r/FeMRADebates • • May 12 '21

Personal Experience just watched The Red Pill Documentary and it revealed to me that feminists arguments have massive blind spots as they seemingly only focus on white men

264 Upvotes

Many issues feminists raise also pertain to men of color.

Take one issue: sexualization. The sexualization of men of color. As a black man, when I confessed I liked my first love and asked her out she told me she didn't like boys with "small dicks" and that she only liked guys with big dicks. I was 14 years old and told out the gate that my worth was only through my penis size. I wasn't even small either.

Few years later? Had my cock grabbed by a girl to confirm to her girls my penis size. She just got away with it. Did I tell anyone? Fuck no.

As a black man I am consistently fetishized, even by women of my own race. To be a "real" black man, you must be alpha of the most alpha. You must be tall as a basketball player, have endless swag, and an 8 inch dick. People constantly sexualize black men and assume we are freaks in the sack as if that's our only worth.

And that's without the assumption that we are inherently criminals.

Imagine being a black boy and growing up in that environment and realizing at an early age that your worth is what is between your pants. Imagine being an Asian boy and having a lifetime of dehumanization and emasculating behavior on the assumption - I'll reemphasize, assumption - that you have a small penis and therefore have little worth.

But according to feminism we have male privilege and are inherently oppressors.

Watch this interview with Big Red:

https://youtu.be/fHppdGqHtrU

Would anything she's saying about men apply to black men or other non-white men?

While I acknowledge that there are some feminists tackling the topic of race, most notably intersectional feminists, is still feels like a massive blind spot. Intersectional feminists regularly argue race issues from women's standpoint. I realize there are some feminists that argue this is a patriarchal issue and they seem to argue it in good faith that men are just as much victims of patriarchy as women are, but I'm not seeing it. I expressed these feelings to a female feminist friend and she said it's just patriarchy and men being placed in boxes. She names the problem but gives zero solutions. She blames patriarchy but it's women that told me not to cry at my own fathers funeral and that I had to stay strong "for everyone else". It was women that said my worth was in my penis. It was women that judge me because I'm less than 6 foot tall. And yet it's men that are the most understanding of my concerns and issues and I'm seen as a bad person when I say I'm not a feminist. My friend stated that women uphold patriarchy just as much as men, but isn't that a little convenient? I feel like these big sweeping things like patriarchy are only held in place arguments to keep women from accepting responsibility for their actions. "Yes you were abuse and assaulted but really it was the patriarchy and therefore men who you should actually blame." Why would any man want to sign up for that? Please humor me.

I saw this TED lecture of a woman's issue and I like this feminism, but it still blames an unseen force, the patriarchy, as the real reason for men's suffering. Video found here: https://youtu.be/l1qZCTmsEv4

I understand that intersectional feminism is very much a thing that tries to tackle the web that affects gender, but in my experience, even with those acknowledgements they still lambast men. It's very common on social media for women to make posts like,"guys will do ___ and ____ rather than go to therapy". Why don't you help form a campaign that champions the idea of therapy for men using that same platform? Even when under the guise of empathy men are still shamed and mocked.

I don't identify as an MRA, but I get it. Feminists also bring up good points. Women absolutely deserve empowerment, women deserve to be supported and not slut shamed when they are raped. I understand that many, many, many men still view women as objects. But I'm not seeing any feminists fight for anything that makes things equal while claiming they are. It very much feels like a women's specific issue. I wish there were a bigger Egalitarian movement that fights both issues facing both sexes. I think many of our goals are aligned and I'm not convinced as to how modern feminism has any actual solutions for the problems that face men.

The main pox of the modern feminist movement is claims that women are the ultimate victims when they are just as likely to be perpetrators. You are not the only one sexualized and you are not the only victims.


r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 24 '21

Politics UN removes International Men’s Day (Nov 19) from its list of international days and weeks, keeps World Toilet Day on the same day

Thumbnail
un.org
227 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jan 26 '21

Abuse/Violence Why do so many people assume that men can just freely walk around in any place without having to worry about their safety ever?

225 Upvotes

I've noticed this claim being thrown around a lot in progressive circles, and it just grinds my gears every time I hear it, especially since men make up the majority of victims when it comes to mugging, assault and homocide.

I've shared a very similar discussion on other subreddits, but it got nuked on Menslib before I got any responses and frankly, LeftWingMaleAdvocates can be a bit of a circlejerk sometimes. So I thought I'd open the discussion on here too.

Another aspect that people with this belief seem to forget is that queer men that are "visibly queer" or appear more feminine are probably at an even bigger risk of getting assaulted. (Same goes with queer women, to be honest.)

I'm guessing it might have to do with the fact that men are, for whatever reason, automatically assumed to be fearless. Which I find a false, and even potentially dangerous claim.

So I'm passing the question off to you, why is this claim as common as it is? What do you think? And if you hold this belief, why is that?


r/FeMRADebates • • Jan 20 '17

Medical Denmark's 29,000 Doctors Declare Circumcision of Healthy Boys an "Ethically Unacceptable" Procedure Offering no Meaningful Health Benefits

Thumbnail
huffingtonpost.com
187 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jun 19 '20

Men should be taught to live lives not focused around women.

186 Upvotes

I, as well as others, have heard the idea from feminists/ women's rights advocates that women don't need, or shouldn't need men. Women should be able to construct a life where they are independent from men if they wish so they can pursue their own goals.

I have no problem with this idea and I support the idea of women being independent entities with no cultural or societal obligation to base their lives around men. But the reason I mention this is because I think that society hasn't realized that maybe men need to hear this as well.

A lot of men are still trapped by old gender roles and a lot of young men in particular base their self worth, and masculinity, on their interactions with women. Primarily in terms of how many dates they can get and how many women they can bed. The negative consequences of men being stuck in these gender roles, and unable to fulfill them, can end up being both detrimental to those men's self esteem and society at large (see incels).

I'm not advocating for MGTOW or necessarily anything that extreme, but i think modern men should be taught how to lead a life that doesn't necessarily involve or revolve around women. I think it would help to improve a lot of men's self esteem and self worth, especially in the age of female empowerment.

I'd like to hear your thoughts and perspectives on this.


r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 20 '21

Other Being stay-at-home is a privilege

162 Upvotes

Privilege is about choice.

The only way people can deny what people commonly term 'female privilege' is to claim that women’s choice is a forced decision and men’s forced position is a choice. This is a common myth.

Being allowed – not forced – to stay at home is a privilege. Historically, only some women had that privilege. Men were forced – not allowed – to go to work to support women.

The difference between being allowed to do something and being forced is important. It’s the difference between employment and slavery. Between sex and rape. Between imprisonment and accommodation. This is why feminists always frame men being forced to do something as men being ‘allowed’ to. eg the draft – men being forced to fight – is cast as men being ‘allowed’ to fight. Gender roles – men being forced to support women under threat of imprisonment – are phrased as men being ‘allowed’ to work. This is as ridiculous as a man claiming female rape victims are privileged because they are “allowed to have sex.” Or slaves are privileged because they are “allowed to work.” Or conscripted men are privileged because they are “allowed to fight.”

Some people believe men historically (and present) were not forced to work and that women were not ‘allowed’ to work, but this is incorrect so let's run down the facts.

Fact #1: Most men prefer staying at home

A survey done in 2007 found that 68% percent of fathers would be a stay-at-home parent if money were no object. Another survey done by the Pew Research Center found that 87% of men who did quit their job after having a child to stay at home say they are glad they did. Warren Farrell reported in “The Myth of Male Power” that 80% of men he surveyed said that if they could stay at home with no loss of income and their wives approval, they would. Only 3% said they would prefer to work full-time.

Fact #2: Most women do not want to work outside the home

A survey done by the Pew Research Center found that among women at home with children less than 18, only 16% (less than one in six) say they want to work outside the home full-time. That drops to 12% if the children are young. For women with children who do work full-time outside the home, more than half want to change to working part-time or not working at all, according to yet another survey done by the Pew Research Center.

Women are 38% more likely to file for divorce if she works more than her husband than vice versa, and 29% more likely to divorce if they have had to increase the number of hours worked outside the home in the last 5 years. As The Atlantic reported:

Two facts are often obscured in the public conversation devoted to women, work, and family. First, the vast majority of married mothers don’t want to work full-time. Second, married mothers who are able to cut back at work to accommodate their family’s needs tend to be happier. The news cycle is stuck in a lean-in loop, but new data show mothers report more happiness when they can lean homeward.

In a 1985 Roper survey, only 10 percent of women declared that a husband should turn down a very good job in another city “so the wife can continue her job."

An overview of multiple studies across Europe concluded that only 14%-20% of women aged 16+ are “work-centered” which it defines as “Committed to work or equivalent activities”. The author concludes:

“Feminists constantly complain that men are not doing their fair share of domestic work. The reality is that most men already do more than their fair share.” and “As factual data replaces received wisdom, several well-entrenched feminist myths have been overturned … Men do substantially more hours of paid work.”

Fact #3: Historically, women were allowed to work outside the home.

In early agricultural societies, women worked by grinding grain for as much as 5 hours a day to make flour, in addition to tilling soil and harvesting crops by hand. This has been confirmed by studies of Ancient Egypt which show that almost all non-aristocratic women worked, including spinning, combing, and carding cloth.

From the 13th to the 17th Century, most brewers were women. A survey in 1228 found 80% of brewers in towns were female. A study of 1,350 working-class households from early 19th Century Britain suggests that the husbands’ proportion of family earning was as low as 55 percent.

Between 1787 to 1815 in families with unemployed children, wives earned 41 percent of household income. In this same period, 66% of married women had a recorded occupation. In 1833 Britain, women made up 57% – the majority – of factory workers. Even in labor-intensive agricultural work, significant numbers of women worked.

https://imgur.com/a/MFGBrg2

However, by 1851 the proportion of married women who worked had dropped to 30%. The share of household income generated by women started to decline rapidly from around 1830 onwards. Notably, this involved “increased leisure for women and children” with the percentage of income generated by men increasing from 55% in 1831-1855 up to 81% in 1860-1865.

https://imgur.com/a/1o4NdJK

By 1890, women’s work in Europe and the United States contributed just 1.9 percent to 3 percent of household income. This was entirely because of married women being supported by their husbands. By 1887, 3/4 of female workers in American cities were under 25 years old. 96% of them were single.

By 1911 only 25% of British women worked. In 1920 in the US, women were only 21% of employed adults.

We can speculate this was because the extra wealth from industrialization meant it became possible for some people to not work outside the home, and women got this benefit. This is supported by the fact that the total working hours have dropped by almost half since 1870.

This change from the vast majority of women working (pre-1850s) to a small percentage (by 1920s) was overwhelmingly welcomed by women, and universally seen as a benefit to women.

John Stuart Mill thought that “it is not… a desirable custom that the wife should contribute by her labor to the income of the family.”

The German Government stated in 1940: “the goal remains to ensure that, in 20 years’ time, no woman is obliged to work in a factory.”

In the Soviet Union, when mothers got permission to work part-time instead of full time, and fathers still had to work full-time, this was welcomed as “liberating” by women’s groups.

Even as late as 1915 women’s rights campaigner Clementina Black was complaining about the fact that married women, as well as single women, had to work to earn money.

During WWII, when many women had to do war work in factories, it was found that women had been “made miserable by the [war work]” and “fervently wished themselves back into their prewar home routine.”

During the war, there were many efforts to get women to enter the workforce, but very few did meaning that they were given the choice.

Men, however, were not.

Fact #4: Historically, men were forced to work outside the home

As early as 92 BC men were forced to support their wives by law.

Men who refused to support their wives were legally punished under Roman law.

Under the common law of ‘coverture’, which existed in England from at least 1660 to the 19th century, and in America until 1839 “A wife was entitled to be maintained by her husband” – if she got into any debts, the husband had to pay them. If he refused, he could be imprisoned in debtors' prison. Wives could not be sued or imprisoned for debt.

It’s because of this that 18th-century texts said that a married Woman ‘is a Favourite of the Law’ and described England as ‘the Paradise of women.'

Coverture was only legally abolished by the Married Women’s Property Act of 1882 (in the UK). Men were responsible for paying women’s income tax for much longer, and this was exploited by suffragettes to send their husbands to jail simply by her refusing to pay tax.

An article from 1912 notes:

Under the married women property act a husband has no jurisdiction over his wife’s property and income. Under the income tax he is responsible for her taxes. If the taxes are not paid, the husband, not the wife, is imprisoned. Mrs. Wilks refused to pay her income tax – $185 – and her husband was locked up. He will spend the rest of his life in prison unless his wife pays or the law is changed.

In 1660, a Venetian noblewoman wrote:

It is a marvelous sight in our city to see the wife of a shoemaker or butcher or even a porter all dressed up with gold chains round her neck, with pearls and valuable rings on her fingers, accompanied by a pair of women on either side to assist her and give her a hand, and then, by contrast, to see her husband cutting up meat all soiled with ox’s blood and down at heel, or loaded up like a beast of burden dressed in rough cloth, as porters are…. In France men may not spend even a centime unless at the request of their wives, and women not only administrate business dealings and sales but private income as well.

In the 19th Century, women could sue their husbands for maintenance while still married, and if she won the man could be imprisoned.

Even after the English common law of ‘coverture’ was replaced, men were legally obliged to support their wives. This was reinforced in successive acts of parliament in 1861, 1881, 1920, and 1964.

Even after the official end of coverture in Britain with the Married Women’s Property Act of 1882 husbands’ were liable for debts their wives had from before they were married. Men could, and were, imprisoned for not paying their wives' debts.

This obligation to support his wife stayed in force even if the couple lived apart, even if she had abandoned him and with no obligation on her (note divorces were extremely difficult to obtain in this period).

Around 1901, this newspaper published this heartfelt letter from 37 husbands jailed for non-support, begging their wives to let them out just for the upcoming holiday:

https://imgur.com/a/URIuwLx

Under Sharia (Islamic) law a man must support his wife: “Allah has ordained men to earn the living of his wife and children”

“A husband is obliged to earn the living for his wife and fulfill all her needs although his wife is a rich woman. The riches of a wife doesn’t nullify her right, which is the obligation of her husband.” But any money a married woman earns is her own and she has no obligation to spend it to support her husband or children.

The Constitution of the Republic of Ireland (written in 1937) explicitly states women – and only women – shall not be obliged to work:

...the State shall, therefore, endeavour to insure mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour

Similarly, in the U.S, the law is highly gendered, with the United States Supreme Court striking down an Alabama law that denied alimony to a person simply because he is male.

And as of now, only about 3% of alimony recipients of men, and campaigners admit alimony laws are only now being reformed due to the fact that now some women are having to pay.

Fact #5: Men have historically worked much harder labor than women

Even from an etymological perspective, the Biblical term eved, “slave,” only has a male form. The terms for “female slave,” shifcha and ama, are related to the Semitic words for “female” and “family.“ “This reflects the fact that female slaves often served as concubines. Clearly, neither term connotes anything to do with labor. Similarly, in Germanic languages, Arbeiter (laborer) was originally male and only acquired its female form after 1800. A second word, schaffen, is said to be derived from the Old German scaffan, “bent double.” “In addition to its primary meaning of “to create,” it also means “to succeed by hard work,” “to toil,” or “to slog.” The derivative term for “worker,” Schaffer, is male and often used as a surname. As such, it has no female equivalent.”

Reality reflects these etymological roots throughout history. In ancient Egypt, the 100,000 people conscripted each year to build the pyramids who, as pictures show, were soundly whipped when they did not pull their weight were not women, but men. Men, whether prisoners of war or those enlisted by press-gangs, constructed roads, dug canals, erected fortresses, and built temples all over the ancient Middle East.

According to the Bible, King Solomon used tens of thousands of male slaves to obtain the materials for building the Lord’s Temple. Men, not women, built the Great Wall of China, dying by the thousands in the process. Countless male slaves, but very few female ones, worked in the silver mines of Laurion from which classical Athens derived much of its wealth.

Men, not women, sometimes took the place of beasts of burden in turning industrial-scale mills where corn was ground. Much like modern prisons, the places where such work was done were normally considered too unsavory to attract visits by members of polite society. During the second century A.D, however, one of them was inspected by the Roman writer Apuleius, who reported that:

Merciful gods, what wretched manikins did I see there, their entire skin covered with bluish welts, their backs torn into bloody strips, barely covered with rags, some having only their genitals covered with a piece of cloth, all of them showing everything through their tatters. Their foreheads were branded with letters, their heads half shorn, their feet stuck in rings. They were hideously pale, the dank of the stinking hole had consumed their eyelashes and diminished their sight. Like wrestlers, who are sprinkled with a fine powder as they fight their bouts, they were blanched with a layer of dirty-white flour.

Being a female slave, to be sure, was hardly all fun and games, both because of the nature of their labor and because they were sexually at the mercy of their owners. However, a scrawny prostitute, or one dressed in tatters, or one too frightened to properly play her role, would have commanded a much lower price, if any. Hence workers in the oldest profession are usually well fed, reasonably clothed and tolerably housed. They are also unlikely to undergo physical punishment so severe as to permanently damage their charms. In any case, as references in Petronius, Horace and Seneca show, male slaves were also open to sexual exploitation.

Source: Petronius, Satyricon, 75.11; Horace, Satires, 1.2.116-19; Seneca, Controversies, IB praef. 1. See also Beert C. Verstraete, "Slavery and the Social Dynamics of Male Homosexual Relations in Ancient Rome," Journal of Homosexuality, 5, 3, spring 1980, pp. 227-36.

In 19th-century America, it was cowboys, not cowgirls, who spent weeks on the trail, sleeping in the open air, unable to wash, shave or change clothes, while driving cattle from grazing ground to market and from market to railhead. In other societies, too, the less pleasant, the more demanding and the more dangerous a job, the more likely it was to be done by men.

Etc. etc.

All of this has and still leads to women having:

  • A better work-life balance,

  • higher reported levels of life satisfaction,

  • higher reported levels of happiness,

  • more free time,

  • more time spent at home,

  • better health outcomes,

  • lower mortality rates,

  • and a longer life.

Though it is a long and persisting myth that women were confined to the domestic sphere and that men got to work jobs which is a privilege, this is discounted by all the relevant data.

Thanks for reading!


r/FeMRADebates • • Aug 19 '20

Abuse/Violence Violations of Boys’ Bodies Aren’t Taken Seriously: How society passively condones sexual assault towards boys

Thumbnail
medium.com
159 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Feb 26 '21

Work Job applications from men are discriminated against when they apply for female-dominated occupations, such as nursing, childcare and house cleaning. However, in male-dominated occupations such as mechanics, truck drivers and IT, a new study found no discrimination against women.

Thumbnail
liu.se
151 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Nov 03 '21

Abuse/Violence Men are primarily raped by women

146 Upvotes

Most statistic that ask about sexual assault have ignored men all together, instead focusing on their perpetration. A significant sexual assault study published 1986 "The Scope of Rape" which was first to addressed underreporting in statistical analysis', only asked men about their perpetration of sexual assault.

" During actual administration, separate wordings were used for women and for men. However, for purposes of demonstration, the female wording is presented in the following sample item and the male wording is indicated in brackets: "Have you ever had [engaged in] sexual intercourse when you [the woman] didn't want to because a man [you] used some degree of physical force (twisting your [her] arm, holding you [her] down, etc.) to make you [her]?"

The same is true of the 2006 "Campus Sexual Assault study".

" For male respondents, a Behaviors module asking about the perpetration of the same types of sexual assault covered in the Experiences module was included "

In fact in 1993 academics at the university of Arizona published "Detecting the Scope of Rape" where they state

"Although consideration of male victims is within the scope of legal statutes, it is important to restrict the term rape to instances were male victims were penetrated by offenders. It is inappropriate to consider a rape victim a man who engages in unwanted intercourse with a woman"

There wasn't an actually sexual assault study that recognized the possibility of men being victimized by women until 2011 when the CDC published a newly revised "National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey". This study found that men were 10 times more likely to be "made to penetrate" then to be raped in their lifetime 17 million vs 1.69 million, but also

"The majority of male rape victims (93.3%) reported only male perpetrators. For three of the other forms of sexual violence, a majority of male victims reported only female perpetrators: being made to penetrate (79.2%), sexual coercion (83.6%), and unwanted sexual contact (53.1%)"

So unless you use a penetration rather than consent based definition of rape, men are primarily raped by women.


r/FeMRADebates • • Oct 10 '22

Idle Thoughts I notice all af mens problems are his own but all of women problems are society's

135 Upvotes

If a men become homeless it's his fault but if a woman become homeless it's society fault.

There are programs that target homeless women and receive a lot of tax payers money but I notice there's no male equivalent.

A men commits suicide it's because he's weak our toxic masculinity but if a woman commits suicide it's because of societal ills and she's a victim.

Basically men are victim blamed and gaslighted while woman are shown compassion and understanding.

So what do you guys think I'm hoping for a thoughtful conversation.

Happy Thanksgiving and if you don't celebrate Thanksgiving Happy holidays.


r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 02 '22

Other 53-year-old journalist Norah Vincent died of assisted suicide on July 6, 2022 after experiencing what it was like to live as a man.

132 Upvotes

https://www.eviemagazine.com/post/woman-pretended-to-be-a-man-dies-assisted-suicide-realizing-difficult

I just came across this article that explores the Assisted Suicide of Norah Vincent and the mental health struggles she dealt with after her experiences living as a man.

I don't really have much to add as I'm still doing some research into her. But I felt this may spark some interesting discussions here.


r/FeMRADebates • • Oct 24 '18

Man bullied into withdrawing from election at a university, because he campaigned for men's mental health to address the suicide epidemic. Dissenters say his campaign is a "dangerous narrative" stemming from "entitlement"

Thumbnail
thesun.co.uk
131 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 14 '15

Toxic Activism "Mansplaining", "Manterrupting" and "Manspreading" are baseless gender-slurs and are just as repugnant as any other slur.

130 Upvotes

There has never been any evidence that men are more likely to explain things condescendingly, interrupt rudely or take up too much space on a subway train. Their purpose of their use is simply to indulge in bigotry, just like any other slur. Anyone who uses these terms with any seriousness is no different than any other bigot and deserves to have their opinion written off.


r/FeMRADebates • • Aug 28 '22

Personal Experience I am a woman. I have marched in feminist protests. I have volunteered my time and labor for feminist charities. I have been involved with several feminist groups. This is the story of why I stopped considering myself a feminist.

126 Upvotes

For some context. I am pursuing a career in academia. I'd prefer not to go too much into detail as I value my privacy. But I have spent ample time throughout the institution I both attend and work for in multiple roles.

My journey to where I find myself today started a few weeks before the creation of this account. A few close male peers of mine opened up to me about their experiences of sexism at the hands of a few members of one a feminist students advocacy group. At first I did not believe them as I believed that sexism in any form was a direct opposition to egalitarian values. And being that they had pointed towards a group that had defined themselves by those values as the culprit I felt that there must be more to the story.

So I asked around. And I found that the members of this group that had been sexist towards my male peers openly admitted to it. Citing my male peers making "MRA Arguments" I then through further digging found that these "MRA arguments" had to do with domestic abuse and a lack of resources for male victims.

Something my own later research found to be a legitimate issue. Which raised the question as to why my peers were dismissed and body shamed for bringing it up. I had heard of MRA's before but I never really looked into them. So I decided to do some digging. For a while I lurked around in MRA and feminist forums. And then I decided to pull the proverbial trigger and join in on a few forums like this one that brought the two groups together in discussion.

though I was certainly aiming to change my mind with new information. I did not expect things to be so abrupt. I was given warm (though often skeptical or distrusting) welcomes from the MRA's I interacted with. While the feminists I interacted with were often rather harsh. I often felt as though I was brushed off for simply not "knowing enough" to agree with them outright. Often my questions or critiques were met with accusations of misogyny or malicious intent. Though to be fair both sides were consistently skeptical of malicious intent. I later learned of just how common it is to have one's words twisted. So I understand at some level the skepticism.

But one underlying issue truly "caught" me. And that is the logic and rhetoric used by either side.

On the feminist side there are decades of academic roots that are deeply entrenched. And while this is undoubtedly a good foundation. I also found that there are many egregious cracks in said foundation. There are a number of well documented but rarely spoken of fallacies throughout this area of academia. From ad hoc rationalizations to confirmation bias to unfalsifiable theories. To quote one MRA I found online

Feminist theory defines patriarchy as an unjust social system that enforces gender roles and is oppressive to both men and women.%5B32%5D It often includes any social mechanism that evokes male dominance over women. Feminist theory typically characterizes patriarchy as a social construction, which can be overcome by revealing and critically analyzing its manifestations.%5B33%5D

So Patriarchy is oppressive to both men and women? But if so then the definition seems relatively gender neutral while the term Patriarchy is not gender neutral. So if our society is oppressive to both men and women then couldn't you just as easily describe our society as a Matriarchy? The equivalent definition for Matriarchy would be:

An unjust social system that enforces gender roles and is oppressive to both men and women.%5B32%5D It often includes any social mechanism that evokes female dominance over men.

So we just need 1 case of a social mechanism that evokes female dominance over men to satisfy the definition of Matriarchy? Well one example would be the social expectation where males pay for dates. So the definition of Matriarchy is satisfied so we must live in a Matriarchy.

But if the definitions of both Patriarchy and Matriarchy are satisfied, then do we live in both a Matriarchy and a Patriarchy at the same time? Why should we describe our society as a Patriarchy rather than a Matriarchy? And if the definitions are relatively gender neutral, then why not use a gender neutral term like Traditionalism instead?

To this I turn to the scientific philosopher Karl Popper. In science a theory is called falsifiable if it is possible to conceive an observation or an argument which proves the statement in question to be false. In this sense, falsify is synonymous with nullify, meaning not "to commit fraud" but "show to be false". Some philosophers argue that science must be falsifiable.

Falsifiability is very important in science because it means you can test predictions and either verify or falsify a theory to obtain a better understanding of reality. Without falsifiability, how can we exclude absurd hypothesis from our set of scientific beliefs such as the idea that a giant flying spaghetti monster created everything? Is the feminist theory of patriarchy falsifiable? What testable predictions does it make that cannot also be explained by Matriarchy?

This is just one example of the issues I started to find. This is not to say that there aren't issues on the MRA side. But largely those issues are a lack of presence and roots in academia. The MRM is largely not rooted in academia like feminists so they don’t have the same strict academic discipline in their language and models, which makes it easy to mock and shoot down. Picture a 40 year old feminist with a lifetime of training in academia and research and activism cutting down young boys and men with legitimate and unaddressed issues and trauma's. Yet the former group feels as though they are punching up but as they now populate highest offices media and academia, they are in fact punching down.

What I also found was that where there WAS academic backing to MRA ideas. It often stood up well to criticism and did a better job of explaining issues on a grander scale than I felt feminist explanations did. And then comes the pole that pushed me off the proverbial plank.

Dogmatism, Bias and an unwillingness to consider alternative ideas.

this may be relying too much on proverbs. But this truly was the final nail in the coffin for me. Many of the feminists I spoke with online had an underlying issue wherein any critique of feminism was treated as an attack on women. Yet there are numerous sly and somewhat underhanded terms, beliefs and theories I encountered about men that are outright misandrist. Yet consistently whenever this was pointed out by anybody (myself included) we were dismissed as simply "not understanding" The terms "motte and bailey" and "dog whistle" both come to mind though I don't have the words to adequately pinpoint what I saw. It was simply often the case that things that reflected negatively on men were to be taken in the most generous way while anything that may reflect negatively on women was to be taken in the least generous way. for example. "Kill all men" is only ever a joke and nobody should ever feel insulted or hurt by it. But "don't be a pussy" is a grave insult against women that demeans femininity by treating female genitalia as something undesirable.

This is clearly the result of numerous in group biases and outright tribalism. And then even when presented with better alternatives or solid arguments as to why either beliefs were correct or harmful. The result was often a push to either silence the people offering them or the one being offered these things would leave the conversation. The appearance was thoroughly such that ones mind could not and would not be changed regardless of evidence to the contrary.

I as a person value academic and intellectual integrity. I value solid rationale and being able to adapt to new information. And in the last year of involving myself with feminists and MRA's. I have found that the MRA's consistently offered these things where it was common that feminists did not if not taking the opposite approach. I accept that there are exceptions to both of these. and that this is simply my own anecdotal experience. But it has been enough to personally sway me in such a way that I no longer identify as a feminist


r/FeMRADebates • • May 23 '20

Relationships University Professor performs small study examining dating preferences. Discovers that most heterosexual self-identifying liberal/leftist/feminist women still preferred men to adhere to traditional dating norms.

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
126 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jan 29 '21

Abuse/Violence I demand an apology from the feminist establishment, not just for Donna Hylton's despicable, inhuman and sick psychopath crime but also for typically embracing and condoning her by feminists absence of ostracism, contempt and disgust and letting her be a speaker at a women's march in 2017

123 Upvotes

• https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.dailycaller.com/2017/01/26/womens-march-featured-speaker-who-kidnapped-raped-and-tortured-a-man

• https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.dailycaller.com/2017/04/27/college-speaker-whines-about-prison-but-fails-to-mention-that-she-tortured-and-killed-a-man

• https://www.reddit.com/r/AskFeminists/comments/5pqwow/why_are_people_like_donna_hylton_invited_to_speak/

• https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donna_Hylton

• https://spectator.org/the-women-movements-embrace-of-psychopath-donna-hylton/

If I would grope a woman's ass without consent, many feminists will consider me an inhuman and despicable monster for the rest of my life, even if I would genuinely have remorse, got legally punished and apologized for it, but Donna gets embraced, are you kidding me 🤨

In addition, a few months ago I saw in the news of the television that a man got 32 years for killing a female cop with a gun (without lots of days of sick, despicable, gender-hating and inhuman torture) and Donna got 26 years, this is a joke. It is no secret that female abusers get handled with kid gloves.


r/FeMRADebates • • Jan 14 '23

Legal 65-85% of men accused of rape are innocent. And I do believe innocent until proven guilty for obvious reasons.

120 Upvotes

This was originally posted in MensLib, but they removed it immediately without addressing any of the concerns.

Much of the discussion surrounding false accusations of rape concerns me greatly. Particularly, the sub has a post titled "Fact Checking False Rape Accusations and Why We Shouldn't Fear a False Rape Epidemic." and it perpetuates very dangerous ways of thinking about these numbers and accusations in general.

The headline is, absolutely no one has any idea how many accusations of rape are false, and every statistic you have ever read about what percentage are false is based on how many are proven false after being reported to authorities. It is very important to understand this distinction, as it is incredibly harmful and dangerous to say something careless like "2 to 10% of accusations are false" because the unspoken corollary is "90 to 98% are true" which is unfounded, and encourages people to assume accusations are true without evidence.

How Many False Rape Accusations Are There?

No one knows, or even has the foggiest idea. I'm going to address why that is and why the statistics that get passed around cannot be used to determine this. The sub's post about this states the following:

Most experts agree that false rape accusations make the total of 2-10% of the total accusations of rape.

In Lisak et al. (2010) they performed a review on 136 accusations made over 10 years to a university in Boston. These were the percentages for each category:

False report: 5.9%

Case did not proceed: 44.9%

Case proceeded: 35.3

Insufficient information: 13.9%

Only 35.3% of cases had enough evidence for the university police department to take disciplinary action. Their conclusion in the research was that with a false report rate of 5.9%, it can be estimated that roughly 2 to 10% of accusations are false. However, would we accept that same reasoning for true accusations? That with a positive case rate of 35.3 percent, it can be estimated that 20 to 40% of accusations are true?

No, I don't think anyone would accept that, and we should apply no such double standard to false accusations. Every single statistic that has ever been made for this follows the exact same error of reasoning.

Using qualitative and quantitative analysis, researchers studied 812 reports of sexual assault from 2000-2003 and found a 2.1% of false reports (Heenan & Murray 2006).

False report: 2.1%

Case did not proceed: 46.4%

Complaint withdrawn: 15.1%

Case proceeded: 15%

Case ongoing or status unknown: 21.3%

2017 Study into the FBI Database found that between 2006 to 2010 the Average number of false rape accusations or baseless accusations was 5.55%, and robbery had a higher false and baseless accusation rate of 5.76%

This actually misrepresents what the study says. Here's a direct quote from the link:

Approximately 5% of the allegations of rape were deemed false or baseless. That was at least five times higher than for most other offence types.

And that's only in a legal context. In a social context, no one is going to accuse someone they don't like of murder. I suppose they could make a false accusation of being robbed or beat up by that person, but in the absence of bruises or a demonstration of lost property, it would be ineffectual and hard to believe. Rape does not have this problem. Many people have sex all the time. It is very easy to claim that a night of sex was rape, because it is a private act. There is no way to prove it's a false accusation.

Another metastudy by Claire E. Ferguson, and John M. Malouff published in December 17th, 2015 put the number of False Rape Accusations at 5%

This one was behind a pay-wall, but I found the full text on sci-hub, and thankfully they address exactly what I am talking about in the text:

Even after the demonstrably false cases have been discovered, many more equivocal cases exist which cannot be confirmed or denied, and even recanted accusations may, in fact, be true. Researchers rarely address this problem or state what level of certainty they applied in deciding that a report was confirmed to be false. Additionally, after rates of false reporting are given, few researchers discuss the many other cases that were in doubt, but not proven or confirmed to be false.

It'd be more accurate to say 2-10% of rape accusations made to an investigative authority will be proven false.

How Many People Falsely Accused of Rape Actually Go to Jail?

This number does indeed seem to be low, which is a huge blessing, but I think it misses the point and the text itself says a handful of very problematic things.

The first important thing to note is that concern about false accusations doesn't exist exclusively, or even primarily, in a legal context. It is more often a social context. Studies are rarely/never done in that sphere, which is why so many of these studies are not representative of the problem. The concern is not that someone will go to the police and make a false accusation, but that they will go to your friends, family, and co-workers, and make a false accusation. That you will be fired, outcasted, kicked out of a college, etc, over someone else's word and their word alone.

The vast majority of false rape accusers always accuse a non existent stranger who raped them and usually not someone specifically

This part is problematic because it seems to imply that a named accusation is significantly more likely to be true, since "most false accusations name a non existent stranger." Once again, this isn't truly the case, and ignores the context of what false rape accusation really represents by hyperfocusing on accusations made to legal authorities.

Why Do False Rape Accusations Happen?

This is also a very problematic section, falling into many of the same fallacies that plague the previous section: Hyperfocusing on legal reports instead of social ones.

Many people who fear false rape accusations claim that women in the work force will make a false accusation against a man in a higher position, or a student who is going to fail an exam will accuse a professor of rape, or a vengeful ex or a woman who regretted sex later.
This shows that the majority of the time, false accusers aren't the serial accusers we hear through the media, nor are in tech jobs, nor college students who regret sex. Instead it is usually either those looking to access healthcare who cannot afford ito otherwise, teenagers trying to get out of trouble and parents of children who make the vast majority of false rape accusations.

The reason why this data differs from what we hear through the media is that the media is often covering accusations that were only made socially, not legally. This is where regret sex accusations, accusations against people in higher positions, students accusing professors, vengeful exes, et cetera, happen.

These people will not go to the police, they know they have no evidence. They will destroy your reputation, and never appear on any of these statistics, and one really important concept to understand when trying to examine false accusations:

Making an accusation that can never be proven false is extremely easy, if it is given even the bare minimum level of consideration.

Conclusion

I understand that false rape accusations are an extremely divisive notion that is laced with political and social undertones, the likes of which are often very nasty. Nonetheless, it is very frustrating to see intelligent people misusing statistics like this to imply that the vast majority of accusations should be considered true, because "this study found only 2% were false." It gives people a way to clear their conscience when they assume accusations are true.

I am not suggesting that there should be a swing to the opposite extreme: Assuming accusers are lying. This is equally awful. Support can be provided to accusers as victims without treating the accused like they are rapists. For those who have experienced a false accusation, it can take a tremendous toll on the psyche. It can ruin lives, careers, etc, and spreading notions like "2 to 10% are false, and most of those are not against named individuals, and by people trying to get medical care" gives people a pass "backed by studies" to assume accusations are true.

Supporting the victim requires knowing who the victim is. If you assume accusations are true, you are merely supporting an accuser that might be a victim, but you could be actively traumatizing a true victim.

So remember this TL;DR when you think about false rape accusations.

TL;DR

  • All scientific estimates on the prevalence of false accusations refer to provably false accusations made to authorities. Not social ones like within friend groups, against celebrities, et cetera.


r/FeMRADebates • • Jan 24 '18

Abuse/Violence Male student claims "biased views against men", and sues Dartmouth over 'sexual misconduct' finding

120 Upvotes

It's this article I read today. By the headline, I expected it to be simply that he was accused of sexual assault and didn't feel that he received due process, but by the details it turned out to be a bigger issue than that

When he awoke, he "noticed that he had bruises and scratches on his arms and back, that his nipple was bleeding, and that he was experiencing extreme pain in his genitalia." Smith sent Doe a text later that day with pictures of her own bruises, stating that the previous night had been "fun." When they talked that afternoon, she revealed that they had participated in "rough foreplay," which included "slapping each other" and falling off the bed multiple times. She also admitted that Doe had asked her to leave multiple times during the encounter...Smith submitted text messages with Doe and with her friends, which confirmed that she knew Doe was "super blacked" [severely drunk] at the time.

So arguably, he was expelled for being sexually assaulted. Literally punished for being taken advantage of while severely mentally and likely physically impaired

Smith made explicitly clear that the sexual encounter had been consensual (ignoring Doe’s intoxication), and that her complaint was limited to the bruises she received from the sadomasochistic activities...Smith told Sheahan that she had "engaged in sexual acts" with Doe and "instigated a wrestling match" with him. She stated that she was "on top of John Doe during their entire encounter" and that Doe’s participation was due to his state of intoxication. Despite these admissions, she insisted that "this is not a nonconsensual sex case."

Notice that the whole time, the only person's who's consent is considered is the woman's. The only question asked is "did he rape her or did he not rape her?", and the possibility or her raping him is not even considered despite that that seems to be more or less what happened. Is it just because she was the initial accuser, even though he also later filed a complaint?

A 2014 speech by Amanda Childress, the head of Dartmouth’s center for combating sexual violence, lends credence to this claim. "Why could we not expel a student based on an allegation?" she asked a conference on sexual assault. "It seems to me that we value fair and equitable processes more than we value the safety of our students. And higher education is not a right. Safety is a right. Higher education is a privilege."

Aside from the fact that fairness and justice should be valued above all else in the case of investigating accusations of misconduct, they seem very selective in terms of who deserves to be safe from sexual violence and what kind of perpetrators should be denied the privilege of higher education

To me, the ruling in this case seems glaringly unjust. And yet the school, the administrators, the office, etc. apparently thought otherwise. Is this college really that prejudice, do you think there are other factors contributing to this outcome, do you think the judgement wasn't entirely unjust, etc.?


r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 02 '21

Abuse/Violence HUGE meta-analysis of 1,700 studies finds that while 57.9% of domestic violence is bidirectional and 28.3% of unidirectional domestic violence was female-to-male, only 13.8% was male-to-female thereby refuting the notion that women merely commit domestic violence out of self-defense

Thumbnail domesticviolenceresearch.org
118 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jul 08 '20

Why is "toxic femininity" so contentious?

116 Upvotes

Why do some feminists get so worked up over this term? I guess one possibility is that they misinterpret the phrase as meaning "all femininity is toxic", but if you pay any attention to the term and how it's used, it should be obvious that this isn't what it means. How the concept of "toxic femininity" was pitched to me was that it's a term for describing toxic aspects of female gender norms - the idea that women should repress their sexuality, that women shouldn't show assertiveness, that women should settle a dispute with emotional manipulation, etc. And... yes, these ideas are all undoubtedly toxic. And women are the ones who suffer the most from them.

I want to again reiterate that "toxic femininity" as it is commonly used is not implying that all femininity is toxic. That being said, if someone did say "femininity itself is toxic", is that really a horrible or misogynist thing to say? Especially if it comes out of a place of concern for women and the burdens that femininity places on them? Many people who were socialized as female seem to find the standards of femininity to be more burdensome and restrictive than helpful.


r/FeMRADebates • • Jul 30 '22

Media the trend of putting pronouns in bios is purely preformative.

115 Upvotes

The majority of the time it is completely useless as the gender of the person is so blatantly obvious. What it does serve to do is make it clear what your political views are. Almost to a person if they have pronouns you can accurately guess the majority of their other views.


r/FeMRADebates • • Aug 13 '20

Why Male Survivors Still Feel Left Out of #MeToo | The environment of casual misandry online damages survivors.

Thumbnail
melmagazine.com
112 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jul 21 '21

Abuse/Violence Should the Violence Against Women Act be renamed to show that it protects all genders?

110 Upvotes

The current naming excludes victims who are non binary, as well as trans and cis men, and reinforces gender stereotypes that members of these groups can't be victims of violence and don't need assistance.

Should the act be renamed something like the Violence Against Intimate Partners Act instead

Edit: and of course also change the law itself to explicitly protect all genders in line with the new name.


r/FeMRADebates • • Nov 05 '20

Abuse/Violence The duluth model is a prime example of how feminist theory has institutionalized misandry. Things like this are why the MRM is against feminism.

109 Upvotes

For those not in the know.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duluth_model

the Duluth Model is the most common batterer intervention program used in the United States.

The feminist theory underlying the Duluth Model is that men use violence within relationships to exercise power and control. This is illustrated by the "Power and Control Wheel," a graphic typically displayed as a poster in participating locations.[5][6] According to the Duluth Model, "women and children are vulnerable to violence because of their unequal social, economic, and political status in society."[7] Treatment of abusive men is focused on re-education, as "we do not see men’s violence against women as stemming from individual pathology, but rather from a socially reinforced sense of entitlement."

BUT. Even the creator of the program. Ellen Pence herself has written,

"By determining that the need or desire for power was the motivating force behind battering, we created a conceptual framework that, in fact, did not fit the lived experience of many of the men and women we were working with. The DAIP staff [...] remained undaunted by the difference in our theory and the actual experiences of those we were working with [...] It was the cases themselves that created the chink in each of our theoretical suits of armor. Speaking for myself, I found that many of the men I interviewed did not seem to articulate a desire for power over their partner. Although I relentlessly took every opportunity to point out to men in the groups that they were so motivated and merely in denial, the fact that few men ever articulated such a desire went unnoticed by me and many of my coworkers. Eventually, we realized that we were finding what we had already predetermined to find."[20]

And In 2011 a study was published on The Helpseeking Experiences of Men Who Sustain Intimate Partner Violence

You can read the full thing here.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3175099/

For the sake of brevity I will only be quoting two chunks of text.

When calling domestic violence hotlines, for instance, men who sustained all types of IPV report that the hotline workers say that they only help women, infer or explicitly state that the men must be the actual instigators of the violence, or ridicule them. Male helpseekers also report that hotlines will sometimes refer them to batterers’ programs. Some men have reported that when they call the police during an incident in which their female partners are violent, the police sometimes fail to respond. Other men reported being ridiculed by the police or being incorrectly arrested as the primary aggressor. Within the judicial system, some men who sustained IPV reported experiencing gender-stereotyped treatment. Even with apparent corroborating evidence that their female partners were violent and that the helpseekers were not, they reportedly lost custody of their children, were blocked from seeing their children, and were falsely accused by their partners of IPV and abusing their children. According to some, the burden of proof for male IPV victims may be especially high

And.

Family and friends were overwhelmingly reported as being the most helpful resource, and mental health and medical professionals were rated as being among the most helpful of the formal resources. These professionals were reported to have taken the male victims seriously and to inquire about the origin of the men’s injuries. The resources providing the least support to men seeking help for IPV victimization are those that are the core of the DV service system: DV agencies, DV hotlines, and the police. On the one hand, about 25% of men who sought help from DV hotlines were connected with resources that were helpful. On the other hand, nearly 67% of men reported that these DV agencies and hotline were not at all helpful. Many reported being turned away.

When the most used domestic violence program in the U.S postulates that men are perpetrators who are violent because they have been socialized in a patriarchy that condones male violence, and that women are victims who are violent only in self-defense.

it creates institutional discrimination against men who simply aren't patriarchal oppressors.

This is what happens when you treat men as the enemy.


r/FeMRADebates • • Nov 25 '21

Idle Thoughts I wish we could all have a genderswap freaky friday once in a lifetime. I'm certain that would be much more compassionate towards the opposite sex

108 Upvotes

Vincent's book Self-Made Man retells an eighteen-month experiment in which she disguised herself as a man. She joined an all-male bowling club,[2] joined a men's therapy group, went to a strip club,[2] dated women, and used her knowledge as a lapsed Catholic[2][6][7] to visit monks in a cloister. Vincent asserts that, since the experiment, she has more fully realized the benefits of being female and the disadvantages of being male, stating, "I really like being a woman. ... I like it more now because I think it's more of a privilege."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norah_Vincent#Self-Made_Man