r/DebateAVegan • • Apr 08 '25

Why aren't vegans kinder to those that couldn't sustain a vegan diet?

9 Upvotes

I was vegan for six years. Not the "I cheat sometimes" kind—the "check every label, argue with waitstaff, berate myself for a slip-up"* kind. I believed, like you, that there was no ethical middle ground. Either you cared, or you didn’t.

Then my body betrayed me.

The Unspoken Health Costs

At first, it was just fatigue. Then the anemia got so bad I couldn’t stand without dizziness. My hair thinned; my nails cracked. Doctors ran tests: **severe B12 deficiency, iron levels in the gutter, a thyroid sluggish from soy overload.** My gut was a wreck—years of processed vegan "meats" and legumes left me with SIBO (small intestinal bacterial overgrowth), bloated and malnourished.

I tried everything—supplements, methylated B12 shots, algae omega-3s. But my ferritin (stored iron) stayed dangerously low. Chronic insomnia set in. My cortisol spiked; I was a ghost of myself.

The breaking point? A nutritionist (a vegan one) looked at my bloodwork and said: "You need animal products. Now."*

The Vegan Community’s Betrayal

I expected concern. What I got was excommunication.

- "You didn’t try hard enough." (I spent hundreds on supplements.)

- "You’re just making excuses." (My labs were medical proof.)

- "I’d rather die than eat meat." (Spoken by someone who’d never missed a meal.)

Worst were the "wellness" vegans—privileged influencers who claimed my health crisis was "just detoxing"* or "low vibrational eating." They peddle orthorexia as enlightenment, ignoring that veganism isn’t biologically viable for everyone. (Even the *China Study* author, T. Colin Campbell, admits some thrive on meat.)

The Hard Truth: Veganism Isn’t Always Ethical

I now eat eggs from my neighbor’s pasture-raised hens and wild-caught fish. My hair grew back. My anemia resolved. I’m alive again.

But according to vegan doctrine? I’m a murderer.

The movement claims to care about all life—except the humans who can’t sustain it. That’s not ethics. That’s a cult.

The Irony of "Compassion"

Ecofeminists like Deborah Slicer argue that "moral rigidity is its own form of violence." Yet vegans weaponize purity to shame those who literally cannot comply.

I still oppose factory farms. I still minimize harm. But I refuse to apologize for surviving.

The vegan community preaches empathy—until you need it. Then, they’ll watch you starve for the cause.

And that’s not justice. That’s dogma.


r/DebateAVegan • • Dec 19 '25

Meta [meta] moderation is too lenient against non-vegans

2 Upvotes

I understand that the mods need to be "nice" to carnists so they won't feel overwhelmed/attacked by the vegan majority and keep coming back, but the rules and moderation make this place a rough experience for vegans.

Just this week, we had a user that only replied with chatGPT answers, refusing to accept any evidence that proved them wrong, and they blocked me after I accused them of this. No moderation was taken against them even though I reported and wrote to the mods.

Carnists constantly troll us and take bad faith positions, but if call them out, your reply is deleted. The mods make this a heaven for people who seek to troll vegans, but vegans are constantly moderated for doing exactly what the carnists are doing.

I think trolls and users who make bad faith arguments need to be warned/banned, not given the crazy leeway they currently get.

Edit: https://www.reddit.com/u/Ecstatic-Trouble-/s/YEL4vhi2H9 and their comments in this thread are a perfect example of users that have no place in this sub. They add nothing to it, despise vegans, make stuff up about what was said, and enjoy the suffering of people that do try to take part in this sub. If it wasn't against the rules, I'd say they are trolling all of us.


r/DebateAVegan • • Feb 24 '25

Ethics Veganism isn't as morally superior as we'd like to think

0 Upvotes

To start off, I'm a vegan, but arguing has made me realise it really isn't that black and white on being evil or not.

You've probably all heard the whole hypocrit argument from a carnist. Plants require animal deaths too, so you're still killing animals. This is pretty easily rebuted by saying "meat requires way more plants than just eating plants directly". But this still leaves two lingering points.

The first point is that we as vegans are really still not that much better than carnists moral wise. Personally I believe factory farms and such are way worse than any crop deaths out there. But if we're going to rank things on how bad they are for the animal, suddenly farms where animals are "treated humanely" become a possibility. In the end we're still killing animals, even if less so.

The second point is that veganism would require you to eat as little as possible, and rid your diet of any products that aren't nutrient dense. If the principle of veganism is to harm the least amount of animals within your ability, you'd basically have to give yourself a set diet that uses the least amount of food possible. As eating unnecessary foods would cause more plants needing to be grown, in turn causing more crop deaths.

In conclusion, I think veganism isn't as morally superior as we'd like to think because veganism still requires killing animals due to crop deaths, and veganism doesn't require you to do your utmost to stop harming animals.

To make clear this isn't a call to not go vegan / stop being vegan. It's still way better than being an omnivore. But I don't think we're that different still. We also have a cognitive dissonance to the animals we kill, and we're still killing animals for our own pleasure, even if less so.


r/DebateAVegan • • Jan 12 '25

Ethics If you are willing to feed your cat meat, you should also be willing to feed your cat dog meat

1 Upvotes

Premise: There is no morally relevant difference between killing fish, chickens, turkeys, cows, pigs, dogs, or cats.

Plant-based cat food contains all the essential nutrients that cats require. Just because it isn’t natural food doesn’t mean it is bad (think of b12 supplements).

If you think it would be “sad” to feed a cat a plant-based diet, it is much more sad to kill hundreds of animals than have a cat who might not enjoy their meals as much. (Pleasure doesn’t justify rights violations)

In this scenario, the dogs would be raised and killed the same way other animals are for pet food.

As Benjamin Tettü said, “Even if feeding pets a plant based diet was more “risky”, it would still be morally required. Because the alternative is to kill other innocent animals. Just as we shouldn’t kill dogs and cats in order to feed chickens or cows, we shouldn’t kill chickens or cows in order to feed dogs and cats.”

Conclusion: If you would be willing to feed your cat meat, you should also be willing to sacrifice hundreds of dogs just to feed your cat instead of feeding the cat nutritionally adequate plant-based cat food.

This whole thing also applies to where if you were feeding a dog meat, you should be willing to feed a dog cat meat.

It’s not letting me put links in for some reason, so I will put my sources in the comments.


r/DebateAVegan • • Jan 12 '24

Environmental benefits of veganism are way overblown

0 Upvotes

First of all, is agree that factory farming and growing monocrops to exclusively feed to livestock is bad. But the environmental benefits proported by various documentaries and people like antinoid are way overblown. Here’s a debunk of every statistic in conspiracy as an example.

https://farmingtruth.weebly.com/a-complete-debunk-of-every-cowspiracy-statistic.html

Furthermore, even if you do take the position that animal farming is as bad as cowpsirscy and other docs say… a vegan world still isn’t the optimal conclusion. It’s completely ignoring how animals are used in a sustainable circular food system which is historically how it was done.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221191241930077X

A vegan world would mean we can’t upcycle corp byproduct and graze crop residues, both of which are extremely efficient, and also means we can’t use marginal pasture land to upcycle grass. It would mean we’d become more dependent on monocrops in reality.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s43016-022-00504-z/figures/2

And it’s meaningless to compare foods environmental footprints on “kg of food product” as its nutrition that counts.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-023-00945-9


r/DebateAVegan • • May 16 '24

Ethics There is no moral justification for drinking coffee

0 Upvotes

Two things to state up front: I am vegan. Also, I don't actually believe it feels wrong for a vegan to drink coffee, but I genuinely have no justification to explain why I think that. I'll be steel-manning this point in the hope that someone can present a compelling reason for why I'm allowed to drink coffee as a vegan.

My argument is quite simple, and I believe all of the tempting rebuttals are flimsy and inconsistent with other common arguments used to defend veganism.

Coffee contains practically zero nutritional value. No calories, no vitamins or minerals, etc. It tastes good, but pretty much the only thing in it that has any effect on the human body is caffeine and some antioxidants, which can also be obtained from other sources.

Coffee is grown and harvested from plants in many countries in the world. In many cases, the coffee cherries are picked by hand. In some, it's harvested by hand or machines that strip the entire branch.

Undeniably, there is some amount of crop deaths, deforestation, human exploitation, and environmental damage as a result of the coffee industry. Since there is no nutritional value from coffee, it is unnecessary to farm it, and therefore doing so causes unnecessary suffering to sentient creatures. Drinking coffee contributes to the demand, and is therefore inconsistent with vegan ethics. There is no way for a vegan to morally justify drinking coffee. It's done purely for pleasure, and pleasure doesn't outweigh suffering.

Here are some foreseen arguments and my rebuttals to them:

  • "Caffeine is a net positive as it improves focus and productivity in humans": People can take caffeine pills that are made from other sources, especially synthesized caffeine.

  • "Antioxidants are good for you": Other things like fruits contain antioxidants in similar quantities, and provide other nutritional value, so are a better source in order to minimize suffering.

  • "Drinking coffee is a social activity or provides mental wellbeing as a daily routine": We say that this is not a justification for other social events, like a turkey at thanksgiving, or burgers at a BBQ. We can replace the item being consumed for something less harmful with more benefit and still follow a daily routine or benefit from the social aspect of it. One example would be kombucha, which is a great source of b12, caffeine, and is a probiotic.

  • "Where is the line? Should we take away vegan chocolate, alcohol, etc as well because they are consumed for pleasure?": I don't know where the line is, but in this particular case it seems very unambiguous since there are no calories or other significant nutrients in coffee.

  • "Veganism is about exploitation, and no animals are exploited so it's ok": This is an attempt to over-simplify the definition of veganism to make it convenient in certain circumstances, but I don't buy that definition. People who say that veganism is just about exploitation or the non-property status of animals still believe that it's wrong to do things like kill an animal to protect your property when a humane trap works, or do other things that are cruel but not exploitative. Avoiding cruelty is a necessary part of the definition of veganism, and causing unnecessary suffering for your own pleasure is definitely cruel.

  • "Allowing coffee makes it more likely that people will go vegan, which reduces the total amount of animals harmed": This may be true from a utilitarian perspective, but this is morally inconsistent. We could say the same thing about allowing people to consume animal products one day per week. More people would go vegan under that system, but vegans say that reducitarianism is still not permissible. Making an exception for coffee is just a form of rudicitarianism.

So please god tell me why I'm allowed to drink coffee. I beg you.


r/DebateAVegan • • Jan 14 '26

Vegans could save more animals faster if they didn’t morally flex on people

0 Upvotes

Vegans tell themselves they don’t act holier than thou; “carnists” and “blood mouths” are just defensive because they’re murderers and rapists. I don’t think this is true. I think the stereotype about vegans shaming and judging is very accurate and drives people away from the cause.

Example: Woman says she’s been vegetarian for 6 months. It’s been hard, but she has compassion for animals. Vegan finds out and calls her an animal killer, even though she’s drastically reduced her demand. She then questions whether veganism is a harm reduction practice or a moral identity that she wouldn’t want to be a part of.

Vegans police the vegan label intensely, often telling other vegans they’re not real vegans if they are “health vegans” or buy second hand leather or commit some either minor infraction. It’s obvious they care more about moral purity than saving animals or the focus would be on omnivores rather than people who are 98% vegan.

When someone stops eating animals for health, environment, etc., vegans view it as illegitimate even though animals don’t care why demand drops. This ultimately means fewer people adopting the label, and makes the movement smaller.

Basically, vegans should be more understanding, meet people where they’re at, praise people for making positive changes, stop criticizing allies for not being perfect, and stop policing the label so hard. And stop calling people unethical when we all participate in the system to various degrees and no one is perfect.


r/DebateAVegan • • Oct 29 '23

Meta Why is there so much guilt tripping?

0 Upvotes

anytime i see a post about veganism or vegans there are always people trying to guilt trip others to join them. So im curious if there are any reasons why it happens so much.


r/DebateAVegan • • Apr 01 '24

My son won't be vegan.

0 Upvotes

My wife and I are both happily vegan (her 5 years, me 9 years). We're expecting a son next month. As of now, I have no intention of insisting he be strictly vegan, or even vegetarian. I'm not sure exactly why, I just feel it's taking a risk with his health and may negatively impact his social life. Change my mind.

Especially interested to hear people who have had a critical look at literature regarding vegan children, or have experience raising vegan children in the UK.


r/DebateAVegan • • Jul 19 '26

Ethics Eating bivalves should not only be vegan, but it should be encouraged (both for vegans and not vegans)

46 Upvotes

My claim is that bivalves, such as oysters, mussels and scallops, should be eaten way more often than they actually are, they should be considered vegan and it could be especially useful for vegan diets.

I'm not a vegan, but that's just because of family related reasons. I agree 100% with vegans and intend to become one the moment I can.

The reason why I say bivalves could be useful for vegan diets is that they contain really, really large amounts of nutrients that are harder to get on a vegan diet, such as B12, omega 3 DHA and EPA and heme iron. These are not impossible to get if vegan of course, but these things are packed with them very conveniently and I think we would be missing out by not using them.

Moreover, the culturing of these bivalves is not only very easy on the environment, even more so than certain plants, it also benefits the wildlife by filtering the water and acting as food if some of them fall off to the bottom.

Now here comes the ethical part

By now we all heard that bivalves don't have a central nervous system, and so they can't suffer.

Thinking logically, nobody should then need to be concerned about consuming them.

But if somebody wants to work under the vegan definition of "avoiding animal suffering as far and practicable" then shouldn't it be allowed too? Since there's 0 animal suffering?

Now, there are two main arguments people make for not eating them:

- "I don't eat them just to be safe, they could turn out to be intelligent"

I don't get this one. Why give the benefit of the doubt to bivalves, when the current scientific consensus doesn't support that, but not to all other food we eat? That just doesn't make sense. You could say it about mushrooms, avocados, beans, whatever. I don't find it to be consistent

- "eating bivalves will confuse other people, and they will think that vegans eat fish"

Now this one is more reasonable, but I just think the pros outweigh the cons. First of all, you could just get them at the supermarket, no interaction required with other people. And in restaurants, other than opening up a lot of options especially in seafood restaurants, I don't think that ordering the spaghetti with mussels or something will drive animal cruelty that much. And you could just explain the position to other people, who might even find this more reasonable.

Honestly, I don't even love the taste of them tho. In fact I despise them, but I truthfully believe they should be consumed a lot more than they are. Theh are sustainable, packed with nutrients and cruelty free. Right now im in Japan and there's great nigiri made with them, which allows me to consume them without facing that slimy texture. You could also just blend them in a sauce.

But I hope that in the future we'll see other foods based on bivalves that will make it nore accessible, like how they make wheat with insects (not that I support that)


r/DebateAVegan • • Sep 27 '24

Buying meat-based pet food is inherently not vegan.

0 Upvotes

This was originally posted on the main sub but got held for moderation and removed, so I'm posting it here instead. I understand that by doing so, I am inviting counters to my points, but this was not originally written for that purpose so please forgive me if something is not articulated as well as it should be for the purposes of debate.

———

I've seen a lot of discussions about companion animals/pets (whatever your preferred language) that are obligate carnivores, especially cats, and feeding them species-appropriate diets within a vegan context. The opinion that I see expressed most frequently is that it is not only permissible but necessary for vegans to feed their cats meat-based food.

This position is demonstrably wrong and inherently not compatible with veganism. To profess to be a vegan yet be of the position that you must feed your pets meat is an internally contradictory claim. Here I have put together all of the most common arguments for this claim, each followed by a thorough debunk, in order to explain exactly why this is the case.

Cats are obligate carnivores. They need to eat meat to survive. If you don't feed your cat meat, that's animal abuse! 

This position comes from a fundamental misunderstanding of what it means for an animal to be an obligate carnivore. In order to provide some clarity on this issue, I will first need to explain the physiology of carnivorous animals and how it compares with omnivorous and herbivorous animals. Since this conversation is so often concerned with cats, I will use their physiology as an illustrative example.

Cats cannot produce the amino acid taurine or the fatty acid arachidonic acid or ARA endogenously (within their own bodies). They also cannot convert carotenoids to vitamin A. This makes taurine, arachidonic acid and vitamin A essential nutrients for cats (an essential nutrient being one that must be ingested from dietary sources in order to be obtained). These essential nutrients are used for building structures within the eyes, muscles, blood cells and nerves. Without these nutrients, cats can suffer complications such as blindness, heart dysfunction and heart failure, muscle atrophy, and immune deficiency. 

Taurine, ARA and vitamin A are, for all intents and purposes, only found in the tissues of animals that can produce them endogenously, e.g. herbivores and omnivores. (Plant taurine and ARA do exist, but typically in only very small amounts - nowhere near enough to sustain a cat). This is why carnivores prey on herbivores - they can only reliably get taurine, ARA and vitamin A from animals that produce it themselves. 

Apart from taurine, arachidonic acid and vitamin A, all the nutrients cats need can be found in other sources.

This is the crux of the issue - it is not the meat itself that cats need to eat to survive; it is the compounds in the meat, some of which are scarcely found in other sources, that cats need to survive. In other words, what cats need is not meat per se, but a specific set of nutrients. 

Taurine, arachidonic acid, and all the vitamins and minerals that cats need can be synthesised under laboratory conditions. These compounds have exactly the same molecular structure as the ones found in meat-based cat food - synthetic taurine and natural taurine are the exact same compound. The only difference is the origin. Synthetic nutrients behave in the body in the exact same way as their natural counterparts do. 

The good news is that vegan cat food that has been specifically formulated to meet the nutritional needs of cats is commercially available, which means that it is entirely possible to feed your cat exclusively on vegan cat food without any adverse effects on their health. Thus, the assertion that it is animal abuse to feed cats vegan cat food is false.

Would you rather vegans just didn't adopt cats? There are so many cats that need adopting, and if we don’t adopt them they’ll just go to a home where they’ll be fed meat anyway. Either that or they won’t be adopted and might get euthanised. Do you want innocent cats to die?!

Since it is possible for cats to be healthy on properly formulated vegan diets, this argument is based on a false dichotomy. Concerning the fate of the cat, the possible options are actually as follows: Either a carnist adopts the cat and feeds it meat, a vegan adopts the cat and feeds it properly formulated commercial vegan cat food, or the cat does not get adopted. (You fall into the category of “carnist” if you adopt the cat with the intention to feed it meat - even if you self-identify as a vegan. More on that later.) The claim that some vegans don’t want other vegans to not adopt cats is a strawman. The actual argument being made is that vegan cat adoption is the only non-speciesist cat adoption - it does not require the exploitation and commodification of many animals to feed one animal, because that animal will be fed vegan pet food. Thus, vegan cat adoption always results in fewer animals being exploited and commodified.

In other words, vegans who say “if you feed your cat meat, you’re not vegan”, or “either feed your cat vegan cat food or don’t get a cat”, or “killing many animals to feed one is speciesist and not vegan” and other phrases to that effect are not saying “vegans shouldn’t adopt cats”. On the contrary, we are saying “vegans absolutely should adopt cats… If they don’t compromise their veganism in order to do it!”

The assertion that the cat “will just be fed meat anyway” is essentially the same argument as is commonly made by carnists, who assert that “I might as well buy/eat the meat. If I don’t, someone else will buy/eat it anyway.” Depending on the context, this is either an Appeal to Futility Fallacy or an Appeal to Popularity Fallacy. By appealing to the assertion that if you don’t adopt the cat, the cat will be adopted by carnists and fed meat-based cat food, as the justification for buying that same meat-based commercial cat food to feed the cat, you are running counter to the very reasoning you used to conclude that you are morally obligated to be vegan, even though everyone else around you isn’t vegan. Just as you have a choice to not buy meat for your own consumption, you have the choice to not adopt the cat if you genuinely believe it is not possible to keep cats healthy on vegan cat food. To still choose to adopt the cat is analogous with inviting a carnist to come and live with you in your house for companionship, and buying animal products for them - an action that is obviously incompatible with veganism.

The “if I don’t do it, they will anyway, so I might as well” argument is also just plainly nonsensical - for every person who decides to not buy the meat, there is 1 fewer person buying meat than there would otherwise have been. Thus, the decision to not buy and eat the meat is never futile (similarly, futility is of no consequence to whether or not we ought to have internally consistent philosophical beliefs and act in accordance with them, but I digress). Likewise, the claim that the cat will certainly be adopted by a carnist if you don’t adopt them is also nonsense. If you don’t adopt the cat, there is a non-zero chance that another person who self-identifies as vegan will adopt the cat and choose to feed them vegan cat food. In such a scenario, you would certainly have contributed to more animal exploitation and commodification by adopting the cat than if you had not adopted the cat. 

There are loads of non-vegan things that vegans have to do! My medicine isn’t vegan but I still have to take it!

You are not entitled to a pet or companion animal - you do not need to get a pet or companion animal, and if you take it upon yourself to get a carnivorous pet, you are doing so purely out of choice, not necessity. If you remain unconvinced that cats can be fed vegan diets yet still want to rescue an animal from a shelter, there are plenty of other non-carnivorous species you could choose that are less likely to get adopted than the typical pet of choice, which is usually a dog or a cat. You would be doing just as much or more good adopting a less popular species such as a tortoise, a parrot or a rabbit for example, than adopting a dog or cat. 

While it is true that not all medicines are vegan, people are entitled to their medicine on the grounds of necessity, even if it contains gelatin or lactose or was tested on animals. Sometimes there is the option of a vegan version, and in those cases the vegan is obligated to take the vegan version. If no such alternative exists, then the vegan is still entitled to take the non-vegan medication on the grounds of necessity. Medicine is a fundamental human right - it is not a fundamental human right to have a pet. 

Vegan cat food is expensive. I can’t afford to feed my cat anything other than cheap meat-based pet food!

This is essentially the same argument as the carnist argument from financial expense - the assertion that “vegan products are too expensive - I can’t afford to be vegan!”. Regardless of how cheap a sirloin steak might be in comparison to wonky vegetables, rice and beans, it is still wrong to pay for the exploitation and commodification of animals - especially in a civilised society where we have access to supermarkets and do not live in a survival scenario where we have to hunt and gather for our food.

And again, as stated before - you are not entitled to a pet or companion animal, and as a person who adheres to vegan philosophy, you must understand that the morally correct option is morally correct regardless of financial cost. If you as a vegan can’t afford to feed your cat vegan cat food, then you can’t afford to have a cat. 

Meat-based cat food doesn’t contribute to animal harm because it only contains the off-cuts of meat that are not suitable for human consumption. It’s a by-product!

Once again, it is quite disturbing that this argumentation has made its way into the handbook of arguments for Reddit vegans, as this is the exact line of logic used by carnists to justify the leather industry. Regardless, the assertion is false. The cuts of meat used for pet food still have to be paid for by the pet food manufacturers, which means these off-cuts are still a commodity - a commodity made from the body parts of an animal, sold for profit. When pet food manufacturers buy offal from slaughterhouses to produce their pet food knowing you will buy it, they are directly contributing to the demand for more offal, which means more animals will be slaughtered to provide it. 

Furthermore, the claim that meat-based pet food is always made of offal, off-cuts or by-products is also false. Some of the slightly more expensive brands of pet food do actually contain muscle - the same part of the animal that is primarily produced for human consumption 1.. This means that the pet food industry directly contributes to and creates a demand for the slaughter of more animals.

Materials of animal origin come from abattoirs and animals, which have been passed as fit for human consumption by the official veterinary services.

The pet food industry is worth more than $150 billion in the US and £4.1 billion in the UK. Over 1.95 billion land animals are killed every year for cat and dog food within the US. That number goes up to 6.96 billion when global pet food supplies are taken into account. The claim that animal-based pet food somehow doesn’t perpetuate the meat industry is a delusional one based in magical thinking. If you buy meat-based pet food, you are financially contributing to animal agriculture and the deaths of billions of animals through simple supply and demand economics. 

In conclusion:

Buying meat-based pet food to sustain a pet or companion animal is inherently speciesist as it prioritises the basic rights of one species over many others, and it is an exercise in the free choice to directly support the status quo of animals as commodities. Thus, buying meat-based pet food to sustain a pet or companion animal is inherently not vegan.

In short: if you buy meat, you’re a carnist. Shocker.

Vegans don’t buy meat, whether they’re buying it for someone else or not. To buy meat is to engage in and directly support the exploitation and commodification of animals - this is the very action that is in direct conflict with veganism and the animal liberation movement. If you keep a companion animal and buy animal flesh to feed it, then you’re not a vegan. You are a carnist. It’s as simple as that. 

I encourage all vegans who are able to adopt rescued animals to do so. I also urge any and all vegans who are considering adopting a cat to do the responsible thing and think about how they’re going to feed it beforehand. Please recognise and acknowledge the inherent selfishness in being so determined to get a cat, that you are willing to contribute to the horrors and injustices of the animal agriculture industry by feeding your pet the body parts of another animal. It is abundantly clear that those who do so want a pet or companion animal for their own benefit, not for the benefit of the animals. You are, of course, completely at liberty to do so. But if you do, you’re not a vegan. 

This should not be debatable.

If you’re not prepared to either feed your cat a nutritionally complete vegan diet or rescind your vegan status to feed it meat, then don’t get a cat. If you decide to become an ex-vegan carnist and get a cat with the intention of feeding it meat, don’t be surprised when vegans get upset at you for calling yourself a vegan. You are at that point literally no different from a speciesist and carnist, who lives by the philosophy that it is okay to commodify the flesh and secretions of some animals, but not others. 

Now for some reassurances that it is absolutely okay for any vegans out there who are reading this and wish to stay vegan, to adopt cats:

All commercially available pet food must meet rigorous standards before it is allowed to go on the shelves. They are informed by teams of animal nutrition experts, including veterinarians. In the UK this regulatory body is known as The Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA). In the US, it is the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). These regulatory bodies work in alliance with the pet food associations of their respective nations; in the UK it is UK Pet Food, formerly known as PFMA (Pet Food Manufacturers Association), and in the US they are PFI (Pet Food Institute) and AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials). These associations oversee around 90% of the commercial pet food produced in their respective nations. Those that are not a member of the associations still have to adhere to the pet food manufacture regulations enforced by law.

Vegan diets can be suitable for cats if the food meets the guidelines outlined by these regulatory bodies and associations, which ensure that they get enough of their essential nutrients, including the essential vitamins and minerals, the essential amino acid taurine and the essential fatty acid arachidonic acid. 

It is recommended that you speak to your vet first to make sure that your cat can be healthy on vegan food, as it's true that not every cat can. Cats can sometimes develop a condition called crystalluria (commonly known as “urine crystals”), which is when minerals in the urine clump together and cause painful blockages in the urethra. Male cats are at higher risk of developing crystalluria because the male urethra is longer and narrower. For most cats, the best way to prevent urine crystals is to make sure the cat always has access to fresh distilled water at multiple stations throughout the home and to feed them wet food alongside or instead of kibble (soaking kibble in water is also a viable alternative).

As discussed earlier, commercially available vegan cat food is supplemented with taurine, arachidonic acid, vitamins and minerals and is therefore safe for cats to eat exclusively. Even meat-based cat food 2. contains synthetic taurine 3. :

2.

Taurine was first recognized as a necessary component of the cat's diet in the late 1980s. Since then, all diets that are formulated for cats are supplemented with enough taurine to meet the normal cat's needs.

3.

Although taurine is naturally present in numerous food sources, it is economically beneficial to synthesize the amino acid derivative with chemical reactions, rather than extract it from natural sources. For this reason, the vast majority of taurine used in supplements and other food products is chemically synthesized.

Due to how the ingredients of most commercial cat foods are processed, the taurine and other essential nutrients in the meat are partially destroyed or lost by the time the food is ready to be packaged and sold. Before pet food manufacture guidelines were introduced, it was very common for cats fed meat-based food to have diseases related to taurine deficiency. This is why even meat-based cat food is now supplemented with synthetic nutrients, including synthetic taurine 4. - especially cat foods that are designed and formulated for cats with specific dietary needs.

4.

Approximately 5000–6000 tons of taurine (synthetic and purified from natural sources) were produced in the world in 1993, and were divided at 50% for pet food manufacturing, and 50% for pharmaceutical applications. An updated global production is difficult to estimate and would require a full market analysis. […] However, there is no doubt that today’s production is considerably higher than it was in 1993. Currently, global taurine production is destined to three main uses: cat food, infant formulas and the beverage industry for “energy” drinks. 

[…]

Taurine can be produced either by extraction and purification from taurine-rich sources or by chemical synthesis. The majority of taurine is produced by chemical synthesis because extraction is less efficient, more costly, and initial materials (e.g., bovine or ovine bile) are not available in sufficient amounts to meet the global market demand.

The taurine present in meat-based cat food is exactly the same as the taurine present in plant-based cat food. It has the same molecular structure and behaves the same way in the body. Likewise for the arachidonic acid and other supplemented nutrients. Additionally, cheap commercial meat-based cat foods usually contain vegetable and cereal based fillers 5. such as corn, peas, carrots and spinach and wheat. 6. Essentially, there are far more similarities between meat-based cat foods and vegan cat foods than most people realise. 

5. 

The industry can use meat by-products, poultry pieces or leftovers from the fish filleting industry that are mixed with vegetable materials (cereals, legumes…).

6. 

Carrots, sweet potatoes, peas, and spinach are all commonly used in cat food.

There is no evidence that feeding cats vegan diets is bad for their health, so long as the vegan food is specifically formulated and pH balanced for cats. For male cats and any other cats who are at higher risk of urinary problems, pH balancing drops or paste can be added to the food or directly orally administered as a further preventative measure (remember to always read the label - it is usually not necessary to add acidifiers to vegan cat food as it is already formulated with them. Too much acidity can also be bad for your cat’s health). The pH of your cat’s urine can be tested with pH strips or a digital pH meter to ensure the food you are serving is suitable for your companion animal. The urine of a healthy cat should have a pH between 6.0 to 6.5 (a little more acidic than water). You should measure the cat’s urine directly as sticking the strips in wet litter can give a false reading. 

There is enough evidence to suggest that vegan cat food is safe, and there is also evidence that cats being fed properly formulated vegan cat food have good health outcomes. In actual fact, while this field of research is still in its infancy, cats fed vegan diets have so far been found to consistently have health outcomes that are on-par with or better than cats fed regular meat-based food.

Some commercially available nutritionally complete vegan cat foods are:

If you have any questions, concerns, or need tips for raising your companion animal on vegan pet food, please go over to the subreddit r/veganpets. I strongly recommend reading through the vegan pets FAQ for more of the scientific evidence and general information on feeding cats exclusively on vegan cat food.


r/DebateAVegan • • Nov 25 '24

Meta "I'm vegan for the environment" is analogous to...

9 Upvotes

[EDIT - Sorry to everyone I haven't responded to, Thanks to everyone who pointed out the inconsistencies in my analogies! Needs work :) ]

[Edit 2 - A few people have suggested I am gatekeeping. FYI I will be the first to call someone vegan for any reason because I think the psychological concept "Self-perception theory" works.
I don't have an issue who calls themselves vegan. Don't really care. The more people checking the 'vegan' box on the census, the more positive that will be on normalizing veganism in society.
The purpose of this post (Which I obviously wrote very poorly, my bad) is for those of us seeking to accurately portray veganism in our own activism, and thinking. And that the sentence "humans should stop exploiting animals because of the environmental benefits that will provide us" shifts attention away from the issue being raised—that it's wrong to exploit animals, regardless of the environmental impact.

Thanks for everyone who responded. I will leave it there!]

(Vegan here hoping to be challenged on my view, I hope this is a different enough take on this topic, disregard if you are bored of it!)

"I'm vegan for the environment" is analogous to:

I'm against child labour for the higher quality clothing.
I oppose war for cheaper gas prices.
I support LGBTQ+ rights for my social reputation.
I support racial equality for my economic gain.
I donate to homeless shelters for better urban aesthetics.
I support women's rights for a stronger economy.

The environmental (or health) benefits of veganism are incidental/coincidental.

Assuming the definition of veganism is: the principle that humans should live without exploiting animals. It seems completely nonsensical to me to say "I think humans should live without exploiting animals...for the environment or health.
"I eat a plant-based diet for the environment" is fine. You are an environmentalist.
"I eat a plant-based diet because it aligns with the principle of veganism. You are a vegan.
You can be an environmentalist and a vegan at the same time!

Would anyone like to poke holes in/challenge my logic on this?
Or point out why some of the examples above don't work?


r/DebateAVegan • • Jun 22 '26

Why do you refuse to call the 90% vegan...a vegan?

0 Upvotes

If they truly believe in the cause, and all they can manage to do is 90%, why do you think calling them vegan is wrong?

You and I use phones, cars and an abundance of other products that contain animal products, are we not vegan?


r/DebateAVegan • • Jul 14 '25

Why is the truth behind dairy, egg, meat and fish not part of our education?

7 Upvotes

Why is the lawful mistreatment of animals, which is found in the lunch boxes, our fridges and stores, hidden from us?

Why do we have to find out about it only decades after being so used and normalised to it, that it has become too hard for the majority to avoid it?

I'm talking about the 100% slaughter of all dairy cows and egg laying hens, and their babies.

About mutilating cows, chicks, piglets. Lawfully smashing babies on the floor. Lawfully macerating or suffocating billions of perfecly fine 1-day old chicks and straight to the garbage.

About 1-3 trillion fish suffocating to death, most thrown away as garbage too.

Why are we taught to not do to birds what we do to chickens, not to do to four legs what we do to cows and pigs and lambs, not to do to dolphins what we do to fish?


r/DebateAVegan • • Aug 04 '25

Ethics Why I quit veganism and find it foolish

0 Upvotes

I get it, it's completely possible to gain enough nutrients as a vegan. That does not undermine the fact it's difficult still, and distasteful. The non-vegan alternatives at the end of the day, perhaps they are more delicious. I don't think this undermines willpower. I argue in A2 why veganism is just an emotion. So if anything, my preference is too. Being vegan, is to feel good fulfilling empathetic needs. Eating non-vegan is to fulfill desire needs. Veganism creates difficulties like eating at restaurants. That is a relevant reason. Why should all effort go to fulfilling this one emotion of empathy. Perhaps if empathy causes so much trouble, better it not be there.

I completely understand the vegan arguments. How could you support such a cruel system?

Yes, perhaps animals are fed into a system to be killed. So what? It's not like I could ever stopped that from happening. Atp, the remains of these animals, whether it's meat, or milk, are just remains, nothing of the animal it once was. I understand veganism is like saying no to a cruel system, and honestly, I respect it. However it's fantasy, not real action. Every animal that would have died will still die, the vegan does not stop that. The vegan objects, but the objection is fruitless. The rebuttal I know you are thinking of atp is, "well, one vegan does nothing, many vegans makes change!"

But here's the thing. That is again, just constructing this fantasy of the collective. Nobody aside from a few extremely influential individuals has agency over anything but their own actions. For me, it was either deciding to be vegan or not. If I was not vegan, there would be one less vegan, not the collapse of a vegan movement. Perhaps if everyone was vegan, change would occur. Reality is not everyone is. Choosing of your own volition to be vegan is just fantasy without any real change.

I used to think it was hypocritical people could claim to love their dogs but be ok with pigs dying. I think that's a foolish argument. Ethics are based on emotion, not logic. Logic prescribes consistent action based on the emotion, but not the emotion itself. Therefore I find it completely acceptable that people are more inclined to love their dogs, which humans are evolutionary more attached to. I don't like how veganism pretends humans have an ethic that says all lives should matter the same, or something in that shape where life is kind of equivalent. Why? There's no reason why all lives should be the same. We obviously all value our family more than others. We value friends more than strangers. Veganism constructs this fantasy of animal rights.

Maybe you think empathy is the key. I confess I still am burdened with feeling empathy for animals, but I hope such feelings dissolve. Here's the deal though: Empathy is an emotion. I respect you if you feel empathy for animals. However that's all it is, a preference. You cannot tell someone else "Hey, you should feel empathy for animals." They don't feel empathy for animals, so there's no grounding for them to do so. Perhaps you think, well if you don't feel basic empathy at these animals dying, you're psychopathic and insane!

Let's talk about empathy. Empathy developed as a trait in humans because it allowed understanding, crucial for survival in tribal groups. So obviously most people feel a lot of empathy for other humans and if a human died or something it would suck. You just can't generalize this to they should have felt empathy for animals, because this was not an evolutionary useful trait. In fact it might've actually hurt if early humans weren't willing to kill animals. I am not trying to invoke the naturalistic fallacy like a lot of bad anti-veganism arguments that say "humans have always eaten meat!" cause clearly that's not reasoning. What I'm saying is you can't criticize someone for not feeling empathy for animals and they are unnatural: no empathy for animals is anything but unnatural.

Look I get it. You feel empathy for animals and I respect that. That dosen't mean everyone should or does. It's just an emotion and it makes sense why people don't. How would you feel if someone said we should feel empathy for plants? Yes, eating vegan kills less plants than not eating vegan. Let's not pretend you care about plants like animals. Why do you not care about plants though? They are alive, are they not. The reason is because empathy never developed because they are too dissimilar. And that's really it. An emotion is not there.

But honestly any vegan argument just relies on why empathy for animals is necessary. The fact they can feel pain, is empathy. But I believe empathy is an emotion, not an argument.

Thanks for reading. Looking forward to hear and respond to some counterarguments.


r/DebateAVegan • • Nov 16 '23

Ethics Vegans are gifted with one of the most easily defensible and logically sound positions possible - why are they so bad at arguing for it?

3 Upvotes

From any perspective, the vegan position is extremely sound. It's objectively better for the environment, and you'd be hard pressed to find someone who doesn't agree that animals suffering is at least a little bit bad. So why are vegans notoriously bad at defending their point? My opinion is that they focus too heavily on the ethical side of things (animal rights) rather than the practical side of things (climate change, etc.). It's very hard to convince someone they are wrong, and have been engaging in bad behavior they're entire lives. This immediately provokes an emotional response and the chance of a logical debate flies out the window. It's much easier to demonstrate the practical good veganism does for society and our planet, at least in my opinion.


r/DebateAVegan • • Feb 06 '25

Why don’t vegans eat honey?

0 Upvotes

Even under the standards vegans abide by, honey seems as though it should be morally okay. After all, bees are the only animal that can be said to definitively consent, since if they didn’t like their treatment, they could fly elsewhere and make a new hive, and no harm is being done to them, since they make far more honey than they need.


r/DebateAVegan • • Nov 27 '22

i try to make vegan choices where i can, but i am not vegan. i am sick of rude vegans harming their own cause

0 Upvotes

i care deeply for animals and think we as a society need to change how we treat them. in my ideal world, animal product would be a luxury, and all come from humane sources.

i buy the majority of my shopping vegan, and treat all dairy eggs and meat as luxury. i try to promote the idea that you dont have to be fully vegan to make these choices, and that if everyone did this it would make more of a difference than a percentage of people being fully vegan.

i spend a lot of time in vegan recipe groups and such, and i have experienced some horrible things in them. I've had: . vegans being generally rude to me and saying i dont belong in the groups . people telling me and my boyfriend that its wrong for us to buy vegan products, because we're taking them away from real vegans . one rather angry woman insisting that if you're friends with people who eat meat thats the same as being friends with child r*pists (screenshots of this in my post history) . the second vegans find out I'm not 100% vegan they become very hostile towards me . non vegans always being super confused about me using vegan alternatives whilst not being vegan, like theyve never even heard of that being an option

my point being: how can vegans claim to care for animal suffering and want to lesson it whilst treating anyone who tries to reduce their consumption of animal product like this? it seems to me that the vast majority care more about feeling superior to others. would it not be in the best interests of the vegan cause to welcome and promote the idea of people reducing their consumption in the way i do? i am fairly sure that if it wasnt for the way vegans are, more people would be doing this.

here because im really tired of the hostility and i just want to know there are some rational friendly vegans out there.

edit: nobody labelled a vegan is being rational. i guess it was too much to ask for. i shall continue making plant based choices where i can (despite how hard vegans make it) and trying my best to encourage others to do the same. i hope for a non toxic vegan community some day.


r/DebateAVegan • • Feb 20 '25

Is it vegan to eat foods you don't need to survive?

10 Upvotes

Is coffee vegan? Sure, that plain cup of black coffee doesn't contain animal products directly, but a whole lotta insects and small mammals died to produce it, not to mention the animals who are threatened with extinction due to habitat loss driven by the coffee industry. No one needs coffee to live, it is purely a luxury item, nor does cutting coffee out of your life cause undue difficulty living in todays world, like not driving a car would for many people.

So does consuming coffee, or tea, or chocolate, or any other luxury plant based food item that provides little to no nutritional value and is only consumed because we enjoy it, count as causing or participating in unnecessary deaths? If not why not?


r/DebateAVegan • • Jun 30 '25

Ethics Why not eat honey or use wool

0 Upvotes

Like why? It’s beneficial to the animal and for wool it’s just sheep wig wig but sheep and if no sheep wig sheep get hot . Hot sheep go sick and sick sheep go dead. Ifyou’re asking about “in the wild” the answer is they aren’t found in the wild it’s called domestication we made sheep for wool.

The honey part

Bees have right they make honey. When bee in bee farm it get home, food, protection in exchange for money. It’s just capitalism and bees in bee farms produce more honey than needed in order to pay bee rent, they then put their “rent honey” in a different comb like a bee safe for the “rent honey”. BEE FARMS ARE BEE APARTMENTS!!! so if you want us to treat animals like people eat honey!


r/DebateAVegan • • Feb 14 '24

In practice, veganism insists upon an arbitrary cutoff between moral sufficiency and deficiency.

1 Upvotes

First, let me get one thing straight. I don’t care what veganism is “in theory”. If that theoretical construct doesn’t match veganism as it typically plays out in reality, then it’s no better than a thought experiment.

In the real world, most of those who adopt the label of “vegan” have decided that there is a particular line that primarily divides moral adequacy from moral inadequacy amongst common behaviors - that is the consumption of animal products.

In the real world, if you eat a beef burger once a month, you’re not considered a vegan, and vegans will consider you morally deficient. Veganism, in practice, demands that one abstains from animal products without exception.

When called out on this, the vegan response is usually something along the lines of “but if you were to rape someone only once a month, that’s not good enough. For some behaviors, the only acceptable amount is none at all.”

However, in practice, that rhetoric gets thrown in the trash when most other common behaviors are considered. For example, by purchasing plant based fast food options, you are helping keep the restaurant afloat, which entails buying large quantities of meat. And while the vegan society’s definition includes a catch all escape route of “as far as is possible and practicable”, that excuse doesn’t work on buying beyond burgers from Burger King. One can easily avoid eating there altogether.

The oddity in all of this is that with regard to the consumption of animal products, perfection is required. But with regard to other common behaviors that act against the theoretical vegan ethic, there is virtually no insistence on abstinence.

The fact that the expectation of perfection dissolves at a very precise point suggests that veganism at the practical level is an arbitrary hard moral line of moral sufficiency. That is likely true of society’s morals as well - but the question is, if both are ultimately arbitrary, how can veganism be “more correct” than the standards adopted by society at large?


r/DebateAVegan • • May 11 '25

There is no ethical argument against individuals eating meat

0 Upvotes

In a vacuum I respect veganism as a personal statement, I think it’s noble to show such a commitment to one’s beliefs. But what bothers me is so many vegans taking it from a personal choice, to a responsibility imposed on every individual, and they are who this argument ks specifically directed towards. There are environmental consequences to over farming, overfishing, etc, but I’m specifically talking about those who find the act of eating meat itself morally wrong and extend that to those who do eat it.

A common reason for this opinion is the belief that human and animal lives are equal, and that it’s unethical to inflict pain on a living being. But this is a contradictory argument in my opinion. How can one believe human lives are equal to animal lives, yet condemn others for meat eating, which is engaged in by every animal with the capacity to do so? And this isn’t me just making some unfair anthropomorphization, many animals are highly intelligent, capable of advanced cognition and even morals.

According to a New York Times article, “Chimpanzees, who cannot swim, have drowned in zoo moats trying to save others. Given the chance to get food by pulling a chain that would also deliver an electric shock to a companion, rhesus monkeys will starve themselves for several days.” These apes, along with many other animals, are capable of real love, compassion, and even a sense of right and wrong, yet at the same time chimpanzees will occasionally kill other animals, even themselves, for food all the time. Are they morally wrong? Keep in mind they’re mainly fruit eaters, they dont need meat to live but they eat it anyway cause they like it. It’s ironic to me that some vegans care so much for the natural world, yet are so detached from it. We’re not separate from or above the earth just because we can think on a high level. The only reason we do so is a resource surplus and no natural predators.

Which brings me to my next point. I think the idea of scarcity and surplus plays into the demographics of who ethical vegans are. Worldwide, vegans tend to be somewhat diverse and lower income, but this statistic seems misleading to me. Many vegans are college kids and young people who don’t have serious careers yet so no serious income. At the same time they may also have less financial responsibilities so more money to devote towards their lifestyle. In addition, these polls also include those just in it for health benefits, or because they’re too poor to afford meat.

Unfortunately I couldn’t find one, but if a poll was taken of vegans in it just because they feel bad for the animals, I’m sure i’d find them to be primarily white, middle to upper class, and more highly educated than the general population. Those who are already privileged have the time and energy to worry about issues like this. A single mother with 3 kids isn’t concerned about the instant ramen pack having chicken broth, and an African bushmeat hunter trying to survive doesn’t care if chimps are endangered. People with scarce resources focus on finding them however they can, while those with access to resources have the time to form opinions like veganism in the first place.

IMO the time some vegans spend criticizing people for any amount of meat consumption would be better spent attacking mega farms and pushing for humane, sustainable farming and fishing. But the meat industry as a whole isnt going anywhere, neither should it. Every species eats meat and we don’t have to abstain just because we have the biological fitness to consider it. We should use that intelligence to manage the impact our consumption has on the environment, not eradicate it.


r/DebateAVegan • • Oct 19 '22

Ethics I don’t understand Vegans

7 Upvotes

I have tried to explore Veganism a bit. I have read a lot about nutrition and that argument is far from compelling. I read a philosophy textbook that had a chapter on Veganism and the ethical argument was a little more compelling. It’s tricky though because morality is relative and it basically comes down to Vegans feeling like killing animals is unethical. Let me explain. Everyone is a speciest. I don’t know of one vegan who wouldn’t fumigate their home if it had a severe termite infestation instead of moving to a new home. This would involve killing upwards of 1,000,000 living creatures. As far as science can tell insects show signs of sentience, have a central nervous system, and can feel pain. They are much more simple than humans, but then again so are all animals. There is no hard morally justified line differentiating a pig from a dog, chicken, salmon, crab, bee, or termite. For some reason some small percentage of humans believe intentionally killing animals for our own pleasure is a horrendous act comparable to genocide, but killing termites is just an unfortunate necessity.

My question for debate. Why do Vegans apparently arbitrarily put more moral value on living organism most similar to humans? What is wrong with the humanist view that the starting point of all moral or ethical arguments should be humans? I believe the mental health of slaughterhouse workers is important, the nutritional value of human diets is important, the sustainability of farming methods is important, etc. but only with the understanding that humans are the primary focus of my morality. In the case of me raising a cow for slaughter in my backyard I see absolutely zero negative impact on my life (as long as I’m conscious of cholesterol, moderate my portions, and cook in a safe way, etc.) and see tons of benefits such as incredibly tasty and satisfying protein and iron rich meals.

What is wrong with this moral view? We are all speciests, so why not focus all moral arguments on the well being of humans? I’m genuinely curious and am open to changing my mind if I hear a compelling argument.


r/DebateAVegan • • Dec 14 '23

Should Vegans Boycott France?

4 Upvotes

France 🇫🇷 has been actively trying to block banning foie gras

The French Consulate sent letters to the NYC City Council asking it not to pass the ban, because it would affect the 1,300 restaurants in the city that serve foie gras. After California voted for a foie gras ban in 2004, the French government also intervened there, saying it would be “an assault on French tradition.”

What about entertainers who eat foie gras?


r/DebateAVegan • • Jun 07 '25

✚ Health Anti-Factory Farm, but not Vegan. Anything else I can do?

10 Upvotes

Please note that you absolutely will not convince me to go vegan. For health reasons, I truly cannot. "But supplements!" "But complex protein replacements!" "But--!" No. I am medically underweight and have been for my entire life due to a relatively rare cocktail of health issues. I tried a tentative bout of vegetarianism a while back and was almost hospitalized.

That being said, I'm extremely against factory farms and the fur industry. I heavily value finding and supporting local food sources; I get about 90% of my meat directly from a local free-range farmer, and I get my eggs and honey from a neighbor who keeps chickens & bees. I eat tofu or beans as the primary protein in about a third of my meals, and I'm currently working on adding to my organic vegetable garden. I do own leather and fur, but all of it was either second-hand or gifted to me.

Outside of actually ceasing eating animal products, what is your advice to people like me who are unable/uninterested in going vegan, but do genuinely disagree with cruel factory farm practices and the industrialized food complex? I want to live responsibly, be environmentally conscious whenever possible, and make a positive impact on my local community. I'm willing to listen!