To show a vaccine actually increases your chance of surviving period, not surviving COVID, or illness and hospitalisation period, not just against covid19, you have to show an overall sum of the benefits and costs by comparing vaccinated and unvaccinated and their total outcome.
It's really telling that pro vaxxers rarely understand this. I just posted a question and like 7+ pro vaxxers already have linked studies saying vaccinated are at lower risk of death FROM COVID, which doesn't prove they are at lower risk of death ... Full stop...
I remember calling for this from the beginning: I said just like any other medical intervention, it has to pass a risk-benefit analysis for each demographic, and that you can't just have bizarre studies in which you take 100 random "vaccinated" people and 100 random "unvaccinated" people and find that "vaccinated" "group" on balance had less severe covid and on that basis blanket force the vaccine on everyone. But at the time I was told that abiding by this common sense and long established basic medical concept (risk benefit analysis based on specific demographic/controlling for risk factors) was spreading "scientific misinformation" and that there is "no evidence" that this is the correct method. I was banned from every single covid and "science" related subreddit.
And now, once they already achieved their objective, after 4 years, they are suddenly agreeing with the "conspiracy theorists" who pushed "scientific misinformation" and agreeing to abide by common sense and basic actual math and science.
In a commentary published in The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM), Makary and Prasad wrote that going forward, the vaccines will generally be approved only for use in people ages 65 and older and those who have medical conditions that leave them at higher risk for severe COVID-19. That is a major departure from the current recommendation from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which says everyone above the age of 6 months should receive a dose of the latest COVID-19 vaccine, which has generally been updated each year.
If manufacturers want their vaccines to be available to healthy people under age 65, “FDA anticipates the need for randomized, controlled trial data evaluating clinical outcomes” before it would approve a license for those groups, Makary and Prasad wrote. Previously, companies had their updated vaccines licensed on the basis of so-called immunogenicity data, showing only that a vaccine can generate antibodies in people. That standard will remain for licensing new vaccines for older and at-risk populations.
Isn't it interesting that it took them 4 years and billions of dollars until they decided to apply this this long-established basic medical practise and are suddenly no longer calling it "scientific misinformation" and "conspiracy theories"? They know there will be a tsunami of excess damage (due to risks outweigh benefits for certain demographics) and are now in damage control mode. But this was already predicted by those who were silenced.
So all who silenced those who called for this common sense act in and since 2021, should be held accountable. I remember especially saying we have to be careful of the vaccines doing more harm than good in certain demographics such as children and that children have astronomically low rates of severe covid and by the time the vaccines were approved for children most children had natural immunity anyways. But at that time they say natural immunity is magically suspended for this virus and only this virus, and that we need to not just jab but perpetually boost each child and ask questions later. And anybody who questioned this anti-common sense bizarre policy was labeled as a conspiracy theories who was spreading "scientific misinformation" because "there is no evidence that 1+1+2 because we deliberately refuse to do studies that show 1+1=2." And the masses went along with it and worshiped these "experts" and silenced those who said 1+1=2 because of virtue signalling.
Also, do you find it interesting how the last major strain that caused a non-endemic (outside flu season) wave was a year ago (summer 2024): JN.1? Fall/winter 2023 was the last time there was significant booster uptake. Since then very few people have been taking boosters, and we have so far not had any new non-endemic (non typical flu season in winter) waves, for the first time.
This is one place where anti vaxxers have misfired and exaggerated. (I know it's very sensitive to criticise anti vaxxers, I'm not pro vaccine I'm just worried about this false talking point (we need to allow ourselves to point out our errors even if we are mostly on the side of truth)).
A) it's highly unlikely bill gates would be so blunt and nonchalant and say that vaccines are a depopulation weapon.
B) in that clip, bill clearly meant that modern medicine would reduce mortality and therefore reduce the necessity for having so many children, reducing the population.
The fact that we were all probably made more vulnerable to whatever the virus was doing because we were all in house arrests, stressed and anxious, and masking up, and doing all the things that would ONLY lead to WORSE health and MORE risk of dying and being ill!
How much was really COVID? How much was ACTUALLY just Self-Inflicted artificial?
I'm not saying the whole pandemic was fake, that's a step too far in my mind, but ... this still stands true.
A new large study from Denmark directly counters those claims. After mining the vaccination and medical records of more than 1.2 million children over a 24-year period, researchers could see no evidence that exposure to aluminum in vaccines led to a statistically significant increase in a child’s risk of developing any of a wide variety of conditions that can be diagnosed in childhood, including asthma and autism.
None of the 50 conditions the group looked at — broadly categorized as relating to autoimmune diseases, allergy, and neurodevelopmental disorders — occurred at statistically higher levels than would be expected, ruling out moderate or substantially increased risk from exposure to aluminum in vaccines, a finding senior author Anders Hviid described as “quite striking.”
McCullough recently published a paper in “Food and Chemical Toxicology” that posits biological mechanisms underlying purported innate immune suppression and harm from SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccination, using VAERs to support their hypotheses of vaccine relatedness of noted pathologies.
This paper proposes that distinct from COVID infection, mRNA vaccines suppress type I IFN leading to a cascade of deleterious downstream effects that lead to various pathologies they associate with vaccination based on VAERs report, claiming to “establish a mechanistic framework”.
This long review article presents many details about various biological pathways, but their links to mRNA vaccines are almost wholly speculative. In some cases, they link to other vaccines, old mRNA technology, or COVID-19 infection, but are not directly linked to mRNA vaccines.
In fact, so much of their evidence is from papers on severe COVID-19 infections, not vaccination, much content in this article might be better suited to a paper pointing out potential downstream dangers of severe COVID infections rather than raising alarm about mRNA vaccination.
A number of places in the article seem to make stronger statements linking mRNA vaccines to some of these processes, but they self-cite a previous review article by senior author McCullough and do not reference any primary biological research making these connections.
They suggest connections of these mechanisms to various anecdotal case reports for herpes zoster reactivation, liver damage, optic neuropathy, T cell lymphoma progression, Hepatitis C reactivation, events not yet confirmed to be related to mRNA vaccination.
The paper amounts to laying out a series of hypotheses about mechanisms of harm that may come from mRNA vaccines. Hypothesis generation is a valuable exercise, including in this context of understanding downstream biological effects of vaccination that might induce harm.
However, not all hypotheses are equally justified. Some are well-girded in direct evidence from relevant studies, while others are more speculative and extrapolate principles from other settings, e.g. SARS-CoV-2 infections or other injected vaccines, as done here.
Indeed the speculative nature of their exploration is implicitly acknowledged by the authors in their choice of wording throughout, including “is plausible”,“one can speculate”,“might be a mechanism”,“one can hypothesize”,“it appears”, “we expect”, “could eventually lead to”, etc.
It seems that rather than “establish a mechanistic framework”, this paper simply lays out speculative mechanistic hypotheses with little direct connection to mRNA vaccines. Hypotheses to validate, not principles to assume true unless disproven, as their conclusion implies.
"We call on the public health institutions to demonstrate, with evidence, why the issues discussed in this paper are not relevant to public health, or to acknowledge that they are and to act accordingly."
Their conclusion uses the classic “shifting the burden” trick, presuming that it is the responsibility of the scientific community to disprove their hypotheses rather than their responsibility to prove it. This tactic has been common in the pandemic.
The entire last part of the paper presents results from VAERs attempting to “strengthen” a causal link between mRNA vaccinations and broad classes of pathologies, including nerve inflammation, heart disorders, liver disease, thrombosis, neurodegenerative diseases, and cancer.
Their case for causation is driven by their claim that the mechanisms discussed in this paper represent “causal pathways”, the fact that most VAERs reports occur soon after infection, and that the vast majority of VAERs reports in 2021 are from COVID, not other vaccines.
"In mining VAERS for ‘signals’ that might indicate adverse reactions (AEs) to mRNA vaccinations, we acknowledge that no report to VAERS establishes a causal link with the vaccination. That said, the possibility of a causal relationship is strengthened through both the causal pathways we have described in this paper, and the strong temporal association between injections and reported AEs. Nearly 60% of all mRNA-injection-related -AEs have happened within 48 h of injection."
This follows a line of argument used by others that the only possible explanation for higher VAERs reports close to time of injection is vaccine causation, ignoring that events immediately following injection are more likely to be considered vaccine related and thus reported.
They step through their chosen symptom categories and list what % of VAERs reports in 2021 were for COVID rather than other vaccines, supposing that high % indicates that event is “especially significant as a potential toxic effect of these vaccines”
"We decided that a reasonable way to characterize the significance of adverse events linked to COVID-19 vaccines was to focus on events received in the year 2021, and to compare the counts in the “SYMPTOM” field for the events associated with COVID-19 vaccines to the total counts for that same symptom for all vaccines over that same year."
Of course, this approach assumes that event reporting rates in 2021 do not vary across vaccine type, i.e. that COVID vaccines are not more likely to be reported to VAERs than flu or other vaccines, a highly dubious assumption.
Here, from various negative control events looked up in VAERs, we can see that indeed reporting is higher for COVID than other vaccines across the board, unless you believe that vaccines cause toothaches, urinary incontinence, Xrays of limbs, or baldness.
Results from several symptom categories demonstrates how their conclusions tend to overreach and ignore important confounding effects.
Here are nerve inflammation symptoms they analyzed.
One nerve inflammation symptom is anosmia. They claim this “clearly demonstrates” the spike injected into arm reached the olfactory nerve, ignoring that anosmia is common with COVID-19 but not linked to vaccine, and could be caused by previous COVID-19 infection, not vaccine.
...There were 3,657 cases of anosmia (loss of smell), clearly demonstrating that the SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein from the injection in the arm was reaching the olfactory nerve...
Here are neurodegenerative disease symptoms they analyzed.
In presenting neurodegenerative diseases, they acknowledge that they take decades to develop, yet imply some sort of connection with COVID-19 vaccines rather than considering the higher numbers for COVID-19 vaccines might be from higher reporting rates for COVID-19 vaccines.
"Alzheimer's and Parkinson's are diseases that normally take decades to develop, and ordinarily one would assume that a vaccine has nothing to do with it. While the numbers are small, most of the cases in VAERS were linked to COVID-19 vaccines."
They conclude by suggesting these VAERs results reflect increased cancer risk from mRNA vaccination, citing their mechanistic hypotheses, in spite of the fact that cancer takes years to form, even after exposure to fallout from a nuclear weapon like in Hiroshima.
"Cancer is a disease generally understood to take months or, more commonly, years to progress from an initial malignant transformation in a cell to development of a clinically recognized condition."
"However, as we have outlined in our paper, if the mRNA vaccinations are leading to widespread dysregulation of oncogene controls, cell cycle regulation, and apoptosis, then VAERS reports should reflect an increase in reports of cancer, relative to the other vaccines, even if the numbers are small. The experiment demonstrating impairment of DNA repair mechanisms by SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in an in vitro study provides compelling evidence that the vaccines could accelerate the rate of DNA mutations, increasing cancer risk (Jiang and Mei, 2021)."
Their suggestions that they have evidence that mRNA vaccines increase cancer risk and that their literature review in this paper indicate mechanisms of action further demonstrate the overreaching nature of the claims made in this paper.
Scientists have detected, validated, and characterized various minority harm risks of vaccines, including anaphylaxis/myocarditis for mRNA vaccines, and VITT/GBS for viral vectors. Detection, validation, and characterization of any other risk is critically important.
And deep characterization of the subgroups at highest risk of these serious complications, and of the severity and long-term effects of them needs to be highly prioritized research and considered in refining vaccination recommendations.
Studies like this one integrating information from existing literature to posit hypotheses explaining these harms and others can be potentially useful.
However the purported “mechanistic frameworks” laid out in this paper lack documented connections to mRNA vaccines, instead linking them to other vaccines, old mRNA technologies, or COVID-19 infections and speculating connections to mRNA vaccines.
Additionally, their case for vaccine relatedness is built upon flawed VAERs analyses that link higher reporting rates with significance as potential toxic vaccine effect, ignoring that events COVID-19 vaccination might be reported more often, as strongly suggested by the data.
Bottom line is that unless these assertions are validated, they should be acknowledged as hypotheses to investigate, not principles that should be assumed true unless disproven. I have a feeling that is not how this paper will be represented and promoted on social media.
Studies integrating information from existing literature to posit hypotheses explaining these harms and others are potentially useful, which this paper purports to do.
However, the “mechanistic frameworks” laid out in this paper lack documented connections to mRNA vaccines, instead linking them to other vaccines, old mRNA technologies, or COVID-19 infections. This makes their hypotheses speculative at best.
The bottom line is that this paper is comprised of a number of speculative hypothesis that can be viewed as unsubstantiated assertions.
Certainly any paper proposing hypotheses needs to acknowledge they need to be investigated and validated, not assumed true unless disproven as the conclusion of this paper seems to imply.
This is especially true when the proposed hypotheses are as weakly supported as they are in this paper.
This is not how this paper will be represented, but the "shifting the burden of evidence" tactic will be used to oversell the evidence for its claims and try to suggest they have demonstrated biological principles and established risks that they clearly have not.
Germany's vaccine policy is guided by the national vaccine advisory organization STIKO which is the most scientifically sound one in the world. Germany is home to amazing scientists like Gauss, Ohm, Planck. In Germany the only required shot is measles which is dangerous because it can wipe out long lived plasma cells and cause immune amnesia. Since 2020 under the measles law, every person in Germany regardless of age and profession is required to have measles shot. No other shot is required for anyone, regardless of age or profession. No other disease is dangerous enough to warrant mandatory vaccination.
The US on one end of the spectrum requires dozens of shots under strong influence of pharma. On the other end of the spectrum, China, India, Russia, Japan, most European countries, Canada, Australia, New Zealand etc. endorse an eugenics policy and do not require any shots. So it appears Germany has the most sensible vaccine policy in the world.
In every field they have looked at, people suffer from Dunning Kruger. Vaccines is no different here.
DK has shown over and over that the people with the least knowledge, education, or skills are the ones who wildly overestimate their own knowledge. Probably because they know so litttle they aren’t even aware of their ignorance.
Driving shows this easily. 80% of people think they are in the top half of drivers. You don’t need a study to realize 30% of bad drivers are wrong. That’s not theory or anything else. That is third grade arithmetic.
The most vocal people here who argue against vaccines in almost every case are completely ignorant. Not just of science, but also the scientific process.
No child deaths have been definitively linked to Covid-19 vaccines, according to a Dec. 5, 2025 report from the Food and Drug Administration that was quietly made public more than five months later.
The analysis comes nearly six months after former FDA vaccine chief Dr. Vinay Prasad said, without releasing evidence, that the agency had identified at least 10 previously unreported child deaths tied to the vaccines.
What that implies is, that someone was at one point willing to get a vaccine, and then got a vaccine injury from that vaccine.
So they can't really say that this person is "anti-vaccine", because this person actually got vaccinated.
Anti-vaccine people, are mostly Ex-vaccine people.
They were pro-vaccine enough to go along and get whatever vaccines were required.
Then they had a bad experience, and stopped taking vaccines, and became Ex-vaccine,
And then thru their road to recovery, they dig a lot deeper into vaccines, and vaccine problems,
And then they are called "anti-vaccine" when they share what they learn, with people they care about.
Autism is the leading cause of anti-vaccine activism on twitter.
This graphic, created by Vaccinate California Co-Founder Renee DiResta, breaks down antivax activism into sub groups. "Conservatives" are green, "Anti-Vax" is purple, and "Autism" is orange. Clearly, Autism is the single greatest motivator for antivax activism.
playing devils adovcate here so dont crucify me ffs, BACK OFF MY NUTS I SAY
IF vaccines are...lets say the opposite of safe, how come the majority of vaxxed people are not dead or have any issues, pretty much every single vaccinated person I know from young to p;d has never been seriously ill or died.
If you make the argument that it "destroys" your immune system, HOW is it delayed? is their nanotech in the vaccines that delays WHEN your immune system eats itself? or is it random? like what specifically is the argument? do you lose 30% of your immunity after 1 year? or is 40%, if you get a form of aids, you would think many ppl would know about it.