r/ECers • • Feb 13 '26

Infant pottying in a "mothercraft" book from 1959

Post image
224 Upvotes

Thought this was interesting! Book refers to this practice as "holding baby out".


r/ECers • • Mar 14 '26

My Son's EC Journey - Potty Trained at 18 Months

Post image
220 Upvotes

Wanted to post how it worked for us and to encourage parents to stick with it through the frustrations!

We started EC when my son was 7 weeks old. He would make very noticeable grunting noises when he was going to poo, so we could almost always catch them. We would sit him on and sing "potty potty potty" in the tune of the "bubble bubble" part of the Tiny Tim Turtle song, then make a humming noise. We did this consistently to get him to associate it with going in potty.

Once he was six months he never pooed in his nappy anymore and seemed to even hold it until he was on potty (but hard to know if true of course!). Pees were a lot harder to get a grip on. We always sat him on the potty when changing his nappy and caught some this way, however, most still in a nappy.

When he turned one we would give him nappy free time in the house (we have wooden floors) and this meant he knew when he peed himself and could feel it. Funny how they look so shocked the first few times, they get so used to absorbent nappies! Then I started to sometimes feel brave and take him out to local park in pants - I remember him doing a pee in the travel potty in the park and that was a high. But it seemed he wasn't holding for the potty, we were just "catching" them if we were lucky. He could tell us that pees and poos go in the potty but not able/not wanting to hold on yet. Around this time things got frustrating. He could say "poo" and would sometimes tell us but we felt he had a real regression and started pooing in his nappy again, just telling us after the fact. I felt we'd tried really hard with it and it was for nothing, he wasn't going to be potty trained any time soon.

Then at around 14 months, with perseverance and a lot of wet accidents and some poos in pants, and basically us just going for it and putting him in pants all day, something clicked. I'd count him as only truly potty trained at 18 months because that's when we stopped thinking about it and an accident became more of a rarity.

He's recently turned 2 and doesn't use the potty anymore, uses the toilet. He almost never has accidents (just on the odd occasion a pee and it is always a big surprise to him and us). He sometimes asks to go but mostly we remind him. We've had a lot of lovely comments on how little he is to be asking for the toilet and it's nice to have the toilet training over and done with before other parents are even starting out with it. Keep at it!


r/ECers • • Dec 02 '25

Potty piano

Post image
207 Upvotes

Sharing just for fun, thought this sub might appreciate my 5.5mo banging on the piano while on the potty


r/ECers • • Sep 10 '26

EC Stories 48 hours in for our 6 month old and my husband and I are hooked

193 Upvotes

This was something my mom talked me out of trying while I was pregnant.

We still did cloth diapers and free bum time.

6 months in and I got a good idea of when she will pee or poo. Every time I would see her pee or poo, I would just tell her "you did x!".

The other day I saw a video of sage.lynn.here (highly recommend her if you like crunchy stuff) talking about EC. I thought to myself that it wouldn't hurt to try!

I ordered a potty and the book "Go diaper free"

Omg.

Wow.

Now I had lots of misses the first 6 hours of the day - but man when I caught one, I got so excited. By the time my husband got home, LO and I were in the swing of things!!

My husband was like "mhm might just be a coincidence".

So we showed him. I said "let's go for a walk, but before we go, potty time!"

She didn't go. Perfect, our plan was in place.

We walked for an hour, we got back and I explained to him what to do.

He checked her diaper - dry. He put on the potty and said "potty time, pee pee?" And 5 seconds later she did a big pee! We showed him!!

My husband's jaw was to the ground! The rest of the evening we caught every single one when we offered! You could tell when we offered, she would think and then go within 30 seconds max.

Around 24 hours after my first attempt, we went to the doctors office. I offered her to pee in the public toilet when we got there and she did it!

I've only changed 2 diapers in the first 24 hours and haven't changed any since (not including overnight diapers).We are so amazed with how fast she picked it up and how happier she seems!

Also, more free bum time!!!


r/ECers • • Jul 26 '26

EC Stories Potty Trained at 11 Months: Our EC Success Story

177 Upvotes

Before I start, I just want to say that I know our outcome is unusual, especially at 11 months. Every baby is different, and this isn’t what I think everyone should expect, I simply wanted to share our journey because reading success stories here encouraged me so much when we started, and I hope ours might encourage someone else too ❤️

It all started when my mother in law (Middle Eastern) casually mentioned that she potty trained all three of her kids around 14 months.
I was absolutely shocked because I genuinely didn’t know that was even possible! She then continued to explain that, back then, if they peed on themselves the first few times, she would drip candle wax on them.
I was absolutely horrified. I adore my MIL and she’s a wonderful person and the best grandmother, but thankfully parenting has come a long way since then.

There was absolutely no way I was going down that road.
Still, the idea that babies could be out of diapers so young completely fascinated me. I started researching and stumbled across Elimination Communication and the rest is history.

We started when my daughter was 1 month old, right after my husband went back to work. I knew him well enough to know he probably wouldn’t get on board with what sounded like a weird new parenting idea unless he saw actual results.
That very first day, while he was at work, I caught her first poop by holding her over the toilet.
I was SO excited that I immediately sent him a picture… of the poop in the toilet 😂 He was completely mortified, but I think a tiny part of him was impressed too. From then on, I was hooked.

We continued holding her over the toilet for the first few months. Around 3 months, when she got heavier, we switched to using a small potty between our legs, which was much more comfortable.
We weren’t hardcore about EC. She wore regular disposable diapers the whole time. We simply offered the potty after every wake up, before leaving the house, and whenever she looked like she needed to go.
Before long we were catching essentially 100% of poops and around half of pees. Potty time became one of her favorite parts of the day.

Around 7 months she started signing “potty” occasionally.
By about 8 months she was signing consistently and was staying dry for days at a time despite still wearing diapers.
Then… 9½ months hit.
She got sick, and it was the biggest regression imaginable.
She completely stopped communicating. Her diapers were suddenly heavy all day long. She wouldn’t do anything on the potty no matter what I tried. I was soo frustrated. I felt like months of work had been for nothing.

Looking back, I realize two things were happening.
First, she had also just learned to say “mama” and “baba,” so I think she became focused on practicing those new communication skills instead of signing.
Second, and I think this mattered even more, I became stressed and frustrated. Potty time stopped being something fun and relaxed and became something I desperately wanted her to do. Babies really do notice these things and reciprocate.

The thing that turned everything around was giving her more independence. We switched to a floor potty that she could easily access herself, and she absolutely loved the autonomy. It was going fairly well (with a lot of toys bribe) , until exactly two days after she turned 11 months, when she started saying the potty word I’d always used while doing the sign. So i decided this would be the perfect time to try letting her roam around the house without a diaper.

Every time she had an accident, I calmly interrupted if I caught it happening, said, “Pee goes in the potty,” and sat her on the potty. I tried to make the experience positive and without shame.

The first day I was definitely overdoing it 😂 I kept trying to catch every pee before it happened and was asking her “mama potty? potty? potty?” every few seconds. I think this is probably something a lot of EC parents do in the beginning because you just want to get it right.
My MIL actually gave me the best advice without even knowing I was stressing: she said i MUST let her miss sometimes because that’s how they learn. So I stopped trying to prevent every single miss and started embracing them as part of the process.

Long story short (not so much) it has now been a few weeks. She wears underwear at home full-time, day and night (diaper only for travel), tells us she needs the potty by saying our potty word and doing the sign, and waits until we get her there. It still amazes me every day.

I’m such a proud mama!

More than the potty training itself, I honestly feel like EC changed the way we parent.
Learning to notice her tiny cues made both me and my husband much more observant and responsive parents. It taught us to really listen before she even had words. And I think it also taught her something so important: communication works. When you tell Mama and Baba you need something, they listen and help you.

Anyway, I just wanted to share our story because this community encouraged me so much when we started. EC has been so much more than potty learning for us, it strengthened our bond and taught us to really listen to our baby.

And to anyone still in the messy middle: keep going, trust your baby, and don’t forget to enjoy the process!

Good luck❤️


r/ECers • • Jan 31 '26

EC Stories Blown away by my 9 month old

153 Upvotes

I started casually doing EC a few weeks ago. I just put her on the toilet and she went right away. Since then, we’ve had no poopy diapers other than one time my mom was watching her and missed the cue. I actually can’t believe it. It’s like she doesn’t want to go in her diaper any more (which I don’t blame).

Yesterday she was fighting her nap so hard. Rolling around babbling but face and eyes all red. Then she had one stinky fart and I was like oh maybe she has to poo and she’s holding it cause she doesn’t want to go in her diaper? I took her to the toilet and she immediately pooped and the went right to bed.

Anyways, this is crazy. I actually just can’t believe how well it’s working so far.


r/ECers • • May 17 '26

EC Stories It worked y’all, we’re potty trained at 16 months

147 Upvotes

First thing before launching in- yall probably all know this, but potty training at 16 months does not look the same as it does at 2 or 3. 16 month olds do not have the dexterity to handle toileting on their own, the language to fully communicate they have to go, or the physical development to be potty trained over night. We’re calling it potty trained because he 1) rarely has accidents and usually has dry days 2) we don’t use diapers except overnight 3) when we go out he consistently comes back in the exact same undies and cloths we left in, and 4) he cues us himself over half the time. But it’s potty training not potty independence and its mostly still on is to accurately read his cues and handle toileting.

Okay, so launching in. We started very lazy “elimination communication” at around 3 months. I was am a stay at home dad and was pretty determined at the beginning but petered off a good deal. Basically what it looked like was setting him on a very tiny baby toilet at wakes, after getting home, and after meals and occasionally starting to “read” his signals on if he was about to go. Aside from that we used disposable diapers and honestly most were caught there. I think the biggest thing this helped with was just normalizing him to going on the toilet and training me as a parent to understand his bathroom rhythms and cues.

Around 14 months he started going on his own to his toilet to try to pee sometimes, without us asking him to. A month or so prior to that he’d also stopped pooping outside the house and consistently waited til we were home to do it. We decided to try full potty training at this point (expanded below) but by day 2 he started crying when we sat him on the toilet so we decided to pause and retry later. He also seemed to pee like 30 times a day which didn’t help lol. Now he pees more like 12 times- still high but more workable.

At 15.5 months we seemed to have a new milestone of him really solidly grabbing himself and looking at us every time he had to go so we decided to try again. We went on a vacation and basically kept him naked whenever we were in the hotel room (tile floors) and tried to bring him to toilet any time he started peeing.

When we got back we launched into it fully. Puppy pads on all rugs (which he constantly pulled up) and him naked from the waist down inside. At home days 1-3 I stayed on him just tracking him 24/7 and moving him to the toilet if he started going. It was exhausting. We also timed every 30 or so minutes and after meals/naps/before and after going out, setting him on the toilet to see if he needed to go. Successful potties got tons of applause and a tiny treat or sticker. Accidents we stayed very calm and just did a “whoopsie, we potty in the toilet and would bring him over.” Days 1-3 we still diapered when we went outside but brought a portable toilet to try after 30 or so minutes.

Day 4 we started going out just in underwear (we use light training underwear s and brought a portable potty and many changes of underwear and clothes). At home we started picking up the puppy pads and stopped setting him every 30 minutes. Days 4 saw many carpet pees, one poop that he decided to try and clean up on his own while I left for two seconds to grab a towel (hellish experience), and two accidents on the way to the park. Day 5 saw 2 carpet pees and one when we went outside. Day 6 was a mostly dry day except the beginning of a pee where he stopped himself and ran to us.

Most days since have been 0-1 accidents. After two-ish weeks we put underwear back on inside and mostly relied on his cues and set times (after nap, wake up, getting home, meals) for toileting.

We’re at 3 weeks since starting and it feels like it genuinely stuck. Though now he’s starting to try to stand and pee and his aim is awful so that’s a fun new issue. I’m sure there will be regressions- daycare, travel, illness, etc. But it’s working and I’m counting it now.

Some important notes- this hasn’t been a process that demanded perfection, just consistency. Day 5 saw our dryer break down and I put him back into a diaper for an hour or so while I troubleshot that. We’re human, our kid is human, a quick break is not going to cause you to lose all progress. We also were pretty big on not wanting it to feel stressful for our kid. When he was getting visibly upset about it at 14 months, we paused. When he just didn’t want to go to the bathroom on the toilet those first few days, we let him get up and accidents happened.

Also progress is NOT purely linear. Day 2 was worse than day 1, day 4 was the most accidents of all, and random days he just chugs too much water too quickly and have an accident or 2 when he can’t figure out he has to go fast enough. And pooping took longer to stick than pees. The process took “2 weeks” not including all the EC before that. And I think it mostly stuck because he was genuinely ready.

Anyway, that’s all! Hope this helps any parents considering trying potty training from EC.


r/ECers • • Sep 30 '25

An unexpected benefit to EC

147 Upvotes

I’ve never been happier that we did EC/lazy EC with my little one. My 19 month old spiked a high fever and we took him in to the pediatrician. They wanted to do a catheter for a urine sample but I told them that he pees on the potty. They were shocked and very impressed when we came back with the top hat full of pee. What a relief for me to not put my toddler through a catheter when he had already screamed his head off over an ear thermometer.


r/ECers • • Sep 08 '24

EC Stories Former ECer now with a fully potty trained toddler: It’s worth it!

146 Upvotes

Just came here to say don’t give up and EC is the way to go! We did a quasi-method of EC: we only caught poops starting at about 6 months, about the time my daughter could sit up independently. We also cloth diapered. We are working parents and I didn’t have the consistency to try full EC. Friends and our parents thought we were crazy. Pay no attention to these people. EC not only made cloth diapering easier/more convenient, it’s made potty training a breeze. Around 18 months, we started encouraging my daughter to walk to the training potty when she needed to go, at 25 months she was going both pee and poop on the potty with some prompting and now at 28 months we are fully trained, going on about a month of no accidents. She’s only had 1 poop accident since 18 months and it was due to an illness. She’s the youngest in her school fully potty trained and my friends no longer think I’m crazy- they think this is incredible. (It is!)

If you are here trying to decide if you should, this is your sign that it’s 100% worth it, even if you only do it part-time. Also a great lesson in parenting, children are capable of doing things, we just have to give them the tools and support to build independence!

This has been a great community and resource for me as we navigated this part of our parenting journey. I just wanted to give something back as we have graduated from this stage. Thanks everyone, One Proud Mama


r/ECers • • Jan 03 '26

Blown away that my 14-month-old consistently tells me when she has to poop

139 Upvotes

I started EC at 5 months not even knowing EC was a thing because my mom told me she put me on the potty starting at 5 months and that I was potty trained very quickly, so I also wanted to try it for my own baby.

My baby would grunt very loudly whenever she started pooping so the second I heard her grunt I would rush over and rip her diaper off and put her on the potty and grunt with her. I only did that, plus very lazy and inconsistent potty time after naps. My only goal was to avoid poop in diapers since I cloth diaper. I do catch some pees but let most pees still just go in a diaper.

We were mostly poop trained at 10 months. It was still a little inconsistent since she goes to daycare part time and they won't do EC there.

Now at 14 months I am astounded at what she can do. She started consistently signing for the potty and grunting to tell me she has to poop. I say "Do you have to poop?" and she nods her head yes. Then I put her on the floor potty with a few toys and leave here there while I do other things around the house close by and when I come back there's poop in the potty every time. She isn't bothered by sitting on the potty at all because she's so used to it now.

Sometimes when I ask if she's all done but there's more poop to come, she shakes her head no. Sometimes when I asked if she's all done and she doesn't really respond I try to lift her off the potty and if she's not done she'll actually bear her weight down and start shaking her head no vigorously and continue to sign "more" or "potty". When she does this sometimes I don't trust it because she's been on the potty for so long or already pooped so much I think she definitely must be done, but give her like 5 more minutes and am shocked when MORE poop comes out!!!!

Her bodily awareness with pooping blows me away at such a young age. When I started EC I always thought it just meant following cues and catching at just the right moments, but never thought it possible that EC would actually lead to them actually understanding a poop is coming and preemptively asking for the potty. And my LO still doesn't even say any words or walk yet!

I just wanted to share this because none of my mom friends do EC and one of them told me it's some weird "granola fringe thing". So I don't talk about it with anyone. But wanted to share this win with Reddit!


r/ECers • • Oct 05 '25

Baby Potty Setup - What Works for Us

Post image
137 Upvotes

I’ve been doing lazy EC with my 9m LO since she was 3 months. I found a setup that works well for us and wanted to share!

I put LO down on the mat to remove the diaper, then immediately put her on the potty. I move the diaper out of the way and lay down a wipe, and when she’s done, I put her right on the wipe to keep the mat clean.

The stool: When I started, I was kneeling down on the ground and it was wrecking my knees. Now I use a fold-up step stool, which made a huge difference! I bend down to sit on the stool (while holding baby), then transfer LO to the mat. Bonus: the stool can be used as a squatty potty postpartum!

The mat: I didn’t want to put LO directly on the bathroom floor, and I had a waterproof liner originally purchased for my dog’s crate. It’s basically a washable puppy pad. Perfect for keeping her off the floor and it doesn’t move around like a regular Chux pad. Easy to throw in the wash!

I put a wipe on the puppy pad before I put baby back down to put her diaper back on. This helps keep the puppy pad clean. Then I use that same wipe to wipe her.

The potty: I used the Baby Bjorn potty from the start. I tried using the insert as a top hat potty but it seemed awkward. It was a little pricey but I like it much better than the Ingenuity potty I tried. The Baby Bjorn has a wider bowl so it’s easier to clean without my hands hitting the walls.

Essential supplies: I keep a basket with wipes, diapers, Aquaphor and a bum spatula.


r/ECers • • Jun 13 '26

EC Stories Didn't expect to try it 4 days PP Spoiler

Post image
127 Upvotes

So I wasn't expecting to be able to do this four days post-partum with stitches, still at the birthing home, but here's how elimination communication has gone.

It started this morning with the observation that she was fussing and I was thinking that maybe she was already pooping, so I waited a little bit, and then we decided to try to change her. There was no poop in the diaper. She started peeing on the waterproof mat and it was sliding off onto the bed. 😅

I didnt expect that cue for pee. It was like she was bearing down and pushing.

Then we held her over what we had out, the wipe/water bowl, but there was nothing. We moved too soon. She started peeing on the mat again.

She was upset from being covered in pee so I gave her the boob to calm down. We tried diaper-free time at that point and blowing on her bottom but she was probably done at that point.

So we concluded that sort of fussing was her cue for the potty, so when we noticed it the next time today, we decided to try EC.

We opened the diaper and there was already pee and some of the water-soluble poop. So we put her over the bucket which was sitting steady on a big plate on the bed.

She started going poop! We were impressed! She seemed to be done when she cried. We wiped her off and put on a clean diaper. We were glad that we didn't have to clean up that mess in her diaper.

We will still wait to start cloth diapers bc I didnt take the time to teach my husband the folds and cleaning system beforehand and now I can't sit up long.


r/ECers • • 17d ago

Potty Training I have no one else to share this with - almost potty trained at 18 months

125 Upvotes

Today was the first day we did undies outside the house. Was out for two hours and went to 3 different places - stopped to offer a pee at the library half way through and she went.

She’s now napping in the same undies. No accidents.

Will see how the rest of the day goes but this is only day 3 wearing undies full time!


r/ECers • • Oct 31 '20

Really annoyed about recent anti-vaxx post by Andrea Olson on social media platforms

117 Upvotes

If people want to disagree with me and share their anti-vaccine viewpoints here, so be it I’ll remain civil. And maybe this post will be deleted by moderators anyways. But I’m just annoyed and wanted to see if anyone else is to so we can have that moment of solidarity. I’ve depended on her materials so much over the years and I’m just like....how do I recommend them to others if I fear it contributes to spreading of dangerous messages? Are there other resources I should recommend instead?


r/ECers • • Feb 21 '23 This

My baby is potty trained and I can’t brag to anyone but you

112 Upvotes

Potty trained or whatever you call the successful conclusion of EC!

We’ve been doing EC light since about 5 months. She just turned 2 last month and she communicates before she pees and poops every time and hasn’t had an accident in like a week or something. This is so different than my first daughter which was exactly the point in going this route! I feel validated and so pleased. And I feel like I can’t brag to anyone I know because I don’t want to gloat. So thank you for listening! That is all 😍 She still wears a diaper overnight so I’m not getting cocky…


r/ECers • • Apr 02 '26

Amazed with our Newborn Experience

108 Upvotes

I did EC with my eldest daughter from 6 months to avoid cleaning up poops off our cloth diapers after starting solids. This whole practice was mind blowing. She caught on super quick, our whole family was amazed and on board to make it happen. We ended up ditching diapers at 16 months and never had to go through the potty training thing.

That ended up being such a wonderful experience that when I got pregnant again, we decided that we would do EC from birth this time around and really wished that we knew about all this sooner with our first.

Idk what I was expecting but I am somehow yet again finding myself amazed at what's happening. It started kind of rocky and we had a tough time catching a whole lot, but stuck to it. All of a sudden it seems almost overnight she started making this very specific grunting noise when she needs to pee and a Zoolander face when she needs to poop. I feel like we cracked some sort of a secret code because we can go multiple hours in one clean diaper while catching everything on the potty and she is not even 2 months old!

EC is absolutely amazing and I will never again look at diapering the same way after all this. Yay for clean booty club!


r/ECers • • Sep 30 '26

My family laughed in my face and it only made me want to do it more

106 Upvotes

I’m not due until the end of March and today at a family dinner I brought up elimination communication. I started by saying I know this is ambitious but this is my goal. My family (specifically my aunt who has a 5 yo and a 1.5 yo) laughed in my face saying it was impossible and completely made up. Needless to say their disbelief has only made me want to succeed even more.

Any tips and tricks? Books or anything I should read to get more prepared??


r/ECers • • Sep 12 '26

EC Stories Fart Based EC

101 Upvotes

Elimination communication with my 11 month has been going so/so lately. Lots of bucking and fussing on the potty even when I know she has to go.

This morning she was starting to get grumpy, and as I squatted down to better steady her, I farted. She looked at me consideringly, and farted back. I had more to give so I farted again. She smiled, pushed again and pooped. This isn’t the elimination communication I read about but I’ll take it 😂

(Jokes aside, I’m not very worried about the fussing. My first was similar when working on walking and I trust it’ll pass like most stages. But if anyone has tips to make this stage easier I’m all ears)


r/ECers • • Dec 03 '25

I don’t know why everyone doesn’t just do this?

101 Upvotes

I feel like I’ve stumbled onto a well kept secret and am honestly now stupefied at how western countries have largely lost this practice to time.

My daughter is 7 weeks old today and I’ve been wanting to try EC with her from birth but have delayed it until now because I thought there would be a steep learning curve. We’re doing cloth nappies and Im already sick of all the laundry, so I started this morning with her squatting over an old Tupperware container and have caught every poo and pee (except one) the whole day?? She seems so relieved that this basic need of comfort is being met and I’m just blown away at how natural this seems. I know it won’t be so clear cut every day but it’s so much easier than dealing with dirty nappies, even disposables, because it also seems to eliminate a lot of unexplained fussing, distraction during nursing etc.

Have you heard of anyone trying EC and stopping? The only reason I can think of why it’s not more common is because many people simply haven’t heard of it or given it a decent try


r/ECers • • Aug 22 '21

A cautionary tale

98 Upvotes

This is gonna be long and probably go on some tangents but writing this out and reflecting on it has been good.

I had a realization this morning.

My almost 4 year old who I EC’d from about 8 months and I were constantly yelling. It wasn’t always a high stress environment until EC and beyond. Sure, you could say that it’s the developmental stage or the terrible threes, but I’m an adult and was acting like the toddler! I think EC contributed to me being a very controlling parent and now in retrospect I think if I handled it differently my daughter and I would not build up so much anxiety off of each other.

Regarding the EC part, she was out of diapers during the day by 1 y/o. And out of night time diapers probably around 18 months. I consider EC to have gone super successfully, and I have been on this sub sharing our experience with it and have really enjoyed it.

The rest of the post is about… something.. else? It’s about how I essentially became an EC helicopter parent. Regressions. Potty pauses. Non-diapered accidents in public places. I had a big need to figure out and control these things and it grew into helicoptering every other aspect of play/life for my toddler and it cause some negative things.

I had a talk with my mom awhile back about “I used to not be so shitty and mad and controlling all the time. When did I become like this?!” And today it finally clicked when I thought back to just how much focus I put on EC. Whenever I fixate on some things I go all in, so I took EC super seriously.

Those first catches were exciting and before I knew it I was always. Next. To. Her. Waiting for the next catch so it wouldn’t happen on the floor. It still did once in awhile and I dramatized it (along so many other things) so much (not in a shameful way but in a “omg what happened?!” way). That’s a parenting tip that failed me, to overdramatize things - it just created a bunch of anxiety like her freaking out every time she would spill something on herself or the floor or otherwise get wet somehow - it became the end of the world because of how I was teaching her to react in essence. Instead of “oh let’s clean up that little mess” it was “OMG OH NO WHAT A BIG MESS who’s gonna clean that up?! We need towels and cleaner and there’s so much pee it’s gonna make the floor smelly and slippery and your shirt is wet WHY ARE YOU CRYING NOW. “ Yeah. I cringed typing that.

BecauseI was always on watch for a catch I was always next to her and I believe that hindered a lot of independent play. It turned into me doing the playing for her somehow. We always showed her stuff that would be slightly beyond her physical/developmental ability and I think that’s a direct correlation to getting so mad that she can’t manipulate object the way she’s seen us adults do it. She never really explored toys at her own pace- even with age/developmentally appropriate toys there was always a grandparent showing and correcting her with “the right way” to hold a toy guitar. The right way to hold a paintbrush. The right way to make a doll stand up. The right way to turn a page. I know now that’s just a terrible way to handle everything because as soon as that happened she would start getting frustrated and yelling “no I don’t want to” and then drop the toy or stop trying or scream “I can’t do it”. Even now, when she can’t get something “just right” she’ll still scream in frustration and give up because either us parents or grandparents always there to fix it for her immediately. She doesn’t come to anyone with a problem or toy because she expects us to come to her. Immediately. I think it’s less of the “she trained you to do what she wants you to hur da dur” explanation and more of we all contributed to creating this problematic dynamic. When she was younger I thought I was being helpful, I thought I was “scaffolding” her learning, but it soon turned into frustration and I would be screaming and yelling about how this doll can’t move its limbs like the other doll because it don’t have joints or whatever. It was a loooong road to build her confidence for independent play, resilience, and patience and I would kill any progress by yelling at her when she was getting frustrated. It would make me angry that she’s angry. It would make me resentful that she can’t just play by herself for a minute without screaming about something going wrong. Kids learn through play and I’m not a kid and I don’t WANT to play right now OK?! I couldn’t keep MY emotions under control and my whole household was feeling the effects yet I expected my toddler to control her emotions. I wanted to be a better parent and I would read so much helpful stuff. And it did help my daughter but I would just be so angry and triggered all the time -very specifically- by my child and their actions. How many things I’ve read explaining dealing with problematic kids behaviors but never delving into the problem with my behavior. Finally I got some medication and coping skills to deal with being so controlling and angry and have been working on reversing anxiety and I can see my daughter being better able to regulate her own emotions and -very importantly- I am too. We’re all doing better now. There’s less yelling. Less crying. Lots of self driven independent play.

I loved EC and don’t blame it. I will 100% do EC again if I have another child. What I do blame is the attitude I approached it with and how it morphed into some kind of personal competition/control.

It’s just only in hindsight and self reflection that I’m able to look at the bigger picture and connect the dots of how eeeeeeverything really negatively snowballed from one thing into another.


r/ECers • • Sep 18 '26

EC is Crazy

95 Upvotes

Just sitting here thinking…. My 6.5 month old hasn’t pooped in a diaper in like 3 months. He poops once a day in the morning on the toilet. We offer the potty later in the day sometimes but really he just likes his morning poo. We started at 3 weeks and he just prefers a potty he always has. He would wait until we changed his diaper and offered the tophat and he’d poo his brains out. Cute little guy. Now he’s just a morning potty lad.


r/ECers • • Aug 25 '24

EC Stories First self-initiated potty 🥹

92 Upvotes

I was sitting on the couch and my 13 month old started walking in the direction of the bathroom. He stopped and then started making noise to get my attention. When I asked him what's the matter, he crawled towards his potty chair and picked the seat. So I said "do you need to go potty?" and brought him to toilet where he pooped!

I can't believe it. Just last month he was in the midst of a potty strike and I thought we were done with EC.


r/ECers • • Jan 16 '26

Unbelievable results 16m old

80 Upvotes

I posted here about 8 days ago in utter despair and I can't believe that after just sticking with no nappy (diaper) I can confidently say my 16m old is potty trained whilst at home, I'm going to start her wearing pants out and about from Monday. She's signalling all the time and she's even dry through the night and for her naps.

I literally cannot believe that I can now tell from her face and her movements what's going on with her body, I always thought this was for other parents and not me but apparently anyone can learn anything 😂 thank you everyone for kind words and advice!!


r/ECers • • Sep 27 '21

I did EC from birth with my second baby. Here's how it went!

80 Upvotes

I didn't find out about EC until a while after having my first baby. I started EC with him when he was 6 months old and then wrapped up at 19 months. It was a bit challenging at times, but overall I loved EC so much I knew I'd start from birth if I had another.

Since I already had experience with EC it felt totally natural to start right at birth with my second. He had his first poop on the potty when he was 1 day old :) it was so exciting to see how babies just know what to do!

As time went on, I found it very easy to read his signals and it was quite rare he would use a diaper. We would mostly do naked time when we were at home. We only have hardwood floors, so any mess was very easy to clean. Then we would use diapers while out and at night.

By the time he was 13 months old, he would get very upset whenever we put a diaper on him. He'd even hide the diaper that I'd pull out with his clothes. So at 14 months I decided to stop diapers completely (both day and night). I'd never done EC at night with him before this. Wrapping up went shockingly well for only being 14 months old. Obviously at first it was mostly EC without a diaper but he quickly started directly letting me know when he needed to go by pointing. After the first week he really hasn't had any accidents day or night. By the time he was ~ 17 months old he would take himself to the toilet for all his pees. He doesn't need me to go with him or to ask him. When he needs to poop he still points because he needs me to get him on the toilet and for wiping obviously.

The journey wasn't totally linear though. Before he was 14 months we had gone through "potty pauses" and a big chuck of time when he'd prefer the floor to the toilet 😒 but overall it was a rewarding and mostly easy journey.

If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer. Just thought I'd share our successful EC experience from birth!


r/ECers • • 9d ago

EC Stories At 4 months I’m already regularly getting dry diapers day and night!

79 Upvotes

We’ve been doing what I would call lazy EC since LO was 1 week old, mostly just to give it a try and see what we thought of it. We had so much fun catching his pees and poo’s (especially because his poops cracked us up with how explosively loud they sounded). We’re not strict about EC, but we try our best. For the past week my LO has seemed even more responsive to all the pottytunities that we give him. Right before every nap and immediately after. And I offer him the potty at 1:30am and around 4:30am. And seriously y’all he seems to be HOLDING it and waiting for the potty!! So many dry diapers and immediate release of pee and poo when he’s given the potty. It’s incredible and I almost can’t believe it! Obviously we still get some wet/dirty diapers but I’m blown away by how well it’s going.

I just wanted to celebrate with EC community here but also encourage yall that it’s so worth it, even if you’re doing it “lazy” :) babies don’t want to soil themselves, and if you’re consistent enough they’ll work with you! (hopefully I’m not jinxing us lol)