r/DarK • u/just_alike • 1d ago
[SPOILERS S3] Not sure about the ending... Spoiler
So I'm late but I just finished the series yesterday for the first time.
I'll start by saying, I absolutely loved this show and thought it was amazing (also, the casting of the young and old versions of the characters absolutely blew my mind). I actually watched most of the series up to S3 several years ago but had to stop for a while when I was going through a bad time, and when I got back to it I couldn't remember enough of what was going on so knew I needed to start over. I've finally gotten round to doing that and actually finished the series this time.
So yes, I loved the show all the way up to the very end, which I wasn't too keen on so was wondering what other fans thought. I paid close attention throughout so I think I had a good grasp of what was going on in all three seasons.
Going through my thoughts building up to the finale, I wasn't too sure how I felt about it when the second world was introduced but after a couple of episodes when they tied everything in it worked great. Then when they introduced the third origin world this made everything feel complete - everything was in threes throughout the whole series so it felt satisfying, and there was that point earlier in the series when Tannhaus said that nothing is complete until you move into the third dimension when explaining time, so all the build up and storylines made sense. I also had already been thinking that Jonas and Martha's son wasn't really the origin per se; yes he was Tronte's father so without him half the cast wouldn't exist, but when Bartosz went back and turned out to be Noah and Agnes' father, he became just as important as an ancestor of most of the cast. I had also managed to figure out that a few characters would still exist (Claudia, Egon, Hannah, and the Dopplers, maybe Katharina depending on how important Hannah's interaction with her mother was) if the knot didn't exist. So I already figured there wasn't a true origin in either knot and everything was just happening simultaneously, so it worked for the third world to turn out to be the origin.
It was just literally the very very end that I had a problem with. I was absolutely certain that when Martha and Jonas went to the origin world, they were going to end up causing the whole thing (either by causing the glitch that made Tannhaus' machine split reality in the first place, or by inadvertently causing the car accident with Tannhaus' family). This would have fit with every single thing we have seen so far, with the utter futility of trying to change anything having been a constant theme throughout the show. When Claudia came to say she had found the loophole and things would be different this time (which I loved because Claudia was one of my favourite characters so I was glad to see her as the main driver of the ending), I was thinking yeah sure things will be different, we've heard that before! I thought the point was going to be that she made this discovery every single time and didn't realise it, just like how all the other characters think they are changing things but end up repeating and actually causing everything (even within the split points that had already happened in the loophole leading to 2 versions of Jonas and Martha B). This to me would have been the most satisfying ending. It also wasn't really explained how Claudia managed to do or discover something different, which didn't really fit with the rules established so far - up until that point no one could change what will happen, because it had already happened, and was happening at that moment, with all events happening simultaneously (linking back to the very first episode and quote from Einstein that time is just an illusion and the only reason for it is so everything isn't happening all at once).
That said, I can see why they may have wanted to have something a bit more hopeful, since we've just watched 3 seasons of these characters struggling desperately to free themselves from this endless cycle of pain so it being a total closed loop right up until the end would have been kinda depressing. However, I think I would have enjoyed the ending where Martha and Jonas are successful in "fixing things" a lot more if this was treated as parallel and co-existing with the other timelines (I.e. both happen, Claudia uses the loophole to send Martha and Jonas to the original world and they destroy the knot, but given what we know of the loophole from the other split points, both versions simultaneously co-exist so the versions of events where they don't destroy the knot happen too, and therefore the knots still exist. This would also explain the paradox of Martha and Jonas existing to destroy the knot in the first place - as both eventualities happen). I guess you can still kind of interpret the ending in this way, but I wish they would have made this explicit since the way it was portrayed was that Martha and Jonas were successful in destroying the knot and everything with it disappeared for good, all except for the lingering deja vu (shown with Hannah) in the origin world. It just didn't seem to fit with the established rules so far and felt a bit out of place considering how neatly everything fit together up until that point. (Also minor side complaint, didn't Regina die of breast cancer anyway, so surely the same thing would've happened in the origin world, and Claudia doing everything so that she'll live kinda results in the same outcome for her?)
So yeah. Amazing show but the very end left me unsatisfied. Guess I just wanted to get my thoughts out into the void and/or see if this is a common viewpoint or if the ending is generally well-liked.
*Tldr* : amazing show but I found the ending unsatisfying and would have preferred if either Jonas and Martha caused the knot in the first place, or that it was portrayed more explicitly that they both do and do not manage to destroy the knot so all 3 realities/worlds continue to simultaneously co-exist forever.

