r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 27 '22

Are Some Evolutionary Creationists affirm The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy and they view Adam and Eve were historical figures are still christians

1 Upvotes

So if you one of those people please step up and if you speak or not because I'll be there with your side or should I say I'm in your side.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 23 '22

Q&A [Q&A] If Adam and Eve were not the first humans, where does the Bible mention other humans?

1 Upvotes

The Bible doesn't say anything about whether or not other people existed. It is silent on that question—as we should expect it to be, for the Bible doesn't mention anybody unless and until they have some kind of interaction with God's people. For example, the Bible never mentions the Japanese even though they existed throughout the historical period that the Bible covers, from the end of the Neolithic (Adam and Eve) to the dawn of ancient Rome (the disciple John). There are only two kinds of people mentioned in the Bible: God's people and those who had some kind of interaction with them (e.g., Canaanites). It never mentions any other kind of people (e.g., Scandinavians), even though we know they existed.

The first time the existence of other people is suggested in the Bible is when Cain is banished from the community of God (Gen. 4:10-12). He went and lived "in the land of Nod" east of Eden (v. 16) where he now had a wife and produced a family, where there were enough people for a walled city (v. 17). There is also the fact that Cain was worried that "whoever finds me will kill me" (v. 14). Notice that he's not talking about his family but rather "whoever" (כּל, kôl). As I understand it, he's not worried about revenge from his family so much as no longer belonging to God's protected community. He is being exiled. He's not worried about staying, he's worried about leaving. So, God reassures him that divine protection will follow him in exile (v. 15).


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Dec 05 '25

Evolutionary science/cognition

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I hope you’re doing well. I’m looking to connect with researchers or professionals working in evolutionary psychology or evolutionary cognition. I would really appreciate the opportunity to discuss some ideas and learn from your perspectives.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Sep 09 '22

Scripture and nature: An autobiographical introspective

3 Upvotes

What strikes us at once, trained as we are in the language of science, is the immediateness with which everything is ascribed to God. He makes the grass to grow upon the mountains. To him the young ravens look up for food. He holds the winds in the hollow of his hand. Not a sparrow falls without his knowledge. He numbers the hairs of our head. Of bird and beast and flower, no less than of man, it is true that in him they "live and move and have their being." O Lord, how glorious are thy works! For the Christian theologian, the facts of nature are the acts of God.

— Aubrey L. Moore, Science and Faith: Essays on Apologetic Subjects, 6th ed. (1889; London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co., 1905), 226.

I expect that this will probably make sense only to those who are (or were) evangelical Christians, especially those who were raised with a fundamentalist biblical world-view, but I have to admit something awkward here that might seem a little strange to almost everyone else:

  • For most of my Christian life I have been deeply suspicious and even frightened of evolution and those who are willing to embrace the theory.

I understand that this may seem a little bit strange to most people, which is why I said that evangelical Christians would probably be the only ones capable of relating. Through many years of religious prejudice I was methodically conditioned to look at evolution as a diabolic enemy of the faith, threatening the integrity and harmony of the biblical witness. It is a godless theory, I was told, one that leads inexorably to a rejection of Scripture and ultimately the loss of salvation. There were times when I would dare to leaf through a book that explains or advocates the theory and science of evolution and I would suddenly feel dirty and guilty, like I was doing something horribly wrong.

From this biographical confession it is almost predictable that the formative years of my Christian faith were carefully and thoroughly shaped by young-earth creationist beliefs and values, which were derived from both personal and academic sources. Over the course of several years I digested a wealth of creationist arguments and teaching with passionate interest and enthusiastically defended it against anyone who proposed any compromise with the godless forces of evolution. If I understood anything about evolution (and I honestly didn’t), it was through the instruction that I had received from creationist literature, the honesty and accuracy of which I implicitly trusted. I had been consistently informed by this material, again and again, that unbelievers were pleased to embrace and advance Darwinian evolution because their darkened hearts were driven by motivations and commitments that were antithetical to the Bible and opposed to God as creator. Their purpose was to undermine the authority of God's word and shipwreck the Christian faith. It was abundantly clear to me that they could not and must never be trusted.

And it was not just the secular humanists that I could not trust. There were even some Christians who were ostensibly conservative evangelicals and yet even these men had compromised infallible Scripture with extra-biblical influences that did not respect God's holy word. I was warned against such men as Charles Hodge, B. B. Warfield, James Montgomery Boice and others whose acceptance of an old Earth had opened the door to compromise and this, I was warned, was how the project of undermining biblical authority really began in earnest. (I would later discover that such men as these were champions of biblical inerrancy and pillars of theological orthodoxy, so just now I was chuckling as I wrote that sentence.) It was unmistakable that the conflict was grave and the stakes were high, with implications that reached as far as the truth of God. [1]

Can you appreciate why I was so frightened? This evolution business was nothing short of an open and brazen assault against God and his Word—and the church has a sacred duty to guard and contend for the faith once for all delivered to the saints. I knew where I would stand. As Joshua said, "As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord," and by the grace of God I will stand firm. Satan has been attempting to deceive the children of God since the very beginning, tempting us to question God as if he is obligated to answer us. "Did God actually say?" Yes, he did—and God remains true even if all others are liars (Rom. 3:4).

Even right now, at this very moment as I sit here and write, a trace of that fear continues to linger. And that is a good thing, in my opinion, because it acts as a restraint. In everything I contemplate and study I am constantly mindful of the biblical and theological consequences, always striving to make sure that everything coheres with an evangelical commitment to the authority of God's word, the only infallible rule of faith and life. Every conclusion that I reach must ultimately cohere with the Bible, the truth of God upon which rests my entire world-view. Inasmuch as wisdom consists in the fear of the Lord and understanding consists in turning away from evil, [2] it continues to be my embattled desire to maintain a solemn reverence for the things of God and to abide in his Word.

I understand that this remnant fear which continues to linger regarding evolution—my fears tend to resist submitting to the grace of God and trusting his covenant promises—is just a byproduct of the destructive attacks launched by certain Christian organizations against fellow believers who are "foolish" enough to explore the relevant science honestly and openly. These attacks usually consist of unjustly characterizing the faith of such believers as weak and compromised. That strikes me as utterly contrary to what the Bible says about how the family of God ought to treat one another, particularly when the target of that attack is vulnerable or sensitive, such as a new convert to the family of God in Christ. Not only that but people tend to have a kind of sensitive awareness within their own social contexts, coupled to a typical and often strong desire for fellowship, which results in obvious hurt when members of their own community turn on them or ostracize them, especially when it is for no good reason or regards something that is false.

We pause now for a word of clarification. When it comes to the covenant community of faith, those feelings of hurt are legitimate if, and only if, there is no good reason for the opposition. Given that the church has this duty to guard and contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints (Jude 1:3), it simply must turn against that which jeopardizes the faith, a thing called "heresy." According to one historian, the church has always regarded as heresy any doctrine that is "sufficiently intolerable to destroy the unity of the Christian church. In the early church, heresy did not refer to simply any doctrinal disagreement, but to something that seemed to undercut the very basis for Christian existence." [3] What I mean to say is that heresy constitutes a good reason for opposition. If it hurts that the church is turning against some heretical view that you are advocating, maybe you need to re-evaluate your reaction because the church is simply doing its job. I am a strong advocate of the church's effort to expose and undermine heresy for the sake of Christ and the gospel of his salvation in Scripture. That is, then, the perennial and ever-relevant question: Is this or that belief heretical? That is, does it undercut or destroy the gospel of Christ that unifies his church?

That raises another good question. What if you are a mature Christian who is an accountable member in good standing within a covenant community with a strong commitment to the truth and integrity of the biblical faith, particularly the gospel of Christ passed down from the apostles and contained in Scripture, which you receive and obey as the authoritative and infallible written word of God? If all of these things are true about you and yet you're still being attacked by fellow believers, then it must be for no good reason. [4] I can attest from my own experiences that sometimes those attacks are leveled against beliefs I don't even hold—attacking a caricature that is weaker than or entirely different from what I actually believe [5]—or they center on some non-essential doctrine, or they are based upon some human authority or tradition which cannot bind the conscience at any rate. In cases like these the attacks are unwarranted and may even be sinful, requiring us to extend grace and forgiveness.

And so I press onward despite the remaining bits of fear because I am confident of the integrity of my biblical faith and world-view. I know that the foundation upon which I stand is solid and unshakable, the sure word of God set down in Scripture. It is from this firm foundation that I seek to explore and understand the natural world, knowing that it is the comprehensible creation of the only sovereign God whose covenant promises are as trustworthy as the regular patterns of nature: "But I, the Lord, make the following promise: I have made a covenant governing the coming of day and night. I have established the fixed laws governing heaven and earth. Just as surely as I have done this, so surely will I never reject the descendants of Jacob" (Jer. 33:25-26). We worship a mighty God who sustains all of creation moment by moment with a providential hand of grace, such that not even a sparrow will fall to the ground apart from our Father (Matt. 10:29). The rain, the wind, the snow, the growing grass, seed time and harvest, the rise and fall of nations, no corner of the universe is autonomous or exists apart from God’s power and presence. Indeed, the facts of nature are the acts of God.

As the Belgic Confession explains in Article 2, God makes himself known through two books of infallible authority, namely, nature and Scripture. The universe, by its creation, preservation, and government, "is before our eyes as a most elegant book, wherein all creatures, great and small, are as so many characters leading us to contemplate the invisible things of God, namely, his eternal power and divinity," a host of things which "are sufficient to convince men and leave them without excuse." The Bible, of course, is the most obvious of the two books, "his holy and divine word" whereby "he makes himself more clearly and fully known to us" through the intricate narrative threads of redemptive history that bear witness to the Son. In the Reformed tradition we recognize that "in both creation and Scripture God addresses us with full authority." The Dutch theologian Cornelius Van Til put it this way:

Saving grace is not manifest in nature; yet it is the God of saving grace who manifests himself by means of nature. How can these two be harmonized? ... Herein precisely lies the union of the various forms of God's revelation with one another. God's revelation in nature, together with God's revelation in Scripture, form God's one grand scheme of covenant revelation of himself to man. The two forms of revelation must therefore be seen as presupposing and supplementing one another. [6]

Accordingly, natural revelation is from the outset incorporated into the idea of a covenantal relationship, for all of creation has always been through Christ and for him—from the heavens to the earth, whether visible or invisible, whether thrones or dominions, whether principalities or powers. He is the beginning. In other words, Christ—his incarnation, atonement, and resurrection—has been the purpose of creation from the beginning. It has never been about us. All things, including us, have always been about Christ, "that in everything he might be preeminent," he who is the true image, the true Israel, the true Son, all for the glory of God. So natural history is necessarily folded into redemptive history. Alexei Nesteruk put it this way, that "nature cannot be an end in itself; its meaning and purpose can only be revealed in the perspective of Christ who, through the incarnation, recapitulated nature." [7] (Nature as cruciform is something that I love explaining to my children through such examples as first generation stars having to live and die in order to fill the universe with the sort of elements required for life, such as carbon. In other words, a sun had to die in order for us to live.)

As I understand it, there are two types of history disclosed through both Scripture and nature, held in a balance that ultimately points to Christ, and they are natural history and redemptive history. Indeed, they are not at once both the same thing, but their Christ-centered balance should unfold like this: Natural history is a matter of general revelation (interpreted using natural science), the meaning and purpose of which is found in redemptive history disclosed through special revelation (interpreted using exegetical theology). Apart from the latter, the former is incomplete and easily misunderstood by spiritually disoriented human beings who are out of communion with God in Christ. As unredeemed sinners we fail to apprehend the unity of the whole creation and our priestly responsibility in Christ as stewards of nature.

  • Scripture is written in the language of redemptive history and covenant theology, not natural history and modern science.


References:

[1] One may observe such allegations still being made in creationist literature, such as The New Answers Book series edited by Ken Ham. See for example the chapter by Ken Ham, "Couldn't God Have Used Evolution?" in The New Answers Book 1, ed. Ken Ham (Green Forest, AR: Master Books, 2006), 35.

[2] "The fear of God is linked to wisdom (Ps. 111:10; Prov. 9:10; 15:33) and is part of the covenant between God and his people (Ps. 25:14; 103:17–18). To fear God is to be in awe and reverence of him (Ps. 33:8; Mal. 2:5 RSV) and to trust him (Ps. 40:3; 115:11). Fearing God means hating and avoiding evil (Prov. 8:13; 16:6)." Leland Ryken, James C. Wilhoit, and Tremper Longman III, eds., Dictionary of Biblical Imagery (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1998), 277.

[3] Harold O. J. Brown, Heresies: The Image of Christ in the Mirror of Heresy and Orthodoxy from the Apostles to the Present (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1984), 2.

[4] Keep in mind, too, that there is an important difference between being unfairly "attacked" and being graciously "corrected." I am not talking about the latter.

[5] Being adequately instructed in critical thinking allows you to recognize these as "strawman" arguments. They attack a view that is barely similar to yours, if at all, being either weaker than or entirely different from your actual view.

[6] This is from a printed PDF document which did not correlate page numbers. The original article was published as Cornelius Van Til, "Nature and Scripture," in The Infallible Word – A Symposium, by the members of the faculty of Westminster Theological Seminary (Philadelphia, PA: Presbyterian Guardian Publishing Corp., 1946), 255–293. Emphasis mine.

[7] Alexei Nesteruk, "Orthodox Christianity – Issues in Science and Religion," in Encyclopedia of Science and Religion, ed. J. Wentzel Vrede van Huyssteen, 2nd ed. (New York: Macmillan Reference USA, 2003), 130.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • May 17 '25

Fungus' role in evolution and earth overwhelms me and my concept of god, any advice, opinion/knowledge to share?

1 Upvotes

I believe in a God for many reasons but one of the main ones is I feel him/it when I focus on Earth and see that everything is connected. I'm not sure what "god" is yet? but to me it feels like this overwhelming energy of love in everything.

I want to believe in life after death, the calmness, peace and stoicism of the religious people I know is something I think is routed in their belief (this also makes sense when you reference rastafairis and such). I think here I'm just getting doubt about life after death, not god, because it feels like almost everything I see god in is related to fungus.

For example in Evolution, Prototaxities likely shaped the environment for trees to evolve and fungus evolved before plants, and plants use it to communicate. I've also taken mushrooms and had that thought that it just feels like proof god is real, but what if this higher consciousness I see on earth is just rooted in fungus? meaning I have this scary thought that maybe that's all it is and the soul and spirit are just things relating to special bacteria, when I die I will become soil but that's all I will be, a few shrubs and soil, no heaven exists, which is still beautiful but I feel pretty sad thinking about it.

fyi- christianity makes sense to me the most out of all religions and just for reference I'm not going through spiritual psychosis or anything I just don't think about these things enough, I'm just lost and want to hear opinions. P.s I don't know that much about evolution so there might be some education missing!


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Jun 10 '21

Quotes Quotes: Augustine, on interpreting scripture vis-a-vis our knowledge of nature

4 Upvotes

Usually, even a non-Christian knows something about the earth, the heavens, and the other elements of this world, about the motion and orbit of the stars and even their size and relative positions, about the predictable eclipses of the sun and moon, the cycles of the years and the seasons, about the kinds of animals, shrubs, stones, and so forth, and this knowledge he holds to as being certain from reason and experience.

Now, it is a disgraceful and dangerous thing for an [unbeliever] to hear a Christian, presumably giving the meaning of Holy Scripture, talking nonsense on these topics; and we should take all means to prevent such an embarrassing situation, in which people show up vast ignorance in a Christian and laugh it to scorn. The shame is not so much that an ignorant individual is derided, but that people outside the household of the faith think our sacred writers held such opinions, and, to the great loss of those for whose salvation we toil, the writers of our Scripture are criticized and rejected as unlearned men. If they find a Christian mistaken in a field which they themselves know well and hear him maintaining his foolish opinions about our books, how are they going to believe those books in matters concerning the resurrection of the dead, the hope of eternal life, and the kingdom of heaven, when they think their pages are full of falsehoods on facts which they themselves have learnt from experience and the light of reason? Reckless and incompetent expounders of holy Scripture bring untold trouble and sorrow on their wiser brethren when they are caught in one of their mischievous false opinions and are taken to task by those who are not bound by the authority of our sacred books. For then, to defend their utterly foolish and obviously untrue statements, they will try to call upon Holy Scripture for proof and even recite from memory many passages which they think support their position, although "they understand neither what they say nor the things about which they make assertion." [1 Timothy 1:7]

Aurelius Augustinus, De Genesi ad litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), bk. 1, ch. 19, para. 39 (written ca. 401-405 AD). See: John Hammond Taylor, trans., Ancient Christian Writers: St. Augustine - The Literal Meaning of Genesis, vol. 1 (New York: Paulist Press, 1982). View this passage at the Interdisciplinary Encyclopedia of Religion and Science here.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Jun 22 '21

Discussion An attempt to prove that evolutionary creationism is delusional

7 Upvotes

Over at the subreddit r/DebateEvolution, a user who goes by u/HorrorShow13666 published an original post (OP) in which he intended to demonstrate that creationism is at once both delusional and a failed scientific hypothesis ("Why I believe creationism is delusional and no longer valid as a scientific hypothesis," June 21, 2021). Relevant to this subreddit here, he was including evolutionary creationism in that decisive conclusion, which quite naturally piqued my interest. So, I had a go with him, a discussion which starts here. I invite members here to give it a read, as it produced a lot of interesting material.

At the end of the day, u/HorrorShow13666 was forced to admit that there is no evidence which contradicts evolutionary creationism and, thus, it is not delusional. After I persisted in asking for this contradicting evidence, he finally pointed to "its lack of existence." To this I replied,

Evidence must first exist before it can contradict anything. If you point to "its lack of existence," then I am compelled to ask, "What is contradicting evolutionary creationism?" Nothing, you admit.

Ergo, you have conceded that evolutionary creationism is not delusional.

I'm not surprised, of course, but as a skeptic and critical thinker I do take it seriously when someone alleges that something I believe is delusional. If that's true, I want to know it. In this case, anyhow, the allegation is bankrupt.

Was there anything in that discussion that caught your attention or raised questions for you? If so, I'm probably not the only one who would love to hear it and perhaps explore it further.


Edit: "At the end of the day, u/HorrorShow13666 was forced to admit that there is no evidence which contradicts evolutionary creationism and, thus, it is not delusional." This is a misleading sentence. He was forced to admit there is no evidence that contradicts evolutionary creationism, but he refuses to admit that it's therefore not delusional. He continues to maintain that claim despite its utter lack of evidence.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Feb 10 '21

Why can't Adam and Eve be the first humans?

Thumbnail self.debateevolution
2 Upvotes

r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Aug 07 '21

Question What are your thoughts on Ham, Hovind, and the like?

4 Upvotes

I've been astonished to see the history and science behind evolution now that I'm no longer holding the interpretive lens of a Young Earth Creationist.

This leads me to wonder about the leaders of the YEC movement such as Ken Ham, Hovind, ICR, and CMI. Do you think that they are ideologically committed to their own lens and are simply misinformed about science or do you think they're aware of their faults but sweep it under the rug.

In other words, do you think they are scientifically ignorant or intentionally deceptive to their audience?

final note: I am in no way challenging their status as a follower of Christ nor am I trying to bash on them at all. I'm just curious what others' thoughts are regarding the YEC leaders.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • May 11 '21

Quotes Only indirectly relevant but really worth thinking about.

Thumbnail self.randomthoughts
3 Upvotes

r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 27 '22

Do evolutionary creationists and biologos that believe the genesis narrative flood as historical event.

3 Upvotes

Can you guys please answer this.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • May 01 '21

Quotes Quotes: Aubrey Moore, on the Christian attitude toward knowledge

2 Upvotes

The Christian knows that the acceptance of truth is a moral as well as an intellectual matter, and in the moral world there is no place for laisser faire. He expects to be called upon to struggle; he expects that the struggle will need his utmost effort, moral and intellectual. His work is both to keep and to claim, to hold fast the faith "once for all delivered to the saints," and yet to see in every fragment of truth a real revelation of the mind and will of God. He has no cut and dried answer to objections, he does not boast that he has no difficulties, but he does claim to look out upon the difficulties of his day not only fearlessly but with hope and trust. He knows that Christianity must triumph in the end, but he does not expect all difficulties to be removed in a moment. And he is strong enough, if need be, to wait.

Aubrey L. Moore, "The Christian Doctrine of God," in Charles Goke, ed., Lux Mundi: A Series of Studies in the Religion of the Incarnation, 10th ed. (London: John Murray, 1890), p. 59.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 28 '21

Review/Critique Formed From Dust: A Response to Norman Geisler and Peter Bocchino

5 Upvotes

In their book on Christian apologetics, Unshakable Foundations (2001), Norman Geisler and Peter Bocchino presented a very brief criticism of theistic evolution that rested in part on human origins. They cited the view of James Buzwell Jr. in his Systematic Theology (1962) when they insisted that "human life, as observed, can only be explained as the direct result of a special act of creation such as recorded in the early chapters of the book of Genesis." [1] They were referring specifically to Genesis 2:7 and Buzwell's conclusion on the matter, which was as follows:

The statement of Genesis 2:7, to the effect that "the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground," seems to indicate rather strongly that man's body was formed, not from some previously existing animal, but rather from inorganic material. [2]

So this forming from the dust of the ground, then, is why human origins can be explained "only" as a special act of creation. Trying to understand this within an evolutionary framework is "untenable," Buzwell thought. These gentlemen, Buzwell, Geisler, and Bocchino, seem to think that when the Bible describes Adam being formed from dust it is referring literally to inorganic material, a human-shaped pile of earthen material, and must exclude any "previously existing animal"—including parents (presumably). The Bible is telling us, then, how Adam was different from everyone else; when it says that God formed him from dust, it's indicating a special de novo creation of God.

I can agree that it was special, but I don't believe that it was unique. Their argument begins to fall apart the moment we realize that the Bible is describing not how Adam was different but rather the same as us, [3] for Scripture teaches that every single one of us is made of dust: "For he knows how we are formed, he remembers that we are dust" (Ps. 103:14; cf. Gen. 2:7 with similar wording; see also Job 10:9; 1 Cor. 15:47-48). Moreover, and this is important, every human being is not only made from dust but also from pre-existing creatures we call parents (Ps. 139:13-16). The same is also true of our parents, and even their parents before them, and so on back through the centuries and millennia to the dawn of redemptive history 6,000 years ago. Being formed by God from the dust and being born to parents are not mutually exclusive ideas in Scripture but distinct aspects of the multifaceted truth of being human. Is there any reason to think this doesn't include Adam, as both made of dust and born to parents? I am not aware of any. It is simply not obvious to me why viewing Adam as having parents is an "untenable" position.


Footnotes:

[1] Norman Geisler and Peter Bocchino, Unshakable Foundations: Contemporary Answers to Crucial Questions About the Christian Faith (Minneapolis, MN: Bethany House, 2001), p. 172. Their criticism is actually leveled against theistic evolutionists but they would probably include evolutionary creationists who hold a similar view on human origins. Not all do, of course (e.g., John R. W. Stott), but perhaps enough of them do.

[2] James Buzwell, Jr., A Systematic Theology of the Christian Religion, vol. 1 (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1962), pp. 323-324.

[3] We must recognize that Adam was very different from anyone else with respect to his historical election and archetypal role as the federal head of old humanity in a covenant relationship with God. However, with respect to being formed by God from the dust of the ground and made in his image and likeness, these are things Adam shared in common with everyone else.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Jun 28 '21

Discussion Intelligently designed broken genes?

3 Upvotes

Despite being an evangelical Christian, I cannot support the intelligent design movement and its arguments. There is a host of reasons for this, some of the more crucial ones being theological (and thus biblical). However, a few of those reasons are scientific in nature, philosophically and methodologically, of which I was reminded upon reading an older issue of Skeptic magazine (2018, vol. 23, no. 3).

In this issue was an article by Nathan Lents who had posed five examples of poor or bad design that proponents of intelligent design (ID) need to address, taking for granted that ID is a properly scientific model. The examples which he listed were fairly thought-provoking but it was the first example of bad design which he had highlighted that I found quite compelling—specifically, broken genes.

Lents explained that in the human genome there are "broken-down versions" of genes that "bear striking resemblance to important and functional genes in other species." A famous example of this is the GULO gene, which "normally functions in the synthesis of ascorbic acid, more commonly called vitamin C." Now, there is a clear and simple evolutionary explanation for why the majority of animals can synthesize vitamin C while primates cannot, and of course it has to do with common ancestry. Lents himself explains that in some population ancestral to the primate lineage (perhaps around 90 million years ago) the GULO gene was disabled by a random mutation and then became fixed in the population. From that point onward it has accumulated a number of other mutations, he said. "We have the GULO gene, but it's broken." I must admit, that makes good sense to me.

The question, however, is what explanation could the ID model possibly provide? "Since creationists don't believe in evolution, what is their explanation?" he asks. "It's not that we don't have the GULO gene. We do. It just doesn't work. Why would an intelligent force intentionally design us with a broken gene? Give us a gene or don't, but a broken version?"

That is an excellent question and I would like to hear from creationist proponents of ID who believe they can answer it. Specifically, I would like to hear an explanation for how this state of affairs makes more sense given intelligent design than it does given evolution (thus providing a reason to prefer intelligent design over evolution).


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Jul 04 '21

Review/Critique "The law of biogenesis" is not a thing

5 Upvotes

Some creationists refer to "spontaneous generation" as the emergence of life from non-living matter and claim that it has never been observed (Brown 2019, 5). Life comes only from life, they say, a fact so consistently observed that "it is called the law of biogenesis." They assert that the theory of evolution "conflicts with this scientific law when claiming that life came from nonliving matter through natural processes."

First, they say "it is called the law of biogenesis" but they never cite a source for that—because there is no "law of biogenesis" in biology like there are laws of physics and chemistry and so on. It's a creationist fiction. The sole exception that I've found is Jeff Miller, on staff with Apologetics Press, who quoted from ostensibly a biology textbook which said, "Historically the point of view that life comes only from life has been so well established through the facts revealed by experiment that it is called the Law of Biogenesis" (Miller 2012). What he neglected to mention was that his source, Biology: A Search for Order in Complexity (1974), was a creationist textbook. Again, the law of biogenesis is a piece of creationist fiction.

Second, "spontaneous generation" was an ancient idea that was popular for millennia until it was disproved by Louis Pasteur and John Tyndall in the nineteenth century. (People couldn't figure out where things like maggots or fleas came from and believed they arose spontaneously from non-living material.) In other words, everyone stopped talking about it well over a hundred years ago—except creationists who, for some reason, keep tilting at that windmill. We know where maggots come from, guys. Move on. Everyone else did.

Third, the theory of evolution has nothing to do with the origin of life. Those are two different things. Evolution is a theory on the origin of species and the continuity of biodiversity. Evolution is not about the origin of life, or the origin of the solar system, or the origin of the universe, much less the origin of everything (the world-view of evolutionism). It presupposes the existence of these things in order to address the origin of species.

Even if we assume for the sake of argument that life indeed could not originate through natural processes, how would that falsify evolution? As far as I can tell, it simply wouldn't—indeed it couldn't, for the theory of evolution presupposes the existence of life. It is a biological theory—a word that means the study of life. This needs to be understood: Notwithstanding how life arose, it has nevertheless evolved. Ergo, undermining origin of life research doesn't undermine evolution.

NB: Brown claimed that "evolutionary scientists reluctantly accept the law of biogenesis," a statement which came with a footnote. I had a look and, for support, Brown quotes from a book published ... [drumroll] ... in 1933. Well, that explains why the author mentions how people generally believed in spontaneous generation "until fairly recent times" (Brown 2019, 51). I guess it was fairly recent—for someone in the 1930s!

References:

Brown, W. T. (2019). In the Beginning: Compelling Evidence for Creation and the Flood, 9th ed. Phoenix, AZ: Center for Scientific Creation.

Miller, J. (2012). "The law of biogenesis, part 1." Apologetics Press. (Accessed July 4, 2021.)


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Feb 20 '21

Moderators Needed

5 Upvotes

Mods Needed

This is a brand new subreddit, created February 7, 2021. It was created to provide a community for a specific kind of user, namely, Bible-believing Christians who accept the scientific theory of evolution and want to explore it in the context of a biblical world-view and the apostolic faith.

What is expected of Moderators?

Here is a quick overview of the qualities and qualifications we are looking for in our Moderators:

  • Experience with Reddit: We are looking for actively involved users with an account that is not less than six months old and a karma count of at least 500, and preferably those with at least some experience with or knowledge of moderating. We are also looking for people who actively enjoy debating the theology and science of origins and have a demonstrable history of doing so with a gracious and civil tone.

  • Committed to a vibrant and healthy community: These responsibilities should not place much of a demand on your time but it is hoped that our Moderators will have a keen interest in maintaining a vibrant and healthy community with a reputation for fascinating discussions of complex and important subject matter.

  • Gracious and patient: This continues to be a hotly contested subject matter within the Christian community, which means some people can be easily triggered and become entrenched in an agenda. We need level-headed Moderators who can maintain their cool in a fiery environment and help bring the temperature down.

  • An interest in the creation-vs-evolution debate: We want people who are genuinely interested in exploring what the creation-vs-evolution debate looks like from an evolutionary creationist perspective, addressing not only the scientific but especially the biblical and theological challenges which this view incurs (e.g., Adam and Eve as real people in history).

What are the responsibilities of Moderators?

Some of the responsibilities our Moderators will have include:


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Feb 08 '21

Discussion An introduction to Varves.

Thumbnail self.debateevolution
2 Upvotes

r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Apr 10 '21

Who are some good Christian Evolutionists (scholars, scientists, speakers, etc.) that you think more people should know about?

2 Upvotes

r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 22 '21

Discussion A question for Christians who accept evolution

3 Upvotes

Over in the subreddit r/AskAChristian, a gentleman who goes by u/JimmyDoom60629 presented basically the following challenge (which I have slightly edited for clarity):

A question for Christians who accept evolution: If Adam and Eve did not exist, then there was no fall into sin. If there is no original sin, then there was no need for a messiah or atonement. Without these, the whole thing quickly falls apart.

So, how do you solve this riddle?

I have recently found my faith in Christ Jesus and, as I’m starting to think through things like this as a born-again middle-aged adult, this thought got me hung up and I was curious how others have answered it.

I am a Christian who not only accepts evolution but also believes Adam and Eve actually existed. I think they lived roughly six thousand years ago and close to what is now the eastern Anatolia region of Turkey (near Lake Van, 650 km northwest of Baghdad, Iraq). So I believe Eden was a real place and there was a real garden from which they were exiled after they sinned by disobeying God. I also believe in original sin because I believe Adam was our federal head in a covenant relationship between God and mankind. Therefore, the need for a messiah and his atoning sacrifice remains. This perspective is commonly referred to as Evolutionary Creationism.

In other words, a Christian can affirm such biblical truths AND ALSO accept the science of evolutionary biology or common descent. There is no difficulty, conflict, or contradiction in asserting that evolution happened and so did the fall of Adam in the garden.

Where problems arise is when Adam and Eve are supposed to be the first humans. However, I don’t think we need to suppose they were. It seems to me that no biblical doctrines require Adam and Eve to be the first humans, only that they existed and can be situated historically around six thousand years ago (according to the genealogies in the Bible).

“But in Genesis it says that God created Adam from the dust of the ground.” True, but what’s true of Adam is true of all people. This is not a way in which Adam differed from everyone; he was the same as everyone in this regard. (The only way in which Adam differed from all others has to do with federal headship. God’s covenant relationship with mankind is through one of only two federal heads, the first Adam and the last Adam, Jesus Christ.) The Bible says we are all formed by God from the dust (Ps. 103:14; 1 Cor. 15:48). This is intentional language conveying important theological truths about God as creator and us as creatures. We all enter this life formed of the natural, earthly (Ps. 139:15; 2 Cor. 5:1); then by union with Christ we are made spiritual, heavenly (1 Cor. 15:46-48).

Moreover, the Bible mentioning only Adam in the garden (and later Eve) does not allow us to conclude that there were no humans anywhere. The first three chapters of Genesis are talking only about Eden and the garden. There was no one else in the garden, sure, but what about the rest of the world? Genesis doesn’t talk about that—primarily because back then they had no concept of the earth as a planet. (Ancient Near Eastern cosmology was obviously very different from our modern understanding.)

Christians who accept evolution and believe Adam and Eve actually existed have two ways of looking at this. Some believe that Adam was created de novo by God and placed in the garden, so he existed in a world with a human population in the millions but didn’t share their ancestry. Others believe he was born to parents like anyone else and later chosen by God and placed in the garden with a holy vocation. (Notice that Gen. 2:15 says that God “took the man and put him in the garden.”) For now, at least, I lean toward the latter view, but I am open to the former and fairly curious about it. I might be mistaken but I think Joshua S. Swamidass holds that view.

 

If you think we are just genetically mutated apes, where did the fall that led to sin happen in the timeline?

First, I don’t believe that we are “just” mutated apes. We are defined by so much more than our biology or ancestry. Yes, humans are apes—that is, our species belongs to the taxonomic family Hominidae. But that’s just taxonomy. It’s not scandalous; it’s not even remarkable. More importantly, it is not our identity, it’s not who we are. Our identity is determined by our creator who chose us as his image-bearers. That is our identity, that is the take-home message—and that ought to be the real scandal. But we callously take it for granted, almost as if we’re entitled to this identity, like it’s not a shocking gift of extraordinary grace.

Second, as I said, I believe the events in the garden of Eden actually happened and, according to the genealogies in the Bible, took place six thousand years ago, more or less.

Please feel free to add your own perspective or concerns regarding the challenge that u/JimmyDoom60629 presented.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 15 '21

What do you think is the strongest/most convincing piece of evidence for evolution?

3 Upvotes

If you were discussing evolution with a friend that didn't accept evolution and thought there was no evidence for it, what piece of evidence for evolution might you point to first?


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • May 24 '21

How do you understand the New Testament's usage of Eve coming from Adam?

2 Upvotes

For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and transgressed. But she will be saved through childbearing, if they continue in faith, love, and holiness, with good sense.

-1 Timothy 2:17-18

For man did not come from woman, but woman came from man... In the Lord, however, woman is not independent of man, and man is not independent of woman. For just as woman came from man, so man comes through woman, and all things come from God.

-1 Corinthians 11:8, 11-12

In light of evolution, how do we understand Paul's appeal to source?


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • Mar 26 '22

Quotes [Quotes] Robert C. Newman on science versus the Bible

3 Upvotes

As far as my view of the integration of science and theology is concerned, I have a few comments to make. Initially, I like the phrase "science and theology." It is common in these discussions to talk instead of "science and the Bible," and while our concern in this book is that our theology be truly biblical, the terms "science" and "Bible" are not parallel. Science can be understood as a method, an institution, or a body of knowledge. In this, it is parallel to "theology" rather than to "Bible." Science is a method or institution that investigates nature, and it is also the body of knowledge that results from this study. Theology (at least biblical or exegetical theology) is a method or institution that investigates the Bible and also the resultant body of knowledge. Theology studies God's special revelation in Scripture, while science studies God's general revelation in nature. If biblical Christianity is true (as I believe), then the God who cannot lie has revealed himself both in nature and in Scripture. Thus, both science and theology should provide input to an accurate view of reality, and we may expect them to overlap in many areas.

Robert C. Newman, "Progressive Creationism," in Three Views on Creation and Evolution, eds. J. P. Moreland and John Mark Reynolds (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1999), 117.


r/EvolutionaryCreation • • May 15 '21

Assuming a local flood, what did God's promise to Noah mean?

1 Upvotes

Then God said to Noah and to his sons with him: “I now establish my covenant with you and with your descendants after you and with every living creature that was with you—the birds, the livestock and all the wild animals, all those that came out of the ark with you—every living creature on earth. I establish my covenant with you: Never again will all life be destroyed by the waters of a flood; never again will there be a flood to destroy the earth.”

And God said, “This is the sign of the covenant I am making between me and you and every living creature with you, a covenant for all generations to come: I have set my rainbow in the clouds, and it will be the sign of the covenant between me and the earth. Whenever I bring clouds over the earth and the rainbow appears in the clouds, I will remember my covenant between me and you and all living creatures of every kind. Never again will the waters become a flood to destroy all life. Whenever the rainbow appears in the clouds, I will see it and remember the everlasting covenant between God and all living creatures of every kind on the earth.”

So God said to Noah, “This is the sign of the covenant I have established between me and all life on the earth.”

Certainly there have been other local floods. What do you think God meant by this promise?