r/Etsy • u/Pride_and_Sudocrem • 41m ago
Help for Buyer Seller insulting me, reported to Etsy. What would realistically be done?
I recently purchased a pair of horns from an Etsy seller, but the headband supplied was completely different from the one shown in the listing photographs, which hadn't been updated. The item therefore wasn't as advertised.
The headband was COMPLETELY different. Different colour, different length, no teeth comb to grip onto the hair. It kept slipping off when putting it on.
The seller eventually agreed to accept the return, refund the item and reimburse my return postage. He explicitly told me that he didn't update the photos since that would be a lot of work.Although I received the item refund, it took almost a month and around three reminders before they finally reimbursed the postage.
After they confirmed the postage payment had been sent, blaming etsy for putting my messages in spam, I replied:
>The overall responsibility is for you to keep up to your legal requirements. Next time, if you fail to supply a service/product as advertised, please rectify it promptly, and do not in any way classify it just a "gesture of good will".
Take care.
Oh, he also told me weeks before he finally refunded me the postage, that he will refund the postage out of good will, despite the fact that he legally required to.
The seller responded as above.
I reported the exchange to Etsy Support. After reviewing the messages, the representative apologised and confirmed that the case had been escalated to a specialist team for investigation.
I did explicitly tell Etsy that I didn't want the seller's shop closed or their livelihood affected. I felt a stern warning would be sufficient, as everyone can have a bad day.
I'm curious, particularly from Etsy sellers or anyone who's experienced something similar: what realistically happens to a shop following a report like this?
Would Etsy typically issue a warning, impose restrictions, or potentially suspend the shop? I'm not looking for further punishment, just genuinely curious about how Etsy handles this kind of behaviour.