r/DebateACatholic • • 5h ago

Should y'all really be political animals? Means and ends n such

1 Upvotes

Basically my contention is in liberal democracies you guys lobbying for religious rights is employing consequentialist logic, and is thus hypocritical.

To elaborate:

P1. Liberal states cannot distinguish between religious groups. It's legislatively prohibited.

C1: as such one cannot assume or guarantee the intention of any legislation is to help Catholics specifically. Even if lobbied for by Catholics.

P2: Giving your group a particular right can give the opposite right to another group. (Eg US Satanists having protected abortion as a religious ritual vs Catholic Drs refusing the operation)

P3: either this given right is acceptable becouse you are a majority (1) or because the intention is good (2).

C2: 1 is consequentalist and 2 is against p1 and P2

Thus:

Catholics engaging in politics violates the doctrine of double effect as intentions cannot be guaranteed and the consequence is the only moral metric. And consequslisim is antithetical to Catholic ethics.


That's my argument anyway, wanna know more about how you guys justify evaluating something such as a government decision to allow a private hospital to refuse abortion, as morally good. Particularly in regards to the government decision itself and the decision being morally good as opposed to something you happen to like.

Edit: Also coming from a place of genuine curiosity, which is why I'm offering an internal critique (from my very limited understanding). As a way to learn more about your guys actual doctrines


r/DebateACatholic • • 7h ago

Why Can't Catholics Be Assured Of Their Salvation?

1 Upvotes

I was thinking over this as protestants seem to throw this a lot:

State of Grace means you are saved

Mortal sin means you are damned

Mortal sin means you know the gravity of the sin and yet you still did it.

So you would know if you are in mortal sin or not.

Let's say someone for example sinned mortally.

If God forgives sinners and he/she lets say repents sincerely and wants the relationship with God back and promises to go to confession let's say a week from now when it is available, why is he/she not saved?

From the Catechism

CCC 1452 is explicit that forgiveness through perfect contrition includes the resolution to have recourse to sacramental confession as soon as possible.


r/DebateACatholic • • 23h ago

A Catholic moral dilemma: When does fighting to protect your child become harmful, and when does stepping back become abandonment?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I’ve been exploring this situation from a Catholic moral and theological perspective, particularly the responsibilities we have as parents, the distinction between perseverance and surrender, and what it means to protect a child when every available option seems to carry the potential for harm.
I shared a more detailed post in r/Catholicism because I wanted to better understand what my faith teaches about these competing responsibilities. I’m not looking for anyone to make this decision for me. I have professionals involved, but I believe considering different perspectives can help me approach such a serious decision with greater understanding and discernment.
For anyone interested in the spiritual and moral questions surrounding situations like ours, I’d really appreciate your thoughts.


r/DebateACatholic • • 2d ago

just a question regarding christian

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DebateACatholic • • 2d ago

Catholic or Protestant

0 Upvotes

I was raised German Catholic and I studied Islam but I go to Protestant churches. I disagree with the Catholic teachings of papal infallibility and supremacy and confession, I also am unsure about the literal body and blood of Christ I am Willing to debate these issues or an answer ans questions about Protestantism if am able.


r/DebateACatholic • • 3d ago

Eucharistic identity does not entail substantial presence

2 Upvotes

This isn’t an argument about whether transubstantiation is metaphysically possible—that has been debated ad nauseam, and I believe a more suited argument can be formulated.

I’m challenging whether it is theologically necessary to explain what Scripture actually establishes. Catholic Eucharistic theology equivocates sacramental identification and substantial identity, treating the former as though it automatically entails the latter.

The phrase “This is my body,” establishes the identity of the sacramental object, but does not independently establish the ontological mode of its presence. Concomitance cannot bridge this inferential gap, since it presupposes the substantial presence it is used to explain. Therefore, transubstantiation requires an additional premise that cannot be derived from the language of identification “is” alone.

By what principle does identifying something as Christ's body establish that it has become Christ's bodily substance? We cannot jump from relational identity to metaphysical conversion without an explanatory ground for that inference.

The identity of Christ's human body is already determined by its union with the Logos. His body does not acquire its identity through the Eucharist, and neither does his person become more fully constituted by the conversion of bread. Another hidden premise that must be established is why the sacramental identification requires the disappearance of the bread's substance and the substantial presence of Christ's already-existing body. Like concomitance, hypostatic union cannot explain either— it only explains whose body is present, not how the elements become that body.

This renders transubstantiation no more than a theological inference, rather than a necessary consequence of the phrase “this is my body.”

Look at 1 Corinthians 10:16-17 where Paul describes the bread as a participation in Christ’s body. Then immediately in the same context—identifies the believers as one body because they share one bread. It shows that real participation and identity do not require substantial presence/conversion. No one argues that believers undergo a metaphysical transformation into the body of Christ.

In other words, if Paul can identify substantially distinct people as one body through their participation in Christ, why does identifying one bread with Christ's body automatically entail the disappearance of that bread's substance?

EDIT:

Consider what Scripture does not attribute to the Eucharist. Even if we grant “is” to mean a predication of substance, that does not automatically entail a predication of person. This is beyond metaphysics and about epistemic/logical warrant. The metaphysics could have been just a byproduct to explain away the theological inference of “is” meaning “substance.” Stating it is also his “soul and divinity” smuggles in the person.

Body, blood, soul, and divinity are neither the identity nor person of Christ. And “divinity” needs qualifying. Divine nature and divine person are answering two different questions. Divinity answers “what”, not “who.”


r/DebateACatholic • • 5d ago

Inquiry into your input of our Theological conditions currently/Nostra aetate?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DebateACatholic • • 6d ago

It is never moral to kill innocent people. God commanded it anyway.

6 Upvotes

The Bible says children must not be punished for their parents’ sins (Deut 24:16, Ezek 18:20). Yet 1 Samuel 15 commands the destruction of Amalekite children for the sins of their ancestors, and kills innocent people.
Therefore, God goes against his own standard of justice,or the bible is not from God; it's not what really happened, it wasn't God speaking.

Premise 1: In 1 Samuel 15:2-3, God says he will punish Amalek for what they did to Israel after the Exodus, and commands Saul to kill men, women, children, and infants.

1And Samuel said to Saul, “The Lord sent me to anoint you king over his people Israel; now therefore listen to the words of the Lord. 2Thus says the Lord of hosts, ‘I have noted what Amalek did to Israel in opposing them on the way when they came up out of Egypt. 3Now go and strike Amalek and devote to destructiona all that they have. Do not spare them, but kill both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’”

Premise 2: The offense (Exodus 17:8-16) happened roughly 400 years before Saul’s campaign, so none of the people killed took part in it.

Then Amalek came and fought with Israel at Rephidim. 9So Moses said to Joshua, “Choose for us men, and go out and fight with Amalek. Tomorrow I will stand on the top of the hill with the staff of God in my hand.” 10So Joshua did as Moses told him, and fought with Amalek, while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill. 11Whenever Moses held up his hand, Israel prevailed, and whenever he lowered his hand, Amalek prevailed. 12But Moses’ hands grew weary, so they took a stone and put it under him, and he sat on it, while Aaron and Hur held up his hands, one on one side, and the other on the other side. So his hands were steady until the going down of the sun. 13And Joshua overwhelmed Amalek and his people with the sword.

Premise 3: Deuteronomy 24:16 says children are not to be put to death for their fathers’ sins, and Ezekiel 18:20 says the son does not bear the guilt of the father.

Conclusion: The command contradicts the standard of justice the Bible itself lays out, so either God violates his own law or the text doesn’t represent God accurately, and God is a moral monster.


r/DebateACatholic • • 8d ago

Saintly people outside the Catholic faith

1 Upvotes

I do find that Catholic and Orthodox and sone protestant churches have some truly amazing people clearly full of the holy spirit. If God said there is only one truch outside of which there is no salvation, how can this occur?


r/DebateACatholic • • 8d ago

Adoctrinamiento cristiano?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DebateACatholic • • 9d ago

Permitted, Regulated, Never Prohibited: The Bible and Slavery

10 Upvotes

My claim is that GOD/The Bible regulates the buying, inheriting, and beating of people as property without ever prohibiting that institution, while prohibiting many other things that were culturally normal. If a moral lawgiver wanted slavery abolished, silence plus detailed regulations is an odd way to communicate it.
I'm NOT claiming that the Bible says it's GOOD, another "moving the goalpost" attempt by slavery apologists.

We all know the slavery passages, although slavery apologists often will leave them out.
LEV 25: chattel slavery, buy foreigners, inheritance, passed down.
EX 21: young girls sold, slaves forever, with their children.
If a man stays past his indentured time because he wants to keep his wife and kids, he's a slave forever.
Deut 20/21. God tells His people to go kill off the people, unless they become Israel's slaves. If they go to war, the women and girls are kidnapped and taken as concubines.

THE DATA IS CLEAR. The Bible was fine with owning others as property and never prohibited it.

The common responses.
Kidnapping verses only cover trafficking, so it FAILS.
Slaves were attained in other ways.
Slaves were bought, taken in war.

Jesus on Divorce. FAILS.
Jesus names divorce as a concession and says, “From the beginning it was not so.” Where does any text say that about slavery? Permitted-but-not-ideal is never stated... This is wishful thinking.

Jubilee. FAILS. Only for Hebrews, doesn't affect the chattel slaves and war concubines.

Returning escaped slaves. FAILS.
This is about foreign slaves coming to Israel, not abolition, and it's widely accepted by scholars.

NT, GAL, PHIL, FAILS.
Neither actually commands abolition, and Ephesians 6:5 and Colossians 3:22 instruct slaves to obey their masters. PAUL goes on to tell slave owners how to treat their slaves, not to free them.
Illogical.

One of the most common, ACCOMODATION. GOD meets people where they are...FAILS.
AND/OR, everyone did it; it was normal in ANE societies.
Illogical.
Why would God accommodate this and not, say, child sacrifice, which he prohibited outright? And it only took some 1800 years for Christians, the Holy Spirit, to figure this out???
Illogical.

Same goes for the Golden Rule. FAILS.
JESUS nor PAUL ever prohibited slavery. IF Jesus was referring to the status and institution of slavery, why did PAUL and PETER and everyone else, including the CHURCH, for a 1000 years not get that??
Again, Illogical.

Slavery was normal, accepted, and perhaps not thought of as immoral or unethical. TODAY we think it is. THIS supports the idea that Morality is NOT objective as well, at least some things are not.

The Bottom line is, if you think owning others is immoral and evil, then your moral compass is better than God's, OR, it was ethical back then, but not today. OR, the Bible is not a product of God, but of man.
Pick your poison.


r/DebateACatholic • • 9d ago

Did You Know Five Bishops in the Orthodox Church in America are Converts from Catholicism?

0 Upvotes

The OCA has 15 active bishops active bishops. A number of these bishops are converts. Looking at the OCA Web page that gives brief biographies of each bishop I noticed that a number have Catholic backgrounds. These bishops are

Archbishop Nathaniel Popp - a convert from the Romanian Greek Catholic Church

Archbishop Mark Maymon

Archbishop Ajejo Pacheco y Vera

Archbishop Daniel Brum

Bishop Benedict Churchill

See the web page for matter of fact references to their conversions

https://www.oca.org/holy-synod/bishops

The reason I bring this up is two fold. The first is the common accusation that Roman Catholics convert to Orthodoxy (or change to Byzantine Catholicism) to become married priests. The second is that reading the history of the pre-schism Papacy will naturally flow into an understanding of the Papacy that matches Vatican 1.

I do not wish to embarrass these bishops and I'm not interested in personal comments about them. Their mini bios only mention their conversions in passing.

What I am interested in is comments on why the pre-schism evidence is so hard to interpret. I have read have read extensively on the issue of the Papacy (feel free to look at my post history) and found the pre-schism Papacy to be different from the post-schism Medieval Papacy.


r/DebateACatholic • • 10d ago

Halloween is Catholic

2 Upvotes

The Coligny calendar or the bronze Celtic calendar mentions samonios marking a time period but it does not mention anything regarding specific rituals at all. This is the second century AD

609 AD Pope Boniface the 4th consecrate the pantheon in Rome and establishes the first collective fees for Martyrs celebrated on May 13th

700 AD English and Germanic churches begin moving their local Allstate celebration to November 1st purely for local harvest abundance reasons

Around 800 AD the Irish Church document martyrology of tallaght proves Irish Christian celebrate their collective saints on April 20th showing no link to November

835 AD Pope Gregory the 4th officially mandates the entire Western Catholic Church observe All saints Day on November 1st cementing October 31st Is All Hallows Eve

1100s AD the Táin Bó Cúailnge and Irish myths are written down by monks describing samhain as a time of seasonal tribal assemblies political gatherings and feasts

This is the era when the spooky elements of samhain are first recorded in writings tails like adventures of Nera and the Táin Bó Cúailnge depict samhain as a liminal night where the ancient burial mounds open allowing supernatural beings aos sí or fairies to enter the human world and play tricks.

So if you want to argue samhain was a time of this kind of festival you're wrong if anything samhain came first as a seasonal marker for winter and a time for political gatherings

but it wasn't a night of the dead or a holiday dedicated to a god of death the concepts of praying for deceased ancestors or souling and wearing masks to scare away evil ghosts are actually later medieval and modern developments that were layered onto the season over time.

Free education!🎉


r/DebateACatholic • • 10d ago

Why do you think Paul was saying he could lose salvation? (1 Corinthians 9)

1 Upvotes

There is a commonly used verse in 1 Corinthians 9 that I see used in Catholics circles to the extent of "Paul says he can lose salvation here."

(But I discipline my body and keep it under control, lest after preaching to others I myself should be disqualified.) 1 Corinthians 9:27

I feel this position is dismissed through the context of 1 Corinthians 9.

The chapter starts with him speaking of the seal of his apostleship being the churches he is ministering to.

(If to others I am not an apostle, at least I am to you, for you are the seal of my apostleship in the Lord.) 1 Corinthians 9:2

He then expresses about how him using his apostleship in teaching this church should result in reward.

(If we have sown spiritual things among you, is it too much if we reap material things from you? If others share this rightful claim on you, do not we even more?) 1 Corinthians 9:11-12

But, Paul, does not use this right.

If he were to start using this right and gaining material things, he might be accused of greed or suspicion regarding why he preaches the Gospel. He doesn't want to hinder the Gospel with this possibility.

(Nevertheless, we have not made use of this right, but we endure anything rather than put an obstacle in the way of the gospel of Christ.) 1 Corinthians 9:12

His reward is simply being able to spread the Gospel.

(What then is my reward? That in my preaching I may present the gospel free of charge, so as not to make full use of my right in the gospel.) 1 Corinthians 9:18

He desires to win over all peoples.

(For though I am free from all, I have made myself a servant to all, that I might win more of them.) 1 Corinthians 9:19

Furthermore, he wants to experience and enjoy the fruit, community, and transformative power of the gospel alongside the very people he helps bring to faith.

(I do it all for the sake of the gospel, that I may share with them in its blessings.) 1 Corinthians 9:23

He then explains that he runs to obtain the prize.

(Do you not know that in a race all the runners run, but only one receives the prize? So run that you may obtain it.) 1 Corinthians 9:24

He already explained what this was earlier. Winning over people by preaching the Gospel free of charge. Keeping yourself blameless in the process so your not discredited. You should run in this manner and keep a good report.

And finally (Every athlete exercises self-control in all things. They do it to receive a perishable wreath, but we an imperishable. So I do not run aimlessly; I do not box as one beating the air. But I discipline my body and keep it under control, lest after preaching to others I myself should be disqualified.) 1 Corinthians 9:25-27

This should be interpreted through the context of the entire chapter.

He desires to continue preaching to others and not to be discredited. This is the reward he is fighting to keep. This is why he disciplines his body and keeps it under control.

In summation, Paul desires to continue to preach the Gospel without obstacle. He wants to continue to win people over to Christ (verse 22) and not be disqualified from preaching (verse 15).

This is why (I discipline my body and keep it under control, lest after preaching to others I myself should be disqualified.)

This is not disqualified from salvation or anything like that, but disqualified in the eyes of others concerning his preaching of the Gospel.


r/DebateACatholic • • 12d ago

How to trust God's Providence

2 Upvotes

"Thy will be done"

One of the main issues I contend with and the usual cause of mortal sin is stressing about my circumstances and worrying if God would be there for me.

There are things in history where Catholics/Christians who were faithful went through horror such as the Irish Potato Famine.

A presbytirian told me that the holocaust, transatlantic slavery, colonialism were all part of God's will. How?


r/DebateACatholic • • 12d ago

Si hay tanta evidencia de la evolución porque muchos cristianos la niegan ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateACatholic • • 12d ago

What is a soul ?

1 Upvotes

Why is it that we have a concept of a soul. Theologians say the soul is what gives a corporeal object life. We know that it can also be explained through the lens of modern biology. I know the soul is not a ghost in a machine. But then what it is and how it actually works.

Theologians say that the human soul is a rational soul. It has both intellect and free will. But what is intellect and free will?

I thought intellect is a result of intelligence and IQ and understanding stuff due to Prefrontal Cortex.

Where does the Soul actually fit?

I feel the concept of a soul is proto-biology.


r/DebateACatholic • • 12d ago

Porque debemos adorar a dios ?

2 Upvotes

Mucha gente me ha dicho por agradecimiento del perdón de los pescados y cosas así y también por las cosas que nos permite tener cómo el trabajo , comida , familia etc , pero que gana dios con nuestra adoración ósea dios es dios y puede hacer lo que quiera , porque necesitamos glorificar a un ser superior ? Eos no sería esperar algo a cambio por las provisiones que nos da ? También mucha gente me ha dicho que si no lo adoras no lo complaces y cómo quien decir no y da cosas que quieres ósea a lo que me refiero es que obviamente dios no es que odie por no adorarle , si nos ue tiene cómo más preferencia se podría decir con los que son más devotos , que opinan ?


r/DebateACatholic • • 12d ago

Deuterocanonical Books Anathema

0 Upvotes

According to Council of Trent, If you do not give these books Equal Authority and Divine Origin you are Anathema. Jewish Rabbi's in the time of Jesus understood that the were historical books and were not considered breathed by God. Early Christians also understood this. According to the Council of Trent Shouldn't Jesus be Anathema, or the Council of Trent is wrong


r/DebateACatholic • • 13d ago

Knowing the nature/essence of things

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DebateACatholic • • 13d ago

Why didn't Jesus fullfil all the messianic prophesies?

2 Upvotes

Mainly those about rebuild the temple and world peace. He didn't even fullfil his own about the fact that some of the ppl with him wouldn't see death


r/DebateACatholic • • 14d ago

Reconciling Unam Sanctum with the 21 Coptic Matyrs.

3 Upvotes

Pope Boniface VIII taught in Unam Sanctam that submission to the Pope is necessary for salvation.

But the 21 Coptic Martyrs were not in communion with the Catholic Church. They were killed for refusing to deny Jesus, and Pope Francis recognised them as martyrs and included them in the Roman Martyrology.

How do we reconcile this?

Does this mean someone can be saved outside visible communion with the Catholic Church? And how does this fit with Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus (outside the Church there is no salvation)?

I'd be interested to understand how Catholics explain this.