r/ECers • • 4h ago

Planning or Considering EC Looking for advice on EC-FTM

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone I’m a soon to be FTM any day now and I’ve come across the concept of EC recently. It’s such an interesting topic and I’ve never heard of it neither do I know of anyone in my circle practicing it.

I was hoping to learn about your experiences both good and bad, how to start and what sort of resources I can use. I’m really envisioning life with my baby girl to be very connection driven, being able to read her cues, lots of baby wearing and time spent on the floor with her etc so the concept of EC is very appealing to me. Thanks in advance!


r/ECers • • 12h ago

Diapers: Disposable or Reusable?

4 Upvotes

Soon to be parent, wondering what type of diapers people use as I imagine we’ll be taking them off often trying to catch the pee/poop!


r/ECers • • 5h ago

General Questions Handling setbacks

1 Upvotes

How do you folks handle EC setbacks? Seems like as I am approaching 8 weeks, baby is less apt to go number two after eating like she did before and is clearly gassy (where before she would almost immediately relieve herself)

Number one still going fine. So maybe just developing digestive system? I have become maybe a bit too invested in EC and see it as a personal slight if I am not catching 2’s 😂, but also don’t want to force her ir make it uncomfortable


r/ECers • • 22h ago

Teaching independence at 14 months old.

3 Upvotes

I would like to hear advice and anecdotes about teaching clothing independence to a 14 month old.

My second born has been interested in the potty since forever even though we didn't do EC. I started letting her sit on my 3 year old's potty chair after taking her clothes off before bath/bed and she has now been peeing regularly in the potty and even makes the ssss ssss sound to me. We cloth diaper and she goes to daycare so we're not really planning on moving on from diapers until she's a bit older and can independently operate her own clothing and get herself on the potty (she's very short and can't reach our toilet + reducer even with a stool).

But I want to encourage the momentum and I'd like to focus on helping her learn how to push her own pants and diaper down so she can sit on the floor potty when she wants to. I remember teaching my first to do this by showing him how to hook his fingers around the waist and and push down but it seems too hard for my 14 month old, in part cause the pants get stuck on the bulky cloth diaper on the backside. Any ideas? Daycare said they're happy to work on potty training once she's independently able to push her pants down and pull them back up but I'm struggling to see how to get her to do it. Is this even realistic at this age or are people with kids this young who happily use the potty doing all of the clothing steps for them?


r/ECers • • 19h ago

Going diaper free with a 12 month old... I think the timing is right but second guessing myself.

1 Upvotes

We've been doing somewhat lazy EC with our daughter since she was 3 months old, and she's now 12.5 months. She started walking 2 days before her birthday so that milestone is now behind us. After searching through the go diaper free website and listening to the podcast (used to have the book but no longer do), I figured a couple weeks after her birthday was good timing since she had started walking independently and wasnt so focused on it. So for the last week or so we have been going diaper free at home during the day with diapers only for sleep, outings, or when we really just have to get stuff taken care of. We were using training undies but have found going commando or pantless seems the best for her and stopped using them for now. I know it's not meant to be a linear process but sometimes I worry we pulled them too early. We've been cleaning up so much pee and even some poop (she was consistently pooping on the potty for the most part for months) in pants or on the floor. She's back to pooping on the potty after about 3 or 4 days of missing (her natural timing for both poop and pee has shifted 😅🤯) and pees have had some really good days of getting lots of catches, and other days where she wont signal at all and just goes wherever she's at all day long. She's started to have a little bit of resistance the last 2 days and I wonder if it's because I'm too jumpy in assuming its what she needs. I'm trying to follow her lead. I've been reading through lots of posts on this sub and have seen a lot of people say they went diaper free between 16-22 months and it's really making me second guess if I timed it right or if it's too early? Based on her walking I thought it's a good time, but cognitively a 12 month old is very different from a 16 month old.

A few other things to consider.

We are traveling the first week of Dec, and I'm unsure what to expect. We have a portable potty reducer but she's been afraid of public bathroom stalls so I'm not sure how well it will go in a tiny airplane bathroom. Plus just being away from home in general. I'm expecting some kind of regression but any tips?

We don't have a floor potty, we have only ever used a reducer since she outgrew the top hat potty and she has always done really great with it. We don't have a lot of extra space in our house, so we haven't thought about getting one, but now I'm wondering if it would help her with independently going? She takes us or signals when she needs to, but doesn't always make it. We have a step but its kind of shallow so she can't get on and off the potty with it. My husband is too nervous about getting a bigger one because he doesnt want her to fall (I would teach her, he is just nervous about her getting hurt, which is fair, but I think she could learn to do it safely). Is our set up potentially making things harder for us? Would ut even make sense for her to try and learn a floor potty at this point?

Lot's of questions thank you in advance!


r/ECers • • 21h ago

Going from EC to pantless went fine but facing regression when I put him in underwear

1 Upvotes

I started Elimination Communication (EC) with my now 21 month old son at 6 months, and he’s been diaper-free at home since 11 months with very few accidents. Up until recently, I relied mostly on timing (45 minutes after fluids, after wake-ups, before leaving the house, coming back home) and subtle cues rather than him explicitly telling me he had to go.

Since I work from home, EC worked great for us, and I planned to wait until he was talking to fully potty train. However, we decided to start him in part-time daycare (2 days a week) at 20 months. But I learnt daycares generally don’t accommodate EC (which makes sense and its fine) so I wanted to transition him to full potty training before he started.

He has always grunted to signal poop, so a month before daycare, I taught him the sign for pee. It took a few weeks for him to connect the dots and sign it back to me when he was peeing on the toilet. Once he started daycare last month, I switched him to going completely bottomless at home. He picked it up quickly and within a few days he was consistently signaling his urges, and last week, we’ve had almost no accidents.

Starting this week, I finally put him in underwear and thought of letting the daycare know that he can sign to pee now but he has started peeing in them. I assumed going bottomless was the best bridge, so it feels like we're starting from scratch. The frustrating part is that he siesnt follow EC timings anymore and I have been wiping pee out of carpets the last few days. I am being adviced that he needs to go back in diapers which sounds like a bigger regression.

Has anyone else dealt with this? How did you get past the underwear hurdle?


r/ECers • • 16h ago

Does anyone else suspect that many babies are fussy because their parents AREN'T using EC?

0 Upvotes

Not at all about shaming. But it occurred to me that the only times I can ever recall my baby being fussy are when he's tired, hungry, or has to go potty.

Every circumstance has a very straightforward and predictable solution. I've never once encountered by baby as inconsolable.

Obviously, every baby is different and we are very likely to be just lucky with his disposition. But does anyone else think that some degree of colic and distress in babies in general could be solved with EC?


r/ECers • • 1d ago

Planning or Considering EC Tips on how to make partner convinced/hyped to try EC with first born?

2 Upvotes

Hi. We are expecting our firstborn baby boy in February.

I have been interested in ECing for a while, but struggle to get my partner (M 44yr) interested. He hasn’t said no to the idea, I just notice he is somewhat resistant/skeptical and not interested in doing research of his own. He believes he won’t mind diapering and considers changing diapers a form of quality time (which it also is).

Does someone know of any good resources specifically for men? Or YouTubers or anything - preferably by a man, made for a male crowd.

Also - it might not matter much anyways, as I’ll be the one at home with the baby the first 6-9 months, before dad has paternity leave. However, we will have a long parental leave (nearly 1,5 yr) before the child is guaranteed a daycare spot (due to strange Norwegian regulations), and it seems like a great opportunity to teach the baby diapers independance before daycare.

Thank you for any tips on the matter :)

Edit: Thank you, everyone, for the reassurance and helpful insight! This seems promising, and I appreciate the dads chiming in here for the paternal perspective ☺️


r/ECers • • 2d ago

EC Stories Rejoice! Caught three poops today.

21 Upvotes

We started EC a little over a month ago with the four easy catches and had enough success with pee to keep going but didn’t start off catching any poop. My baby girl is 10mo old and frequently poops in the high chair during meals so our only warnings came too late.

But! She’s started to poop when cued a little bit and has been using the potty more either right before meals or right after. And today she went on the potty three times which means I didn’t have to scrape a single cloth diaper today. What a victory.


r/ECers • • 1d ago

What to do about a newborn that poops while eating?

0 Upvotes

Our newborn poops while eating about 80% of the time. Very inconvenient for trying to put him down at night because changing him obviously wakes him but I feel like it would be very inconvenient to try to work on elimination communication. Anyone get through this?


r/ECers • • 2d ago

Feeling defeated with 13 month old...help!

5 Upvotes

We have been doing EC since 5/6 months old. She caught on pretty quickly and before long we were catching most poops and a few pees per day. Things were up and down for a while although catching poops stayed consistent after about 7 months. We were feeling really confident around 9-10 months, catching a lot of pees/poops and having consistent stretches of dry diapers.

Ever since 11ish months things seem to have gone steadily downhill. The biggest issue has been that she refuses to sit on the potty. We have a mini potty, a toilet seat reducer, and have done the EC hold (which she now refuses).

We backed off of EC for a while, but even diaper changes were dramatic, she'd start crying whenever we'd walk into the bathroom with her (where we change her). Things resolved a little with stand up diaper changes and sometimes she'll pee in the shower (not sure if this is good or not but it has helped us at least keep the habit of peeing outside of diapers up). We have gotten lucky catching maybe 1-2 poops per week the past 2-3 weeks.

I'm at a loss of what to do. Some stuff I read says it's a "potty pause" and to be patient and assured that she will get through it and the resistance will go away. Other things say the potty pause is a signal that she needs more control and suggests to get rid of diapers. I don't see how I can do that if she won't even sit?? (She is not quite walking yet)

She knows what the potty is, she will point to it and do the ASL sign. She used to sign after she peed but I don't think she has ever signed that she needs to go. That being said she seems to know what should be happening and seems to prefer eliminating in diapers (cloth).


r/ECers • • 2d ago

Rinsing off triggers more poo?

3 Upvotes

Pretty new to EC, but we’re getting into it with our 1 month old. Quite a bit of exciting success, and plenty of questions.

My first question is if anyone else has experienced what I’ve been noticing. I’m holding him in the traditional EC squat over the sink. I’m regularly getting some pee and poo, but when he seems finished and I rinse off his bum with warm faucet water (like a bidet, lucky kid) it seems to trigger him to really relax and suddenly he has an even bigger poo! He seems so calm for it. Is this normal or unique? How am I ever going to know when he’s actually done?

Also, curious how people can tell when the baby’s crying is a signal of discomfort in the EC hold or discomfort as they work through a poo?


r/ECers • • 3d ago

EC Stories Clueless parent, instant success anyway

34 Upvotes

I had a mental block about getting started. Where do I set up? How do I transition baby from the changing table to the potty without pee going everywhere? What are my cues? How will I know what's going on? Is this going to work with a 4w old preemie who's still only 38 gestational weeks old, or is this too much for him?

I decided to just try tonight after a feeding where baby was particularly awake. No harm in trying, right? I'd already had a diaper change with two golden showers earlier anyway.

So tonight I take his diaper off, quickly put him on the top hat potty, and he pees. Great! Unexpected! Easy, put him back on the changing table and realize OH WAIT, he's also pooping!! He's in the middle of pooping and now he's pooping on the changing table puppy pad!! Put him back on the potty ASAP and he proceeds to poop on the potty like a little adult. I didn't do anything! I started improvising a grunting cue to associate, but my brilliant baby had this all figured out without me, I just had to give him the opportunity.

I'm blown away. And feel like nobody in my life will believe me or care so I have to ramble about it here lol. Maybe it won't always be this simple going forward, but that was a heck of an encouraging start!


r/ECers • • 2d ago

Books & Resources Where to start

3 Upvotes

I have mountains of laundry waiting to be folded today… Does anyone have a YouTube video or podcast they recommend I can listen to so I know how and when to begin with my 13 month old? Thank you


r/ECers • • 3d ago

Starting EC at 10 months

4 Upvotes

Hi, I am looking into starting EC pretty late at 10 months for baby boy. Any recommendations and encouragement is appreciated! Which potty should I buy or should I get toilet reducer?


r/ECers • • 3d ago

Troubleshooting Baby boy wants to pee standing up

2 Upvotes

Has anybody else had their baby suddenly want to pee standing up? 3-4mo currently and he has not shown this behavior before?


r/ECers • • 3d ago

Overnight breastfeeding question

3 Upvotes

I discovered EC a little late but started two months ago around 16 months because my daughter was regularly pooping within 15 minutes of getting out of bed in the morning. (So maybe it's potty training? Lol doesn't matter...). She's now quite regularly doing most pees in the potty and telling me when she has to pee and sometimes even says "pee" when she has to poo. Unfortunately she doesn't poop every single morning anymore but that definitely helped her learn the sensation so we probably catch 2-4 a week.

She is now 18 months. We are breastfeeding and cosleeping so she feeds quite often overnight and when I say her overnight diaper is SATURATED that could be an understatement. I'm curious for those who breastfed their toddlers overnight how long it took them to stop going so much overnight or whether this is something that may just come with night weaning.

I'm also curious how to transition her to use a toilet because she told me she had to pee a couple weeks ago at a play group and they only had a toilet at that facility and she was very stressed and refused.

I'm also using pampers 360s, is there a large difference between them and pullups? Should I be switching soon?

Thanks! New to the game and I wish I'd seen this earlier because she's catching on quickly and I think she'd have done well even younger, but better late than never!

TIA


r/ECers • • 3d ago

FTM Need advice for 17 month old

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ECers • • 3d ago

Starting EC at 10 months

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ECers • • 4d ago

Do we „have to“ get them out of diapers before 18m?

8 Upvotes

Mine is 16mo and at home he only wears trainers, split pants, or nothing at the bottom. When we go outside, we put him in cloth diapers and offer the potty as soon as we get to our destination. For naps, he wears cloth diapers and for the night disposables.
Now I thought that the sensitive phase for pottying is 12-18mo, so I worry that I have to get him completely out of diapers by 18mo. Is this true?
He has good days where he points to the potty and uses it at every pottytunity I give him (mostly relying on timing/intuition/transition instead of signals). He‘s been telling me when his trainers are wet for the past couple of days, so that‘s new too.
He also has „bad“ days where he probably focuses on something else and doesn‘t care about peeing or even pooping and wets his fresh undies 20mins later. I‘m fine with this and should probably do an observation time to figure out his subtle signals, but also my goal would be that he tells me when he needs to go.

It‘s almost winter now, I don‘t know how to go out without diapers with all those layers. In the summer, if he gets wets, no big deal. In the winter, we don‘t have a second set of rain pants or tights and it would also be so much harder to feel whether he‘s wet.

I just don‘t know how to go on from our situation, any tips?


r/ECers • • 3d ago

Diaper Recs

2 Upvotes

Hello! I am only 27w but already planning to try EC since it just makes so much sense. Currently building a registry/shopping on FB marketplace for stuff.

Dumb question (maybe) for the group--do you use disposable newborn diapers or reusable ones? I'm imagining that I'll be taking them on and off a lot trying to catch the pee/poo.


r/ECers • • 3d ago

Troubleshooting 9m old hates the potty

2 Upvotes

I decided to start trying lazy EC'ing with my 9-month-old, since we're currently potty training her 3-yr-old sibling. Because of that, we have a little potty seat that rests on top of an adult toilet seat, and we also have a small separate floor potty. (I don't know if there are tiny baby-sized ones we should be using?).

I have tried putting my baby on both of these, but only 3 times so far. She gets agitated and upset every time.

Should I stop? Is she going to have negative associations with the toilet if I keep forcing it?

TIA!


r/ECers • • 4d ago

Troubleshooting How to catch newborn poops??

3 Upvotes

I read Andrea Olson’s book while pregnant so maybe I’ve forgotten her specific tips.

I’ve been attempting lazy EC recently. Baby is 6 weeks old and I’ve caught several pees around diaper change but can’t figure out poop.

Poops appear to be completely random. Not always during or after feeds. Some days we have two poops some days like six. I see no cues. I hear an explosion of gas and poop and by then it’s too late lol

Any tips??


r/ECers • • 4d ago

EC Stories 14 month old finally showing interest in the toilet

13 Upvotes

I just want to share my joy.

I started EC at 3 months, its been great and we had a period around 6 months old where I changed 3 poopy diapers in a month. I just held him in a squatting position over the toilet.

At 11 months we started using an adapted toilet seat, which he disliked the first two weeks but accepted it afterwards. Usually one or two poops in the toilet per day, rest in the diaper (we eat a lot of fiber). We always cheered and clapped our hands when he pooped in the toilet. He almost always pees in the toilet, even if he doesn't poop.

Last week after a poop he started verbalizing our word for poop and pointed at the toilet which I stupidly ignored. 2 minutes later he pooped in the diaper. Oh well, that's still progress!

Now for a few days straight he expresses his need to poop if we're near the bathroom and has started walking there himself. I am very very happy. I know he doesn't have proper sphincter control yet but I am very happy he sees the toilet as something fun. At daycare he was content at sitting on the toilet when they changed his diaper, even though he didn't poop.

I hope proper potty training will go smoothly


r/ECers • • 4d ago

General Questions Lazy EC works well at 12 months. How and when to move to potty training?

1 Upvotes

We started a few weeks ago. Now she doesn’t poop during solids meals anymore but she poops right after on the potty (and/or before and at random times, but she used to always poop during meals and she hasn’t done that since we started EC). She often pees in the potty too.

How do we move forward to encouraging more pees and poops to go in the potty?

She is 12 months old and we offer the potty after meals and after naps and after the night currently.

Thank you!