Of course everyone is free to participate, but when it comes to who I'm debating, this post is aimed exclusively at Catholics.
My thesis/argument,
-- If you believe in Catholic doctrine, then the Vatican is leading half of their flock to hell while leaching off of their righteous members.
-- For everyone who doesn't believe in Catholic doctrine, it's obvious the Vatican is leaching off of all of their members and telling both factions whatever they want to hear.
-- It's pretty obvious none of the people running the Catholic Church believe a word of their silly doctrines. And if they do, then they are even worse, because that means they are fine leading at least half of their base to hell.
I was writing a post for a blog about my opinion on the Latter Day Saints (LDS), which inspired this post. The LDS is a huge organization, but unlike the Catholic Church, their members are much more uniform in their beliefs.
On the one hand, I respect that the Catholic Church allows for a wide range of beliefs within their system, but on the other hand, they are doing it for all of the wrong reasons and the way they do it is immoral.
I have several Christian friends, including friends of different denominations, and friends of different traditions within the denominations themselves, like with Catholics. In the case of Catholics, I have multiple Catholic friends, most of them are the liberal kind, who believe being gay is not a sin, and are in favor of birth control, abortion, etc. And that's great, I agree with them on that. But my issue isn't with them, it's with their church. The Vatican teaches they are heresy, and if they don't change before they die, God, the most merciful being ever, will roast them in a fire forever. But their local parish doesn't teach any of this. They teach a fun and rosy version of Catholicism.
While I hate many churches for being openly bigoted, I at least respect that they are clear to their members about their beliefs. The Catholic Church plays their liberal flock by allowing them to believe in what they call heresy, just so they can keep taking their money. Those liberal parishes still proclaim to adhere to Catholic doctrine, meaning by their own proclamations, they are leading their flock to hell.
Meanwhile, I have one friend who is a Conservative Catholic, a true to life Crusader larper, who thinks the Church is one Pope away from bringing back the "good old days" before Vatican 1. I openly call him a Crusader larper, I'm not taking any digs at him behind his back. I met him in a religious studies class and he's very serious about following every jot and tittle of Catholic doctrine. Although he doesn't like Vatican 2, he does mental gymnastics to incorporate it's existence into his beliefs. And before you say he's one case, he's invited me to mass and to hangout with his other Catholic friends, who share his religious beliefs and are also hopeful about having a new Pope like Benedict the next time they pick a Pope. Everyone I met at his parish was also a Crusader larper, or in politer terms, a "Traditional" Catholic.
The Crusader larpers are being played even more than the liberal Catholics I know, because their parish is all hoorah about being "traditional," and looking down on the liberal parishes, so they stay with the Catholic Church, hoping for the good old days to come, while they complain about their church being "infiltrated by heretics." Meanwhile the Vatican will give out a Pope like Benedict every once in a while to appease their Crusader larping base, but then they switch to a moderate Pope like Leo to appease their liberal base while also not pissing off the larpers too much.
My theory is that Francis really pissed off the Crusader larping base of the Catholic Church, and Benedict really pissed off the liberal Catholics, so this time they chose Leo as a moderate. And I hate to admit it, but it seems to have worked. My liberal Catholic friends adore Leo, and my Crusader larping friend and his friends like Leo enough, far more than Francis for sure. And for the Vatican, I think that's exactly what they want.
It's obvious to anyone outside of the Catholic Church that the Vatican is playing both sides of their base and that they have no plans to change the status quo.