r/Etsy • • Aug 09 '23

Discussion note to sellers: please stop with the packaging

0 Upvotes

I’m a frequent buyer (altho I am trying to buy less stuff in general).

Sellers: please stop wrapping everything up all cute, adding cards and gift bags and handwritten notes and ribbons and “extras”.

Do you know where this goes? Straight into the trash (most is not recyclable).

If you want 5 stars and more purchases, make a good product, advertise it accurately, ship without delay, and answer questions politely and helpfully.

Don’t add to the ungodly amount of waste we already generate in modern society.

Thank you.

Addition:

Did not expect so many responses. Many of them to the effect of “that’s your preference but not everyone shares it” or “it makes me more money.” Blanket response: obviously you are going to do whatever you want, some buyers like getting random shit, and some sellers will send it regardless. I’m not asking you to cater to me. This post is for any seller that has thought “this is wasteful” but also thought “I need to do this because it is what buyers want.” I just want sellers to hear at least ONE VOICE that says not all buyers want or reward that, and in fact, some buyers will penalize for it. So maybe instead of assuming that we are all crazy for plastic and paper, start out from the assumption that buyers are different and then decide what you feel like is a good use of resources.

Addition 2: Okay, someone “reported” me? sigh the internet


r/Etsy • • Apr 13 '22

Rant Stop whining

38 Upvotes

Etsy provides traffic and sales that you wouldn’t otherwise have. If you hate what Etsy does, learn how to generate the traffic yourself and leave Etsy. Paying 6.5% of your sales price to acquire a customer is a damn good price. If you’re getting punished by bad reviews that’s not Etsy’s fault. You need a better product/better communication. If you’re getting punished by late orders that’s not Etsy’s fault. That means you’re not in control of your business. If you’re getting punished because of a low message response rate that’s not Etsy’s fault, it’s your fault. Etsy provides tons of traffic and opportunity to sell and if you’re not selling as much as you want then try different products. Try changing your description. Plenty of small shops are still very successful. Because they spend their time working on improving their product and shop instead of whining about why it’s somebody else’s fault that they’re not as successful as they want to be.

Edit: I see many comments partially agreeing with what I’ve said but then still whining about something. Take control and responsibility of your business. Placing blame on forces beyond your control is a waste of energy. Do what you can do to grow your business and shut up about everything else.


r/Etsy • • Jan 01 '23

It's only Jan 1 & already people griping about Etsy

18 Upvotes

1) HOW DARE ETSY CHARGE 20CENTS PER LISTING!

2) I SOLD TRADEMARKED ITEMS AND ETSY PULLED THEM DOWN & NOW HARASSING ME 18 MONTHS LATER!

...And the day just started


r/Etsy • • May 17 '25

Discussion Warning Sellers: This sub encourages practices frowned upon in other communities.

0 Upvotes

I just wanted to warn the sellers in this sub that practices that are frowned upon in other Etsy subs, are encouraged here.

I just came across a post with a buyer asking for advice on whether to send an item that Etsy automatically refunded them for, back to the seller. Every single piece of advice was to take the money and keep the item.

Many Etsy communities here on reddit consider this a scam practice that hurts sellers. I have had to stop selling my handmade jewellery on Etsy and now only selling digital items/templates, because of this scam practice that is being encouraged in this sub. I put my heart and soul into that jewellery and it was made from precious materials, it was just getting stolen on Etsy. The impact on sellers is similar to shoplifting, and Etsy enables it.

Unfortunately, even the mods encouraged the scam practice by closing the thread before any opposing views or comments could be posted.

Etsy sellers have such little support as it is, and it’s very disappointing to see main popular subs encouraging a practice that us sellers have been fighting so hard against for so long. We may as well just give up.

This is why handmade products are being replaced with aliexpress/temu/shein crap on Etsy. All the good sellers stopped listing their handmade products on Etsy because buyers kept stealing them with this scam refund practice.

Anyways, if this practice is encouraged in the main Etsy sub, what hope do us sellers have?


r/Etsy • • Jan 08 '26

Feedback Friday Are my prices fair?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hello! I just started an Etsy shop after my family told me I should sell my artwork (I made them all pet portraits for Christmas). I’ve gotten some views and checks on my listings, but nobody has bought anything yet. It hasn’t been long so I know I should give it more time, but I wanted some outside opinions on if my prices are fair for the work I offer. Attached is a picture of my listing, unfortunately I can only upload one photo. For prints and framed prints I charge extra, because of printing fees and the price of buying the frames. It’s also extra for a custom background rather than a plain color. What would you pay for this?


r/Etsy • • Mar 31 '23

I’m tired of sellers feeling entitled to 5 star reviews.

0 Upvotes

I’m a seller on Etsy and also a buyer.

As I seller, I get that reviews are important, especially good ones. It can feel devastating to get a less than positive review.

That being said.

I’ve received a couple of orders now with demands about reviews that just feel aggressive.

One order included a full size piece of paper on which only contained the message was “don’t leave a negative review before messaging us” in big, bold, highlighted letters.

Another order included a card insert where the last line read “contact us before leaving negative or neutral feedback”.

To me, this feels like interfering with reviews. My insert card includes language about how I appreciate reviews and language about the buyer being able to reach out with questions and concerns, but I don’t link the two together.

Review aren’t there as a “reward” to the seller it’s a way for future buyers to understand the experience of past buyers. As a buyer, I’d like to know if there are problems with orders that the seller is constantly having to fix behind the scenes.

I have had small issues with orders (specifically the orders with these notes in them) that aren’t big enough for me to want to have a conversation with the seller about, but enough for me to want to let future buyers know. (An accessory item that was listed as part of a slime and not included, shoes that were more brown when the listing images made them appear closer to yellow).

If you’re a seller and you feel the need to tell buyers to ask you before leaving a negative review, I think you need to figure out what you can do to fix the issue in the first place.

Curious to know other’s thoughts. Do you put these notes in your orders? Do you feel intimidated as a buyer when you see them?


r/Etsy • • Mar 09 '24

Discussion Just found out the shop I've been buying perfume from was not sending out perfume in those opaque bottles...

86 Upvotes

TLDR: stop now if you think perfume needs to be shaken before use and just walk away smugly thinking I'm an idiot

Been purchasing samples from one shop for a little over a year, trying to find one that worked well with my skin chemistry. The smaller sample sizes came in tiny amber roll on bottles, and the large sample and full sized perfumes came in opaque spray on bottles.

Normally, I wouldn't buy perfume in a bottle that completely obscure the contents. But I was familiar with the seller irl, and had seen their work area, had familiarity with the ingredients they use and their level of knowledge of perfumery and its formulation, and had received samples from them in person, decanted on site into clear spray bottles. Those samples I received in person were what I was basing my confidence as a consumer in.

None of the perfumes I've purchased from this seller through Etsy have had any ingredients listed, usage instructions, safety disclaimers, any of that, and instead of being put off by it, I just figured, "eh, it would be shady but my previous experience with this merchant's products gives me assurance of quality".

Sigh.

Found a perfume in the shop that I love, and it works so nicely with my natural Sweaty Betty essence... I had used almost 2/3 of the large sample size I purchased (which came packaged the same as the previous large samples - in a small opaque plastic spray bottle with the perfume label slapped over the spot where the spray cap threads onto the bottle) and decided to purchase the full size while it was included in a sale the shop was having.

The full size bottle arrives - yay! But it leaked a little around the lid while shipping. Since it's just a screw top closure and not crimped down, I figured I'd just decant the perfume into an empty bottle I had on hand and not even bother contacting the seller. After all, IDGAF about the packaging, I'm really just here for the fragrance itself.

But. The liquid that pours out of the leaky bottle the seller sent it in is cloudy, weirdly pearlescent stuff that soon settles to being mostly milky liquid with strange clear globules throughout, topped by a very thin layer of oily amber stuff.

I take pics, message the seller, and get a response of "it's supposed to look like that, that's why the bottom of the bottle says to shake before using" and they refunded my order.

Yo. My bottle did not have anything about shake before using on it. None of the perfume products I've purchased from this shop have had ANY info on the label or bottle other than the name of the shop, the name of the creation, and the word perfume.

When I told the seller that there wasn't a notice about shake before using on the large bottle I purchased nor any of the previous perfumes I'd ordered, I got no reply but they refunded, like, 4 of my other, much older, orders from them - even a couple of orders where I wasn't purchasing perfume but completely other, non skin contact items.

When I looked back through their listings a day or two later, absolutely nothing had changed about their item descriptions.

They totally did it on purpose. The goth bottles weren't an aesthetic decision, they were all about hiding the contents of the bottle.

On the plus side, maybe I don't have as many fragrance sensitivities as I thought I did, I've just been applying unknown concentrations of fragrance chemicals and whatever else was in those bottles directly onto my skin several times a week for over a year.

So there's that, at least. Yippee


r/Etsy • • Aug 12 '16

How to get away with robbing people blind on etsy.

3 Upvotes

So nearly a year ago, I ordered some items from an Etsy store totalling $115. I was contacted by the store owner that the items would take some time to make. A few months passed and I asked where she was at with the progress and was told that she needed a little more time. It's now been 10 months, she's closed her etsy store down which deleted my etsy claim, and paypal claims automatically close as the transaction is over 180 days old. After speaking to a paypal rep over the phone, he suggested my only other option is to take legal action. Against a business that doesn't exist and has no address or names or contact details associated with it.

So if anyone is looking to make some free money, open an etsy store, sell some bullshit products, wait a few months, take the store down and winner winner chicken dinner. Run away with everyone's money and not a worry in the world.


r/Etsy • • Apr 22 '22

Advice Needed Someone purchased ALL my stickers (32 qty of one listing) and 8 sticker sheets. How do I ask them why?

1 Upvotes

I don't offer wholesale or anything, so I didn't expect to see this gigantic order. This person ordered all 32 stickers in quantity of ONE of my listings, and 8 sticker sheets from a second listing. How do I go about asking why? Should I cancel? They even wrote instructions that they should be packaged in a box or padded mailer. Not sure what to do.

Edited: Thank you to everyone who responded, didn't expect the thread to explode! I'm sorry in advance for not knowing what to do at first, but this was my first time experiencing this and honestly didn't know what to do. I will proceed with the order as everyone has suggested and will mail it in a box. Thank you! I appreciate it.


r/Etsy • • May 28 '24

Help for Seller Is it safe to say that Etsy takes about 30 % of your sales?

0 Upvotes

I see artist shops who look like they are making 100000 k a year in sales at least. If sales on etsy takes 30 percent then you have 70,000 left and then pay 30 percent of that in taxes. My original math was wrong after you’d be left with around 50,000k.


r/Etsy • • Mar 08 '24

Help for Seller Bad Review- Help ):

1 Upvotes

I received my first bad review ): I have 6 five star reviews and got my first 1 star review. I sell wax melts and she said they put out no smell and I feel as if it's not true at all. I use the melts myself and they put out very strong sent & I remember hers being just as strong as everyone else's, including mine.

Unfortunately, I responded in the middle of the night and didn't know/ pay attention that once you reply, they can't change the review even if you "fix" the "problem" which I have offered to do by comment on the review. Which I have found is also not the move. You live & learn I suppose.

I'm 9 months pregnant and due to go into labor in a few weeks and highly emotional right now and can't shake the feeling that all of the hard work I have put into my shop & my melts was now a waste. I was on my way to star seller and now I have a 4.4-star rating & with being a new shop with only 7 reviews & one being a 1 star I feel like giving up and closing shop. Is my shop doomed? Or do you think it can recover? I can handle the honesty. I'd rather not spend the next 2 weeks before labor continuing to make melts if this 1 star is going to be the end of my shop anyways.

): Thank you!


r/Etsy • • Dec 29 '22

I’m nervous about being scammed!

0 Upvotes

I made my first etsy purchase today and the shop had many sales and many good reviews but not even 5 minutes after i placed my order it said that it had shipped out. Is it sketchy or am i just overthinking it?


r/Etsy • • Aug 30 '23

Help for Seller THIEVES & SCAMMERS EVERYWHERE!!!! NO ONE WARNED ME!

2 Upvotes

I’m a new shop owner of only 3 months. I quit my job of doing hair after 17 years to be able to spend more time on our farm.

I wanted to still have my own income so I dove head first into graphic design, marketing, analytics ALL the things to be successful on the ETSY platform.

Iv watched a TON of youtube videos (as I’m sure we ALL have)

And NO-ONE said a word about how rampant the THIEVERY is on this platform!

I have not taken ONE day off since I have started this venture and have been working 12-13-14 hour days trying to get my shop established so it can take off and I can get back to doing more of what I love.

Only to find out that ALL of my best selling designs have been STOLEN right off my listing photos!

Some people even stole the listing photos WITH the design even though it has OUR farm logo watermark on it!

I am absolutely appalled and amazed!!

I started doing GOOGLE image search’s for my shirts and designs and found them EVERYWHERE!!!!

ALL over the internet!!

Not-JUST ETSY!! Even though ETSY is the ONLY platform I listed them on.

People are selling my designs as PNGs as well.

I thought watermarking photos and downloading at a low resolution would be enough to deter that sort of thing.

WRONG.

NO ONE warned me that I needed to obstruct part of the graphic in order for them to not be able to obtain the full image.

I guess now I know.

You live you learn.

So if you are new here.

And you make high quality unique graphic designs

-BECAUSE NO ONE TOLD ME-

!! PROTECT - THEM !!

They-WILL-steal-your-work!!

It’s a dog eat dog world in here and no one warned me.

Every YouTuber out there tries to sell it like it’s the best thing ever leaving out ALL the bad ( the fees, the payment reserves, the scammers, the thieves, the listings that get taken down for no reason, the amount of actual time it takes to be successful, that you have to work like an insane person to get it off the ground before it can be called “passive income”, on and on.

No, you have to learn the HARD way.

Or “I” did.

The least I can do is try and save someone else the heart ache.


r/Etsy • • Feb 18 '19

Reddit Is Full Of Etsy Employees

0 Upvotes

I've noticed every time someone makes and unruly comment about Etsy .There is always some out there to smash or tear apart any Bad Thing You Say About Etsy ..Its very easy to see just read some posts and you will see what I'm talking about.. Etsy Employ Hundreds Of People To Crush anything you say ...


r/Etsy • • Sep 20 '25

Discussion I can't buy from Etsy anymore

3 Upvotes

I've been scammed one too many times. I try to only buy from reputable homemade shops but it's getting too hard to tell. It's sad but I'm done. There's no way to even give feedback to etsy that's not part of a claim. Maybe there will be an alternative soon because I know many people who have done the same. Very sad.


r/Etsy • • Jun 29 '26

Help for Seller Etsy stole $300 for buyer after order sent to address on file rather than apple pay address!

0 Upvotes

So Etsy deducted over $300 for the buyer after order was sent to the address on file rather than apple pay address they gave me in messages.
This is a solid copper handmade item...
They did not take responsibility for it at all and split cost. I hear sellers are not covered if seller sends to an address not on the account! Well i can tell you you are not covered either way! If a buyer does not change their address on Etsy and message you with another, and you mistakenly send to the address on their account because you are so bust and forget to look through every message of-which their are many!

Etsy should take some responsibility for this... They should have a notice for apple pay customers... They should have a warning if a customer sends another address in messages that lets them change address so this does not happen.

Not only that, but this is a loophole.....
buyer not only got a full refund stolen from my account, but could easily contact a previous neighbor to pickup the item delivered to the previous address....
Meanwhile, i lose over $600 and over an hours work and etc... Not to mention my time dealing with the cleanup...

Buyer also does not respond after refund about a question on whether or not he's able to pickup from previous address or have someone else and etc.


r/Etsy • • Aug 19 '25

Discussion Sellers, please do not feel obligated to communicate with me

10 Upvotes

To answer one of my questions, to ask a necessary question of your own, sure.

But do not send me thank-yous, invite me to your brick-and-mortar store hundreds of miles away, etc. Every time you send me an unnecessary message, I have to go to Etsy, and read it to see if it really was necessary. I buy on Etsy a lot. Sellers' idea that constant communication is good is a pain in the tail.

ETA: And I truly hate videos. I'm trying to look at the item and essentially getting it waved around at me. Just don't.


r/Etsy • • Jun 16 '22

Help Did I make the right choice?

1 Upvotes

I’ve made the decision to close my Etsy shop. After having a shop for about 2 years. Etsy is where I make majority of my sales but with what they take from every sale I just can’t afford to keep breaking even and not making profit. I would have to raise my prices too high in my opinion to make anything. I’ve looked into building a website but the prices are extreme. Did I make the wrong choice? Should I have just stayed with Etsy and raised my prices? Also if you have a website what sight did you use to set it up? Everything I’ve found is pretty pricey or takes just as much as Etsy. Hence why I’m questioning if I made the wrong choice.


r/Etsy • • May 06 '24

Discussion Why do people feel the need to ask if I’ve shipped the item yet when clearly the tracking will give you that info?

0 Upvotes

A few days ago I received an order for one of the gemstone specimens I had for sale on my Etsy. I really don’t use Etsy anymore since I’ve switched over to my own website, but I appreciate the extra sale. The customer keeps asking when I’m going to ship it. It’s still well within the time frame Etsy requires me to ship. It’s just starting to get irritating because I know there’s no reason you need a rock in any fast time frame, no matter how “badly” you want it. I told them I’d ship it out on Saturday and it’s Monday and they’re already messaging me about it again. Obviously it wouldn’t get scanned in over weekend. The urge to give customers like this the response they deserve is UGH so strong. I’m sure I’m not the only one annoyed with customers like this


r/Etsy • • Aug 05 '23

Help for Seller Am I right in refusing to send someone's order or refund it.

3 Upvotes

I got an order for an handmade customised order in February.

I sent it within my dispatch times to Canada ( I'm in the UK). About 6 weeks later I got the parcel back from Canadian post waiting it was not picked up from the post office.

I messaged the customer straight away, I never heard back from the customer and in May I took the item to a local market and sold it for 25% of the original sale price as was just in my house and I don't have unlimited storage.

In early July the customer contacted me and asked me to resend their I didn't have it anymore but thought I will remake it to keep the customer happy and send them it. I sent them a link to pay the postage.

Today they messaged me saying they will pay the postage next week. I honestly can't be bothered with them. It's well over the 100 days since original purchase and I think I've been fair.

Would I be a dick if I just said you've missed your chance and put them to spam?


r/Etsy • • Feb 26 '22

How can we remove ALL resellers from Etsy?

0 Upvotes

(Edited for clarity.)

We're organizing a seller strike. It's barely over 24 hours, but we're already at more than 100 members in the new subreddit. It's inspired by the fee increase, but that isn't the whole reason we're taking action. There are a lot of things that have really gone downhill on Etsy, for those of us who have been here for a long time.

We're coming up with a mission statement - and one of the really important topics we want to work into it is Etsy's reseller problem. It doesn't affect me personally much, but I see so many posts about it. Buyers feel cheated when they pay a "handmade" premium for things they could have acquired much more cheaply on Amazon or Aliexpress, and they decide not to shop on Etsy in the future. Legitimate sellers are forced to compete with these dishonest resellers on prices, as reseller products are often featured in the "you may also like" section of their listings.

Etsy keeps making promises to crack down on resellers, but the fees obtained from these resellers represent a substantial part of their income. There is a discrepancy between the interests of Etsy as an online marketplace, and the interests of the sellers they purport to represent.

I've been thinking about it, and I had an idea. We need a reseller crackdown program that is more transparent. Sellers need the ability to hold Etsy accountable, and see that they actually are taking steps to reduce the total percentage of illegitimate sellers among all sellers on the platform.

What if the system where we go to report a handmade item as not-handmade was fed into a publicly available database? Where we can see all data represented something like this:

  • Number of sellers with items reported to Etsy as not handmade

  • Number of reports followed up by Etsy and found to be legitimate handmade/vintage/supplies

  • Number of reports followed up by Etsy, with seller removed from the platform

  • Number of reports pending Etsy followup.

What do you think of this idea? Do you have suggestions, or a better idea of your own?


r/Etsy • • Apr 02 '26

Help for Seller Why the change in fur products on Etsy?

0 Upvotes

No rabbit fur? What about Dolls, etc made by the Inuit? Apparently the folks at headquarters aren't aware that there aren't any cows above the Arctic Circle..... I'm perfectly fine not selling animal furs trapped for their pelts BUT doesn't look like anyone considered different cultures when they made this rule ...

In addition to prohibiting products made from endangered and threatened species, Etsy prohibits products made from or containing natural fur from animals killed primarily for their pelts, regardless of age or origin. This includes products like raw pelts, finished garments, and accessories made with real fur from animals such as mink, fox, and rabbit. This does not include taxidermy and byproduct materials (such as leather, sheepskin, wool, or mohair).


r/Etsy • • Nov 21 '23

Discussion I thought purchases were private?

2 Upvotes

Used my Etsy account to purchase an item from a seller. Someone contacted me saying they saw my review and wanted to know about said item. I thought Etsy had made buyer info private back when people were buying sexy items and the world could could see? How is it that some rando can contact me regarding what I bought???


r/Etsy • • May 08 '26

Help for Seller Etsy scams

2 Upvotes

This is my third post about this:

I got an order for an item costing $1,200 and immediately received a message asking to change the shipping address.

I canceled the order and had them order with the correct address.

their profile is a ghost profile. On my pre posts a lot of people said it’s a scam.

i want to understand how a buyer can scam in this situation? With a stolen credit card or hacked account? What is the danger for me?