand and we've stepped over it now. I won't worry about this any more, it's over with, I'll just concentrate on living my best life going forward, knowing my husband is totally onside with this choice.


r/Fencesitter • • Sep 28 '20

Anxiety I overheard a conversation where men were trashing their partners bodies after they had children...it disgusted me and has pushed me more in the childfree direction....

972 Upvotes

Context: My SO had some friends visit from out of state. They are both fathers. My SO has expressed that he definitely wants kids. I considered myself childfree but him wanting them so much has pushed me on the fence.

Situation: They woke up early and were all talking outside, I slept in a little. When I woke up I could hear them talking very clearly (paper thin walls) from my bed without even getting up. I wasn’t really paying attention to what they were saying but started to when I heard a sudden volume drop. His friends were talking about watching the birth of their kids. How they were absolutely disgusted. Then they started talking about their partners vaginas and labias, how they were “hanging” now and never the same, laughing about how gross and ugly they looked now. Laughing about how “ugly” their breasts were now after breastfeeding. My SO didn’t say anything, and then he changed the subject.

I was horrified. I was already a fencesitter and imagining my SO being secretly disgusted by my post-baby body brought tears to my eyes. Pissed me off that women have to sacrifice their bodies to bring life into this world just for men to trash them, but still use them for sex. Ugh.

Idk, can any fencesitter men who ended up having children restore my faith in humanity? Do you still love your partners changed body?


r/Fencesitter • • May 04 '22

AMA I Reluctantly Had A Child And Regret The Decision, AMA

929 Upvotes

I was a specific type of fencesitter.  I was on the fence because "I don't want kids, but my wife does."  If left to my own devices, I would never have become a father.  But in the end, I loved my wife more than I loved myself and wanted to give her what she wanted.  And besides, as society will tell you, everyone loves their own kids and it's different when it's your own.

I've posted various parts of my story on Reddit as they happened, so if you want the play-by-play, that journey starts here: https://np.reddit.com/r/childfree/comments/201prv/reporting_back_from_the_other_side/

In summary of those posts, as much as I wished and as much as I tried, I never properly bonded with my daughter.  It led to years of depression, pretty much constant for the first 5 years, and on and off (Unfortunately more on than off) in the years since then.

And eventually came the real kicker.  My wife left me for someone else and they had a child together less than one year after we were divorced.

None of us are bad people.  We all tried our best.  Depression is contagious and I don't blame anyone for what they would do to escape from it.  My daughter was well behaved for her age all along this journey (I can only imagine how much worse things would've been for me if she wasn't).  And she's grown into a pretty awesome little person.

But I can't help but regret.  This isn't the life I wanted to lead.

I've heard some people here say something like "If it's not a hell yeah, then it's a hell no."  Even from my position, I disagree.  I imagine most people have some amount of doubts and fears becoming a parent.  My general stance is "Don't have a child unless it's something you want"

I didn't want a child, but I wanted my wife and I loved her enough to make the sacrifice.  In the end, I lost that wife but still have the child.  I didn't end up with what I wanted.  If I wanted my wife and my child, at least I'd still have some part of what I wanted.  Just using the word "sacrifice" there is enough of a sign that I shouldn't have become a parent.  Having a child shouldn't be a sacrifice.

So honestly, if you're a fencesitter purely because you have a partner that wants a child but you would never want one yourself, please be true to yourself.  It could work out fine, but it might not.  And if it doesn't, it's not just you that suffers, it's not just your partner that suffers, it's also your innocent child that suffers.

Ask Me Anything

(And in the interest of not letting this post itself become too unwieldy, I'll post some comments with additional thoughts and reflections on my situation as well)


r/Fencesitter • • Feb 13 '21

Literally how I’ve begun to feel since age 35

Post image
924 Upvotes

r/Fencesitter • • Jul 09 '25 This

The Mental Exercise that Got me off the Fence

877 Upvotes

My partner (35f) and I (37m) have been on the fence for about five years. When it came to the decision to have children, we kept kicking the can down the road, always thinking we'd deal with it later. As the years went on, our age eventually pressured us to think more critically about whether or not to have kids.

We are both fortunate enough to earn a decent income, so our lifestyle is very much travel oriented. We vacation internationally once or twice per year, with a couple domestic trips squeezed in as well. When we aren't travelling, we enjoy the freedom of going out on the town most weekends or having a quiet night at home with some takeaway and a bottle of wine.

Our child pros and cons list is similar, I'm sure, to many on this sub. Pros: sense of emotional fulfillment, expression of love with my partner, personal growth, social connections. Cons: Loss of freedom, financial strain, lifestyle change, stress.

After many conversations ultimately going nowhere, we decided to enlist the help of a couples therapist to try to provide some clarity. She had us go through different exercises that focused on envisioning ourselves in different child and child free scenarios. We found these exercises helpful, but when the session was over, we still had the same fears and trepidations as when we started. Ultimately, my partner found her way onto the pro-children side of the fence, but only slightly. However, I was still firmly dead center.

After a few months of this, our therapist tasked me with a different exercise. For the next three days, pretend that you have definitively made the decision to have children. After that, spend the next three days pretending you have made the decision NOT to have children. So, for the next three days, I tried to trick my brain into thinking that my partner and I were going to have a child. It took about a day or two for me to really convince myself, but when it finally set it, I found that my overwhelming emotion was not fear or anxiety, but excitement. So much so that I didn't even bother with the latter three days of the exercise. Something about extending the mental exercise beyond the 45 minute therapy session allowed me to really take stock of the decision, and how it made me feel.

Fast forward a bit, we're expecting our baby boy in January.


r/Fencesitter • • Jun 27 '22

Childfree We are off the fence!

869 Upvotes

As a big thank you to this community I wanted to share some of my own reflections and perspective on how we arrived at our decision. I understand these tips/strategies will not work for everyone! Apologies for formatting, I’m on mobile.

We are choosing childfree. To sum up the decision in one sentence, it came down to going with the least “riskiest” option that aligned with our values as individuals and as a family. We know we can be happy and fulfilled together as things are in the present and we choose to not chance that.

Some realizations along the way:

  1. For us, it was not a decision that we made once, in one conversation. It was many conversations, back and forth, for about 3 years.

  2. We acknowledged that either way, we will have regrets. What we needed to think through was: which regrets are we okay living with? For us, we would rather regret not having a child than regret having one. We feel better about the options we have if we develop a desire to parent (pets, fostering, nieces and nephew visits, mentor programs, etc) than if we had a child of our own and regretted it.

  3. Over the years we’ve had people pass away in our families and have observed parts of the “who will take care of you when you’re old” sentiment played out. Many times, we noticed sons and daughters barely around to help their parents. We’ve also seen childfree friends or family members pass with equal if not more care and attention than those with children. I recognize this is certainly not everyone’s experience. The truth is, we have no control over if our child will even want to be in our lives as an adult, vice versa. We do have control over how we want to set up our retirement and end of life care, that can be our decision.

Some strategies we used:

  1. We made the decision to have kids, then lived our lives for a month thinking we would absolutely have kids and journal out what we went through and how we felt. Then, we decided to not have kids, and lived in that headspace for a month while journaling. After this, we took three months off and didn’t discuss kids at all. We came back to the conversation when we were ready.

  2. Read “The Baby Decision” together, the book made me lean towards having a child and had the opposite effect on my partner.

  3. Couples counseling, enough said :)

  4. We went though a “values” exercise together and individually. To do: grab a list of values from Google, a long list, 50+ values. Narrow the list of values down to 20, then 10, then 5, until you get your top 3 values that you stand by personally and as a family.

  5. We each brainstormed a personal mission statement (use any template from google to guide your thinking, and make sure your values as an individual are represented in the statement)

  6. Then we brainstormed a mission statement as a family (again making sure those values are in there. And yes, it’s absolutely as cheesy as it sounds and I loved every second of it!)

  7. Created 5-year personal and family goals

  8. Created 10-year personal and family goals.

There is also the financial piece. Our careers are a library assistant (part-time) and non-profit work. Neither bring in big bucks but both are personally rewarding for us. And it’s enough for the lifestyle we like to maintain. If we had a child, we would need to make more money.

Overall, we treasure our quiet mornings, spontaneous trips abroad and only having ourselves, pets and the garden to care for.

Lastly, this is our life. We’ve realized that a child or children do not have to be our legacy. We can leave a legacy without having children. We get to decide what we want to do and for us personally, a childfree life allows us to live more in tune with our personal values and goals.

It’s been a long road, grateful we put in the work to land on this decision and privileged to actually have a decision to make and not be forced one way or another.

Wishing you all the same clarity and peace of mind with whichever decision you choose!

PS: we booked a trip to Disney to celebrate!!!


r/Fencesitter • • Mar 26 '20

Recently received some unsolicited advice that I actually appreciated.

868 Upvotes

A co-worker nonchalantly said 'Well,when you(F/30) and your husband(M/29) have kids...blah blah...' (as one does) and after I mentioned that I didn't think we would have kids, he said:

'I'm sure you receive a lot of unsolicited advice, but I have some more for you. Once you decide, be 100% in or 100% out. Take the good and the bad of either decision and own it.''

To me, that meant if I have kids don't spend my time thinking about what could have been, go into it whole heartedly. If I don't have kids, whole heartedly enjoy the CF life - which is starting to feel like the best route for us!

Hope someone else can find that as helpful as I did!


r/Fencesitter • • Aug 30 '26 Helpful

If you're unsure about having kids, don't do it.

826 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I'm 36m. I was always around 25% sure of wanting children, and my wife 35f was 70% sure. My biggest concern of having kids was loss of autonomy and losing control of my day to day. Fast forward to now and we have 4 month old twins.

It's terrible.

My autonomy is gone. Every part of my life is affected by my children in a negative way. My sleep, my eating habits, my work outs, my relationship with my wife and friends. It's terrible.

On top of it all, I have a history of anxiety and depression and having children exacerbated those things considerably. I had to go to a behavioral health urgent care for panic attacks and increased depression. I definitely had post partum anxiety and I had days I could barely eat anything due to the stress.

My wife is more content with the children, especially since she wanted them more in the first place.

If you are in a relationship and don't see eye to eye on children, break up. Seriously. Divorce. Seriously. Unless you both can be content without having children, seperate.

The stress and strife of a divorce is so much smaller than having a child.

Once you are single again, find hobbies and people with similar interests. The weight of the world will be off of your shoulders.

Having kids cannot be a half-assed decision. If you have doubts, please don't have children. For your sake and for your potential children's sake.


r/Fencesitter • • Aug 14 '26

A former fence sitter, 10 days postpartum

824 Upvotes

I was childfree most of my life, then fencesitter. Wanted kids for many of the usual reasons - didn’t see what we’d do for the next 55 years, achieved everything I wanted in life, over clubbing and drinking, wasn’t fulfilled by work or hobbies, friends were having kids and got FOMO, felt life was too comfortable/boring/pointless, everything was monotonous and just work broken up by the odd holiday. Didn’t want them because sensory issues, read endless horror stories about regretting it, hated other people’s kids, love quiet time to myself, love my freedom to read 40 books a year and have 10 hour sleeps.

Got off the fence very slightly, pregnant first try, panicked massively. Genuinely considered abortion in the first trimester, went through many counselling and mental health services. All I’d read was horror stories about drudgery, nightmare children, “you’ll never sleep again”, relationship breakups, and as a risk averse person I couldn’t handle the uncertainty of what was to come. Physically, the pregnancy was pretty textbook and easy, just the last few weeks was physically tough (and nausea and heatwaves). Mentally very hard and anxiety riddled. I made lots of pregnancy friends, more in 6 months than the previous 10 years.

Well….now she’s here! And I absolutely love my life. I literally can’t fathom my old life anymore. I love her so much, I love looking at her little face and all the funny things she does, and feel guilty about how I felt in 1st trimester. And I know it’s very early days, but none of the internet horror stories have come to pass. We do mostly formula, so me and husband split the nights into 5h shifts (or sometimes full nights each). On a good night shift we get 7-8 hours each, on a bad night 4-5, but there is no day I’ve been a zombie apart from the night in hospital in a shared ward, and night 3 when I was stressed over relatives staying with us and slept 2 hours. She sleeps 3 hour chunks and my husband has been going to the gym regularly, we’ve been out with her loads for brunch, our house is clean and tidy, and I’ve been making my way through Desperate Housewives 😊

I was worried about the baby crying aggravating my sensory issues….she doesn’t really cry unless we’re late to feed her, and actually holding her calms me down so much whereas nothing used to before. And her crying is sad but not in that rage-inducing random kid in a supermarket way, just sad because I want to fix it.

Thought having a baby would be drudgery/monotony - it would be if it was someone else’s baby, but with mine, changing nappies and feeding/burping her is a joy. It’s hard work when you don’t like what you’re doing, I’ve enjoyed every single moment with her. In my old life, I’d feel guilty for watching TV all day and not being productive. Now I don’t care because keeping her alive is productive!

I was worried about getting fat in pregnancy….put on 6-7kg and lost it already. Baby was 3.4kg at 38 weeks so very healthy.

Worried other mums would judge me about formula or wanting a c section….no-one cares.

Worried I’d have no time for myself - yes I can’t sit all day long reading or on the internet, but that’s a GOOD thing as I had too much time on my hands before, and at the moment I still have a lot of time - just 2-3 hour chunks.

Worried our relationship would go to shit - it’s stronger than ever as we are a team.

I would caveat this by saying we were in a good financial position, have very good mat/pat leaves, and my husband is 50/50 in everything so far and I knew he would be. And I’m not exclusive breastfeeding, I think that would make things MUCH harder.

If you are someone who gets bored of jobs, hobbies, or projects, having a baby is the best. It’s an ever changing lifelong challenge - just as you have something sussed, they develop and change.

TL/DR - having a kid 5⭐️ would recommend


r/Fencesitter • • Mar 31 '21

Finally off the fence

771 Upvotes

Yesterday I made my choice, I’m finally free.

My choice is not to have kids, I’m officially, 100%, childfree.

I’d love to say that it came after deep contemplative thought, but for me it just suddenly ‘clicked’.

I was reading an article about the Japanese Cherry Blossoms blooming earlier than ever because of climate change, and that’s when it finally happened.

I know that if I were to have a child I’d spend the rest of my life worried for their future. I don’t want to live my life that way and I know it would a constant thought in the back of my mind.

It feels so good to say I’m finally off the fence!


r/Fencesitter • • Feb 08 '25

Reflections Some things I wish I knew before I had kids

762 Upvotes

I was on the fence for several years. Worried I wouldn't be 'maternal' enough, not good enough, worried about a lot of things, including my freedom and relationship with my partner. Now I have two kids (4 and 1) and am very happy about it. Here are a few things I wish I knew:

1. It's perfectly possible to not be a 'kids person', but adore and be happy with your own kids

I never particularly enjoyed the presence of kids. I would never voluntarily work with them. I don't remember ever seeing a baby in the street and thinking "Oh, how cute! I want to hold it" Yet, I love my own and think they are awesome. I enjoy being around them.

2. Who you have kids with is probably the most important decision you can make when you become a parent

Perhaps I chose wisely, perhaps I was just lucky, but honestly, as a mother, I never felt that my partner didn't do enough or that I had to handle all the mental and physical load by myself. We are naturally pretty 50/50 in terms of childcare and domestic work for us that works very well. If I'm tired, I ask him to take over, and the other way around. We are a united front.

3. Your house doesn't need to be a complete mess with kids

When I visited acquaintances with kids I was often a bit taken aback by all the huge piles and piles of toys lying around everywhere in the house (not judging them personally, just not something I'd want for myself - I really enjoy when my flat is tidy and uncluttered). In our case, the toys are in the kids room, and there is a small corner in the living room with toys, that's it. It takes me 5 minutes max to tidy those things - I just have a bunch of big boxes where I throw the toys and get them out of sight and out of the way quickly. Done. I'd say out apartment is pretty tidy most of the time. Admittedly, our flat is not perfectly clean, but I think we could solve that if we hired a house cleaner once every 1-2 weeks.

4. You can learn how to be a decent parent. It's not rocket science

My parents were abusive and I never had any good models in terms of parenting, so I was pretty worried that I wouldn't know what to do and how to parent. First of all, I went to a therapist and worked on my own demons - that was crucial. Besides that, I also read a handful of books/blogs about parenting and that gave me enough information to be (I think) a reasonably decent parent. There are solutions for pretty much any parenting problem out there. You don't need to know everything from day 1. You can take time to grow into your role and learn about parenting issues once they come up.

5. There are so many possible ways to make your life easier as a parent

First of all, IF you have money, you can outsource a ton and hire help, get a house cleaner, nanny, babysitter, groceries delivered etc. Your baby has trouble sleeping? Hire a sleep coach - that really helped us tremendously. Breastfeeding doesn't work well? Ask a lactation consultant. Obviously, many people don't have that money, so those are not solutions for everyone.

Second, a lot of the things that many parents hyperfocus on and often struggle with nowadays aren't actually that important, according to the best scientific evidence. For example, breastfeeding is great if it works, but the benefits according to the best studies are actually minuscule. Formula is a fantastic alternative, unless you don't have access to clean water. Another example is that daycare is fine. Any beneficial and detrimental effects that studies find are very small (on average!). If you don't wanna be a stay at home parent and can afford daycare, use it and enjoy the freedom. Also, screen time is not the devil. It is definitely possible to overuse it but some minutes of screen time when you need to cook dinner in peace is fine.

6. It probably won't get easy, but it will likely get much easier pretty quickly

My 4 year old is so easy compared to my 1 year old. She can dress herself, go to the bathroom by herself, play by herself, tell me what she wants. She can easily stay with her friend for an afternoon and sometimes sleeps over at her best friends'. She does let me sleep in in the morning and finds something to occupy herself. Yes, she still has occasional tantrums, is impatient, doesn't know how to do a lot of things, but I don't need to worry about her every second, and it is definitely possible to spend some weekends away from her (when she stays at her grandparents). So, my freedom is not nearly at the same level it was as before kids, but I am not tied to my kids every single minute either. Some amount of freedom came back pretty quickly for us, and it feels even more special now.

7. You will be shamed and judged no matter how you parent. So you can as well do it as you like

Pretty self-explanatory. You will never ever not be judged as a parent. So don't even bother trying to please everyone with your choices. Do your research, and then do what is right for you.


r/Fencesitter • • Aug 12 '21

Reflections Life After Baby

752 Upvotes

I was on the fence about having a baby, leaning more toward no. I wish there had been more posts like this (i.e. people who have healthy children, supportive partners and financial resources) when I was lurking, so I’ll share for your benefit.

I had an easy pregnancy. Was able to sleep well, eat healthfully, walk 5-7 miles per day and use our Peloton until about 8 months.

Delivery wasn’t easy, and we were in the hospital for a week following(for my health), but labor was nowhere near as bad as I’d imagined and recovery has been straightforward/progressed well.

We have, by all accounts, an easy baby. She is happy and cries very little, discounting a predictable (but not regular) fussy period for 15-60 minutes on and off per day if she’s overtired. She even stops crying, for example, if she has a wet diaper and you set her on her changing pad, or if she’s hungry and we put a bib on her. She sleeps 6+ hours per night consistently at 8 weeks. She smiles a ton, loves to cuddle, and strangers stop us to tell us how cute and well behaved she is.

We have been able to afford help, including a great home daycare, a night nurse who comes once a week and a mother’s helper who will sit when we have dates. We had 4 showers, got everything on our registry and have a great friend community that loves to help out (unsolicited).

I have a great job that is very flexible, has great benefits and pays well. My husband is very engaged and is with our daughter at the pediatrician now, and also works at a company he founded/loves working at. We split time on the evenings and weekends to be able to do things we want and do things together. We formula feed, and I am not tethered to the baby at all times.

I’d do anything for my daughter, and my heart absolutely melts when she smiles or when I snuggle her during a late night feed. There is no doubt in my mind that I love her.

Before you think I’m here to rub in what a great life we’ve got, I’d say that even with all this (and a full awareness of the privilege I have on so many levels that I don’t take for granted) I wouldn’t do it again if I could choose. Here’s why:

  1. I miss myself. I miss having opportunities to do whatever I want, whenever I want. In particular, I miss travel and reading at the moment.

  2. I miss my husband. Even with some intentional rituals of connection daily, it feels like we’re ships passing in the night.

  3. I miss my career. Of course it’s my choice, but I passed on a promotion because I wanted to make sure I could be a good parent.

  4. I miss my body. This is probably the most controversial, but I had a great body before that I worked hard to maintain, mostly because I love the endorphin rush from a workout. I also miss sex. It’s incredibly painful (even though I had a C section) because baby sat low on my left side and my pelvic floor muscles are very tight (grateful to be able to see a great PT).

I work in education and take each of our nieces and nephews (who live too far away to see regularly) on 10th birthday trips, so I had the fulfillment of interactions with children and a job that (I hope) makes a difference before baby. We are 40, well educated, live in a city and are likely considered upper-middle class. We were married 12 years before baby, together 17. Husband wanted kids much more than I did (adding for context).

On the balance, I am sure I will look back one day and be glad to have a child, particularly if she turns out to be a wonderful human being, which I can imagine her being. That said, I know for certain I wouldn’t do it again if I could go back in time.


r/Fencesitter • • Jul 02 '24

Childfree I wish there were more childfree groups that are not child-hating.

725 Upvotes

This isn't even about the childfree sub. However, from a recommended post this morning, I believe they are unironically supporting eugenics 🙃. However, this goes for any child-free group.

I lean toward childfree for several reasons: mental health, finances, freedom, etc. However, I don't hate children; if I don't know a child, I might be awkward, but I try to be friendly and positively interact with them. I see them as little people who just haven't learned to self-regulate yet.

Most child-free groups I join, even the ones that have clearly in the rules "No Child-hating," usually at some point have people deciding it's a good idea to call children "it" or parents "breeders" and other derogatory names.

I don't get it; you are so happy being child-free, but you spend every waking moment finding ways to shit on kids and parents?


r/Fencesitter • • Dec 07 '25

Parenting Thoughts after having a baby 6 months ago

711 Upvotes

(Sorry, it's long. Reflection / summary at the bottom)

Background:

My husband and I were child-free since we met in college. We went through all of our 20s and over half our 30s as very firmly child-free. Then something changed. I think it was a trip to Paris, where we ate and drank and did everything we wanted to do. It was pure hedonism, and it should've made us happy. Instead, it highlighted to us that no matter how great our lives were, something felt hollow, like we were lacking meaning.

Meaning can come from a lot of different sources, but we didn't have any of those (family/friends far away, careers good but not meaningful, not religious, no big hobbies). In retrospect, I think this was a bad reason to have a kid, as having a kid doesn't automatically give you meaning (at least not for me).

Anyway, after fencesitting and reading this forum for a few years, I pulled the plug on my IUD and we switched to cycle-tracking as our only birth control while trying to figure out what to do. This part sucks, as you all know, and a part of me hoped the decision would be made for me somehow. Well, a few cycles into it, we were irresponsible once (ovulating, we ran out of condoms, and I said it was fine to proceed) and bam. Pregnant at 38 years old. I think I knew as soon as it happened.

Pregnancy:

As soon as I was pregnant, I went into autopilot, and booked all the Dr appointments, started taking supplements, made spreadsheets on what to buy, and even stopped drinking coffee.

But a week into it, I finally processed it, and went into a full on panic spiral. I took the day off of work and read r/regretfulparents until I was pretty certain I'd made a massive mistake. I told my husband that I didn't want to keep the baby, and he seemed shaken, but said he'd support me. I picked up the abortion pill (don't live in the US) after work. But everytime I contemplated taking it, I'd come up with a reason to wait. Taking the pill felt 'wrong' to me in an intuitive way. I wrote down all the reasons I shouldn't have the baby, and then decided, F it, we're having this baby anyway, and threw away the pill (apologies for wasting resources).

The pregnancy was fine except for some gender disappointment. I always pictured having a little girl, so when I found out it was a boy, I went back to panicking and feeling regretful. I was sure I was 1 and done, but now I'd never have a girl. I didn't want a hyper / rambunctious boy at all. Was a bit depressed for awhile over this.

Birth:

Giving birth was worse than I thought it'd be. I'm good at managing pain, but this was somethin else. I had 'back labor' and thanks to a lack of resources at the hospital I was birthing in, had to wait 6 hours (pure agony) for an epidural. Once the epidural was in, labored for another 10 hours, and they kept saying I wasn't dilated enough, and were pumpling me full of pitocin to speed up the labor. My uterus was duing backflips and the baby's heartrate was all of the place. Turns out, I'd been dilated for a long time, but the passageway was blocked by the membraines around the baby. The only way forward was an emergency C-Section. It was honestly fine. I was glad for it to be done.

The moment I met my baby, I felt a sense of peace. I knew I'd do anything to protect the little guy. I don't know about overwhelming love, but it was more like "this is mine to protect".

Postpartum recovery:

I'd been very active throughout my pregnancy, and healed up pretty quick in that I was walking around the next day and within a few weeks, was doing some challening hikes. I had some issues with recovery mostly bc I have a hard time resting (incision was infected, got nipple thrush from the antibiotics used to treat the infection, incision started opening a bit, stitches popped out) but by my 6 week check up, all was healed. C-sections are not the easy way out, and even with people who say they healed quickly, the incision takes awhile to settle.

My pelvic floor had somehow gotten overly tight, and even 6 months after, need to go to physical therapy to help loosen it up back to normal. It hurts too much to have sex, and so we don't, which has been difficult.

Sleep:

Sleep, or lack of, has been the hardest part of all of this. I didn't realize that when I decided to exclusively breastfeed, that it meant I'd be doing 100% of night duty. In my head, I thought somehow we'd share nights, or do shifts. But when the baby just needs a little boob time to settle, it doesn't make sense for both parents to be up.

My baby gets up every 2-3 hours to eat, through the day, and through the whole night. In 6+ months, I haven't had more than a 3 hour stretch of consecutive sleep. I feel emotional just thinking about sleep, and am sure I've gotten a lot dumber this year.

My husband and I sleep in seperate bedrooms so he can sleep through the night, and then around 5am, I feed the baby and hand him to my husband, and then I get 2-3 hours of uninterrupted sleep. That last bit of morning sleep has saved my sanity.

The sleep regressions have been brutal, especially the famous 4 month regression. He was up every 30-45 mintues through the night, and I almost lost my mind. We're currently attempting to 'gently' sleep train the guy, but so far it's been hit/miss.

Parenting:

A lot of early parenting depends on what kind of baby you get, but also your attitude. I love my little guy so much, but he's been a very difficult baby. He screams when you put him down, only naps on a person or in a carrier, won't tolerate sleeping in a crib, or sitting in a car seat, took 5+ months to tolerate sitting in a stroller/pram, refused baths (have to shower him), refused bottles, had a bad latch, had colic/reflux so spent hours screaming everyday until he was 3 months old, insists on eating every few ours even at 6 months, and is generally very 'high needs.'

We decided to roll with it, and have done a ton of traveling while on parental leave. We realized that they key was to go outside as much as possible, so we strap him on, and walk. He's completely happy/chill as long as we're outside. We've been to 4+ countries over the last 6 months, and it's been good.

The older he gets, the easier it gets too. He's now so giggly, smiley and fun. His laugh is like the best dopamine hit. It's also so cool seeing his face twist up or light up when he tries new food. I'm excited to see how he grows and who he becomes.

Relationship:

This has been hard. My husband and I are rock solid, he's my bestie and has been since we were 19. I suspect my husband has postpartum anxiety (dudes can get it), as he's always worrying about random shit ('we need to check pollution levels', 'microplastics!', 'research every ingredient in his diaper cream', etc..). My husband is absolutely obsessed with this baby, and during the day, is the primary parent.

Having a baby will compound even the smallest issues/fights you had before. My husband and I used to occasionally fight bc I don't like my in-laws (with good reason). Well, this came to such a head when I was just a few weeks postpartum. Won't go into details, but it was so hard.

Our relationship has definitely suffered. We argue at least once a day about the stupidest stuff you can imagine (partly due to me not sleeping enough, partly due to his anxiety, and partly bc we're dumb like that).

But I know it's a season, and our foundation is strong enough that we'll be fine.

Reflections:

I love my little guy more everyday. Don't regret a thing. If I (+ my husband) didn't have generous parental leave, or was strapped financially, this might've been a nightmare, so I do acknowledge my privilege. This might have also been so much easier if my baby was 'easy' and slept well, but you get what you get.

I think having a baby doesn't give meaning, but rather, you're so distracted, you don't care anymore. I'm now on a lower level of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, so don't need to worry about self-actualizing. If I'd known this before having a baby, I might have doubled down on looking for meaningful hobbies or something instead of having a baby to scratch that itch in my life.

In an alternate world where I didn't have my baby, my life would be a lot easier. I don't think I appreciated just have simple/easy/free it was. I didn't appreciate how much time I had. If I'd wanted to, I could sleep as much as I wanted! I could go to the gym for a long time and nobody would be mad. I could have uninterrupted laptop time, for hours and hours! I grieve this old life, and do feel weepy when I think about it too much.

It's also easy to spell out all the ways my life is harder now, but harder to explain the absolute joy I feel when snuggling with this tiny baby. His laughter is gold. He's all big eyes, dimples, button nose, rosy cheeks, fuzzy head, and soft skin. He's absolutely gorgeous, a perfect combo of me and my favorite person, and him being 'difficult' doesn't bother me as much as pre-baby me might think. I spend more time laughing than I did before. There's a lot of joy and satisfaction in doing things for someone else (a lot of us have martyr tendencies). I 'get' why people have more than one now, but think I'll probably stop with one.