r/Favors • • Aug 05 '11

[Request] Your participation in a grand experiment: I'm taking the moderation of /r/favors wholly democratic.

26 Upvotes

EDIT: an hour into it and 1 person threw their hat into the ring. In the interests of making this about /r/favors and not about me I've made Mutki a moderator of this subreddit to handle transition. Consider his actions as part of his candidacy. As for me, it's apparent that the mob is not interested in my dialog at this time so I'm going to have a day.


TL;DR: I'm de-modding Anomander, YTKnows and mjvarchmin and hereby pledging to operate in a purely supervisory manner in order to open this subreddit to moderation by a democratically-elected team of term-limited moderators. I'm not stepping down but I'm sure as hell getting out of the way. Your participation is invited and encouraged. this will not be an immediate change but I hope to have everything fully switched over by September 1.

  • WHO: Anyone who has been a part of /r/favors for any amount of time and who values what this community stands for. Those who don't want to moderate are asked to vote. Those who do want to moderate are asked to announce their candidacy below and offer substantiation for the community as to why they would be a good moderator for /r/favors.

  • WHAT: I intend to make a mod post on Monday in which all those who have announced their candidacy below will run for moderation of this subreddit based on popular vote. I intend to turn over the mod queue, the FAQ, the rules, the sidebar, ALL OF IT to the candidates of your election. The top FIVE (subject to increase pending discussion) elected candidates will have near-total control over this subreddit from September 1, 2011 until March 1, 2012, at which time a new team of moderators (incumbents freely permitted) will take over their mod duties.

  • WHEN: Candidacy to be announced below. Election to begin next Monday, total votes to be counted next Friday (time TBD and agreed-upon beforehand). Candidates to be modded next Saturday; full-time, un-inhibited moderation to be 100% democratically-selected and openly-enacted by September 1, 2011.

  • WHERE: Elections will happen right here. MODERATION WILL HAPPEN IN PUBLIC, if I can figure out how (input is welcome), much like the moderation in /r/anarchism. Moderation will be publicly available for review, in real-time, via a link in the sidebar. Who watches the Watchmen? You do.

  • HOW: I shall remain top mod. Yeah, yeah. Whine, whine, gritch gritch. Listen for one fucking minute: I've grown this subreddit from 1 subscriber to 17,000 through hard work, altruism and a willingness to be the hard-hearted dick so that it doesn't become /r/begging. You're all here because I worked my ass off to make it a place you want to be. This is an experiment and it could go horribly, horribly wrong; I reserve the right (with prior public announcement, with public input) to yank the plug on the experiment should I judge this new moderation process to be detrimental to the users of the /r/favors community. Any potential termination of this experiment will be upon consideration by the community but final determination by me; You're going to have to trust me on this one.

  • WHY:

Well, that's complicated.

First off, I realized moderation makes me mean. Not this subreddit, but /r/DoesAnybodyElse. I signed on as a moderator at /r/DoesAnybodyElse purely to crack skulls. I figured with ~200k comment karma and a general distaste for stupidity, cleaning house in there would be easy.

What I discovered instead is that saying "yeah, actually it's quite common to strip naked to take a shit, I've seen four posts identical to yours in the spam queue" to people three times a day wears on you. Particularly as most anyone with a burning desire to see who else shits naked tends to be violently rude when you tell them there are other places for that.

Lie down with dogs, wake up with fleas.

The first subreddit I ever moderated (deliberately) was this one, because I value people helping people. What I've discovered is that "moderating" the act of people helping people involves determining who gets to ask. We could go around and around about how "anybody should be allowed to ask" and I'll stop you there - even /r/INeedAFavor, with 6 hours of uptime, put rules in the sidebar.

Regardless, I've gotten to the point where I'll shit down the neck of an innocent person looking to get some charity work done even though another moderator banned the post. And yeah - all three of us had gotten really good at not getting in each other's business for moderating (I give people who witch hunt me a hard time; Anomander comes down on anyone with an account newer than 3 months, ytknows has done fuckall in the better part of a year, mjvarchmin hasn't even shown up since the subreddit's inception) but really, this whole retarded dustup has shown that our mod team is gob-smackingly dysfunctional.

I probably spend 20 hours a week moderating for Reddit. If what it gets me is a hair trigger caustic temper defending the decision of another cranky mod, I need a better way to spend my time. I deserve better, you deserve better, we all deserve better.

Violentacrez has been making a great deal of hay with this image. It's part of a larger thought-piece on how to deal with the burgeoning size of Reddit and the bottleneck of moderation; it's in a private subreddit but I'll link it public later today if enough people care. The bulk of it deals with the overlap of subreddits and how similar subreddits could be consolidated, and all moderation could be taken public, a la Wikipedia. I have long been of the opinion that Reddit's approach to community management (shadowbans in particular) is detrimental to fostering healthy communities but getting 600 of these in exchange for one of these is a blaring beacon in the night that shit's got to change.

Not just for me, not just for you, but for everybody. So we're gonna try that here. If it works, maybe it catches on.

And maybe being told "lol die faggot" 400 times will have been worth something.

(side note: yesterday wasn't exactly bad for subscriptions, despite three different threads suggesting that people leave. We must be doing something right.)


r/Favors • • Aug 04 '11

[Request] (MOD) Help me list all the other cool subreddits that keep the Reddit favor engine running.

0 Upvotes

Hey, guys. 17,281 readers. Pretty fuckin' awesome. And we've seen some seriously cool stuff go down in here.

We'd be idiots to presume that /r/favors is the one and only place where redditors help out other redditors, though. We have always acknowledged many of the other helpful communities in the sidebar, but there's never been enough room over there. And let's be honest - we've been due for a refresh for a while now. Reddit has roughly 10 times as many eyeballs reading it as did when we launched this ship and there are far more communities in a helpful vein than there were the last time we revised anything ("new! /r/Proofreading!" a community for 8 months).

So I'ma revise the sidebar and I'ma revise the FAQ and I'ma revise a bunch of stuff to make this a more user-friendly community and help point people in the best direction to get what they need.

SO HERE'S WHAT I NEED FROM YOU:

Use the space below to list other communities that are in a "favors" vein. /r/randomactsofpizza is an obvious one, so's /r/snackexchange. I know a whole bunch of you guys have linked to your new, helpful subreddits for inclusion in the sidebar; here's a chance to get 'em added.

  • Gimme the subreddit's name, a link to it, about how big it is, and a 1-sentence or so description of what it's about. If you're a moderator of that subreddit, please say so - I'm going to take your summary and include it. If you're not a moderator of that subreddit, please PM the mods of that subreddit and invite them over here to say their peace.

Any and all discussion is welcomed, any and all links are welcomed, any and all input is welcomed. Thanks to all of you for making this my fondest corner of Reddit, and thanks for over a year of helping others out just to be cool.

NEW FAQ, NEW SIDEBAR TO FOLLOW


r/Favors • • Oct 03 '12

[OFFER]Super bored this evening. I'll do a free tarot reading for you. Past lives are a fun specialty.

0 Upvotes

Just give me some details on what you are asking. Important to note that I am not going to be telling you what you want to hear so much as what I read in the cards. Seems to have dried up in here. Thanks for the time and hope I helped out.


r/Favors • • Aug 04 '11

[request] We forget about Kleinbl00 and try not to bring down an amazing subreddit over one badly thought out comment.

0 Upvotes

r/Favors • • Aug 06 '11

r/favor mod voting round 2.

0 Upvotes

Here are the rules for this round of voting:

All candidates, and only candidates, will be able to post a paragraph or two describing why they will make a good mod for r/favors. Discussion by you, the readers, should take place about why or why not that mod would make a good mod in that mod's specific paragraph thread. I recommend you do your research on the candidates below. Know who you are electing and why. Scour their comment history for the good stuff, and sling a little mud for the bad. It wouldn't be a democratic election if the voters were not passionate about their candidate. Any post in the main thread that is not by a candidate will be removed.

ONLY UPVOTES WILL BE COUNTED FOR VOTING PURPOSES

Monday there will be a thread posted with just the names below for you to vote on. All other comments will be removed. The top five winners from that thread will become the new mods of r/favors.

Regarding the current mods

Anomander didn't nominate himself in the last threads, but I'm throwing his name in the running because being added yesterday allowed me to see who is doing actual mod work here, and boy is that guy awesome for this community. The spam filter goes for days looking like that.

ytknows declined nomination. And that's ok. His work was minimal (I didn't see any actually) and this community does not need absent mods right now.

mjvarchmin is non existent here, and on most of reddit.

So without further ado,

THE LIST:

Anomander

Wordslinger1919

Mutki

toro_de_rojo

steve93

panickedthumb

TheDashingPrince

redditisfun

lanismycousin

MrZ33

Patrick5555

andrewsmith1986

bceagles

megaepictroll


r/Favors • • Jul 07 '12

[REQUEST] I need to temporarily use a netflix account since I just got a job and am buying a subscription at the end of the month.

0 Upvotes

I live by myself, and have nothing to do. I'm tight on money, and really want to watch some awesome shows. I promise if I can borrow the account, I'm only going to use it for about 2-3 weeks tops. I'm going to use it on my Xbox, so I don't even need your email/password information.

Someone please! :(


r/Favors • • Aug 04 '11

Concerning Kleinbl00...

318 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm toro_de_rojo, a mod for r/funny and r/askreddit. I've noticed the rage campaign against Kleinbl00 today, and would like to say a few words on his behalf, even though I will probably be suiciding my karma level because of it.

He probably doesn't even know who I am. But I have him friended here on reddit for a very specific reason.

http://www.reddit.com/r/Youngluck/ is that reason. Kleinbl00 is the reason Youngluck, a redditor who went to jail for making a mistake in life, got a reduced sentence. It's one of the most awesome things that has happened here on reddit. The TL;DR is here.

Regardless of how much you hate him right now (and I'm not defending how he acted), the guy is genuinely a good person. He assisted a redditor, a real person, when they needed it most, and good things came of it.

It's my opinion that groupthink has taken over, but it is the internet, so it will be forgotten next week. Kleinbl00's actions on reddit (and there are literally dozens more) have affected so many people in positive ways. More than all of you attacking him is affecting him negatively I'm sure.

Be the bigger people here. He fucked up, admitted it, and apologized. And that's good enough for me.


r/Favors • • Dec 07 '10

[offer] I will read Tarot Cards for you.

3 Upvotes

Hi guys,

I posted this in AskReddit first, but someone wisely suggested I place this offer here instead.

So here it is. I want to give a bit of background as to why I'm doing this.

Where I live, there are no jobs. I've applied at everywhere that had an opening, some places more than once and I haven't even received a call back to come to an interview.

So, I decided if no one will give me work, I'm going to have to make it for myself.

That said, my skill set, as well of the bulk of my knowledge isn't exactly the norm. I've spent an inordinate amount of time studying and practicing various mystical philosophies and occult ideals. So, thats what I'm working with.

My hope for this thread is to get some practice. I offer you free readings, on whatever you want, in hopes of working on my skills, with the eventual goal of doing this full-time for pay.

So, if you are into this same kind of voodoo as I am, leave a message here in the thread, or PM me. If you are curious, this is free, so why not try? If you are a skeptic, keep in mind that I'm not claiming to be a psychic or that this is magic.

Either way, hope to work with you guys over here in /r/favors in case we missed the chance over at /r/askreddit.

Thanks guys!

EDIT -

Hello again,

I want to let you know the easiest way for this to happen. Just send me a pm, or post here, in regards to what you want me to look into during the reading. It can be ANY subject or topic. I usually send people their readings right here on Reddit by means of Private message. If there is another way you would rather go about it, let me know!

This usually takes me a while to work through all of the requests, so if I'm going slow I apologize and I promise I will try to work fast to get to you.

Thanks again.


r/Favors • • Apr 05 '12

[request] Someone to take a photo of themselves with an ipad 2 or 3.

0 Upvotes

Hi guys.

So I'm writing a review for an ipad 2. It's not terribly positive but it's fair. One criticism is that you look like a bit of an idiot taking a photo with it, and I was going to use a photo to illustrate this point.

However, I've sold the ipad before I started writing this review. So my question is that you could take a photo of yourself in a mirror with the ipad (making yourself look as foolish as possible would help prove my point).

Big thanks.


r/Favors • • Jan 14 '10

[Request]: My parents need an internet miracle AskReddit Crosspost.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Favors • • Jun 13 '13

[REQUEST] Survy for school

0 Upvotes

Hi!

Seems like I'm not the only one asking for this request but could you do a quick survey. Its for school and no personal information will be taken.

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/N3YNNCG


r/Favors • • Sep 17 '11

[Request] Reddit, I am trying to learn more about how people monitor their workouts. Will you guys help me out and fill out my survey (~5 minutes). Thank you so much for your help! (Link in post)

2 Upvotes

If you are a gym user, will you fill out the survey. Thank you in advance for your help.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/viewform?formkey=dGRUOHRNME1IQThHWHFOTThFWU1iZEE6MQ#gid=0


r/Favors • • Mar 06 '13

[Request]I need y'alls help. I am running a anonymous survey on marijuana use for a final. Its 10 questions and would really appreciate your help. Thanks

2 Upvotes

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/BS5W5KM

Thank you for your feedback.


r/Favors • • Oct 19 '10

[Offer] $10 to the first person who can explain why Kleinbl00 is such a dick to new members.

0 Upvotes

r/Favors • • Mar 15 '13

[Request] Wow Game time for brother

1 Upvotes

Looking for any denomination of time. This is for my younger brother who recently had a sports accident and is unable to go outside until his injury heals. Please and thank you.


r/Favors • • Jan 05 '12

[Offer] 20% off Origin discount code

1 Upvotes

EDIT: Appears to be used up.

AVPVC-EAPAJ-XXSNC

Can be used on the Origin store on any already released game (except pre-orders and new releases). http://store.origin.com

It's good for 30 days and I don't intend on using it. Maybe someone else would like to. Please comment if you use it up.


r/Favors • • Oct 05 '12

[OFFER] Intuitive back and ready to give some free tarot readings. Past lives are what I'm best at!

0 Upvotes

Given some controversy in the last thread, please note that any advice I give is based off of a strongly held belief on my part. It is up to you whether or not you take it. If I don't know, I will say just that. Also, if you are interested in any aspects of what I do/believe please AMA EDIT: Off to bed now folks. Starting a new job in the morning and want to be able to not look like an ass bag for it. Hope this was insightful or at least entertaining. Take care!


r/Favors • • Jun 10 '11

Hey r/favors, I made a new subreddit specifically for Photoshop requests. Just trying to get the word out.

0 Upvotes

r/Favors • • Oct 21 '11

[Request] Grand Theft Auto IV Steam($3.50)

0 Upvotes

Hello reddit! I was wondering if anyone could purchase me a copy of GTA IV on steam. I have wanted this game for a long time and now that it is on sale I would love to get it. I do not have any money at the time but within a week I will be able to pay you back :) Thats redactors for all you time and kindness!


r/Favors • • Oct 25 '11

HELP REDDIT!! I need people to take my survey for my Marketing Class

0 Upvotes

We are performing research on specific demographics and require you to fit these demographics to take the survey. The survey is very short, and will be submitted anonymously. The results will be used for academic purposes only. The following are the required demographics of the survey takers: Age 18-29 Ethnicity: Hispanic, African American, Asian

Link: https://hofstra.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_2gFslrnXvwCVaRe Thank You, your cooperation is greatly appreciated!!


r/Favors • • Jun 06 '10

[Offer] Post A Picture and I'll make it look all cool and Cross-Processed

9 Upvotes

I'm really bored and I could use some photoshop practice. Send me a picture of yourself, your dog, or whatever you want and I'll make it look cross processed (or add some other random effect).

I can't promise that I'll do this quickly but I'll try and respond to as many as I can.


r/Favors • • Nov 09 '11

[Update] And the winner(s) of a free copy of Skyrim are...

10 Upvotes

From this thread. I know I said Thursday, but no one else was submitting, and I felt that they would not really be bested, so here are the winners:

hairybalkan and mystimel! Each of their stories and photo's touched me (especially hairybalkan's snow man) and I couldn't let them both go unrewarded.

Enjoy the game you two!

A note to the rest of r/favors and reddit: pay it forward. This is a crazy, brutal world we live in, and people from all walks of life are suffering at all times. Of course we can't help everyone, but we can help some of them, even if it's to do something silly like purchase a videogame for them. Because ultimately, we do it to make someone smile, to see them happy. That's what favors are: acts of unadulterated kindness.

And for this place to do it for complete strangers makes me happy to be a human being.

-toro


r/Favors • • Nov 13 '11

Microsoft Office for MAC

4 Upvotes

EDIT: A wonderful Redditor homeygmoneygrip has come through on my favor request! Thank you again!

Does anyone know how I can get a copy of MS Office for mac? (Cheap or free) My computer crashed and the apple store had to re-install the operating system, as a result I lost the program because I don't have the disc.

EDIT: I don't have a serial key any longer. :(


r/Favors • • May 03 '10

[request] Someone to photoshop together the faces of Glen Beck, Sarah Palin, Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity so we can see what the devil looks like.

22 Upvotes

r/Favors • • Jun 06 '15

[offer] 50 Google Inbox Invites

5 Upvotes

PM me the email you'd like invited and it will be done