r/DebateaCommunist • u/OfHammersAndSickles • Mar 13 '13
Who here supports the DPRK and why?
I support North Korea wholeheartedly
r/DebateaCommunist • u/OfHammersAndSickles • Mar 13 '13
I support North Korea wholeheartedly
r/DebateaCommunist • u/mantasp • Sep 23 '13
A question from a communist for some of you on this subreddit. Seriously, what is wrong with you? We have almost a century of experience now of where this leads to. Do you still believe that these totalitarian regimes can/could empower the proletariat for its own liberation?? Or is it that anything goes, you can be murderous and exploitive as much as you want, just be against (market-)capitalism?
(By distortions I mean, e.g., claims that Lenin's "socialism" and Marx's first stage of socialism/communism is the same)
r/DebateaCommunist • u/hippynoize • Nov 03 '12
r/DebateaCommunist • u/dongxiaoping • Nov 13 '12
I want to hear both perspectives. Throw in your opinions on the Men's Rights movement as well.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Hussaria_Z_Polski • Mar 21 '16
It's one of if not the most blood soaked ideologies in the world, and has had massive repercussions on the nations it used to be used in.(I.E my native Poland, Ukraine, the Baltics etc) It also takes away civil liberties and freedoms, makes people starve and forces the deaths of non-Communists, why defend it? Soruces: Lived in Communist Poland and Yugoslavia for an extent, grandfather was worked to death on a Kolkhoz in Russia, Soviets executed tens of thousands in the Katyń crimes.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/DavidByron • Jun 20 '13
r/DebateaCommunist • u/[deleted] • Dec 11 '13
r/DebateaCommunist • u/[deleted] • Dec 17 '12
r/DebateaCommunist • u/[deleted] • May 25 '13
To expand on that, why is there such a strong dislike between the far right and the far left? It seems like, for the most part, many of the groups have similar ideals (fascists and proto fascists want to create a society that produces great people through social and state reform, communism seeks to do the same through economic reform), and there's a lot of overlap between the two groups when it comes to things like the environment, social programs, and even philosophy (most of the Italian fascists were fans of Marx and Socialist thinkers, and many modern left wingers seem to be pretty into Nietzsche). I'm curious why there's such a strong dislike between the two groups, when they seem to agree on 90% of the issues.
By far right I of course mean fascists, nationalists, some primitivists, Torys, traditionalists, pro-theocracy types, ect.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/[deleted] • Jun 03 '14
Insofar as Marxism is a normative theory, I think it has a lot of good ideas. Marxists, however, seem to have a very dodgy track record when it comes to making positive claims. The attack on human nature seems especially unscientific and also unnecessary. What's up with this and can one be a Marxist without denying the reality of human nature?
r/DebateaCommunist • u/ruizscar • Jan 11 '12
r/DebateaCommunist • u/DavidByron • Nov 18 '12
I wonder if feminism is likely to become more violent now as a means to censor opponents. This is an article from a student run site about a bunch of feminists forming a mob to block the ability of men's rights author Warren Farrell from giving a lecture about equality.
http://www.ryersonian.ca/article/25226/
Is this the sort of feminism that people here support? Attacking equality? Attacking men's rights? Using violence to stop opponents from being able to talk in public? Is there any other kind of feminism?
Violence and hatred of men seems like a rational response for anyone who believes in core feminist ideology like "the patriarchy" -- a teaching that says men are by nature of being born male, violent and aggressive against women.
Is it good for the Left to be associated with what is increasingly seen as a nasty sexist movement of man haters?
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Ceannaire_Cogadh • May 05 '16
Verdict:
Communism cannot be reached due to its global implications. Furthermore, those who were trying to justify communism here fail to acknowledge and accept the basic laws of the human being. In addition, one individual even denied the atrocities committed by the U.S.S.R. Due to this, I am not only still against communism, but even more so against in, based on the principle that the followers of its tenets are poorly informed. Love live the bourgeoisie!
An elaboration on the title: I will debate your points, not to be an arse, but to see how comprehensively you understand the subject matter.
My stance: communism, in theory, is utopian - however, due to inherent flaws in human nature, communism is ineffective and impossible to execute in its purest form. As corruption permeates communist governments, it essentially establishes an extremely rich political caste, with the rest of the country being significantly poorer, relying on the government for handouts.
Feel free to ask me a question about my beliefs on the subject, mentioned or not. This was just a quick write-up, so I can expand on the matter.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/CuilRunnings • Dec 05 '12
Pay is absolutely the best motivator. Rynes and colleagues did an annual review on the subject. That paper is behind a paywall, but here is a related one by the same authors.
There was a thought in Cognitive Evaluation Theory, that does have some research support, that pay and other tangible rewards like it actually reduced intrinsic motivation. This may be the case, but the primary evidence is that even so the net gain in motivation is still tops.
Having said that, it's certainly not the only motivator, and it should never be assumed that high pay alone will keep people moving. There is a substantial amount of variance not explained by pay, and other factors need to be addressed. One thing in piece-rate work that tends to be incredibly demotivating is the monotony, and trying to structure work characteristics in such a way as to alleviate that monotony would probably go a long way.
Autonomy, mastery, and purpose is not a silly idea, but it is an old one. It goes back to research in the 70s and 80s (here is the classic paper, don't dismiss it due to age), and still has good work done today. It's rooted in work design (or work characteristics) theory, which is designing work to provide autonomy, give feedback, doing work with meaning, among others.
It's good, and that stuff truly can be motivating. Is it more motivating than pay? No, absolutely not. Is pay motivating enough to ignore other factors such as work characteristics? No. Pay may motivate job candidates to apply and accept job offers, and it may keep them in the job for awhile, but other factors like job characteristics keep people happy, engaged, increase tenure, increase OCBs, etc.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Chronic_Medicine • Sep 25 '19
To my knowledge its never worked. The USSR starved and massacred millions of innocent people, Cuba is economically destroyed and the rate of poverty is very high, and North Korea and China are oppressive authoritarian governments.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/amaxen • Jul 22 '14
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Leadhead1311 • May 13 '16
Under heavy Socialism/Communism, Bill Gates would not have a fraction of the money he currently does because a large percentage of it would go towards the less fortunate of society instead.
Look, I see no issues with a limited social welfare program for those who actually need it. But this whole notion that Socialists and Communists have about 'income inequality' is ridiculous. People earn money in this world by providing something the market wants (e.g. being a doctor, being an engineer, becoming an entrepreneur, creating something society wants (Facebook, for example.))
People who get it illegally or through nefarious means are obviously jailed and their assets drained in our society (unless you're the bankster scum, in which case you're not jailed for some reason.)
I understand a small inheritance tax, because the individual didn't bust his or her balls to get that money.
But why do you want to take money from people who earned it?
r/DebateaCommunist • u/[deleted] • Sep 07 '15
Hello, I used to consider myself a pretty devout Marxist. But after studying economics, history, and science it became quite clear to me that Communism can't work (or that true communism is impossible to achieve). I was wondering if you have any ways to argue that Communism still has a strong basis.
How do you explain the huge economic gap between Capitalist states and current and former socialist states (for example, why are South Korea, Taiwan, and Western Europe so prosperous while North Korea, the PRC, and the former Eastern bloc behind)?
How do you explain the massive amounts of deaths left by communist states?
Why has every communist state ended up authoritarian and not progressed to the 'stateless" phase predicted by Marx?
Thanks for your attention
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Tentacolt • Feb 20 '13
I'm speaking both about rioting and trials against the wealthy.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/DavidByron • Dec 10 '12
The first men's groups were labor union groups, back in the days when that really meant something, but today the socialists are seen as increasingly identified with feminism and anti-male hate.
Article at /r/MensRights about Warren Farrell protest
Per the link above the Canadian Socialist Worker web site was involved with getting together the mob that tried to violently prevent the lecture by MRA speaker Warren Farrell at Toronto University the other month. The activities of the mob got a fair amount of negative publicity with video put up on YouTube and so on. But instead of socialists protesting against the elites they were attacking rights for ordinary men -- exactly 180 degrees the opposite of what socialism used to stand for back in the day of the early unions.
One man's experience with Occupy anti-male sexism in Vancouver
So to summarize an article you ought to read, it's by a man who claims he used to be a Marxist, and was at the first days of Occupy in Vancouver, who became increasingly angry with the sexism of the movement until he dropped out. Although he doesn't say so explicitly, it seems to me this experience also pushed him away from the Left in general. Here's a quote:
For all of my erstwhile enthusiasm for the tenets of Occupy (and the social redress contained within the 99% meme) I now felt terribly let down, affronted and wholly betrayed. I resented being cast in a mold as some manner of existential ‘other.’ A burgeoning sense of anger and betrayal, due to my gender being discriminated against and speciously marginalized, swept over me in a wave. I found myself angry at being cast through a dark meniscus, just for the happenstance of being born male. Right there and then I wanted to murmur something about this being (surely) sexist, but the larger super-ego structure within my psyche told me to shut the fuck up
There's nothing like being emotionally bullied and rejected to make someone feel excluded from a group and as a result to reconsider their deepest religious or political beliefs. Of course you might say well he can't have been much of a Marxist if being discriminated against put him off the Left (he does mention a 30 year history of activism briefly in the article). Just because feminists were assholes doesn't mean the whole message of socialism is wrong. But it's harder to argue that when so many people tell us that you have to be a feminist to be a communist etc etc.
What seems to really break the issue open for him is seeing a male friend of his attacked mercilessly by feminists (see article).
At the moment the Men's Rights movement seems to be becoming more popular. Certainly more popular than Socialism is. And these young men who are getting politicized through that issue of fighting for their civil rights are being told that socialism and the Left is their enemy. And frankly they are not wrong about that are they? I can't go and tell them they are wrong at /r/MensRights can I?
ETA: trying to find some figures on this
Pew research 2010 on socialism
OK so this has a break down by gender. It says women are about one third more likely to have a positive view of socialism and the specific numbers are 25% of men vs 33% of women. (It also says that 43% of young people vs 29% of people as a whole see socialism positively, so I'd really like to see how the young people break down on their views of socialism).
r/DebateaCommunist • u/SongunStrength • Sep 03 '13
May the DPRK grow! Strength, aid, defense, and support to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea!
May every nation know the freedom of independence and national sovereignty! May every nation someday know that her people are free from the threat of Imperialism!
Korea, glorified by Songun, stands slandered and illegitimized by the yellow rags of the west and the slanders of traitors. The untrue and farcical allegations, without a shred of proof, continue to pollute the discourse of western politics. Even now, with no evidence, the Imperial media bays for the blood of Syrian citizens! Will Americans stand for their Syrian brothers, or will they sigh in oppression, trapped in the belly of the Imperial Beast?
No people or nation is safe as long as the Imperialists take breath!
What is Juche? Juche is independence. Juche is freedom. Juche is autonomy.
The Juche Ideal is the correct knowledge that only through the realization of independence in politics, self-sufficiency in economics, and self-reliance in national defense can a nation be truly free from Imperialism and domineering gangster politics!
The masses of the DPRK are the masters of their own destiny. It is a fundamental revolutionary task for the government of the republic to achieve the complete victory of socialism in the northern half of Korea by strengthening the people's power.
True democracy is found in the localized People's Assemblies, which come in three forms: provincial, city (urban), and country. Supreme power is found in the Supreme People's Assembly.
For a peaceful friendship between the peoples of the world and the Democratic People's Republic of Korea!
r/DebateaCommunist • u/scientific_thinker • Dec 23 '12
I was reading the following article about right to work laws and something jumped off the page at me.
DuPont, Pew and Sloan funds also seeded the American careers of Ludwig von Mises, Friedrich von Hayek, Milton Friedman and Murray Rothbard, among others.
Does anyone have more information on this? I haven't found anything beyond this article so far.
This is not hard for me to believe (although I remain a bit skeptical since this article is my only source for this information). I have disliked Friedman for years. He uses irrational persuasive arguments which I detest on principle. I have always thought of him more as a used car salesman than the academic he pretends to be. If you think I am being unfair, anyone is welcome to post a short Milton Friedman argument and I will show you how it is irrational. I will only do the first one or two, I don't want to spend a lot of time on this so I will only do short ones. This is because he has a pattern where he begins by stating obvious truths to build up trust and saves his irrational leaps until the end when he tries to convince the audience of something. I am not up for sitting through more than ten minutes or so of his foolishness.
I don't find the other guys mentioned much better. As a group, their work is littered with logical fallacies. Beating up strawmen seems to be the favorite.
I want to make it clear, even if this turns out to be true and their job was basically to create economic propaganda for the right, some of their arguments might be valid (I don't want this to be an Ad hominem attack). It is not fair to attack the person but I think it is important to see if they had an agenda other than discovering how economic systems work.
A couple questions:
If this turns out to be true, would any of you fellow lefties be surprised that these guys are little more than salesmen for capitalism and free markets?
If this is true, those of you that have been repeating arguments made by these men, does this give you pause and make you look a little more critically at the arguments they try to make?
[Credit where credit is due: here is the link that lead me to the article: Dark History of Right to Work Laws Thanks MikeBoda]
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Frostav • Apr 23 '15
My own political ideology is murky but at best I could call myself a Social Liberal. I believe that people should be free without screwing over the good of the community in general. Because of this, I prefer a mixed economy that has a free market, regulated by the government, and with welfare and other social programs backed by taxation. I have a few reasons for why I am not a Socialist, but, I do have the humility to admit that perhaps I am working from outdated ideas, misconceptions, or an inability to imagine such a revolutionary society. So, here they are:
1: Socialism ascribes to the worker this christ-like sinlessness to near-cult levels. The worker can never do wrong. The worker always knows what's good for them and implements it perfectly. The worker goes over everyone else. The worker will always give their all for the greater community, never mind the fact that people are greedy and materialistic assholes by nature.
2: Socialism is incredibly utilitarian. Everyone must give themselves up to The Greater GoodTM and if you don't, then fuck you. Individuality is nothing more than capitalist oppression. People must dedicate every second of their lives to the community and can't engage in the slightest show of excess or they are wasting. How exactly can art exist in such a society? From a purely utilitarian standpoint, all art, be it music, literature, movies, etc. is utterly worthless. Art doesn't feed, clothe, or shelter people. It doesn't benefit the community. As an author, what am I supposed to do? Give up writing because it's a "worthless waste of resources" that could be better diverted towards working?
3: Following from the above point: since the idea of a company doesn't exist in a Socialist economy, there's endless homogeneity. To name an example: I am a car enthusiast. In the current society I am willing to pay extra money to get a sportier car with a manual transmission. But in a socialist society, said sportier car is a "waste", so I have to make do with what the community wants. And in a socialist economy, there is no Ferrari to constrast with Lamborghini, Pagani, Koenigsegg, or Bugatti. There is no Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and Audi. No Toyota, Subaru, Nissan, and Mistubishi. Hell, there's no Ford, Dodge, or Chevrolet because there are no companies by definition. There's just what the community produces, and fuck you if you want choice 'cause that's just a Capitalist LieTM. And before you go off, yes, there are appreciable and noticeable differences between the cars these brands produce.
(And speaking of cars, I guess motorsports would be banned since that's just a "waste of resources". And normal sports too, for that matter. I guess entertainment is also a Capitalist LieTM)
4: Socialism operates under ridiculously reductionist viewpoints. Waste must be entirely eliminated. The worker is always perfect and right. The slightest bit of capitalism causes oppression. As soon as Socialism gets implemented we will literally live in a worker's utopia where everyone holds hands and has their needs met perfectly. The only reason it hasn't is because those Capitalists are oppressing the workers, who obviously want Socialism because I read it in a book and books are NEVER WRONG
The world doesn't work in these absurd black-and-white ideas. What exactly makes you people different from Libertarians screaming about how taxation is the end of the world and socialism will result in gulags and massive starvation?
I could go on and on, but these are my main issues. I'm presuming that you have answers for these.
r/DebateaCommunist • u/Reuwalk5 • Jan 27 '13