r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 02 '21

Politics Donald Trump is a Real Man: Presidential Post-Mortem

0 Upvotes

Now that America has had some distance between the presidency of Donald Trump I thought it might be interesting to discuss some of the gendered rhetoric concerning the Trump's 2016 presidential campaign and administration. This post is not intended to be about Donald Trump's policies concerning gender politics, but that's a fine thing to argue if you wish to do so. I'm more interested in how Donald Trump performs masculinity, how people talk about Trump's masculinity, and what consequences this rhetoric has for discussions on gender and identity politics.

Below are three contexts that I think are useful for framing this discussion. The intent here is to attempt to provide some neutral examples without passing judgement on their contents. Each part ends with some discussion questions that are about the topic in general, not necessarily the contents of the part. The intent here is not to compel you to answer all questions as if it is some sort of test. Discussions will probably be benefitted if you choose one area to discuss. Nor is the intent to limit your responses to the questions I raised. The topic is broad and you should feel encouraged to pose a question of your own.


Part 1: Trump as aspirational man

Prominent MRA Paul Elam wrote this article on Donald Trump that in many ways inspired this post.

Trump’s presidential saga is a microcosm; a story that has been told in the lives of men everywhere for the last 50 years. A plainspoken real estate developer from Queens, Trump realized white collar ambitions without ever shedding a bit of his blue-collar mentality. He’s successful, salty, straightforward and unrepentant. He’s everything feminists hate about men. Everything they take such delight in attacking and everything they wish they could be, but can’t.

He has the qualities that most men aspire to, and to which so many men are shying away from publicly because feminists have been successful in demonizing those qualities. He’s the kind of man male politicians lack the guts or integrity to be.

Successful, salty, straightforward, unrepentant. He has a hot wife and lives the big life. No one tells him what to do and he won't bow to people (especially women and or white knights) hen pecking him or telling him to be some other way. He is who he is, and that makes him a man.

Discussion:

  1. Men, do you aspire to be the kind of man Donald Trump is, why or not?

  2. What components of your masculinity do you see reflected within Trump, if any?

  3. Would you identify any traits associated with Trump as misattributed to his manhood?

  4. Do you think any masculine attributed traits Trump possesses are maligned and demonized? Why?

  5. Do you think any masculine attributed traits Trump possesses are praised uncritically? Why?


Part 2: Trumpian politics and its relationship to masculinity

From the beginning his campaign Trump positioned himself as a teller of harsh truths. A person who would not bow to criticism, who would speak his mind, and who's successes would translate to more successes for the country. In his first speech announcing his campaign he railed against Mexico sending 'rapists' which some have identified as a long standing trope of race-based fear mongering over black and brown men

The myth of black and brown men as sexual predators toward white women is a deeply psychological motivator that activates people’s basest survival instincts

The summary of the idea is that women must be protected from a sexually promiscuous other, weaponizing both a women's fear of othered men and man's desire to protect, shield, or control women. (This is not to say that these emotions are broadly held or typical, just that this is the sort of emotion it is targetting). Trump projects the role of the strong man in this context.

Discussion:

  1. Do you have any other examples of Trump's rhetoric that relates to men politically, for better or worse?

  2. Have you noticed any change in gender discourse as a consequence of Trump's rise?

  3. To what extent do you think Trump's politics are coded to gender politics?

  4. What would you ascribe as Trump's gender political stance, if he had to choose one?


Part 3: He vs. She

After he was nominated Donald Trump was up against the first woman nominated for president by one of America's two major political parties, Hillary Clinton. To say that the discourse was charged would be an understatement. Donald Trump's manliness or lack of manliness has been a frequent subject by opponents and supporters alike.

It is hard to forget the time when Republican primary debates devolved into alleging that Donald Trump had small hands and thus a small penis being confronted openly by Trump bragging that there was no problem in that department, or the many think pieces devoted to contrasting gendered political styles of either candidate..

Here's a fun sort of article from slate comparing the election to the Battle of the Sexes movie

The election was in many ways similar to the battle of the sexes in the sense that the gendered differences between the two candidates were highlighted and debated by both sides. Either candidate's genders became (for better or worse) representative of gender wars at large. This includes both attacks on Donald Trump as a representative of patriarchy or toxic masculinity as well as idolizing him as a sort of archetype of masculinity.

Discusssion:

  1. How do you think Trump's position against Hillary Clinton framed our views of his masculinity?

  2. What do the attacks on Trump's masculinity reveal about our stance towards masculinity as a society?

  3. What does the acceptance or praise of Trump's masculinity reveal about those same stances?

  4. Can there be a woman that does Trump's rhetoric as well as Trump does?


General Discussion:

  1. How would you define the relationship between Trump's masculinity and his politics?

  2. What do you think the future holds for gendered rhetoric within politics?


r/FeMRADebates • • Dec 01 '20

Theory Equality of Opportunity vs. Equality of Outcome, a false distinction.

1 Upvotes

Frequently I've seen appeals to making the distinction between equality of outcome and equality of opportunity when arguing about various efforts to support a given group. Most often this occurs in response to efforts to support people who are not cis white males, but that's neither here nor there. Making this distinction is rarely compelling to me for a number of reasons.

First, the false separation. In the capitalist western civilization, opportunity is not divorced from prior outcomes. In fact it's more than simply married; it's a feedback loop. Successful outcomes lead to an increase of opportunity in a way that snowballs. Seeking equal outcomes in many cases is seeking equal opportunity.

Second, the argument assumes a system where merit equates to success that does not exist. This is seen in arguments about affirmative action most of all. The fear is that by not trusting in a merit based selection process, people will end in the wrong places in the hierarchy. However, we have no reason to trust that the system is fair at all. The act of selection is prone to bias as are all human endeavors. Worse, the selection process tends to be opaque, making it hard to evaluate whether the process was meaningfully merit based. Refusing to acknowledge outcomes in favor of this mystery black box that dispenses only fairness is not appealing.

Third, it is sometimes implied that this meritocratic system is the ideal way to organize humans. "If you're a good human you benefit and if you're a mediocre human you suffer" has some real problems morally. Attempting to do meritocracy should not get in the way of doing good. Sure, play the capitalism game, but let's not let the people who do poorly at that game be destitute and have their kids sorely uneducated and disenfranchised.

Fourth, I don't really get the sense that equal opportunity is really what is being argued most of the time. In many cases I've seen it, it is used to argue against increasing opportunity for a demographic that typically lacks it. I'm for equal opportunity, yet I often find myself at the receiving end of accusations to the contrary because I've voiced support for something that catches someone up.

In summary, I think the argument has a host of unqualified assumptions that makes it hardly compelling to me. Here's equality of opportunity for you: tax the rich and confiscate their estates. Distribute the wealth so that every child is nutritionally secure, has shelter, health care, education, and the same chance of going to college without going into massive debt as the children of rich people. America, the land of equal opportunity, does not do these things, so let's not pretend opportunity is equal out there.


r/FeMRADebates • • Oct 17 '15

Other Way too MRA

1 Upvotes

Ok. I identify as egalitarian but let's be honest here. This sub is way too MRA. Y'all/We'all scared away most feminists. The tough ones stayed but, in my opinion , most of the MRAs here are NOT of equal QUALITY.

The feminists that stayed here are tough as nails and argue with the best of them. But - sorry to say - most of the MRAs here rely on a few members to make the salient points and take the flak for the movement.

Here are facts:

Feminism is a mainstream movement.

MRM is NOT.

Equality is seen as a WOMAN'S Issue, not men's.

So let me be blunt here.

Stop.

Fucking.

Around.

Feminists like Elena are honestly trying to incorporate MRAs (don't agree? I DON'T care and neither does CNN/CBC/BBC/Aljazeera.)

BE INCLUSSSIVE!

WORK TOGETHER!

STOP. BEEING. SO. EXCLUSIONARY! Don't like TERFS? YOU may just be one IN SPIRIT!

I love people.

I love men, and women (women more, but that's cuz part of me says kidddddssssssssssss).

Stop partisanship. Stop pointless debates.

Children are vital, and it is vital that THEY ARE WANTED.

So get together.

Work it out.

And if you can't figure out who has to pay? IT'S THE GOVERNMENT (sponsored by the "Fucking seriously, USA?" coalition of Canada and other non-anti-worker countries.)

So come one people; stop fucking yourselves (it's way less fun.)


r/FeMRADebates • • Dec 29 '21

Politics A fight broke out in the Jordanian parliament live on television when discussing adding a "female noun" to the constitution to ensure equal rights to all citizens. Notice the women calmly looking on as the men push and shove each other.

5 Upvotes

Fist fight in Jordan's parliament caught on live stream - BBC News

Gender equality debate leads to brawl in Jordan parliament- Times of Israel

Moment Jordanian MPs exchange punches as brawl erupts on the floor of the country's parliament during fiery debate over equal rights- Daily Mail

All this while the Queen of Jordan, Queen Rania, has been an outspoken advocate for women's right for over a decade. Clearly there are mixed messages coming from this little country.


r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 04 '21

Idle Thoughts Raping is a Reproductive Strategy Females Cash In On

3 Upvotes

In zoology it's observed that the more a penis protrudes, (i.e. the larger it is) the more adept a male will be - if he so chooses to do it - at forced copulation.  Assuming women and men are animals, and if women (I don't think they do, but if they did) routinely rate dick size as an important feature (in favor of larger, not of smaller), does that mean they are trying to leverage for themselves the alleged reproductive advantage conferred by large penis size (i.e. their male offspring's improved ability to rape)?

Rad fem, here, not an MRA. /waves

-.-.-.-.-

Edit*

I was hoping I wouldn't have to explain this but the first comment I received alerted me to the fact that a lot of people probably just don't know this; animals are vehicles for genetic travel - we're the unwitting and involuntary slaves to the almighty gene.  In this context, reproductive success isn't just having an offspring; it's having an offspring that survives to adulthood and then goes on to have its own offspring, thus passing on your genetic material, which then goes on to live to adulthood and have its own offspring which then go on to live to adulthood and have their own offspring which then go on to live to adulthood and have their own offspring etc etc etc and so on and so forth forever and ever into infinity (the genes hope, anyway).

Sons carry the genetic material of fathers AND of mothers. As such, it can be (I'm not saying it always is, just that it can be) in a mother's interest, just as well as it could be in the father's, that her son reproduce.  Perhaps it's a bonus if he reproduces in such a way she is neither expected nor required to materially provide for her son's spawn.

Edit 2: Raping is a reproductive strategy that may be used by males or females. The possession of a dick does not imply one will rape. The possession of a big'un does not imply one will rape. A female's choosing of a male based on the enormity of his phallus doesn't imply she is in favor of rape, nor does it imply she wants to have rapist-babies with him. Humans are animals, in my humble opinion, so, ultimately, I'm just wondering what ancestral humans were up to that lead to humans having such big wieners. I'm also wondering why there's such a focus on dick-size in pop culture. If you would like to submit alternative ideas to those of mine proposed above, please do.


r/FeMRADebates • • Feb 16 '25

Relationships How Destiny proves my point about pedophilia.

0 Upvotes

I’m genuinely tired of people refusing to engage with this topic honestly. I’ve been accused of not understanding why people fear pedophiles, yet no one has provided a logical argument—only appeals to emotion, strawman attacks, and the absurd conflation of thoughts with actions. If anyone has a real, evidence-based justification for this prejudice, I’m waiting. But every time someone tries, they fail and refuse to acknowledge that their position is based on fear, not reality.

This brings us to the streamer Destiny, who has admitted to filming and sharing sexual material without consent. He has spent years discussing consent, even educating his audience on how to create environments where people—especially women—feel safe saying no. If we judged him by his words, he wouldn’t seem like a danger. And yet, his actions prove otherwise.

This is exactly what I’ve been saying: if we truly care about protecting children, we need to stop obsessing over pedophiles and focus on the real threat—people who disregard consent. The moral panic around pedophilia blinds us to the actual danger. It’s not about hidden thoughts or attractions; it’s about the willingness to violate boundaries when it suits someone. This behavior can come from anyone—your spouse, a respected public figure, or someone who claims to be an advocate for consent.

Demonizing people based on their thoughts doesn’t make anyone safer. Watching, reading, or even writing fictional material about minors does not mean someone will harm a child. The only thing that predicts harm is a demonstrated willingness to ignore consent. Pretending that the label "pedophile" is some magical predictor of abuse is just an excuse to uphold a socially acceptable form of prejudice. It’s not bravery to declare yourself “anti-pedophile.” It’s performative.

If you actually care about protecting children, then focus on those who show—through actions, not thoughts—that they are willing to violate consent. Otherwise, admit that this isn’t about safety—it’s about having a group you can openly hate without consequences.

Stop pretending the label matters. Start paying attention to what actually does.


r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 14 '15

Media Matt Damon Interrupts Successful Black Woman Filmmaker to Explain Diversity to Her

Thumbnail
jezebel.com
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 11 '19

Adulthood is a virtue.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Apr 01 '25

Politics Feminists should quit debate spaces

1 Upvotes

I've noticed an uptick in pro-feminist particpation here recently, so I wanted to put my perspective out for debate among feminists/feminist allies: people who support feminism should leave online debate spaces. If you agree, leave a comment so we can build some solidarity.

We've reached a point where we can't afford to have our allies sitting on the sidelines doing unproductive work. Online debates have always just been spinning the tires on tired issues. If you look back through the history of this sub, the same supeficial arguments have been made over and over and over for almost a decade. What we really need to be doing now is getting connected to our local communities, and providing support to the first people who are being impacted by rising fascism. I say this with full self-awareness as someone who has spent way too much time on these forums: later is better than never.

To the extent that there are anti- or non-feminist particpants that are also anti-Trump and would join in resistance, our participation here is counterproductive. There are plenty of pro-Trump anti-feminists who would love to have us stun locked arguing over pointless things like which gender precisely "has it worse" in society. At absolute best these sorts of debates are a wedge issue for potential allies. At worst, there was never common ground to be found in addressing specific issues anyway, and we're more validated in spending our time elsewhere.

And finally remember to stay healthy, make sure you're getting regular exercise, and don't burn yourself out all at once. This will be a marathon, not a sprint. Best of luck in the coming months.


r/FeMRADebates • • Oct 09 '14

Other How is the MRM fighting for women?

1 Upvotes

I see a lot of criticism that feminism isn't doing enough on mens issues, but is the MRM doing anything on women's issues? Please list concrete examples.


r/FeMRADebates • • Jun 19 '15

Abuse/Violence It's not about mental illness: the big lie that always follows mass shootings by white males

Thumbnail
salon.com
3 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jun 29 '21

Abuse/Violence f the mens rights movement has always been focused on ending genital mutilation, why didn't they- and not feminists, lead the rally against fgm?

0 Upvotes

there was a post here recently about how feminists don't do enough to advocate and end mgm....and how feminists don't care about igm unless it happens to females, when it should be banned outright. if that is true why didn't male activists lead the movement to end fgm? they must have thought that was just as bad as fgm?


r/FeMRADebates • • Apr 21 '22

Idle Thoughts The Problem With ‘Hey Guys’

1 Upvotes

https://getpocket.com/explore/item/the-problem-with-hey-guys

The feminist project to reshape language into gender-neutral (or at least gender-equal) terms has difficulty with the word "guys" because it is ambiguously male-gendered and quite popular. It is also arguably hard to replace: the most promising candidate, y'all, sounds less formal and has a Southern-US association. Other suggestions include folks, friends, ladies/gals, comrades, people, and you all (the author's favorite). What informal third-person plural pronoun(s) do you prefer? Do you try to reduce gendered language when possible?

Sidenote: it is curious to find John McWhorter, known for anti-woke takes on racial issues, among those cited here in his role as linguist.


r/FeMRADebates • • Nov 04 '19

No Woman Should Die Because of her gender

Thumbnail
un.org
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 14 '18

Other Campus political correctness: Data paints a different picture

Thumbnail
vox.com
2 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Oct 04 '15

Other Well done, feminism. Now men are afraid to help women at work

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
4 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Sep 02 '18

Moms should stay at home

0 Upvotes

There's an insurmountable amount of evidence supporting stay at home moms over working ones. Its too much to be unsure or inconclusive or to refute whatsoever. I'll list them, in total these meta analyses cover 263 studies.

Maternal Work Early in the Lives of Children and Its Distal Associations With Achievement and Behavior Problems: A Meta-Analysis (2010)

This Meta analysis of 69 studies Looks at both educational achievement outcomes and behavioral variables to make its assertions. For formal education and achievement tests, the meta analysis found that "Examination of the individual effect sizes indicated that, for majority two-parent samples, there was a negative association between early employment and achievement; this effect was significant for formal achievement tests only". This is the effect controlled for family structure, it doesn't neccessarily impact IQ. However, controlling for Socio-economic variables resulted in a negative effect that career motherhood had across all achievement domains, with middle upper class being hurt while the poor benefited from maternal employment. When it came to looking at behavior, once controlled for family structure (one or 2 parent household) and socioeconomic variables, it showed that career moms showed negative behaviour problems and increased externalizing behavior for their kids. To sum this study up

However, early maternal employment was associated with negative outcomes for other subgroups, namely with decreases in achievement for two-parent families and increases in behavior problems for samples with mixed one- and two-parent families.

TLDR: If you can sustain yourself with only one income, then you should have a stay at home mom watching your young children

Maternal Employment and Children’s Achievement in Context: A Meta-Analysis of Four Decades of Research

This Meta analysis of 68 studies supports the conclusion (once accounting for stuff like socioeconomic status) that being a career mom is a negative for your children's achievement and education. To quote "Although the point estimates did not reach traditional levels of significance, the direction of effects was negative in middle/upper-middle-class samples". Admittedly, the effect from this meta analysis isn't as big as the last one but still relevant.

**A Meta-Analysis of Published Research on the Psychological Effects of Nonmaternal Care on Child Development: Social Policy Implications

This is a meta analysis of 101 studies published in between 1957 and 1995, the results of this study are the strongest as a result of the incredibly large amount of study's taken here. This study finds statistically significant increases in problems for 4 domains for children of working moms. They are cognitive (reading issues, test scores, IQ etc.) behavioral, attachment and social emotional (peer relations, personality measures etc.) issues. They found statistically a significant negative impact in all 4 domains for career moms. This study accounts for various factors, including socioeconomic status, age of kid, year of publication, ethnicity, country, hours of care in child care, beginning age of child care, sponsor of daycare, caregiver to child ratio, caregiver education, licencing of day care, mothers education, number of children and family structure.

Counter: the negative increases are small

They seem small, but that's merely because they aren't using a proportional system. The increases in problems in all 4 of these domains ranged from 7% to 19% percent. These are the differences in the whole population between working and non working moms. For example, when it came to attachment issues 49% of working moms kids had these issues versus 30% for non working (therefore yielding a 19% difference). However, this doesn't tell you your increased chance of having a child with attachment issues. 19% is 63% of 30, so your actual increased chance is 63% if your a career mom over a working mom. So your actual increase chance is fairly high and relevant in practical terms.

Security of Children's Relationships With Nonparental Care Providers: A Meta‐Analysis

This meta analysis of 24 studies find children have greater attachments to home based rather than center based care providers. This in general supports the idea that stay at home moms have a higher attachment security than working moms.

counter: studies like this show that men with working moms are more oriented to gender equality, while the daughters are more likely to be employed and had higher incomes and had more years of education.

Well, working moms raise working moms and SAHM's are more likely to raise SAHM's. Of course working moms are going to have better careers and such and are going to raise kids who will follow in their path. The key thing here is that these study's don't measure any psychological effects of being a career mom.


r/FeMRADebates • • Apr 13 '18

Other Feminists to Men: Castrate Yourselves

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Mar 29 '19

Idle Thoughts It literally makes no sense to be right-wing if you're an MRA

1 Upvotes

Right-wingers are the group that is the least likely to care about men's issues. The mere idea of men as a group having problems is reprehensible to the average right-winger because men are supposed to be self-reliant according to traditional masculinity.

I'm not saying that left-wingers generally care about male-specific issues, because I don't think they do. However, at least the left is much more open to the idea that men can be victims.

That is why I'm baffled by right-wing MRAs, like the Honey Budgers, it's like they recognize some problems but then they support the group that is by far the least likely to do something about those problems.

There could be reasons to support right-wing parties, but surely not because they're pro men's rights...


r/FeMRADebates • • Jul 26 '18

Map of the World rescaled by total research citations. European ("white") derived Populations produce (by far) the most scientific output per capita.

Thumbnail
proxy.duckduckgo.com
2 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Apr 25 '21

Theory All Masculinity Is Toxic

Thumbnail
vice.com
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jun 12 '15

Personal Experience Discussing privilege with the privileged

0 Upvotes

My husband is not terribly interested in gender-related issues, but because he loves me, he makes an effort to engage with me on things I care about (I reciprocate, which is how I know anything at all about the Austrian school of economic thought). I remember the first time I tried to discuss privilege with him, as in white cis straight male privilege. He immediately went on the defensive (he’s a white cis straight male, for background) because, as he pointed out with great vigor and many examples, he had hardly let a privileged life! (Very true—his level of poverty growing up sometimes even exceeded mine, which is saying something—the places I lived did always have functional plumbing, for example. And he also had many stories of growing up in nonwhite majority neighborhoods, where he was often threatened with and sometimes on the receiving end of extortions and group beatings from nonwhite kids.)

Seeing that my approach wasn’t working well, I backed off and thought about it for a while. The problem was, we weren’t using the same definition of privilege, and he wasn’t able to let go of the adjectival, personal definition of privilege as an advantage or source of pleasure granted to a specific person and replace it with the sociological, cohort definition of privilege as advantages specific groups of people have relative to other groups. It wasn’t that he wasn’t intellectually capable of understanding the difference; it was that he was emotionally invested in not allowing the usage of the second definition to supersede the first, ever. However, we’re both native and solely American English speakers, and I’m neither Shakespeare nor Sarah Palin when it comes to new word generation, so I was stuck with the word that existed. How to overcome this language barrier?

What I ended up doing was reframing the discussion so that it targeted a different group—specifically, white cis straight females (I’m one, for background). He couldn’t think, even subconsciously, that I might secretly be out to get myself, so the act of doing so went a long way towards eradicating the defensiveness that had impeded the early conversation. It worked out pretty well, and now we can talk privilege without too much emotional impedance.

Now, the only reason this did work, though, is that white cis straight females do have a few privileges to speak of, so I could use them as an example. What if, though, I were a black trans lesbian..? I can’t actually think of a single privilege, sociologically speaking, that this group enjoys, so it would be impossible for me, if I were one, to use the same tactics to break through the defensive emotional barrier some people have reflexively when they hear the word privilege. What tactics can sociological groups without privilege, use to communicate about it effectively to a member of a group that does..?


r/FeMRADebates • • Aug 04 '15

Media The real reason some men still can't handle the all-female 'Ghostbusters'

Thumbnail
dailydot.com
0 Upvotes

r/FeMRADebates • • Jul 06 '22

Other the slippery slope and sexuality

1 Upvotes

In a recent post the Peterson tweet was being discussed. In that thread a user commented

appropriate treatment for gays, lesbians and trans persons was originally to try to change the mind to fit cis het norms.

That made me question where the line is for acceptance of a persons sexuality. When we look at the trans issue one side says it doesn't matter if they cant be the other sex we will socially accept them as they wish to be treated. With homosexuality we decided we could not infringe on their rights.

We however dont accept trans racial or trans age? Regardless of the fact they cant do anything we dont accept pedophiles. It seems like these lines cant be held by the same group who holds trans and lgbt beliefs. It does make sense from the conservative view but breaks down if the liberal principles are held. Why is killing an animal for meat fine but beastialty wrong if you believe a persons sexuality should be respected? If that person ate the animal they would be in the wrong but if that person "loved" the animal?

Just where is the line? What the principled way to allow one group but not the others? We're not talking about the greys here. We are talking about the logical reasons that come from a principal.

Edit for clarity on the principle im talking about. It does not matter if you can or can not act on a sexual "orientation". Why is it not respected AS an orientation. As in the quote not confirming to cis hete norms is not reason to not respect the orientation.