r/DebateaCommunist • • Jan 01 '12

/r/DebateaCommunist, we need to talk. This HAS to stop.

76 Upvotes

Rules: Do not downvote for a difference of opinion. The only posts that should ever be downvoted is Spam or personal attacks.

Take a look at this. http://imgur.com/MvhKd

These are some of the many, many, examples of downvoted posts I've encountered recently. It doesn't matter even if it's wrong. This isn't /r/politics. The PURPOSE of this subreddit is to have a debate. If people can't even speak their mind without fear of being downvoted into oblivion, how can anyone except a Communist try and have a debate?

This subreddit isn't for the Communists. It's for the Anarcho-Capitalists, the Free Market Capitalists, the Austrian and neoliberal economists, and those that still believe that Capitalism is the best possible system. This subreddit was created for the purpose of discussion. If you downvote any Capitalist who tries to post, no matter even if they are wrong, you'd be hurting the movement, drive them away, and appear like a circlejerk.

I've been getting a lot of complaints from people, and as much as I'd like to say that they were easily offended, the truth is that they brought up a very legitimate point, and that in a debating subreddit, much of what is going on in here is totally unacceptable. Many of the Capitalists here are invited on my behalf, and you guys are making me look bad. Remember, the Capitalists are the guests here. Not us. If you invite a guest to your home, you are expected to treat them with courtesy. I don't see why this should be any different.

We are NOT a circlejerk.

Downvotes are for spam and personal attacks only.

Do not downvote for a difference of opinion.

Thanks.

<3 Tux.

Edit: Also, please please no personal attacks.

You understand why I have to hold you guys to a higher standard of etiquette that the Capitalists I invite here? If someone doesn't understand something, patiently explain to them. If someone doesn't understand about the Labour Theory of Value, or the Tendency for profit to fall, or the hundreds of other Marxist theories that exist out there, calling them ignorant isn't going to help them to understand. Don't drive them away.

Many Capitalists are very, very, intelligent people. Don't treat them like idiots. The only reason they remain one is because of circumstance, or lack thereof. Explain patiently, or don't explain at all.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Nov 18 '12

The FAQ says in order to post here I need to accept that there has never been a communist nation. Would you also agree that there has never been a capitalist nation?

63 Upvotes

In my view there are two possible ways we could construct reasonable definitions for "capitalist" or "communist" nations:

  • A nation is capitalist (or communist) if almost all material wealth is wholly privately owned (or collectively owned), and if almost all relevant laws and regulations respect the right of the individual (or collective) to make peaceful decisions about how to utilize and dispose of that material wealth, and those laws are almost always upheld.

  • A nation is capitalist (or communist) if a majority of all material wealth is essentially privately owned (or essentially collectively owned), and if a majority of relevant laws and regulations respect most rights of the individual (or collective) to make decisions regarding that wealth, subject to some limitations, and those laws are usually upheld.

Under the second definition, we can point to numerous examples of capitalist countries (the U.S. between 1815 and 1860, the Icelandic Commonwealth, medieval Ireland, and so on and so forth). Similarly, we can point to numerous examples of communist countries (North Korea, Castro's Cuba, Mao's China, etc.). Under the first definition, where we require rigid adherence to the strictest property rights understanding of the terms "capitalism" and "communism," there are no examples of either system being fully implemented outside of perhaps a few intentional communities with populations numbering only in the thousands. Certainly there has never been any large, sustained nation in modern times which fits the literal definitions of "communist" or "capitalist."

In the past I have heard some communists dismiss this argument by claiming that the American government is actually a capitalist tool, and therefore all a part of the capitalist system. I can assure you that this is absolutely pure magical thinking. Go talk to any small business owner, or any tax-paying Republican, or really just about anyone in the world, and ask them if the government is a tool of capitalism. The government is in its founding, in its definition, in its constitution, fundamentally anti-capitalist. Businessmen don't want it, workers don't need it, and capitalists have vociferously argued against it for centuries.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Mar 31 '12

A new form of debate: An invitation to Civcraft, where Minecraft meets politics

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/DebateaCommunist • • Mar 10 '12

"He's paying you $75 a day to tell him to work faster!"

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/DebateaCommunist • • Jan 23 '12

Why don't you guys put your money where your mouths are and start a bunch of worker owned companies?

42 Upvotes

It seems like communism has such a bad name because there are practically no examples of it working. Why not take a risk and start a few worker based business/communes/kibbutzim? Just start a llc where everyone owns an equal amount of shares and pay dividends? Then when your system is working on the small scale and your businesses blossom due to lack of worker exploitation, the rest of the world will take you more seriously?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Feb 24 '13

Please don't ask questions like "but how will people wipe their asses in communism?".

41 Upvotes

... because no communist knows. The point is that all we know about communism is that it is stateless, classless and moneyless. We know how to get there (every tendency has it's own theory on that at least), but we can not know exactly how it will be, because contrary to everyone else, we are materialists, and do not pretend we can know exactly how humanity will handle itself based on some abstract notion about "what people generally do".

We firmly believe that humanity will be able to produce what it wants in such a society and distribute it correctly. Humans have a record of thousands of years of finding new ways to produce the things it needs and will continue to do so without markets or price signals, and it will most likely be better at it than we are now.

If you wish to ask or debate something about Marxist, Leninist, Maoist, Luxemburgist, Bordigist theory, or whatever other tendencies comrades have managed to come up with, we will be happy to oblige, but this is getting tiring, and frankly, it's pointless

Sincerely, Communists

Edit: It will be front to back


r/DebateaCommunist • • Mar 04 '12

Lenin, Trotsky, and the Bolsheviks were counter-revolutionary

40 Upvotes

First of all, the Bolshevik takeover took place after the revolution had kicked out the Tzar and established democracy. Lenin's actions did not bring about democracy but ended it. The Russian Constituent Assembly established by the February Revolution was imperfect, but still a democratic institution. The Bolsheviks took over in the "October Revolution", but this was not a mass uprising of revolutionaries. The Bolshevik party tightly organized the takeover of the government by a relatively small group of Bolsheviks and supporting military personnel in Petrograd. It was more of a coup than a revolution.

The Bolsheviks had seized power before elections could be held for it, but went ahead with elections anyway. Before the election even began, Lenin made it clear that he had no intention of being bound by votes. In the election, Bolsheviks only received half the votes the Socialist Revolutionaries did. The Russian people had made it clear they did not support Bolshevik rule. The Constituent Assembly met once, where it agreed to end the war with Germany and carry out land reform. Bolshevik soldiers and the Red Guard shut down the assembly, and the Bolsheviks took control of the country. Lenin claimed that the Constituent Assembly was undemocratic, and the workers' soviets throughout the country were a better, more democratic way to run the country. That may have been true, but soviet rule is not what Lenin established after taking over.

Lenin spoke a great deal about democracy and worker control, but he consistantly worked against such things. The All-Russian Soviet of Factory Committees had been established earlier in the revolution, giving the workers democratic control over their factories. The assembly proposed a Provisional All-Russian People's Economic Council, which would grant the workers democratic control over the economy. Lenin rejected it. They went on to propose an All-Russian Council for the Regulation of Industry, which meant to keep the factory committees from being integrated into the state. The proposal also cut out union bureaucracy and capitalist employers from factory management. A Bolshevik spokesman said "It is necessary to make an absolutely clear and categorical reservation that the workers in each enterprise should not get the impression that the enterprise belongs to them." Lenin's decree on worker control said that workers' decisions could be annulled by trade unions and congresses. Additionally, the committees were subordinated to the Russian Council of Workers Control, where the workers' committees had 5/21 seats. according to the Bolshevik government's General Instructions on Workers' Control, "the right to issue orders relating to the management, running and functioning of enterprises remains in the hands of the owners." Kommunist, a left-wing journal, criticized Bolshevik policy, so the Bolsheviks demanded it was shut down.

While the Bolsheviks were consolidating power in the cities, anarchist peasants and cossacks in Ukraine were rising up all on their own. The Bolsheviks, unable to gain any control in anarchist Ukraine, attempted to use it as a bargaining chip with Germany. The anarchists formed the Revolutionary Insurrectionary Army of Ukraine, or Black Army, to resist foreign control, fight Ukrainian nationalists, and resist the White Army. They were willing to ally with the Red Army, but did not accept its authority. When the Germans withdrew after allied victories, the Bolsheviks betrayed the Blacks and moved south. Trotsky had to replace the local Red soldiers with Chinese and Latvian troops because so many were defecting to the Blacks. Trotsky murdered villagers and allowed Tzarist cossacks to devastate the countryside to finally defeat the Blacks. When the anarchists made a deal with the Red Army, they were tricked into a meeting where they were greeted by a firing squad.

In 1921, there was a mass meeting of Petrograd workers over closed factories, abysmal rations, and the lack of clothes. The Bolshevik-controlled government banned such meetings. Strikes were opposed by Bolshevik soldiers, and demonstrations were blocked by Red Army cavalry, but the unrest still spread. The strikers called for freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom of assembly, and end to the Cheka. The Bolsheviks suppressed the workers' uprising with martial law and mass arrests.

In the naval base of Kronstadt, the sailors were kind of pissed. They had been hardcore revolutionaries, participating in the Bolshevik takover in 1917 and acting as communist shocktroops during the civil war. The sailors drafted fifteen demands:

  1. Immediate new elections to the Soviets. The present Soviets no longer express the wishes of the workers and peasants. The new elections should be by secret ballot, and should be preceded by free electoral propaganda.

2. Freedom of speech and of the press for workers and peasants, for the Anarchists, and for the Left Socialist parties.

3. The right of assembly, and freedom for trade union and peasant organisations.

4. The organisation, at the latest on 10th March 1921, of a Conference of non-Party workers, solders and sailors of Petrograd, Kronstadt and the Petrograd District.

5. The liberation of all political prisoners of the Socialist parties, and of all imprisoned workers and peasants, soldiers and sailors belonging to working class and peasant organisations.

6. The election of a commission to look into the dossiers of all those detained in prisons and concentration camps.

7. The abolition of all political sections in the armed forces. No political party should have privileges for the propagation of its ideas, or receive State subsidies to this end. In the place of the political sections various cultural groups should be set up, deriving resources from the State.

8. The immediate abolition of the militia detachments set up between towns and countryside.

9. The equalisation of rations for all workers, except those engaged in dangerous or unhealthy jobs.

10. The abolition of Party combat detachments in all military groups. The abolition of Party guards in factories and enterprises. If guards are required, they should be nominated, taking into account the views of the workers.

11. The granting to the peasants of freedom of action on their own soil, and of the right to own cattle, provided they look after them themselves and do not employ hired labour.

12. We request that all military units and officer trainee groups associate themselves with this resolution.

13. We demand that the Press give proper publicity to this resolution.

14. We demand the institution of mobile workers' control groups.

15. We demand that handicraft production be authorised provided it does not utilise wage labour.

The sailors set up a revolutionary committee, arrested the two Bolshevik officials who threatened them, and seized control of their ships and the fortress at Kronstadt. The Bolsheviks responded by ordering a press blackout and isolating the island. Bolsheviks claimed this was a conspiracy by Tsarists and French intelligence. Lenin sent Trotsky to organize loyal Bolshevik troops to crush the rebellion. Bolsheviks bombarded Kronstadt and assaulted the island three times over the ice. The Bolsheviks' human waves were gunned down by the revolutionaries, but Trotsky just sent more to weaken the besieged sailors through attrition. After ten days the Bolsheviks took Kronstadt in bloody close quarters fighting, and executed the prisoners.

tl;dr: Lenin crushed democracy, took power from the revolutionary workers, suppressed all dissent, and slaughtered left-wing revolutionaries.

Sources:

The Leninist Facade

Chomsky on Lenin, Trotsky, Socialism & the Soviet Union

1917: Bolsheviks Seize Power

Constitutional Assembly

Theses On The Constituent Assembly , primary source

Reactions to the dispersal of the Constituent Assembly, January 1918, primary source

Factory committees in the Russian Revolution

Soviets and Factory Committees in the Russian Revolution

The Experience of the Factory Committees in the Russian Revolution

1917-1921: The Ukrainian Makhnovist movement

To All Peasants and Workers of the Ukraine, primary source.

1921: The Antonov Rebellion

1921: Workers' Opposition

Workers Revolts against the Bolshevik regime

Kronstadt 1921: the end of the Bolshevik Myth

1921: Kronstadt Uprising


r/DebateaCommunist • • Dec 18 '12

Concerning /r/Communism's officially held view on "pornography"

39 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I view and post regularly on many leftist-subreddits including /r/Communism, so I am posting this using a "sock puppet" account for anonymity. I cannot prove that I am either female or not a reactionary troll, so take this as you will.

I have been fairly busy and have not extensively browsed Reddit lately, and yesterday I finally noticed the link on the top of /r/Communism in which declares it a Feminist subreddit, and listing a couple specifics as to why. Point #3 caught my eye: "(3) Pornography is exploitation and oppression against women, queer people and children. Don't be a creep.". Although I disagreed with it right on the spot, I looked through some of the comments and saw one in particular getting a lot of responses for questioning the 3rd point as well (http://www.reddit.com/r/communism/comments/ruexe/yourselves_as_cultural_revolutionaries/c48vmsl).

The most upvoted response was a link to a documentary on Andrea Dworkin and her argument against pornography. I watched the entire 40 minute video, and I was shocked at how one-sided the documentary was. Dworkin's argument was the only one presented in the documentary, with no opposing opinions presented to the viewer (even for Dworkin to refute). She backs her argument up by loading on evidence of extreme and illegal misuses of women by criminals distributing pornography far from any publicly-certified Adult Entertainment Store. The women presented as "victims" of the pornography industry are women who were abused mentally and physically throughout their childhoods', and were coerced using physical and mental means into making such extreme and violent forms of pornography not by mainstream producers, but by criminals presented by Dworkin as parallel to (though, through rhetoric and documentary style the viewer will be lead to believe that they truly are) every single producer, director, crew, male pornstar, etc working for Adult Film Businesses such as Playboy, Hustler, etc. or even just amateur directors acting within what is legal in their respective nations. The argument used is in essence exactly the same as what is used to justify keeping Drugs illegal, being that they have the potential to harm some either through addiction, as well as through the violent activities that we say today from the Drug cartels.

I consider myself a "sex-positive" (why it is necessary as an adjective to differentiate myself from anyone besides Right-wing Authoritarians, I do not know) Feminist, in that I believe that women should be free to pursue their sexuality as freely as men without being scorned by the overwhelming majority of society. I am also opposed to the foolish and bigoted view that women don't enjoy porn or even masturbate equally as much as males do. Sure, I and many other women may not watch the exact same type of porn as most males do, but it's the same premise almost all of the time (excluding a few fetishists), being consensual, non-violent sex between two adults who are ENJOYING it. Sure it may be acting, but the fantasy is completely enjoyable sex for both partners. Many actresses who have had stable childhoods and are mentally sound have actually consistently said that they enjoy their job probably more than most others enjoy theirs. The Youtube Channel KassemG has done (what I see as) probably one of the least biased series of interviews of well-known pornstars (being completely amateur and unsupervised by the porn-industry, albeit there are a lot of sex jokes on the part of the interviewer), including extremely popular to near complete amateurs, with no bias based on gender (popular trans* star Kimber James was interviewed, even though there was one "very cute boy" joke, Kasem still made out of her despite him knowing that Kimber was trans*: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFqV-ptvLmI&list=SP2DF3673D1DF139A3&index=6). The entire series: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2DF3673D1DF139A3

To conclude, I do not understand how one can assert that Pornography can viewed as completely harmful against oppressed groups, as well as pro-rape unless you yourself refuse to see both sides of the argument, and are fearful of sexuality in general. Porn is still patriarchal in its current state, but only right-wing nut jobs want to outlaw it. Dworkin's views are asserted by using the strawman of the abusive nature of illegally produced and distributed pornography as representative of everything you see in sold in a certified Adult Video Store, and thus it is all evil and viewing always results in violence against women, as well as women not enjoying porn in general in a near equal amount to men. Viewing men as serial rapists at heart only feeds the fire of the MRA argument against Feminism, as well as alienating the other half of Humanity from the movement. Oh, and we may as well outlaw dildos and masturbation as well if we're outlawing porn!

TL;DR: Saw /r/Communism hates porn, uses Andrea Dworkin's propaganda full of strawman to assert this. Women coerced mentally and physically into performing in pornography are in the minority, and are liable to sue producers for massive amounts of damages (Lindsay Lovelace). Outlawing porn is like the continuing prohibition on drugs, it only strengthens the psychopathic criminal enterprise and its ability to harm the populace through armed conflict between crime-syndicates or targeting specific individuals and groups perceived as a threat (see: Mexico of today), removes any rights (there should be much more) for actresses, and have the opposite intended effect on rates of male-violence against women.

You can read a scientific study on the correlation between rape/sexual assault with viewership rates of pornography here

Or, if you can tolerate Penn Jillette's self-alignment with the American "Liberatarian" party, or you can tolerate watching an episode of "Bullshit!" with a somewhat body and male-centric stance though presenting a fairly solid thesis on the harmfulness of Pornography backed by statistics and expert opinions, as well as presenting the other side of the argument, though the argument itself and evidence commonly presented is refuted directly after presentation. !!Disclaimer#2!!: I am explicitly saying that Penn comes off as an insensitive asshole to many leftists with his mode of humor, so I am going to tag the Bullshit episode with a TRIGGER WARNING for those sensitive to innuendo and slight male-centrism. I am posting it because, although I have had no direct experience with physical sexual assault or body-shaming, I found it funny and informative, even if Penn is a Right-Libertarian with little regard for the oppressed in his expression of his opinions.

I ended up spending over 2 hours checking typing and checking over this argument so that it may be presented with logical refutation of all Pornography as advocating violence and directly oppressing women with a somewhat sincere view, though I am too fatigued to post more citations, so this should point skeptics in the direction of more informed arguments. Once again, I believe that it is necessary for Pornography to be reformed/regulated somewhat to prevent the inherit Patriarchal undertones, tighten protection for female actresses, as well as make sexual self-satisfaction equal for all genders. If you read my whole post or just my extremely long TL;DR post, thanks for giving me a chance before spouting refutations. I hope those fellow Comrade's and Feminists can recognize the importance of Pornography in our society and the possibility of dismantling it as a purely Patriarchal institution and its potential as a potentially liberating force for women (just think, no more s-(slur) being used constantly in porn!) should it be moved in a better direction. Oh, and just remember that while not necessarily ALL women watch and enjoy pornography, there are still a lot of us that do ;)


r/DebateaCommunist • • Feb 14 '12

The collective is alive and well, it's all around us, in front of us and keeping us warm and fed. It is known as "The Market". (PDF)

Thumbnail commonsenseeconomics.com
39 Upvotes

r/DebateaCommunist • • Feb 18 '12

Hi /r/debateacommunist. It's time for another chat! As a Democratic Community, we need input on how we should operate. Also, new Macros.

38 Upvotes

Hello /r/debateacommunist!

One month ago, we were forged from the fiery depths of Mt. Doom with a purpose, grand vision in mind, to provide a medium for polite, educated, and civil discourse, and to attempt to educate people who have misconceptions of Communism and Socialism. In the pursuit of Truth, discourse is usually the best course of action, allowing each idea to be judged according to its individual merits.

One month later, we have created a Community of 835 Redditors. We're not perfect, but we're sure as hell making an effort! I want to thank all of you for helping build this Community, and for allowing civil discourse to take place. This Community could not have existed without you, so give yourself a pat on the back!

Having said that, there are two trends that are recently worrying me.

The first trend is the large number of posts being downvoted despite remaining perfectly civil and respectful.

Take a look at this. http://i.imgur.com/H43OL.png

That's only a small selection of what's been recently going on in this subreddit.

This needs to stop. Do not downvote just because you disagree with what someone says. Even, and perhaps especially, if someone is wrong. This subreddit operates alongside a different set of guidelines from normal Reddit, and for a good reason; to promote debate! It doesn't matter even if your opponent wrong. This isn't /r/politics. The PURPOSE of this subreddit is to have a debate. If people can't even speak their mind without fear of being downvoted into oblivion, how can anyone except a Communist try and discuss anything?

If any Capitalist who tries to post is being downvoted, even if they are wrong, you'd be hurting the movement, drive them away, and appear like a circlejerk. The Capitalists are the guests here. Not us. If you invite a guest to your home, you are expected to treat them with courtesy. I don't see why this should be any different.

We are NOT a circlejerk.

Downvotes are for spam and personal attacks only.

In case it wasn't clear enough, Spam and personal attacks as in:

"FREE PENIS ENLARGEMENT ONLY $3.50"

or

"U R MORONS AND FACKERS AND UR MOM IS PHAT I HOPE U DIE"

If any posts do not contain either of these two, do not downvote. Ever. Do not even downvote someone if you don't like the tone of his posts, or feel that his post is too accusatory. Personal attacks are very different from merely attacks against an ideology or a group. If you're ever in doubt, upvote instead.

To bptst1, jscoppe, euthanatos, SuperNinKenDo, Smashpineapples, and anyone else who have had the downvote brigade targeted at them, I'm sorry, and I apologize on the Community's behalf.

Secondly, a large number of people are forgetting to remain tactful, and I'd like to once again remind all of you to make an attempt to be civil and tactful, and to be aware of how seemingly friendly posts may be misinterpreted by others to be excessively aggressive and hostile. This subreddit was created with the intent of facilitating polite discussion, and we should intend to keep it that way. If anyone posts something that can be interpreted as non-polite, please help to tactfully inform them so! The new Macro should help with that. Do not downvote.

Having said that, I'd like to once again ask for input on how this Community is being run. Are there any suggestions on things that should be changed? Any advice on how to stop people from downvoting posts they don't agree with? Are there any policies that you feel are unjust? Anything you want to share with the general Community of /r/debateacommunist? Do you just feel like trying out the new Image Macros? Since this is a Meta post, there's no criteria for topic relevance. Post anything below!

Also, my inbox is always open. Feel free to message me anytime, for any suggestions or concerns regarding this subreddit, or even to have a little chat.

Additionally, for those who haven't already read the new FAQ, do so! Feel free to Edit the FAQ, by the way. It's meant to be Democratic!

Also, last thing. The Mods at /r/debatereligion have assisted me in getting Debate Macros up and running. Using them is purely optional, and you may choose not to use them at all. I just thought it might add a bit of professionalism and eloquence to this subreddit. If you think these Macros are a horrible idea and might bring this subreddit in a negative direction, let me know.

To get this MacroUse this CodeFor when you want to mean
I agree with the comment I am replying to.
I disagree with the comment I am replying to.
I concede a specific point. (Not necessarily the whole argument)
I am playing devil's advocate.
I am giving information that does not agree with my personal views.
I seek clarification.
I think a Logical Fallacy has been made. Let me explain why.
My post is related to the Subreddit itself.
You have made a statement that was not tactful and hurt my feelings. Let me explain how.
Please read the FAQ before posting.
I am requesting a source or citation to back up this statement
This specific statement is incorrect. Let me explain how. (This should only be used for things that is easily and concretely verifiable, such as "Moscow is the Capital of Russia", not things based on opinion.)

If anyone has suggestions for additional Macros that should exist, post it at the bottom!

Cheers <3

-Tux

tl;dr: Thanks for being in this Community, but remember to be civil and polite, and not to downvote people. Also, we've added some Macros. Please brainstorm for other necessary macros. Feel free to suggest anything else, too.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Nov 28 '12

Leninists: What checks and balances, if any, can prevent a vanguardist party from devolving into totalitarianism or a cult of personality?

36 Upvotes

"Lenin's methods lead to this: the party organization substitutes itself for the party, the central committee substitutes itself for the organization, and, finally, a "dictator" substitutes himself for the central committee."

Leon Trotsky, "Our Political Tasks" (1904), as quoted in Isaac Deutscher, The Prophet Armed (1963).

I'm one of those people who see the crushing of the Kronstadt Rebellion and the outlawing of the Left Socialist Revolutionaries as the beginning of the end of a truly revolutionary Russia. I'm skeptical about the idea of a single party state ever representing the working class and not its own interests. Am I wrong? What structural changes could have been made to prevent Lenin's party from turning to Stalinism and eventually falling to opportunists intent on restoring capitalism? Can the desire for constitutional limits be reconciled with the nature of a revolutionary party?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Jul 28 '21

"It wasn't real communism" is an argument against communism, not capitalism.

34 Upvotes

Dear Communists,

If Venezuela, the USSR, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, China and North Korea aren't/weren't real communism then that says more about communism than capitalism. If your system is so corruptible that every time it is implemented it doesn't achieve it's intended purpose and turns authoritarian and corrupt then something is wrong with communism itself. Most communist regimes collapsed, the few that remain are extremely authoritarian and the people that live under them are suffering from poverty and have lower standards of living.

What does this say about your system?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Jan 13 '12

Most Communists say that [almost?] any country called Communist isn't. Wouldn't every Communism regime ever being hijacked by authoritarians show that there are inherrent flaws in Communism?

34 Upvotes

I occupied for a bit and got in some rousing debates with Communists and Socialists(I was further to the right than most there). Most held that the countries that are typically seen as "Communist" (the USSR, Vietnam, North Korea, Cambodia, etc) are not actually communist, and that the revolution was corrupted in some way.

30-40 years later, most are still using the same literature and the same(or similar) revolutionary theory.

Why is this? Wouldn't the revolution constantly being hijacked by genocidal authoritarians indicate that the revolutionary theory is wrong, and does not behave in the way it's supposed to?

I guess I just don't understand how "Oh, well every 'revolution' has failed horribly" is somehow a defense for the ideology.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Oct 18 '12

"Debate a Communist" or "Get Downvoted by a Communist" ?

33 Upvotes

Scanning several threads, I've noticed that this subreddit has become a leftist circlejerk (or maybe it always was one...?). Most capitalist responses are at <= 0 votes. Few of these responses are non-critical, non-observant, or non-relevant to the thread. Honestly, there aren't even many capitalist replies (I wonder why), but you might find some if you scrounge around the bottom of the thread.

So, do you want to debate or do you want to jerk? Why are there even downvotes in the first place? Why not upvote or spam?

Edit: Would the removal of downvotes and flair increase or decrease the intellectual atmosphere (or leave it unchanged)?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Apr 30 '12

What would stop skilled members of a communist society from leaving to join a capitalistic one?

33 Upvotes

Some claim that communism would only work on a global scale. Even if that were true, at some intermediate point you will have to have some communist societies and some capitalist ones.

Let's say I'm a highly educated, skilled worker, maybe an aerospace engineer, living in a communist society. Because my skills are highly valued in the nearby capitalist society, I would be able to acquire a large amount of wealth by moving there. This would mean that I would be able to live more comfortably there than here, or I would be able to work less while maintaining the same lifestyle. Why wouldn't I move?

Here are some options:

  1. You are not allowed to leave. Would you support this kind of coercion? Do you believe it is justified by the society's overall benefit from you not leaving?

  2. You don't leave, because you have everything you want here. For some people this may be true. But leaving could allow you to retire early and spend the rest of your life doing whatever you want, whether that is engineering or travelling the world (or working and donating money/goods/ideas to your friends back home). Nobody would rather have less choice, right?

  3. You don't leave, because you want to better the lives of others. These are the people who will work hard simply to support others. But you can better those same people's lives by gaining in the capitalist society and contributing it back to the communist one, if you really want.

What am I missing? What are the flaws in my argument? Why would you stay?

And even if human nature become such that most people are happy to work solely for the good of society, there will always be the few who will not. Wouldn't this mean that you would always have skilled workers trickling out?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Oct 21 '20

"Telling people to read theory is classist" is classist

32 Upvotes

Let me tell you what's classist buddy boy. What's classist is perpetuating a stereotype of working people as illiterate hicks who can't read anything above a 3rd-grade level. What's classist is contributing to a situation where socialism is represented to the majority of people by controlled opposition that tells them socialism is when you vote blue no matter who. Reading theory is not about letting Marx or Bakunin or whoever tell you what to believe; it's about seriously thinking through the how and why of things, and performing this interrogation is a necessary part of breaking your chains. Proletarian, you are smart enough to read theory, and you should be wary of the elitists who try to convince you otherwise. They don't all mean to do Porky's work for him, but either way, Porky loves it when you make yourself intellectually dependent on someone else to tell you what your own ideology consists of.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Nov 03 '16

Wow

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/DebateaCommunist • • Jan 22 '15

I don't understand why my company profiting from my labor = theft, when I consented to my salary.

31 Upvotes

My understanding of Labor Theory of Value and profit is that, because the fruits of our labor bring in more money than is ultimately paid back to the workers, this extra amount (the profit), constitutes a theft. This argument does not resonate with me and I struggle to see why I should be upset about this.

I have seen numerous times this sort of arrangement being equated to exactly the same thing as theft. In my opinion, theft is something that happens without the consent of one party. If someone is ok and agrees to a certain financial arrangement with another party, and it is honored, I don't see how that can be considered to be taking something from me that is mine, since I've already agreed that it's not mine. I see socialists/communists telling me, "hey, that should be yours!", and in my view... no... it shouldn't, because I did not ask for it.

But I also think I didn't earn it. The work that I put into the company is augmented and amplified by both the work that my superiors and the company owners do, as well as the establishment and mere existence of the company itself. Were I not working for a commercial entity (with everything from a business license to webpage to being a known entity, etc), then the value of our product would command less market value by virtue of it being created by "just a group of people". The mere fact that the work we are doing is being done by the company we are increases it's value. I think this is applicable to just about any business. Hence, I think it is perfectly understandable that a certain amount of additional value is added to the product from sources that do not come from any one person's labor, but from the establishment of the company itself. And the owners are the ones who established it and maintain that establishment.

So I'm flattered that all you communists think I did all this extra work to bring in additional money that you think I'm owed. But honestly, I don't think I'm to thank for that.

Lastly, I started my job with an understanding of what my duties would be and what I could expect to earn from them. I like the way the arrangement has played out. It's been honest and true to what was presented to me in the offer. Why should I not be allowed to engage in this arrangement of my own free will?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Dec 07 '12

The asymmetry of tolerance between ancoms and ancaps speaks more than philosophical technicalities.

30 Upvotes

I was browsing various anarchist/communist and libertarian/capitalist subreddits today (as per usual) and noted (as per usual) just how much more accepting the libertarian/ancap community is of speculating, tolerating, and experimenting with non-capitalist/communal arrangements than the left-anarchist is of voluntary capitalist arrangements. Many ancaps will oppose communal arrangements on practical grounds, but have no issue with voluntary experimentation. Others (like myself) believe that such arrangements would proliferate in an anarchic society, adjacent to and woven through capitalistic organizations.

Reading left-anarchists comments beyond the theories and argumentation I get a solid and general sense of contempt about this asymmetry: "Oh so you'll let us have our little pockets of communism will you? How nice." As if, the ancap arrangements are someone preventing the leftists from demonstrating how practical and fulfilling their own arrangements are.

In my opinion this whole dynamic comes from an essential, emotionally charged difference in the view of human nature. The ancaps view people as self-directed and self-responsible. If they fall into poorly executed or unfair social arrangements, that's their own fault. Nevertheless, people mostly know what's good for them and will gravitate towards more fulfilling and productive lifestyles (bereft of systemic state interventions). With technological and intellectual progress, people (as a whole) will learn from past mistakes and increasingly settle into the best arrangements based on their personal circumstances.

The ancoms view people as lacking self-direction and self-responsibility. People are easily fooled into unfulfilling and unfair arrangements (wage slavery, rent, capitalism, etc.). If people have the option of communism or capitalism, they might choose capitalism because they cannot see the consequences. We cannot let people have this choice.

The ancoms of that sentiment forget that the ones "freeing" people from capitalism will not be ideologues. They will be thugs. They will not make fine distinctions between possession and private property. They will not have read r/anarchy101 or Das Kapital. If people choose capitalism and proprietarianism you should let them learn from their mistakes.

The understanding I've gained from observing the asymmetry between these types of ancaps and these types of ancoms has further lead me to believe that violent revolution, class consciousness, social engineering, etc. will never succeed. In the end, people will continue to break the fine technicalities of your tidy system for their own personal reasons and circumstances. Anarchism will only come about through a long process of accidental technological and intellectual development. You cannot force society to be anti-statist, anti-capitalist, or anti-communist. No amount of sincere philosophical, net-positive blather is going to make that happen. Essentially, this is why libertarian proprietarianism has the advantage: it does not need collective ethical consensus to operate, rather it is maintained through a network of exchanges and contracts between individuals. Only those individuals are bound by those interactions, yet the entire network reacts to each individual disruption and fluctuation without collective mandate.

I'm not looking for your philosophical technicalities as well-intentioned and well-argued as they may be. I'd prefer if we discussed the motivations and assumptions underlying the ideologies instead. The grey area between psychological projection and ideology.


r/DebateaCommunist • • Nov 09 '12

Capitalists, do you have a counter-argument for the tendency of the rate of profit to fall and its consequences, which explains how capitalism has gotten to where it is today?

30 Upvotes

Before responding, please watch this video. It's not the best explanation of the theory, but I think it is still pretty helpful for understanding this part of Marx's analysis. In it, the speaker explain how, starting with the labor theory of value, Marx explained the development of capitalism in response to regular crises. In the last third of the video, he named a few ways in which the system has delayed a falling rate of profit, such as speeding up production, lengthening the workday, pushing wages down, and merging with other companies. The most recent adaptation has been using credit instead of actual value, in addition to sending production overseas to super-low wages. Lenin explained concentration of capital in order to preserve profits in greater detail in Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism. Numerous other Marxists have also picked up where Lenin left off, carrying the argument into the 21st century.

The continued survival of capitalism could not have been possible without help from the state, and I would also argue that colonialism gave capitalism its first big boost with primitive accumulation. This was, of course, state-backed.

I have not seen any defense of privatized commodity production which took into account the tendency of the rate of profit to fall. This is a pretty big omission, because Marx's theory has the force of explanatory power behind it, and if you accept his method, then his conclusions must also be correct. He goes straight into the bare-bones definition of capitalism and condemns it from within. If Marxism consisted of nothing more than a moral complaint, I wouldn't subscribe to it.

So, do you think Marx took the correct approach? Do you think capitalism can or should be preserved in spite of its instability? Does anything in your ideology negate this effect permanently?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Jun 21 '12

Do capitalists deny estrangement of labor?

30 Upvotes

I was wondering what the opinion of capitalists is on Marx's theory of alienation. To me, it seems almost self-evident in our current society. Ever since I was a kid, I remember watching cartoons and seeing episodes where the character complained about their soul-sucking jobs. Now that I'm an adult, everybody I know who works considers their job to be time that is not theirs, even people that enjoy their employment to some degree. It is only when they're not working that they feel free to indulge in their hobbies and real interests, as Marx said. Alienation seems firmly entrenched in our society even in non-Marxist sources.

What do capitalists say about the theory of alienation? Is it something alien to capitalism that could be fixed, like the state supposedly is? Is it plain untrue? Or is it an unavoidable fact of life that we should get used to?


r/DebateaCommunist • • May 30 '12

Isn't Reddit an example of how "boredom as a motivation" wouldn't work?

30 Upvotes

Every time someone brings up the question "what about all of the slackers", somebody else responds that people would simply be bored and would look for something to occupy their time, thus finding their dream job and contributing to society. That's all well and good... but I don't see any evidence that that last part would actually happen.

Look at Reddit. Countless people spend enormous amounts of their free time on this site. Some wake up, go to work at their desk job, browse reddit, go home, browse reddit some more, and go to bed. Some spend much of their weekends here. It's not that they don't have time to do something productive or interesting; they just prefer reading reddit.

Another example: gaming. Many people would happily spend each day glued to their monitors, playing the latest hit game from morning to night. I see no reason why they would get bored of this, especially when new games (and state-of-the-art hardware) are completely free and there is no obligation to do anything else.

The internet (and the world in general) has enormous amounts of opportunities for self-enrichment, learning new skills, helping people out, etc. for free. Many people already ignore them and instead spend their free time doing something enjoyable but not helpful to anyone else. Why would it be different in a communist society, where the necessity to work to feed yourself is removed?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Apr 24 '12

Capitalism is what makes me productive.

30 Upvotes

Many people have energy, vitality, or intrinsic motivations for doing something - some people are social workers because they like helping people, others are chefs because they love food and culinary science, etc.

If the world consisted only of people like them, then I could see how a communist/anarchist post-private property society could function. However, this is not the case, as the world also includes people like me: people who are lazy, unmotivated, whose motives are purely extrinsic. In my case, the only reason I ever bother getting out of bed to do anything is because I have to go to work to survive.

Thanks to money, capitalism has a built-in system of coercion for people like me who are lazy, and who would otherwise just be a burden and a bother to the system. If you produce, you eat; if you don't produce, you starve. People like me - we're no better than the donkey; we need that carrot in front of us, as well as that stick behind us, or else we quit moving.

It's not quite that simple, but that's the basic mechanism, and - in a way - it works.

So my question is, under communism, what would there be to coerce me to be productive? Wouldn't I just wind up being a leech to society if I didn't starve (as I would in a liberal capitalist regime) or get sent to a gulag (as I would in a state capitalist regime)?


r/DebateaCommunist • • Jun 07 '12

Earlier, some capitalist asked for a marxist analysis of why profits seem to decline over time that used NO marxist language... David Graber does it here: Of Flying Cars and the Declining Rate of Profit

Thumbnail
thebaffler.com
29 Upvotes

r/DebateaCommunist • • Jan 02 '12

Is selfishness/egoism/individualism an inevitable part of human nature.

29 Upvotes

I've been reading this Subreddit for 24 hours, and I'm close to needing to leave. Not because of trolls or idiots, everyone here is remarkably friendly, civil, helpful, polite and intelligent.

But I don't think my body could physically handle another reading of: "true communism arrives only after we've lived without capitalism for a long time and the egoism that was taught to you, and was necessary for life under capitalism ceases to exist. The actions you describe are the most pure egoism, which you probably ascribe to "human nature", but which communists believe is a product of your life under capitalism."

This was written by mmaluf, and have seen it several other times by other people.

Do Communists here truly believe that selfishness (let's call it rational self interest) or even individualism is merely a product of a capitalist structure?

It's one thing to claim that we could learn to be less greedy and self-centered.

It's another thing to claim that humans can view themselves not as individuals, but as a selfless part of a greater machinery.

Eliaspowers has said: "If I could prevent two people from suffering by removing the kidneys of the third, I would."

If two people could have their suffering cured at the expense of HIS kidneys, would he do it?

I cannot fathom the mentality of a human who does not hold his own interests (even if those interests include a charitable nature) to a lesser degree than others who he may not even know.