TLDR: stop now if you think perfume needs to be shaken before use and just walk away smugly thinking I'm an idiot
Been purchasing samples from one shop for a little over a year, trying to find one that worked well with my skin chemistry. The smaller sample sizes came in tiny amber roll on bottles, and the large sample and full sized perfumes came in opaque spray on bottles.
Normally, I wouldn't buy perfume in a bottle that completely obscure the contents. But I was familiar with the seller irl, and had seen their work area, had familiarity with the ingredients they use and their level of knowledge of perfumery and its formulation, and had received samples from them in person, decanted on site into clear spray bottles. Those samples I received in person were what I was basing my confidence as a consumer in.
None of the perfumes I've purchased from this seller through Etsy have had any ingredients listed, usage instructions, safety disclaimers, any of that, and instead of being put off by it, I just figured, "eh, it would be shady but my previous experience with this merchant's products gives me assurance of quality".
Sigh.
Found a perfume in the shop that I love, and it works so nicely with my natural Sweaty Betty essence... I had used almost 2/3 of the large sample size I purchased (which came packaged the same as the previous large samples - in a small opaque plastic spray bottle with the perfume label slapped over the spot where the spray cap threads onto the bottle) and decided to purchase the full size while it was included in a sale the shop was having.
The full size bottle arrives - yay! But it leaked a little around the lid while shipping. Since it's just a screw top closure and not crimped down, I figured I'd just decant the perfume into an empty bottle I had on hand and not even bother contacting the seller. After all, IDGAF about the packaging, I'm really just here for the fragrance itself.
But. The liquid that pours out of the leaky bottle the seller sent it in is cloudy, weirdly pearlescent stuff that soon settles to being mostly milky liquid with strange clear globules throughout, topped by a very thin layer of oily amber stuff.
I take pics, message the seller, and get a response of "it's supposed to look like that, that's why the bottom of the bottle says to shake before using" and they refunded my order.
Yo. My bottle did not have anything about shake before using on it. None of the perfume products I've purchased from this shop have had ANY info on the label or bottle other than the name of the shop, the name of the creation, and the word perfume.
When I told the seller that there wasn't a notice about shake before using on the large bottle I purchased nor any of the previous perfumes I'd ordered, I got no reply but they refunded, like, 4 of my other, much older, orders from them - even a couple of orders where I wasn't purchasing perfume but completely other, non skin contact items.
When I looked back through their listings a day or two later, absolutely nothing had changed about their item descriptions.
They totally did it on purpose. The goth bottles weren't an aesthetic decision, they were all about hiding the contents of the bottle.
On the plus side, maybe I don't have as many fragrance sensitivities as I thought I did, I've just been applying unknown concentrations of fragrance chemicals and whatever else was in those bottles directly onto my skin several times a week for over a year.
So there's that, at least. Yippee