Number one:
The table in the paper describing the temporal relationship between vaccination and the symptoms wasn't intended to provide a generic account of every developmental delay, behavioural issue or unusual symptom the children had ever experienced. It was identifying a particular set of behavioural symptoms and regression patterns relevant to the investigation.
This is an important distinction because Brian Deer's argument often seems to conflate the existence of any behavioural or developmental concern before vaccination with the onset of the particular symptoms being described in the paper.
Those aren't necessarily the same thing.
A child could have experienced some relatively minor developmental difficulties beforehand, or had an unrelated behavioural problem at an earlier age, and subsequently experienced a distinct regression involving social interaction, communication, play or other behaviours after vaccination.
The existence of the former doesn't automatically invalidate the latter.
Nor does it mean the child couldn't have experienced a period of relatively normal development in between. Development isn't necessarily a straight line, and the existence of some earlier difficulties doesn't establish that a later deterioration was simply a continuation of the same problem.
The question is whether the specific symptoms being investigated actually emerged at the time reported, not whether the child had ever displayed anything unusual beforehand.
Number two:
You're also treating the date something was formally diagnosed, the date it was first documented in a medical record, and the date it actually began as though they're interchangeable.
They're not.
Autism doesn't suddenly begin on the day a doctor gives someone a diagnosis. Symptoms can emerge gradually, parents can recognise changes before professionals do, and it can take months or even years before a child receives a formal diagnosis.
So when you find a medical record showing that a child was diagnosed with autism months after vaccination, that doesn't establish that the relevant symptoms only began months after vaccination.
You have to distinguish between the onset of symptoms and the subsequent recognition and diagnosis of those symptoms.
The retrospective assessments:
This is where the nature of the Royal Free assessments becomes particularly important.
The professionals weren't simply copying dates out of existing GP records and reproducing them in the paper. They were conducting clinical assessments of the children, taking histories from the parents and examining the available information to establish what had happened, what symptoms the children had experienced and how their conditions had developed.
That necessarily involved looking retrospectively at events, including things that might not have been documented in the original medical records.
For example, a parent might describe a particular change in their child's behaviour shortly after vaccination, but the GP might not have recorded that change at the time, or might have recorded it months later when the child was eventually referred for further assessment.
The absence of a contemporaneous medical entry doesn't automatically invalidate the parent's account. Equally, the date of a subsequent diagnosis doesn't override the evidence about when the symptoms actually began.
This is particularly relevant when you're dealing with developmental conditions, where the onset can be gradual and the distinction between normal development, developmental delay and regression isn't always immediately obvious.
If the professionals, having assessed the children and considered the available histories, concluded that particular symptoms had emerged shortly after vaccination, then you cannot simply dismiss that assessment by pointing to a later diagnosis or an earlier medical entry documenting something different.
You can certainly question whether their interpretation was correct. But that's a different argument from demonstrating that Wakefield deliberately falsified the children's histories.
Now, here's why the background to these assessments is particularly interesting.
A large part of the reason these children ended up at the Royal Free in the first place was precisely because their parents were dissatisfied with how they had previously been treated and assessed by other doctors and GPs.
The parents described doctors as dismissive, defensive and, in some cases, quite unpleasant towards them. They felt their children's health problems weren't being taken seriously and that their concerns were being brushed aside rather than properly investigated.
They described difficulties getting GPs to address unfamiliar or complicated symptoms, and felt that doctors were often reluctant to entertain their explanations. Some said they were made to feel as though they were exaggerating, imagining things or somehow responsible for their children's problems.
They were also frequently reassured that their children would simply get better, that the problems were normal developmental issues that would resolve themselves, or that there was nothing particularly unusual happening.
But the problems didn't necessarily resolve.
In fact, some parents initially contested the autism diagnoses their children received. They believed that doctors were using autism as a convenient explanation for their children's difficulties, without properly investigating what had happened or considering whether there might be another underlying cause.
The irony is that the parents' dissatisfaction with those explanations, and their belief that something had happened to their children, was part of what eventually led them to consider a possible connection with MMR.
There is another important point here: in several cases, it took months or years for doctors to formally diagnose the children with autism. This reinforces the distinction between when a condition was diagnosed and when the symptoms actually emerged.
Now consider what this means for the medical records.
If the parents' accounts of their previous experiences with GPs are accurate, then there are legitimate reasons to question whether those medical records provide a complete and accurate account of what was happening to the children.
Think about it.
If a parent repeatedly takes their child to a GP with concerns about developmental changes, behavioural deterioration or other unfamiliar symptoms, but the GP dismisses those concerns, doesn't investigate them properly or simply attributes them to normal childhood development, what sort of medical record are you likely to end up with?
You might have a handful of brief entries documenting individual consultations, perhaps recording a particular symptom or concern, but without any meaningful investigation into the wider history or the sequence of events.
You might not have a record of everything the parents observed at home. You might not have a record of the precise timing of particular behavioural changes. You might not even have a record of concerns that the parents repeatedly raised but which the GP didn't consider significant enough to document in detail.
And if the parents were describing a temporal association with vaccination that their doctors were dismissing, you cannot automatically assume that the absence of that association in the GP records proves the parents never reported it.
I'm not suggesting that every discrepancy can be explained this way, or that we should automatically assume the GPs were wrong. The point is that medical records are not an infallible, comprehensive account of everything that happened to a patient. They are a record of what was documented during particular interactions with healthcare professionals, and the quality and completeness of that documentation can vary considerably.
This is precisely why the Royal Free assessments and the additional information obtained from the parents matter.
The professionals were looking at the children themselves, taking detailed histories and considering information beyond what happened to have been written down in their previous medical records.
So when Brian Deer subsequently takes an isolated entry from a GP record, compares it with the clinical history presented in the paper and identifies a discrepancy, there is an important question he needs to answer:
Why should his interpretation of that isolated entry automatically take precedence over the retrospective clinical assessment, the parents' accounts and the wider evidence considered by the professionals?
He doesn't get to establish that Wakefield falsified something simply by finding a medical record that appears inconsistent with the paper. He needs to establish what the discrepancy actually means, whether the record is sufficiently complete to support his interpretation, and whether the alternative explanation has been properly excluded.
Otherwise, he's effectively treating the original medical records as an unquestionable source of truth while dismissing the possibility that they were incomplete, imprecise or simply didn't capture what was happening.
And there's another important consideration: the state of autism diagnosis in the 1990s.
Autism wasn't understood in quite the same way it is today. Diagnostic practices and clinical understanding were evolving, and there was considerably more uncertainty around how certain developmental presentations should be classified.
That matters because you're looking retrospectively at children whose developmental histories were sometimes complicated, whose symptoms may have emerged gradually, and whose diagnoses weren't necessarily made until considerably later.
A GP might have documented developmental delay, behavioural difficulties or an unusual pattern of development without recognising the significance of those symptoms in relation to autism. Another specialist, examining the child years later and with considerably more information available, might reach a different interpretation.
That doesn't automatically mean the later assessment is correct. But it does mean you cannot simply treat every difference between an earlier medical entry and a later clinical assessment as evidence of dishonesty.
And this is where I think your argument falls down.
You're looking at discrepancies between the original medical records and the published paper, assuming that the original records provide a complete and definitive account of the children's histories, and then interpreting any differences as evidence that Wakefield deliberately manipulated the data.
But there are several separate questions here:
Was the original medical record complete and sufficiently detailed to establish what actually happened?
Was the symptom being documented the same specific symptom or developmental change that was subsequently described in the paper?
Was the date in the medical record the actual onset of the symptom, or simply the date it was first reported, recorded or formally recognised?
Did the Royal Free clinicians have additional information from the parents and their own assessments that wasn't available in the original records?
And, most importantly, is there actual evidence that Wakefield knowingly changed or misrepresented information, rather than a disagreement about how the children's histories should be interpreted?
Those questions need to be answered individually.
There may well be cases where Deer's criticisms raise legitimate questions about the accuracy of particular descriptions in the paper. I'm not suggesting otherwise. But identifying a discrepancy and demonstrating deliberate record falsification are two very different things.
You cannot simply skip all the questions about clinical interpretation, retrospective assessment, parental histories and the limitations of the original records, jump straight to an accusation of manipulation, and then present that accusation as though it were established fact.
That's not a particularly rigorous way of evaluating medical evidence.