r/FanFiction • • 16d ago

Discussion Please be mindful when distributing fics you didn't write.

189 Upvotes

Since AO3 has gone down, I've seen a lot of people come together to share fics they've downloaded over the years.

Please try to reach out to us authors before you start publicly uploading fics to sites we didn't consent to. I've seen people distributing large quantities of fanfiction via platforms that many of us deliberately left due to concerns regarding AI training policies.

Edit: I can't reply to anyone since this is locked, but you guys are insane. Distributed works without consent is indisputably illegal and against AO3's ToS. The writers have every right to report your reuploads. Your disregard for consent puts your various accounts at risk


r/FanFiction • • May 11 '26

Discussion I was today years old when I realized people apparently hate epithets in Fanfiction

0 Upvotes

I've been writing fanfiction for around 15 years, and I only today came across some discourse that apparently the use of terms like "the blonde" or "the brunette" are supposedly despised in written works. Went into a whole deep dive and yeah, people seem very passionate about this.

The arguments against them I've seen have been pretty interesting to me. Saying that readers typically don't notice the names or pronouns used over and over again, but do notice epithets. I'm pretty much the opposite. For example, especially in a M/M work, I find that constant use of names and pronouns gets incredibly repetitive and boring (or even confusing as to who is doing what) and really gives me the impression that the writer really has no sense of whimsy about them.

It's also never taken me out of the experience for a character to think of a character they know the name of by their hair color or height. I fear this is not as jarring as people seem to believe when I'm far more concerned about the narrative of the work rather than how the character is being described every couple of paragraphs.

"But you would never think of your IRL friend as "the blonde", would you?" Probably not, but my IRL experience is not narrated with the intention of being entertaining, either. My fics are.

For as much as it's claimed to be a sign of bad writing, never once in 15 years have I had anyone comment on a fic of mine and say "Well, I really enjoyed that, but the epithets really took me out of it." It feels odd to discourage new writers from them when I highly doubt the average commenter is going to bring it up as a dealbreaker and it comes across as more of an overblown pet peeve than anything.

Frankly speaking, if someone hates my use of epithets that much, I would think they'd probably just click off and go read something else. Which I would absolutely prefer. I write for fun and for free. Not for someone to tell me reading a couple epithets made them ignore the other 15K+ words I wrote.

Sure, I don't think every single sentence should be "the priestess" to the point that you never use the name, but I do indeed get bored of both reading, and more importantly, writing *Insert Character's Name Here* 97 times in a couple paragraphs. I think it's fine to have fun with writing and using epithets here and there to add variety is nowhere near as "jarring" as it's made out to be.

Saying "we just want people to improve their writing skills" shouldn't subsequently make a person enjoy their own writing less. I would much rather write something I enjoy reading than try to cater my writing to someone who is consuming my work for free feeling entitled to consuming it in a specific way. There's hundred of other fics out there to read instead.

TL;DR, I don't find epithets that bad at all, and the hate for them honestly seems like looking for something to be mad about. There are a hundred things that will take me out of a work sooner than a couple of epithets. If you're that taken out of a work because "the blonde" appears more than five times in a 4K word chapter, I honestly have to wonder what you're actually reading for. If the narrative itself is good, I don't see a single reason why an epithet would be the dealbreaker for a fic.

But that's just my opinion. I really just felt like sharing this so people don't think hatred for epithets is universal. If no one is actively going out of their way to bring up to you that your use of them is ruining the fic for them, I wouldn't stress over actively trying not to use them.


r/FanFiction • • Jan 23 '23

Venting Condoms in fiction NSFW

2 Upvotes

I'm sick of people who put condoms on a pedestal, in fiction of all places. I don't consume fiction to remember the discomfort that might happen before, during or after condomless sex. I consume fiction to indulge vicariously in an alternate setting free from that kind of discomfort. Noone’s at risk of STDs or UTIs in fiction. Fictional characters should be able to fuck other fictional characters without condoms

"But, but, but, realism! And fictional condomless sex would have a negative effect on consumers-"

Said by the same people who react strongly to criticisms of their favorite questionable fiction. That's when, "fiction =/= reality, learn the difference, bigot"

Fiction shouldn't be a substitute for sex education

If someone has been learning how to fuck from fiction, they and their education system are the problem. Not the fiction

Why I posted this: my preference for condomless (gay) fiction was shamed


r/FanFiction • • Dec 31 '22

Discussion Fiction CAN affect reality and depiction CAN be endorsement in fiction.

19 Upvotes

I often see the opinion on this subreddit that any fiction about anything is morally acceptable, and that having a different view is censorious. Now to be clear, I'm not an 'anti' - I don't believe in banning content and I certainly don't want to harass authors.

But the two often repeated canards of 'fiction doesn't affect reality' and 'depiction is not endorsement' are just not always true. They're probably mostly true, but certainly not always.

For an example of fiction affecting reality, think about how popular searches for BDSM activities became after 50 Shades. I think it's a perfectly reasonable criticism that 50 Shades depicted really unsafe, abusive sexual practices as desirable, which had an impact on people's expectation of real sexual practices. Or read about Birth of a Nation which was a film that depicted the KKK as heroes so successfully that millions of people joined the KKK.

Similarly, depiction absolutely can be endorsement. A highly pornographic text involving an adult narrator having sex with children could absolutely be intended to endorse that behaviour or at least to sexually arouse readers with reference to that behaviour. A fanfic where the narrator uses racial or gender stereotypes can be, though certainly isn't always, a reflection of the author's real views.

So I wish people would take a more nuanced approach to this discussion. I repeat that I don't support harassing authors or censoring content. But some fanfiction really is an expression of morally reprehensible ideas, and we should be able to say so!


r/FanFiction • • Dec 23 '24

Smut Talk Which Brother/Sister Incest smut do you like and tropes for it? NSFW

3 Upvotes

For those of you enjoy the the forbidden fruit that is incest, how do you like it done? The Step Siblings angle? Or the full on blood related kind? What are your favorite tropes used? Whats your limit on the age differences or do you prefer the twin angle? Your least favorite trope?


r/FanFiction • • Aug 03 '25

Recs Wanted Are there any fanfictions where the x-men take in a trans girl?

4 Upvotes

Title. Surprised I haven't found any. Thanks


r/FanFiction • • Sep 04 '24

Activities and Events Sexually Explicit Fanfiction: A Study of Reader Perceptions and Sexual Health NSFW

1 Upvotes

Principal Investigator:

Jan Cioe, Ph.D., R.Psych. (Retd), Psychology Department, UBC Okanagan, email: [email protected] 

Co-Investigators:

Kinjal Gupta, Undergraduate Student, Psychology Department, UBC Okanagan, email: [email protected]

Description:

The purpose of this study is to examine the perceived educational value of sexually explicit fanfiction. It seeks to understand readers’ consumption frequency, reading motivations, and their level of sexual health awareness. Despite its popularity, there is a dearth of research addressing the use of sexually explicit fanfiction. This research aims to fill this gap by examining the use of sexually explicit fanfiction

If you choose to participate in this study, you will complete an online, cloud-based survey using the Qualtrics Survey platform. You will be asked to answer a series of questions regarding your consumption habits, reading motivations, sexual health, perceptions of sexually explicit fanfiction, and your demographic information related to age, gender, ethnic identity, and sexual orientation. 

Participation in this survey should take approximately 20–30 minutes to complete. We ask that you complete the survey in one sitting.

You will have the opportunity to win one of four $25 (CAD) gift cards. After you have submitted your responses to the survey, you will see a hotlink you must click in order to be entered into the draw. You must provide a means of contact (e.g., email) and complete a skill testing question in order to be entered. The information you provide cannot be connected back to you in any way; it is only used to enter you into the Amazon Canada gift card draw.

To participate, you must be fluent in English (English level Grade 12), be at least 18 years of age, and read sexually explicit fanfiction.

 Link to the study: https://ubc.ca1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_0B8u9gAPCYmm5Wm


r/FanFiction • • Aug 21 '24

Discussion Trans characters in fics/writing? NSFW

0 Upvotes

Hi chat (because I can’t be serious)! I was wondering on your opinion of trans head-canonned (canoned?) characters. I was wondering if it bothers you or genuinely annoys you guys. I’m obviously not going to change my head canons or writing to appease someone else, but I wanted to see other peoples opinions.

And as a side-note, other trans authors, do you guys end up trans-ing your favourites/most relatable characters?

I know that I find doing that makes me feel more affirmed if that makes sense? Like writing trans characters in certain scenarios makes me feel better. I know things like smut scenes can be seen as fetishizing/sexualizing trans people, but I do it for self-affirmation.

Don’t hurt me, it’s my first time posting here 😭

(Tagged as NSFW because I added smut/sexualization questions)


r/FanFiction • • Dec 27 '21

Venting People who place the responsibility of their fanfic curation onto us as creators...

23 Upvotes

Can I use kids these days? Because I feel like I can.

Some people really are entitled, especially those tiktok kids who very rudely say that you need to tag really tiny things, and fly into a temper tantrum when you don't.

I understand dead dove warnings or trigger warnings for traumatic experiences, but things like trans people, or gay ships (m/m) shouldn't need a fucking tag.

Sure Jacob, I get that you find trans/gay people icky, but it's on you to curate your fanfic archive. The real world isn't like the internet, you'll be exposed to small triggers (like gasp, gay people!) and demanding they simply censor themselves from your sight isn't pratical.

Has anything like that ever happened to you before? Re. entitled people expecting you to tiptoe around them?


r/FanFiction • • Jul 29 '24

Ship Talk Favorite incest ships

64 Upvotes

I'm thinking of signing up for the relationshipping exchange, but I don't have enough incest ships. What are your favorites and why do you ship them?

Don't be shy if you think you're the only one shipping it! I feel like there are a ton of siblings I lowkey ship while watching a movie or reading a book, and then sadly I forget about them when it's time to sign up for exchanges haha.


r/FanFiction • • Nov 12 '25

Discussion Cirtique on bookmarks

0 Upvotes

I've always been baffled by the idea from mainly AO3 users that if you want to critique a work in needs to be positive otherwise you need to take it private or take it off site to do so so and yet the AO3 ToS has this to say:

Is criticizing fanworks allowed? Is criticism a violation of the harassment policy?
Criticism is allowed on AO3 and is not considered harassment. This includes negative commentary in comments, bookmark notes, bookmark tags, and other locations. Criticizing a work is not a personal attack against the person who created that work, nor against people who enjoy that work. Issuing personal attacks or threats against other users for creating or enjoying a work is harassment and is not allowed.

How does the harassment policy apply to comments?
Criticism of a fanwork, even harsh criticism, is not by itself harassment. All creators have control over the comments on their works, and can delete comments or block users for any reason. Calling a creator evil, wishing them harm, and repeatedly posting negative commentary in a manner designed to be seen by the creator (such as by posting multiple negative comments on their work) are potential examples of harassment

Maybe it's the fact that I have mild autism but to me this makes it clear that the general social contract is that critique and criticism is allowed, especially as from my experience over the last about 20 or so years that I've been reading fics online prior to a lot of fandoms migrating to AO3, reader critique both positive and negative have always been welcomed. Personally I'd rather hear from a reader that has noticed where I've stumbled with the pacing of the story I'm writing, a characters feels too OoC and it pulled them out of the story or that I've made grammatical or spelling errors.


r/FanFiction • • Jul 04 '22

Venting Just had my fic "rated" in the bookmarks

0 Upvotes

It just grosses me out that people are still doing this. Bookmark notes, unless private, can be seen by everyone, including the author. So getting a "So so 1st chapter" note left on my fic is not a great feeling. I scrolled through their bookmarks and saw that they did that to almost every fic (they had over 1500 bookmarked!!) so most likely they're just a troll or a child or whatever, but *sigh* it's just very disheartening sometimes.

They have been blocked but I'm not sure if they can still see my works or not.


r/FanFiction • • Jul 06 '26

Recs Wanted M/M sibling incest fics wanted NSFW

0 Upvotes

I realise this is very much not for everyone, but I know I'm not the only one with this particular fictional kink, so here goes. :))

I'm looking for ships between brothers who are either biologically or socially related (though if they're only related socially, they need to have grown up together as brothers), with good fics.

Bonus points for longfics, but it's not necessary. What is essential is that both brothers are major/main characters in canon, and that the incest is at least somewhat a taboo in the fictional world of the fanfic itself (otherwise, where's the fun of incest?).

So far, I've read a lot of:

- Wincest

- Holmescest

- Itasasu

- DabiShou

- Sesshumaru/Inuyasha

- Jadecest (MDZS) and Jiang Cheng/Wei Wuxian

- Thorki

Which ships or fandoms am I missing? Do you have any favourite fics you would be willing to share? If you don't want to share publicly, you can always do.

Thank you in advance! 🥰

--

ETA: RPF is welcome, too!


r/FanFiction • • Feb 09 '25

Discussion Why do some fans insist on changing characters' names?

5 Upvotes

Let's say the name of the character in question is Pascal Pedro. We know that Pascal is his surname and Pedro his first name because the character had a son who he named Pascal Luís. Why do people still insist on writing fanfic as if the character's first name was Pascal? I just read a great fanfic, good plot, good character development, but the author wrote that Pedro is the family name. Everyone around him calls him Pascal. I know it's just a detail, but it irritates me so much. I feel the same thing when I read Naruto fanfic and they write the characters' names in the Western style, like, instead of writing Uzumaki Naruto, as is correct according to the canon and Japanese culture, they write Naruto Uzumaki.


r/FanFiction • • Mar 07 '24

Discussion Why are canon couples not taken into account in many fics?

1 Upvotes

( english is not my first language)

Im asking because i've seen many fics that have the main character either never knowing or rarely interesting in the canon love interest.

Here a few examples...

Brian laborn aka grue from worm.

Both cho chang and ginny weasley from harry potter.

Ochako uraraka from my hero academia.

Why is this?


r/FanFiction • • Aug 18 '26

Writing Questions So I want to continue a Fic that isn't mine

0 Upvotes

Long story short, there is this fanfic that I love that hasn't been updated since 2019. The author most likely isn't coming back, I have sadly accepted this. But that doesn't mean I should leave this master piece alone.

So, I've come to reddit. I am still new to the writing circles and thought I would ask you guys before I do it, could I continue the fanfic? Is there specific things I should keep in mind like saying I'm continuing a story that never ended? Saying I'm a co-author and saying the name of the original?

Thoughts please!


r/FanFiction • • Mar 17 '26

Discussion How do I put a fandom up for adoption?

0 Upvotes

I am in a very small, unpopular fandom and I really want people to write more fics on it, specially about a side character I like.

I am currently writing one myself. There are exactly 3 fics in the entire AO3 including mine—(the other two were one shots).

I don't want to come off as rude or unmannered so where do I post it for adoption? How can I get maximum visibility?

Thanks in advance :)


r/FanFiction • • Jun 15 '25

Venting Too much smut

0 Upvotes

Do any of you guys run into this problem or is it just me? I search up character fics and literally the majority of the fics are just pure smut. And listen i don’t hate smut but when it’s the only thing people can write about/ask for, it gets annoying (to me).


r/FanFiction • • Oct 10 '21

Venting "I don't like anyone criticizing my work." Well, I'm sorry dear author, welcome to the internet.

15 Upvotes

I get that many people cannot handle negativity really well. It can also be tricky to differentiate hateful versus critical comments on a written format. However, if you cannot even handle a little bit of criticism from your readers, you may not be prepared in posting your work online at all.

I had an experience wherein a reader commented everything that they want to happen in the story. It's alright for me if it was just a general comment like "I want X to be with Y in the end". A comment, nothing more. But this person posted every single detail from beginning to end. It was almost an entire chapter itself, and I ignored it because it does not matter to me.

Every comment, whether positive or negative, has something in them that you can use to impove your work. Sometimes, it is even gratifying that someone can point out your mistakes as you can use it to make your writing better. If it is too hateful, then you can always ignore or delete.

However, if you post something along the lines of "I cannot accept any criticism of my work", then I think that you are still too immature and fragile to be on any online platform. Work on your story in private, this way you can still think of yourself as the best writer in the world and no one can tell you otherwise.

Note: I'm sorry if I sound like all fanfic writers should have expert level writing skills. No one is obligated to improve as fanfiction writing is free. However, if you ask for feedback, then get angry when there is a negative feedback, then there might be a problem there.

Note 2, Electric Boogaloo: Oooh I'm getting downvoted! I'm losing all of my internet points hehe

But seriously thanks, I'm starting to see that I may have some opinions that irked some people here seeing all the downvotes. However, I did put my thoughts in this platform expecting every single kind of response so it kinda proves my point. Well, kinda.

I get that receiving input without asking is annoying, and commenters can get harsh about their "critiques" regarding your technically free work. However, If you are going to ask for feedback, you need to prepare yourself as not all of them will be kind.

On the other hand, if you did not ask for any kind of feedback, then you can ignore, delete and continue doing your work.

Note 3: comment reads: "No one gives a shit about what you think" Point taken.


r/FanFiction • • May 26 '24

Discussion New OTW/Ao3 comment moderation policy

0 Upvotes

The details can be found here OTW News Post—Moderation Policy.

But the news post is basically OTW announcing stronger comment moderators policy. Quoting the original post:

In recent months, we have developed a News Post Moderation policy and recruited a team of volunteers who you may see commenting on posts in the future. We would like to announce the key points of the policies our News Post Moderators will be following when monitoring the comment sections of our News Posts.

Comments on news posts may be frozen or hidden by a News Post Moderator if they contain:

Spam or unsolicited advertising

Content about topics outside of fans, fandom, and Internet policy, and which would not fall under the purview of the OTW

Misinformation (particularly about the OTW) with the potential to harm or mislead others

Explicit/graphic sexual or violent language

Attempts to draw negative attention to a specific individual or fanwork

Insults and personal attacks towards other users

Inflammatory or speculative language that may result in harassment

Violations of the site’s Terms of Service

Please note that the above is not an exhaustive list of all comments that may be actioned.


r/FanFiction • • Apr 21 '25

Discussion Fanfic tags

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one that feels like the tags spoil the entire fanfic. Like, what do you mean "major character death" don't tell me that, I need to figure that out on my own. AT THE END OF THE STORY!!!


r/FanFiction • • Jan 18 '23

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Male Characters are too similar in fanfics

1 Upvotes

This is my first post and it is going to be controversial. Sorry if this offends anyone.

When I read fanfics on fanfiction.net, ao3, and Wattpad (especially Wattpad, no offense to the platform), the male character in heterosexual fics are very similar. Even the characters in the canon itself can be very different, but writers tend to write them as the same "good guy" during romances. They are entirely lacking in personality when it comes to love. IMO there are so many different types of good guys. Instead of writing them all in the expressive, lovey-dovey, super-caring style, the male characters should be more diverse.

Just my personal opinion. Correct me if I'm just reading low-quality fanfics.


r/FanFiction • • Jan 17 '23

Discussion Is AO3 dying?

3 Upvotes

I'm being a bit sarcastic, due to the periodic 'FFN is dying' posts that seem to pop up every couple of weeks or so...

History has been screwed up for more than a week, e-mail notifications have had problems and apparently the search is also having errors. What's going on with AO3?

Is it the Russians? ;)


r/FanFiction • • Jul 20 '26

Resources Where to Write that Doesn't Feed Into AI? (NOT ASKING WHERE TO POST)

0 Upvotes

Google Docs feeds writing into AI, and I don't trust Google in general, so where else can I write so that it won't be used for AI? (Please only answer if you're informed on your recommendation and have read the TOS of the rec before, because how would you know to trust it if you hadn't?)


Edit: When I asked this question, I was looking for answers instead of, "Your question is pointless. Why are you asking?" type of replies. But since a few people insist to do so anyway, I'll answer. As I have already said, I don't trust Google in general. The thought of them currently feeding my work into AI isn't the only reason why I'm here. It's already known that Google collects information from whatever Google services you use. Whether they're directly scraping my work into AI or not, idk. Whether they're doing it at all, idk but probably. (If not now, then later. Let's not pretend Google isn't sketchy.) Whether they're gathering information from my work AT ALL, I do know, and I don't like that.

And I don't know how exactly AI training works, but unless you're saying that everything uploaded to a fanfic website is automatically being fed into AI, I don't care about "It's going to be fed into AI anyway once it's posted," because it's not that simple.


r/FanFiction • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion How come most fanfiction is gay but a very large portion of popular published books are straight?

0 Upvotes

I am queer, and I mostly read queer books, but there are so few compared to straight books. But on ao3, I have never faced this problem. Most of the stuff on ao3 is m/m. It is my understanding that the major consumers of both fan fiction and published romance novels are straight women. I get why straight women love to read and write m/m fics, but why is that sentiment not extended to novels?