I love fanfics and theories. However, I cringe whenever I see posts on social media specifially tagging the people involved in the creation of the work its based on with their fanfics and ideas. It turns out, it's a terrible thing to do and will might actually make it impossible for those ideas to happen.
Neil Gaiman, the probably the most prominent author remaining on the hellsite that is Tumblr, posts about this topic several times this week after receiving fanfic links from fans.
--
First post from December 17:
If you send me an ask containing links to Good Omens fan fiction you think I should read, I'll delete it. Do it again and I'll (regretfully) block you. This is a general blanket sort of thing -- I don't want to read it, legally I can't read it, no I won't make it into the next series, and, no matter how pure your motives, it's crossing a line.
Second post today, December 19
I’m reading a lot of baffled responses to this. People, I’m showrunning and co-writing the Good Omens TV series. I can’t legally read unsolicited plot ideas. Think of Netflix. Their terms of service include:
8.2. Unsolicited Materials. Netflix does not accept unsolicited materials or ideas for Netflix content and is not responsible for the similarity of any of its content or programming in any media to materials or ideas transmitted to Netflix.
…and you’ll find similar clauses out there for other production entities. They are trying to safeguard themselves. There are people out there who are certain that a hit film or TV series is based on their stolen idea. The easiest way to avoid that is to make sure that their ideas can’t get to you.
It’s nothing to do with not approving of what you do. It’s about not putting me, the producers, the BBC or Prime Video at risk — or about having to throw away plans for the future because someone did that in fanfiction first. I can’t legally read unsolicited scripts or story proposals or manuscripts and sending me a link to your or someone else’s Good Omens fiction counts as those things. If I read your story and then did something close to it you could sue. So I’m not going to read it. There’s no emotional baggage in this. I’m definitely not telling you that what you are doing isn’t valid. (And If I wasn’t showrunning I wouldn’t be so Please Don’t and I Will Delete about it. But I am. So don’t. Thank you!)
-- There's also a story and an article shared by a Tumblr user regarding Babylon 5 that Neil reblogged that's relevant to this topic.
A plot point in one of the episodes was very similar to an idea shared in the Usenet discussion list that creator, J. Michael Starczynski, used to be active in. The episode had to put on hold as they need to have the person who pitched the idea sign the necessary paperwork stating that they will not sue the show. Production had apparently started on the show even before the idea was shared but because the creator had come across during the production process, they need paperwork signed. J. Michael Starczynski has since posted on Twitter that he will be blocking people on Twitter sending him ideas as the show is now being rebooted.
TLDR: Do not send unsolicited fanfics and ideas to the people involved in the creation of the work its based on. They will just ignore it to protect themselves from being sued if the idea happens to match the plot they already have in production.
Edit to add: Don't do this as well to people whose works are already finished. They may have a specific reason for that ending and we, as fans, just have to accept that. We can try to fix it through fanfics but never share them with the author. Anne Proulx, author of the short story Brokeback Mountain that eventually became an award-winning movie, ended up hating her work after receiving fanfics in the mail from people who rewrite the ending to a happy one.