r/DaystromInstitute • • Apr 30 '24

The emotional instability of the Discovery crew is consistent with their experiences

5 Upvotes

Much has been made of the choices made in the representation of the Discovery crew, especially their portrayal as overly emotional - however, in the context of their actual experiences - it makes sense.

The crew have gone through several Captains in 5 years. Traditionally, Starfleet captains command immense respect and loyalty. They are mentors, confidants, and even role models. Their crew often admires them, feels intimidated by them, and even cherishes personal advice from them.

Now, consider the Discovery's unique situation. They've served under not one, but several captains in a short time. These weren't just any commanders; they included an evil doppelganger from the Mirror Universe and a morally ambiguous version of their original captain. The person that got their original Captain killed, albeit inadvertently, is their current Captain - after being branded a traitor and sentenced to punishment. This certainly has a lasting psychological impact on the crew.

The crew was originally on a "black ops" mission, and thus would have been seperated from regular interactions with other Starfleet crews. They are awe-struck by interaction with Captain Pike. Due to their ever changing leadership and other isolation, they never learned how to mature into the types of officers as seen on TNG, DS9, VOY, or event ENT/TOS.

Then of course, they travelled into the far future, with not only everyone they ever knew being dead, the Federation was apparently destroyed at the time. They should all have PTSD at a minimum.

Here's the twist: despite their emotional displays, sometimes reckless behavior, and a penchant for dramatics, the Discovery crew gets results. They saved a version of the Federation a millennium in the future, and they possess the unparalleled Spore Drive technology that remains unreplicated. They have defeated numerous opponents in the future timeline. This begs the question: why change a (seemingly) winning formula? This unconventional success could reinforce their emotional approach, creating a self-fulfilling cycle.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jul 24 '24

Exemplary Contribution TNG "The Outcast" shows the limits of Star Trek's both/and approach to social issues

0 Upvotes

When we talk about Star Trek's progressive values, "The Outcast" is an episode that often comes up. The episode shows Riker falling in love with Soran, a member of the officially non-gendered society known as the J'naii, who is experiencing supposedly "primitive" feelings of being female. When their affair is found out, Soran is put on trial and delivers a stirring address that uses key phrases and tropes from the rhetoric of gay rights -- she says that she shouldn't be persecuted for the way she was born, for example, and that the "deviant" gendered J'naii express their love in the same way. In the end, Riker is willing to risk his career to save her from what is clearly meant to be a metaphor for gay conversion therapy, but he is too late -- she has been brainwashed and only wants to conform.

On the one hand, this is a clear allegory for gay rights, hence a progressive gesture (although one that was regarded as long overdue even when it aired in 1992). On the other hand, what is literally happening in the episode is that people who experience traditional gender identities are being persecuted by those who want to forcibly eliminate it. This latter aspect was presumably intended to help straight viewers identify with the plight of homosexuals, but it also plays directly into conservative paranoia -- even moreso today, given the hateful conspiracy theories around liberal teachers supposedly "grooming" children to be trans.

And how on earth does the conversion therapy work so quickly?! It has been a matter of hours since the trial and she has already embraced her persecutors and turned away from Riker. This, too, seems to "backfire" into an anti-gay message by implying that "curing" non-normative sexual practices is not only possible but easy -- a false belief that has caused huge amounts of harm and even driven some gay people to suicide.

To me, this episode is emblematic of Star Trek's approach to controversial social issues. Though on the surface it appears very progressive, it is actually deeply incoherent and can very easily be read in a more conservative direction. Once we identify the pattern, it is easy to find more examples -- even among the most famous "breakthroughs."

One of our colleagues recently pointed out, for example, that the famous interracial kiss between Kirk and Uhura is actually super creepy and weird -- they are forced to do it for the entertainment of their captors, and both express fear and regret about doing so. On the one hand, it's the first interracial kiss on TV! On the other hand, it's portrayed as something no one would actually want to do!

We could also think of the episode where Jadzia Dax reconnects with the female lover of a former male host. On the one hand, it's the first same-sex affection on Star Trek. On the other hand, the couple is "really" straight underneath it all -- and the scenario is reminiscent of the kind of "lesbian action" for straight male tittilation that was especially popular in the 90s.

The basic rule here is "Star Trek giveth, and Star Trek taketh away." For every progressive breakthrough, there's a more conservative or even reactionary undercurrent that undermines it. And this makes sense when we realize that Star Trek is not primarily a form of political advocacy, but a commercial entertainment product. Incoherent political statements allow them to offer "something for everyone."

But what do you think? Are there other examples of this both/and approach? Are there major breakthroughs that don't have a "poison pill" aspect?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 03 '22

While Star Trek has always been morality plays in space, current Star Trek suffers from forcing a verdict on the viewer

2 Upvotes

So this was response to some one on a meme thread and a comment suggest I add this here for you all to discuss.

The term "woke" gets thrown around so often its hard to know what it means. Its just become a general catch all for "overly political, to the left" and that's just way to vague. so I'm going to try and explain that what people mean by "woke", in the context of star trek means 3 main things.

  1. An underlying sense of pessimism toward the future

  2. A lack of confidence in its positive messaging

  3. A need to present a clear verdict to the topic of each episode

To start with the obvious: its not that star trek is political now, it always was. It’s that it’s no longer allegorical in its approach, nor is it taking "the view from nowhere" and letting the audience make up their mind. More critically it lost its sense of optimism.

I'm going to use DS9 and Piccard to examine the difference, a very political episode of DS9 is the union one. To sum up, the bar is losing business due to a Bajoran holiday, Rom is sick, and Quark is a bad employer docking wages to make up for loses. Rom gets motivated to start a union and from their it escalates.

Some key moments are

  1. Worf crossed the picket line and doesn't really care about the union or strike. He gets into it with O’Brien, but he's not condemned for it as a mater of plot.

  2. Quark, while being a bad boss still has his struggles as a business owner represented fairly, showing his struggle to adapt to the strike

  3. The Ferengi government getting involved makes things exceedingly difficult for the strikers, reminiscent of early 1900s unions and the troubles they faced.

  4. Quark is violently beaten, and pays the price for Rom’s revolutionary act, showing that those brave enough to act are not always the ones who pay for their actions.

  5. Rom wins the argument, but not the optics. He can get what he wants, but not right away and not publicly as their society isn’t ready for the change Rom wants, even if Quark is willing to change for his brother.

The story is very much about the struggles to form unions, not "are unions good?" The show doesn't really answer with a strong yes or no, Rom doesn't get a full win, he has to compromise. It’s strongly implied, yes unions are for the best, because Rom gets what he wants in the end, but the challenges to forming a union and are also given a fair representation, with out denigrating that side of the argument.

Beyond that, they aren't human. A major appeal of Star Trek, for me and my friend at least, is the idea that we "got over our selfies" we are no longer a slave to the lesser angles of our nature and we, humans as a species, evolved and are more cooperative and better 400 years later. The Ferengi are an invented species with a hyper capitalist nature created to discuses issues of economic struggle, in contrast to the much more “morally advanced” federation, with out pointing fingers or naming names. its an allegorical vehicle for story.

Now compare that to Piccard season 1 or 2

TNG episode "a measure of a man" IMO is one of the best episodes, to quickly sum up its a trial held to determine if Data is a real boy or a PlayStation. Can he be taken apart at the whims of an engineer or does he need to consent? TNG decided that if Data were a PlayStation that would be akin to creating a slave race, and the humans of TNG knew better, and that creating such a legal fiction would be wrong.

The humans of Piccard, forget this existed and have gone full steam ahead with androids as a salve race. Not only that, they turned they backs on the Romulans in a time of need and have perpetuated ghettos across the galaxy. The Federation tried to make peace with the Klingons, the Cardasians and even the Dominions, but the Romulans enter a time of need and the federation becomes racist? Piccard spent time on Romulus with Spock trying to reunify their two people, this was supported by the federation.

This destroys the idea that "we got over ourselves as a species." We clearly didn't if Piccard has anything to say, we are brutal, savage, discriminatory people and always will be. I just hate that message, and dont enjoy it.

"Woke" means a lot more than "political motivated" its a way of thinking that presumes the conclusion in the question. It’s less about teaching people how to think for themselves, and more about teaching them how to think correctly.

The example of the union episode in DS9, it didn't concretely say unions are great, every business needs a union. It discussed the difficulties of crating one on behalf of the strikers and the struggles of working with one as a business owner. It didn't make one side a cartoon villain with no redeeming qualities and the other poor oppressed do-gooders. It tried to tell both sides fairly, and it did so in a way that maintained the optimistic future Star trek promotes. If you came away from that episode thinking "hey unions seem like a rather promising idea" its fair to say the show would be happy, but if you came away with "man unions just dont seem worth the effort" the show isn’t scolding you for having the wrong opinion.

Compare that with the depiction of ICE in Piccard season 2, its painfully clear the creators of the show detest ICE and want people to feel the same way. there is no redeeming quality in any of the ICE agents.

to sum up

  1. Old Trek maintained an optimistic future where humanity got over its lesser nature, new trek very much sees the problems of the present in the future.

  2. old trek used allegory and a "view from nowhere" to try and present the struggles of progress, giving the devil his fair due

  3. Old trek was happy letting its viewers come to their own conclusions regarding the episodes message, new trek is very much advocating one position at the cost of another.

If you disagree I am happy to discuss. I really love the 90s Trek, but dont really like the new stuff IMO the Orville does a better job at star trek then modern Trek.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Oct 20 '23

BDSM and Federation Culture

0 Upvotes

So, I'm active in the BDSM lifestyle. Many, many human beings are. We find it a deeply satisfying, enriching, and healthy lifestyle when performed safely and with constant, enthusiastic consent among all involved.

As racy a topic as it is, sexuality is a part of being human. A big part. And for some of us, BDSM is an integral part of our lives. I don't see that changing in a utopic future. In fact, I'd think the number of people engaging in the lifestyle would increase, when societal pressures and misconceptions fall away.

For obvious reasons, the shows never touched this topic, and I feel they're right to do so, for such a mainstream exposure. However, i cannot see even Star Trek's version of humanity not having BDSM as part of it. What are your thoughts?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Oct 16 '20

I see no evidence of socialism in the Federation; just that they have more resources and there's no real poverty

2 Upvotes

TLDR; Star Trek/the Federation is not communist. They're capitalist with a heart. Cuddly capitalist. Like Norway. If Norway had replicators. And spaceships.


A common misconception is that the Federation is socialist or communist. I honestly don't really see any evidence of that. In fact, everything I see contradicts that. Granted, there doesn't seem to be hoarding of wealth either and there's no space expansive megacorporations.

Private property and private businesses exist in Star Trek. Picard's family owns a vineyard, Sisko's father owns a restaurant, Quark runs his own business with the holodecks (he's Ferengi, but his business isn't in Ferengi space - if the Federation were truly communist, they wouldn't tolerate this). In newer Star Trek series, we have the pilot in Picard who demands payment, and Picard is very understanding of those arrangement. Riker and Troi seem to own quite a bit of land, which is more than "each according to their need".

Communism would mean the state runs everything; I see no evidence of this in the Federation other than stuff provided by Starfleet, which is pretty normal for military vessels. Socialism would mean the group decides and I don't see evidence of this either since everyone is free to do what they want or run businesses as they please.

Picard says in First Contact that the acquisition of wealth is no longer a driving force, and it is the betterment of humanity that motivates people. This may sound like communism, but from everything we actually see, it's not. It would be communism if this were actually enforced; that everything HAD to be for the betterment of the whole. From the evidence we see, most people simply choose to work for the betterment of the whole. People moved past the hoarding of wealth. Likely because replicators made that pointless. I can't really imagine any point in hoarding wealth and possessions in a world where replicators exist.

He also says there's no money in this same scene, but this is objectively false and flat out contradicted numerous times in the series. The only explanation I can think of is context; in this scene, the girl is asking how much the Enterprise cost them. The Enterprise is a government ship, and so Picard was giving a brief overview of how the economics work on the government level and how Starfleet thinks of as funding the construction of the Enterprise. Money changes hands in private businesses, but the Federation doesn't seem concerned with the acquisition of resources and funds. Also, Picard obviously wasn't about to give a full 23rd economics lesson right there on the spot, so he broke it down in easy to explain terms as best as someone from that period would understand.

Back to hoarding wealth; I'm not sure how one would do it even if they wanted to. The economy is mostly service based, which would allow small private businesses to run pretty good, but not so much for bigger corporations. Family restaurants like Sisko's have a social interaction aspect to them. Corporation fast food doesn't really have that. Corporation fast food just gives me decent food in a timely matter, which one can get just as easily from a replicator. Pretty much all retail businesses are trashed in a world with replicators. Entertainment and real estate might just be the only way. However, these may not work either. Celebrities may be few and far between because with no poverty and need to work, amateur artists are free to explore their passions so the market is pretty saturated. Wannabe real estate tycoons also have their work cut out for them, since you're not really limited to where you can live. Not only are there transporters that negate the need for convenient places to live, but there's literally all of space you can go move to. Hospitals could if they wanted to, but the American model of healthcare wouldn't work in a world where medical science is so advanced that all but the most serious of injuries and illnesses are pretty trivial, with most requiring no more than a shiny light.

And that brings me to my last point. If it's not communist, then what is it? Given my last paragraph, I'd have to say it's a capitalist utopia. The technology available has negated the bad parts of capitalism, mostly replicators. There's no sweatshops and third world slaves be cause replicators exist. Nobody is starving, because again, replicators. Businesses are all in perfect competition with each other, which prevents any one business from getting too powerful or unethical. For example, nobody is able to extort money for medical services because medical services are so abundant that if Doctor A is trying to price gouge, the patient can just go to Doctor B who isn't an asshole. Restaurants aren't allowed to get so big that they become impersonal, because then they lose their purpose and people would just replicate their food and stay home. Real estate people have a lot less leverage for reasons I already said. People aren't treated bad by their boss because, as with no threat of starvation, they can just up and leave.

The only thing that one can argue is communist is perhaps energy. Energy that makes the replicators work and is really the only thing that makes this capitalist society a utopia instead of a cyberpunk shithole. But having one thing be a social program doesn't mean their economy is communist. If we had UBI on top of the current American system, America wouldn't then suddenly be a communist country. We'd still be capitalist, we'd just have UBI on top of that.

Just because nobody is starving and there's no poverty doesn't mean it's not capitalism.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Apr 07 '25

The season 3 episode of enterprise "damage" should have never been produced. It is antithetical to what starfleet and star trek is all about and the suggests it was an acceptable evil.

0 Upvotes

I'm this episode Archer decides to turn the enterprise into a pirate ship and steal the warp coil from a friendly alien ship because they refused to trade it to them.

The aliens refused the trade because it would leave them 3 years from their home and they didn't have enough supplies for the return trip.

Without the coil it will take several weeks to get their warpndrive online and they have a meeting in 3 days with the engineer of the xindi weapon. Archer has no idea what this meeting will be about. To clarify, it's not an action that will directly destroy the xindi weapon or anything.

Before and after Archer pirate raids the friendly aliens, his crew is like "wow are we really going to do this?" Followed by, "you did what you had to, I would have done the same thing". Archer justifies it by leaving them with trillium D (because it is worthless to them because it will make tpol go crazy, though she is secretly using it as a drug) and a little bit of food.

There are no greater consequences for this disgusting action after tbr brief bit of guilt displayed in episode. Star trek is FILLED with stories of star fleet captains taking the high road in the face of dire conflicts. Janeway does it several times a season. When voyager was stranded in the void, she rejected her former ally and the only piece of technology to get them out of there because the guy stole it (and killed the owners).

This makes Archer and the enterprise crew no better than ransom and the equinox and we were supposed to be disgusted by their deviation from starfleet values. They had the same "it was our only choice" attitude but after realizing they were wrong they had to pay for it with their lives and their ship.

Archers decision taints everything that comes after it including the founding of the federation.

This episode upsets me both in universe and out of universe I wish it had not been written and produced.

I think a good fix to this is to have a storyline in a future storyline in a star trek series (voyager legacy series anyone?) Where the logs and all information on that enterprise episode are kept highly classified and a heroic captain discovers the information and wrestles with what that means for all of the starfleet values that they (and we) wrongly believed were immutable from the beginning. That story ends with that info being disseminated to everyone and Archer loses any reverence he has with the future generations and his legacy is forever tainted while the future acknowledges they can still hold their values despite his horrible actions.

Thank you for reading


r/DaystromInstitute • • Nov 25 '22

Misleading Title, See Edit Star Trek is magical fantasy OR all the sentient races are the same species: pick one

0 Upvotes

Obviously, it's not fantasy*, so that leaves but one conclusion: they ARE all the same species.

The first thing to establish here is: what is a species?

Now, according to Earth science and taxonomy.... ... we don't know. We have trouble defining it, which is the root of the problem I'm bringing up. BUT most importantly, a species branches off when certain things occur, and is considered to be its own distinct species once it no longer produces viable offspring with the parent population under standard circumstances. This is why Darwin's finches on separate islands, despite probably still being able to fertilize each other's eggs into viable offspring, were considered to have speciated into different courses: they could not have that natural interaction without some form of intervention that exposed them to one another. (Isolation is the biggest cause of GENETIC speciation, wherein offspring simply cannot occur [e.g., cat and dog] due to an incompatible number of chromosomes, or sterile offspring due to incompatible genetics. We'll come back to 'isolation causes genetic distance' later.)

For example, the grizzy and polar bear species on Earth! These have been traditionally acknowledged as two different species with distinct phenotypes. If we stuck two of them in a zoo, they might reproduce - and that offspring would have a functional genotype and often not be sterile at all! But that didn't really matter, because in their natural habitat, they would never cross territories long enough for this to happen on its own, so it doesn't matter what the offspring aren't sterile because there's no natural environment that allows polars and grizzlies to interbreed. Or, well, there wasn't.

Changes in global climate have resulted in alteration of grizzly AND polar territory in the northernmost expanses of the Western hemisphere. For the first time ever, polar bears and grizzly bears are naturally crossing each others' paths in the wild.... and they are definitely fucking when they do it. SO NOW THERE ARE WILD GROLAR BEARS! What a delight! Only that leaves us with a problem, a problem that lies in how we define a species: according to that definition, they're not a different species anymore. They may never have been distinct.

So what does this have to do with Star Trek? Well, all of the sentient species can interbreed and produce viable offspring with no notable genetic defects or flaws. I know there is a canon background explanation from one of the films that says humans were a seed race and all these other species are actually descended from us; that would explain a lot, except for the millions of years of separation and genetic drift since. Isolation is the biggest cause of genetic drift that results in speciation. Over the last million years, we branched into several hominids that are genetically distinct from us (but again, since there's Neandertal DNA mixed in with ours, it's obvious there was interbreeding and viable offspring, so again: we were never actually a separate species). What's the timeline on all those other planets getting their humans who then evolved into the local sentients, anyone got it memorized?

But all of this leaves us with a problem. Scientifically, if you can boink a Vulcan and get a half-Vulcan child, one who could later marry a Klingon and have quarter-human babies with THEM.... we are all the same species, to this day, isolation and genetic drift since notwithstanding. The visual differences - pointy ears, lobster ridges, Trill spots - are just phenotypic differences, the same way that humans who live really far north lost melanin so they can absorb more vitamin d from oblique-angle sunlight.

Therefore, once humans and other species are returned to circumstances where their paths cross "naturally" and they have the opportunity to attempt to produce offspring, we should be acknowledged to be the same species again.

Details that would be useful to either counter or affirm this:

Are there any species in Star Trek that are canonically NOT interbreedable with humans for reasons other than mass sterility/non-sexual reproduction (the Borg/Jem'Hadar)?

Are there any who ARE interbreedable with humans but who are distinctly excluded from that 'seed' group (Changelings? Founders?) and if so, what's the explanation? Do we just see them in relationships or have actual confirmation of non-sterile offspring?

Are there species groups who are interbreedable with each other but not with humans? Did -they- have a seed event? Why can Cardassians and Bajorans produce viable offspring with each other? Were they also started from pre-humans?

I know that the main reason all these species can interbreed is because it's more fun for storytelling, full stop. But it does hearken more to Lord of the Rings style fantasy where everyone can mate with other species, and produce viable offspring, than any real-world scientific explanation.

Therefore, my ultimate conclusion is either that yes, the canon "all sophonts started from the same group" MUST be true on a universal and fundamental level, more than they ever fleshed it out; OR Star Trek is in fact magical fantasy and it doesn't matter if there's different species making all these various cross-species people who grow up and have kids of their own.

More information and details about the seed event would be useful. Further examples of anything that can interbreed with humans in ST would be appreciated.

hoping to focus the discussion on the plausibility of the explanation provided in "The Chase" without dragging Star Trek's genre classification into the discussion—it's not the discussion even trying to have. I apologize for the title that is misleading.

    • There is nothing wrong with fantasy. It is not inferior to sci-fi for any reason.


r/DaystromInstitute • • May 06 '20

YET ANOTHER TUVIX THREAD Just watched Tuvix and Janeway definitely committed murder

6 Upvotes

Tuvix was a unique lifeform, akin to a child of Neelix and Tuvok. He had attributes of both, but combined them in a way that made him unique from both of them. Thus, he was ultimately a unique individual. That's all the reason you should need to not kill him. I am disappointed in Janeway for obviously breaking Starfleet code and basic laws of the Federation.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 24 '22

Warrior is a Gender in Klingon Society

83 Upvotes

The main thesis of this post will be that the Klingon Gender System is composed not of a binaristic gender model, but a poly-modal model consisting of sex adjacent genders including (but not necessarily limited to);

(presented in order of commality of appearance on ST)

  • Warrior

  • Woman

  • Healer

  • Education

  • Scientific

It is further noted that these are often labelled 'castes' or 'classes' but that that should be considered a mistranslation - or a recognition that the gender/class system in Klingons is merged.

Evidence and argument:

The main point of evidence that this rests on is the line said by Worf in TNG S2E19 "Manhunt", where in response to Luwaxana Troi's advances he says "I am not a man".

This is unusual in Startrek as men and women are regularly reffered to both human and non-human males and females. Its worth noting that Startrek was created at a time when oppositional sexism (aka the belief that males and females are opposites, all males are men and heterosexual and any deviation from this is unnatural) and this definitely affected startrek - the number of species with anything other than a binary sex/gender distinction is almost ubiquitous unless the episode makes a onetime exception to make a point. So to have a character not identify as a man is at least somewhat notable. Perhaps whats being alluded to is that Worf is not a human man, but as mentioned before - Startrek normally doesn't hesitate to call other races men or women.

And upon doing a speed replay of all Startrek episodes I do not remember "Klingon m(a/e)n" being said much at all, whereas the mention of "Klingon wom(a/e)n" is common. However "Klingon Male" and "Klingon Female" is, especially irt to mating rituals, which suggests they have the concept of binary biological sex.

In addition to this (and the most striking piece of evidence of all) is that while women have somewhat discreet gender roles, 'men' do not, but warriors do.

But what is a gender? The word gender has the same root as genre, and comes into English modern use via linguistics. It's use to be synonymous with 'sex' is because of its meaning as 'category' or 'grouping' - in linguistics this grouping is to do with how words are grouped together because of their connection analogy to masculinity or feminity, which are the primary groups/genders for European languages which were the main focus of early modern linguistic academia.

But the association with male/masculine and female/feminine is a happenstantial one, even with people. A society need not use that same distinction and while most human societies have used that (as human sexual dimorphism and division of labour is about medium), many societies have also had more genders too. Theres plenty of a rabbit hole if yiu widh to look up 'third genders', and even a mapped distribution but I'm not sure if I can remember the website.

SO to bring this to Klingon. Warrior is the primary identifier used by Klingon Males. It is reinforced by numerous rituals and is prescribes many aspects of life, in ways where you'd normally expect allusions to gender. Think about it, you could replace almost any instance of 'warrior' with 'man' and it would make sense, albeit a very toxic masculinity version of what it means to be a man.

THIS suggests that female warriors are not women - which seems to be true. The females we see on starships often dress and act more like warrors than they do (say) the Duras sisters or Grilka. They are still agressive but they very much do not live and die by their aggression and honour like warriors do.

Likewise in ENT with the lawyer who was not a warrior, there was a clear difference in a lot of how they acted and such. Plus the capture of the system by the warriors seems a bit like patriarchy. This suggests, if these wre genders, that trans Klingons are common... though contentious.

Plus the warrior (gender) is justified in much the same way man/woman is, calling back to biological tendancies of Klingons for justifications as to why it exists.

EDIT: It should be noted that a LOT of these things are seen in caste systems IRL. However I would argue that perhaps that shows the caste and gender system are one in the same within Klingon society.

I'm going to end off by admitting that this is not a foolproof theory. I think there are holes in it. One avenue of evidence I'd like to explore is if the linguistics of thlIngan Hol agree or disagree with the theory, but I don't have enough understanding of the language to do so. I may ask on the discord. Both supporting and dissenting evidence is invited!! :)


r/DaystromInstitute • • Oct 13 '25

Enterprise: Damage - why not just hitch a ride?

2 Upvotes

So this episode bothers me and I've read previous threads about the moral problem and quandaries concerning it, but that's not quite what bothers me.

In other ST shows describing similar situations I've seen both sides and it's a trivial matter to understand that sometimes morality will tug in two different directions.

It's been said that this season (3) was made in the aftermath of 9/11 and describes the feelings of USians at the time.

To me it describes something much darker - the penchant for Americans (and people in general) so seek violent revenge even when alternatives are available (e.g. invading Iraq and killing 1 million Iraqis for literally no reason at all).

Which brings me to my point: the whole "I had no choice" premise of this episode falls flat when they could have just made a deal with the friendly aliens to hitch a ride to the rendezvous with Degra!

Gotten help from the Xindi and then gone back to Enterprise and installed a new warp coil or whatever.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Nov 25 '23

TNG "The Survivors" is the kind of episode people have in mind when they say Star Trek has a colonialist mindset

0 Upvotes

"The Survivors" is a very frequently discussed episode, mainly because of the figure of Kevin Uxbridge. As is well known, Uxbridge is a near-omnipotent alien who falls in love with a human woman and puts aside his powers to be with her. In their old age, they move to a remote colony to live out their retirement, and the settlement is attacked by a species known as the Husnak. Uxbridge refuses to use his powers to kill, leading to the total annihilation of the colony. In his rage and grief, he radically reverses course and exterminates the entire Husnak species. When the Enterprise crew finds him, he is living in a simulated idyll with a mental projection of his late wife. Captain Picard gradually unravels the mystery and leaves Uxbridge alone on the colony, saying they have no law for the kind of crime he has committed.

My first thought is that they do have laws related to genocide, which he is very straightforwardly guilty of. It may be that Picard is attempting to disentagle himself from a dangerous situation and therefore saying anything he can to make sure Uxbridge doesn't feel threatened by the Federation. The same would go for his praise of Uxbridge as a creature with a profound moral conscience. That would be my preferred interpretation, but it doesn't seem like the writers' original intent, nor Stewart's as an actor. The whole thing is presented completely sincerely as far as I can see.

So we have a situation where someone has settled on a remote world, which is attacked by a species described as "savage." The Husnak's motives or reasoning are not discussed or explored. Was the planet their territory? Did they view the human colony as dangerous invaders? Was there any way they could view themselves as in the right? No one cares -- not Uxbridge, certainly, but also not Picard or anyone on the Enterprise crew. The people who destroyed on small colony are irredeemable savages, while someone who has committed genocide against a space-faring species (hence against a population that may be in the billions) has a rich and fascinating interiority. The Husnak are fully defined by their violence, while Uxbridge's act of almost unimaginable violence is an unfortunate deviation from his otherwise profound moral code. Picard, our ultimate moral arbiter, even appears to admire him.

The only mindset that would allow this kind of one-sided moral assessment, so at odds with the facts, is that of settler colonialism -- which glorifies those who take the land and resources of others, demonizes those who resist, and even paint the original aggressors as helpless victims. In the end, the violence committed by the settler is always a sad necessity, while the violence of the "savage" always highlights the settler's moral superiority.

As a mystery episode, this one is okay. And it is certainly one of the more memorable concepts. I enjoyed watching it, and presumably I will enjoy watching it again the next time I loop back around to it in my perpetual rewatch of Star Trek. But it is profoundly, disturbingly morally bankrupt.

ADDED: I understand why most people don't like this, because we want to think of TNG as the optimistic utopian Star Trek show. But imagine this exact same plot were translated to Discovery, with Burnham instead of Picard figuring out the mystery and interacting with Uxbridge in this way. I'm pretty sure fans would be outraged and see it as evidence that Discovery was betraying the ideals of Star Trek yet again.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 11 '20

The humor in Lower Decks causes it to unfaithfully represent the idea Star Trek because of the childish behavior of the officers.

0 Upvotes

The title pretty much says it all. 24th-century Starfleet officers are not supposed to behave like an 8th-graders. A Starfleet starship is not supposed to resemble an elementary schoolyard during recess. This is not how officers behave and ships are run. You can say that these are lowly officers (Even the senior officers act like children) and that the Cerritos is not the flagship, but we have seen how other ships and other ensigns function in other ST shows, and it's not like this. I believe its wrong to demean Star Trek like this so it can appeal to a younger audience; I liked ST for what it was when I was young.

I'm interested in hearing others' thoughts on this.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Apr 25 '19

Discovery irredeemably tarnished the image of the Federation

5 Upvotes

In the first season of Discovery, the Federation plants a planet destroying bomb in a volcano on Kronos. Some complained at this, but surely it pales in comparison to what came next.

In the second Season, the Federation backs and staffs a clandestine organization that creates a weapon that almost destroys all sentient life in the galaxy, and in at least one timeline destroys all sapient life. This is galactic scale genocide. Far from a utopian thing to aspire to, the The Federation is now responsible for one of the biggest blunders in Trek. And pretty soon they'll goof on such a scale once again (Vger).


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jan 26 '18

If Georgiou is lying about Lorca’s grooming, I’m gonna be pissed

0 Upvotes

Content warning: rape and sexual assault

Although I had previously liked the character of Captain Lorca, even while harboring suspicions he was from the MU, I now hope that he is in fact the sexual predator he has been made out to be.

I have a close male friend who was raped by a woman some years ago. I also have another friend who struggles with PTSD resulting from sexual harassment and stalking. Earlier in the season, we saw Ash Tyler apparently grappling with PTSD that triggered flashbacks to his rape. We were invited to watch Tyler come to terms with his victimhood and try to come out stronger for it. It would’ve made for a compelling story arc, especially for a man, considering that male victims of female rape are largely invisible in media (and yes, of course, rarer than the reverse). But we never got resolution to this plot since (it is a plausible reading that) it turns out Tyler was actually just misremembering his consensual sexual encounter with L’Rell. In other words, the supposed rape victim was just “misremembering.”

I hate this message. We should be believing victims of rape; the vast, vast majority of rape allegations are true. Yes, this is sci-fi; it’s not a “realistic” scenario. But Star Trek had the opportunity to tackle an actual serious issue and they dodged it, and in doing so, they promoted a harmful and false stereotype about rape victims misremembering/fabricating their assault.

Now we are told that Lorca “groomed” Michael — that he was pursuing an illicit sexual relation with her. That language, “groomed”, in particular, is just inescapably reminiscent of real life stories like that of Larry Nassar, who for decades groomed and abused hundreds of under-aged girls. Girls who trusted him and his position of authority over them. Or Harvey Weinstein, who groomed and exerted his power over young women in Hollywood. The real world is in the midst of a revolution against sexual assault, and Star Trek has usually handled contemporary issues well (e.g., civil rights, religious tolerance, the Cold War, eventually homosexuality, etc). If this accusation that Lorca was grooming Michael turns out to be false, it’s going to piss me the hell off. That is not the message that progressive shows like Star Trek should be sending.

What do you think? Did the Tyler/Voq reveal bother you? What will it mean if Lorca is actually not a sexual monster and is, at worst, just a normal baddie?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Apr 23 '23

Why did DS9 work while Discovery and Picard seasons 1-2 didn’t?

3 Upvotes

Arguably out of all of the Star Trek shows since 2016, the one most like DS9 is Discovery season 1 in that it wasn’t afraid to take risks about how it made Star Trek (eg. Focusing on MB instead of a captain and bridge crew while DS9 focused on a Starbase commander instead of a starship captain, going much darker than previous franchise installments, and being more serialized than previous series). A similar argument can be made to a lesser degree about Discovery and Picard S2, and to a much lesser extent Discovery S3. So while DS9 took risks and was applauded for doing so, what did the newer shows do that made them be received much more poorly by comparison?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 16 '20

Star Trek Discovery & Picard aren't inherently bad. They've done what was needed to continue: Adapt, for better or worse, to newer plots, storylines, & more in place of the older methods & styles.

13 Upvotes

Each Star Trek show & motion picture is a relic (for a lack of a better word) of the time they were made in. A future imagined by them using their past. When TOS was made, space was the frontier to expand towards while computers seemed like nothing more than the next passing thing. Enter Discovery, made 50 years later, and the roles have nearly been reversed with IT growing exponentially & space, relatively, becoming a much slower avenue. So did everyone's worldview, preference, knowledge, and more change in similar fashions.

And so did the shows' 'style' change based on the times they were made in. The further away you're from the show's time, the more different &, in some cases, the more alien it becomes. Watching TOS for the first time not so long ago for me was a pain, especially the first few episodes. In the end I liked it, not because of how it was made, but because it showed how 1960s saw their future, their aspirations, and how they used to be. But the only reason ST continues on now is because it changed. TNG changed, DS9 changed, VOY changed, ENT changed and so did DIS & PIC.

[Old Trek means ST before & including Enterprise; New Trek means Discovery & beyond]

The Style

Star trek, originally, was a show of curiosity. Mysteries, discoveries, inventions, cultures, phenomena and more waiting to be stumbled upon in the vast expanses of space. What mattered most was what was in space. The romances, the jokes, the relations, the arguments, and the weirdness certainly were an integral part of every episode, but remove the space setting and you would've never had a successful show. That isn't the case anymore. Space isn't so mysterious anymore but it isn't so welcoming either. Decades of looking out to the sky to find out that there wasn't much out there. And the fervour of the space race was never carried forward to the 21st Century. Space on its own is no longer interesting (unless you've Interstellar level of ideas), but instead what happens in space, how we react to it, how we survive in it, etc are the one that matters (See Expanse, Another Life, Origin, The First, etc.). And of course, comedic shows based in space (Space force, Orville, LD, etc.) are successful. Basically, even though all space shows are space operas, (old) ST was more a show about space whereas (new) ST was a show about us in space.

Lengths of Storylines

And the length of each story has changed too. Having a season-long storyline before 2000s was considered bad/stupid/not preferred because it discouraged people from getting in later. If you're lucky, the show was replayed or you got your hands on a VHS. But more likely than not you still would've preferred to pay less for more, so the demographic who bought the entire series would be a small percent of those watching the series on TV. Basically TOS, TNG, VOY, LD. Even DS9 & ENT had mostly made episodes with a definite ending. Enter streaming services (or just the internet). You could archive older videos (and add ads if you're money hungry) allowing anyone to join the series at any time. This comes with the added bonus that if the show's premiering, you've basically addicted the audience till the end of the season (or if you're particularly evil, the end of the show). Mainly DIS, PIC, and last episodes of DS9 (& Xindi Arc) come under this.

The Differentiating Factor

And addressing the (tabooic) social issues of the time was a major point in all Star Trek, if not the differentiating factor from other scifi shows. The 'Golden Age' shows & TOS addressed highly controversial but important social issues (which were mainly person-based) of that time (Kirk's 'womanizing' was meant to take the censors' attention from the more controversial aspects of TOS) and even had dedicated episodes for a single issue (usually using some alien problem similar to what we have/had). The problems now aren't on the scale of the person but on the scale of the people, such as Climate Change, Poverty, Obesity. These are easy enough to emulate, but not so easy in the universe of ST in which these are supposed to have been eradicated. Not for the lack of trying though with Hugh & Stamets in Discovery and Machine Rights in Picard.

The Inexcusable Flaws (mainly DIS)

  • The continuity craziness. The problem isn't Technologies such as holograms (The holograms in TNG are Tactile, the ones in DIS aren't, which is a major difference) as an scifi show with modern audiences will prefer something similar to our Technology; nor is it the Klingons (as every show has a problem with it, TNG-Mixed to the side of Dishonorable, DS9- Mostly Honorable, TOS- Villains, ENT- Everything with a side to the anitvillainous, etc); but plain old (in universe) history, with the sheer impossibility that none of this was ever mentioned and that there were no repercussions from the war.

  • The Characters (& their development) in the first season. This could especially be seen with how shallow Burnahm was originally. Not much of a flaw since Season 2.

  • Not sure if this is a flaw or not, but almost all sci-fi shows nowadays have their plot based on cataclysmic (or galaxy ending) event, with every episode playing some part in advancing towards it. Nothing is thought of the little things, the things that give the show life. (Old) Trek had episodes specifically made for comedic relief, other storylines, character development, etc. You had Fair Haven, Tribbles, Q-pisodes, Vic Fontaine, Shore leave, Carbon Creek and more, adding in air of reality & relatability. These no longer exist in New Trek (other than specific shows such as LD), which, I think, is one big mistake in the part of New ST.

The case of Lower Decks

And then there is Lower Decks. I haven't seen it yet (damn you CBS for allowing it only in US), so take my opinion with a grain of salt. From what I've seen, most trekkers (who thought animated ST won't be that good) feel that it's the show that resembles the most to conventional Star trek. But it's the most unconventional of ST too. They have tried to combine the styles of today with animation with humor with (old) Trek, coming close but not enough (as many newer audiences don't like LD). And even though it partially succeeded in being a sort of 'bridge in b/w', it is still not that successful as it wasn't as appealing to the common viewer. So it alone (or others like it) won't be enough to carry (old) ST forward.

The Rating Disparity-

Then there are the actual ratings. Most (but not all) old Trekkies feel that DIS and PIC while good in some aspects, are mediocre at best (compared to old ST) and that only LD is good. While the argument for this side has many good points, it won't much of a difference to the average viewer, with most day-to-day viewers (as well as some modern critics) giving generally good reviews (80% +) for PIC & DIS compared to the mediocre reviews for LD (50% +).

Conclusion

All this basically shows Star Trek can't survive now with the same formula of previous ST shows. And if nearly destroying the ST feel by making DIS & PIC more like a 21st century space-fi lets Star Trek continue, maybe it's not too bad of a trade. After all ENT was considered bad when it was released but has now almost reached the level of TNG. And almost every Gen Z will have a hard time getting interested in TOS at first. So who knows how it will be perceived a few years from now.

Ultimately change is inevitable. You can either be with it (& at least change into the uncertain) or be against it (& be forgotten). Maybe you've managed to come close to both like Lower Decks, but in the end the old way of ST just isn't viable anymore.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Aug 20 '21

Why does Starfleet use the metric system?

0 Upvotes

Considering it's an American show, and Starfleet used imperial measurements in TOS, why did Starfleet switch to metric--and when?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 30 '15

Theory Benjamin Sisko was a Section 31 operative.

0 Upvotes

I was told in /r/FanTheories that this post would be more fitting here. I've expanded upon it slightly from the original:

One thing that always bothered me about Deep Space Nine's Dominion War was that if Starfleet had a rogue intelligence service that was willing to do anything to win the war up to and including genocide, why weren't they the ones to bring the Romulans into the war? Were they really unable to think of a plan when the whole of the Federation was at stake? No, Section 31 had a plan and Sisko was their man to make it happen. Given what we know about Section 31, it can seem at odds that Sisko would join them, but I think there's a solid case to be made.

Joining Section 31

Sisko wasn't always a member of Section 31. When he first arrives on the station he's just a normal Starfleet commander. 31 probably didn't even have an interest in DS9 until the wormhole opened up. It's at that point that the organization begins to seriously look for agents on the station. Bashir isn't on their radar yet, his secret is still safe. Meanwhile, there's been a lot of political instability not just in the region, but within the Federation. The Maquis threaten to get the Federation involved in a new war with the Cardassians or worse, precipitate a civil war. Sisko has seen people he's trusted, people he's known for years, betray him and the Federation. He becomes increasingly belligerent and ruthless with dealing with the threats to the Federation, and Section 31 takes notice. If I had to state a specific moment in the series, I would say that after the events of For the Uniform would be when 31 recruited Sisko. He's a practical, pragmatic type of guy who is willing to put the good of the Federation over anything else, so he recognizes the need for Section 31 in these difficult and dangerous times. Fast forward to everyone's favorite episode...

In the Pale Moonlight

What we see in In the Pale Moonlight isn't the whole story. What we're witnessing in Sisko's monologue and log entry isn't the confession of someone conflicted between doing what's right and what's necessary. It's theater. The actual events that bring the Romulans into the war are mostly the same as described in the show, but everything that happened was planned from the beginning. Section 31, Sisko, and Garek had no illusions about what was going to happen. The forger and the Senator were both going to die. The forger so he couldn't tell anyone what really happened, and the Senator in the explosion that damaged the forged rod and made it look authentic (that part needed to happen in order to add more authenticity to the idea of a 'Dominion Plot'). So then why the obfuscation in Sisko's personal log? Section 31 was confident that the forged data would be convincing enough to get the Romulans into the war, but couldn't guarantee that it would forever remain a secret. There could be some new forensic technique that would mark the data as forged, thus in that eventuality 31 could leak the """deleted""" logs from Sisko, in which he confesses to being the singular originator of the plan. The Federation would be politically blameless.

Sisko and Sloan

Section 31 can never have too many talented operatives, and so they attempt to recruit Julian Bashir. They can't use Sisko for this operation in the event that Bashir rejects them, and so Sloan is brought in to be the Doctor's handler. Julian rejects 31 and their methods, but Sisko is there in the background able to push Bashir in just the right direction to get him to unwittingly cooperate. It was Sisko that claimed that Starfleet didn't know about 31, it was Sisko who ordered Bashir to work with 31 in order to 'infiltrate' it, and finally, when Section 31 did cross the line, Sisko used Bashir to eliminate Sloan, both to stop the genocide plot and because Sloan was the only 31 operative known to his crew. With him gone Section 31 would just be a rumor.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Feb 18 '24

If Picard wanted earth and the federation to be ready for the borg/threats in the future shouldn't they have stayed behind to change the past in 2063?

2 Upvotes

We see in star trek that outside of the alpha/beta quadrants there are some very evil and powerful groups out there like the dominion and the borg that would want nothing more than total conquest of the entire galaxy. The dominion and the borg came very close to defeating the federation on several occassions.

why the borg and dominion are such great threats.

The dominion native to the gamma quadrant when they engaged the alpha/beta quadrants in a war sent out only an expeditionary force with bulk of their forces still in the gamma quadrant. In conjunction with the cardassians/breen while using local materials were able to sustain full scale warfare with the combined might of the romulans/federation/klingons for 2 straight years. if the prophets didn't interfere with the wormhole the dominion sending 2500 ships to the alpha quadrant would've spelt the end of the allies. The dominion have shown they were able to crank out ships faster than the allies also grow soldiers at a much faster rate than the allies could train replacements.

The Borg native to the delta quadrant went from having a handful of systems under their control in the 1400s to being in control of at least half the quadrant by the 2370s. The first time the enterprise-D encountered the borg cube in system J25 (7000 LY from federation space) the cube manhandled the best ship the federation had in 2365. The borg cube destroyed 40 starships at wolf 359 without suffering any damage. The Borg cube plowed through the federation fleet in sector 001 in first contact even though they destroyed the cube but only with picards insider knowledge. If Picard wasn't there the cube would've destroyed the fleet and assimilated earth.

Let's not forget in 2152 when the surviving drones of the sphere wreckage in antartica were able to comandeer the science transoprt using their technology was able to upgrade that transport to the point where it posed a legitimate threat to the NX-01, which was the most advanced starship starfleet fielded at the time.

As I see it the federation are totally not ready for any major power adversary on this calibur. at least not the present timeline federation.

with all the dangers facing the fedeation/allies in the future, when picard and the enterprise-E crew went back in time to 2063 earth... shouldn't they have stayed behind to help earth advance even further with their technology/knowledge? Temporal prime directive in this case should be ignored as the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

What do you think ?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Nov 04 '13

Meta Attention all crew: No downvoting at Daystrom!

30 Upvotes

We recently had an incident where a newcomer to Daystrom posted a theory they had created, for the rest of us to discuss – and that theory was strongly downvoted. It got about as many downvotes as upvotes. Someone also posted a rude reply in that thread. As a result of this downvoting and the negative attack, the newcomer deleted their post and unsubscribed from this subreddit.

This is totally inappropriate. This is absolutely and totally not the atmosphere we are trying to build here.

The Daystrom Institute is a discussion subreddit: it was designed to share thoughts, not to stifle them. It is driven by discussion from its subscribers. As such, any post or comment should be considered against the criterion of whether or not it contributes to discussion.

Even a bad theory contributes to discussion: every voice deserves to be heard. There is therefore no reason to downvote it. It might not deserve an upvote, but it certainly doesn't deserve to be downvoted. The same applies to most comments and posts here: they are attempts to contribute to a discussion. They might not be good enough to be upvoted, but they don't deserve to be downvoted.

So... what does deserve to be downvoted?

Comments which break our rules deserve to be downvoted. However, comments which break our rules also need to be reported to the Senior Staff. That's one reason we have Senior Staff here: to enforce the rules. So, instead of downvoting a rule-breaking comment, people should report it for us to deal with.

The end result of this is:


In the Daystrom Institute, there is no need to downvote any post or comment. Ever.


This is not a new policy. This has been stated in our Code of Conduct since day one: Chapter II, Article Two of our Code of Conduct states “Don’t downvote just because you disagree with someone.”

Unfortunately, we have observed a growing trend recently toward downvoting here at the Daystrom, with the above incident being only the latest and most extreme example. We therefore feel it necessary to point out that, here at the Daystrom Institute, we do not downvote opinions we disagree with. This isn’t a subreddit where everyone always agrees: that’s /r/TheBorgCollective, and they’re always on the hunt for new members. This also isn’t a subreddit for people who know everything. If you think you do, things are stagnant over at /r/TheQContinuum (at least according to their hacker mods who keep popping in and trolling us). But /r/DaystromInstitute is a place for discussion, and any opinion that is lucid and respectfully stated is welcome. We don't shout down those we disagree with like we are in some Klingon beer hall. This is /r/DaystromInstitute – that’s supposed to mean something.

To put this a completely different way, who do you think would be more likely to downvote a post they simply dislike: Captain Jean-Luc Picard or Kai Winn Adami? What do you think that says about downvoting?

We have considered removing the downvote button. This was something we discussed even before the Institute opened, but we hoped it wouldn’t be a problem. We therefore decided not to remove the downvote button at that time. We have discussed this again recently, and we have again decided not to remove the downvote button... at this time. However, we would like to remind all Daystrom personnel, crew, and guests:


In the Daystrom Institute, there is no need to downvote any post or comment. Ever.


First Officer out.

Dismissed.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jan 16 '23

Why didn't Voyager consider time dilation?

1 Upvotes

I can certainly understand the impulse to get home as fast as possible, but "fast as possible" is 70 years at warp given their starting position. Voyager was very lucky to make it home at all, and making it in less than ten years was to be frank miraculous.

Given what we know of a Federation starship in that... Or even Kirk's era really, you should be able to punch the impulse engines til you're just about at c, at which point it takes no time at all from your perspective to get ANYWHERE. It takes a few thousand years for everybody else, but in 70 years... Your friends are dead and society has changed a LOT anyway.

Once you're up to speed, time literally isn't running anymore. You're not using any resources, you're not getting older sitting in a tin can etc. It's the sure bet. If you make it up to speed and can decelerate on the other end, you WILL get back to Earth at that point. Hell, you could even send a message to the rest of the Federation telling them what you're doing. On the off chance they have some manner of technology breakthrough that could get you home fast, they can come get you in the lifetime of all your friends etc.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 02 '24 Take My Silver

"Darmok" is a great idea, but not a great episode

0 Upvotes

Searching for previous posts on "Darmok," I found that ten years ago, Daystromites voted it as the fifth greatest Star Trek episode of all time -- ahead of any TOS episode, even "City at the Edge of Forever." It's not hard to see why fans love "Darmok." The idea behind it is irresistible: what if there were a culture that spoke in nothing but cultural references? How could we figure out a way to communicate without that shared context? (The fact that the same description arguably applies to Star Trek fans surely doesn't hurt, either.)

Rewatching "Darmok" today, though, I found that the actual entertainment value of the episode paled in comparison to the promising idea. Our heroes are too easily flustered, too slow to figure out that these references probably point to stories. Even when Troi and Data do laboriously figure it out, it doesn't seem to do any good since Picard has to figure it out separately on the surface -- pointing to the broader problem that the plot back on the ship seems irrelevant, as though they are just marking time. The Tamarians' range of references is much too narrow to be believable, and it beggars belief that it wouldn't occur to them that a bunch of aliens don't know their culture's stories.

The result, for me at least, is an episode that is more frustrating than entertaining, as I wind up almost yelling at the screen that these must be narrative scenarios with some analogy to what's happening. More than that, though, I can't really imagine what they could have done better. Making the Tamarian range of references more rich and varied would have simply been confusing in the context of one hour of television. But without that, you don't have a lot to decode -- so we need to make our heroes a little slow on the uptake, and maybe stall a little by cutting back periodically to the ship....

Basically, "Darmok" could have been an excellent literary sci-fi short story or novel, but it doesn't really work as an episode of TV. How, then, to account for its popularity? To me, this points to something pretty unique to Star Trek fandom -- we tend to value the idea behind an episode (or character, or technology, or concept) more than the actual execution. "What they were trying to do" typically matters more than what they actually achieved. The gap between concept and execution is a feature, not a bug from this perspective -- it gives fans greater ownership over Trek, since much of its value is in what we can imagine about it, beyond the bare facts of what appears on screen.

The result, of course, is that we wind up clinging to fragments of narrative, which we use as a kind of short-hand for the most promising ideas we see in it. Then we develop elaborate in-group discussions in which, for example, "But what about Thomas Riker?" counts as a decisive intervention -- bearing within it not only knowledge of a particular episode's plot, but its implications for how the transporter works, its significance for the continuity of life and selfhood in Star Trek, etc., etc. One can then imagine a post-apocalyptic scenario in which the survivors had nothing but the full DVD boxsets of Star Trek....

Even then, however, "Darmok" would remain a poorly paced, frustrating episode. But I'm sure you disagree.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Mar 07 '20

Mandaxic Neurosclerosis and the writing pitfalls of Discovery and Picard

0 Upvotes

In the latest episode of Picard, there's a point where Soji remarks that "real is better". Sensing the obvious issue for someone who's dealing with the knowledge that the first couple decades of her life is entirely fiction, down to her family relationships and friends, plus the only person she was actually emotionally involved in independently betrayed her, Troi tells her a story intended to reassure her.

Here's the thing...this doesn't hold up psychologically, medically, physically, or philosophically.

This question of natural vs artificial and truth vs lies is a huge theme of Picard. Troi is a sympathetic and knowledgeable character. It's inevitable that what she says will fall along the lines of the message of the show. Thus I'd posit it's reasonable to look at her response not just as what Troi herself would think or feel, but what she would think Soji needs to hear, and what the showrunners are trying to say.

Let's first break this down.

Psychologically

Dahj is grappling with insecurity because she feels she has no ability to tell what's real and what isn't. She's coping by descending into nihilism of "nothing matters". She is an artificial person - which right now she seems to equate with being a "fake" person. Telling her that her value as a person comes from cultivating cells in her brain - or more generally, through her willingness to sacrifice herself or serve other people - is not helpful.

Medically & Physically

There is no such disease as "Mandaxic neurosclerosis". How does a silicon-based disease affect a carbon-based lifeform?

How does a positronic matrix - and only a positronic matrix - remove "mandaxic neurosclerosis"? Plus, if they have to extract the cells to put them in a positronic matrix, why don't they leave them out of the person? If leaving them out kills the person, then how do they take them out?

"Mandax" sounds like Latin for "Mendax", but that just means liar, so unless this is a cryptic signal that Troi is making this up, this doesn't help anything. It's more likely supposed to be some planet, and the name is likely syllables selected to just sound nasty.

Essentially the writers have pulled a nonsensical disease out of their arse with the precise properties they wanted. And this is a problem.

Philosophically

Troi's reason for "real is not always better" is completely fictitious and nonsensical, so the episode has failed to make its point.

How to fix this?

The obvious example to use is Picard's heart, which I probably only remembered because it was brought up right at the start of this episode.

What Troi should have pointed out is that Picard’s heart is artificial- just because he wasn’t born with it and it was artificially designed, doesn’t mean it can’t do the same thing and work at least well. Just because it isn't biological doesn't make it any less 'real' to him.

The symbolism practically writes itself here.

This implies that the value of Soji's memories and life isn't tied up in what she can do for organics. Different doesn't mean any less real. The value her memories have to her is still just as real. If she feels loved because she has memories of her mother, she shouldn't force herself to feel unloved for the sake of negating those memories.

How does this apply to Discovery?

When people in Discovery are gushing over how science is cool, but when all the science is completely made up and honestly just plain unrealistic magic, it falls flat. They've shown that magic is cool, but not science. I don't want to dissuade kids from going into STEM, but it's also just a poor argument.

Now, you can say that they make up technology for every Star Trek series, some more than others. But in TOS and TNG and DS9, this technology had rules and functioned analogous to existing tech. The ship has an engine, the engine needs fuel, etc. Physics things have physics solutions.

With Discovery, we're treated to magic mushroom being more powerful than antimatter. It can also fix brain damage, or give you visions, time travel, bring people back from the dead, kill Control...

It's basically the deflector dish, except instead of being limited to generating arbitrary particles, it can do whatever the plot needs it to.

This pattern of using a make-believe example to 'prove' a message of the episode, rather than demonstrating its merits or demerits by letting it play out, or using a real situation as an analogy, prevents the message of the episode from holding up to critical analysis. Ironically, critical thinking skills are super important from STEM. I doubt that the writers are being meta enough that they're deliberately writing plot holes for people to find and enjoy exercising critical thinking skills.

It also gives later ideas no solid platform to build on.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 06 '18

Locked The disappearance of LGBT characters: A theory

5 Upvotes

LGBT human crewmembers are present in Discovery but entirely absent from other Trek series—neither the main characters nor even background extras are shown to be in same-sex relationships. How did we go from Stamets and Culber having an open, long-term relationship in Discovery to, about 100 years later, Dr. Crusher not even considering the possibility that she could have continued her romantic relationship with Odan after he transitioned to a female host body? What happened in the 100 years between the sexually diverse Discovery era and the entirely straight TNG-DS9-Voyager era? The real-world reason is that each show is a product of its era, and it takes much less courage to have an LGBT character today than it took in 1967 or 1987 or even 2001. But might there also be an in-universe explanation? I explore this question below.

The best explanation is that social attitudes toward sex shifted. It’s a mistake to conclude from recent American and Western-European histories that societies will become irreversibly more accepting of LGBT status over time. There are plenty of historical counterexamples of societies becoming less accepting: think about the temporary tolerance of same-sex relationships during wartime Europe, followed by the more restrictive1950s. Could it be that the Federation—or at least the slice of Federation culture that we see on a Starfleet ship—over 100 years turned into a place where it was not a good idea to be seen with a same-sex date in Ten Forward? Could it be that LGBT people existed in the TNG-DS9-Voyager era, but that they understood that it was best for them to remain closeted or abstinent?

Notably, the Enterprise—especially in TNG—was short not only on LGBT people, but also short on open heterosexual relationships. The Enterprise-D was, overall, a sex-negative place. For most of the series, the main officers are steadfastly single, and often abstinent. Miles and Keiko O’Brien were TNG’s only on-screen regularly appearing couple. The only other officers known to ever be in long-term heterosexual relationships were Crusher (who is a widow when the series begins and never remarries) and Riker/Troi (who spend most of the series un-coupled). (You might also include Worf, but he doesn’t enter a long-term relationship until the end of DS9).

Starfleet, in the TNG-DS9-VOY era, nominally permitted romantic attachments, but, in practice, people knew that romances hurt one’s career and social standing. Picard and Vash are powerful examples. Picard’s sole romantic relationship is formed while he is on leave. He tells no one in the crew about it. When Vash shows up and reveals his secret to the Enterprise crew, Picard is teased about it, and he feels embarrassed. Gay fans might see something familiar here: Picard hides his romantic life in the same way that a closeted gay man hides his. Picard does so because he knows that it is in his career interest not to openly display a romantic side.

Then there is Worf. Though a passionate guy, Worf has no on-screen relationship until he moves to DS9 and hooks up with Dax. Worf apparently had a brief sexual relationship with K’Ehleyr (one-night stand?) and is later surprised to learn they have a son, Alexander. But, when K’Ehleyr dies, Worf—who at this point has known his son for less than a week—immediately sends Alexander to live with Worf’s adoptive parents. One year later, they bring Alexander back to him, and he’s annoyed about that, and wondering how to fit Alexander into his Starfleet career. In “New Ground,” the episode where Alexander returns, we see how family-unfriendly the Enterprise-D is. Worf is late to a meeting with Picard after dropping Alexander off at his first day of school, and Picard chides Worf for that. Then, Worf is embarrassed to have to receive communicator calls about his son, and a (mildly amused) Picard tells him to forget about their business meeting and go take care of his son. It seems that unless your kid is useful to the ship’s mission—like, Wesley Crusher-brilliant—dragging your kid around the Enterprise-D is tolerated, but hardly beneficial to your career.

Speaking of Wesley Crusher: He’s our best view of what a teenage boy in the Federation is interested in, and Wesley Crusher is not interested in sex. He dates a few girls (or, at least, beings that he thinks are girls) and even kisses one once, but, so far as we see on-screen, that is it. Jake Sisko seems to be a bit more of a player, dating a dabo girl, but Jake’s formative years are shaped by the more sexually forward Bajoran and Ferengi cultures than they were by Federation culture. (Deep Space Nine, being on the far edge of the Federation’s military and cultural orbit, seems to be where Starfleet goes to let their freak flag fly).

Both the sex-negative Federation culture and the seeming disappearance of LGBT persons in the TNG-DS9-VOY era had a common cause: The Federation’s culture changed after the Discovery era. The approach toward sex and family became more practical and less emotional. What was behind that change? One word: Vulcans.

Vulcans mate once every seven years (pon farr) and then take a break. Pon farr, in turn, is a deeply private affair, which Vulcans don’t speak to outsiders about. For Vulcans, sex is not about pleasure, and (obviously) not about emotion; it is strictly utilitarian, a biological necessity. As such, there seem to be no same-sex pon farr unions; what would be the point?

Under the Vulcans’ needs-of-the-many-outweigh-the-needs-of-the-few ethic, not everyone in society ought to reproduce. Important people engaged in vital work ought not to bother themselves with the work of raising a child. Important people, like Starfleet officers, for example, should instead devote themselves to their careers, and leave to less ambitious members of the species the job of reproduction and child-rearing.

As a corollary: To a Vulcan, not only child-rearing, but emotional entanglements in general would be inappropriate baggage for Starfleet officers. Sex, and love, were not bad, per se, but marriages and romantic relationships represented a choice to value the relationship over work. For example, Sarek’s decision to have a child might have been seen as culturally inappropriate not only because he chose a human woman as a mate, but also because Sarek ought to have been occupying his time with his more important diplomatic work.

The Federation is a multi-cultural society, and in such a society, over time, different cultural attitudes rise and fall. Vulcans, over time, began asserting their logical, unemotional, utilitarian view of sex. Between Discovery and TNG, the Vulcan sexual ethic slowly began to prevail in Starfleet and in the Federation. By the time of TOS, you already see a notable lack of long-term relationships aboard the Enterprise. Kirk is a horndog, but his occasional one-night stands are consistent with a Vulcan sexual ethic so long as they’re short-term dalliances that don’t compromise his work.

LGBT crewmembers, meanwhile, became much less visible. They weren’t in the closet; they just, for career reasons, abstained from romantic attachments for the same reason that hugely successful officers like Picard kept that stuff under wraps: If you wanted to be successful and get promoted, you left all emotional baggage behind, and projected an image of someone entirely devoted to a Starfleet career.

Which brings us to Sulu. In the prime timeline, Sulu is aboard the Enterprise in a Vulcan-dominated culture; in the alternate timeline, Vulcan has been destroyed and the cultural influence of Vulcans has been severely diminished. Prime Sulu is gay but keeps it to himself. Alternate-Sulu, free from Vulcan sexual morality, is openly in a gay romantic relationship.