This post discusses FFRK's different healers, comparing them to one another and discussing their niches. Note that mainly offensive white mages (Minwu, Arc, Rem) are not included here, nor are units that are primarily support who can also heal (Mog, Cait Sith, Orran). The rankings are based upon currently available tech in Global.
Understanding the characteristics of each healer is very important to high-level play. In Magicite you'll generally pick the best available healer for the niche you need, while in Cardia the realm's healer has a huge effect on the supports and general strategies available to you.
Within each tier, the healers are listed from best to worst, however, this is extremely approximate, as healers within the same tier are mostly of similar value.
S Tier
These healers are the best healers overall in FFRK.
Elarra
Elarra being up here should surprise no one. While there are healers who can provide more raw healing (most of the Wrath healers in particular), no healer matches Elarra's utility while still healing competently. She is able to use both Bard and Dancer, and her USBs and AASB all give excellent utility. She's the best utility from the healer spot in a "generic" physical team thanks to the rare critical damage buff from her USB2, and she's excellent for mage teams as well with Bard and Dancer. Elarra can even generate gauge passably enough by using a Summon of the proper element, though it's nowhere near as good as the Wrath healers.
Fina
Now here's a surprising choice. While many other healers can provide more utility than Fina can, no one matches her sheer healing power. You see, unlike most other healers, Fina's AASB and Sync both work with Wrath. While this is mostly trivia for Sync (Wrath doesn't provide extra gauge when used as a chase), being able to spam Wrath under AASB and still get the heal chase is massive, very quickly getting Fina to six bars. This, in turn, lets her abuse her 75% damage reduction barrier from USB. While USB only provides HQC1, the Brave command gives another HQC1 at level 3, allowing her to compete with most other healers' QC.
Fina's only downside is, as mentioned, the lack of utility. This is relatively minor, since she heals so well and most teams for modern content carry a support as well, but it's something to keep in mind.
A Tier
These are the other high-end healers. They're not quite good enough to go in S tier, but all of these girls serve very well in their niches.
Deuce
Deuce is an excellent healer who's similar to Elarra in many ways. However, there are three major factors keeping her from reaching S-tier like the little girl in pink. First, Deuce does not have access to crit damage like Elarra does. While obviously not mattering in mage teams, this means that she will never be as good as Elarra in physical teams. Second, Deuce cannot use Dancer or Summons. The latter isn't terribly important these days, but having Dance access would provide her with very valuable utility. Finally, Deuce AASB only chases with Stoneskin. This means that Deuce must rely on White Magic, LMR procs, or other SBs to keep from dying when Stoneskin pops. Stoneskin reliance itself is a double-edged sword; it is generally superior to standard heal chases and Stock against opponents that like to spam Anti-Heal (think Argent Odin), but against other bosses it can become problematic, especially if proc RNG is bad.
Penelo
The Rabanastre dancing queen is by far the best dancing healer. Not only do dances provide excellent debuffing, Penelo's HA lets her buff extremely well, especially in mixed teams. In addition, Penelo is on par with the Wrath healers (only clearly beaten by Fina) in the sheer healing department. Both HA and Passionate Salsa heal a small amount of HP on use, but the real beauty here is the interaction between her LM2, USB2, and AASB. With all three active, not only will you have a 40% damage reduction barrier every turn, you'll also be healed to full most of the time, since LM2's heal can proc off the original dance, the USB2 chase, or the AASB damage reduction barrier chase. That's three different opportunities to throw in an extra heal, and she can do so multiple times (and, due to the higher proc rate of an LM2 compared to LMRs, she will often do so two or three times). A similar effect occurs with her Sync--both the Sync command and the Dance chase can trigger the extra heal.
Penelo's main downside is that she can only provide IC1, which is weaker than the HQC2/3 that most other healers get (if she had HQC2 she would be S tier). Dancer also doesn't provide Allegro access in particular, which means you'll want it from your support if you're running mages (enter Orran/Cait/Edward/Mog).
Vanille
Vanille's only reason for being here is her Sync. Her AASB is just decent (it works on Support but the heal chase is stuck at a weak 25) and her USBs are not great, but her Sync is amazing. For the 15 seconds it's active, Vanille Sync lets her spam HQC1 to the party while still chasing with an AoE heal from her HA. This is amazing for offense, but the relatively poor defense (both AASB and Sync effectively limit you to a small heal every turn) plus the lack of buffing and debuffing are what keep Vanille from being ranked higher.
B Tier
B tier represents the upper echelon of the "average" healers--those good enough not to be in D tier but not good enough for A or S.
Sarah
Sarah is another bard healer, similar to Elarra and Deuce, meaning she can give much of the utility those two can. However, Sarah's Ultras are poorer than Elarra's and Deuce's. She doesn't get the critical damage buff of Elarra USB2 or the healing chase of Deuce USB3, instead getting minor buffs if Warrior of Light or Garland is in the party, or else a Brave command. Also, her party QC is on USB4 (QC3), which many people don't have and is not available in Anima.
Aria
Yet another Bard healer, Aria ends up as a slightly weaker version of Sarah in practice. Her AASB trades a standard scaling heal chase for Stock, which is a losing trade in most cases. Also, unlike Elarra, Deuce, and Sarah, Aria's LMs all trigger off White Magic, not Bard. Since using Bard abilities is generally better than using White Magic, this is not a positive, especially on a healer limited to Stock on her AASB. Her USB2 is also worse than Elarra USB1, Deuce USB3, and Sarah USB4, because of only providing IC1 instead of multiple QC turns. That being said, however, Aria will always be solid enough due to the simple fact that Bard provides great utility.
Hilda
Hilda is another healer who's here almost solely because of her Bard access. Hilda leans heavily towards physical defense--her USB1 gives a 100% DEF buff while USB2 and AASB both give physical blinks, which is probably not worth the tradeoff. Her AASB is damage reduction barrier when using White Magic and Bard abilities. However, it doesn't enjoy the same synergy with her LMs or other relics that Penelo's does. She doesn't have a heal chase USB, and her LM2 can only proc off the initial Bard ability, not the barrier chase or White Magic abilities, so chances are that Hilda will need to use a USB at some point during her AASB to avoid running out of HP. That being said, she's in a DB realm that does a ton of raw damage, and Bard ensures she can never drop down to the lower tiers.
Alma
The only reason Alma's here is because her new USB3 allows her to spam a 50% damage reduction plus HQC2 to the party. Most of the rest of her kit revolves around "party-starter" buffs, though Sync has an interesting gimmick allowing you to cast damage reduction barriers every third turn. Alma's big drawback is her lack of ability access--she can't access Support, Bard, or Dancer at all, something all of the other healers in B tier and above have and all of which provide major utility over just White Magic.
Lenna
Lenna is a healer who can be rather awkward to use, though effective. Her main value is offsetting Anti-Heal, which is becoming more and more popular (Azulmagia is famous for reducing heals to one for example). AASB1 can blink almost any attack, even ones that are normally unblinkable like Bahamut's nukes (though not a maxed-out Megaflare), while AASB2 chases with Stock. Sync, meanwhile, subtracts Anti-Heal levels from the party (or adds healing levels if you're not under Anti-Heal). For all that nifty-ness, Lenna is simply not easy to use. Her only spammable Last Stands are on either a non-instant USB or a Level 3 Brave command, meaning you need to plan ahead to keep it up. Also, AASB1 does not trigger off Dancer, while AASB2 doesn't provide self Quick Cast (it gives dualcast instead), limiting their value.
Larsa
Larsa is a weird case. He's one of the best Astra sources in the game and can use Wrath, but he has serious issues dealing with raw damage. Both USB2 and AASB have trash heal chases (USB2 for 1,000 and AASB for 1,500), though USB3 does provide the rare critical damage buff (only Elarra has that among other healers). Because of how much damage modern contents do, most players prefer to use another healer and deal with status attacks in other ways, but Larsa is always an option you can consider.
C Tier
Here we come to the basic healers. These healers are average--nothing special, but not terrible either.
Relm
Long a favorite of many Keepers, in the modern meta Relm is simply average, maybe slightly above average. Her calling card is Wrath-able Stoneskin alongside a very solid (though fairly standard) healing kit. Her lack of other utility can be a serious problem, however, and Deuce has a much easier time maintaining Stoneskin than Relm does (Deuce gets it from her AASB chase).
Y'shtola
Y'shtola is another Wrath healer, who has a magical Aerith clone (mHQC3 on USB2). She ends up much better than Aerith, however, because of Wrath and the fact that she can give herself quickcast without AASB1. AASB1, while we're on the topic, can grant 70% Stoneskin every turn while dualcasting White Magic abilities under self HQC, which is a very potent combination. However, she's only viable on mage teams due to lacking any way to give QC/IC to physical characters.
Rosa
Most famous for being the first Elarra USB1 clone, Rosa has it alongside Wrath. However, Rosa can't compete with Elarra in terms of utility, and most of the rest of Rosa's kit focuses on magic blink while other healers have gotten close Elarra USB1 cousins. All this together means Rosa hasn't aged well, but a Wrathable Elarra clone will never truly be bad.
D Tier
These healers are below average, though not so bad as to wind up in the cellar of the tier list. You probably should not use any of these healers outside their realm contents.
Aphmau
Aphamu, one of the original IC1 healers, checks in here. Simply put, her kit isn't overly impressive. Her USB1 is almost a straight downgrade from Relm's (and she can't Wrath), and AASB is a stock chase on top of a standard entry. Most likely, you won't use her outside of XI content.
Iris
Remember how I said that Deuce suffers from her AASB only providing Stoneskin, often requiring you to use a USB during AASB time? Iris has it much, much worse. Instead of Stoneskin, Iris AASB gives 40% damage reduction, and she doesn't have any sort of heal chase LM. This is bad news, even moreso on a character without Support or spammable Last Stand access. Furthermore, she can only provide reusable QC to physical teams (though thankfully XV is almost entirely physical). This amounts to a rather poor healer overall.
Aerith
One of the original HQC healers alongside Elarra, Aerith has gotten much worse over time. She is a Last Stand healer who has no way of dealing with sap, and is utterly useless outside of physical teams. What's more, the only way she can give herself QC is with AASB, which is single use (and no, it's not worth honing). In fact, Aerith is so bad that she even struggles to solo heal Bahamut in a sub 30s setup. Outside of VII Cardia, do yourself a favor, let SPOILER: and use someone else.
Porom
Oof. Porom is almost entirely limited to mage teams, and has a very crappy kit for a healer who can only use White Magic. USB2 has a heal chase, but unlike Deuce's it's every other turn, making it far less viable as a mode of survival. Her bUSB does give 50% damage reduction barrier, but with only WHM access Porom has trouble getting enough gauge and the Brave command is ass. Given that Porom AASB is a stock chase, which is a major problem for someone who can't generate gauge quickly, you'll probably only use her if you have her AASB but not Rosa's.
Tama
And now we come to the the-fox. Tama is a weird mage hybrid who's not particularly good at anything. AASB2 does have the same HQC spam Vanille's does, but unlike Vanille he can't heal the-well enough for this to be useful and he doesn't have Wrath either. USB2 is also a rare Astra on a healer, but Larsa is better at it in every way. Save yourself the trouble and use the-someone else.
F tier
And now we come to the truly bad ones.
Yuna
Yuna is just as bad a healer as the others in this tier (really confused kit and not particularly potent), but unlike the others here she can at least function passably as a DPS. AASB1 is the "canon" Yuna--she will attack with Summons while chasing with a nice heal, but AASB2 is a lot better (full buff to overwrite DB/Bahamut BS along with a bar refunded). Her USBs are where her problems are. She has a flaw that's repeated over and over in these bottom tiers: she has a number of nice effects, but they're all spread out across her USBs. In X Cardia you have little choice but to use her, and she does get a lot better with her AASBs, but that doesn't stop her from being a hot mess.
Eiko
Eiko is very similar in most respects to Yuna, except that she's not an effective damage dealer in any way. AASB1 is very similar to Yuna's, but Eiko is stuck with Wind and her HA is much weaker than Yuna's while still not being effective at healing. With her USBs, meanwhile, her good stuff is too spread out across her USBs for her to be effective--she simply can't get enough gauge.
Selphie Tier
You knew this was coming.
Selphie
Oof. Selphie's USBs aren't too terrible (USB3 in particular grants damage reduction barrier), but they're not amazing either and she has one of the worst healer AASBs in the game. AASB shoehorns her into using a school (Dancer) which can't heal, while just spamming DRB. Penelo's does that too, but Penelo AASB has better entry effects, Penelo USB2 is on lenses (Selphie USB3 isn't), and Penelo's LM2 has a higher proc rate than Selphie LMR2, and doesn't cost lenses. Without USB3 (which is likely most Keepers), Selphie is the worst regular realm healer in the game and it's not even close.
Aemo
Utterly forgotten by the devs, Aemo is the worst healer in the game bar none. She has no instant-cast SBs at all (even USB has 2.5s CT), no AASB+, no nothing, just Astra on her USB. Hey, someone had to be worse than Selphie.